EP037 - Amazon Prime Day Recap
EP037 - Amazon Prime Day Recap
Amazon held it's second annual Prime Day on July 12th 2016. Scot and I break-down the good, the bad, and the ugly from this Amazon invented shopping holiday.
Amazon claimed it was it's biggest day ever (but was a bit vague about what that meant). Amazon claimed US orders were up 50% this year over last year (up 60% internationally). Last year Amazon said they sold $400M on PrimeDay deals, so assuming a similar AOV this year, that's $600M in sales.
Third party sales on Amazon were up 30%, reflecting the fact that it was still difficult for third parties to get in on the prime deals act.
Amazon did particularly well selling it's own hardware, such as the Kindle and Echo.
There were some early technical problems for some users, prompting the #Primefail hashtag.
Amazon didn't disclose numbers, but Prime Day was probably a major driver of new Prime subscriptions. Expect Amazon to promote all the other prime benefits hard over the next month (shipping deals, prime exclusives, music, video content, Prime Now, etc...) to help retain those new Prime members.
Several other retailers tried to piggy back on the Prime Day by offering their own "Black Friday in July" sales. Some evidence suggests that it was a higher volume than normal day for many other retailers.
Amazon is also eliminating many list (or MSRP) prices from it's site. A number of articles suggest that Amazon may be doing this to enable it to raise it's own pricing, but that's almost certainly NOT what Amazon is doing. More likely they are eliminating list prices in categories where sellers have artificially inflated list price, and to help Amazon avoid deceptive pricing practice law suits.
Don't forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.
Episode 37 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded on Wednesday, July 13th, 2016.
Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:00 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here is Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. This is episode 37, being recorded on Wednesday, July 13th, 2016. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, and as always, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo Hey, Jason. Happy day after Amazon Prime Day.
0:40 Happy post-Amazon Prime Day to you as well, Scott. Were you able to take advantage of any deals, or were you jetting around somewhere and unable to, to hit the buy button? No, I was able to take advantage of a few deals. Uh, I feel like you can jet around and still buy a lot of stuff from Amazon Prime Day. The limiting thing might be those, uh, Echo-only deals are hard to take advantage of until you get home. Yeah, absolutely. The, um… Can you share what, what some of the things that intrigued you were? Yeah, I didn't get a ton of, uh… frankly, I didn't get anything I was super excited about. It was more the, the thrill of the deal and, uh, putting, uh, Prime Day through its paces.
1:25 But, uh, there were some really good deals on SanDisk memory, and I actually just got sent a, uh, fancy new Samsung phone to try that takes SD card. So I bought a big memory card from that from SanDisk. Um, I bought a extra remote control for the Echo because that was a voice-only deal. I wanted to do one of those. And bought some, uh, boring staples for our baby son. Interesting. Yeah. That, uh… I did the, um, I also took advantage of the Alexa deal, and I did the little drone. Uh, and then I bought another Echo because you just can never have enough of them, and, um, I had never seen it $50 off, so it's normally $179, and, uh, I'm sure you saw it, but for listeners that didn't see it, it was down to $129.
2:14 Uh, and that was an interesting deal because I jumped on it early thinking, "Wow, this is gonna sell out." And it didn't sell out, but then if you look at these recaps, it was one of the top sellers. They must have had, you know, I would, I'd guess millions or, or, you know, high hundreds of thousands of those units to, to sustain that deal all day at such a good price. And with the, you know, the, the external data sources pointing to the, the Echo as a huge hit, it just seems like that was a really interesting one from several angles. Yeah, no, I think that was really smart, and that, that was a terrific deal. Were it not for the fact that I already have three of them, I, I definitely would have jumped on that deal too. Yeah, what you could do, though, is return them and save, uh, 150 bucks.
2:57 Yeah, well, some of them are probably too, too old to return even from Amazon But I probably could have returned one. I just was… I guess I, uh, wasn't willing to work that hard. Here's a fun, uh, insider Amazon thing. Did you know that Amazon maintains a, um… It's called… Internally, I've heard it's called a sugar rating, and, um, their policies tend to kind of flow by your sugar rating. And I'm gonna bet that you and I have very high sugar ratings And, uh, those are the kinds of things where, um, if, if you wanna do a return outside the window, this is what jogged it for me, they'll look at your sugar rating, and the customer service reps are kinda trained if, if it's a very high sugar rating, they'll, they'll override those policies, and if it's medium, you get the standard policy, and if it's below, you get kind of an even more constrained policy.
3:44 Yeah. I, uh, I had, in fact, heard that. It… Uh, to me, it's sort of the, their equivalent of the, the Uber rating for, for, uh, passengers. Yeah. Ah, I thought I had a scoop on you. Dang it. Uh, I feel like my sugar rating's so high that they're actually opening my own fulfillment center just outside of Chicago that I'm pretty excited about. Yeah, you're in the Frosted Flakes territory. Exactly. Or a hat tip to our last guest, the, uh, the Easter, Easter Oreo kind of, uh… That's, that's your sugar rating. It has just a picture of an Oreo. Exactly. I feel like the Birthday Cake Oreo may be the sweetest Oreo. I know a lot about Oreo flavors. Not as much as Neil. Yeah, I found that I could have done a whole show on that.
4:25 I don't know if our listeners would have enjoyed it as much as you and I, but I thought it was fascinating. Yeah. To keep that show under an hour, I had to edit out that whole 15-minute segment you had about the Star Wars Trident gum. Yeah. You know, the… It's fascinating, the Vader versus the Yoda, and it's gotta have them all. Yeah. It's awesome. Um, and I would, uh, while we're, we're, uh, chatting, I do wanna amend my previous answer. I also did buy a super exciting desk lamp Wow, that you did kinda go boring on Prime Day this year, huh? I, I went crazy. Well, you know- A little sad … uh, I feel like we haven't talked about this yet, but I, uh, in the last couple weeks built a new PC because of the hardware requirements for the Oculus Rift.
