EP001 - Double 11 Singles Day, Same Store Sales data, Personalization, Holiday, Money2020
This episodes covers singles day, the personalization paradox, Channel Advisor SSS report, holiday promotions trends, and digital wallet news
Episode 1 covers singles day, the personalization paradox, Channel Advisor same store sales report (SSS), holiday promotions trends, and digital wallet news.
Links:
11.11 Day http://www.alizila.com/alibabas-shopping-festival-rakes-in-14-3-billion/
Forrester digital business forum https://www.forrester.com/DIGITAL+BUSINESS+2015/-/E-EVE6702
Channel Advisor SSS - http://www.channeladvisor.com/blog/?pn=scot/holiday-2015-same-store-sales-first-week-of-november-results
Money2020 - http://www.money2020.com/
ShopTalk - http://www.shoptalk.com/
Hosts:
Scot Wingo, Founder & Executive Chairman Channel Advisor
Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish
0:00 Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring hosts Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here is Jason and Scot Hi, everyone. I'm Jason Goldberg, SVP of Commerce and Content at Razorfish. And I'm Scot Wingo, co-founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. You are listening to the inaugural episode of the S- Jason and Scot Show. So if you have tuned in, this is gonna be a podcast all about the latest in e-commerce news and trends and, uh, the latest in digital shopper marketing.
0:44 So we have selected the perfect day for our first episode. Uh, we are recording this on November 11th, 2015, and those of you in the know will know that, uh, 11/11 is Singles Day in China, the, the world's largest online shopping event. And, uh, Scott, have you, uh, seen any of the results from this year? I have. Happy Singles Day, Jason. And happy Singles Day to you, Scott. Even though we're both married, we can celebrate. The, uh, first, what do you think about Singles Day? I, I've always heard it was just a PR thing that Alibaba created, but today a lot of people were saying that it was a university anti-Valentine's Day thing. That felt like a PR story that was kinda just contrived. I don't know. What, what have you heard?
1:25 Yeah. So I do think that there is some truth in that story, and I, I think there is a marketer inside of Alibaba who is my all-time hero. Because essentially, there clearly was a locally celebrated event in a few universities called originally Bachelor's Day for- Mm-hmm uh, for single men, and it ultimately expanded to include both genders and was Singles Day. And it was, you know, frankly, just an excuse for university students to get together and party and actually resolve their singlehood through blind dating and things like that. And it happened to fall in autumn, and the rumor goes that, you know, Alibaba was looking at the great success of Cyber Monday here in the United States and was looking for, you know, a holiday to promote that was at the right time of year, and that Singles Day was the winner.
2:14 And, uh, it, it's funny 'cause I just… I have to imagine that there's some, some poor guy that picked that day and came to the meeting and proposed that they convert this- … this, like, unknown dating holiday into a major shopping event and, you know, he was probably laughed out of the, out of the room. And, you know, today he, he generated almost fifteen billion dollars in sales. He's a hero. Exactly. Mine, for sure. Yeah. So, so last year it was by far the largest day in the China holiday period, uh, and they did nine billion. This year, what I'm seeing is fourteen point three billion. So by my math, that's a fifty-eight percent increase year over year, which is pretty impressive, 'cause I think, I think Alibaba in general is growing kind of in the forty percent range.
2:57 A lot of people are watching mobile very closely for Alibaba because it monetizes a little bit less than desktop, and, uh, this is interesting from the US perspective. Mobile was sixty-nine percent of that number. Through the day it was actually trending higher. Uh, they, they did a little kind of a ticker symbol through the day, and it was in the mid-seventies, and then in the last four hours it kinda trended down to sixty-nine percent, where I think people were on their computers in the evening versus during the day. Another interesting stat was that they injected four hundred and sixty-seven shipments into their top shipping partner. I heard on the radio that that's more than FedEx or UPS sends in a year. Have… I, I, I wanted to fact check that with you. I figured you would know that off the top of your head. And to put all that in perspective, last year Cyber Monday was two point seven billion, and if we say that we're kind of aggressive and we say that that grows fifteen percent this year, that'll be three billion.
3:44 So, you know, Singles Day looks like it will be, this year, five times the size of Cyber Monday. So it's actually getting bigger than Cyber Monday kind of in big orders of magnitude. How do you feel about all that? Yeah, I mean, it's, it's overwhelming. Like, it's almo-- when you're talking about stats in China, like you, you just have to reset your, your whole frame of reference, 'cause the numbers are so much bigger You know, certainly you, we expect Chinese consumers are more accustomed to shopping on mobile, so you would expect the number to be higher, but, you know, sixty percent of, of all of that, that transaction volume on mobile feels super impressive. Like, I think I saw that that's something like two hundred million shoppers. I think they, they equaled last year's total revenue about twelve hours into the event, and I think it took them about eight minutes to get their first billion dollars.
4:34 So I'm sure part of that, you know, early sales are like sort of front-loaded sales from shoppers that had filled up their cart, you know, well before Singles Day and were waiting for the deals to kick in. But it, it's still hugely impressive. And I did have the exact same question you did about the shipping, right? Mm-hmm. And so I did find some interesting stats, not annual volume, but over holiday. So November, December, FedEx will ship about three hundred and seventeen million packages, and UPS will ship six hundred and thirty million packages. So those guys are, are sh- are shipping more packages in one day than FedEx will ship during the entire holiday period and, you know, almost as much as UPS will.
5:15 Wow, I, I knew you would know the answer to that. That's kind of funny. That's a lucky break. Uh, we, we probably won't get there before. But here's the stat that I think is gonna cause people the most grief in my world. They hit a peak transaction volume of a hundred and forty thousand transactions a second. Yeah. And the reason I think that's gonna cause a lot of grief is I feel like every one of my poor clients that's doing their holiday readiness assessment, and they're, they're struggling to hit their comparatively modest goals, those IT teams are gonna have to hear about how Alibaba was able to do a hundred and forty thousand a second, and I, I don't think they're gonna like talking about it for very long. I think the payment number was even higher. I, I saw something in the two hundred thousand a second for Alipay kind of transactions.
5:56 That must be amazing. Yep. Yep. Do you think they're using their, um… They have an AWS competitor, right? Do you think they're using that under the hood to power all this? They… That is certainly what, what they are claiming is that it is on the, the same stack that they, that they, uh, make available to corporations, and they, they… I'm sure they'll be using that as a marketing vehicle. What do you think was the most interesting promotion that you saw? Yep. Well, so, you know, the, you turned me on to one I wanna hear more about, the Delta Airlines one, but certainly the one that got all the, the buzz, uh, in the media was the Cadillac promo. Yeah. On that one, they… If you pre-ordered a Cadillac, if you were one of the first 100 people to pre-order a Cadillac, you got 50% off.
6:39 So that's… I don't, I don't know how you determine who was first. Peop- that must be people waiting up till midnight just hoping they hit the buy button or something, but that, that's pretty interesting. And then on Delta, it was a, it was a Singles Day promotion, and it was half off a flight, and it was really, you know, obviously an American company promoting it to Chinese travelers as a, as a way to kinda get around and, and enjoy travel on Singles Day. I hadn't seen a lot of travel deals before, so that was kind of interesting. And I certainly hadn't seen half off cars. I thought that was, that was an interesting promotion. Yeah. And, like, presumably that's promotion in the truest sense of the word, that, that, that was really a marketing promotion around building brand, 'cause it- it's hard to imagine that that was a, a- Yeah profitable offer for anyone to make.
7:20 Um- Didn't Gilt do that, like, in their heyday when… Didn't they do, like, a car for half off or something? Yeah. I do, I do think, you know, some- That's very similar … some of those, like, you know, short-run fantastical deals, um, as I like to call them, you know, they, they certainly generate buzz. Like, I, it, it's interesting who that was generating buzz for. And I'm not sure at this point Alibaba needed the buzz It was kind of joint. It was Singles Day and Cadillac, I guess Exactly. And then so it'll be interesting to see what, what the sort of lifetime value of that promotion is to Cadillac. But I do think it underscores one of the big trends. You know, I think the early… You know, Singles Day started in two thousand and nine, and for the first few years, it was all about like super deep discounts on Chinese goods.
8:00 Mm-hmm. And I, uh, it sort of morphed from there, and I, you know, I think last year was the first year there were a lot of luxury goods, uh, being promoted on Singles Day, and particularly a lot of luxury Western brands. And, you know, Jack Ma has, has definitely said that he wants it to be a global holiday, and this really feels like the year when all the global brands jumped on board in terms of making offers to sell to Chinese consumers. So not only do we see all the big apparel brands that have been there for a while, like Nike and Under Armour and Abercrombie & Fitch, this year we actually saw the retailers getting in the act. So Costco and Macy's from the US, we saw Sainsbury in the UK, you know, and other, other retailers taking advantage of the fact that that, you know, Chinese consumer has a, a huge thirst for Western goods, and they're, they're leveraging the power of that, that, uh, shopping festival as a, a way to meet new Chinese consumers.
8:56 Yeah. Jack Ma was on CNBC, and he was talking about Nike and New Balance. He called them out. He also talked about that the handset manufacturer Xiaomi and how that was quite popular. Then he said something mysterious. He's like, "Next year, I'm bringing Singles Day to New York and London." So I, I thought that was somewhat mysterious, and they asked him questions, and he wouldn't go into it. But I, I think they, they very much would like to get You know, other countries involved, but, but it's not really sticking other than the import kinda side of the equation. No. And I will tell you, that comment, uh, terrified me a little bit because I-- we, we published, uh, the Razorfish point of view on Singles Day today, and we, we definitely see it as a powerful tool for Western brands to market to Chinese consumers. And we actually think there's a second huge global opportunity to sell goods to Chinese expats that are scattered around the world.
9:44 And I think, you know, this year they're, they-- uh, Alibaba's cross-border shipped to two hundred and twenty countries on Singles Day. So I think that's a, a growing trend. But I went on record as saying that I don't see it being adopted in the US by, by US retailers and, you know, no great logic-- uh, mystery to, to that logic. It-- Singles Day is Veterans Day in the US, and it's perilously close to a, a promotional calendar that retailers are already addicted to, and it just, it just seems unlikely that there's a bunch of untapped demand that could be, you know, sussed out through, you know, further promotions. Like, I, I think we're already gonna see the, the US holiday season get stretched out and start earlier every year.
10:29 But, you know, highly unlikely that kicking off a Singles Day in the US is suddenly gonna generate some net new, new revenue. So, uh, you know, we'll have to see what Mr. Ma has up his sleeve in terms of, of, uh, New York and UK. I'll certainly be interested to watch. Yeah. Hopefully he's wrong and you're right. It would, uh, be the first in history, but I will certainly take it. So I, I did notice that the, uh, ChannelAdvisor Same Store Sales report also came out yesterday, uh, equally important event in the world of e-commerce. Scott, what can you-- would you tell us about that? And, you know, were there any big takeaways you had? Yeah. And since this is probably the first time, uh, a lot of our listeners have heard about it, let me just give the really quick kinda overview.
11:11 Uh, at, at ChannelAdvisor, we have about three thousand customers. They use our software to sell all different places across the internet, and they generate about six billion dollars goes through our software. And what we do is we look at that data, compare year-over-year trends on a same-store sales basis, so we strip out any customers we've added or that have left in, in the year period. That-- We feel that gives us a pretty interesting benchmark. Uh, and that's how this came about, customers asking us, saying, "Hey, I feel like I'm doing pretty well on Google Shopping. I'm up eight percent, but how am I versus my peers?" So I'll, I'll separate it into two buckets. We have kinda the leaders and the laggards. And I always use this benchmark of fifteen percent. Comscore has come out with that the last three quarters and pretty consistently for a long time It's 13% desktop, 3% mobile, and you add those up and you get to kind of 15%.
11:59 So the leaders are growing f- uh, at that pace or, or greater. Google Shopping product listing ads came in at 32%. It's kind of the fastest growing channel we saw. Uh, and this is all for the month of October. We have two marketplaces, eBay and Amazon, and then we have 45 other marketplaces, and we, we bucketize them and call it other third-party marketplaces. That grew really well at 25%. Uh, a lot of people always ask, "Is Jet inside of there?" And Jet won't be in these data until they've been up a year or so, and we're only, like, 15 weeks into Jet still. It's still a very young company, so that's not in that data. That's other marketplaces like Sears and Best Buy and folks like that. Amazon grew 16%, um, and then eBay, the parts and accessories part of eBay, which is motor parts, uh, that grew 16%.
12:43 The laggards were comparison shopping engines at fif- 11%. eBay, eBay overall was at 3%, uh, and search, which is kind of the AdWords kind of part of search, was down 7%, so minus 7%. So it kind of an interesting mix there of, of Google, other marketplaces, Amazon, and a part of eBay doing really well, and then traditional comparison shopping engines, eBay, and search, uh, eBay overall, uh, not doing so well. Yeah, and you know, that, that does beg the question. I feel like this is the second or third report in, in a row where, you know, eBay is… The core eBay has notably lost ground, and, you know, some of, some of these other guys seem to be, you know, catching more market share. Like, is… Like, in your view, is… Does eBay not have the right model?
13:26 Are they gonna keep losing customers? Is there, like, in something that they can fix, or what's Yeah, eBay's in a tough spot. They-- A little over a year now, they, they had two events hit them at once. They had a Google SEO action, which is every retailer's worst nightmare to hear those three words. Um, and then they also had a, a hack, a breach. So they had to reset everyone's password, and eBay's password system is very nineteen ninety-seven, and it's really confusing 'cause a lot of people don't understand they have a separate eBay and PayPal account, and eBay and both PayPal are trying to get people not to use their emails as their login IDs, all this kind of stuff. So it, it caused this whole cascade of problems. Everyone thought they'd be through that by now.
14:07 Uh, eBay is still kind of talking about it. It, it's, you know, they, they bring up Google SEO actions a lot as one of the reasons. When I talk to our customers, one challenge that they point to is the eBay search engine is really broken, and it's very hard to find things on eBay. I'm sure you've had that, that experience. Uh, another one is the fee structure is very unusual today. Uh, there's all these marketplaces. None of them has a listing fee, kinda like a, you know, like a, almost like a classified listing. eBay still does have listing fees, and it, it just creates a lot of headaches and, and pain for people selling there. So, you know, the, the, the good news is they have a new management team in there. They brought over a guy, Hal Lawton, from Home Depot, and he seems to be really strong leader.
14:49 Uh, he's running North America. Uh, he's an NC State grad, so that, that means he's awesome in my book. So he's building a team there and had add-- has added some really good execs from Walmart, and he's building a retail orientation. eBay has lacked that for a long time. Uh, obviously, they compete with Amazon, and we, we talk to the execs at Amazon. They all, you know, eat, drink, and sleep retail. So it's gonna be good to inject some of that DNA into eBay. So still kind of a turnaround story here. Yep. But, uh, I have to imagine that the, the focus they're likely to have now can only help them. Like, obviously, you know, a lot of the, the supplemental businesses, the PayPal, you know, GSI, Magento, you know, the… all those things have, have split back out, and now, you know, they're really in the business of matching up those buyers and sellers and Yeah.
15:33 Yeah, I agree. I, you know, I think, I think it is another positive that they're a separate company now. I, I, I totally agree that being able to just focus on building a marketplace i- is good. And then, um, last week you were traveling, right, Jason? You went out to the Forrester eBiz? So I was. I have to admit, a- as my travel goes, it's about the easiest travel I have 'cause it, it's an Uber from my, my, uh, home in the Chicago suburbs to downtown Chicago. Ah. Did, did that time out? So I like-- I love it in the rare, rare occasions when the, the shows come to me. But I, I did attend. I got a chance to participate on a panel with Sucharita, and, uh, it, it was interesting. The… My big takeaway, it f- it felt like the most popular topic at the show this year was around personalization. And, you know, Forrester shared a bunch of survey results from both retail business leaders and also IT leaders that all, you know, indicated that personalization was high on the, the initiatives list for retailers and IT organizations.
16:26 And, you know, there were lots of best practices presentations around how to really lead the market in terms of personalization. But, you know, the cynic in me, you know, is sitting there listening to all these presentations, and you keep hearing the same question over again. Cool, I totally believe it. Like, it makes perfect sense that personalization is super important. Who are the great examples of e-commerce sites that have really gotten personalization right and therefore, you know, are getting outsized returns right now? And- I even struggle with what it means. Is it just like- … you get your own set of search results, or every page is different, or it just says, "Hey, Jason. Welcome back"? Yeah. I think it means that your name is in the upper right-hand corner next to your account.
17:07 Ah, okay. Yeah. So that brings up a great point. Like, to me, the, the surveys are silly for a couple reasons, right? Like, to say one of your major initiatives is personalization, like, personalization isn't an outcome, right? Like, so to your point, can you add the customer's name to the corner of every page and check the box that you, you know, that was an initiative this year and we added it, right? Like, it, it, it didn't add any customer value. And to your point, personalization means so many different things and, you know, there… It's not a, a binary thing. You don't have it, you have it. Like, it's a, it's a continuum of user experiences. But, like, when you look at the e-commerce ecosystem and you-- through a personalization lens, what you see are a lot of personalized product recommendations.
17:49 You know, so you've got all the, you know, browse by, buy biologics, and the Sortonas and the MyBuys and the Rich Relevances of the world and the, and the stuff they do, which, like, clearly works and adds value. And you see some personalized offers. Like, you see the Walgreens and Safeways of the world, like, using all the, the behavioral data they're collecting about you to try to cater offers that are likely to be more relevant to you. And that, you know- Seems also like a no-brainer. But, you know, I, I feel like you can go to every retailer in the world and still say, "Man, you know so much more about me. The experience you're giving me, you know, doesn't take that into account," right?
18:31 You know, I guess I, I am the… In my mind, the jury is a little out. Like, I, I think the reason that people want personalization is because they want the sh- the experience to be more relevant, to understand the context of the shopper, to know what their mission is and deliver that mission. And I, I absolutely believe that lots of retailers do that to varying degrees of success, and the better they are at making their experience relevant, the more profitable they are. But I don't believe that, like, superficial personalization is the only path to relevant. And, uh, you know, I… It, it is interesting. If it's as simple as we all just need more customized homepage, it's shocking that someone hasn't started a company that has a website plugin that, that makes homepages more personalized.
19:15 Yeah. And, and you have to hit diminishing result returns on these things, right? You know, if… I, I heard this one retailer say they've got 10 to 15 data scientists just plugging away on this all the time, and it just seems like you could, you could almost over-optimize where you're just kind of, you know, chewing away at this problem and personalizing and personalizing. And, and at some point, you're, you know, I don't know how much it costs to have 10 data scientists. It's gotta be like two million bucks. You know, at some point, do you… do they still have work to do? I, I don't know. Yeah. And, I mean, to, to a large extent, I do think it's a, it's a shiny object syndrome, right? Like, personalization, uh, for its own sake isn't that, that valuable, right? Like, there's a, a smartphone out there that you can get made to order, the Motorola X, and you can, you know, pick the materials it's made with and have your own logo burned into the back.
20:01 And, you know, I think there's thousands of permeations of that phone. It's completely personalized to you. The iPhone isn't personalized to you at all, but, you know, I think the market has spoken pretty clearly, and, you know, the, the iPhone is more relevant and valuable to most consumers than that Motorola X is. Yeah. Yeah, it's interesting. Yeah. So I, I, I'm gonna continue to watch it, but I do… I take it with a grain of salt when, uh, you know, these studies come out saying, you know, personalization is, is the next big, big thing in, uh, e-commerce. Maybe it's a conspiracy theory. All the personalization vendors are, are just pushing it. Exactly. And if that's the case, maybe we should start a personalization company.
20:41 Okay. After our podcast business, we'll, we'll do that. That, uh, it- it's a, it's a plan. But so speaking of the next big thing in e-commerce, that's gotta be, uh, holiday season in the US, right? Yeah. Yeah, we've been talking to reporters already about holiday, and the… most of them kinda say, "What, what are you expecting?" And, and a lot of it's repeat, so mobile and social, all that good stuff. The one thing I've seen that's new is there's a little bit of a backlash against the commercialization of the holiday. REI started this off with their, what do they call it, opt-out program or opt to go outside, and where they're gonna close on, on Black Friday. And since then, a, a couple other retailers have said they're not gonna open on Thanksgiving, and, and that should be the holiday.
21:23 So, so that's really interesting. What, what do you think about that, Jason? Yeah. I mean, there… it does seem to be like that there are these two opposing trends, right? That there are a bunch of studies that are out now that, you know, consumers have said that- They would prefer that retailers not open on Thanksgiving. And I always take those studies with a grain of salt because that's kind of asking your rational brain and, you know, I tend to think most, uh, shopping is done, uh, with the subconscious. So I'm not sure how valid that methodology is, but it is interesting that, that overtly customers are saying, "Hey, we don't want all those kids, you know, missing Thanksgiving with their family, and we don't, we don't want all the pressure of having to go shopping on Thanksgiving." Uh, certainly, you know, REI is banking on, on, uh, the goodwill that they're generating from giving most of their employees, you know, Thursday and Friday off.
22:08 At the same token, I think Toys "R" Us is, uh, moving their opening date from 6:00 PM on Thanksgiving to 5:00 PM, and a bunch of the big retailers are sticking with that, that 6:00 PM opening on Thanksgiving. And they, they wouldn't be doing that if they didn't feel like there's a huge advantage to being the, the first shopping destination that those consumers choose when they, when they go out of the house. Yeah. One other thing I wanted to ask you about, Forrester just came out with their holiday forecast, and they, they came in and, uh, this is for e-commerce, they came in at 11%. NRF/shop.org, they came at 8%, I think. And I haven't seen Comscore. Uh, they usually do it just a little bit closer to Thanksgiving so they can kinda get some press out of it.
22:49 Uh, but I'm anticipating they'll be kind of around this 15 kind of, w- you know, w- watermark they've had out for the whole year. What are your thoughts on all those forecasts? Yeah. Well, so I, I, I think forecasting is really hard. Like, I think, you know, once the holiday season strikes, we'll see the analytics companies reporting the actual results, and they won't even agree, right? Yeah. And so, you know, if you can't get, if you can't get a consensus on the numbers when you're looking at the actual data, obviously there's gonna be a significant amount of variance in the forecast. I do think some of those forecasts are skewed by the fact that they're, they're forecasting for all e-commerce businesses in the, in the, you know, Depart… US Department of Commerce, which is, you know, like tens of thousands of e-commerce sites.
23:29 And so you would expect the growth on some of those really small sites to, to not be as meaningful as the, the growth on the top couple hundred sites. But all that being said, the forecasts feel light to me as well. And, you know, as a consultant in the space, that's super useful 'cause we like, you know, sandbag numbers that are easy to, uh, to exceed. But I personally will be disappointed, uh, for most of my clients if they only see, uh, 11 or 12% growth in e-commerce. Hmm. Okay. That's-- So, so we're on the same page there. Yeah. Wow, that never happens. I do think there's an interesting phenomenon, and, you know, frankly, like I think I saw you write about this last, last year, and it may have kinda tweaked my thinking a little bit, but the whole conflict of online and offline shopping over the holidays.
24:13 And, you know, like traditionally for many years or since the advent of e-commerce, you've had this traditional sh- shopping day when people left the house and went to the stores, and that was Black Friday, and that was a huge in-store day. You know, and then later, this behavior of shopping online on Monday, you know, emerged, and that became the biggest online shopping day of the year. Mm-hmm. And I, I do think the modern consumer dynamics are dramatically changing that, right? So, you know, now consumers are much more likely to be shopping on their mobile phone, which means they can be shopping while they're at their family's house on Thanksgiving or on that weekend and don't have to wait till Monday when they get to work on, on the work laptop to shop. And so it feels like the, the online orders are spreading out to more days.
24:56 There definitely is a shift. You know, there are a lot of consumers that are opting out of the holiday madness, and, you know, I think something like 40% of all the growth in, uh, in holiday shopping is coming from e-commerce. And so there are a lot more people that will choose to go online than visit those stores. And it, it has this effect of Taking all the sales that were on this one discrete day, Monday, and, you know, at the very least spreading them out, you know, to Thursday through Monday, which I think you called Cyber Five, which I've frankly stolen from you. Oh, yeah. Thanks. As long as you always attribute it to me, that's, that's perfect. I, I am putting a quarter in a jar every time I use it. Oh, good, good. I'll put it in the college fund. Yeah, yeah, definitely. We, we've seen, uh, especially Thanksgiving, the mobile traffic is really high, so I think people are out at the Thanksgiving Black Friday sales, and they're, they're multitasking and shopping around, and, and we've seen smartphone last year, that was kind of the peak day.
25:47 So it's definitely interesting. I kinda… Y- you and I both know someone from REI, and I, I was kind of joking, you know, are they gonna close the website on, on Black Friday as well? I, I have a feeling they won't. So, so it's, it's interesting. That, that could actually juice their e-commerce sales by having that day off for their employees. Absolutely, and I, I, I strongly suspect you're right, that all the folks we know at REI are gonna be working pretty hard on that day. Um, I will say, you know, it's funny, when people talk about that, like, I keep pointing out to people, uh, B&H Photo in New York, right? And they're, they're a very successful, very large, uh, single store operator and e-commerce site, and they're, they're, uh, Hasidic Jews. So they, they literally close the website on their Sabbath every week.
26:32 And, you know, man, that's really, like, practicing what you preach, right? That they w- they w- you know, you could imagine those, those servers r- just running and n- not requiring any intervention and collecting a bunch of orders from, from Friday night to, to Saturday night. Yeah. And they, they choose to literally not let you order there. I never realized that. Yeah, so it'll be, it'll be interesting to see if, uh, if anyone ever takes the, the closed holiday to that extreme and gives all the, the e-commerce guys and the, the factory workers, the warehouse workers the, the day off. Yeah. W- whenever we're together at conferences, I always enjoy talking to you about payments 'cause you follow that a lot more closely than I do. And, um, you always rave about this show, Money 20/20, and I think I saw that was last week or, or kind of thereabouts, maybe right before Halloween.
27:17 How, how was that show this year? Yeah, so, uh, it's the same week as the Forrester eBiz Show, so I wasn't able to make it this year. So I ha- uh, I had to send, uh, a f- a few folks in my stead, and did get a pretty good download. You know, I've gone the last couple years, and it… A, it's just an excellent show. Like, I, I think it's only about a three-year-old show, and it's, it's quickly grown to over 15,000 people. I think last year the fire marshal kicked them out of the, the Aria Hotel in Las Vegas, and so they had to move it to The Venetian for a bigger venue. And, you know, they, they picked a hot topic, and I, I chuckle at the name a little bit, right? Like, they called it Money twenty twenty, which when they started the show in, in two thousand fourteen or, you know, two thousand twelve or whenever it was, that, you know, probably seemed like a far-out date.
27:59 But now, you know, as they're getting awfully close to the year twenty twenty, they're trying to rebrand it to say that it's, you know, twenty twenty vision about money. Wow. So that might be a little silly. But it, it, uh, by all accounts, it, it continued to grow and was very active this year. Like, obviously, there's two big topics in payments that are going on right now. There's this liability shift that w-- a, a lot of people expected would cause, uh, all brick-and-mortar retailers to start accepting EMV payments, so those credit cards with the little chips on them. Mm-hmm. And, uh, this, this shift happened in October that was supposed to be an impetus to get all the banks to shift and, you know, there's, there's some sentiment that, that, that if, if everyone did shift to that system, that our payments in the US would be safer, which I, I somewhat dispute.
28:44 But so there was a ton of hardware vendors at the show this year that are all selling EMV-compatible hardware because the entire world of retail needs to, you know, buy new hardware to accept those, those chips. So there's, you know, this is gonna be a great excuse for a lot of retailers to upgrade their POS systems and their, their payment technologies, which, you know, I'm excited about 'cause I think they'll add a lot of other… They'll take the opportunity to add a lot of other features. And then the other big fight is on mobile wallets. And, uh, I'm super interested in mobile wallets. It's kinda funny. I think Microsoft had this notion of Microsoft Passport back in nineteen ninety-nine, and, you know, they had, they had identified that, hey, you know, nobody wants to type their name, address, city, state, and credit card number over and over again on the web.
29:30 You know, and here we are sixteen years later, and we, we still haven't figured it out. And there, you know, there's literally dozens of companies now offering mobile wallets to both let you use your mobile phone to pay in store, you know, but from a volume standpoint, more importantly, mobile wallets that make it easier to buy stuff online through, through websites. And, uh, it's to me a little frustrating at the moment because every vendor wants to be the winner, and so they're all offering these, you know, uh, winner-take-all type solutions that expect the whole world to exclusively adopt their wallet, and that just doesn't seem Likely practical or, you know, frankly good for the consumer.
30:12 Yeah, I saw Jim Cramer was saying on CNBC the other day… Can you tell I watch CNBC a lot? He said that, uh, if Starbucks took their mobile payments and spun it off as its own solution that, you know, he said every company in America would license it, and it would be this whole big business. I don't, I don't know how true that is, but they're often cited as one of the leaders in mobile. What, what do you think about that? Yeah. Well, I, I mean, I think they certainly are. I think they're the only volume player out there. I think s- you know, they… At the beginning of this year, they were at something like 16% of all their payments were, were, uh, via the, their mobile system. And, uh, and I think just last month they announced that it's now up to 20%. So that's like 9 million transactions a week. One out of five customers at that cash register is paying with that mobile wallet.
30:55 And it's, you know, frankly, a particularly good mobile wallet. Not only does it handle payment, it, it has affinity program tied right to it. You know, last quarter they added the ability to remote order and, you know, have your beverage ready for you, you know, or hopefully ready for you when you get to the store. Um- Which is awesome. Oh, it's, it's, it's been, uh, a, a life-changing feature set for me. Yeah. I'm, I'm a three-minute elevator ride down to the Starbucks from my office in the Merchandise Mart. And so I n- I now know exactly when to hit that, send that order to have that drink come up right as I get off the elevator. The… You had mentioned, I, uh, I think that the Money 20/20 guys are working on another show. Did they talk out all about that?
31:35 So I didn't get to check with the guys that were there. But I certainly have, uh, uh, I'm starting to see some promotions for the show. That's the Shopper Talk Show. And I know, you know, again, these guys seem like they're, they're very good at putting on shows. They… The Money 20 show is very well run and, and, uh, got big very quick. You know, Shopper Talk is, is targeted, you know, more directly at, at digital shopping experiences. And I, I know they hired a, a well-regarded, uh, Forrester analyst to be responsible for producing all the content for that show. So I, I, uh, I think they're targeting having some, some, uh, big name speakers and some good content in the show. Cool. Cool. That should be interesting. Yeah, definitely one to catch next year.
32:17 I personally am gonna have to invent a cloning machine because apparently it's very difficult to pick a, a date for these new shows, and so that, that new Shopper Talk Show is the exact same dates as IBM's big show Amplify and, uh, SAP Hybris' big show Sapphire. And so I'm gonna have to figure out a way to be in three places at once that week, I fear. Good luck with that. Uh, thanks. I'll, I'll let you know how that goes. But, uh, I'll tell you what, Scott, the, our, our 30 minutes, uh, or 35 minutes in this case have gone really fast. I feel like we're probably out of time for this week. Yeah, bummer. We, we still have more to talk about. We'll just have to kick it to next week. Exactly. It sounds like, you know, we might have to start doing this as a, a weekly event, and that I think is exactly what our plan is.
33:00 Or we can make it five hours every month, something like that. We'll, we'll talk about it. Yeah, I'm not sure, uh, anyone- … needs to hear me for five straight hours, as my wife would, would quickly point out. But if you did enjoy the show, we sure would appreciate it if you'd subscribe to our podcast on iTunes, and, uh, we'd love to get your feedback. So, uh, leave us a review if you liked it, or, you know, send us critical feedback via email without leaving a review if you didn't like it. But either way we'd, we'd love to hear from you. We hope you felt this was a five-star performance. Good deal. So this has been The Jason and Scot Show. See you next week. Thanks, everybody You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show.
33:41 For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes and please leave a review
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed