Welcome to The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News!
Nov. 30, 2016

EP061 - Cyber 5 Holiday Recap 2016

EP061 - Cyber 5 Holiday Recap 2016
EP061 - Cyber 5 Holiday Recap 2016
The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News
EP061 - Cyber 5 Holiday Recap 2016

EP061 - Cyber 5 Holiday Recap 2016

Thanksgiving:

Black Friday

Cyber Monday:

  • Cyber Monday set the all time US record for e-commerce sales at $3.45 billion , 12.1% YoY Growth (Adobe)
  • Mobile 56% visits / 37% sales. Mobile Conversion 1.9% vs Desktop Conversion 4.3% (Adobe)
  • Macy’s had a significant site outage for 8 hours. William Sonoma, Victoria’s Secret, Express and Pier 1 also had interruptions.

IBM Realtime e-commerce dashboard

Conclusion

Black Friday has become a major online shopping day (only $110M smaller than Cyber Monday) and growing much faster (likely to pass Cyber Monday next year). Black Friday is the busiest Mobile shopping day of the year. Cyber Monday set the all time US record for e-commerce sales. Mobile traffic is over 50% over the holiday but mobile conversion is close to half of desktop conversion, but the conversion gap is narrowing. Store Traffic is down which likely means a mediocre overall holiday.

Don't forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.

Episode 61 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded on Thursday November 28, 2016.

http://jasonandscot.com

Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.

0:02 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here are Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. This is episode 61, being recorded on Monday, November 28th, 2016. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, and as usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey. Happy Cyber Monday, Jason.

0:43 It's one of my favorite days of the year. How are you doing, Scott? It is my favorite day of the year, unless there's, uh, something else personal going on, but it is a great day. Do you hate all the people in China? No. No, they're all good people too, but, uh, just not as exciting as Cyber Monday. I, uh, it is more fun to be able to, uh, uh, see it all happening live right in front of you as the- the poor UPS guy runs around with his head cut off. Yeah, and shows up at, like, 11:00 PM, and he's halfway done with his deliveries. Exactly. We're- we're recording the show late at night, and, uh, uh, I feel like I've had several deliveries since we started the show already. Yeah, you are doing a lot of research today.

1:23 I'm, um, I'm, uh … It's awesome. Good- good of you to do that for the show. We appreciate it. Hey, I- I am here for our listeners. Uh, that's one of the things I always chuckle about, is a lot of the retail reporters will go out and they'll do secret shopping, and they'll try, you know, buy online, pick up in store orders. And, you know, they're always buying something that you know they want. Yeah, yep. Did you have a good Thanksgiving? I had a great Thanksgiving. Uh, I got to see lots of family and, uh, a lot of the little cousins got to hang out with my, my little, uh, one-and-a-half-year-old, so it was wonderful. How about yourself? I did. Uh, had a big question for you, though. I, I know you like the sweets. What's your, uh, favorite… What's your go-to Thanksgiving dessert?

2:05 Uh, so I'm a traditionalist. I'm a big fan of the pumpkin pie, although- Ooh … an aunt showed up with a pumpkin cheesecake, which I feel like might have been the, the consensus winner this year. Nice, nice. Do you go, uh, your pumpkin pie, do you have it, uh, naked, or do you throw a little, uh, Cool Whip on there or whipped cream? I prefer some whipped cream, and then once again, uh, one of my culinary relatives upped it a notch with a cinnamon whipped cream this year- Whoa … which was delicious on the pumpkin pie. Yeah. Man. Man, that is, that's fancier than we do here. We're, we're kinda basic folks. I am the beneficiary of some other people working hard on those things. I was not that creative. Cool, and even more important than Cyber Monday is Star Wars, of course, and Rogue One tickets went on sale, uh, this morning or last night, depending on how you look at it, at midnight.

2:55 Did you stay up and get your Rogue One tickets? I did not have to stay up because, uh, I unfortunately have an obligation on opening day, and so my, I will have to wait until December 21st to see it, but I do already have my tickets. You can always cancel obligations. You gotta have your priorities straight. Uh, that would lead me to believe that you're seeing it on opening day. Is that true, Scott? Yes. There's… The, the problem with Star Wars, as you learned last year, is if you don't see it on opening day, then you get spoilered, and that's just painful. Yes. A, a young nephew spoiled it last year, although I'm more nervous about you spoiling Rogue One. I, I don't like spoilers, so I try not to spoil it for other people No, no I will-- I'll be good.

3:37 Let, let the record show that you're completely trustworthy. I was just having fun with it. Well, listeners, this is our Cyber Monday show, and we're gonna go through the data so far that's been out there, some of the highs and lows, and try to get an early read on how the holiday's shaping up. As a reminder, as we headed into the holiday, if you didn't get a chance to listen to our last podcast, first of all, shame on you, and second of all, just to bring you up to speed, there was probably the widest range of forecasts for this holiday that I've ever seen. Um, the first one that was out was eMarketer, and they said 17% for e-commerce and 3.3% for all of retail in the US. Deloitte came out, uh, and topped that with 17 to 19% for e-commerce, which was pretty exciting.

4:18 4% for all retail. NRF did not break out e-commerce, but they said 3.6% for all retail, which would imply they're kind of at 18% if you kinda do the math on that. Um, Comscore came out, and they said 16 to 19%, so similar to the Deloitte number. Uh, and then Adobe was the low on this one. Uh, as To- Tamara said on our show, she said they're at about 11%. Um, and as she told us on the last episode, uh, we're actually trailing behind that, and she wasn't sure if they'd have to bring it down or not. So that was a little depressing. Uh, then IBM was kind of in the middle of those, uh, at 14%. They just recently came out with their forecast. They did a just-in-time forecast.

4:59 Um, so that's kinda the setup going into this. And then another kind of just interesting thing, uh, it wouldn't be a Jason and Scot show if we didn't talk a little bit about Amazon. So one of the interesting things going to Amazon that had a lot of us concerned, there was a threat of a pilot strike. I think they actually did go on strike, uh, but then a judge ordered them back to work in, like, a day or two. So, um, it's interesting, you know. Amazon's really only had planes for a year, year and a half now, and now, uh, it's-- they've got 40 planes and something like 70, uh, pilots, cargo pilots, and it could have actually been pretty disruptive to Prime deliveries to have that happen. So just kind of interesting that, you know, you-- they're starting to get so big that these things that wouldn't have impacted them before could possibly impact them.

5:42 Yeah. It, it's ironic. Like, usually this time of year, we're talking about, like, a particular port or the longshoremen or something that would affect the supply chain for all retailers, and they're, you know, they're, they're all terrified of it. This was a rare occasion when the majority of retailers were rooting for the strike Yeah, yeah, yeah. Except for, uh, the Amazon sellers. They were, you know, if you got your stuff in FBA, you really need that infrastructure to work for you. Absolutely. So Jason and I went back and forth on the best way to present this data, and we ended up kind of with a chronological order. So what we're gonna do is take each day of the Cyber 5 so far, starting at Thanksgiving, and kinda put up some highlights and some interesting things about that day.

6:23 And then, uh, at the end of the show, we'll t- talk about the holiday in totality and kinda how we see things shaping up. So Jason, why don't you kick it off with Thanksgiving? Yeah, so there are a few interesting things in Thanksgiving. Going into Thanksgiving, there were a lot of early stories. Mall of America announced that they were gonna be closed for Thanksgiving, and there was this, you know, this whole theory that, hey, maybe the arms race of stores opening early and earlier was gonna stop. Um, and then Macy's came out and announced, "Nope, we're gonna open on Thanksgiving, and we're gonna open an hour earlier than we did last year." Um, and that, that's somewhat controversial. Uh, there, y- there are customers that like to shop, and when retailers have opened on Thanksgiving, they've been pretty successful.

7:04 The downside of that, of course, is there are a ton of store employees that don't just have to be there for the opening but have to be there hours before the opening e- to get the store ready, and that means they're probably not spending Thanksgiving with their families, which, you know, is a big bummer. Um, so, uh, wherever you come out on that, uh, it seems like Macy's is gonna do pretty well with their Thursday opening. Um, I think they had 16,000 people just at the Herald Square store on, on Thanksgiving, which, uh, is, you know, a gonna be a pretty good traffic day for that store. Yeah, it's after the parade, so, uh, it was interesting. I was watching the parade with my kids and saw Terry just sitting there in the front row. It's kind of… You know, I've met him a couple times.

7:45 It was just kind of funny to see him just, like, right there on TV. Yeah, I'll bet he gets a very good seat. He had the front row. You guessed well. Um, he probably didn't have to get up super early and save it for himself either. Uh, the… And then, you know, the other thing you see is it used to be that no one shopped online on Thanksgiving. Um, you know, back in the day, people were mainly shopping online on desktops, which is kinda where Cyber Monday even came from, is, you know, people spent the weekend with their family or they went shopping on Friday, and then Monday they'd go to work where they had the good computer, and they had privacy from their family members, and that's when they did their holiday shopping online. Um, and you know, more recently, and I, I suspect we'll talk about this, we've seen a lot more online behavior earlier in that weekend.

8:29 And now with the advent of the smartphone, we're all, you know, on that phone underneath the dining room table during the Thanksgiving meal. And as a result, uh, Thanksgiving is the, the fastest growing online day. And so we saw Target announce, you know, record sales for, for Thanksgiving this year. We saw Kohl's announce record sales. Um, did-- What other interesting facts did you see about Thursday? So, uh, Adobe, uh, has probably been the most diligent with putting some data out, and one of the more interesting things they came out with was that it ended up being 40% sales on mobile, 60% desktop. So not quite getting to that 50% sales from mobile, um, but, but really kind of flirting with it.

9:15 Um, and one thing we'll be sure just for listeners to be careful, when you talk about mobile and desktop, it's easy to be sloppy. Uh, we'll be diligent about talking about sales or GMV, and by that we mean actual transaction va-value. Um, and then or we'll talk about traffic, which is different. The conversion rate, as you've probably, um, you know, if you've listened to the show, varies greatly, which is why these things tend not to line up. So we'll, we'll, uh, we'll be sure to stick to that as we talk about those topics. Um, one of the other things I saw, uh, it's really interesting when you start to read all this data, there's a wide disparity of data out there. So for example, PayPal had a thing that said their Thanksgiving average order value was fifty-eight, uh, fifty-one, which is really low.

9:56 When you see everyone else's average order value, it's usually like a hundred and fifty, a hundred and sixty bucks this time of year. So I thought that was interesting. Um, they, they had some, uh, some stats later that we'll go into about mobile desktop too. Uh, and then Adobe-- uh, Comscore came out and they said, uh, for the third year in a row, Thanksgiving surpassed one point-- one billion, coming in at one point three billion, and that was, um, 17% growth on desktop. Now, the way Comscore puts their data out, they have real-time desktop data, and then mobile kinda catches up quite a bit later 'cause I think it's more of a survey or an instrumented thing. Um, so for some reason, their mobile lags by usually two weeks.

10:38 So we won't know the full picture, but it has nowhere to go up than up from 17%. So I think that's a baseline. Surely mobile grew. Um, you know, we're seeing reports of anywhere from sixty to a hundred percent. So I think once Comscore tags that on, you're gonna be looking at a day that was at least 20%, if not higher, um, for Thanksgiving. So Thanksgiving, you know, re-regardless of what all the offline guys did, my conclusion on Thanksgiving is it was another big win. Um, and it still hasn't caught up with Black Friday. Black Friday was really strong, uh, this year, but it is getting really close to kinda getting, getting right up there with Black Friday. Yeah, absolutely. Speaking of Black Friday, um, it came in at 3.34 billion, which is… This is Adobe's data, which is up 21.6% year over year.

11:24 Uh, and again, I think the Comscore stuff, when we kinda line it up, it'll, it'll come in in line with this. Um, they projected 3.05, and so this, uh, billion, uh, or 11% growth. So this really blew away Adobe's projection, uh, for Black Friday, which I took as good news. Some of the big sellers they talked about were, um, it seems like all the Apple products are doing well. Although I haven't seen iPhones mentioned. I, I see a lot about iPads and MacBook Air, which is interesting because iPad sales have been pretty, you know, meh. Um, so it's, it'll be interesting to see if s- for whatever reason, these new iPads they have out, the Pro kinda family, uh, has picked up for whatever re- with consumers.

12:05 Um, lotta, lot of game consoles doing well. Both the Xbox and PlayStation came out with minor releases that seem to have kinda caused some momentum there. Um, when we look at our data, the, um, some of the really interesting things are, um, drones have been on fire, especially the DJIs and kinda the professional drones have always been pretty hot. Uh, but what's this new category that's really lit up is some of the first person view drones have gotten, quadcopters have gotten under, uh, $100. And those are, you know, those are just, like, selling like hotcakes. We've had customers, like, literally selling tens of thousand of them. So, um, you know, I don't… Hopefully people realize it's not gonna be that DJI level of a of an experience.

12:48 Um, but, you know, if you wanna have a good entry level into droning, then that's probably a good, good product, and it seems to be a really hot gift this year. So be careful walking the streets of Chicago after Christmas, 'cause I think there's gonna be a lot of drones flying around. Yeah. And they're, they're totally fun, but they are harder to fly. Like, they, what they don't have in them is, is like the GPS and the geostationary mode. Mm-hmm. So, uh, uh, it, they do take a little practice Yeah, yeah. The, the, they're very-- The joysticks tend to be very finicky and, and little fingers tend to be very binary, like hard up, hard down, and those things can like flip over and do all kinds of crazy stuff. So it'll be exciting. Yep.

13:28 One other thing I did wanna just mention, I saw the iPads, uh, being listed as a fast seller and, and tablets in general, but one of the interesting things, they're also one of the most discounted products this year versus last year. So like the, the average discount on tablets last year was like 10%, and this year it's like 30%. And so there's a, a theory that like tablet sales had sort of plateaued and that, that people are being much more aggressive with promotions this year. And, you know, Amazon in parti-particular is selling some really inexpensive tablets. Um, and you, you mentioned the iPhone didn't show up on any of the fast sellers, which I agree with. That's even more interesting because a, a unique thing Apple did this year that we haven't seen before is they had, uh, Black Friday deals on the, the brand new iPhone 7 products.

14:15 Yeah. Yeah, I saw that. Um, I don't think it was very aggressive. And, and I think they have a stock problem. You know, the, um, the, the higher storage units are just still sold out and the Jet Black. And so I still think they have a shortage of supply, which may be a limiter there. Um, so sticking with Black Friday, uh, kinda digging into mobile. Uh, first of all, the exciting news is according to Adobe, it was the first billion-dollar mobile day. Um, now I kinda wanna get another data point on that. I'm, I'm hoping Comscore chimes in with something on that. But they said 1.2 billion, so I, I feel pretty good that that's gonna be our first billion-dollar mobile day, so that's pretty interesting. So that's a new kind of high watermark for mobile. Um, so it ended up being mobile was 36% of sales or transactions.

14:59 It experienced 33% year-over-year growth. Uh, and, uh, traffic-wise, it was well over half traffic. So 55% of traffic. So let me recap that. 55% of traffic, 36% of sales. Um, the, uh… I'll let you talk about store traffic. That's more your forte. Uh, and then the global… So according to IBM, IBM's been kinda quiet, but they, they said, um, they kinda randomly put out a Black Friday thing that said the, the growth on Black Friday had been strong, coming in at 28% year-over-year. So that was kind of the highest one I've seen. Um, so it feels like Thanksgiving and Black Friday were kind of north of 20% if, if you kinda lead-- read the tea leaves and, and get kind of a down the fairway look at what, what's kinda being reported here.

15:47 Yeah, it, um, it's going to be interesting. Uh, s- spoiler alert, we're gonna talk about Cyber Monday in a few minutes, and Cyber Monday continues to be the largest online shopping day in the US. So the, so sales from Cyber Monday this year, uh, which, uh, are still happening, are gonna end up being higher than, than Black Friday. But it's getting very close. And so of the five days, you think about Thursday's the fastest growing because it started at a very low base. Uh, Friday is kinda the slowest because it's the largest. Um, but Friday is really the day where the large volume gains, uh, online are, are being seen. And so you're, you're starting to see those big numbers. And for some reason, more mobile shoppers are shopping on Friday versus Monday.

16:32 And so you're, you're actually seeing, uh, uh, mobile surpass, uh, on, on Friday surpass Monday even, uh, uh, both, both traffic and conversion. So, so that's been interesting. Uh, but you alluded to one of the first real, um, Debbie Downer notes of the holiday season is Obviously, the, the majority of, of consumer spending in the US still happens in retail stores, not online. And all of, uh, the data points we've seen on retail traffic for Black Friday, which is historically one of the highest shopping traffic days of the year, were down year over year. So, uh, Cowen, uh, you know, uh, said that they, they saw traffic down 3 or 4%.

17:18 Um, ShopperTrak, which is a company that h- uh, a lot of retailers pay to count their traffic for them, said that traffic was down 1%. RetailNext, which is another in-store traffic monitoring service, said that traffic was down, like, 5%. Um, there, there are a bunch of, like, more qual- qualitative, uh, companies that, like, go measure how many cars are in the parking lots, and they generally, um, said that, like, parking lots looked sim- looked similar to last year. But all three of these data points tell you fewer people walked in the store on, on Friday than the year before. Um, and you know, frankly, that, that loss in, in revenue from, from those customers probably greatly, uh, e- exceeds the, the gains that, that we made online.

18:09 Yeah. I think there's this interesting cycle. So, so the brick-and-mortar guys, you know, they resisted putting Black Friday deals online, but then Amazon was really aggressive in stealing share, so then they had to. But then now it's like taking people out of the store. Like, why go to a store at 5:00 AM when you can stay at home and get the same doorbuster deals? So there's this kind of really… There's a bit of a death trap in there. Um, uh, there was a funny article out today where Brad Stone called it the Amazon Flywheel of Doom. Uh, the doom was meant for other retailers, that they're kind of, you know, they're in this, this trap where they're, they're damned if they do, damned if they don't. And, and that's a… I think those stats are a really interesting kind of example of, of that on a very specific day of being a tough s- position to be in.

18:52 Absolutely. And, and we'll probably talk about a little bit the, the exact opposite scenario on Monday, uh, where, you know, historically there have been online only deals and some retailers are, are starting to make those more omni-channel as well. Um, but, but other sort of k- key things of note on Friday, we talked about it being the biggest mobile day. Um, Walmart for the last several years has really dominated mobile on Friday. So I think last year they were around 60% of all their traffic was mobile, and this year they said they exceeded 70% of all their traffic on mobile. Um, so that, that's super interesting. Uh, a, a data source we haven't talked about a lot on this show, there, there are a couple companies, uh, Profiterole and Clavis, that actually scrape all of the, the big retailers' e-commerce sites, um, for product data.

19:42 And so they're able to actually see the promotions that are being offered on those product pages. Um, and they came out and said, "Hey, of all the…" Clavis, uh, in particular, said that of all the retailers they monitored, Amazon was showing the, the deepest average discount, um, of any retailer, um, which was 42%, uh, versus 30%, 36% discount at Best Buy, 35% at Target, and 33%, uh, at Walmart. So the… You know, looking at a, a particular basket of Black Friday deals, um, they're, they're saying that at least from their data set, they're s- they're seeing, uh, Amazon being more aggressive than anyone else. They also sort of highlighted that, that Amazon had a major Black Friday focus on apparel and jewelry, um, which are, you know, two categories that Amazon has, has made major focuses on in, in recent, uh, years.

20:35 Uh, we also have seen a, a couple other retailers, uh, Fanatics, which is a, you know, a great, uh, pure play r- retailer say that, uh, 56% of all their sales were on mobile. So that's passing peak mobile for sales, which again, much bigger milestone than, than traffic is, is 56% of sales is pretty impressive. Um, another pure play retailer that we've had on this show, eBags, uh, saw some similar things. They saw their mobile traffic up 88% o- over last year, and they saw their mobile sales up 95% over last year. Um, so that, that's really huge. Um, and a- another just encouraging sign overall I saw at eBags was, um, they mentioned that their, uh, margin dollar growth is actually exceeding their revenue.

21:24 So that's super interesting because Uh, in general, margins on e-commerce are, are more challenging than, than brick-and-mortar. And partic- you know, the, the knock on all these big numbers we get on this weekend is they're all on heavily discounted product. And so there's, there's a lot of people that feel like we sell a lot of stuff but don't make any money. And so for someone like eBags to come out and say, "Hey, our, our gross margins grew even faster than our revenue," is pretty encouraging Yeah, yeah. The Fanatics one's interesting. Um, I think they're a little bit of an outlier because I imagine this time of year they're, they're largely selling NFL gear. They seem to have some deal with NFL where they're always talking about the NFL Shop.

22:06 They power the NFL Shop, uh, which is largely on during games. So I think that it's a common second screen thing to be watching the game and say, "Hey, I need my favorite Chicago Bears jersey," um, or, "I should get that for my wife for, for a holiday or something." Um, and I think that's why they kind of over-index on mobile. But they're, they're probably a harbinger of things to come, I think we would all agree. Yeah. And I, I do feel like this weekend is an inflection point for them. You know, if you're a casual fan, you might not be prepared to invest in that $100 Bears jersey at the beginning of the season until you find out if the Bears are gonna be any good. Um, but usually by, by this week in the NFL, you know whether you're going… uh, you have a legitimate shot at the playoffs. So suddenly a lot of people are all in on the apparel.

22:48 Although, that would not include the Chicago Bears this year. Ah, bummer. Did you see any, um… So another kind of story arc that comes out every year this time is, uh, the press loves to latch onto any kind of fight, uh, over a Black Friday deal. Did you see anything good there? You know, I didn't see a ton of stuff this year. Um, there were a bunch of pictures that went viral on social media of a, a Nike outlet store that looked like it had just survived a tsunami, um, with all these like open shoe boxes just sprawled all, all over the floor. Um, and, uh, you know, uh, just a heavily, heavily shopped store. Uh- Yeah … did you see anything?

23:29 Uh, I saw that one, and, uh, I saw it because, uh, I think an employee tweeted and they said something like, "I hate our customers." And then it got like 1,000 retweets, and I was like, wow, I wonder if that person is still employed at the Nike, uh, outlet there. Um, there's a funny, uh, I, I guess not funny, but there's a Walmart video where, um, that seems to be where a lot of things break out. Uh, I don't know why, but, um, you know, some employees took some shrink wrap off. Uh, I couldn't tell if they were big screen TVs or some kind of a stereo component kind of thing. Um, and the way they did it was just poorly designed. They had like 10 people in front. They started taking this shrink wrap off. Of course, there's a fight to get, you know… There, there's clearly a s- like four pallets of these things, so it's not worth fighting, but there was a little bit of a grabbing, kind of pulling situation over some of the things there.

24:16 So it wasn't… I've seen a lot worse. So, um, stores have gotten smarter at, at how they queue people and how they open these things and to avoid these kind of fights. Yeah, I was gonna say, like in general, a few years ago, you would, you would, you know, see escalating weaponry being brought to Best Buy and Walmart stores where people were using like, like, uh, pepper spray and stuff like that, um, which was really scary. The- In general, the retailers have kind of operationally figured this all out. So for most of those deal busters now, you get vouchers before you even go in the store. And so you can, you know, shop at your leisure. There's no race to the product because you're holding a, a voucher that you can use or a wristlet that, that entitles you to buy one of those products at the POS.

24:58 And so those kind of techniques, it seems, have largely done away with, with a lot of those things. But obviously, still totally possible for an individual score to, to make a mistake and, and cause, cause a little bit of, uh, chaos. I, I travel around a lot and talk about social proof online and how, how persuasive it is for selling, and I always have this joke in my presentations where I say, "But, you know, we really haven't figured out how to give social proof in the store." Um, and you know, the, the best example of social proof we have in the store is the police tape around the TV display at, at Best Buy on Black Friday. So I always- Yeah … I always like to get new pictures for that joke. Another one that's interesting, I, I'd put it more in the controversial pile than the, uh, the fight pile.

25:42 But, um, so some of the Wall Street analysts, they'll actually go out on Black Friday, and they send out these real-time store reports. And, um, one of them was really showing that every JCPenney they went to was like, had people 15 deep at the registers. So, you know, their whole conclusion was JCPenney seemed to be winning Black Friday. Um, and then, uh, on CNBC today, there was a big argument over, um, you know, the, the contrarian view was JCPenney had missed their last quarter. Um, they've marked things down so much, to your earlier point on margin. They're not making any money, and the reason there's lines is there's almost no store associates. So they had these poor store associates that were, um, a lot of them were temporary employees. They didn't know how to ring this up.

26:23 JCPenney has a relatively complex system of discounting and things on this rack or that, and all this kind of stuff. Plus, there's a loyalty card, and there-- and the coupons. And, um, so they're-- they actually had the opposite angle that said, you know, "No, these people are in there so deep because, uh, they can't check out. And even if they do, JCPenney will lose money." So I thought that was interesting that, you know, all these things have two edges to them. Yeah, absolutely. And that, that is, uh, you know, across the board, all retailers, of course, have to hire a bunch of seasonal labor. Ideally, you don't have that seasonal labor on the, on the, uh, cash registers, um, 'cause that is a pretty critical touchpoint for customers. And I, I read a bunch of stories both ways of, of, uh, customers that were having trouble checking out and, and, you know, inefficient lines and, you know, all, all of these unique promotions can sometimes cause things to, to gum up.

27:16 And then I've read the opposite, you know, stories about, like, going to a Target and, man, the, the, the clerk was checking me out, uh, with her right hand while she was doing an online pickup with her left hand, and it was super efficient. And, um, you, you sorta see both ways. Uh, I definitely have seen Walmart talk about, uh, you know, since they raised the pay of all their employees, um, them seeing, like, significant increases in customer satisfaction. So it, it'll be interesting to see, uh, when the final tallies come in for the in-store data, uh, it'll be interesting to see if, if Walmart's higher paid sales force this year was able to do better than, than previous years.

27:56 Uh, the interesting sort of dialogue I've seen about Friday is even whether Black Friday is relevant as a shopping day anymore. Though, like, certainly there's this convention that lots of people are gonna go shopping. We've talked a lot about how it used to be a sort of a pure in-store day, and Monday was a pure online day. But now, you know, that's really blended. In, in this year in particular, there were 10 million more visitors to e-commerce sites than there were to, uh, stores. So we actually had more people shopping online on Friday than we did in store. Um, and a ton of those deal bu-- uh, those doorbusters that used to be online, uh, in-store only are now available to everyone.

28:39 In many cases, they're available for, uh, you know, a week before Black Friday. And so there's just this whole sort of graying of Black Friday, where it's really become, you know, just another sort of, um, promotional period that, like, at, at best starts Thursday, not Friday, and at worst starts a week before Thursday and goes through Cyber Monday and all these sorts of things. And I, I, I saw, um, one, one, uh, retail leader, a guy, uh, uh, Bayard Winthrop, who, who's the founder of a, a, an online pure play, uh, apparel retailer called American Giant. Uh, he used to run Chrome, which, uh, for all the The action sports folks out there would-- you'd be familiar with Chrome.

29:24 Uh, Baird, you know, basically summed it up and said, "Hey, Black Friday has become this marketing mechanism for dying brands desperate for end-of-year revenue." And just talking about how, like, you know, in the modern era, there w- there are ways we need to be relevant to customers year-round, and, you know, the retailers that are still operationally focused on, uh, deeply discounting stuff this weekend to try to drive customers in, you know, probably isn't a sustainable long-term model. So an interesting POV at the least. Yeah. Yeah, it is. Um, so he invented the Chrome browser, is that what you said? No, no, no. Sorry. Uh, that would be the geek version. Uh, Chrome is a super popular brand of like messenger bags for, um, cyclists.

30:07 Ah, okay. Uh- Not me. Yeah. Uh, your, your kids, uh, uh, probably have it on their Christmas list, Scott. Oh, good. Good, I'll check that. The, um… Okay, so that was Black Friday, and that takes us to what I call Cyber Weekend. Sometimes people call it the Thanksgiving weekend. I prefer Cyber Weekend. I think it's more, uh, more cool. Um, so over the weekend, NRF came out, and they partnered with someone. I forget who they partnered with. Uh, Prosper Insights. And, uh, they had done kind of a, you know how they do the exit polls at the, uh, elections? They did kind of an exit poll of shoppers and had some interesting data that got a lot of headlines. So first of all, they asked folks, you know, "Where did you shop?" And 40 f- 40% said they shopped in a store, 44% said online.

30:52 So I think that was the highest, uh, online number that had been recorded in that survey. And so that, that kind of created another news cycle of this kind of stores are in trouble, online is surging. Um, and when you do the math, and you take that to the population and, and multiply it out, uh, that equates to 108 million online buyers and 99, uh, offline buyers. Uh, the thing that confused me about that stat is when you add the numbers up, it's 84, so I don't know what happened to the other 16% of people. Um, but then also, you know, surely there's, s- surely there's some kind of-- there's online only, online and offline, and offline only. So there's, you know, I don't know how those segments kind of-- the overlap of the Venn diagram, so maybe that's where the 16% actually comes in.

31:34 Um, so, uh, so sometimes that one confuses me more than, than, uh, illuminates for me. Uh, Adobe came in and said, uh, when they kind of take Thursday to Sunday, so the, you know, kind of the, the four days of Cyber 5, the first four days, uh, that they were up 16.4% to 9.3 billion. Um, things slowed as we got into the weekend. That always happens. So they were kind of at more of a 20, 21% growth, uh, Thursday and Black Friday, and then by the time we got to Saturday and Sunday, things had slowed down to pull the number down to 16%. Um, but then, so that, that felt pretty good because they had that 11% number, so it felt like we were over-performing it. But then they said, "Well," but then when you look at the holiday, which started November 1st through, that we're still only at 7%.

32:22 Um, and I kinda took that to mean, wow, if we're there through Sunday, uh, that-- I don't know how you get to 11%. So, um, we'll have to kinda see how that goes. And then, um, deeper on the NRF, uh, survey, they said that the average shopper spent, uh, $289 or was planning to spend on holiday, and that was down from $299 last year, so a 3.5% drop. Uh, so I've s- I've seen a lot of articles take that and actually say Offline sales are down three point five percent, and I don't know if that's fair because you just can't take the AOV and decide that because the other factor is, well, how about the number of shoppers? If the number of shoppers is up and AOV is down, you can still have enough new shoppers, uh, to offset that.

33:07 So I didn't get how people drew that, that-- You know, maybe I missed something there, but I didn't get how people-- Uh, a lot of more negative articles came out, and then they would say, "But then RF is standing by their survey or their, um, their forecast of three point five percent growth." So that goes back to when we had, uh, Adobe on. Um, if you recall, she talked about kinda the, the gap that the election created, and it doesn't feel like looking at the Adobe data that we've made that up yet. E-exactly. That's-- I, I think w-uh, when it's all tallied up for these five days, Adobe's gonna say that, that we are slightly over their forecast for these five days, but we are dramatically under their, their original forecast for November first through, uh, Thursday.

33:52 Um, and, and they attribute that largely to depressed spending in these, these big states that predominantly voted for, for Hillary Clinton and, and presumably are more depressed about the election outcome. Um, and so they're, they're literally saying like that, "Man, we, we lost almost a billion dollars in sales leading into Thanksgiving, and we haven't recovered those yet." But, you know, the, the moment we're on track, uh, for their forecast for all the days after that. So the magic question is gonna be, uh, what happens the rest of this month and December? Uh, we haven't talked about this yet, but I would remind listeners there actually is not a terrific correlation to sales this weekend and overall holiday sales.

34:36 So there have absolutely been years when, when, uh, brick-and-mortar and online sales were terrific this weekend, and the overall holiday was kinda meh, and vice versa. There, there have been occasions when this was not a big weekend, and overall holiday was pretty good. So, uh, I, you know, I don't think you can, you can take anything to the bank from this weekend. But, uh, at the moment, Adobe's, you know, feels like they're, they're, uh, you know, gonna be slightly off of their eleven percent, largely as a result of the first two weeks of November. Yeah. Yeah. So that's, um, that kind of gets us through Sunday, and then today is Cyber Monday, but there's been some news out. Uh, what did you see about today so far?

35:17 Yeah. So as of about an hour ago, this-- I feel like we're doing the real-time election news. Um, Adobe's projecting now that today is gonna come in at three point three nine billion, which would be the largest online shopping day ever in the US. Uh, and it would exceed, uh, Friday, but not by a heck of a lot. Um, and so that, that's interesting. Um, I wanna say-- I don't have the data in front of me, but I wanna say that's about ten, or, uh, from memory, ten point two percent year-over-year growth from last year. Um, a-another, uh, good day for mobile, fifty-six percent of all visits, thirty-seven percent of all sales were from mobile, so that's not quite as mobile as Friday was, but still, uh, it definitely feels like this, this holiday is, uh, going to be the, the peak mobile, uh, the, the day we reach peak mobile, where, you know, if you, if you haven't been mobile first before this, you should certainly be mobile first after this.

36:15 Um, there have been some interesting focus on mobile-only deals as retailers try to drive people to their apps and things like that. So I know, you know, um, Amazon, for example, like even offers deals that are exclusive to the Echo. Walmart has deals that are only available on the, the app. You know, so that's all interesting. Um, and, you know, a topic we like to debate ad nauseam, Scott, is this, this mobile conversion gap. And I'll remind listeners that normally that's about three to one, so, uh, you're three times more likely to convert on desktop than you are on mobile. Um, for holiday, it's, it's getting pretty darn close to two to one.

36:57 Um, and so I'm not prepared to say that-- uh, claim, claim victory based on that trend. There, there just are a lot more people with buying intent that are, that are coming to all these sites. So in general, conversion's better everywhere on this holiday weekend than a traditional day. Um, but it, it is an interesting trend that we're starting to see. Did you see anything else interesting for Monday? I did. Um, and, uh, I did-- So IBM has this one dashboard, and they actually showed desktop conversion kind of almost doubling, and then mobile didn't. They almost had a different outcome than that Adobe point, so I'll go with the, uh, IBM data. All right. They- they're, they're essentially saying the reason mobile is hanging in there is just because there's so much extra traffic coming that the conversion rate kind of, you know, it, it… Yes, it's lower by a f- you know, it's two-thirds lower or only a third of, of desktop.

37:49 But, uh, you know, now that the traffic is well over 50%, that it's kinda more than making up for that disparity. Um, the, uh, back on the NRF survey, they also, for Cyber Monday, they said, um, a record number of online shoppers, 122 million, were planning to shop online on Cyber Monday. So there's a projection part of that too. Uh, and then Comscore has come out and said they think that Cyber Monday will be 3.4 billion, which lines up with that Adobe data point. And I'm sitting here watching our live dashboard, which is, uh, pretty interesting 'cause we only have one re- hour, and it looked like the peak time was 9 to 10 o'clock Eastern was the top It's interesting, you see, this is the same I think I've seen before.

38:32 You see there's these two winders- windows of Cyber Monday. There's kind of a 2:00 to 4:00 PM Eastern. Uh, and I kind of view that as people feel like, "Okay, I've done my work for the day, and now I have some time to look at these deals that came out," kind of a thing. Uh, then you, you taper off during the dinner hour, and then 8:00 to 10:00 it really kinda lights back up. Um, so, so interesting, you know, Cyber Monday does seem to have been very, very strong, uh, which is awesome. Absolutely. I was just gonna say, like a pro and a con of IBM versus Adobe's approach, uh, IBM does have this very cool real-time dashboard that, that, uh, I think you were just looking at. Um, so you don't, you don't have to rely on a analyst to kinda get between you and the data, and you can, you can, you know, kinda ask your own questions and see 'em, um, and you can, you can see it in real time, uh, where, where the peaks are, mobile versus desktop, all those sorts of things.

39:24 So I love that about the Adobe dataset. I mean, I'm sorry, the IBM dataset. The downside, IBM is primarily getting their data from sites that are using what used to be called CoreMetrics, now called IBM Analytics, as their web analytics tool. And Adobe- Mm-hmm … is primarily getting their data from what used to be called Omniture, now called Adobe Analytics. Um, and both are good products. You can certainly run your business on either of those. There's a third one that competes quite a bit with them, which is Google, um, who unfortunately doesn't share any data. The, uh… Once a platform like IBM buys an analytics company like CoreMetrics, they have, uh, it suddenly becomes, uh, much harder for them to sell the analytics as a standalone product to a retailer that is only using analytics.

40:11 So suddenly CoreMetrics, uh, gets, gets concentrated to IBM customers much more directly. And so as a result, CoreMetrics is installed on a much smaller subset of retailer sites than Adobe is. And so, uh, not saying… You know, the data's perfectly valid, but it may not represent… You know, it certainly doesn't represent the 75% of all retail spending that Adobe says their data represents. So you gotta, you know, uh, ask yourself who the IBM customers are, and they're gonna tend to be, you know, a handful of very large players at the top of the ecosystem that are s- gonna skew their data. Yeah, I was… I'm sorry, I was a little confusing. So I, I, for conversion data, I looked over at the IBM dashboard.

40:54 Uh, and we'll put a link to it in the show notes if people wanna get to it. Uh, and then I was looking at the ChannelAdvisor GMV dashboard. We have this kind of internal tool that lets us track it in real time how GMV is doing, and that's how I was able to see the shape of Cyber Monday for us- Ah … which I think is probably pretty representative for other folks. Oh, very cool. Well, if you don't have your own cool e-commerce company, um, the… I would recommend, and I'll put a link in the show notes, checking out the real-time dashboard from IBM, 'cause it, it, it actually will let you see sort of those peaks by hour and those sorts of things. I just wish it was on a bigger set of retailers. Yeah. Yeah, totally agree. So in the, uh, so last year, the, one of the big stories was Target had, um, they rem- fresh of my memory, was it a free shipping or was it 10% off?

41:38 Or was it 15% off? 15% off online. Okay. All right. And they did it again this year, and I-- they seem to be pretty stable. So, uh, did you see any kinda instability out there in e-commerce land? Uh, I, uh, sadly, I did. So, like, just, just, uh, to recap, last year, you know, Target offered this 15%. It was a total surprise, um, to customers, and it generated more demand than they expected, and it actually caused their site to crash. Like, they, they would quibble with that and say, "Our site didn't crash. We, we had to throttle traffic, so we essentially put a queue in front of our site, and a lot of people, you know, would get this page saying, 'Please refresh every 10 seconds until we let you in.'" Um, and so that was, you know, pretty big black eye for Target.

42:19 You know, they had had some other problems before that. I haven't seen any problems with Target this year, so congratulations to them. And they actually did the 15% this year. They did it online and in-store, and they did it for two days. So seems like that worked pretty well for them last year, so they doubled down on it this year. Um, the sad news is that we saw a number of other retailers have glitches. So, you know, at various times, we saw Best Buy throttling some traffic. I saw Williams-Sonoma was down for a bit. Victoria's Secret had some glitches, Express, uh, Pier 1. But by far, the retailer that made the most news for being down, which is never what you want, is Macy's, and they had a pretty extended, uh, outage on Black Friday.

43:02 I'm not sure that they were completely down for this whole time, but a lot of customers were complaining about not having access to the site for as long as eight hours on Black Friday. So that, that could be a real stinger for them. Yeah, and, and this is kind of an interesting thing, you know. How do you, how do you prepare for that? The, um, w- w- we've, we've always just, you know, it's always hard to do this because you've seen what s- past Cyber Mondays are. Um, Cyber Monday's always the trickiest day for us. Uh, so you, you know you're gonna have a day that's kind of three X of any other day, um, which is fine, and you can do some math and everything. But then you always question the math because the shape of the traffic looks different, and it's hard to predict it, you know.

43:46 So for example, mobile versus desktop. Or, um, for us, we have, you know, probably 800 different ways people can hit the servers. There can be API calls, there can be pixels. There's just all these different things that cause a transaction on a server. And, you know, some of those transactions are heavier than others, and if the traffic skews in a, to a different mix, it's a much different look and a different hardware requirement. Um, how do, how do retailers deal with that? So, you know, y- imagine Macy's was able to kind of say, "All right, we think Black Friday we're gonna get this much traffic." It, it's also another challenge is it's hard to test these things in a sandbox kind of environment 'cause to do that you have to have as much hardware in your sandbox as you do in production.

44:30 You can't really test it on production because then you're gonna give yourself an outage if it doesn't work. So, um, what do you recommend for retailers, and what are some of the best practices you've seen for, for these kind of scenarios? Yeah, it, it's a big challenge, uh, for all the reasons you mentioned. You know, I, I should say the standard practice, which kind of stinks, is that what you do is you take some surrogate for your production environment, right? So the right way to do this would be, you know, if you had 100 of a particular server in your production environment, you'd go rent another 100 servers to, uh, do your load tests on. But almost no one I know does that, right? So instead, what they do is they take some smaller servers or smaller number of servers that maybe was their staging environment or a QA environment or a variety of sandboxes, or they rent some smaller servers, and what they do is they, they put a load test on that and, um, uh, do some math to say, "Gosh, if these number of servers can handle this load, then the number of servers in our production environment should be able to handle this other load."

45:33 Um, but that's a pretty huge fallacy, right? And we talk about sort of the analogy to plumbing, right? It's like saying, "Hey, you've got, uh, a three-inch pipe, and you see how much water you can put through that, and then you should be able to do math and know how much water you can put through a five-inch pipe." But the problem is it's rarely the pipe that causes the leak, right? Like it's the O-rings where the two pipes are connected or the faucet or the hot water heater or all these other things in this super complex system that don't get properly tested in that kind of surrogate test. And so, you know, the first thing I would say is, you know, for sure run load tests on, on, you know, your, your, um, sort of staging environment or whatever you can.

46:17 Um, and, and for gosh sakes, if you f- if that tells you that you have a, a capacity deficiency, you, you absolutely wanna address it, but you should absolutely not feel good just because you passed that kind of load test. Um, the, the other big thing that really gets you is, is you mentioned customer behavior is wildly different, right? And so when you're doing a load test, you're basically writing a bot that acts like a customer, and a bunch of those bots aren't very well written. So, you know, maybe it's using an API to exercise the, the cart, whereas a real shopper is clicking a bunch of buttons on a website to exercise the cart, and that, that can feel different. But a huge difference is most of these sites only have to feed, uh, content to a small subset of their traffic, and that's because they use a lot of caching.

47:05 And the most popular flavor of caching out here for e-commerce are these, these content delivery networks, these CDNs. And so essentially what happens is you, you have an origin server and, and that, you know, uh, runs a computer program to generate a page every time someone asks for a page. But in front of that, you have a caching server that keeps copies of the most popular pages, and when a customer asks for that popular page, it just gives them the copy, which takes much less effort. And then that copy, that cache, is replicated to hundreds of servers around the world via these CDN networks. And if it all goes really well, a high percentage of the customer requests get hit by these various caching things and, and they, they don't put a lot of stress on your server.

47:52 Um, but guess what kind of content can't be cached? Dynamic Dynamic content, exactly. And the, the trend for customer experience in e-commerce is all towards this dynamic, personalized content and things like calculating shipping and calculating the cost, the, the value of the items in your cart, and calculating how much lower that cart will be with your 15% off discount. And so you- Quantity available. Exactly. Um- Dynamic pricing. Yeah. And so it… all of those things end up being, you know, uh, meaning that the origin server can get exercised much more than the load tests assume, and, uh, these high traffic e-commerce days hit the origin- exercise the origin servers much harder than normal.

48:38 So here's this funny irony you get at. You have all these tools that specialize in personalization, and the salesperson for that tool, you know, is constantly telling you how great it is and how you ought to do all this personalization. Um, and then, you know, hopefully about April, you start doing your holiday readiness assessment, and that vendor that just sold you that million-dollar personalization tool comes in and says, "All right. Let's do a holiday readiness." The first thing we suggest is you turn off all the personalization and don't do any promotions. Um, and you know, because they're trying to protect the load on that, on that origin server. And so as a retailer, you're having to balance between, um, being as efficient with your server capacity and having the, the best possible customer experience, and that's, that's just a cruddy compromise to make.

49:22 So the short answer is most retailers today are on some somewhat antiquated, uh, platforms. They tend to, you know, own their origin servers in their own data centers. Um, most of them are, are geographically concentrated, so they have a single data center. Um, and most of them have a bunch of single points of failures. They have the points they know about, um, but they often have a bunch of single points of failure they don't know about, like a, a, a tag on their site from a third party or an advertising provider or all these other… a personalization vendor, an analytics vendor, all these other things, and if that vendor has a glitch, it, it affects your experience.

50:03 Um, and there actually are better infrastructures for doing this, and the public clouds now are frankly much better at, um, geographically dispersing the load than are the most of these, these private data centers that retailers are built on. So you think about someone like a Google, um, and when's the last time you remember Google having outage, despite the fact that they, they, they have, uh, completely personalized content for a much broader range of, uh, a much higher traffic load than a typical e-commerce site gets? And they do that by having these sort of container-based clouds that are super dynamic and can elastically add more capacity on demand and add it all over the world and kind of avoid internet congestion, denial of service attacks, all these cool things.

50:52 And as a retailer today- You can buy that kind of infrastructure. Like Google actually rents their infrastructure. It's called Google Platform Services. You can run an e-commerce site on the same infrastructure that Google's using to host Google Search. Um, obviously, more and more retailers are moving to Amazon's infrastructure, AB- AWS, which can give you a lot more of that elastic capacity. But if we went and, and surveyed the top 500 sites, you'd, you'd, you'd see the top three or four having really sophisticated site ops and a lot of good geographic, um, diversity and, you know, minimizing those single points of failure. But the other 496 would all be based on this sort of older model that we now know is not a best practice and can't scale for these kind of loads.

51:37 And so they're frankly all a little fragile Yeah, one middle ground, and this is where we ended up at ChannelAdvisor because we've been around since 2001, so we did have, you know, pretty big on-premise kind of investment, is a hybrid model. So if as our on-premise stuff gets full, we can switch over to cloud and, and kinda load balance between the two, which is… There's some nice benefits there. You still have the, the control of being able to like, you know, drive to the server and press the button if you want to. Uh, but then you also have the flexibility of spiking up when, when you need to. Um, and to my earlier point, you can… A lot of retailers I talk to, they don't wanna use Amazon Web Services 'cause they don't wanna, you know, feed a competitor kinda thing. But, uh, you know, so to your point, there is Google and other options.

52:21 But, but even, even if you hate Amazon, one of the things you can do… It used to be impossible to kinda spin up a production environment, but the way Amazon leases machines, you can actually go do that. You can kinda go spin up a very quick slice of your production environment, run load against it on Amazon, and then kinda turn it off in, in a way, way, way more economical way than you, you could with buying any hardware or actually leasing it and having humans set it up and that kinda thing. So, so there's some interesting, you know, even if you have kinda married to an on-prem solution, um, there's a hybrid option in there, um, that, that isn't as binary as kind of cloud or, or, you know, public or private kind of thing. A- absolutely. And I, I would say, like, there are lots of third parties that sort of turn Amazon into a hybrid option.

53:06 Like, natively, Amazon was sorta built to be a, a public cloud. Uh, but Microsoft has a product called Azure, which is really architected to be that hybrid cloud. And so- Yep … there, there are some good third-party solutions no matter what you need, um, to get you there. And, you know, to kinda put it in perspective, you know, Walmart, which is, you know, depending on how you count, the second-largest e-commerce site in the US, um, they built this pretty cool layer that they use for all their site ops, and it's called OneOps, and they actually open-sourced it. So any other retailer is welcome to use it. And it, it's a container-based system. Walmart has a ton of their own data centers, and so they, they run it on their own computers. But OneOps also runs on Google, Azure, and Amazon.

53:51 And so you literally can have a situation where, um, as long as your capacity can be managed by the number of servers that you own, you, you keep using those. But you can, in real time, elastically expand to these servers that you rent for however long you need them on Amazon or Microsoft, and you can literally arbitrage those servers against each other in real time and rent wh- whoever has the best price on a given day for, you know, a minute or an hour of capacity if you need it. Awesome. Yeah. So, um, so bringing it back to holiday. So we've looked at all this data. We have all these forecasts that were 11 to kinda 19%. We're seeing data points that are, you know, Adobe is kinda like a 7% holiday year to date, and then you have, uh, Comscore and some others kind of with the days coming in in the 20s.

54:42 Uh, how do you feel the holiday is shaping up? Yeah. So, uh, I unfortunately am a little concerned. I think the traffic numbers are a real concern. Again, we get real-time data on online sales, but, but data on brick-and-mortar sales comes much slower. So, you know, if, if we use the holiday traffic as a surrogate for the period, um, I think we have a real potential to land at, like, 2% growth for brick-and-mortar sales this holiday period versus most of the forecasts you, you hit at the top of the, the hour were for, like, 3.6%. So that's potentially a huge miss. Um, and that means, you know, we have a bunch of already distressed retailers that could be talking a lot more about, uh, closing stores and things like that.

55:27 I, I, I think the one s- piece of silver lining for the brick-and-mortar retailers is they've been much smarter about their, their inventory this year. Um, and so I, I think they're not in as bad an inventory position, so I think they can, they can manage 2% growth a lot better than they, they did last year. But online, I think it's gonna be an interesting, uh, uh, tale of the have and have-nots. I think Adobe probably has it right across all retail. We're probably gonna see 11 or 12% growth. But the bummer is gonna be, we're not gonna see a lot of individual retailers with 12% growth. What we're gonna see are the biggest retailers that are the best operators and have really nailed their email marketing programs and their promotion engine and dynamic pricing and stability and all those sorts of things.

56:12 Um, and they-- tho- those big players have a bunch of intrinsic advantages at this point, so you're gonna see the Amazon, Walmart, Targets of the world growing at, like, 20% this holiday. And that, unfortunately, is gonna leave most of the other retailers with about 7% growth. Um, so again, I think brick and mortar is gonna be a little soft. I think online's gonna be at 12%, but it's gonna be a story of, of big retailers gr- uh, having a great year and, uh, uh, some newer retailers struggling a little bit more. Um, and then I do think when it's all said and done, we are absolutely gonna see some proof that that mobile gap that we talk about is, is starting to close, and I'm, I'm certainly excited and optimistic about that, and we'll talk more about that in another show.

56:57 Yeah, yeah, I, I agree. It's gonna be very feast or famine. Looks like, um, you know, Walmart has done pretty well. Seems like Target's doing well and Amazon. Um, and we'll have to see how some of these other guys do. So, uh, it's gonna be interesting to see how the rest of the holiday shapes up. And just wanna thank everyone for joining us tonight, and hope your holiday sales are up and to the right. A- absolutely, Scott. It, it has certainly happened again. We've spent a perfectly good hour of our listeners' time. Um, so we're, we're really grateful for everyone for tuning in. And rest assured, we'll be doing a number of shows for the rest of the holiday period, and w- appreciate, uh, hearing your stories and getting your feedback as well.

57:38 Thanks everyone. Happy commercing. Happy commercing. You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes or visit www.jasonandscot.com.