5:11 And so I'd sort of r- just redone my PC and the whole desk area so that- You're, you're bumping again- up, up against the gadget budget, as it were, already. You're, you're kinda digging out of a hole, so you couldn't really go crazy. Exactly. And I just frankly didn't have a lot of unfulfilled, uh, needs. Uh, as my family is quick to point out, the, the gap between recognizing a desire and fulfilling it is very short in my, my consumerism. Yeah, it makes birthday presents and, uh, holiday gifts a challenge. Yeah, I suspect you and I probably share that challenge. Cool. But I am pleased to announce, I brought up the Oculus Rift, uh, specifically so that I could call you out.
5:54 You ordered your Oculus way before me, uh, same day, but much earlier in the day, so you received it much earlier than me, which I was very bitter about. And I, I think it's gonna be true that I have actually set mine up and used it before you. I'm, like, three-quarters through the setup, and then, uh, I'll have to take a week off, and then I come back, and I have to go through, like, six hours of Windows updates. So I've spent all my time, um, you know, burning on Windows updates while I, I try to get my Oculus Rift going. It, it reminds me why I enjoy working on a Mac every day. There, there you go. Um, I, I will say, I have already wasted money on stupid games, uh, on the Oculus that weren't very good.
6:34 So we'll have to do a, a, a deep dive in the Oculus at a later show. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. So Scott, what were your big observations from Prime Day this year? Well, it, it was a, it was an interesting day. So when we look at kind of just results, um, uh, for the day in the Channel Advisor data, we, we have same store sales data, and we report on various events. As you know, we do monthly same store sales, and during the holidays, we look at a variety of different things. So what, what was interesting this year is from a same store sales perspective, uh, in the US it was flat to down slightly. Um, and then internationally, it was up pretty, pretty high.
7:16 I think in Germany it was sixty percent. Let me pull this up to make sure I don't get any wrong numbers. And then in-- Yeah, Germany was sixty percent year over year, and then France was fifteen, and both the UK and Italy were twelve percent. Now, um, once we put this data out, Amazon was quick to point out that, uh, third parties were up thirty percent overall. And, and that makes sense because it's apples and oranges. When we report this, we're taking a, a cohort of customers that have been the same cohort for a year. Uh, so these-- we don't-- We add a lot of customers, and sometimes people go out of business and whatnot. So there's, there's some customers that aren't-- that were here a year ago that aren't here, and then there's a bunch that we've added over the last year that are not in that comparison.
7:58 The reason we do this is because it's a better benchmark than to just say, uh, if we just say it was X, then that's more of a, uh, quality bar of how we've added customers, not necessarily how customers did on the channel. So, so we do the same store sales. It, it started, um, not for Wall Street or anything like that, but for customers to help benchmark how they're doing on these various channels. And we felt like the same store sales was a better benchmark kind of, uh, uh, uh, you know-- And these are all transactions. We're not, we're not surveying, we're not looking at little traffic samples or anything like that. These are actual transactions going through our system. So, so, you know what, what's interesting is Amazon reported much larger numbers.
8:38 Um, another thing that's important to note is our data is third party only. The bulk of the Prime Day deals are Amazon first party. So even, you know, obviously, like Amazon's devices and stuff are first party, but even if they went and had an awesome deal on a Samsung TV, that was what we would call, the slang would be one P or a traditional retail wholesale kind of relationship where Amazon's setting the price, Samsung is, is just, you know, selling wholesale to them and, and all that good stuff. So, so, um, there's those two reasons why there's a delta, um, and You know, but, but kind of digging back into some of the results, Amazon did put out a press release that was pretty interesting, and they said Prime Day grew sixty percent globally, fifty percent in the US.
9:23 So what I took from that was, in looking at our data, is it really kind of-- You know, I think last year they had really good, um, US saturation. This year, the international kind of came along. It would be a big theme of Prime Day this year. Um, and then they said 3P grew thirty percent. Later in the press release, they said, and you have to parse this stuff really closely, so I'll make sure I say this right. They said for sellers that had deals in Prime Day year over year. So I think what they're doing is it's not a cohort. The cohort isn't the same sellers, but there was X sellers that had deals last year and Y this year, those sales tripled. That makes sense because last year it was near impossible to get a Prime Day deal, a-and this year it was, it was just merely impossible.
10:09 Uh, it was, it was merely hard. Um, so, you know, I think-- I don't think that's a fair comparison either. Um, so, you know, I think the thirty percent probably is, is pretty fair. Another thing is last year we saw, I call it knock-on effects. Um, so what-- the way it worked last year is they would promote maybe a Samsung TV, and it would almost be like a search result where the Prime Day deal would be at the top, but then you had, um, even, even on the SKU and underneath the SKU at the search result level, third-party res-- um, listings would show up. So the Amazon deals would sell out, and then we would get a fair amount of pull from, from our customers that there are third parties kind of quote-unquote backfilling that deal.
10:53 Uh, this year they changed the search experience a lot more. I don't know if you, you played around with it much, but there was like six or seven homepage banners, and there were kinda showcase deals and this kinda deal and that deal and deals you're watching and chronological deals, every different way you could look at deals. And when you clicked on them, there were search results there, but they were very restricted to only, you know, Prime Day deals. It's like they implemented this filter so that they could then on the back end say, "This is a true Prime Day deal. These other offers from sellers aren't." And it feels like it had, um, you know, the slight, the, the, I don't know if this is positive or negative, but it had the impact of having less knock on-- The, the traffic coming in for this didn't splash over those walls, that the walls that they built this year were much, you know, bigger and, and people stayed in this kind of f- you know, very isolated pool of Prime Day deals.
11:44 Um, couple other quick things From the press release, Prime member orders from mobile were up 2X. A million folks used the Amazon app for the first time. Device sales were up 3X year over year. Uh, it looked like pretty much every device, uh, they didn't mention the Fire Phone, uh, oddly enough, but every other Amazon device. Uh, do they even sell that? I don't, I don't know. No, I don't think so. I, I doubt they… I, I think they finally sold out of all of them. Um, uh, I think, you know, uh, every device had a record day. Um, what, you know, and Alexa was, like, some kind of amazing stats. Um, the… Another kind of interesting kind of thing that supports this theme around Europe really lighting up, uh, they said seven million items, uh, were sold in Germany, and the past record was 5.4.
12:30 So that's probably either, um, Green Monday is really big in Europe, or then there's also Black Friday has kind of caught on. So I gotta imagine that's probably the 2015 Green Monday would be my best guess, and then Black Friday would be my second guess. So it's pretty interesting that, you know, at, at a super 30,000-foot level, what I think s- fascinating is Amazon wasn't, wasn't a first mover on this, but they have effectively created a holiday in the summer. Uh, and, you know, I, I think kudos to them. I think it's great. Um, we could talk about why they would wanna do that, but, but I think, you know, it, it's built on the success. They already announced today they're going to do one next year. So, you know, I think this is gonna be, you know, something that they, they, they do forever un- unless it, like, somehow failed miserably, which, which I don't see happening.
13:18 Yeah, no. And I mean, rolling all that up, if, if sales really were up 60%, and it… I think we're talking, uh, number, sales in terms of number of orders, correct? Um- Yeah … the, that, that does officially make that it Amazon's biggest day, right? So That was the highest volume, uh, day they've had. That would be bigger than Black Friday in the US last year. I don't know if they exactly said that. You have to… When I read it, they, they did for certain things. They didn't like… My, my parsing of it, of it was it- they didn't say it was their biggest day, period.
13:59 It was the biggest day for devices. It was the biggest day in Germany. It almost sounded like they were dancing around like maybe there was a bigger order day in- during the holiday last year. Which, which would probably be… It would be inter- I would find it hard to believe they would beat Cyber Monday. Um- Yeah, I mean, that- … it's possible, but, but unlikely. Well, so that's what I was just thinking is that, I mean, that would be truly impressive if they could create a holiday in two years and surpass Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Um, it follows the trend, I think, that you and I talk about in those holiday sales that we're, we're just seeing the, the spending, particularly e-commerce spending, spread out across bigger days in a bigger window.
14:39 Um, the… I, I saw sort of a, a, a funny reference to 2005, and in 2005, 25% of all e-commerce sales happened on Cyber Monday. And of- Mm … course, course today, like we, those flagpoles aren't, you know, are still the big days, but they're not, you know, close to, to that high a percentage of the to- total sales. So it's just, uh, interesting to see Amazon spread sales out even more. And I guess the, the unanswered question is: Did they just take sales away from the next couple months? Did they just move some sales forward that they would have got to anyway, and potentially at lower margins because of the deals? Or did they actually create new demand and, and generate incremental sales that wouldn't have existed otherwise?
15:27 Yeah. Yeah. It's, it's really hard to say that. You know, I'm going through the press release again, and it, it's really a little confusing. So the headline is, "Amazon's Prime Day is the biggest day ever." And then the sub is, "Biggest day ever for Amazon devices." So it's not really clear on if it's like two best or kind of a what we mean is devices. And then the first sentence says, "The second annual Prime Day was the biggest day ever for Amazon," period, full stop. But, but it's, it's not really clear is that orders or sales? So maybe, you know, that makes it sound like if you just take it at face value, that it was bigger than, than Cyber Monday. Um, which I just have a hard time believing that. Well, you know, Cyber M- globally, th- that could be because Cyber Monday is just gonna be the US.
16:11 You don't get any pickup, uh, in other countries on Cyber Monday. So, so, you know, I guess it is possible. And, you know, we, we didn't… And, and they don't really compete with anyone else on Prime Day, uh, which could help too, because Cyber Monday, everyone's throwing deals out there. So I don't know. Maybe, uh, we have a lot of Amazon listeners, maybe some of them could help clarify that a little bit for us. Yeah. I'm sure Jeff would appreciate it if many of them would call in and just sort of clear it up for us. Or if Jeff wants to call in, we'd be, um, we could probably find some time, maybe September, October for him to, uh, come on the show. Exactly. I, I would be willing to, to, uh, slightly adjust my s- my calendar if necessary.
16:51 Yeah. Well, we'll see. We'll have our people reach out to his people. So did you see any kind of wacky deals that, that caught your attention? Um, nothing that really jumped out at me. Like, so I, you know, one, one thing we, we alluded to but we didn't explicitly say is there was an extra $10 off on your first voice order, which again, seems clever. It both helped, helped, uh, sort of juice some of the Amazon Prime Day deals, and it's also teaching all those new Echo owners this new behavior, 'cause they've really expanded the ability of the Echo to actually accept orders.
17:32 And so, you know, now they're, they're giving everyone a $10 incentive to, to place the order. So I thought that was pretty smart. The deep discount on the Echo, uh, certainly jumped out at me. There's, there was a very good Samsung TV that was a particularly good deal, but that was a little bit outside of the, probably the impulse price point for most people. So I'm, uh, uh, I'm not … I'll be, I would be interested to know how, how that played out. And then, you know, there were a lot of other things where the … It was a good deal, but, uh, only incrementally better than other deals. So, like, a lot of those Amazon Fire tablets, they've been having a fire sale on them, uh, pun semi-intended, anyway.
18:15 And so there have been these terrific deals on the tablets, and they were a little better for Prime, but it wasn't, you know, earth-shatteringly different. What about you? Did you notice any, uh, interesting or goofy deals? One that was kind of strange was Segway. Um, you know, they make that, that platform thing that's… What does that cost, $10,000? Yeah. They had this little mini Segway I'd never seen before, and it looked like a Segway and a unicycle had a baby. And, um, that was like $999, and, and it looked like it was getting a lot of momentum on it. Um, which, you know, to your point of, of things outside of that, that, you know, consideration set, I, I was a little surprised that people seemed to be, um, you know, nibbling on that one pretty hard.
19:01 They, they have a quote in the press release from Segway, but it's, it's very vague and doesn't have anything about, you know, the, um, the, the quantity or anything like that. The, um, the… Aside from devices, they did say the top seller in the US is a Instant Pot seven-in-one multifunction pressure cooker. So you know, that's a… I would not have guessed that would… I would always… You know, you always think when you see these deals, you're… It's gonna be some kind of a cool new 4K Samsung TV or something like that. But I, I thought it would, you know… This pressure cooker evidently really resonated with folks. Wow. Yeah, that is interesting. That, uh, I did see the Segway deal, and that, that particular Segway is sort of their answer to the hoverboard, I think.
19:45 Although, obviously at a higher price point. Yeah, yeah. And it probably doesn't explode. One would hope. The, uh, for $999 it better not explode. Uh, I thought you would enjoy the top seller in the UK because I know you're passionate about, uh, this. It was the Oral-B CrossAction Electric Toothbrush with Bluetooth connectivity and SmartSeries. I'm, I'm not familiar with that toothbrush, but I just kinda wonder, you know, do you really need Netflix in your toothbrush, and then why does it have Bluetooth? So I don't, uh, you know… UK or folks are ahead of us on, on Bluetooth or, uh, toothbrush technology featuring Bluetooth. That's hard to say.
20:25 Yeah. Uh, I'm gonna slightly disagree with you. I feel like you can get both Bluetooth toothbrushes and Bluetooth forks in the US today. So, uh, I'm disputing that, that UK's ahead of us, and certainly with Brexit they're gonna fall further behind as far as I'm concerned. Um, but, uh, I am a big Sonic, Sonicare loyalist, so I'm waiting till they add Bluetooth to their toothbrushes What does the Bluetooth do? Does it like order a replacement for itself? Does it like a- No. Uh, you know what it's really targeted for is for kids, and it, uh, it gamifies brushing your teeth. Monitoring if your- Yeah … kids are brushing their teeth. Yeah. So, you know, I think there's some, some super advi- uh, zealous people that might use it for sort of the, the measure self movement and log how many minutes they spend brushing their teeth.
21:13 But it's, it's mostly like, you know, for kids to, uh, earn an allowance by making sure they brush their teeth for at least two minutes every night and that kind of thing. And the same thing with a fork. It's, uh, it's like literally intended to, uh, to help, you know, teach, teach toddlers how to, how to eat. Um, I guess I have seen one fork that alleges to, to do, do some sort of calorie estimates. Hmm. Interesting. Yeah. Not sure how that works. Wonder if you could like stab it with a rice cake and then go pick up a giant piece of roast beef and fake it out. Yeah. I would figure out a way to gamify it. Yeah. Pop-Tarts weigh exactly the same as rice cakes.
21:55 The Alexa deal, uh, observation's interesting, and I, I noticed this year they were pushing Prime Now both on the homepage and in the app. And I think I got a couple emails or notifications about it too. So they were definitely trying to… You know, it seemed like a sub-goal this year was to activate some of these other Prime features because you, you, you can imagine when they look at the data, if someone has a Prime subscription and they're just getting shipping, they probably have a normal kind of attrition rate. But then if they add video, music, Prime Now, Alexa, um, I'm sure I'm missing something in there. Um, what's the Warehouse club one? Um, you know, there, there's like five or six other little benefits in there, and Prime Day of course I think is another one.
22:39 If they activate any of those, then… And, and the more that, you know, the more features of Prime people are using, the less churn there is. So, so it seemed like they were definitely doing a lot more of that this year than they had in the past. And they have a lot more to do. In just a year, it's amazing how much they've added. Yeah. The, uh, I assume all those things make it more sticky and probably improve your sugar score, sugar score as well. Yeah, I'm, I'm sure. Absolutely. Did you see any other interesting things, uh, around Prime Day? Uh, not s- Well, so a, a couple of things. One thing that, you know, Amazon doesn't disclose, but I'd be curious what your theory is. I'm assuming another benefit to Amazon is that there were probably meaningful new Prime membership signups to, to, uh, enable the shoppers to get access to these deals.
23:28 Yeah, Pri- Amazon's very, um, quiet on this. The only data they put out kind of… For a while they didn't say anything, but now they'll say tens of millions. So that gives you a range of, you know, 10 million to 99.9 million, I guess if, if you were taking rounding out of the equation. So that's a, that's a pretty big swath of folks. Uh, and that's a global number, tens of millions. Um, when we do back of the envelope, we end up around between 45 and 50 million. Um, there's folks that do more survey work, and they end up with a, you know, some are, are in the range where we are, and some come out much higher. Uh, it is the kind of day, though, where, you know, you could see, you know, could the Prime base grow, at least with kind of people in a free trial period, 10 or 15%?
24:12 You know, I, I think that's definitely possible. So if they're at 50 million, you know, they could easily add 7 to 10 million new Prime members. Uh, and then it becomes kind of a, a goal to get them to stick and, you know, it, it… It'll be interesting to see. It, it, it's hard to tell unless you're in that, that free trial period. But I've got to imagine that just like when Facebook was early, they, they finally realized if you have eight to 10 friends, then you stay forever. I'm sure Amazon knows, you know, it has lots of data on what it takes to kind of get you to activate in that, that free trial period. And like I said, it's probably some combination of video, music, using the free shipping, um, using Prime Now, getting an Alexa, all those things.
24:55 Uh, you know, enjoying some of the, the, the premium exclusive content deals and, and they're doing a lot around video games and, uh, all those things. It, you know, I, I bet they'll, the next 30 days between now and August 12th, they'll be doing a lot to try to ac- you know, not only keep those guys but activate them into different parts of the Prime program. Yep. I am certain you are right there. I, I think we'll, we'll see some aggressive stuff to try to, uh, retain those, those, those customers. Because, you know, one unfortunate thing is the, the, the people that just want access to Prime Day are deal seekers, and so that's exactly who you might expect would do the, the free 30-day trial and, and cancel.
25:36 Yeah. Yeah. How about, um, I saw some news reports about it. I didn't get a chance to dig into it. Uh, I didn't witness it at all. Uh, but there was evidently some kind of a problem with the cart. Were you able to track that? I was a little bit. Uh, I, I don't think it's totally clear, uh, but, uh, it, it seems that early in the day there was at least one legitimate bug, um, i- uh, with regard to putting Prime deals in your cart. Um, and so, uh, early in the day on Twitter, there, there were a ton of consumer complaints, and they sort of adapted this, uh, hashtag, uh, uh, #primefail. And, uh, w- Sort of reading through all those tweets, it seemed like the common denominator was folks that tried to buy non-Prime items and put a Prime deal in the cart at the same time were having trouble checking out, and then when they would try to rebuild their cart, uh, it wouldn't let them put the Prime item back in their cart because it would tell them they had already taken advantage of the deal.
26:38 And I, I caveat that a little bit because there clearly were a lot of people early in the day that were successfully shopping on Amazon, and it seems like a lot of the complaints early in the day might have been user error. Um, you know, the Prime Day deals are a little confusing, um, in the, the sort of short-term nature of the items and, and, you know, the waitlisting system and all those things. Some of the complaints probably weren't completely legitimate, but I know a lot of the, the, uh, media that covers, uh, e-commerce, you know, sought comment from Amazon, and Amazon did clarify that, that sort of by noon that the technical problems had been resolved.
27:19 So I, I take that as affirmation that they did in fact have some legitimate technical problems in the morning that kept some users from getting Prime deals. And then, you know, of course, those deals then went away, and so those users were, you know, justifiably upset because they, they saw something they wanted to take advantage of, and they were, they, uh, were excluded from that deal through no fault of their own. Yeah. It kind of makes sense to me because this, this kind of, you know, hard flag that it's a Prime Day deal was very new this year, and I could see that being hard to system test at, at, at a capacity, at a, you know, at a load test that they would get on that day.
27:59 So, so it kind of, you know- Yeah … for whatever reason, makes computer science sense to me that that could be an area. Amazon's very, you know, rigorous about testing, and you rarely see glitches. So it is interesting. Um, and, you know, they're, they're again saying it was their largest day. And on, on the way we interface at ChannelAdvisor with Amazon is through APIs. And in the early days of the APIs, and this is going back to, you know, like the '07, '08, '09 timeframe, uh, days like this, you would see really big slowdowns and, and struggling on the back end. And we would eventually-- The orders would come through, but it would be like six-hour delays and not catastrophic. Everyone would get their packages on time, but enough to make, make our folks and their folks sweat a bit.
28:41 Um, you know, we, you know, to my knowledge, and knock on wood, we didn't see anything kind of, uh, on the back end there from, from Amazon. So, you know, the-- this investment made by, uh, AWS, I feel, has given them, you know, massive headroom for these kinds of things on, on the technology side from a, a capacity standpoint, bugs notwithstanding. Yeah. And, um, so I, I mean, a couple of takeaways from that. W- Number one, I feel like there are a lot of other retailers that were probably thrilled to see Amazon have any kind of technical glitch because, you know, frankly, if you're any of these other retailers and you've had a capa- and you don't have AWS behind you, and you, you've had a capacity glitch on Black Friday or Cyber Monday, like almost certainly one of the things you heard from your peers within the retail organization were, uh, "Hey, I noticed Amazon didn't have any problems and we did.
29:31 What's the deal with that?" So I, you know, I, I think, uh, there are probably a bunch of, a bunch of, uh, s- uh- Uh, system operations guys today that were, were routing around, you know, what failures they were and sharing that, you know, even Amazon isn't, isn't perfect. Um, an interesting thing though is that was the, the bulk of the negative sentiment about Prime Day was this, you know, relatively small pool of users that were complaining about a technical glitch. Last year, there were a ton of complaints about the quality of the deals. Um, and so there, there were a lot of people that used that same Prime Fail hashtag last year because they were, you know, mostly joking about how silly the deals were or how short, you know, the quantity was of the items that were on deal.
30:18 And there, there was, there was this general concessi- uh, sense- consensus last year that, hey, Prime Day was an economic, uh, success and that, that they sold a lot of stuff, but that y- a significant amount of the sentiment around the day was negative. And it, it appears this year, uh, that the sentiment was much more favorable. And I know Adobe and some other, other folks with social listening tools sort of track that carefully, and they, they all sort of concurred that the, the overwhelming majority of, of social sentiment around, around Prime Day was favorable Yeah. And, um, you know, the adjustments, I, I mentioned a little bit of it at the top of the show, but it seemed like Amazon did what I would call, not only did they go deeper on the deals, they, they kind of went wider.
31:04 So, so last year was very door bustery. Some of the best deals were in the early a.m. hours East Coast and, and then, you know, Pacific missed out on them, which cheesed them off. So, um, this year there was just a much better spreading out of the deals and, um, you know, you could tell there was a lot more thought put into it of, we're gonna have a good electronics deal for every hour for 12 hours, a good toy, a good video game. You know, that kind of thinking. So, um, and then the, the deals were definitely deeper. I, I mentioned the… I, I was just shocked the Alexa deal didn't sell out, you know, any time during the day. It must have just been, you know, ginormously deep on, on that one.
31:45 Um, the other thing, you know, the other thing I noticed they did this year is there was a lot more promotion. They were promoting Prime Day on the tape on the box. There was TV. There was, um, a lot of digital campaign. There was a lot of email, you know, marketing to Prime members. Um, there were interstitials. There was a lot of onsite. Uh, it, it was-- It just felt… You know, last year I remember seeing one digital thing and, uh, there was a TV ad with a dancing box guy that I saw, like, maybe once last year. Um, and this year, you know, there was a kind of a blackout period of 48 hours before Prime Day where you couldn't hardly sneeze without kind of hearing about Prime Day.
32:26 Absolutely. One of the other interesting things to me was, you know, last year there just wasn't a lot of notice to anyone before Prime Day, and so it was interesting to see how other retailers reacted to Prime Day. And if, if you remember, um, there-- It, it ended up being there were some weird circumstances. So, you know, last year was the 20th anniversary of Amazon, and so the first Prime Day was, you know, uh, partly to celebrate that 20th anniversary. And, uh, once it became clear that Amazon was gonna do, you know, meaningful promotions on that day, Walmart jumped on the bandwagon. And you almost got the impression it was a little ad hoc, um, because they were ba-they were basically celebrating Prime Day too.
33:07 And you-- So you had this sort of weird, weird circumstance where Walmart was celebrating Amazon's 20th birthday with, with their own deals to try to counter-program against Prime Day. Um, and so now you fast-forward a year, all the, all the other retailers knew it was coming. They, you know, probably had a lot more opportunity to prepare their own strategies, and I think we saw probably two or three very different strategies that different retailers took, um, to, to address Prime Day. And so that was pretty interesting. Yeah. Have you heard anything about how it did this year? So, you know, um, Penny had a Pennypalooza or something like that, and then I didn't see Target do anything.
33:50 I think Kohl's did something. Walmart had, uh, was it five days of free shipping? And then eBay had a couple of snarky kind of exclusive for everyone, and we don't, we don't require a membership kind of things. The, the deals didn't seem to be much more different than their everyday daily deals that they do. So I think they were just kind of snarky banners. Yeah. Did, did you see anything, um, or hear anything b- out there in the, in the interwebs? Yeah. Well, so there, there were a number of retailers that tried to do their own sales as opposed to last year when they literally, you know, called them Prime Day sales. Uh, this year I noticed that the big trend was that they were calling them Black Friday in July. So, uh, y- you know, the, the other retailers clearly recognized this year that, "Hey, we don't need to help advertise Prime for Amazon anymore."
34:38 And so they're-- you know, they, there was a concerted effort to sort of rebrand that day. I don't, I don't know how successful that was, 'cause to your point, like, no retailer that I saw put, like, meaningful media dollars against that. And obviously Amazon, um, did, did have a pretty big marketing, uh, push around Prime Day. But, but so Macy's and, uh, Walmart were much more likely to refer to it as Black Friday in July. Uh, as you mentioned, Walmart's big promotion was to give away free shipping, which is interesting because last holiday, Walmart, um, was very conservative about their free shipping promotions, which was Is not typical for holiday season.
35:21 And, you know, Walmart didn't have a, a particularly awesome, uh, growth over that holiday period and, and lack of shipping promotions was probably part of the reason. So now you fast-forward this year, and they're giving away free shipping and, you know, they're, they're tr- starting to promote Shipping Pass, which is their answer to, to Amazon Prime, and that's a, you know, $50 membership, free shipping-- free two-day shipping from, from Walmart. And, you know, that-- this goes back to your Amazon's very interested in you taking advantage of all those other benefits of Prime because, you know, frankly, Walmart's, uh, Shipping Pass is exclusively a shipping deal.
36:01 And so, you know, if, if you're a Amazon user that uses any of those other benefits besides shipping, it makes Amazon-- it makes Prime look more competitive against, you know, these new competitors like Walmart Shipping Pass, for example. So I thought that was interesting in terms of their promotional strategies. Uh, there, you know, there were other retailers that offered deals, none of them with the breadth of product that Amazon did. You know, they all had some sort of targeted deals. And then there's a whole other set of retailers, um, that, you know, really just leveraged the fact that this is sort of back to school season. So a bunch of retailers had back to school sales. They almost certainly would have had back to school sales anyway, um, and they really just hung their hat on those back to, um, school sales.
36:47 So that was kind of interesting. And then there was sort of mixed messages about how Prime Day was affecting traffic on those other retailers' e-commerce sites. So we, uh, we saw a couple of third parties report that, that there was a clear spike in traffic on all big e-commerce sites and, and depending on the source, I've seen people say, uh, that, like, traffic was twice as big as the previous Tuesday or even three X as big as the previous Tuesday, um, across the board in retail, which is a pretty big spike in traffic. Um, but then, uh, folks were not reporting huge spikes in sales that were commensurate with what Amazon's claiming.
37:31 And so, you know, if you add those things together, your takeaway would almost be that, that Prime Day caused shoppers to, to visit a bunch of sites, but the, the conversion was much better on, on Amazon due to the preponderance of deals there. Um, so- Hmm. So that was all interesting, and, uh, it'll be interesting to see what, you know, as, as sort of retailers do their postmortem on, on, uh, this Prime Day and, you know, if, uh, Amazon continues to have the success they've had, you know, it'll be interesting to see what they do next year. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. Well, there definitely will be a Prime Day next year, so it's already locked. Yeah, I, I am sure. Um, so one last thing that was-- that sort of overlapped Prime Day a little bit.
38:14 You, you asked earlier, you know, if, if I saw any particular deals. One of the things that was sort of ironic is all the Prime Day deals were, um, showing you the offer price against the list price, and in many cases, there was a big gap there, right? So, hey, list pri-pri-price on the Echo is $179, and we're selling it for $129. Um, the, the reason that was a little ironic is there have been a number of articles noticing that over the last couple weeks, Amazon has been doing away with displaying list prices on their website, and there's, there have been several articles that speculate about why Amazon would do that.
39:00 Um, and I, I'm happy to talk about that. I, I sort of feel like some of the articles' speculation are probably wrong, but it's interesting at the same time that Amazon's getting rid of a lot of, of list prices that they were, they were leveraging list price pretty extensively for their Prime Day deals. Yeah, that, that, that is ironic and, um, we're pretty intimate on this one. So we had customers that noticed this in May, uh, and I believe it started in the apparel category, and then, um, they thought it was a bug. They're like, "Hey, Amazon, you know, the list price," and, and then it-- there's kind of two parts. There's the list price and then a, a calculation of a d- effective discount, um, for the current price. They're like-- And both, both the percentage and the list price were gone.
39:44 So they started contacting their account managers and, and ultimately Amazon said, "Yeah, we're, we're, um…" You know, sometimes you would hear it called a testing or it's definite in apparel or category kind of based or a phasing out. So we-we've heard kind of different flavors used for this thing, so it's not entirely clear what's going on. But, but then the justification that was given was it's a bad consumer experience. And, and digging into that, what they're telling folks is there were sellers that were abusing this and, you know, saying… 'cause you can just put anything in there. It's like a f- a field that you say what was the list price. So you'd have sellers saying, "Oh, this, this super rare HDMI ca-" I'm making this up obviously, but, "This, this HDMI cable was normally eighty dollars and we're gonna sell it for eight, so it's ninety-two percent off," or whatever that works out to be.
40:33 Um, so you know, that-- the Amazon felt like there-- because there's no validation of that list price, it, it was being abused. So, um, you know, one, one argument there is Amazon could-- This could be one of those areas where Amazon says, "Look, for one piece stuff, we're gonna keep it, and deals we vet, we feel like we've done the curation to really say that is the list price, and those are gonna have this feature, then everything else isn't if we can't kind of vet it." Um, you, you know, I haven't heard how they're gonna split that up. The, uh, I also got a bunch of questions on this, and, um, one of the most interesting ones have been around, you know, is, uh, um, you know, is Amazon doing this to effectively give them the ability to increase prices?
41:16 So the argument goes, if the list price isn't there, then what keeps you from charging over list price? Um, and that, that one just doesn't really, um… You know, maybe some third parties would do that kind of thing because, and, um But again, I, I doubt it. Really, really things are only sold over list price if they're extremely rare and, and supply and demand kinda have worked out, so that there's more, more demand than supply, and, you know, it's the hot new toy or whatever for the holiday. Then you start to see things go above list price on the Amazon Marketplace, but it's very rare because the market's pretty efficient, and usually things are below list price. Um, the, the example, you know, I like to give on that is if you, if you talk to anyone at Amazon, uh, their DNA is they know their flywheel very well.
42:00 There's-- Their flywheel is selection, value, and convenience. Um, and, you know, trust is kind of in there too, but they, they often don't say that one. But, but that… They, they are religious about selection, value, convenience. Selection, value, convenience. Um, and the story I like to tell is, um, when you sell in the third-party marketplace, everyone signs up for what's called price parity, and what that means is you can't put your products for more expensive on Amazon than they are on your website. So if you have a widget that's a hundred dollars on your website and a hundred and ten on Amazon, you violate that policy, and they'll actually give you a warning and ultimately suspend you if that happens. We, we have this challenge that if our customers update their website first, and, and it's almost like an electron race condition, uh, it, it's so tight.
42:45 You know, they'll be updating their website and then their inventory through ChannelAdvisor, and we're updating Amazon. In that span, that gap, which can literally be, you know, minutes, um, Amazon will flag a price difference. And, you know, what that tells you is they are watching prices across the internet at a, uh, just, you know, an unimaginable kind of capacity. Um, they must have just a massive project that does that. So, you know, again, I don't, I don't think they would have this kind of culture and the, these kinds of policies and these kinds of things if they, you know, people were there to jack up prices. If, if anything, I, I do believe, um, you know, they're very consumer-oriented, and, and I could see that consumer argument.
43:26 What, what do you make of the whole MSRP thing? Yeah. Well, first of all, I'll take one quick step back just to make sure everyone is sort of tracking. Um, when you show a list price and then you X it out, and you show the price you're offering it at, we, we often call that is-was pricing. Like, you're showing the, the price it is and the price it was, and, uh, you're, you're clearly enumerating the deal the, the customer's getting. And there's overwhelming evidence that the, uh, that that psychology really impacts consumers. So the psychological principle behind that is called anchoring. When you see that, that was price, that makes you feel like the, the product was of value at that price, and now you're getting it for a better value, and it, uh, has a, a very meaningful effect on sales, and it's sort of considered a best practice.
44:16 The overwhelming majority of sites on the, on the internet use is-was pricing, or some, some retailers will call it high-low pricing Um, so when Amazon gets rid of that list price, one, one concern you would have immediately is, hey, are they losing the ability to have is/was pricing? And for most retailers, if you didn't show the list price, you, you would have no other way to have a meaningful is/was price. In Amazon's case, they actually do get to show multiple prices even without list price. So because they have the 3P marketplace, and they show the price that that product's offered at, um, at a variety of sellers, you, you, in, you, in, you actually have is/was pricing even without list price because you, you get to see multiple prices and, and those multiple prices sort of serve as an anchor.
45:08 And in cases where we've seen Amazon take away list price, they still seem to have is/was pricing. So they use that dynamic pricing engine. The dynamic pricing engine changes prices. They change something like 2.5 million prices a day. And so if the price changes, they still show the is/was price, um, from their own changes. And so they, they still have that psychology of give, of sh- giving customers a better deal. Now, the reason that I think they're not showing the list price anymore, um, is because there's a, a extreme version of this pricing practice, uh, that's actually illegal, or at least, uh, certainly illegal in some states.
45:53 So back in 2013, a California court ruled that it's illegal for a retailer to make a fake list price that the product's never sold at, and then i- use that as an anchor and then have a, an is price that's much lower than that. And so, uh, you know, a retailer lost, um, a lawsuit, uh, as a result of having these fake list prices. And since that, that lawsuit, uh, a ton of other retailers have been sued, and you, you can think about all these circumstances. You know, JCPenney famously has, you know, always has high-low pricing, and Ron Johnson, when he was there, even came out and said, "Hey, this is what we do and it's silly.
46:34 We're gonna try to move away from it." So he sort of admitted that they were using fake high-low pricing. Um, and JCPenney has stores in California, and there are a bunch of outlet malls that sell products that, you know, are made for that, that outlet store, and they have a, a, a suggested list price that they've never been sold at, right? And so there are a ton of retailers that are getting sued right now for that practice. And if you're Amazon and you're getting a bunch of your list prices provided by, by third parties, um, you can't guarantee that that's a real list price that the product's actually been offered at. And, you know, at this point, Amazon's one of the largest retailers in the country.
47:15 They're a great target for lawsuits. And so my, my strong speculation is that, uh, Amazon only wants to show list prices when they're confident that it's a, a real legitimate list price that the product's been offered at, and that they're trying to minimize their Their profile as a target for, for these pricing lawsuits, and that Amazon more so than other retailers feels like they, they can successfully remove the list price and still have credible is/was pricing because they have the buy box and they have the dynamic pricing and those things. So I really think that's the, that's the driver, and I 100% agree with you.
47:58 For sure the driver is not that Amazon's hoping to sell, uh, at higher prices and expect people not to notice, 'cause that's just fundamentally against their DNA, it's fundamentally against the flywheel, and it, it just wouldn't make any sense. Yeah. The, um, unfortunately a lot of the, the sellers that they're, are good citizens were upset about this and, um, you know, there, there's a lot of these third-party sellers that are-- they really focus on closeouts, and that's an area Amazon's not really active in, so it's a great kind of segment that's pretty, I hate to use the word protected, but, you know, a pretty good niche and a, and a very large niche. So they're kind of like little mini TJ Maxxes, and the way these guys work is they, they work off MSRP discounts.
48:39 So some retailer or, or, you know, will have some liquidation kind of… and, and these are big lots of liquidation. And on these sheets they'll actually list the MSRP and the discount, and that's how the negotiation is done, where you'll go in and you'll say, "Look, I'll give you effectively, you know, 30 cents on the retail dollar for this stuff." Um, and that factors into their calculation because they know, uh, to your point about the psychology, they, they know consumers really want 50% off. So they're, they're gonna kind of do their economics, make 20% margin, mark it up 20, they're gonna get 30% off MSRP. So, so they feel like they've lost a really big feature and benefit, um, to help, especially in this kind of markdown segment.
49:21 So, um, not sure if Amazon's gonna do anything about that, but, but it, it's definitely been perceived as a bit of a negative for, for that audience of folks. Yeah. And I, I can imagine that they're right, or at least, uh, I can certainly, uh, sympathize with their concern that, that the loss of that dramatic is/was pricing could affect velo- sales velocity on those SKUs. So, uh, that feels like everything we, uh, had on Prime Day for this week, and I, uh, feel particularly grateful to our listeners. This is actually the third podcast that we're, we're publishing this week. So it's a hugely dense week on the Jason and Scot Show.
50:05 Yeah. Yeah, we had, uh… The summer was kinda slow, and then we've had a lot to talk about this week. A lot of folks were available for interviews, and, and it was great to be able to put out, uh, all this content in one week. Exactly. And so I know next week, uh, we have some conflicts, so we may not put out a show. So that'll give a chance for the listeners to sort of catch up on these episodes. I will be at the shop.org digital merchandising, uh, workshop next week and, uh, would love to, to say hello to any listeners in person that are attending that. It's a great event, and I'm looking forward to speaking there. Yeah. And unfortunately, I won't be able to make it this year but, uh, look forward to hearing who you rendezvous with. I, I, uh, will, will miss seeing you, but I will do my best to represent the, the Jason and Scot Show a- uh, at, at the, the resort in Southern California.
50:55 Um, and so with that, uh, I will remind all the listeners that if you enjoyed this show, we'd certainly appreciate a review on iTunes. And if you'd like to continue the conversation, uh, please, um, meet us on the Facebook page and post your comments. So until the next podcast, happy commercing. Thanks, everybody You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes and please leave a review
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed