EP011 - E-commerce Companies Q4 Earnings Recap
EP011 - E-commerce Companies Q4 Earnings Recap
Episode 11 covers a recap of numerous Q4 earnings calls including E-Bay, Facebook, Alibaba, Amazon, Starbucks and Microsoft. Also Uber, Macy's, Walmart news.
The Jason & Scot Show. Podcast about e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:00 Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here is Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. This is episode 11, being recorded on Thursday, January 28th. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, and as always, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Jason. How you doing? I am doing terrific. H- how are you doing, Scott? I am doing good. Um, you mentioned at the top of the show it's January 28th, and we are deep into earnings season.
0:46 So it's been, been a busy time in e-commerce land following all the stuff going on, and blogging, and talking to reporters about all the different, uh, companies that have reported. Yeah. I feel like, uh, we even pushed the show back a day to make sure we got some of the big, uh, e-commerce earnings calls, including Amazon's today, right? Yeah. Yeah. And, um, so chronologically it started with eBay. They were yesterday after the market. Uh, and it was a little disappointing. So eBay came out, and the marketplace grew 4% on a GMV basis. A couple interesting things. So for the first time, um, this is their first fourth quarter as an independent company. They had always been with PayPal.
1:27 So they actually, uh, provided a bunch of new information. So they released, uh, StubHub and how their classifieds are doing, and then they broke out the core marketplace. Uh, it was kind of a good news, bad news kind of thing on that because the good news was StubHub is growing at a whopping 30% year over year. Uh, even the eBay classifieds is growing kind of 15%. But then the bad news is that actually the eBay entity is growing s- five or 6%, but then the marketplace actually is growing only 4%. So, um, I know longtime listeners know this, but bears repeating. Uh, I always use the comscore. They came out and said the holiday was, uh, right around 14%, and then e-commerce last year was kind of in the 14 to 15% range.
2:09 So I always use that as a baseline when I think about how these different companies are doing. So, you know, obviously 4% is, is not in line with e-commerce. So eBay continues to struggle. They, they listed kind of three things which was interesting. So one has been going on since March of w- uh, '14, uh, and that's this SEO problem that they have. Uh, the second one was really interesting, and that's mobile, and the third is consumer to consumer. And, uh, those two are the first time they've talked about those being headwinds. Um, mobile was really interesting because they said that GMV on mobile grew 21%, but when I did the math on that, um, that was a pretty material deceleration. Uh, we saw in our numbers more like 50% mobile growth, uh, across our customer base.
2:53 So, um, all this goes back to September of last year. Uh, they did a whole new version of the eBay app called, uh, eBay 4.0, I think. Or do you, do you track this stuff? Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Yeah. And it, um, it universally got terrible reviews. Um, and they had-- uh, earlier in the year, they had hired this guy from Apple who was like their core UX e-commerce guy, and this was his redo of the app, and it has much more of an Apple kind of curated feel. Uh, but I think the challenge is, you know, you go from Apple where they have something like a whopping eight SKUs, maybe, maybe 12 Uh, and you know, now you're at eBay with, you know, someone, you know, millions of SKUs and, uh, it's universally been poo-pooed by everyone that's used this app.
3:35 And, uh, eBay, uh, you know, kind of even called out that they're, they're working quickly to try to fix that app. So it seems like they stubbed their toe kind of self-inflicted on mobile. Um, and then consumer to consumer was interesting because they've never really split out B2C and C2C. They used to do this maybe in the Jeff Jordan regime, you know, way back when in like '03 kind of thing. Uh, but they were back to that nomenclature this time. And, um, it was another one of these good news, bad news things. They said B2C grew 8%, but if I kind of do the math on that, then I think C2C shrank, uh, like 6%. And then on mobile, if mobile grew 21%, that implies given their 4% growth that desktop shrank like 7%.
4:19 So, um Really tough sledding. Uh, on the SEO front, they also got some bad news. Uh, you're more familiar with this company than I am. They're, they're Moz, I guess, M-O-Z. Uh, and they do this annual report of the winners and losers in SEO, and, and eBay was a, kind of a, had the dubious honor of being, uh, another loser. Um, and they look at, you know, where you're placing across all these different terms and, and all this kind of thing. And for 2015, eBay was a loser. So a lot of the things they're doing from an SEO perspective are not really moving forward. Um, the last thing about that, uh, is they're really focused on… You've probably seen when you're on, uh, Amazon, you have this kind of pristine product catalog.
5:00 So if you search for an iPad, it's very clear, you know, here's the iPad Air 2, here's the iPad Air 1, and then you drill in there, and you can see you have one universal SKU, and then the seller's against that SKU. eBay's always been more listing-oriented. They're trying, and this is the third time they've done this over the 15-year arc I've followed eBay. They're trying to get to that Amazon catalog-like thing, and they call it the SDI, the Structured Data Initiative. Um, so, you know, they, they spent most of the time on their call with Wall Street talking up this, this initiative. And, you know, you, you-- I agree that it's something they need to do, but you kinda wonder how is that really gonna solve their problems.
5:41 And, you know, a lot of what they're doing is for SEO, which, uh, you know, I'm not an SEO guru, but it seems to me like you should design for humans first and then robots. But it seems like they're really, really focused on SEO a lot there. So, uh, so that was interesting. Did, did you see anything out of the eBay news that you thought was interesting? Yeah, I mean, well, I think you hit on all the main topics, but, you know, it, it is interesting prior to, to the, uh, V4 mobile experience, a lot of people would've said that eBay was an early leader in mobile usability, and that they actually, you know, had more users on the mobile app and were, and were doing a better job of conver- of, of actually conducting transactions versus the rest of the industry.
6:22 And so, you know, when they went to 4, they got a ton of consumer complaints, and in the, um In their, their annual report, their, or in, in their, uh, reporting today, they, they talked about we've done a good job of mitigating all those consumer complaints, and we're not getting all those complaints, but the new platform still doesn't even perform as well as the old platform. And obviously, you know, when they spent all that money to go to version four, presumably it was in the hopes of having better performance than version three. Um- Yeah, I kind of wondered, you know, why don't you just roll it back, you know? It- Yeah I don't know. Uh, I, I mean, I do think it's a cautionary tale. You know, anytime you do these big bang changes and, you know, there are lots of retailers out there that are right now thinking about redoing their mobile experience as a big bang.
7:08 Just redesigning it is, is not a guarantee of success , and, uh, I, I think there certainly are a lot of learnings from, from eBay, who's now paying, you know, about a year's penalty on, uh, on that step backwards. The, the C2C thing I thought was interesting. Like, of course, you know, a lot of people probably know eBay started out as a C2C model and evolved into the, the B2C, and I think that's similar evolution we see with Alibaba in China. C2C is still a huge chunk of Alibaba's revenue, and the fact that, that eBay's starting to talk about it again, I wonder if they do see a potential market in the US, or at least a bigger white space in the US for some, some form of C2C where obviously they don't have near the competition that they, they do on the, on the B2C side.
7:54 So that'll be interesting to see if they, they try to make more hay of that. Uh, I, I saw an interview with their CEO earlier in the week, and he was talking about how, you know, he felt like there was room in the marketplace for multiple winners, uh, implying he doesn't have to beat Amazon to be successful, which I certainly agree with. Uh, but he talked a lot about, you know, Amazon is where you'll go for utilities, and that eBay is where you'll go for the hard-to-find stuff. Mm-hmm. Um, and frankly, like if that's gonna be their value proposition, that's a little scary to me. 'Cause if you look at the pace at which Amazon is adding SKUs Uh, like I, I don't think, uh, eBay being the place that you can get hard-to-find stuff that you can't find on Amazon is a very long-term defensible position.
8:39 Yeah, that latest survey had Amazon getting up around 400 million. Um, and eBay has that many listings, but there's a lot of duplication in there. So, so I would argue Amazon's probably already a superset of eBay. Exactly, and th- and that's really what that structured data is all about, right? Like, Amazon has one page for every SKU, and if there's 10 sellers, they all share that same page. Uh, in the, the, the non-SDI world, eBay has a different page for every listing, and I think they said that SDI is up to around 50 to 60% now of all their- Yeah. Yeah, 60% of 18 target categories, so. Oh, got it, so even, even narrower.
9:20 Yeah. So obviously, like, probably less SKUs overall. The SDI thing is a big challenge for SEO, um, and so I, I do believe they'll get more Google traffic when they get SDI meaningfully fixed. I think they, they said they didn't expect that to happen till at least 2017 or 2018, that they would see an economic benefit from that. But it also comes with a bunch of headaches that I don't know if eBay's prepared for. Like, at the moment on the Amazon Marketplace, because all the sellers do share a listing, there are lots of sort of gray hat things people can do to hijack listings and, you know, they all, they all fight over the content on that page, and sellers can benefit from other sellers investing in content and things like that.
10:02 So there's, there's a whole- A whole new set of challenges you have when you, when you're managing a marketplace with shared listings that, you know, I'm not sure eBay has totally experienced yet. So be interesting to see how they- Yeah … they manage that. And then on the SEO thing, uh, you know, the one sort of, uh, scuttlebutt that, that went around a little bit today that I, I don't totally buy. Um, so part of eBay's problem is they actually took a manual action from Google in 2014, and, and Google essentially said, "Hey, we don't like the way you're creating some of these pages. We think you're doing them just for our bots and not for users. Um, and we're gonna manually penalize you for that." And, and I think that that manual action is off, but as you pointed out, they're, they're getting less search share this year than they did last year according to Moz.
10:50 Um, and so even with that penalty off, they're losing ground in SEO. And, you know, a narrative I saw a couple people make today is eBay did release this famous internal study a couple years ago where they essentially concluded that pay-per-click advertising probably wasn't profitable for them. And so there was this, this theory that like, oh my gosh, you know, they, they took a big shot at Google by saying that pay-per-click advertising doesn't really work, which is Google's core business, and that, you know, some of these SEO problems that eBay is having are, are retribution from, from that, that old article. It's impossible 'cause Google's motto is "Do no evil."
11:31 Exactly. Uh, well, I would not r- hang my hat on that as my sole protection. I actually don't think Google would t- y- it'd be a pretty huge risk to take a manual action against someone specifically because they didn't like them. So I do, I do sort of doubt that those two are related, but I do note that i- in this year's earning call, you know, eBay's spending a bunch of money on pay-per-click and saying they're getting a good return on that investment. So whether… You know, for one reason or another, they seem to have backed off of that, that earlier stance that maybe pay-per-click didn't work. And, you know, frankly, part of me wonders, in the old days, they were one of the few pay-per-click advertisers, and then they had the space to themselves. And as it got really competitive, you know, one of the things you could do is publish some data to say pay-per-click didn't work, that might scare away some of your competitors and help you get a lower cost to click.
12:18 So frankly, I think that article might've been more to help keep their costs down than some, some real effort to help the industry by teaching them not to give their money to Google. Yeah. Who knows? Yeah. This has been going on. There was this whole, um You know, Google launched, when they launched the, the checkout system, uh, there was a lot of a back and forth there. They had a tea party at one of the eBay events, and that really upset eBay, and then they yanked search back then too. And so, so these guys have been trading blows for a while- Exactly. They're two- … either, either publicly or behind the scenes. Yep. They, they have been, uh, uh, in the space as long as anyone. Yeah, Google hasn't reported, but my, my guess is that they are gonna do better than the 4%, so seems like they're… Google's winning this round if there is a battle going on.
13:03 Yeah, that's certainly where I would put my chips. Yes. You're winning. Speaking of else won. How about Facebook? Did you see, see those results? Yeah. I did. I think they also, uh, are a good place to put your chips right now. Yeah. Yeah, the stats there are just mind-boggling. Um, you know, and it, it's kind of s- I always feel bad for Twitter for some reason whenever the Facebook stuff comes out, 'cause if, if Facebook didn't exist, Twitter would be a darn good company. Um, you know, with like over 300 million active users and all this stuff. But, but here's Facebook at, now they're at 1.6 billion monthly active users. Um, 1.4 of those access mobile. 800 million, uh, are mobile only, which is kind of interesting.
13:43 So, uh, about half of the mobile audience is mobile only. And then when you look at the dailies, they've crested over a billion daily users. Um, and one of the things they did this quarter, I don't know if, if it actually launched this quarter or a little earlier, but they talked a lot about it, was, um, they ga- they turned on advertising for Instagram, and it seems like, and, and you may know more about this than I do, it seems like they opted people into it, and you had to kind of opt out of it. Because, you know, they said something like 98% of advertisers are also on Instagram. Um, so, so, you know, given the scale of Instagram, just to open up a massive, you know, uh, a- amount of page views and, and ad units to that seemed to really help Facebook in the fourth quarter to, to blow away everyone's expectations on the top and bottom line.
14:31 Oh, definitely. And y- it's crazy if you think about, like I, I think the narrative just two years ago was, "Hey, Facebook might be capping out on their potential because the world's going to mobile, and Facebook really isn't ready for mobile." Yeah, and to their credit, they f- they redid the mobile app. They got rid of all the… Remember they were doing HTML5, and they didn't wanna do a native app, and then they said, "This isn't working," and they tripled down on mobile and, and it has really worked. Exactly. And frankly, like, those kinds of, of, uh, pivots or stu- you know, student body left are really difficult to pull off in a 100-person company. So, you know, frankly, I give I give Facebook a lot of credit for being able to make such a big swing, and obviously they're, they're reaping the results of that now.
15:14 And certainly you mentioned Instagram. Uh, Instagram feels like a darling amongst the advertising platforms at the moment. You know, it's much smaller numbers than you can get on Facebook, but the, the numbers are the demographic that advertisers really want. Like, they're, they're skewing much younger. They're, they're the, those millennials, and they tend to have a much higher buying intent. And so I know, you know, people are already jumping on the platform. But at the moment, the advertising platform on Instagram is a little rudimentary compared to the audience targeting that you can do on Facebook, which is, like, frankly awesome. And so, you know, I know a bunch a, a- advertisers are really salivating to get the, the full Facebook targeting ca- uh, suite o- uh, with the Instagram audience.
16:02 And so I, I think people are really bullish about the future of that platform as well. Yeah, I thought this was, um, this was interesting. I, I, I did not make the call, but I was reading the transcript, and they actually called out a retailer as the example. And, um, you know, when I talk to retailers, the thing they love about Facebook is, uh, top of funnel. And, and this does a good job of kind of explaining it. And, and let me just read it. And it says, uh, "Our third priority was, uh, the improving the relevance and effectiveness of our ads. Uh, we shipped a lot of new ad units last year. These products help deliver personalized marketing at scale." And they said, "For example, the UK's second-largest online retailer, ShopDirect, uh, before Black Friday teased upcoming sales with a cinemagraph video to build awareness."
16:43 Uh, and I imagine they probably did that to a… They don't say it here, but they did it to a, a, you know, a lookalike audience. They then retargeted people who saw the video with one-day only deals, and then on Black Friday, they used the carousel with the digital product ads to promote products people had been ch- had already shown interest in. This, this combination showed 20 times return on ad spend from the campaign helping them achieve their largest Black Friday. So I thought it was interesting that they, they called out a retailer to kind of show how how people are tying together all these different products that they've come out with in a cohesive program like that? Oh, yeah, absolutely. I mean, we, you know, at Razorfish, we, I don't know, uh, we, we do a bunch of launches for Mercedes on the Instagram platform, and the numbers are just crazy.
17:26 Like, they literally launched the, the GLK, that, that, like, 25, $30,000 version of the car trying to reach millennials on the, uh, on the Instagram platform. And, like, it drove r- huge volumes of test drives in the dealership. So, like, pretty low on the funnel for a super high considered purchase on a platform that wasn't really, you know, initially designed to support advertisements. So Seems like they have great traction at the moment. Yeah, I think, you know, I think the acquisition of Instagram was genius. Uh, you know, WeChat TBD, but if, you know, you and I are big believers in this whole chat thing, so that, that should be a no-brainer. And then really the only other one that, that has to come to fruition is Oculus and, you know, we'll know this spring how well that's doing.
18:10 Exactly. They have your and my money, so it seems like they're, they're- Yeah … they're trending well with the Foolish early adopters of no other segment. A survey we just did indicates 100% of people are ordering the Oculus. Exactly. Of old silly white dudes, 100% are ordering Oculus. That, that podcast late at night. Exactly. Uh, so then that was yesterday. Then today we kicked off the morning with Alibaba out of China, uh, and that was interesting. Uh, there's been, um… I would say there was a lot of people biting their nails on this one because there's been so much macroeconomic kind of negative news coming out of China, uh, where you have companies like Caterpillar whiffing because, you know, they're not selling any bulldozers there, and everyone, everyone knows the Chinese lie about GDP and how bad is it and all this kind of stuff.
19:00 Um, and, you know, and I think Alibaba actually kind of exceeded expectations, especially given that backdrop. Some of the metrics I saw, they hit 400 million active buyers. Uh, the GMV grew 23%, but then revenue grew thir- 35% for the marketplace, and that's because they've really been focused on monetization. And in a marketplace monetization, we call it, uh, we call it take rate. Sometimes you'll hear people think of, call it the, um, commission rate or, or something like that. It's the percentage that, that they earn off of the… It's essentially revenue divided by GMV equals take rate. Uh, and what's interesting is the US marketplaces are kind of in the 10 plus range. So, so eBay and Amazon call it, you know, they actually charge 12-ish, and then two is payment, so it's 10% for the marketplace.
19:46 Certain categories are higher, others are lower, but on average. Uh, Alibaba's always been lower at about 3%, uh, and, you know, it's actually five, and then two goes to Alipay, and they're left with three. So, so that's been working up and, and historically, um, just like the US, they're, they're way ahead on this. Uh, mobile has just been on fire there, smartphone, but the monetization has lagged, and it looks like the monetization has caught up, which was a real positive and caused them to… The, the GMV was a little light, but then they over, uh, exceeded on monetization. Um, they now, 65% of their revenue now is from mobile, so they've definitely kind of had their mobile moment, and that, that's not traffic. That's, you know, actual revenue. Uh, another thing that was interesting, um, oh, um, they're really starting to talk a lot about their cloud service, which is called AliCloud, uh, and that grew 126% year over year, and it's starting to be just like AWS.
20:38 It seems to be like it's, it's becoming a pretty material part of their business there. Yeah. Uh, that, I think that is clearly a trend that we, we s- we'll, we will talk about on some of the other earnings calls is, like, it seems like it's good to be a cloud company, for sure. Um, it is interesting, Alibaba versus Amazon. I, I tend to think of Alibaba as being a little more a la, a la carte, no pun intended. Um, meaning, like, you pay your take rate for the privilege of, of having a listing and selling something, and then any marketing services that you want to help, help shoppers find that listing, you buy separately, and you actually buy them from a division within Alibaba called AliMama, which is also really fun to say.
21:25 But so, you know, at Alibaba, you can get a super low take rate because it doesn't come bundled with any of these marketing services that you, you know, frankly, you probably need in order to get a very big audience. Whereas Amazon gives you some of those basic services built into the listing, but then they charge a much higher take rate. And it, y- frankly, it seem s- wise, it makes it look less expensive to get into Alibaba because of that low take rate. But in actuality, if you look at a lot of the successful sellers, um, they have a meaningful budget on AliMama too, and I think, uh, in that same earnings call, they also reported that, that they got a nice kiss from, uh, the growth of their marketing services as well.
22:07 Mm-hmm. Yeah, the other nice thing about having a low take rate is it, it, uh, lowers the selection funnel or, uh, filter. So, you know, if you have certain products that are lower margin, at 10%, you may be like, "You know, it's not worth listing this thing or selling it on this platform." But if you start it at a low percent, then you give me the tools to advertise what I want to. Maybe I don't advertise those low margin things, and I can still have a 10% margin product on a 2%, you know, margin or a take rate marketplace. So, so I, you know, I think that's one of the secrets of Alibaba's success of, of keeping eBay and Amazon out of their own backyard. And, uh, there's a lot of, you know, I've always thought it'd be interesting if, if they bring that to the US what happens?
22:49 And, and, you know, I think, I'm not sure how well, uh, I think eBay would be kind of the first caribou to fall, and then it's not clear if, you know, if Amazon would kill their cash cow, which I believe to be the third party marketplace to counteract that. So it would be quite disruptive if that came to the US. But, you know, everyone's been waiting on that for, for like six years and it hasn't happened. So we'll, we'll have to wait and see. Yeah. It'll be interesting. Obviously the, the outlook isn't super encouraging in the short term for, for China, and it's certainly impressive that Alibaba was able to continue their growth in that soft economy. Uh, but folks have to remember, Amazon in the US is about 30% of B2C sales if you look at their total GMV. Alibaba is like 80% of B2C sales in China.
23:33 So they have, like if you think Amazon is dominant in the US, Alibaba is three times more dominant in China and less than half of the population in China is even on the internet much less shopping yet. So even though those citizens in, in tier one and tier s- two cities that have driven a lot of the growth so far may not be seeing their, their, um, economic outlook as brightly as they would like to, uh, there are awful lot of additional consumers still to come into the Chinese marketplace and they're coming into a marketplace that has this true 800 pound gorilla. So it, it seems like there's, there's still plenty of headroom for those guys. Yeah.
24:14 And then, uh, the-- a real exciting one was Amazon reported after the bell today. Uh, and, uh, it's interesting 'cause if you read the headlines, it seemed like an, a, a total train wreck. Uh, but it was really just, uh, you know, I think Wall Street got a little bit ahead of itself because Amazon's been beating its own forecast for, for so long. And, um, so, you know, as you know, uh, when you're a public company, you put out this kind of forecast or, or guidance for the next quarter. Amazon put out their guidance. They came in at the top end of it, uh, and it wa-it was pretty aggressive guidance. It called for kind of fifteen to twenty-five percent growth, and at that scale, uh, you know, it's pretty impressive. So they came out right at the top, but I think Wall Street was expecting them to blow it away.
24:55 But don't believe the head-the headlines, you know, largest revenue ever, largest free cash flow. Um, profitability took a little bit of a hit because I think they were even surprised by how active FBA was. Um, a couple of the other, uh, metrics that I track. So again, e-commerce, let's call it fifteen percent. Amazon grew twenty-six percent. And all these numbers I'll say take out, uh, foreign currency impacts. Um, in, in Wall Street language, they call it Ex-FX, and FX stands for foreign exchange. So what you do is you look at constant currency to get these growth rates, uh, because the US dollar, uh, has become so strong. Um, your European business, for example, would be off five or six points because when you converted it to a US dollar a year ago, uh, versus today, it, it actually loses some growth.
25:41 It's not fair when you look at in constant currency. So, uh, so that being said, they, they grew twenty-six percent year over year. Again, very, you know, about twice the rate of e-commerce. When you peel the onion, it gets better. The, the part of Amazon I watch the most closely is called EGM, which stands for Electronic General Merchandise. Uh, it's basically all the non-media stuff. And in the US that grew-- Overall, it grew twenty-nine percent. Twenty-eight percent in the US and thirty-one percent outside the US. Um, that's a little bit of a tick down from last quarter, but that's 'cause of Prime Day. Uh, so they, they kinda pulled some growth into early Q3 with Prime Day. Um, first party, and this is a ChannelAdvisor estimate, first party grew twenty percent, third party grew forty percent.
26:22 So again, you know, the marketplace is growing, you know, more than two X the rate of e-commerce. Uh, when, when I do the math on the GMV, uh, and they don't report this, they report their revenue, and we have to kinda unpack it. Uh, for the quarter, it's seventy-seven billion, uh, which is Pretty, pretty big. And first party was 31 billion. Third party was 46 billion. Um, a couple other interesting stats. Prime, uh, they said Prime subscribers grew 51% year over year globally, 47% in the US, and then that makes international had to kinda outpace that at about 60%, I would guess. Um, you and I have talked a lot about logistics. On the conference call, they get asked straight up, you know, "Are you competing with UPS?"
27:04 And they said, "No. The reason we're buying trucks, planes, boats, and, uh, you know, whatever else, drones, uh, is our, our," you know, this is kind of a quote, "Our, our logistics partners are no longer able to handle our peak, peak needs." So, uh, I thought that was interesting. Um, they called out India. Uh, the stat there that was interesting was they've sold more in the fourth quarter of '15 than they did all of 2014 in India. They just-- Amazon just crested over 300 million active buyers. Um, and then, um, FBA was at 50% of units, and last year it was at 40. So they just saw this huge… And that's that unit that is itself growing 40% year over year. So they just saw this huge kind of saturation of FBA, and they're kinda hinting that they were beyond capacity.
27:49 And I, I read the tea leaves that almost said, "Hey, we're gonna build some more fulfillment centers." Now, I haven't seen any of the Wall Street notes yet. If, if Wall Street reads that as what came out, they'll freak out because it'll be a, quote-unquote, investment phase. Um, and the last thing I wanted to highlight is you and I have talked a lot about the Echo as kind of, um, you know, this really interesting product. And since we've talked about it, and I, I think we should take all the credit, uh, everyone's now calling it kind of their third or fourth billion-dollar business. Um, and they announced today that they're going to be doing a Super Bowl ad for the first time, and it's not Kindle, it's not the retail store, it's not drones. Uh, it's actually the Echo. They're gonna be doing a Super Bowl ad, uh, featuring your favorite actor, Stephen Baldwin.
28:32 So, uh, those were the highlights that I got out of the Amazon call. I thought it was, uh, to me, in the e-commerce world, I thought it was a, you know, a pristine quarter. It was, it was very impressive to have a holiday as big as this on top of the holiday they had last year. I think they had a tough comp. They had an amazing holiday last year, and they, they blew this one out of the water too. Yeah. Yeah. Uh, just for the record, my favorite actor is Dan Marino, who also is in the, the Echo Super Bowl ad. Um- Sorry, I got them mixed up … and it's actually, it's Alex Baldwin, right? It's not Stephen. Oh, okay. Uh, you or I could have Stephen in our ad probably. I get my Baldwins mixed up. Yeah. It's a, it's a easy mistake to do. Uh, I do think that proves, as, as we have seen over and over again, that Jason and Scot Show really is a market maker Um, so I'm excited about that.
29:17 Uh, it was, I, I thought a lot of the early headlines that, like, frankly came out during the the Amazon call were pretty funny because they, it, it, most of them were best quarter ever, stock plummets. Yeah. And, you know, it's after-hours trading, it's on a small volume. But I, I do think there's this, there, you know, there's this huge sentiment, you know, lots of people are understandably jealous that, that Amazon has historically been able to take a longer view and not necessarily post impressive profits and, uh, you know, still, still maintain their stock price. And, you know, I think, I think there were people that were giddily hoping this is the sign of investor impatience.
29:57 But I, I have a feeling that, that after we get, like, real volume on the market tomorrow, uh, I'm not sure that's gonna be the case. Any other Amazon news that you saw? I think those were the main things. Again, did we talk about their cloud, um, business? That, that, that, obviously the last earnings call was the first time they broke that out, and that was Uh, I think surprised a lot of people with the size, and then they, I think they did beat their estimate on, on, uh, AWS growth. Yeah. It, it, I think it was 69%. I'll have to look it up. Uh, you tell us about Microsoft while I double-check that. Fair enough. Uh, I, I didn't have a lot of takeaways from Microsoft other than the same thing we noted about, um, Alibaba and Amazon that, like, w- amongst their brightest spots was Azure, which is their, uh, SaaS-hosted infrastructure that sort of competes with AWS.
30:50 And I think the sales were up, like, 140% there. So it, uh, I don't know if that will ever be a winner-take-all type market, but at the moment it feels like everyone in that space is going lights out, and that there just appears to be a lot more demand in the marketplace than there, than, you know, is, is currently being fulfilled. So, uh, it seems like a, a, a good, smart place to be investing. Yeah. So here's the Amazon stats. So AWS grew 69% year over year to 2.4 billion in the fourth quarter. Um, but then the operating income soared, and that was up 161%. So not only is it, is it really kind of tracking, um, you know, very aggressively on revenue, but, but it's quite profitable, too. Yeah. Um, makes me think maybe we should do a Jason and Scot cloud services.
31:33 Maybe we'll, uh, we'll chat about it on the next podcast. Absolutely. If anyone's interested in that, please leave comments, and we'll be happy to take your order. One other thing I did wanna talk about, it's not really Amazon related, but, but sort of related to that. You, you mentioned, you know, that Amazon said, "Hey, all these investments in, in fulfillment are really because we, we think the world's capacity is capped, not because we necessarily wanna replace UPS." Some other news today, yesterday, was that Uber is opening up some APIs, uh, to their Uber Rush service. And so essentially what this lets businesses do is offer, uh, Uber's delivery service, um, through your own, uh, user interface.
32:14 And so, you know, uh, one of the targets for that, or the main target for that service was e-commerce operators that wanted to be able to use Uber Rush as a delivery service, and I think they mentioned 1-800-Flowers and Nordstrom as potential early partners. And I think they also announced an integration, or they've already had an integration with Shopify. And so the idea being e-commerce sellers could use Uber as a fulfillment channel. And I was Curious if you, uh, I, I have a, a strong opinion about that. I was curious if you think that that's encouraging or how you sort of look at that? It's definitely interesting 'cause the question I get is-- And I, I do this whole, you know, you, you've seen this where I go through all the stuff Amazon is doing and, uh, and people kind of freak out.
32:56 And, uh, Prime Now, for example, is in twenty-five metros, and, and I think Amazon could roll it out in another twenty-five this year pretty easily because it's just out of the fulfillment centers. Uh, and that's where you get, um… So it's a different app and a smaller set of inventory. It's only like three thousand SKUs, but, uh, you get them in an hour if you pay eight dollars. You have to be Prime. So you-- if you pay for, uh, eight dollars, you'll get it within an hour, uh, and then if you're happy to get it after an hour, you get them for free. Uh, it's in Chicago. I'm, I'm sure you've tried it. You've got a, a baby, so you've probably had diaper emergencies and stuff. Um, so people rave about that and, and a lot of retailers say, "What, what could we do to counteract that? You know, we've got the stores, but we don't-- we can't do this kind of delivery out of our stores."
33:40 And I think the Uber thing could be interesting there. The challenge is the, the package density. Um, and Amazon even has an Uber competitor. A lot of people don't know about this. It's called Flex. If you go to flex.amazon.com, you'll see it. And, uh, the way it works is Amazon sends a signal out to drivers and says, "Hey, we've got ten packages going to this zip plus four in Chicago." And it's, it's pretty efficient because they'll say, "We'll pay you twelve dollars." But because they can get package density, the, the cost per package is sub five dollars, which, which totally works. Um, the thing I don't get about Uber is Can they get to that package density by kind of doing these onesie, twosie things?
34:20 And, uh, you know, that, you know, if, if they can't, then it's gonna be 10 to $12 a package, and then you're kind of looking at luxury goods would be my guess. I'm curious to hear what you think. Yeah. I, I mean, I think that's one of their two problems. The A, I, I did wanna mention, I do have Amazon Prime now, and we frequently use it. One slight hidden cost, like, they like you to tip the driver, so there is a, a gratuity expense in there, too. And interestingly, they used to suggest you tip but not build it into the UI. Now they'll collect the tip on behalf of the driver in the UI. Hmm. Uh, 'cause so many people would, you know, have the driver drop packages off and not see the driver, so the, the drivers weren't making any tips. And in Chicago, we're super excited 'cause they've now announced they're gonna have Amazon Eats, so they're, they're gonna be, uh, doing restaurant delivery here in Chicago pretty soon.
35:07 So I'm, I'm looking forward to trying that as well. But going back to Uber, I think you hit one problem. It's going to be expensive to deliver a single package in a Camry, right? And there, there absolutely is a, a niche demand to go pick up a pa- a package off a shelf in a store and deliver it to a consumer, but that just can't… Like, the e- the economics just don't work for that to be a huge scale problem. It's simp- it cannot be the most cost-effective solution to ship a bunch of those products on a pallet to a store, pay a guy to cut them all open, put them on the shelf, pay another guy to drive his car, put that one-pound package in the car, and drive it across town and deliver it.
35:50 Like, that, there's so much friction in that system that that can't be the high volume solution for delivering goods to consumers. And the time when we most need extra capacity in the system, the time, uh, that, you know, the… A big part of the reason that Amazon said they're investing in their own fulfillment capabilities is for those peaks like holiday. And Uber doesn't own any drivers and can't make anyone deliver a package, so the way they get those drivers to work on those busy days is they, they have dynamic pricing, and they pay the drivers more with surge pricing. Yeah. And so if, if the regular cost to deliver the package is too expensive, uh, no retailer is gonna be willing to pay surge pricing to get packages delivered on Christmas when they most need it So it just doesn't seem like it solves a very big problem.
36:41 It almost feels like having it integrated in all these checkouts isn't gonna work. So it almost needs to be a separate app that, you know, like Prime Now where you would say, "Here's Uber Now," and, uh, it just kinda flips it on its head, and then you could say, you know, "If the minimum is if you order $100, then we'll bring it to you." Something like that to have some control over that part of it. Yep. I think for shopping, like, there is some ar- you know, argument in being able to aggregate all the stuff you could get so that you could aggregate the volume in that car. And I, I think- Yeah … ShopRunner in some ways has had a similar problem with a similar service if you really think about it, that, you know, it's, it's difficult to know what packages you can get delivered from ShopRunner when you're shopping, and so that makes it less appealing.
37:23 One thing I do think is I'm a big fan of, and so I don't wanna poo-poo too much, is I do really like the idea of businesses providing open APIs to let other people do mashes-up of their services. And even the, you know, the core Uber service, you look at now that it's built into all the airline apps, and it's built into a bunch of the hotel apps, and it's, it's- Maps built into Google Maps. Exactly. I think anytime you have a service that you can make available to other people, other people are gonna do really clever, smart things with that service, uh, that you may not have even thought of. So I, I do like that even though I, I'm not really bullish that, that Uber package delivery is gonna be the great savior of the e-commerce industry.
38:04 Totally agree. Well, we're, we're up against time. Any, maybe five minutes, any interesting retail news? Um, since we, we've been kinda talking e-commerce. Yeah, so like really shortly, you know, a, a number of interesting things going on at Walmart, but the, uh, one that, that caught my attention the most was an announcement this week that the, the CTO of Walmart is now reporting to Neal Ashe, who's the president of walmart.com, the, the e-commerce group. And so the, the technology organization for all of Walmart is now living in the e-commerce group. And to kind of put that in perspective, Walmart's the largest technology buyer in the world, right?
38:45 Like, so this is the CTO with the most purchase orders in the world now is an employee of the e-commerce group. And that to me is a very interesting shift. Um, you know, I think if you talk to a lot of e-commerce leaders a couple of years ago, they, they felt like collaborating and competing for turf with, with, uh, CTOs was a significant problem. And at least at Walmart's case, they've said, "Hey, e-commerce is the strategic growth area. We wanna make sure that technology first and foremost supports it." Yeah, it's almost, do you think it's like a coup almost, where, you know, the, the e-commerce was kind of, is taking over the business? I think if nothing else, like it's a brilliant PR gesture that am- that Walmart gets to show that, "Hey, we're really serious about, about e-commerce."
39:31 And you know, obviously, you know, one of the challenges they have to answer to their investors is, you know, that they're getting so out invested in, in technolo- in e-commerce technology by the likes of, of Amazon. And so, you know, I think putting the CIO underneath e-com is, is a signal and a good talking point there. You know, it'll be interesting to see if other retailers follow suit and then that becomes a, a new structure or that's something unique at Walmart. One thing I, I, I'm sure you saw, the store closures, and a lot of them are that Walmart Express. And I thought that Express was almost an answer to Amazon, where they were gonna be able to get small stores close to consumers, and they were gonna do buy online, pick up in the store.
40:12 So does that … I guess that means that that's not the, not the strategy going forward. Y- you know, what, what about it didn't work, do you think? Yeah. So one thing, you know, Walmart has at least three concepts. Like, they have the Walmart Superstore, they have a store, a middle-sized store called the Walmart Neighborhood, and then they have this Walmart Express, which is their smallest footprint stores. And they, uh, the intention is for that to be in city centers and places that, you're right, like, are great pickup locations and delivery locations for e-commerce. So they, they do have, uh, robust buy online, pick up in store lockers in all those Expresses. But I think the problem they ran into is the experience you can give in Express is exactly opposite of the Walmart value prop, right?
40:54 Like, so Walmart's value prop is all about assortment and big box, and when you can only have one brand of tissue paper and one brand of paper towels, it just doesn't feel like a Walmart experience. They, they were hoping that, you know, with their pricing advantage, that that would carry the day for them, but it, it just seems to have not worked. And it is interesting, 'cause at the same time that concept hasn't worked for Walmart, there is some evidence that Target's version of that concept, the Target City Center stores, are, uh, doing well. And so, you know, some, some difference in the Target audience and the assortment in those two stores. Seems like Target's figured out how to make those, those city-based stores do a little better.
41:34 The one thing I will say, the Walmart Neighborhood stores which have grocery in them are continuing to do really well, and they get a ton of visits. And so that seemed like even though they closed some super centers and all those, uh, Express stores, they didn't touch the, the Walmart Neighborhood stores, 'cause that, that apparently is gonna be, uh, one of their growth platforms going forward. Hmm. And they raised their minimum wage, uh, this week, which is, has all kinds of ramifications, and some people are cynical, but they're the largest employer in the US, so I'm, I'm, uh, happy for those 300,000 employees that got a, a raise this week. Yeah. Hopefully they'll, uh, buy stuff online. Exactly. Any other retail news? I think the one that got a lot of, uh, buzz was, uh, you know, Macy's has, has talked about this off-price concept store called Backstage, I think is what they call it.
42:23 And, and, uh, you know, I think they're talking about opening some freestanding Backstage stores that would compete with Saks OFF 5TH and Nordstrom Rack. Uh, but there was a news bul- blurb last week that they also were thinking about opening a Backstage department in every Macy's store. So, uh, a discount department, you know, in, in, uh, each store. And, uh, that is very controversial. I think, like, all the pundits, myself included, are pretty skeptical, uh, that that's gonna go well to, you know, to have that discount product adjacent to the, the full-price product in the store is really, you know, potentially gonna erode their value proposition and their price points and, you know, potentially cause them some, some problems with vendors as well.
43:11 Hmm. Yeah, it's kinda like they'll just put it on one side of the store and walk it over to the other and … It's kinda- Exactly. It's way cheaper, uh, to move that inventory than it is for, like, a Nordstrom Rack. I will, I will give you that. But, you know, it's, it's, you know, kinda like having a dump bin in the front of your, your luxury department store. Like, it, you know, it's- Yeah … it's a message to everyone that comes in and goes to one of those full-price sections that, like, "You're paying too much." Just wait Yeah. And that, that, you know, kind of doubt can have a huge impact on sales, so It wouldn't be a good Jason and Scott show without me talking about the death of malls. And, uh, it was interesting, uh, during the Starbucks earnings report, Howard Schultz went on a bit of a riff.
43:52 Um, I know you follow the payment stuff. I, I didn't really look at that, but he, um, about six months ago, he was talking about, uh, you know, that smartphones are just gonna cause this epic change, and it was gonna be a very dramatic change in retail. Uh, and then on the call this quarter, he said… I'll, I'll read the quote. I thought it was interesting. Uh, this is Howard Schultz: "I, I think today in the headlines you've seen just in the last three weeks store closures of almost 50 Macy's, 150 Walmart stores. You've gotta ask yourself what's gonna happen to the future of those malls that they're anchored by those big box retailers." Um, and you know, I, I don't know the numbers, but a lot of Starbucks are in malls and, and you've gotta believe that they're, they're, you know, not gonna be opening a lot more mall Starbucks because they're, they're kind of saying, uh, traffic to malls is way down.
44:39 People aren't using it. They're … They prefer the independence, uh, the convenience of ordering from, uh, the Starbucks app and being able to pick it up right at the store and not have to go through the whole mall experience. So kind of, kind of interesting. You know, you could argue it's just the coffee dude, what does he know? But, uh, he's actually been pretty good on this trend, uh, over the last couple of years. Oh, absolutely. I, I tend to agree with him. Like, I would make a quick Caveat, um, there's multiple flavors of malls in the world, and there are these, you know, outdoor lifestyle, uh, center malls that, uh, are doing very well and, you know, generating over $1,000 a square foot across the whole mall. You know, there aren't a ton of those, but those malls, I think, you know, that are sort of entertainment venues are continuing to do well.
45:22 But all these indoor regional malls, which is kind of how I took Howard Schultz's comment, I think is a real challenge. And especially because they're anchored by stores that people, you know, don't tend to wanna shop in anymore. And, you know, a bunch of those stores are in the process of closing as well. So it, that's going to be a, a big challenge. I was, uh, following an event this week that the president of General Growth Properties, which is one of the big owners of those malls, um, was at. And he was talking about the future of the mall is we have to get all these retailers to have open APIs and share all their data, so that we can give shoppers a great universal mall app, so they can shop the inventory of all the stores from a single app, and so that the mall operator can give the shoppers a better experience in the mall.
46:06 And h- and his, his position was, you know, when we can do that, then, uh, you know, we'll, we'll be able to restore our rightful place in the, in the shopping ecosystem. And, you know, frankly, I thought that was, uh, a total pipe dream. Like, like, customers aren't going to the mall, so the experience you give them in the mall isn't likely to, to make a big difference. And I think his problems are much more systemic than the fact that he can't have a universal app with all of his tenants' products in it. Yeah. And I, I think Howard Schultz is probably right. I did wanna point out another piece of credibility for Howard Schultz is he's dominating mobile shopping and mobile payments. Like they announced that they're up to 21% of all their transactions are now from those mobile devices.
46:49 And, you know, you and I talked in the, uh, past about they rolled out this new, uh, mobile order and pay- Mm-hmm … which is kind of like buy online, pickup in store for coffee. And it's now, during their rush hour, it's 10% of all their orders are, are, uh, mobile order and pay, which is, you know, huge adoption in a relatively short period of time. Um, and so it just, it seems like they are making all the right moves. They're one of the, you know, best examples of a retailer, uh, that's creating those customer experiences that their consumer wants ahead of time. And, uh, like I, I have a lot of admiration for, for what they're doing right now. Yeah, anecdotally, I've gotten the formula at my local Starbucks that if there's three to four people in front of me, it's faster for me to do the mobile order, and I'll actually come out in kind of front of the, the number three person.
47:37 Yeah. I, I don't know how well it works, but I will tell you there's a cool… In San Francisco, there's a super boutique coffee place called Blue Bottle Coffee. They, they have a store in the ferry terminal, um, where the, you know, the ferry from the, the North Bay, like, docks to let people off that, you know, tend to work in downtown San Francisco, and they have that feature. But they have an extra cool feature. They have a geolocation in the app, and they allege that they'll figure out when to transmit the order based on, like, where the ferry is to make sure that the coffee is hot and ready for you when you get off the ferry, which, uh- Nice … I don't, I, I'm a little skeptical that they're doing it that well right now, but, like, that, that use case makes perfect sense, and I think, you know, we're, we're just gonna see more and more of that stuff where, where retailers and manufacturers are able to, like, meet our needs in all kinds of ways we don't even imagine today because they can use all these, this, uh, data and these powerful super computers in our pocket.
48:34 Cool. Anything else in retailing? Yeah, so there's one huge piece of news that I saved as our blockbuster, uh, ending, and that's for all of you that have been waiting, for all of you that have been in mourning, it now looks like Circuit City is coming back. Bum, bum, bum. Exactly. Watch out, Best Buy. Yeah, yeah. So I think, you know, Best Buy and, and, uh, Walmart and Amazon are all cowering in the corner 'cause, you know, some folks bought the, the rights to the Circuit City name from TigerDirect. So they're launching a new website, um, and they're opening some stores, and the description of the stores, they're small footprint stores that sound an awful lot like RadioShack-type, uh, footprints. And they mention that they're gonna be selling, uh, private label Circuit City goods through a bunch of marketplaces, including the Sears marketplace.
49:21 And so my immediate reaction was Circuit City brand, RadioShack footprint, uh, Sears marketplace, like, that is a recipe for success if I've ever heard of one. Yeah, yeah. It's gonna be interesting to track that. Exactly. So this might be a good time, uh, to invest in that. But with that, we should probably call it a day for episode 11. Yeah, it's been a, been an exciting week. Hopefully everyone enjoyed, uh, the summary of all the earnings. Uh, the one we didn't catch in this podcast is Google, which is now known as Alphabet, and they report next week. So we'll pick that up in next week's show, which is episode 12. We'll be looking forward to that.
50:01 Thank you very much for listening, and Scott, great to talk to you as always. Thanks, everybody. You've been listening to The Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes, and please leave a review.
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed