Welcome to The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News!
Jan. 16, 2016

EP009 - CES Recap, NRF Preview, #RIPPurePlay, Amazon, Holiday Recap

EP009 - CES Recap, NRF Preview, #RIPPurePlay, Amazon, Holiday Recap
EP009 - CES Recap, NRF Preview, #RIPPurePlay, Amazon, Holiday Recap
The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News
EP009 - CES Recap, NRF Preview, #RIPPurePlay, Amazon, Holiday Recap

EP009 - CES Recap, NRF Preview, #RIPPurePlay, Amazon, Holiday Recap

EP009 - recap of CES, a preview of NRF, L2 #RIPPurePlay event, Amazon fulfillment and tax news, and Holiday wrap-up.

/ / http://retailgeek.com/podcast

/ / Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.

0:00 Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here is Jason and Scot Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show. This is episode nine being recorded on January 13th, 2016. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg. And as always, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Jason. Welcome back from CES. I, I guess you survived, and we didn't have to go bail you out of Sin City or anything.

0:41 Uh, you did not. Although, I have several upcoming events, including one with you in Las Vegas, so I won't rule out that you will ever have to do that. I'll keep, uh, keep some cash on hand just in case. I appreciate it. What, um, tell me all the exciting stuff you saw at CES. Yeah, so I think there's, you know, both some interesting personal stuff and that are probably more professionally relevant to us. But, you know, when you look at the big five trends overall at CES, TVs always get bigger and better every year, and this was the year that, like, all the consumer-grade TVs became 4K TVs, and there's a lot of content for the, uh, in 4K for the TVs. So, uh, in the TV part of the show, it definitely was the year of 4K.

1:22 The car industry is really taking off at CES. I think, like, 12 auto manufacturers were at this year's show. And a ton of car tech, connected car stuff, uh, from all the manu- ma- major manufacturers, and of course, some, some cool, uh, autonomous car stuff. I know we talked a little bit about the Faraday concept in our last episode. But the other big trends at the show, I- uh, Internet of Things keeps getting bigger, and, you know, there's now a huge section of the show dedicated to specifically to Internet of Things for fitness and Internet of Things for connected home. This definitely felt like the first year that, that connected home could potentially go mainstream. And then the two topics that I know you would've totally geeked out on, uh, there was just a ton of augmented reality and virtual reality and, uh, like, more drones than you could shake a stick at Cool.

2:16 Were they actually letting them fly the drones around the Las Vegas Convention Center? Kind of. They've totally figured out how to exhibit drones at CES. So there, there are a wide variety of these cages that they hang from the ceiling, uh, some of them quite large. And so like in the Parrot booth, there's a huge cage, and they do these, um, synchronized… It's almost like a dance number with like music, and the, uh, the drones like doing autonomous flight to the music. And, um, there's some pretty big spaces. There was even one cage that had like laser tag built into the drones, and they literally had drone battles in the cage, which was pretty fun. Whoa, that sounds fun. Yes. I did not get to, uh, c- partake in a battle, but I enjoyed watching a few.

2:59 One thing I think surprised me is I saw a lot of, um, cool new features and announcements around Amazon Echo. Uh, and that's funny because a lot of people have poo-poohed Amazon's hardware ambitions, especially after the Fire. And I remember when Echo came out, and for those of you that don't know, it's that, that kind of vertical black, um, speaker. It's like a Bluetooth speaker, but it has natural language with Alexa as kind of their Siri. Um, and I'm seeing more and more momentum around home automation, and I think there was even some connected car stuff. What-- Did you see anything related to that? I did. A ton of people have integrated E- uh, Echo into their product. So I think Amazon has started to open up APIs, and they clearly are participating with third parties.

3:44 And so a bunch of booths were announcing their new Echo-enabled capabilities. And to me, like one of the best examples was Ford. And Ford had fully integrated the Echo into their dashboard. So any of the commands that you would traditionally give to a, an Echo at home, you could give to your car, and your car would relay them to a, a, an Echo service in the cloud, um, and execute them. So if you have, uh, lights integrated to your system at home or thermostats or garage door openers or if then then, this then that, which I can never say right- … any of those things that you have integrated to your Echo at home, you can now launch from your car.

4:25 And vice versa, they had added a bunch of car verbs to Echo. So you could now give Echo from your home commands like, "How much gas do I have?" "Where's the car parked?" Start the car to preheat it, you know, all, all of those kinds of things, and it, it was pretty elegant and smooth. By accident, it enabled some interesting things like when you're driving, you can, you know, be adding things to your Amazon wishlist. You can do some, some interesting searches about, you know, uh- uh, products in stores and things like that. So it, it both seem pretty powerful. Echo is also pretty good at media. You know, certainly if you, if you subscribe to the Amazon, uh, Echo system, uh, pun not really intended.

5:09 And, you know, are using Amazon Prime video content or, or storing your music on there and those things, uh, that then gives you access to all that content in your, in your car, which is pretty cool. But to me, even just taking one step back, better, uh, more seamless user interfaces were a huge trend at CES, and the, and pr- natural language was, was a big one. A lot of the TV remotes, uh, Apple, TiVo, um, Sling, you know, all, all now responding to, uh, natural language stuff really elegantly, and that seems like one of the reasons that Amazon's getting integrated into a bunch of these products is it may be one of the, the better natural language user interfaces that you can access via an API.

5:53 Although I, I've read recently that Microsoft is opening up, uh, APIs for Cortana Cortana, yes. That felt like a big trend. Also, a ton more, like, uh, gesture recognition. Intel was showing a lot of their, uh, using their 3D cameras in all sorts of interesting ways, uh, as a user interface. Hmm. Cool. Any, uh, retail, um, examples there at CES? Yeah, so there were a few things. There literally is an e-commerce section of the show this year, and it was sponsored by MasterCard, and specifically their mobile wallet, Masterpass. And so they, they had a booth, uh, with some interesting use cases. They were showing Masterpass-enabled commercial laundromats, so you could pay to do your laundry without finding coins, but you could also do interesting things like reserve a washing machine while you were still at home to make sure that there was one available when you got there.

6:44 They're, they're showing… They, they have, uh, facial recognition as a second authentication factor. I'm, I'm not super confident that that's how people want to authenticate themselves, but that was kind of interesting. While you're taking a selfie, you can authenticate. Exactly. It's like, it's kind of a two-for-one. Yeah. That people are sort of jokingly calling it selfie commerce. But they do have an interesting way to extend their mobile wallet. They, they have, uh, an ability to take any device with an NFC chip in it and, uh, make that a token for, uh, mobile payments. And so, you know, it turns out there are more and more devices that we own or carry anyway that might have an NFC chip in them. Obviously, a lot of phones, but some, uh, car key fobs have NFC chips in them.

7:30 There's some hideously ugly, quote-unquote, smart rings that have NFC chips in them. Uh, Samsung was showing a bunch of apparel with NFC chips in them, so there's an NFC chip in the sleeve of, of a Samsung business suit and in, in some athletic wear. And, uh, using this, this administrative console for Masterpass, you could give any of those devices permission to be payment vehicles. So imagine you're wearing the Samsung smart suit. Uh, you could permission that sleeve to pay for things, and if you go anywhere that accepts NFC payments, you swipe your sleeve and, uh, it, it, uh, gives a token from, from, uh, Masterpass to pay for it We're-- It seems almost a little too flexible.

8:11 I'd be, you know, gesticulating and paying for stuff by accident. Yeah, I think there's both that issue and, you know, people worry about losing some of those devices and then having someone else run amok with it. But, um- Yeah … which I think is a real risk that the way they mitigate that is, you know, this is a whole administrative console where you can quickly turn off those individual devices without turning off your, your whole account. Um, but so they, they had some interesting use cases. They had a smart gas pump, um, which potentially means, you know, faster transactions at the gas station. In this section that they sponsored, Alibaba had a booth, and their booth was mostly about, uh, helping, uh, US companies import Chinese goods.

8:53 Mm-hmm. This particular show, uh, Digital River had a small booth and a few other, like, obscure, um, e-commerce anti-fraud companies and a f- a few things like that. It, it didn't seem like e-commerce was a, a huge hit as a dedicated section at CES, but, you know, there's e-commerce scattered throughout CES. There are a lot of the Internet of Things devices that, you know, now enable payments. I think we talked last week about the smart refrigerator. Um, the-- Amazon has a booth at CES, but it's mainly about, uh, signing up, uh, B2B companies on their marketplace. Um, so, so you could definitely find some, some commerce if you looked.

9:34 To me, the most interesting things were sort of some of the retail applications for the consumer technology. So Panasonic had some cool stuff. Uh, they had a technology that they call, um, Visible Light Data Transmission, I think, which is a super elegant name. But the notion is that they can, um, oscillate a visible light at a speed that's, that the human eye can't see, but, but that transmits data to the cam- to the camera in a smartphone. Um, and so what that lets them do, the, the use case they had was like a subway station that's like a four-sided subway station, uh, terminal, and each side is giving you a map of a subway going in a different direction.

10:20 And, uh, you, you pop open the subway app and just aim the camera at the, the backlit sign, and the sign sends a URL to your phone that pops up the, the schedule for that particular uh, Subway. And so if you, you know, you point the camera at any of the signs, and you get that sign's data. And frankly, it was a way faster, way easier version of what we might have done last year with, like, a QR code. Yeah, it's like QR codes without all the hassle. Yeah, it's like QR codes on steroids, really. Mm-hmm. Um, and so you could definitely see that having an application in retail. They had some interesting surface-mapping technology for projectors.

11:01 So a few retailers are already experimenting with this, but you can kind of, uh, wrap a three-dimensional wall with video using some of these projectors and do some interesting things. And then you combine that with gesture recognition, and so you could, for example, turn a wall of athletic shoes into a digital display that had, you know, product information projected next to the shoes. And you could know when someone picked up the shoe and change the content and do stuff like that. Hmm. Cool. Yeah, so some cool underlying technologies. We'll see if, if retailers really adopt them. If that's the case, what we'll probably see is see them again next week at NRF. Yeah, yeah. Did, did you see, uh, speaking about drones, um, it was interesting 'cause Google, uh, did a little bit of, bit of drone trash talk.

11:45 They were kind of out Uh, you know, in an un-Googly kind of way talking about how far their drone program has go- gone, and they're projecting package delivery within a couple years in the United States, they, they said. And, um, looks like it's kind of them and Amazon pushing the FAA. Uh, and then I also saw that they are doubling down… They've always had Google Cardboard, which is their, uh, AR/VR effort, um, and they have the camera thing as well. Uh, but now they've announced they're actually gonna have a whole division within Alphabet focused a, a lot more seriously on virtual reality. So I thought those were two interesting kind of CES-ish, uh, but I guess they were separate from CES, but interesting to see Google getting a little more serious about bo- both of those technologies as well.

12:28 Yeah, absolutely. And if, if nothing else, like, they, they certainly validate both of those product categories when you see them, uh, making much more significant investments in resources and people in those, those two techs. Uh, to your point, it was interesting. You know, they had a lot of meeting space at CES, and I'm sure they were talking with folks privately, but they didn't have a actual booth and didn't… You know, they, they actually waited till after CES to make some of those announcements. Hmm. Did you see the, um, uh… Otherwise, this week, there was the whole bit of a controversy around L2. Did you see that? I did. I, I followed that. They, uh, had an, an event. They were, uh, live tweeting the event, and the hashtag for the event was called, uh, Rest In Peace Pureplay.

13:09 Hmm. I think the premise, and this is not a new position for L2 to take, I think they've been there for a while, is that Pureplay is not a sustainable model and that Pureplay e-commerce sites are not gonna be successful, uh, and that, that most of the ones that we like to name are all moving to become omni-channel retailers. And they use, of course, Warby Parker and Bonobos as big examples of companies that started out Pureplay and have shifted to omni-channel. And, uh, you know, their, their feeling is that shipping costs are just too high for Pure- for Pureplay to be profitable and that all these companies are gonna need stores as points of distribution in order to make the math work.

13:50 Hmm. Do you agree with that? I don't. Um, I don't think pure play is an easy path to success. I mean, I think all forms of retail are hard, frankly. You know, for sure, I think there's some unique challenges around being a pure play retailer. You know, I work predominantly with omni-channel clients, and it is absolutely true that those brick-and-mortar stores are great advertising vehicles that help build brand and drive traffic to the e-commerce sites. And so I certainly think there are some challenges in being a pure play retailer. But that being said, you know, I, I think there already are successful examples of pure play retailers.

14:30 I think of, you know, folks like Revolve Clothing or Newegg or eBags and, you know, certainly as soon as you leave the US and you look at, like, Alibaba or JD and some of those, I, I think, I think it's hard to say that there are gonna be no successful pure play retailers. Yeah. Yeah, I agree. The, um, one thing we had talked about a little bit because, uh, I guess it was… Was it last episode or maybe the one before? Um, there were some rumors out about flash sales, and since then those have been confirmed. Um, so first I guess it is now confirmed that Gilt has been sold. What do you think about that? Yeah, I, I don't think that was a huge surprise to anyone. I mean, I think that follows the same prin- trend as a lot of their competitors like Hautelook and Zulily.

15:13 But, uh, I, you know, I think the marquee thing there was the valuation. That, right, like they were at one point had a billion-dollar valuation and were a unicorn, and then, you know, they had to do a down round. And ultimately, uh, Hudson Bay Company paid less for them than the total amount that they raised. And so, you know, I think if you were an early investor in Gilt, you probably still did okay. I think if you were, uh, one of the founders of Gilt, that you could certainly consider this exit a win. But if you were a late investor, you, you probably didn't do well. And if you were a employee that stuck it out there for a long time in the hopes of, of your equity being worth something, you probably got totally screwed. Yeah. Usually works the other way.

15:54 Late investors do better than early investors, so probably, uh, because they have this preference stack that they get their money back first. Exactly. Yeah. I don't… I mean, who knows? Like, maybe there was a ratchet clause or something that they didn't, uh, didn't disclose. But I haven't, haven't heard anything about that. Yeah. And then, um, there's a couple other ones in the news, uh, and I don't know what happened. So One King's Lane, I think they were saying they were trying to raise money, but it was not going well, and the valuation was also cut. Um, any other f- uh, A, did you hear that, and B, any other flash sale news? Yeah, so I think, uh, Jason Del Rey broke that news that One, One King's Lane might be struggling financially. And then I think this week we heard that Beezer, which depending on how you count, you may or may not consider a flash sale, that they, uh, were coming close to running out of money and were finding it hard to raise more funds.

16:43 And for folks that might not be familiar with Beezer, Beezer is one of the founders of fab.com. And so, you know, Fab was maybe the original and best example of a fast-running pure play that, you know, arguably had a billion-dollar valuation at one point. And, uh, I think they got liquidated a couple times, but if you roll them all up, like, the core company probably ultimately sold for less than 10 million bucks. Yeah. Yeah, that's kind of a bad outcome. Exactly. It's particularly bad for me because the, the founder, uh, shares my same name, so I, I take a lot of the blame for, for that, that crash. Do you actually have people reach out to you or? All the time. People confuse us all the time. When the site was going well, it was funny because they had a lot of off-color product descriptions on the site.

17:28 And so I used to get emails from angry mothers that didn't like some of the salty language on the, on the pro- on the site. And now, you know, I get blamed for being a, a washed up, uh, e-commerce executive that crashed and burned a company and now has to, uh, make my living as a consultant. Which is, of course, half true. Yeah. You won't say which half. Exactly. Cool. D- so these flash sales kinda hitting the skids, does this kind of, uh, support the L2 theme? It does. Scott Galloway, the founder of L2, I think he's talked about this for a while, and I think he got it right. When these flash sales started, there was a real opportunity and need in the market for them, that there was a glut of product, we were entering a recession.

18:09 Uh, the luxury companies in particular had a bunch of distressed inventory and no way to clean it. And the flash sales, you know, really had an opportunity to get some good, appealing inventory and do some interesting things with it. Um, but that wasn't a sustainable model. It wasn't good in the long run for the luxury, uh, guys to be liquidating their, their product at lower prices in their home market. Um, and, you know, so ultimately they found better ways to, to clean up that inventory. The, you know, the big retailers, Nordstrom, uh, with Nordstrom Rack, and, and, uh, Saks with Sa- uh, Off Fifth, and, you know, the TJ Maxxes of the world. The market just got much more efficient at liquidating all that inventory, and suddenly the flash sales didn't have this good, cheap supply of products.

18:54 And, you know, as their, their inventory got less appealing, you know, it became really hard for them to be sticky. And, you know, ultimately, they, they just weren't earning any repeat customers. And e-commerce is, is very expensive when you only sell one thing to a customer. Yeah. Cool. Well, it wouldn't be a show without me, uh, sharing some Amazon news. So this week, uh, was pretty interesting. Uh, on Monday, it came out that Amazon was buying a French delivery company, and this is a courier, kind of like a FedEx, UPS, but much smaller obviously, but in France. Um, so, so that's pretty interesting. So they're, you know, uh, one of my 2016 predictions was that they will get a lot more serious about this, and, and this was an interesting first pass.

19:36 Um, they also announced, uh, a partnership with the University of Pennsylvania or UPenn, where they're going to be running an Amazon pickup and drop-off center within the university mail room. Uh, I thought that was pretty interesting. And, um, in that press release, what came out was, um, they said, uh, around half of the packages delivered to, to that whole facility all-- that all the students go to were Amazon, uh, boxes. So pretty amazing kind of stat there. And what I think was kind of lost in some of the press was, yes, this is, this is, uh, gonna be a convenience for the students to be able to kinda pick up their packages but also drop off returns.

20:17 But now you have an aggregation point there, and y- another aggregation point on the other side is the fulfillment centers. So instead of many UPS trucks bringing the packages and then, uh, you know, UPenn delivering them, now I think it'll be that much easier for Amazon to substitute in an Amazon truck. So, um, you know, you're starting to see these little collection, you know, uh, points, density points where Amazon can go in there, take that over, and, and take over that part of the delivery tree. So I think those were two interesting kind of movements from Amazon down this logistics path. Did, uh… What'd you think about those, and did you see any other interesting Amazon news this week? Yeah. So I mean, the college thing makes total sense. It's almost like they just added a will call window to a sortation center, and they essentially, to your point, have, have everything they need.

21:03 And, you know, as they start peeling off Business from, from UPS and taking it direct, those are gonna be like, you know, easy, easy points to make profitable. It's funny 'cause I think, uh, Sucharita Mulpuru had pointed out some, to me earlier that there were a bunch of college campuses that are complaining that their, their shipping and receiving, uh, facilities are now broken in the e-commerce era. That they, they s- can't keep up with the package volume. So Amazon has this great business interest in moving into those campuses, but it sounds like a lot of campuses are going to need Amazon or some other solution because they, their, their legacy facilities w- just weren't designed to receive the … They, they just literally don't have physical space for all the packages that students are getting.

21:45 Yeah. The, the loser on this is I don't know who runs the bookstore there, but that was probably a depressing announcement for them. Yeah. And especially like, uh, I think I also read in that same announcement that there's gonna be some pretty fast delivery, right? Like, that they're same delivery on orders, uh, uh, before noon and next day delivery on orders up to 10:00 PM. And so I mean, there's even immediate gratification on a lot of that. It's almost kind of like some kind of a hybrid Amazon Prime Now for students kind of a thing. Exactly. I, uh, so I've been a longtime student of Amazon's naming convention, and I believe that's gonna be Amazon College Prime Now. Hmm. Okay. I doubt it. Oh, the other Amazon news I noticed this week is I, I came across… I think it might have been out for a little while, but I just came across, uh, an Ohio State study on the impact of sales tax on Amazon And I, I found it a little interesting, uh, because I remember when Amazon first started collecting tax, um, there were a bunch of early studies that indicated that it really wasn't having a derogatory impact on their sales or their business.

22:49 And to be honest, I just filed that fact away and had sort of assumed that Amazon was starting to collect tax in all these states where it now had nexus as it opened fulfillment centers, and that they weren't having any impact from collecting that sales tax. But this Ohio State study seems to say that they absolutely are being impacted by collecting sales tax. And so I'll put the link to the study in, in the show notes, but the key findings in the study are that in states where Amazon started collecting tax, they're selling 8.3% less merchandise, which is pretty close to the average state tax rate. So, you know, that tells you that consumers are spending about the same amount, amount with or without tax, and that, you know, Amazon's just getting less of that revenue when they have to charge tax.

23:35 That… The study also showed that on big ticket items, items over 250 bucks, the spending got hurt even more, which kinda makes sense. When you start, you know, spending hundreds of dollars, y- the tax starts feeling more meaningful. And so they found that, uh, Amazon was selling 11.4% less when, on, of items that are over 250 bucks. But the, the most interesting thing to me was trying to figure out what the impact of Amazon collecting tax has on other e-commerce sites and on brick-and-mortar retailers. 'Cause, you know, when all of these e-commerce tax issues were being kinda debated in public, it was always that that was the unfair advantage that Amazon had and that brick-and-mortar retailers were getting screwed.

24:18 And what the Ohio State study saw is that when Amazon started collecting tax, it was beneficial to other e-commerce sites in that state in that same category. So they looked specifically at consumer electronics, and they saw Newegg sales go up by 11.3% when Amazon started collecting tax. Presumably Newegg wasn't collecting tax in there, and so again, that's- Hmm that's not shocking, right? Like, that's exactly what- Yeah … what you might expect, is that the, that bargain hunters shifted to a site that didn't collect tax. But what was mildly interesting to me was they showed Best Buy sales going up 7.1% in states where Amazon started collecting tax, and that, that to me is a little interesting that suddenly it was more appealing to go to a store Which is- Yeah maybe one piece of potential good news for omni-channel retailers.

25:06 Yeah. The, uh, it's interesting. I w- definitely wanna read that. So, um, we did a little study around, uh, when they launched in California, when Amazon started collecting tax, and what we did is we indexed the transactions in California versus the rest of the, the country on a same store sales kinda basis. And what we saw in our data was a run-up, you know, Amazon over-performed running up to the tax event. Um, and then it underperformed, but it only lasted, uh, if I recall, about 30 days, and then they kinda went back to the norm. Um, so the sales were kind of comparable year over year to those in states that Amazon doesn't collect tax in. So, uh, definitely interesting to see. I think our data was a little bit different than that.

25:47 Yeah. You know, there's definitely a convenience factor in there, and I, I think, you know, Amazon has kind of done some calculus on the, the cost and, and the, the convenience and the Prime factor of the lock-in of that, and, uh, it hasn't slowed their growth. So they're… I think, I think 60% of the US population now, um, uh, uh, has tax collected in, um, so, you know, definitely crossed the midpoint. So it hasn't slowed their growth down, so, um, you know, I haven't seen, seen it in the data there. Yeah, no, if there is a, a tax penalty for Amazon, they certainly have overcome it in growth, right? Yeah. It, it, it would be interesting. I normally am not a big fan of surveys, but a fascinating survey for me would be to survey a big chunk of Amazon customers and, and ask if they are paying tax or not.

26:32 Um, and my, my theory is there, there are a bunch of Amazon convenience shoppers that don't actually know that they're now paying tax. Yeah. It could be. Um, but it is… With all of these studies, you know, we've talked about it before, it's, it's important to understand where the data's coming from and what the methodology is, right? 'Cause obviously you guys have a super interesting data set, but it's probably fair to assume that it's gonna skew towards categories that are, uh, have a lot of 3P activity. Mm-hmm. Yep. Um, and, uh, I think the Ohio State data was, like, 500,000 users, but they were 500,000, uh, users that were using, like, a, a mobile shopping app to track their, their purchases.

27:15 Um, and, you know, so to me, the first thing I hear when I hear that kinda stuff is, oh, this is a, a self-selected segment of, of users that are, uh, a lot more digitally aware and engaged than the, you know, probab- probably typical consumer. Yeah, most Amazon shoppers don't use a- another app to track their shopping. They just use the Amazon app. Exactly. Cool. One thing we haven't talked about a while, even though it's late in 2016 here on, uh, January 13th, is the holiday wrap-up. Uh, so comScore was out with their wrap-up, and it was pretty interesting. I don't know if you had a chance to look at it or not. Uh, I did, uh, get an overview, but it sounded like they felt like they were pretty close to their original project.

27:59 Do I have it right? Yeah, they were at 14%, and they said that, uh, the holiday came in, uh, just below that. They didn't, they didn't kind of put a number out. I think they're waiting on their mobile data. It takes quite a while. Um, but so, you know, I think, uh, our data, we put out our same store sales, and we came in at about 13 and a half percent. So a little bit below kind of the 14, 15% that comScore was saying. Uh, the comScore data, one thing that was interesting, they said the, that desktop really underperformed. They were expecting kinda 8 to 10% growth, and it came in at 6. Uh, and then mobile, I think they're expecting 45 to 50% growth, and it grew, uh, at, uh, 60 to 65%. So it made up some of the slowness from desktop but, uh, not enough to kinda get to the, the overall.

28:43 So, um, then they also highlighted, um, a lot of big wins by omni-channel. Uh, particularly they called out Target and Walmart around, uh, Black Friday, Thanksgiving, and those kinds of promotions, saying that they had a very strong, uh, uh, showing, at least in their data f- online from, from those offline promotions. That certainly jibes. Like, when we've looked at retailers starting to report their holiday sales, the big boxes, Target and, and Walmart, uh, certainly did well versus some of the, like, department stores and, and some of the other retail categories. Yeah. So, uh, big event coming up next week. Are you excited to go to the, the big show, the NRF big show? Uh, I am. I'm all geared up. I was just gonna say, if you're not doing anything, we should both go.

29:24 Uh, let's do it. Let's, uh… We should even, like, shoot the show from there. Hey, that'll be perfect. We'll do it f- like, we'll do it, uh, right on the show floor to get that, the vibe and the energy of, of the, the big show. I, I, I think that'd be great, although we may need a better audio engineer than the one we're using now. He's fired. Exactly. Um, uh, one thing I wanted to point out to folks is I will be leading a talk Sunday at 3:00 PM. Uh, if you're not watching NFL games, feel free to stop by. Um, and we're gonna, uh, it's a panel, and we have GameStop, Neiman Marcus, Sofil, and TPN Retail, and we're gonna talk about this trend that's, uh, really caught on fire here with retailers, which is opening, um, innovation labs kind of as a, a way to, uh, have a area within the company where people are free to, to innovate and try different things that you normally wouldn't do within the, the normal corporate structure.

30:19 So would love to see a lot of our listeners there at that. Yeah. Uh, will you be signing autographs after the session if we want? I will. Um, I'm at a booth where they're $50, and you have to go get a ticket and, uh, whatnot. But you can, uh… You'll see signage for that. Cool. Can you buy the tickets online? No, I d- I, I don't believe in that. I, the, the e-commerce is just a fad. Gotcha. Uh, no, that does sound cool, though. I'm, I will certainly be there, and, uh, will be looking forward to it. It… That's a hot topic. You know, what is the best way… Like, obviously everyone wants to be more innovative and feels like they're challenged with innovation, but it feels like there's a bunch of different recipes that each are kind of in vogue at the moment.

31:00 So it'll be interesting to hear if the, if the, the folks on the panel all agree or if there's some, some, uh, conflict hopefully. Yeah. And then, uh, the other big thing I'm keeping an eye out, uh, for is, uh, some results coming out. So, um, and usually by now these companies would have reported, but at the end of the year, they get a little bit extra time from the SEC. So eBay is first out on January 27th with their results. Uh, and then Google/Alphabet is out February 1st. Um, and then Amazon is out February 4th. The, um… Wall Street is particularly excited about Google Alphabet because for the first time they're gonna, um, break out Google the search engine from the rest of Alphabet.

31:40 And, um, there's a wide variety, uh, uh, of kind of guesses out there for how big is Google and how profitable is it. And I imagine that people are gonna be blown away by, A, how big and profitable the Google search engine is, and then, B, by how much they're losing money over on the non-Google search engine stuff. So it's gonna be kind of fascinating to see that. It's kinda… I liken it to when Amazon broke out AWS. Uh, everyone had different theories, and most of them were wrong, and Amazon just blew away everyone's expectations. So that's gonna be kind of a big news event here in the world of, of e-commerce and just digital. Yeah, no, and I, I imagine that those are, uh, from a pure investment standpoint, that those are always scary moments because there's, there's these assumptions cooked into the price, and then when, you know, the real data comes out for the first time, there can be a pretty big, pretty immediate, uh, adjustment.

32:31 That's all I had this week. How about you? That feels like a pretty good week. Obviously, I'm really excited to see many of my e-commerce f- uh, friends and particularly you next week in New York for NRF. So I wanna thank everyone for listening, and we look forward to seeing many of you next week. Thanks everyone. Bye. You've been listening to The Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes and please leave a review.