Welcome to The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News!
Nov. 8, 2016

EP057 - CDW VP and GM of E-Commerce, John Seebeck

EP057 - CDW VP and GM of E-Commerce, John Seebeck
EP057 - CDW VP and GM of E-Commerce, John Seebeck
The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News
EP057 - CDW VP and GM of E-Commerce, John Seebeck

EP057 - CDW VP and GM of E-Commerce, John Seebeck

John Seebeck is the GM of E-Commerce for CDW. We spoke with John about his B2C e-commerce background (Crate & Barrel) and the unique B2B challenges and opportunities for a firm like CDW. We spoke at the Shop.org digital summit 2016.

Don’t forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.

Episode 57 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded on Monday September 26, 2016.

http://jasonandscot.com

Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.

0:02 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here are Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg. This episode is being recorded live from the NRF shop.org Digital Summit 2016 on Monday, September 26th. As usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Jason.

0:42 It's good to be back here at the shop.org NRF Digital Summit. It is terrific to be here. This is actually my favorite venue for shop.org. Really? Dallas? It is, and the reason is, uh, six years ago, the last time we were here in Dallas, I met my wife for the first time. Oh, did you meet her at that event where we were at the, uh, Cowboys stadium, and she saw you kick a field goal and was like, "That's the man I'm gonna marry"? That clearly was the closer. We, we met earlier- Oh … um, in the day. So it was kind of a date. But clearly when she saw the, the powerful leg that I had, I know that that was a extra appeal. Boom. Yes, and my, my amazing field goal dancing ability.

1:26 We'll have to put a video of that up on the site. Yeah. Happily, I, I may have, uh, been able to censor all of those videos. Well, I'm sure someone saved it. Well, we have a real treat for our listeners on this episode. We have John Sebeck on the show. John is the VP and GM of E-commerce at CDW, and before that, he was the VP of E-commerce at Crate & Barrel. Uh, he served on the shop.org board, where Jason and I got to know him really well, and always enjoyed talking e-commerce with him. John, how are you doing? I'm doing great. Thank you guys for inviting me. It's great to be here. Yeah, and you are based in Chicago, so- In Chicago … and there's kind of a running joke. You and Jason are both in Chicago and never see each other there. You have to come to Dallas to see each other. Exactly.

2:06 That's right. We are, we are neighbors, but we just never, uh, seem to be in the same city at the same time, which I think is my fault. Uh, I think one time you were… We almost got together, and I think I backed out. You may have stood me up. Yeah. I, I don't know. I don't want to stand up, but I, I know I backed out. You got advance warning, right? How long officially, Scott, do I have to be sitting at the coffee shop alone- … crying before it's officially a stand up? 20, 20 minutes. Okay. Then, yeah. Yeah. Maybe I didn't get stood up. Yeah. 15 is they went to the wrong Starbucks and they should have messaged you by then. 20 is just total stand up, yeah. Yeah. So one of these days we're gonna get together in Chicago. I will look forward to it, but I'm thrilled to have you here. It's great to be here.

2:47 Yeah. So John, tell us, you've been in the industry for a while. Tell us a little bit of back- your background. I'd love to hear, you know, did you, um… All the way back to college, what'd you study, and then how did you get into e-commerce, and, and then take us through Crate & Barrel and, and the whole enchilada. Wow, that's great. College. So I grew up in Chicago. And my applied to schools in the Midwest. And then one, one evening my godmother called and said, "You know, John should apply to the University of Richmond in Virginia." And I'd never considered it, and I applied. I got accepted. And- The Spiders. Spiders. You wanted to be a Spider. Never- You wanted to be an eight-legged beast … never visited the school, and I wanted to be… wanted to do that.

3:28 For your listeners, it's kind of like a- Oh, you guys do a spider? You take your hand. Yeah. But that's only five legs. That's what they do in the crowd. It's kinda like a- D- But to be, like, technical, y- you have to do eight legs. Yeah, you have to keep your thumbs down. Oh, okay. Ah, very good. For our listeners- And, uh, fingers … im- imagine three old guys- … creepily, uh, squeezing an orange with their hands in a odd, uh, and potentially inappropriate gesture. Exactly. Okay. There you go. So I was there in 1985, which was the year that the Spiders had their kinda Cinderella run, if there- Oh, yeah are basketball fans as listeners. And the big win was against Charles Barkley- Mm … in Auburn. Neat. So Richmond, and then I moved back to Chicago. I was in the insurance business for six years, worked for a company called Johnson & Higgins, which was bought by Marsh.

4:13 If you know insurance, you've probably heard of Marsh. And- Were you selling insurance or marketing insurance? I was an insurance broker. Oh, cool. Cool. So we were- Do you have, like, the little coffin with the mirror in it, and say, "Here's your future"? What do you see in here? No, it was- What do you see in here? Thank God it was pr- it was- The cheesy insurance … I started out in marine and aviation. Wow. So marine cargo and aviation cargo, then I moved into international property and casualty. It's more B2B insurance. So it was all big, big business. Not consumer. Mm-hmm, and travel. And m- I went from Chicago to New York. Worked in New York for about nine months, and then I got relocated to DC, and that was a beautiful thing because that kind of got my wife and I together for, for permanence, being back in DC.

4:55 Cool. So. Did you kick field goals for your wife at all? D- No, I proposed to her on the Brooklyn Bridge, though. Oh. That's nice. That's romantic. That was a- A little sunset- … fun experience … kind of a thing. Nice. Very Harry Met Sally. But she, she went to Gallaudet University, which is a national school for the deaf. So Richmond, worked in the insurance business, and I realized- Yeah, insurance is really about pr- loss prevention. At the end of the day, like brokering a policy is, it's a negotiation game, and I, I wasn't an engineer, and so loss prevention was not my bag. And I always wanted to get my master's, so I applied to the University of Virginia and a couple other schools, and went to Darden and got my MBA.

5:35 And that was nice. It was in-state tuition. And my summer job was with IBM, so I was very much wanting to move into technology and get as close as I could to kind of general management, 'cause that was the degree. And so IBM down in Research Triangle Park, and then upon graduation, I ended up working for Circuit City. So retail, I went into a re- a store manager in training program, and that's how I got into retail, and worked in Richmond. Then we moved to Philadelphia, ran a store in King of Prussia, and then moved back to Richmond.

6:16 And then I got relocated to Chicago, which was home for me. And after about six years, I said, "I gotta get out of this I gotta get into the internet. I shouldn't say I gotta get out of, and I wasn't gonna go back to Richmond, which is where Circuit City was headquartered. And they said, "Well, you know, y- you're interested in this internet thing. Why don't you go do it for us in Richmond?" And I just didn't wanna leave Chicago. So I went with a grad school, uh, friend, colleague, and we had our own design consulting firm, and that's kinda how I jumped in with both feet on- online. Mm-hmm. And- What time, what, is this like '98, '99?

6:56 So this was, I left in November of '99. Uh, November 1st, '99 was my last day at Circuit City, and we were together until I started … So it was about 18 months. And as we know, the- the bubble hit, and what started to happen was companies were saying, "Hey, this is really important. We gotta bring this in-house." And my partner was in New York, I was in Chicago. There were just a number of reasons why I wanted to make a change. And then I looked for a couple different things, consulting or, uh, one was Crate & Barrel. So just, it was a great, uh, opportunity 'cause I had store background and some internet background, and they, they were looking for someone to, to come in and help them with e-commerce.

7:38 So my original title was senior manager of the internet back in March- Ooh … March 2001. All of internet. Not just at Crate & Barrel, just senior manager for the entire internet. Senior manager, comma, internet. That's right. Yeah. Mm-hmm. So Crate was, you know, it's a i- iconic brand, right? A big Chicago story. Um, Gordon Segal was, was the CEO. He was the CEO until 2008. And the web business was probably, you know, the, the company now is a billion and three or so, I would guess. I don't know. I haven't been there for a while. But the internet was probably $12 million in annual sales.

8:18 In 2001, and we were selling… Basically, we took this limited assortment of the gift registry business, and we put that online, and that was, that was the essence of what it was. So there was a lot to, to do there. And started just pure online, then I moved into a marketing role, direct marketing. So I had catalog responsibility and then database responsibility, and, um, did that until probably 2010 or '11, and then kind of went back into a pure e-commerce role. So really focused on customer experience, you know, delivering the promise of the brand online as opposed to driving traffic.

9:00 Uh, so we kind of made this break between marketing and, and customer experience. Got it. And do I have it right? Did Crate & Barrel start out as a cataloger before the stores, or did the- No … which came first? Okay. So the store, there's a store on Wells Street in Chicago, and that's the, that's the first store in 1962. So they, they started mailing a catalog in 1967. So it's, you're, you're not far off, and so that, that was a great Uh, advantage, right, to Crate & Barrel and other catalogers is they had the pick, pack, and ship operation, and they could-- They had photography, and there were certain things that just weren't, you know, foreign to them to, to get into. They were used to direct-to-consumer delivery- Yeah … pickup in store, all those things.

9:43 Yeah. Customer service. Mm-hmm. They could get it done, so… Um, but after… I was there 13 years, and I loved, uh, every, every day. It was just a great, great company and, uh, great experience. But I was just restless. Like, at the end of the day, I would feel like I'm almost 50, and I wanna, I wanna do something different, and I wanna really get kinda full with a whole new experience. So I started looking actively, and then I had the good fortune of being contacted by a recruiter for CDW in that summer, that same summer I was looking, and one thing led to another. And I gave my notice to Crate & Barrel in the fall of 2013, and then ended up, uh, leaving in early 2014, or starting CDW early part of 2014.

10:29 So my role there, you know, it's, it's completely different, right? It's… Sure, it's vice president, GM of e-commerce, so it has many of the same aspects, but the business model is completely different. I mean, the s- size of the business, we're-- we finished at 13 billion, uh, last year. It's B2B. I mean, we definitely get consumer business, but our, our mission in life is to help companies, organizations, you know, solve their problems through tech. It's usually, like, bigger B. It's like, you know, I'm a company, Fortune 500 company, and I need CDW to come in and help me manage all my laptop assets- Right … some server stuff. You guys do a lot of kind of really big corporate kind of MIS, you know, kind of things and- Right … that's, that's kinda how I envision it.

11:12 Yeah, I mean, the-- You m- mentioned you went right to one core competency. It's just it… You know, I mean, we work for a retailer. You wanna go into the warehouse. I love going in the warehouse at Crate & Barrel and seeing, like, all the boxes get shipped. In CDW, you get to see how we configure all the, the notebooks. Mm. So yeah, you can literally… Or we, we can sell you 500 notebooks, and they can come to your business, and you just have to open them up and turn them on. You know, they're all pre-configured and ready to roll. So it's-- But it's beginning. It's small customers, and it's large customers. It's state, local, federal government. It's healthcare. It's hospitals. It's any kind of school, K through 12, higher ed. So it's… The customer base is really large, and that kind of balanced portfolio of the customer is, you know, is a great advantage to us in the s- the cycles, the business cycles that come, come and go, so… Does CDW, um, do a fair amount of business that's not e-commerce?

12:04 'Cause I, I also envision they have just kinda like a direct sales force and- Yep … you know, procurement systems, and there's certainly kind of, you know, kinda two legs there. There's probably more of a direct sales force part, and then also an e-commerce, more transactional small stuff is- Right … is that kinda how it splits up or? Yeah, so the, I mean, the company was kinda built on the backs of the, the PC revolution. It started in 1985, and it was, um, an account manager, has been the title really forever, model, and it's the, you know, commission sales model. And, you know, that is our primary go-to-market strategy is you-- every, every customer, every prospect has an account manager who calls on customers, and the internet has been a great enabler for customers to either do, you know, high-touch integrations or just, you know, purchase all their products.

12:56 So we, we're very much a bimodal service and delivery mode. So, so number one, we have just the core transactional products, and people often think of CDW as really good at what you describe. But there's this part of CDW that we're trying to do a better job of communicating, and it's that we, we have cloud expertise, we have mo- mobility expertise for your mobile workforce. We have a really strong security practice. We have a data center practice. So they're, you know, they're really important solution areas that, that, uh, companies are trying to figure out, and we've got those types of, uh, consultative and actually field engineer s- uh, teams.

13:36 And then we sell hundreds of thousands of products. We represent many different partners and partners we refer to as HP or, um, Cisco. And so our goal is to stay relevant to our partners and our, and our customers, and we think if we can do that, then, you know, we'll, we'll continue to thrive and grow. Yeah. As a, as a geeky guy, I've, I'd known about CDW back from the Computer Shopper magazines. Like, I think they were, you know, one of the players in that whole thing when the- Yep … you get these three-inch… You probably did this, Jason. You'd go flip through those and find that one little widget you needed. Uh, but then, you know, I feel like it, you guys didn't really have much of a brand, but then lately, and I don't know when this started, but there was maybe in a Super Bowl ad a couple years ago. Mm-hmm. You know, it seems like you're kinda trying to build this kind of, kind of almost like consumer brand awareness kinda thing, and there's celebrities.

14:22 Like, I've seen Charles Barkley. Yep. And, uh, is he still the spokesman? And, and what, what do you think is kinda the, the thinking there to kind of… Is that just super top of the funnel so that, you know, people kinda understand when the purchasing guy is like, "I got it from CDW," or what, what, what's going on there? Or is it an attempt to be more consumery? It's definitely… It might have that effect of seeming more consumery, but it's, you know, our, our buyers are our consumers at the end of the day. So partnerships… So, so a couple points. One is, yeah, the ad campaign was, was with Barkley, which is over a number of… You know, the Gordon and Taylor was a, was an organization, kind of a mock company, b- and Barkley was an IT guy at Gordon and Tay- Taylor, and it was very funny.

15:06 C- CDW's always had a kind of a, a, a humor, humoristic part of its brand. So it was, how can we- Uh, raise awareness without taking ourselves too seriously. Mm-hmm. And, you know, Barkley was… Everybody knows Barkley, and our data said that our, our customer, the, the IT manager or IT buyer is often a sports watcher. So that begat partnerships, you know, him as a spokesperson, that got- begat partnerships like the NFL. So we, we never did a Super Bowl ad, but we are very present at the Super Bowl, and Monday Night Football we've done ads, and then the PGA. PGA's been another. So a- athletic sponsorships have been a, a big part of our marketing the last, I'd say, five years.

15:49 Interesting. And when you shot that ad, did you get a chance to tell, uh, Charles that you, you upset them in college? No, I was nowhere near that- … ad. But I… That was happening, uh, right when I was getting there and… But ev- you know, with a spokesperson, eventually you have to, uh… How long can you have a spokesperson? And, you know, spokesperson wants to do other things, and so, you know, the current campaign is about orchestration. That's orchestrat- IT orchestration, and it's trying to dial it back to it all starts with a conversation with CDW. Yeah. Right? So we're- That's where you have, like, the Lenovo Yoga, and it's kinda like doing its whole thing and… Yeah.

16:30 Yeah. Those are neat. Yeah. Yeah. And we're t- we're talking to the… We really understand the customer's needs, and so we can design custom solutions for, for our customers. Yeah. Yeah, the spokesperson thing is kind of fraught with peril, 'cause there's, like, the, the Dell dude, he went sideways. Yeah. Uh, and then I've seen that Verizon guy now is on all the Sprint ads, and he, like, totally throws Verizon under the bus. It's pretty, pretty tricky. But Flo has kinda hung in there, so you can always trust Flo. Yeah, that's, that's a good long-term- Yeah … example. Barkley, I think Barkley, there's no doubt that, uh, our brand awar- awareness increased under him. He was great. I think the Gordon Taylor ads were very, very funny and very on point, and I think the orchestration campaigns are great too.

17:10 So, but no, we're not… I think we, we get consumer business. I mean, people think we're retailers, um, but we are really built wired to serve businesses and organizations. And, uh, I know this would've predated you, but they were a pretty early mover on, you know, in terms of digital sales as well, right? Like- Yeah, I think their site was… I remember Crate & Barrel launched in, uh, April of '99. I remember that date. Uh, it was before me, but CW was before that. I mean, they were '98 or before '98. Yep. And I, I wanna say, uh, so I, I used to be a, a principal in a small business, and we were a customer.

17:55 And, uh, one of the things that was a big revelation for me was the first time I ordered something, like, in the business day for delivery the next day. Yeah. Um, and back then, that was unheard of. And the first time you said, "Wait a minute, like, our, our inkjet printer that just, uh, you know, took a dump, we could, uh, get a new one tomorrow," and it was exorbitantly expensive. Like, there was no free shipping back then. Right. Um, but, but that was a game changer for me. And that really, like, as, as a retail guy back then, that was really that first aha moment that- Right … hey, this is gonna fundamentally change how, how we all shop. That's the… That's what we're known for. You know, we, we… Scott described a scenario where we would We'd have the product, we'd know what product, and we could get it to you really fast.

18:42 And facilities that when I started in early 2014, the, the main distribution facility, there's still, you know, still a customer pickup area. Cus- so customers still come in and get their, get their product. It's like a depot-type setup if they really, really need it. So we're, we've been really good at distribution. We're not getting any worse at distribution. So that's a huge advantage- Yep … for us. And so are all the… Like, I know there were some actual retail stores. Are they all closed now? Yes. Well, they all… You can still go to this, uh, facility on Milwaukee Ave. The old one. Yeah. So come on, come on back. I will though. Visit us. You, as you probably know, you had a store across the street from the Merchandise Mart. I used to- Yes … walk by every day on the way home.

19:23 Right. It's always… Like, I know you might be B2B, but I was B- a C customer that- Right … could have a dangerous shopping spree in that store back in the day. Yeah, I mean, it's, it's, uh, it's well known in the Midwest. Um, and it is, uh, I think more and more well known nationally, and we're international now. We, um, started working in close partnership with a company called Kelway, and then that became an acquisition. They're a UK-based, uh, solutions provider, and, and now that's CDW UK. So that's done wonders in terms of global reach and ability to service multinational customers. Gotcha. Yeah. I wanna talk a little bit about that, but, um, I actually wanna go back for just a sec and make sure we're clear on sort of what the scope of your role is.

20:11 Uh, I'm not even sure it's clear when you talk to a- Right … B2C person and say, "Hey, VP of eCommerce," what the scope is. But in, in your role, do you, do you have any responsibility for, for product assortment and procurement, uh, for delivery? Is it purely the, the order acquisition? Like, what, what… Where does your job start and stop? So my job is, um, all the site experience, so what, what you generally think of in terms of product management, visual design. Uh, engineering's a dotted line, and also includes the kinda search marketing, SEO, um, you know, display.

20:53 Um, but no, the, all the procurement and all the distribution is, that's run elsewhere. Yep. Which is kind of- In- … good because we've been doing that a long time, and that's… We have really smart people. Yeah. You mentioned some marketing activities in there. I'm curious how you divide which ones end up in, in your role. Is it the digital versus non-digital, or is it the, the sort of direct response versus brand building, or? Yeah, it's, it's a really good question. We, we currently are- W- there's-- So in the marketing department, uh, where e-commerce sits right now, we have, um, someone who runs, let's just say, you know, the brand, traditional brand and, uh, the broadcast media.

21:40 And so, like when we were talking about those orchestration campaigns, those Barkley campaigns, there's a ton of display, uh, kinda traditional display that goes with that. And then, you know, w-we're l- there's also a lot of remarketing. And so it just bleeds into-- It's into his area and my area, and so that is a big, um, area we're working on together. Like we've created what we call a center of excellence. We put someone in charge of that who wants to m- who will really get us executing better across, you know, the, the whole breadth of marketing campaigns 'cause there's just-- we just have a lot of questions in that area, and we have a lot-- Uh, we're trying to get as many answers as we can.

22:20 We know we can be better. And so much-- The digital's just spread throughout the whole marketing organization, so it's… That's why we're, we're working together closely in partnership, so. Got you. Um, you-- We talked a little bit about the stores and the, the w-we'll call windows. How do you guys think about omni-channel? Like I imagine you have customers that, that use the web but might still have an account manager, and I, I think- Yep … you have a tele, uh, a telesales group too. Is that…? So the account manager is our telesales group. Got it. Like, so, so essentially, um, you know, we hire out of, out of college, um, put people in a training program, and account manager will get a, get a book of business and then expect to be productive with that book of business.

23:08 So, you know, oftentimes we're, we're trying to help acquire customers ourselves that oftentimes get, you know, fed into the account manager. So there's certainly a size of the account that makes more sense for an account manager. We have-- We do have what we call a sales contact center, which I think that's, that's what you're referring to, where I think it's really the s-smaller accounts, um, nascent accounts, ones that we're really trying to build up. And so that w- there's always a personal touch. There always can be a personal touch. Um, but not everybody wants an account manager or is, um, you know, does it make sense for us to be serving them that way.

23:53 Got you. Um, and are, is, are these-- Are the account managers and your site synergistic? Like, uh, or, uh, is there channel conflict there? Are you conf- uh, are you- No … stealing commissions from the account managers? Right. So that was a beautiful thing when I arrived there- I was paid by an account manager to ask that question. Well, they-- You, you know since you know account managers, they get paid no matter where the sale is conducted. So I never had to worry about that. Nice. I think it's a smart, smart thing. You know- We have this ability to… Customer can create a quote online and, you know, submit that to their account manager. Account manager can just complete that, update it, and then account manager can complete a quote and send it to their customer.

24:38 So there, there, there's always been like, how can we supplement and make the account manager more impactful through, through digital? And I think we're just kind of beginning to figure, figure that out and do-- There's lots, lots more to do. Yep, and it seems like there's a lot more nuances in, in the B2B space about all those workflows that you might wanna start an order with an acc- a, a personal touch and then complete it self-service or vice versa. Right. And, you know, often procurement is different than the, the end user and all of those sorts of- May even have approvals, you know? Maybe- Yep … your account manager knows that for X dollars it needs to go up a level or something like that.

25:20 Yeah. Yeah, I mean, you guys, you're right on. I mean, there's … That, that core business that we kind of grew up with is people wanna self-service that more, right? It's much easier, and we're, we're very much… We, we create very customized experiences for our customers online. So once you log in, your experience is very much yours and very different than, um, one of your competitors or any other customer. So, you know, that's, um, kind of the, the core of who we are, and so it w- you know, how can we do more of, of that is, is what we're trying to, to work on.

26:03 Sure. A- another thing that's really interesting to me, uh, you mentioned your partners earlier, and I think- Yep … like Lenovo or HP. Yep. Uh, we are at shop.org. Uh, Scott and I are gonna do a session on, uh, a, a number of things, but one of the things we're talking about is brands going direct. Mm. And it certainly seems like a lot of your partners have gotten very serious about their direct to cons- direct to end user sales. Right. Like, is, has, is there more conflict than there used to be for you, and how, how do you guys think about, like, those sorts of efforts from your partners? Are they frenemies now or? So in some cases, we have some, we have some really interesting agreements.

26:44 Like, for, there's, there's some partners where you'll be on their website checking out, and we'll, we'll actually read that data, and we'll complete that order, and we'll ship that product. So, and there's some customer, some partner of ours that would like us to actually be their, their website experience, their front-end website experience. So a lot of our partners draw lines i- in a sense of w- how far down they'll go in terms of size of organization that they'll wanna service and cover. And so they look to us as, like, really good at serving small customers, and we're good at serving large customers, and so we're actually becoming the website for some of our partners, which, you know, is a really interesting notion.

27:34 Under their URLs? Yes. Yep. You would not know the difference when, when you go there. You're white labeling basically- Mm-hmm … a e-commerce experience for them. I think it makes sense if you're gonna have this high touch, high customization thing, you can't have that for the router company, the, you know, the UPS company, the laptop company, the, the every- you know, the cabling company. Right. It just doesn't… It's not scalable, and it's inefficient, and I don't think it would work, so. Right. So it's… We're… That's just an, an e-commerce capability that I would never have imagined, you know, leaving Crate & Barrel, which is one of the reasons why I wanted to go CDW, was doing integrations, number one with our customers. I think you referenced that, Jason, is kind of procurement integrations with ERP systems.

28:18 How can we make purchase a whole lot easier? And then the, the… we could actually use that type of capability to, you know, connect, solve a partner problem, and help, you know, them focus on, um, higher level things. And that's You know, at the end of the day, we, we want our account managers solving our customers' problems, right? And we want them to be having higher level conversations with our customers, and the more we can kinda offload, um, let's just say the, the transactional business, it's, it's good for our customers, good for our, our account managers. And if that experience is completely customized, and we know exactly what, you know, they're purchasing and the, the price is the right price for them, then that, that can be a really… That's a good experience for us and them.

29:05 Cool. So John, going back to your s- your, um, Crate & Barrel time, you had this front row seat from kinda, I think you said '01 to '13. Mm-hmm. Um, you know, they had stores. I don't know how many stores they had when you joined, but, you know, they, uh, I kind of first experienced them through stores. Uh, and you, you saw this interesting life cycle of omnichannel, and everyone we talk to is very different how that, that went. I'd love to hear some, you know, how that went during your tenure there. Yeah, so the, the point of view at Crate & Barrel was very, um, store. I mean, the, the leadership was, uh, concentrated more on the store, and the m- the catalog was meant to drive traffic into the store. And, um, the furniture sales associates are all, they're all commission-based- Mm-hmm … at, at Crate & Barrel, and I don't know if they still are today.

29:52 But, um, there was definitely, uh, channel conflict in, in the early days because we're, we're, we're exploding with, with growth. And the store business, uh, was still growing at a real healthy pace, but there was, um, just a lot of… First, a big-- it was a cust- it was customer experience, which I think was the, the thing that always grounded Crate & Barrel was, you know, if we, if our images weren't good enough online, or if the product description wasn't good enough online, then the stores got the problem. It wasn't, wasn't necessarily the call center. So I w- I made a point always to go to stores, visit stores, and talk to the store, store leadership.

30:39 So when it came time to do something big, like eventually roll out furniture online, it was done kinda together, and done in a way that we create a high-touch model on the store side. Um, but I think- There's, there's-- It's still always a difficult thing when you do have commissioned salespeople- Mm-hmm and the business, their business over time just ends up being much harder to come by. And, you know, there are some who, uh, understood the, the value of the web and how customers were researching and coming in to purchase. Um, um, but I, I would say it took, it took a while, like the mindset of, um, looking to the web in the beginning was, was hard for people to do.

31:26 Like today, we, we-- the three of us were together and someone was showing an example of the Washington Post where they just took the Post story and then they put the, of, from the paper, and they literally put it on the web, and there was- Yeah … you know, a lot of that in terms of how can we deliver our, our marketing campaigns, our catalog, um, photography in, in better ways. So, um, organizationally, it never, um, the, the… There were still like store operations and e-commerce. It was still kind of broken out that way. I used to always joke when we had, uh, clients that wanted to just take the, that catalog and, and digitize it, that like when you did your first television ad, did you just aim the camera at the newspaper ad for thirty seconds?

32:13 Well, that's, um, it's funny you should bring that up, Jason, because that was kind of like- You can't fight City Hall in a way. Like, I just said, "Okay, we'll go ahead and do that. We'll go ahead and put the page-turner catalog because, you know, if that's what some of the, the team wants here- Yep … we'll just, we'll just deliver that." And, um, we all know that people never… It just didn't really work, but it was w- You gotta pick your battles. You do have to pick your battles. It was my- Yeah. You gotta check the box and move on. My philosophy on that. Yeah. Um, but, you know, I think we… You know, mobile was, uh, was a, was r- really becoming more and more important as I was leaving, and I think that the team there now has done some really, really great things.

33:02 But the, the ability to kinda deliver these experiences there, especially on the gift registry side, that include a store event, you know, uh, offline marketing and then online marketing and an app. You know, those were, those were some of the things that, you know, are, are great examples of how to leverage all the different touchpoints. Cool. It wouldn't be a Jason and Scot show if I didn't ask you the Amazon question. So, um, the Amazon question is you've seen this arc from, you know, even maybe back in the Circuit City days, you probably saw Amazon and were… You know- Mm … it may have been something that inspired you to get more into the digital side. The- Right … uh, then, you know, I'm sure you competed with them at Crate & Barrel, and then now, you know, you know, effectively, you know, Amazon has Amazon Business.

33:43 They have a lot of IT products on there. How, how do you think about Amazon? Are they kind of a competitor? Are they a friend and, um, you know, how do you… You know, if, if there was a young e-commerce kinda company coming to you for advice, what, what would you tell them? I remember Amazon approaching us when I was at Crate & Barrel, and I, I took that conversation, um, you know, all the way to the point where it made s-sense just because I wanted to learn as much as I could about it, and as did others at Crate & Barrel. And at the end of the day, it came down to, you know, proprietary product brand and then who owns the customer. And so I've kind of always seen Amazon as a competitor- Mm-hmm … y- dialing it back to that, that experience.

34:28 And so CW's a little bit different because, um, you know, they're, they're certainly a competitor. They are ramping up their Amazon business presence, and so we're, we're, we're paying attention to that. And, uh, they're selling many of the same technology products that we are. Uh, they also have Amazon Web Services, which we've all heard about and read about, and, you know, CW helps customers migrate to the cloud and make, um, platform as a service decisions. So what is our relationship with them there? That's, um, that conversation I think is very unique to some of my peers here is-- I was in a, a small group talking about Amazon, and that, that aspect of it is completely different.

35:17 So- It's kinda like Target carrying the, the Echo or some of the devices. You kinda have this multifaceted relationship because, you know, they're a brand man- they're an electronics manufacturer now, and they're a cloud provider and- Right. Yeah. So I… But some of the things that Jason was mentioning, just the, the procurement and the customization and, um- We have had really good success in that area, and Amazon is there in that area now as well. And for us, we just, we, we, we put a lot of emphasis on the account manager and that relationship. And then we have, you have… We have engineering teams, we have solution architects, people who can really help customers solve problems.

36:02 So the human element to CW is, has always and w- uh, will always be part of who we are, and we think that's owning that relationship and having an active, healthy customer relationship will, will make the difference. Yep, and it, it certainly seems, you know, if you're a multi-brand retailer, you're right in Amazon's sweet spot. So you're really sort of competing- Right … right in, in the mouth of the beast. Um, you guys have a lot of elements of your customer experience today that, that Amazon doesn't offer. Mm-hmm. Um, and so that certainly wouldn't give me great comfort 'cause they're obviously a scary competitor. Um, but you do have some, some points of differentiation in your customer experience today that Amazon isn't trying to meet.

36:44 I'm always curious, it seems to me one of the big impacts they have on you is shifting those customer expectations. Like, do you have customers that expect t- not to pay shipping anymore and expect to get goods faster and all of those sorts of things because they, in their personal life, they, they place an order for one laptop o- on Amazon, and they get it really fast, so why can't I place an order for 5,000 laptops with you and get them just as fast and free? Right. So a lot of times we can get it there just as fast. Um, the free part, I think it just depends on, on the situation and… But if you go to our website, you know, you'll see different prices than, than them.

37:24 In some cases that, that pricing is very competitive, some cases it's not, but you'll see shipping, and that's a, that's something that we're talking about actively- Yep right now. And is that a controversy in your space at all? Like, you have an open website, so I can go browse products even if I don't have an account. That's right. I know a lot of B2B companies, rightly or wrongly, sort of lock down the browse experience to customers only. Well, you, so if you are a customer, you can… Your, your logged in state is, um, you know, is gonna be very different. But we've got to get that point across to people who aren't our customers, and I think that's one of our, one of our challenges.

38:08 So we do talk about price and, um, you know, you dial it back to our, our, the PLA experience on Google and what… Are we price competitive just straight up on certain products that can be that starting point of a relationship? Mm. And if you throw in shipping like you are, that's, that can be a factor in us not getting that first sale. And so I think about how we, um, should maybe adjust things or how can we, how can we tackle that, that problem? Because I think, I think customers, it's not so clear our value w- if you just come to the site straight up, and I think that we, we can do a better job in, in making that value proposition more, more clear.

38:55 We, we're not, we don't wanna… Price is not how we wanna compete, but we, we wanna be price competitive. Yeah. That makes sense. Um, you mentioned earlier when we were talking about Crate & Barrel that mobile was just starting to impact the expectations and experiences. What about at CDW? Like, how… I think it's a big next on the list area. So I've been there two and a half years, and it, it's been a question of prioritization and what comes first, second, third. So just the straight up data from our customer is just very different than what I was experiencing at Crate & Barrel, just the sheer number of, um, visits and… Now, visits to the site Now people are definitely looking at our ads heavily on, on mobile.

39:46 Um, but our… So we, so we have a mobile optimized site and we have, um, apps, but we haven't invested in those, um, really n- now since I've been there. And we, we want to really understand what kind of problems can we solve w- for our customers using mobile. And I think, Scott, you were talking about purchase approvals, and there's, there's just some really easy things- Yeah … that you have to do in the day in the life of a, an IT manager or someone in procurement. And I- Even just, like, what assets do I have, it seems like mobile would be perfect for that. Like- Yeah … oh, I've- Tagging … I'm going to building X- Yeah … what assets are here? You guys would kinda know a lot of that and be a, a helpful partner on it.

40:27 Yeah. So that's where we're headed with- Yeah … with how can we use mobile to, to better deliver, um, success in our customers' jobs. So it's more to come- Nice … on that one. We will, uh, look foring, forward to seeing it and hearing about it. Yeah. Um, but it has happened again. We've used a perfectly good 45 minutes of our listeners' time. So John, we're super grateful for you taking the time out of your busy schedule here at shop.org, and we really appreciate your insights. Thank you, guys. Yeah, thanks, John. We really appreciate it. We know you're busy, and, and appreciate you taking the time. It was fun. Thanks. Thanks. You've been listening to The Jason and Scot Show.

41:07 For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes or visit www.jasonandscot.com.