EP035 - E-Commerce Deadly Sins
EP035 - E-Commerce Deadly Sins
A list of the 15 common mistakes we see in digital commerce:
- Requiring the user to create an account to checkout (See $300M button, now known to be Best Buy)
- Spending too much on Adwords vs PLA's
- Not offering Free shipping
- Not having a fully developed channel strategy
- Not telling the shopper “when they will get it”
- Overfocus on customer acquisition, not enough on retention
- Not having a prominent Search box
- Over emphasis on mobile app vs mobile website
- Lack of social proof (rating & reviews, question & answer, user generated content
- Omni-channel failures (not having accurate inventory)
- Poor product photography
- Too much checkout friction (too many fields, leaving header/footer on)
- Pricing surprises in the checkout
- Prominent Promo field in the checkout (See: Promo field is costing Sears $16M/mo)
- Poor Pageload Speed (too many 3rd party tags, especially on mobile)
Don't forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.
Episode 35 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded on Wednesday, July 6th, 2016.
Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:00 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here is Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. This is episode 35, being recorded on Wednesday, July 6th, 2016. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, and as always, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Scott. It's been like two weeks since we last chatted. I'm sort of in Scott withdrawal.
0:40 Uh, how was your 4th of July? It was awesome. You're, you're sort of in withdrawal or you're, you enjoyed the break? I'm fully in Scott withdrawal, but I just didn't want our listeners to know how much I missed you. Aw, that's, uh, that's both sweet and kinda creepy. Uh, July 4th was awesome. We are in North Carolina, and there's a little place in the mountains here called Blowing Rock, which is near Boone, North Carolina, and we went up there, and it was, it was awesome. Very Norman Rockwell with the fireworks and the little parade and the firetruck all decked out in American flags and clowns, all that good stuff. Very cool. And were you… Did you find a barbecued hotdog to enjoy? Oh, we found barbecue, not a barbecued hotdog.
1:23 That sounds like some kinda Chicago thing that you would do. Gotcha. I just thought that was the American 4th of July food. I don't know. We did have apple pie, so- Perfect … checked that box. Feel like you're totally covered then. Excellent. Yeah. How about you? Uh, I also had a nice 4th of July. I was on holiday, uh, the week leading up to the 4th of July, so we got home to Chicago for the long 4th of July weekend to sort of recover and decompress from our vacation. Cool. Did you have a good vacation? You were with in-laws, which is always tricky. I did, and it's possible some of them are listening, so yes, I had a great vacation. Especially enjoyed your time with your in-laws. Oh my gosh, my mother-in-law is a total treat.
2:04 Nice. Good times. Mary Katherine, I hope you are listening, and I know you know that's true. I have a feeling you're gonna email her this one. Exactly. "Hey, you should, you should definitely check out episode 35." Yeah, at least the first two minutes Well, great. So, uh, since we've had a break, tonight we're going to do a bit of a deep dive, and we thought it'd be interesting, uh, to look at some of the common mistakes that Jason and I see across e-commerce companies. Uh, and as we were prepping for the show, we were shooting for 10 of the biggest mistakes, and in typical Jason and Scot Show spirit, we actually came up with 15.
2:44 So you, our listeners, are getting 50% more for no additional cost here on the Jason and Scot Show. So we're excited to continue to add value to your, your podcast experience. Um, the … We're gonna call these the 10 plus 5 Deadliest E-Commerce Sins. And what I thought was interesting when, when, you know, we have, we each have different things we focus on, and we were building the list, I thought it was really illustrative because you tend to fo- focus on what I would call merchandising and site optimization and that kind of stuff, and I tend to focus more on marketing and customer acquisition and, and those kinds of elements. So, so I think it works, uh, works well, and I really look forward to learning more about what you're gonna say about how folks can improve the merchandising and site optimization.
3:30 So with that background, you wanna kick it off? Absolutely, Scott. Uh, these are in no particular order, but I do think this first one may be the highest financial value tip I have on the list. Uh, so my number one deadly sin is requiring a account in order to check out, or to say it another way, not offering a guest checkout Um, and this is a, a hotly debated, uh, practice in, uh, e-commerce circles. There, there are a number of very successful sites that do require an account to check out. Uh, you're quite familiar with the famous one called Amazon, um, that successfully is able to do that.
4:13 But my premise is for the overwhelming majority of e-commerce experiences, consumers do not want to create an account, and they for sure don't wanna create an account before they complete their first order, um, and have their first successful relationship with you. And, uh, in dozens of client, uh, sites, we've, we've tested this and added a guest checkout, and conversion almost universally goes up dramatically. Uh, there's a famous case study that's, that's I think almost eight years old now that, uh, that folks in the industry called the $300 million button. Um, and it talks about an anonymous site that I, uh, I will tell you now is Best Buy, uh, that at one point, uh, did not offer a guest checkout.
4:59 And when they offered the, the… When they added a guest checkout feature, they, they captured $300 million of revenue in the first year. Um, so for the overwhelming majority of sites, I think it's a huge mistake to not offer a guest checkout. And as I like to remind folks, y- uh, when you do a guest checkout, you collect all the information you would need in order to create an account. So it's perfectly fine to offer to create that account after you've captured the order. But asking people to create the account before you capture that first order is just a, an extra mental hurdle that many shoppers aren't prepared to make. And so for that reason, I think it's a huge mistake.
5:39 So I guess the thinking is, is this because people are, like, incented based on account creation or something? Or, like, so, so why… A-and I guess that you can email… You can still, you know, do some email marketing to folks even if they don't create an account, or is that kinda what you're trying to do? You're trying to get them to go through T's and C's so you can get them into your email program. So is that, is that kind of the driver of why people would not wanna have a guest checkout? Yeah. Well, I think the biggest reason that folks don't, uh, wanna offer guest checkout is because they want to, uh, be able to store that payment information and make subsequent checkouts lower friction. And their, the premise is that if I, um- Create, if I go through the, the extra pain of creating that account once, that those account holders in the long run will be much more valuable.
6:26 Um, and, you know, everyone just looks at Amazon and looks at Amazon Prime members and says, "See? You know, those, those users are way more valuable, and we want a bunch of users like that, so why not, you know, go through just the minimal extra effort of, of forcing them to create an account before that, that first checkout?" Um, and that, of course, is a misnomer. When you look at a bunch of e-commerce sites and you look at the, the average revenue per account holder versus non-account holders, it's not obvious at all that account holders are more valuable. Um, and frankly, even when users create an account, an alarming percentage of those users create a new account every time they check out because they don't retain the, the knowledge that they had an account.
7:10 And, you know, then you potentially block them from creating a new account because that email address already exists, and then you send them in this whole bad cycle of password recoveries and all these, these other bad things that can happen. To, to a lesser extent, I think you're also right. You know, they want you to opt into the email programs. Like, obviously you, you capture an email address even in a guest checkout because you wanna be able to email an order confirmation. Uh, and you could certainly market to them after that order. You know, you could market the opportunity to get on those lists after the order using the email you just captured. Um, but, but there are, there are retailers that would rather get that double opt-in up front. But again, you're, you're just, you're optimizing for this idealistic scenario that doesn't exist for most retailers.
7:58 And most retailers just aren't gonna be a frequent enough destination for the average consumer that it makes sense to force account creation. So what if we play this to its logical conclusion and don't have registered accounts at all? Yeah. Um, so w- when third-party digital wallets are good enough, I, I do think that's entirely viable. Uh, I mean, n- you know, this is not a new concept. Microsoft launched this product i- in 1998 called Microsoft Passport, and the whole notion was, gosh, we should just have your credentials on, in the cloud on the, you know, once and store it, and, you know, ev- everyone o- you know, you ought to be able to permission any site you wanna do business with to access those credentials and not force you to create that stuff over and over again.
8:44 And, you know, in China, for many users, that's… or for the majority of users, that's Alipay, right? Um, and to a lesser extent in the US, that's, that's PayPal. Um, and as those kinds of services get more robust, I think it's, it's entirely possible that there'll be less inclination to, to offer account creation on, on all of these individual e-commerce sites. Yeah, and I, I have to admit, I actually kinda like logging in with the Facebook button because it's already, you know, active on all my devices, and it's easy and… But then what's funny is they, you know, a lot of people, it's a little bit of a trap. They're like, "Log in with Facebook," and then they're like, "Oh, we only need six more pieces of information for you to log on to Facebook," and you're always like, "What?
9:27 I thought this was supposed to be a lot easier." Yeah. So obviously Facebook is great for social sign-in. Not very many people have payment information stored on, on Facebook yet. Um, but the… And social sign-in is even a more controversial one, uh, because to your point, there are a lot of users that really like it, and it can be a lot faster, and it saves you from having to create those individual password, which is a huge mental hurdle for a lot of users. I think there's a, a funny stat out there that three out of five users would rather clean a toilet than invent a new password. Um, and so that certainly argues in favor of the social sign-in. The, the downside of social sign-in are users often forget which social service they used for social sign-in.
10:08 So most sites let you sign in with Facebook or Google, um, and then y- you know, you come back, and you don't remember which one you signed in, or you don't remember that you created an account at all. And i- if normal password recovery is bad, um, password recovery when you used a social sign-in is a disaster. Cool. Well, that's a good one. Hopefully, uh, hopefully that folks are-- have a guest checkout, and if they don't, they're gonna add one soon after listening to this. Um, number two, which is my first one, uh, of the deadly sins, is really what, what we've found is you, you-- when you think about customer acquisition, um, Google is kinda the first word you think about.
10:49 And one thing we have found over time is Google started with you, you have kinda three programs we can talk about. So you have, uh, obviously SEO or organic, which is the free part of Google. Um, that's on decline because mobile, um, reduces the amount of real estate that's, that's on the, the page for, for SEO. And then also on-- even on desktop, Google has kinda consistently pushed down the free results, uh, on the page. Google is in no way incented to, to have a bunch of free results there because their monetization engine is not the free results. So, um, so then you have the sponsored listings, which are commonly called AdWords, which is the program. And then increasing your-- increasingly, you have product listing ads or PLAs as we call them in the industry, uh, and it's also known as Google Shopping.
11:34 So one thing we find a lot of when, when I'm out talking to retailers is they are so addicted to kinda AdWords, they've under-invested in PLAs. And when we look across our customer base, PLAs have gone from zero, because it was a free program, you know, literally, uh, in, I think, two thousand twelve is when it went paid. So, you know, since then, it's kind of slowly but surely, kind of every year, about ten percent of wallet has gone to PLAs, and you see it in the, in the screen real estate, it's e-even more. And now you're seeing these obnoxious kind of four by three PLAs and, and they're just taking up a ton of real estate, um, because they work really well for Google.
12:15 So one thing we find is we'll, we'll go to these very large AdWord, uh, customers, and we'll find that they're still like ninety percent AdWords and maybe ten percent PLAs, and they're not sending their whole catalog to Google. They don't believe it works. Um, and a lot of these experiences come from, um, either, um, frugal, and they're still upset that Google's charging for this, uh, which is kinda silly, uh, but yet they're still spending, you know, tens of millions of dollars on AdWords. Uh, uh, or they tried it, you know, in two thousand fourteen, and it didn't work. And there's this kinda common misperception that PLAs don't work, and therefore they're just gonna keep juicing AdWords. So, so we actually have seen kind of a seventy percent, um, PLA, thirty percent AdWord balance across our entire customer base.
13:01 We're kinda heading there. We'll get there probably, you know, in the next couple months. We're, we're on our way to that. So, so that should be a wake-up call to look and see, you know, read, revisit PLAs, look is your entire catalog being put out there. Um, there's a lot of different ways to create target groups and to do the bidding and to be smarter about it. I don't wanna go into all that. But, but that's something that, that we, we commonly see is, is a huge problem, uh, that's out there. Yeah. Do you have a, um, premise for why that is? Like, I, I talk to a lot of clients that still talk about a fear of data share with Google Yeah. Yeah, that's one thing.
13:42 But I, I don't really, you know, I, I don't know what data Google's getting with a PLA that they're not effectively getting with an AdWord, because with an AdWord they know the landing page, so they know the product. If you're using analytics, they know the conversion rate. So, um, it's not like Google's building this massive catalog kinda like Amazon has done with their marketplace. Um, so I don't really know what, what data they'd be worried about that's not already out there in the AdWords platform. So, so I think that's a… Yeah. I, I think the horse is out of the barn and it's dancing around and, and worrying about the barn door at this point is, is kinda, you know, silly if, if you're an AdWords spender. Now, if you're, you know, if you're super Google paranoid and you're not doing AdWords because of that, then yeah, PLAs are just as bad if not slightly worse than AdWords i- if a, you know, if you're super concerned about Google being able to see some of your data.
14:34 Yeah. I mean, there, I think there's an optional element to… Once you're doing PLAs, the, you know, the other thing that I think really is a best practice but some people are leery of is then having a local inventory feed. Um, so you can add the in-stock nearby icon to those PLAs if you're willing to share your inventory, your local inventory feeds with, with Google, and I, I, I certainly have talked to some retailers that are reticent to share that level of data. Yeah. And that, that's called, uh, LIA, local inventory ads. And, um, so, so retailers are nervous about the data. Uh, a lot of retailers I've found, they really s- It's a lot of data. So if you're, if you've got 1,000 stores and that's got 100,000 SKUs, um, one of the main problems with that is just getting it out to Google in a timely manner is very hard.
15:22 And, um, you know, a lot of these, a lot of these retailers are generating these kind of, uh, XML-based files or CSV or whatever the format is, and they end up being, you know, many hundreds of gigabytes because of the scale of each store. Uh, and then it takes Google… And it takes them like 48 hours to generate it. It takes Google, because it's such a large file, a couple days to digest it, and it ends up being a bad consumer experience because, uh, the, you know, the product quantities are, are, are four days old by the time it gets in there. Now, there's more sophisticated things you can do. So you can kinda do a, um, kinda what you would call like a big upload and then a, uh, kind of a frequent API update to kind of catch up, um, as it were.
16:03 Um, and, you know, we certainly, uh, have that capability and we do it with normal PLAs a lot. Um, we just found that retailers don't have that level of inventory system to be able to do that for, for the local inventory ads. So, so, so the feedback I get on local inventory ads a lot of times is, um, concern over the user experience when you get all excited that you see an ad for that size 10 shoe you need, and then you click through and the site kind of And then it's usually kinda awkward, right? Because you usually then end-- add on a-- land on a page, but then you have to kinda go do the store lookup again. And, and then as-- when you go through all that, then you're kinda like, it's out of stock, and you're like, "What the heck? It just kinda… Over at Google, it said it was in stock, and now it's not out, not in stock."
16:45 So, so to mitigate that, what a lot of folks do is they just send a slice of their data, and they, they tend to cut out, um, a lot of those kinds of products that are either thinly traded and inventoried or have kind of complex style, kinda size combination kinda stuff. Um, so I have seen that the, the LIA is a lot less popular than a, a general PLA. Got it. And, uh, going back to the general PLAs, the, the famous retailer in my mind that, that, you know, with a, a few notable exceptions, doesn't use PLAs is Amazon. Like, are they not using them because they just simply don't wanna give the revenue to their competitor or Google? Or what, what do you think their philosophy is? Yeah. And, uh, the caveats are some of the Amazon subsidiaries do use it.
17:28 So Zappos and Q-Quidsi definitely do. And Amazon's gone in and out with Kindle devices over time. Um, and, um, I think as of the last time I checked a couple days ago, they were not doing it. Uh, Amazon hasn't publicly stated why they don't do that, but, um, if you read some books and some articles about it, you know, internally, folks have said on sites like Quora that the feeling is if you think ab- y- if you think about at a super high level who has the best product search, Amazon wants to own that, wants to win that battle. And if they take their approximately three hundred million SKUs and up-forklift them into Google, then Google will have the union of Amazon and everyone else's inventory.
18:10 And I think Amazon looks at that and says, "That would be stupid. Why, why should we let Google be a better search… You know, as good or better a search engine than we are by giving them our entire inventory?" Um, so I, I think it's, you know… The flip side of that coin is, um, it's one of the few places that you don't compete with Amazon in online marketing. So if you're in AdWords, for example, Amazon, you know, they, they have, uh, you know, they seem to bid very aggressively because they can look at the cost of a… The LTV of a customer is very high on Amazon. If they can get them to be Prime, that LTV kind of probably multiplies by four to 10. So you do see Amazon very aggressively on AdWords. Uh, and then they're awesome on S-SEO as well.
18:51 So it's one of the few areas on Google where you can be and not have to compete with Amazon, so that's a positive. But, um, to your earlier point about data, that is an example of a company saying, "I don't wanna do PLA because of the data." Now, now I think they're the one company that has a valid concern there because of the three hundred million SKUs they've built over, you know, the last twenty years. Yeah. I think that, that makes perfect sense. So you've, you've convinced me PLAs are the, uh, the investment, and I assume you would say, um, uh, make sure they're mobile PLAs as well. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. And then, um, you know, uh, Google is working on a program where you can actually buy from the PLA. They call it, uh, Buy on Google, uh, or Purchase on Google. They, they change the name of these things all the time.
19:33 Uh, and, and I think that's one of the ways they see as potentially solving this, this conversion rate problem you and I talk about on mobile. Yeah, and that, that has been interesting. Um, there have been more use cases where that has worked well than I would have initially thought. Um, I still think it's, it's not a perfect solution for everything, and obviously one of the big challenges there is in most cases you don't wanna sell just one SKU, you wanna sell a basket of SKUs. And, you know, when you just buy the one product through the, the, the PLA experience, you're, you're in most cases missing the opportunity to upsell and add to cart and, and all of those sorts of things. Yeah, absolutely. Yep. So my, uh, next tip, uh, is also one that I, I feel disproportionately affects, uh, financial performance for many sites, and that is not offering free shipping.
20:24 Um, so the bad piece of news for, for most folks that don't know is the overwhelming majority of e-commerce sales are with free shipping. Um, I think from the latest Comscore data, Q1 of this year, sixty-three percent of all e-commerce sales included free shipping. Uh, it a- free shipping actually spikes in the fourth quarter for holiday, and so it's, it's about seventy percent, sixty-nine percent, um, in Q4 of, uh, 2015, and it'll be even higher this year. Um, and those numbers are just going up. If you go back in time about three years, it was about, uh, forty-eight percent of, of sales were with free shipping. So, you know, about three years ago we passed the fifty percent mark, and now we're running an average of higher than sixty percent and hitting seventy percent on holiday.
21:12 And so it, it turns out that we are hardwired, um, to disproportionately avoid certain fees, right? So we really don't like taxes, and we really don't like fees, um, and charging for shipping is a huge impediment to, to e-commerce sales. And so, you know, I, I encourage everyone to find a way to put that free shipping icon on their site. Now, the good news is there's a hundred different ways to offer free shipping and put those magic words on your site. Like, that doesn't mean you have to unprofitably ship every order to every customer for free. It means you, you offer free shipping with a threshold, and you promote that, and you have a good, good user experience about getting users over that threshold.
21:59 Or you offer free shipping when you pick up in store if you're an omni-channel retailer. Um, there's a whole host of low-cost tactics you can use to offer free shipping, but it's super important one way or another to offer free shipping for the majority of your, your sales. Yeah, but Jason, it's not really free, is it? Uh, the, I'm nothing is, is in fact truly free, and as we've talked about on this show, the costs for do- giving that free shipping are actually going up. And so, you know, you're, we're seeing retailers have to get r- much smarter about managing their shipping costs and spreading their, their, their business out across multiple carriers to optimize for cost and, um, sort of, you know, take as much friction out of the shipping system as possible because just the, um, the, the raw cost from the big carriers for shipping is, is going up.
22:53 And at the same time, customer expectations to not pay for that shipping are also going up, and that, that's, that dynamic, you know, puts a ton of strain on the profitability of the e-commerce model for most retailers. Yeah, and, and that's, you know, there, there's a fair number of people that are still holding out on this one. And, and whenever I talk to them, they say, "Look, we, we don't want the consumer to think it's free, and we feel like if we even charge something, then that avoids us getting on the slippery slope." And I know what my argument is against that. I'm curious, like, what you would argue. Yeah. Well, I mean, A, the, the big, the, the, the threshold from $0 shipping to .1 cent shipping is the most expensive jump.
23:35 Like, it, it, it, it's psychology as much as it is rational economics. And so, like, we've, we've literally done these tests where you offer free shipping, which has a $12 value, or you offer $15 off, and the customer will take free shipping every single time and twice on Sunday. Or the, the free shipping promotion will sell more goods than the $15 off promotion will. And so it's, it's not… Consumers aren't making rational purchase decision in figuring out the total landed cost of all these goods. They, in the very brief attention span they're gonna give you while they try to acquire some item that they need to make their life better and move on with their day, um, they're, they're gonna see a giant neon sign that says you're charging me for fr- for shipping, and increasingly, that consumer knows there's a ton of other options on the, the internet to get that same item that won't charge me for shipping.
24:31 So they don't do the math. They just go to one of the sites that will have a big, bright free shipping logo on the top of their header, um, and they'll feel better about making the purchase from that. Cool. That's, uh, that's exactly what I would say. But I wouldn't have all the cool data you had. So thank you. You would, you would say it, uh, with far less, uh, ums and uhs in the sentence. I don't know. I probably would've just said, "Hey, you need to talk to this guy Jason about this thing." The, um, number four on the list, I call this one, um, having a fully developed channel strategy. And full disclosure, as one of the founders and CEO, now exec chairman of ChannelAdvisor, I've spent kind of 15 years, we just had our 15-year anniversary, thinking about this one.
25:13 And, um, the way I think about it is there's, call it 200 million-ish is the latest data f- I think from Comscore on the US audience. Maybe it's gotten a little bit higher than that. Uh, and they, you know, these folks shop in different places. There's these little eddies and pools that where they like to shop, and they have affinities with these sites. And getting them to your site may be impossible, so you should definitely have a site and market it and do all that stuff, but you need to think about what other channels you can put your products on. The three buckets I tend to think of are search, where, where I talked about that earlier with, with AdWords, et cetera, comparison shopping engines. PLA is a comparison shopping engine, but there's still many more out there. And then a lot of the … In the mobile world, you're seeing this resurgence of new kind of comparison shopping engine kinds of things like Wanelo, and I even kind of view the Pinterest Rich Pins in that category.
26:02 Um, and then the last one that, that, uh, I spend a lot of time talking about is marketplaces. And, you know, the two, two 800-pound gorillas, well, the one 800-pound gorilla is Amazon, and then the 400-pound gorilla is eBay. Um, but it's easy to forget that Sears has a marketplace, Newegg, all these other places have marketplaces. Um, and I think an interesting metaphor is go to Google and do a search for one of your most popular products. So I just did randomly a pair of Levi jeans. And when you go there, think about all the paths the consumer's taking from there and where they're going. And what's interesting is a lot of our customers spend a fair amount of time on this, and they can end up with 20 different paths to their products. So for example, I'm, I'm there now.
26:44 I've got an Amazon PLA, uh, sorry, AdWords is number two. Um, there's a couple marketplaces. eBay is very prominent in the PLAs. Uh, you know, you should be there directly, uh, of course, if you're selling a pair of Levi jeans. And then in SEO, the first result is Levi, and the second one is Amazon. And then you have Sears, eBay again in the organic. So, so what's interesting is if you kind of think about this strategy, you could have 18 different entry points just from Google and, and think of that as shelf space. So if, if in the physical world you could go and have your product 18 different times on the shelf, and maybe it looked a little different and the path to it was a little different, you're on different aisles, but you're still getting all this shelf space, you would do that.
27:26 So, so that's the metaphor I think for having, um, and you know, and it's not just for Google, because there's gonna be people that just prefer to shop on eBay. You know, eBay has hundreds of millions of registered users. It has its own audience. Uh, Walmart has a new marketplace. They have s- you know, like 80 or 90 million active users. Um, so it's real easy to forget that these, these different audiences pool in different areas, and they may never come to your site. So it's important to get a, an at bat by being in these popular kind of top 20-ish, uh, websites where you do have the ability to list things either through a search, a comparison shopping engine, or a marketplace. Yeah, I, I totally agree.
28:07 Like, it's a little bit cliche, but, you know, we all talk about this, this paradigm shift in, in shopper marketing that we used to be able to tell the consumer how we wanted them to behave, and we used to sort of be able to force the behaviors we wanted on them, and now that, that completely doesn't work anymore. The, the consumer's in charge and, and they'll dictate how they, they wanna interact with you. And if they choose to interact with you through a marketplace or through, you know, a, a CSE or, or any other tool, you, you really need to be there. It's a mistake to, you know, assume that you can, you can change the consumer behavior by only being in the, the places that, that you want the consumer to go to.
28:49 Yeah, and a lot of the, um, even the platform cart guys are really catching onto this, and they have different names for it. They can call it distributed commerce or democratization of commerce, and they all have kind of a different word because they don't wanna use our word, which is kind of channels. Um, but you know what the most common negative I, I get from, from folks is, uh, and, and the shoe guys are all like this, where they're like, "Well, I don't, I don't want my brand associated with that brand." But what's always funny to me is, um, you know, all these guys have outlets, uh, in the real world and where their stuff is half off, and they all sell to TJ Maxx and, you know. But then when they get online, they're like, "Ooh, I wouldn't want my brand associated with Amazon and eBay."
29:31 And I don't… It just kind of really doesn't hold a lot of water for me. You're-- They're effectively saying, "Well, you know, there's two-thirds of the internet I don't want my product exposed to." Um, and, and it's just kind of a weird argument that doesn't really make logical sense to me. Yep. I, I can imagine some edge cases where it makes sense to opt out of certain, uh, channels, but I think your, your broader point is you need to have a full channel strategy. Like, you, you need to be evaluating being on all those things and make good business decisions about where to be, and your default, uh, option should be to be in all of those places unless there's a darn good reason not to be. Exactly. So transitioning to my next deadly sin, which is number five on our list, is not telling the shopper when they'll get it.
30:19 Um, so this is alarmingly common on e-commerce sites, but the majority of s- sites will tell you how many, uh, days the shipping is going to take, right? So we're gonna ship this two day, or we're gonna ship this ground, and to your zip code, that's gonna be four days. Uh, but the majority of the sites won't tell you when they're gonna process your order or when those goods will leave the, the site's warehouse. And consumers don't care how many days UPS has your product, right? Like, they care that they're gonna get your product before their vacation or get your product before the party that they're hosting or whatever their use case is for your product. And so it's, it's critically important to know when those goods will arrive.
31:03 Um, and I would argue that this is one of the fundamental customer experience advantages that Amazon has is, is that they, they're very clear about when you'll get the goods, and they're, they're very good at getting the g- the goods to you very quickly. Um, and you know, in a, a, a related example, we were, uh, talking about a, a new user experience on Amazon, uh, today that we'll talk about maybe in another show. But that, that someone on my Twitter feed commented, "Hey, that looks a lot like that site Wish." And my sort of smart aleck response to them was, "Yeah, but Wish promises four to 28-day delivery for goods," and, and Amazon, you know, is, is offering 12-hour delivery for most of those goods.
31:45 And so that, y- you know, that's gonna win every day of the week and twice on Sundays, and it's free to do. Like, do the math and tell customers when you'll give-- uh, when the product will arrive at their door, not how, how many days, uh, you're gonna pay UPS to deliver it. Yeah, and, um, you know, what's interesting is Amazon started and it was in the checkout where you would kind of see it. And, and then they got really good at nailing what they said in the checkout. But then they moved it to the item page, and you probably know this. I, I don't really track this that closely, but I don't usually see that on an item page. You know, it's usually most other e-commerce sites, the big guys, it's, it's still kind of back in the cart. Um, so, uh, eBay tried to do this.
32:27 They had something called, uh, I always used to call it Fast and Furious, but I think it was Fast and Free. Yeah. Uh, where they would, they would kind of give you, uh, a little bit of a range, and then if they were way outside of that range, so they'd say three to six days, and if it ended up being eight, they would refund you your shipping cost kind of thing. Um, but that was almost felt like it was worse because it was kind of like it was such a big range that it was kind of like, well, you know, I'm assuming the worst, and that's pretty bad. And, and, and I think what they, what they were doing is they're taking the, the ship and, and ship from and the to zip and, and kind of doing some math there, but, but ended up being… They took it off, so I assume that it, it had the, the opposite strategy. So if you are gonna… So number one, you know, get really good at it, maybe have it in the checkout.
33:11 And then number two, if you do move it to the item page, you have to be pretty darn good at it, and don't give these wide ranges to give yourself a, a, a huge benefit or escape because the consumer's gonna assume the worst case. Yeah, absolutely. I, I think the pilot you're confusing at eBay is the Fast and Furious was the, the really small pilot where Vin Diesel actually delivered the goods to you. In a car. In… Yeah. Exactly. Um, but yeah, tot- totally agree. And, and Amazon is a best in class example of also creating scarcity on that product detail page. You know, they'll, they'll often tell you, "Order in the next 54 minutes and get it tomorrow." Yeah. Yeah. And this is a little teaser. We're gonna have one of the guys that came up with that program at eBay on the show in the near future.
33:54 That's all I'm gonna say. Oh, nice. I am, uh, uh, titillated to find out more. Good. I'm kidding. I actually know. Um, so my number six, uh, and this is one, uh, that I see a lot, a lot of… So at ChannelAdvisor, we have about 3,000 customers, and some of them, they're all interesting, love them all. Some of the most interesting ones are very entrepreneurial, and they're born on marketplaces, and we call them mid-market. And, um, and one of my favorite examples was these two brothers that were selling golf clubs called Rock Bottom Golf, and they were maybe doing a million dollars when I first met them, and they've grown it to, I think they're on the IR 500 as like 30 or 40 million dollars a year.
34:34 Um, so you know, when they-- when, when people-- when, when these mid-market companies get off a marketplace, it's a great training wheels for e-commerce, and they open up their site. What I've found is when we start talking about their site strategy, they spend 99% of their budgets on acquisition. So they're doing everything you can imagine. You know, they're, they're doing Google. They're buying email lists. They're at shows. They're thinking of opening store-- They're doing everything to acquire customers. So then I'll ask them some basic questions about, you know, "Are you doing email marketing? Are you doing segmentation?" And m-many of-- most of them are doing basic email marketing, but it's kinda like Constant Contact level or MailChimp level. It's just kinda like broadcast.
35:15 Um, they're not thinking about, you know, some of the ways to, um, to also, uh, do like subscription e-commerce and replenishables and all that kind of stuff. Um, so there's-- The good news is, and, and a lot of times you ask them why, and they're like, "Well, you know, the big guys have all this data science they can do, and, and we can't afford that." Um, the-- what's interesting is there's a whole host of companies now that are, are kind of applying a lot of the same logic that, that you could get with cloud-based solutions to retention, um, that, that's out there for acquisition. So, you know, the, the old adage, the, the easiest customer to acquire is the one that's already happy, um, i-is, is very true in e-commerce. And, and we definitely see, you know, even some of the big guys, some of the IR 500 guys do this, but, but we definitely see it in this mid-market where there's this over-focusing on customer acquisition and a not on retention, not enough on retention.
36:06 Um, full disclosure, I'm on the board of a company, Windsor Circle. They focus on this. Um, there's several others, Retention Science. Um, you probably know, uh, more of them than I do. Uh, but it, but it's a really kind of growing field, and you can plug these things into your CRM, and they'll rec- make recommendations, and they'll say, "Hey, if you ran a campaign, um, that, you know, sold, um, you know, uh, Greenies to people that already bought Greenies, and then you ask them to subscribe, this much money could come out of your, your existing customer base." So, so encourage everyone to really think about retention because we so over-focus on customer acquisition. Yeah, absolutely.
36:47 And it, it's funny, you, you look behind the scenes at most e-commerce sites and just look at the n- number of people that are dedicated to the retention experiences versus the customer acquisition experiences, and it's, it's totally obvious that they would over-focus on acquisition 'cause they The just, the majority of the team is focused on it. Yeah. Yeah, but they're … It's funny 'cause they're all focused on CAC and LTV, um, but you don't, really don't get any movement in LTV if you don't do the retention piece. So it's, it's a little outbalanced, and I'm, I'm not exactly sure why, but, but I think, um, you know, companies that, that rebalance that will see really nice dividends paid. Yep. Uh, uh, uh, for sure if you come to me and say, "Hey, I need a short-term, uh, revenue," or, or I'm sorry, uh, gross margin kiss, uh, I'm always gonna say that, you know, we can get a faster ROI from, from conversion and, and, uh, uh, r- retention programs than we can from new customer acquisition.
37:44 In, in the long run, like, the answer is those two activities have to be and not or. Mm-hmm. Um, so my number seven tip is not having a prominent search box on your, uh, e-commerce site, and particularly in y- the header of your e-commerce site. Um, so for the majority of e-commerce experiences, the folks with the highest purchase intent that land on the site are going to use that search box. If they don't parachute into a particular product detail page that they're gonna buy because they came straight from a, a, a Google AdWords or a PLA or something like that, then, uh, then they're, they're going to use search to find the product.
38:25 And those users that use search have much higher buying intent than the browsers that use the traditional menu navigation on most sites. Um, and so that, that search box is some of the most profitable, valuable retail, uh, real estate on the site. And in a shocking number of cases, the search box isn't very prominent or friendly, and it's actually getting worse 'cause a lot of sites are moving to responsive design. They feel they can't fit a, a visible search box in their mobile experience, and then they, they… You know, so they hide it behind an icon, and they just give you a search icon, and they assume users will click that icon and open a search box, which in many cases turns out not to be the case.
39:06 But then they carry that same metaphor to their desktop experience even though there's plenty of re- real estate to have that prominent search box on the desktop experience. So whenever we take search out from behind that hidden icon and show you a big search box, uh, we get more searches and we get higher con- version. And actually, just the size of that box, making it, like, overly visually prominent makes a big difference in conversion. Um, and I guess a, a related pet peeve, a, way, way too many retailers put a big box right above the search box where they're asking you to enter your email address that they would like you to capture.
39:47 Um, and when the, those, when those retailers have, um, on-site analytics, like they're using ClickTale or Crazy Egg or something like that, you, you can find this really funny thing, which is that- A majority of users type their search terms into the email box. 'Cause, uh, I mean, just, you know, people … We just way overestimate how much attention our site is getting, right? Like, these are, these consumers are busy. They're doing other things. They have one baby on their lap. The other baby's crawling across the kitchen floor to the poison under the counter, and they, you know, they, they just have a few seconds to complete that purchase, and so we have to make it really easy for them. And part of that is there should be a big text field for search, and it should be the only big text field on the top of the site because that's become the e-commerce convention.
40:34 Yeah. Someone was pointing out to me, uh, and, and I don't track this on a daily basis, but, uh, target.com, um, now has a search bar that's literally, like, three-quarters the width of the page. It's at the top. Uh, it's, it's tall. It's the only data entry. I think it's even persistent when you scroll. Um, and, you know, so they are already taking your advice. And I, I remember it being kind of small and to the right and a little bit hard to find. Um, and I think, you know, one of my pet peeves on mobile, you mentioned this, but sometimes it's even in the hamburger menu, and I'm like, "Gosh, how do I search this thing?" And, and you know, that's terrible to have it even buried kind of inside of a menu, not even having an icon on the homepage. Yeah. Yeah. Totally agree, and it happens way too often, and it's almost becoming the trend to hide the search box, and I would argue it's only becoming a trend for people that aren't focused on making money on their site.
41:26 Harsh. Okay. Um, so I think we're up to number eight, and, uh, this is one I put on here because I know this is near and dear to your heart. Uh, and this is where you still find a lot of folks, uh, really focused on building an app versus having responsive design. Uh, so, uh, I see this a lot. I, I'm not an expert on this, but it just feels like when you look at all the data, you know, there's eight apps that kind of are in the use set, and then it really falls off from there if you look at the comScore data. And consumers are using the mobile browsers and, um, you know, I think in-- many retailers have put, you know, if they've got X dollars, they're putting ninety percent in the app and ten into responsive design for the mobile web, and I, I think that should probably be reversed for the vast majority of retailers as they think about mobile.
42:14 And, and, you know, it goes without saying mobile is, is super important and, and, uh, you could argue this could be, like, the number one thing that, that people need to think about because they're so far behind on mobile, I think. Yeah. Uh, obviously, I totally agree. I-- uh, one semantic, like, uh, uh, I tend to not focus on responsive design, uh, particularly. Like, that's one tactic in a set of tactics, but I just more generically would say a mobile-optimized site. And so, uh, I think it's a huge mistake to spend a big focus on an app and not have a great mobile-optimized site. And I feel like an app can be a value add thing to have after you've really nailed the mobile-optimized site. But the mobile-optimized site is overwhelmingly the majority of your reach, and that's why it's most important.
42:59 And, you know, you look across the ecosystem of sites, and you still find a bunch of sites that literally don't have a mobile experience at all. So they're pinch and zoo-zoom, or way more frequently, they outsource their mobile site to a third party, and those are usually these m-dot sites, which, you know, Google has said from a search standpoint, they're depreciating and, and is a bad experience for a variety of reasons. And now, like, adding insult to injury to some of these, these, uh, companies that focus too much on app versus their mobile-optimized site, the new thing is they're putting these annoying interstitials on their mobile site trying to get you to download their app. So, you know, you, you in the beginning talked about how important PLAs are, right?
43:41 And a super common experience on the web right now is you, you do a search on Google on your mobile phone, you find a product you wanna buy, you click that product, and it sends you to a site that then pops up a interstitial and says, "Hey, don't buy that product right now. Download our app." And, you know- If the user does download the app, like, A, it, it's, it's, you know, semi a miracle if they're successful 'cause they have to know their Apple ID, which 40-something percent of users don't know. Um, but once they get that app installed and launch that app, it's not taking them to the product they saw on the, the PLA that started this whole j- v- j- uh, this whole voyage, right? So I just, I feel like there are too many retailers that have a silly KPI around app downloads, and that, that causes all of these bad behaviors and missed financial opportunities with mobile-optimized sites.
44:33 Hmm. And why are you so anal about the word responsive versus mobile optimized? Like, what, what's the right way to do it? Yeah. Well, so, um, the language in our industry is sorta imprecise. There's an engineer that invented this, this concept of responsive design, and he really meant it to be a specific set of programming tactics, and so it's essentially, uh, using, uh, uh, CSS and, and a tool called Media Queries to find out what… how wide the viewport of your browser is and adjust the experience to the width of the browser using a fluid layout. And so it's a set of specific tactics, and building a site that just uses those tactics, for me, is not a best practice.
45:16 So for number one, tr- sites that are truly responsive tend to perform really poorly and have bad page load times. Uh, number two, um, there's a lot of times when we actually want a different experience on the desktop than we have on mobile. So I, I would like to show you a different number of search results when you do a, a desktop site, uh, search versus a mobile search. I'd like to show you a different number of product tiles on a category page, um, when, when you're on a mobile experience versus a desktop. Um, and so there's, there's this general notion of mobile-optimized sites which tend to use things like responsive design but also use things like, um, device identification and server-side adaption where, where I just send the, the right bits of code to your browser based on what device I know you have, and that ends up giving you a better ex- a better user experience and faster, faster stuff.
46:14 So, uh, for the, uh, for the presentation layer developers in the audience, I, I don't recommend purely using responsive design. But for most business users, when they say responsive, all they really mean is a mobile-optimized site that has one URL that looks great on a, a desktop browser and on a mobile phone, and I, I totally agree with you that that's very important. Okay. So responsive just isn't enough. You have to really optimize the whole thing. Exactly. Got it. Um- Cool So, uh, going to number nine, it's a lack of social proof. Um, so, uh, social proof is this concept that people wanna know that shoppers like themselves have made this purchase decision before them and had a good outcome.
47:00 And so the most famous version of social proof we have in e-commerce is ratings and reviews, and shockingly, ratings and reviews are still not ubiquitous on e-commerce site. There's still a surprising percentage of sites that are holdout, and, holdouts and don't have ratings and reviews. And I, I'm still shocked when I have to have a, a, a debate with a business owner about the value of ratings and reviews. Like, it's, it's, it's one of the most proven things we have in e-commerce is that ratings and reviews are at the very top of the decision tree for purchases. It's one of the primary reasons that Amazon has a big advantage is because they, they have this enormous repository of ratings and reviews. But I, you know, I would point out there's a bunch of ways to offer social proof.
47:42 Ratings and reviews are just one. A question and answer is another very good one that is underutilized by a bunch of sites. Um, other forms of user-generated content. So, you know, showing, showing pictures of other users that they've uploaded to Instagram or, or to, um, Snapchat, um, of them using this product are all great forms of social proof, um, that for the right type of product can make a lot of sense. And so I'm, I'm constantly surprised when I see sites that are really, like, completely devoid of any flavor of social proof Hmm. The, the s- the thing that, that, you know, I spend so much time on Amazon, one thing I've noticed is all these sites that have reviews, they're so sparsely populated except for some folks like Backcountry seems to have, like, a very aggressive review group.
48:31 Um, and then niche sites like eBags has a lot of reviews and, um, but it's interesting. So if I go, not to pick on anyone specifically, but like Best Buy, Target, Walmart, um, I find they just don't really have the density of reviews that I would get on Amazon. So like video games, if I'm looking at an interesting new game, um, you know, there may be like two reviews. Then you go to Amazon and there's like 50. So, um, yeah. Is it, is it valid to kind of say if, if you're not gonna have people using it, is it-- does it actually have kind of a negative impact? Yeah, absolutely. Um, like poorly executed social proof programs like rating or, ratings and reviews can absolutely have a negative impact on conversion. So the, the least influential aspect of, of ratings and reviews is the average score, right?
49:15 Like people care a lot more how many you got, and they wanna see a diversity of scores. Like that tells them that, that, uh, a lot of people bought that product, right? And so there, there have been these funny studies on Yelp, you know, are people gonna go to the restaurant that's four stars and has 12 reviews or are they gonna go to the restaurant that's three and a half stars and has, uh, 1,200 reviews? And overwhelmingly they'll go to the 1,200 review restaurant because they feel like that's just a much more popular choice. Um, and so that does drive you to a bunch of best practices that are rarely used. If you land on a product detail page that has no reviews, um, don't put a big icon at the top of the page that says zero reviews, zero stars, right?
49:59 Like- Mm-hmm … um, you know, the-- this is all done programmatically, so you can change that content. You can, you can, you know, have a call to action to write a review. Um, very few people write reviews from the product detail pages. So the, the best practices for getting ratings and reviews is to have a outbound marketing campaign, um, you know, targeted at those known purchasers of product to get them to write reviews. And in a perfect world, you'd like to target them sometime after they brought the-- bought the product, not immediately after they bought it. And so you, you see those retailers that have a good density of reviews, it's almost always because they did it on purpose. They have people and resources dedicated to soliciting, um, tho- those reviews.
50:43 Um, but I would, you know, point out, even if you're in a category or you're a retailer where collecting those ratings and reviews is really hard, there are other forms of social proof that you can come up with. Take the one review you have and turn it into a testimonial. Like, because then it looks like you curated them and just showed one review as opposed to, uh, inviting the whole world to write reviews and only one consumer accepted. Or use, use some of the, like, Olapic or Bizarre Voice curation features to show user-generated images instead of reviews. Or, you know, have an active Q&A community. You know, do, do something else to have a good form of social proof, um, is, is first and foremost.
51:24 And then, you know, too much depth for this episode, but in another episode we'll talk, there's a bunch of best practices within ratings and reviews, like letting people see ratings and reviews from users that are more like them, right? Like, so, you know, the example I'll always use is, uh, you know, good golfers don't wanna read my review of golf clubs. They wanna read the reviews of other good golfers. So give them tools to, to know that those reviews are coming from users that are like them and things like that. Hmm. Interesting. Cool. Um, so we're up to number 10, and I have a feeling we're gonna have to go fast 'cause we're, we're, uh, in true Jason and Scot format we're, we're taking like twice as long per item as we probably should. So I'll go through this one fast and, and I call this one, um, n- number 10 here, omni-channel tail wagging the digital dog.
52:10 And two examples of this. And so this is for those retailers that have a store and their, their, you know, a store footprint and their digital and how they're integrating it. Um, uh, I, I had an interesting meeting one time with someone and talking about their e-commerce efforts, you know, kind of a, a, someone that had I think a couple hundred stores, and they were really excited about e-commerce 'cause it was growing. And then I s- I was, you know… I always like to s- kind of see the difference in selection between a, a typical store and online. And I asked the question and they were like, "Oh, it's awesome. You know, we, you know, our, our store has 10,000 items and for the longest time e-commerce had 5,000 and now we just got it up to parity with the store." And I was like, "Wow, that's kinda crazy because most people view, you know, the endless aisle and, and online gives you the ability to have a super set of inventory, not an exact match or a subset."
53:01 Uh, and they were like, "Well then they wouldn't be able to find it in the store." And I was kind of like, "Well, that's, you know… I think, I think consumers could get their head around that 'cause that's how everyone else does it." And it was an interesting kind of argument that their belief was that they wanted store and online parity because they felt like it would confuse the customer to have stuff available online that wasn't in the store. Um, so it just felt like, you know, this, this kind of old school store mentality kind of, you know, really, um, hurting the e-commerce experience. A- another one I see works the other way is a lot of these retailers with, with omni-channel, they have these, these point of sale systems from, I don't know when they're from, like 1965 or something. Uh, and they have poor inventory levels and they all implement buy online pickup in store, which, which is theoretically awesome until you drive to that store, you think you're getting the baseball cleat your son needs, and they're like, "Yeah, I wouldn't try to find it and we really don't have that.
53:56 It, you know, it's probably in someone's cart," is usually what they'll say. Uh, and, and that's, that's a really terrible experience 'cause now I've kinda committed to that experience and, and they haven't dotted the I's and crossed the T's. So, so those are ones I've seen that, you know, they, they really take away from the whole omni-channel experience the way it's supposed to work. Yeah, I, I totally agree. Um, you're, you're calling out the retailers that are just seeking parity, uh, between digital and, and retail. Like, there, there still are major retailers that feel like retail should be fundamentally advantaged over digital, right? So I, I, I feel like in the, the last shareholder meeting, Costco, like overtly said, like, "Hey, we, you know, we're not interested in a lot of these digital tactics that give, uh, consumers a reason not to visit our stores" which seems crazy to me.
54:43 And I still talk to retailers that have, um, buy online pickup in-store experiences or ship-from-store experiences where once the inventory level gets low, um, they, they won't sell it online. And you go, "Oh, that's smart. You're doing that because you have no confidence in your inventory, and you don't want them to come up and have it be empty," right? And there would at least be an, a decent argument against that kind of system. But they … but, but I have heard from multiple retailers, "No, I don't wanna sell my last one of an item to an online customer because then it won't be on the shelf when an in-store customer comes in to buy it." And you're like, wait a minute. You're avoiding selling the item, uh, today in the hopes that you might sell the item tomorrow.
55:26 Wow. Yeah. I guess they just think the store customer is more valuable. Yeah, I mean, it's, it's obviously just a, a mindset that, that, you know, some, some older retailers haven't, haven't, uh, migrated beyond yet. But, uh, you know, I think those, those attitudes are falling by the wayside pretty quickly is the good news. Um, so I will just jump into our five bonus tips, uh, at, at a much higher level of brevity. Um, so number 11, uh, there are still a shocking number of sites that have very poor product photography. Um, in, in the big picture, it turns out that the imagery is the most important element to that product detail page, and that's really the thing that sells the product. And, you know, too often, uh, retailers or brands invest in a bunch of other parts of the experience and under-invest in having great aspirational photography of their products, or they have great pr- photography and don't, don't leverage it in their, their product detail layout Yeah, and this kind of goes into a, uh, a bucket of where, um, again, I'm not a site guy, but, but when I talk to people about their site, they, they always talk about the homepage and the carousel and the curation on the homepage.
56:39 Um, but what's funny is I, I think if you, if you looked at the analytics, you would find that the, the sum of product detail pages is usually much greater than the category pages and the homepage. Um, so, uh, so I think people really under-invest on that product detail page to your point of pr- of product photography, um, just great descriptions, uh, lots of up clear in front. We mentioned sh- you know, free shipping or tell me when it's gonna ship. All that stuff needs to be on that page. And I think people, if there's a pie chart of their attention, they seem to kinda have this human element of putting like 80% onto that homepage because I think as merchants they like feel that that's really gonna where they have this huge impact and all this storytelling and stuff, um, which is great, and I'm sure it, it does move the needle.
57:26 But imagine if you put that storytelling down at the product level. I, I think, I think people have this pyramid, inverted pyramid kind of mentality, and it-- they need to kinda like flip that pyramid and put the product descriptions up top versus the homepage. Yeah. That, that's a great point, Scott, 'cause that, you know, too many people have this metaphor that the, the, um, online is just a digital version of the store, right? And so that homepage is the front door to the store. Like, obviously that's where I should have my best experience because everyone has to walk by the front door. And the problem is the, the metaphor is flawed. Like digital is a store without a roof, and all your users can parachute in to any shelf they want, right? And to your point, the overwhelming majority of users start their experience at some page other than the homepage.
58:11 And, uh, you, you mentioned carousels. Uh, a year ago, I would've put carousels on this list 'cause it turns out that homepage carousels are a totally stupid feature that, that don't work well, um, and that people shouldn't be using. But I've actually stopped even having that, that conversation with clients because, to your point, I don't care. Like, um, it's a big religious argument about the carousel, and it's on the homepage, and it doesn't influence that many people. I'll, I'll, you know, uh, concede that point and let them keep their carousel if they'll give me what I want on the product detail page, and I know in the long run I'll help them make a lot more money, um, by doing that trade-off. Is, is there good data on that? Like how, how much traffic is on the product detail versus the non-product detail pages?
58:54 Is there- So I haven't seen a public study that I can cite for you, but I can tell you that, like, when we're having these conversations with, with, uh, retailers, and particularly when we're contemplating a very meaningful site design, like, one of the things we'll always pull are, um, the, uh, a, a traffic by page template as opposed to by URL, right? So, you know, how many people are coming to the homepage template, how many people are coming to the category template, how many people are coming to the search template, how many people are coming to that PDP template. And the PDP template is by far the highest trafficked template on every site. Now, you know, as y- as you'll note, Amazon has 300 million PDPs, and they only have one homepage.
59:36 So if I look at URLs, which is how, you know, most analytics tools are designed to, to report, it looks like the homepage is the highest traffic page. But when I look at templates, which is a little bit more work to figure out, that, that PDP is much more valuable. Hmm. Cool. That was always my intuition, but it's good to have it reaffirmed. I, I very rarely have seen, uh, it not be the highest volume page, and obviously it- it's mostly not gonna be the highest volume page when there's very few products on the, on the site or where the site inventory is very tertiary and changes a lot. Um, so jumping into my, uh, last one's number, uh, 12 is just fundamentally too much checkout friction.
1:00:20 Um, so, you know, this is where you make or break your financial performance on e-commerce sites. There's a huge amount of cart abandonment and checkout abandonment, and the easiest way to make money is to fix some of that, and fixing that almost always means reducing friction. And so that's, that's, uh, eliminating fields that aren't absolutely necessary. That's, you know, taking all the, the extra fluff off your site when people are in the checkout funnel, right? And you, you go to a bunch of sites and they still have their whole header and footer live on the checkout funnel. And so they're, they're offering you the option to read the About Us or sign up for an email list in the middle of the purchase process, right? And if you think about a store checkout experience, no one would ever do any of those marketing activities in the middle of a store checkout activity.
1:01:08 But, but, you know, people don't seem to think very much of doing it online, and it, it really hurts them. And there's just… You know, we could do a whole show about the 15 deadly sins of checkout friction. Um, but suffice it to say that that's a, a super important area and, and the most common practices in checkout still have a ton of friction in them. Um, so a couple things kind of related to that. Uh, number 13 on my list is pricing surprises, and you alluded to another kind of surprise earlier that until you get to the checkout page, you don't know when you're gonna get the product. Um, but, but very often when you go to that, that checkout page is also the first time you see sales tax.
1:01:48 It's often the first time you see shipping charges, and all of those surprises are the number one reason for, for checkout abandonment. And so no one should ever get to that checkout experience and learn something new that adversely affects their, their interest in purchasing from you. If you have any bad news, if you are gonna charge for shipping, you need to make sure they know that before they add the product to cart. If you're gonna charge tax, you need to, uh, give them visibility to that, um, before they go into the checkout experience 'cause surprises will kill you in terms of checkout conversion. Um, one that I've blogged about before, uh, is a… there's a very specific field on checkout which is super expensive, and that's the promo field, right?
1:02:30 So irony, a bunch of sites, as we talked about earlier, you know, don't have a very big prominent box on the, on, on their, uh, site header for search. Um, on the flip side, most site checkouts have a giant prominent box for promo field Um, and the majority of people purchasing don't have a promo code. And so you're sort of saying to someone in the middle of checking out, "By the way, you're the only sucker paying full price for this. Everyone else has a promo code that they're typing into this field and getting some kind of discount," right? And the, you know, a huge percentage of shoppers when they see that blank promo field immediately abandon your site and go to RetailMeNot or go to Google and do a search for, for promo codes And, you know, that, that starts this whole cycle of, of bad outcomes that don't have them coming back to your site.
1:03:17 Um, and so you certainly need a way for users to, to enter a promo code and do that with low friction, but having a giant field is not the way to do it. Like, so we very often, we have like a l- a link that says, you know, a promo code and, and when you click it, it expands to give you a text box as opposed to showing you a big empty text box that you feel bad leaving empty And it, and then, uh, number 15, my sort of final, uh, of the deadly sins is just having a site that is too slow. Um, and that's, you know, uh, having pages that load too slowly. Um, and again, we could do a whole show on page performance and how to measure it and how to set goals and all those things.
1:04:00 But suffice it to say that most sites are very slow and on average are getting slower every year. And a big part of that is that all of these sites are adding more and more third-party utilities and third-party tags to the site, and all those vendors have this, the, tell this w- little, um, half-truth that I call the biggest lie in e-commerce, which is it's just one tag, it has no effect on page performance. Um, because I, I visit these sites and there are 60 of those tags and they absolutely have a, a cumulative effect on page performance. And these days when the majority of our traffic is coming from mobile, that performance penalty h- becomes enormous.
1:04:42 Like having 60 third-party tags on your site on a mobile, um, experience is deadly because each DNS lookup over the cellular network is much slower than it is over a, a hardline connection. And it, it just cumulatively, more people are moving to mobile and as a result, uh, the average page load time is getting worse every year for e-commerce, and those slower loading pages, uh, do not convert as well. Yeah, and, and Google factors that into their mobile SEO algorithm and they'll, you know, they'll put you in the penalty box if you're taking a long time to load. And, um, an interesting news item I saw is eBay's actually working on, um, you know, experimenting with re-platforming essentially onto this Google AMP platform, which is primarily for, for, uh, content sites, but now you're starting to see more dynamic sites look at it and say, "Hmm, if we use that," uh, and, and, you know, eBay's obsessed with SEO, so I think there must be some hook there where they, they probably said to Google, "What, what else can we do to improve our SEO?"
1:05:43 And Google's like, "Well, you know, the fastest mobile thing is this AMP framework we have where, where essentially Google hosts the page and, and it makes it super snappy." And Facebook has their own program and so it's gonna be interesting down the road if, if you play this out to the extreme, will e-commerce platforms have to almost be quote-unquote replatformed or, or kind of shared across these mobile networks that, that are even that much faster? Yeah, absolutely. The, the, the mobile accelerated pages, the map pages, which I think is what you're talking about, um, is a, a new technology that's very promising, and it's a little tricky right now to figure out how to use it for the, the kind of dynamic pages that, that most e-commerce sites have.
1:06:23 But, um, there are lots of other technologies that are being introduced into the browser, um, and into the web standards every day that enable us to make faster pages. And the challenge is you just go to most site owners, and they don't have dedicated staff or dedicated resources or dedicated sprint cycles to improving page speed. And frankly, very few, um, site operators are even very savvy about how to measure page speed or how to set goals for page speed. And, you know, it's the old joke, like, you know, it's hard to lose weight if you don't have a scale. Um, in, in most cases, like, retailers just need to get smarter about how to set he- uh, goals and KPIs for page speed and then dedicate people to achieving those goals.
1:07:07 The, the good news is ev- all the tactics you need to achieve them are out there. It just has to be a priority. Yeah, absolutely. So that wraps up our 15 deadly sins. Um, and as per usual, we're, we're slightly over time. Uh, but Scott, next week, uh, I think we're gonna record the show on Sep- on, uh, July 12th, and that is a special date, is it not? It is. That is Amazon Prime Day. So it is kind of a, a bit of a secret, and Amazon just around the 4th announced the Amazon Prime Day this year will be on the 12th. Um, so either on the 12th or early on the 13th we'll record a show kind of talking about what we saw and give some data and, um, some, you know, how did it go.
1:07:50 Last year was, was really interesting. Um, it exceeded, I think, every seller's expectations, but a liar- a lot of buyers were not happy because there were all these deals and they sold out by like 9:00 AM. Um, so, you know, there was, there was a, a, um, a lack of deals aft- later in the day, especially on the West Coast, and, and there was a little bit of social backlash. So this year it looks like Amazon has, the numbers I'm seeing are hundreds of thousands of deals. So I think they learned a lot last year, and they're gonna be spreading them out. And they've more than double, doubled or tripled the third-party participation in the deals that are gonna be rolling out. So it's gonna be really interesting to see how it goes. Last year, uh, it was as big as Black Friday for, for a lot of our customers, which was pretty mind-blowing considering usually this time of year is really, really boring in the world of e-commerce.
1:08:34 So, um, it's interesting to see if they can kind of turn this into a de facto like Singles Day kind of thing that, that Alibaba created. Um, so far it, it, you know, with one data point it, uh, it's off to a good start and it'll be interesting to see how it does this year. Yeah, I, uh, I'm very bullish on Amazon's Prime Day. Like, I think they're gonna be much bigger and better than last year and have better overall consumer sentiment. So, um, assuming I'm right on that, the thing I'm gonna be really interested in watching is how other retailers respond. So, you know, last year a bunch of other retailers tried to jump on the bandwagon and ironically sort of celebrate Amazon's 20th anniversary with them. Um, and it's gonna be interesting to see whether they double down on that tactic and try to, you know, uh, ride on Amazon's coattails on Prime Day or whether they take some other tactic.
1:09:22 Yeah. Yeah, we'll have to see. Yeah. Um, so with that, we're gonna wrap episode 35, and I will remind our users that, uh, if you haven't taken the opportunity yet, we'd love it for you to go to iTunes and write us a review, going back to that social proof point. Um, and if you'd like to continue the dialogue, we'd encourage you to visit the official Jason and Scot Show Facebook page and make a post, and we'll be happy to chat with you about any of the topics we covered on this week's show or anything else that you're interested in. Um, so with that, I will wish all our listeners a happy e-commercing. Thanks everybody. You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show.
1:10:02 For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes and please leave a review.
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed