Welcome to The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News!
Dec. 5, 2019

EP202b - Cyber 5 Recap with Adobe's Taylor Schreiner (audio repaired)

EP202b - Cyber 5 Recap with Adobe's Taylor Schreiner (audio repaired)
EP202b - Cyber 5 Recap with Adobe's Taylor Schreiner (audio repaired)
The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News
EP202b - Cyber 5 Recap with Adobe's Taylor Schreiner (audio repaired)

EP202b - Cyber 5 Recap with Adobe's Taylor Schreiner (audio repaired)

Support the Show:

The Jason & Scot Show as been nominated for "Best Retail Media Resource" by the VIP awards. We'd appreciate your support, if you could take a minute to vote for us.

Adobe Recap

Taylor Schreiner is the Director of Adobe Digital Insights. He uses Adobe's data to give us a recap of the Cyber 5 (the five shopping days from Black Friday through Cyber Monday, this year Nov 29 - Dec 2).

Adobe Holiday Dashboard

  • Thanksgiving 11/28 - $4.2B (up 14.5% YoY) below forecast of $4.4B
  • Black Friday 11/29 - $7.4B (up 19.6% YoY) below forecast of $7.5B
  • Saturday - 11/30 - $3.6B (Up 18% YoY) at forecast
  • Sunday - 12/1 - $3.8B
  • Monday - 12/2 - $9.4B (up 19.7% YoY) at forecast

Don't forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.

Episode 202 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded on Wednesday December 4th, 2019.

http://jasonandscot.com

Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, Chief Commerce Strategy Officer at Publicis, and Scot Wingo, CEO of GetSpiffy and Co-Founder of ChannelAdvisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.

0:02 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, Chief Commerce Strategy Officer at Publicis, and Scot Wingo, CEO of Get Spiffy and co-founder of ChannelAdvisor. Here are Jason and Scot Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show. This is episode 202, being recorded on December 4th, 2019. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg. And as usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Jason, and welcome back Jason and Scot Show listeners.

0:42 We are in the thick of holiday 2019, and are really excited to have back on the show, uh, Adobe. And I think this is the fourth time. Uh, can you fact check, check me on that, Jason? Have one of the interns, uh, check that? I, I, I actually had one of the interns send you that number, so yes, it's right. Good. All right. Pre, pre-fact-checked. We're getting pretty, uh, reliable here at The Jason Scott Show. Um, this year representing Adobe, we have Taylor Schreiner. He is the director of Adobe Digital Insights. Welcome, Taylor. Thanks for having me, guys. Appreciate it. Uh, we are excited to have you, Taylor. And a sort of tradition on the show, um, we always like to give, uh, listeners a little bit of background. So can you kind of share with us, um, some highlights of your background and, and what your role is at Adobe?

1:25 Sure. Um, so I was the 52nd best chess player in Utah in fifth grade. Uh, and then from there I went into a career in retail. Uh, no, I, I went, uh, to work on internet insights about 15 years ago with some of the major internet players, um, across the industry, and I've been doing that for a decade and a half. And then about three years ago I found my dream job here, uh, at Adobe running Adobe, Adobe Digital Insights. We get to tell these amazing stories about how the digital world works, and we get to tell people about how tech and companies and events are changing their digital lives and companies about how those same trends are affecting how they need to run their businesses.

2:07 And we get to talk about retail, we get to talk, talk about travel, we get to talk about a whole host of different things. Uh, and it's been fantastic, and I get to work with some amazing data scientists and analysts to develop these insights, and it lets me have conversations like this one with you guys. So it's, it's a perfect gig and I love it. Awesome. So to recap, this is sort of a career highlight for you right now. Yeah, I like to, I like to go from highlight to highlight, but this one- Yeah. Yeah … I'm loving it. Pe- uh, pinnacle. I like it. Um, and I'm- I think Jason means being on our podcast. He, he wants an explicit answer on that one. Oh, yes. I, let, let me give you a quotable thing. Being on the Jason and Scot Show is a career highlight, uh, to date. Boom. That… Boom. Yeah, you'll see that in the, in the preview show pretty soon here.

2:49 Uh, and I'm sure all this insight stuff is gonna be super fascinating, but I, I have to know first if you've kept up your chest at all… chess at all. Uh, only recently. My eight-year-old has started to learn to play chess, and he's creeping up on being able to beat me, and that is, uh, not acceptable. So- Yeah … it- That's a losing battle. You could probably keep ahead of him for a little while, but I, I think, uh, there's a, a natural progression there that's working against you. I'm afraid so. Um, awesome. Well, let's jump into the data. Uh, so we talk about your data a lot on the show. We already did a, a, an episode this week in fact where we talked about some of your data, and it always falls on me to describe your data set and I'm sure I'd butcher it. So, um, here's a chance to kind of refresh our audience from the horse's mouth.

3:31 Can you tell us a little bit about, um- Uh, what the data set is and, and, uh, how you use it Sure. So we build a model of US online retail sales based on trillions of website visits, based on tens, in fact, I think over hundreds of millions of SKUs, based on data from thousands of different companies all across the US, across a, you know, a variety of device types, OSs, uh, and other information. And we use that to, to plan out, especially on a day by day and occasionally hour by hour basis, uh, how we think that that season's gonna go.

4:12 So we predict it all, and then we go back and we track, uh, on a daily and, again, sometimes hourly basis how, uh, US online retail sales go. Uh, so it's a big data lift, and we spend all year getting to this point, uh, to be able to talk, uh, in almost real time about how, uh, how those sales are going Got it. And so just to make sure my understanding is correct, so, um, there are a ton of, of major e-commerce sites that use an analytics product called Adobe Analytics, which is, uh, if you go back far enough, formally, uh, Omniture. Mm-hmm. And so it- the, the core of your data set is an aggregated view of all of those customers that are using that analytics tool for, for their e-commerce sites.

4:58 Do I have that right? Yes. So the majority of the data that we, we've got, and this is not including, uh, some data from the recent Magento acquisition, so that adds a whole other d- set of data sources, as well as some other things we talk about around the periphery. But the core of the data, uh, that we work with are data from opted in, so companies that have chosen to share data with us, um, uh, and for, for value that we give them. And so that shared data, anonymized before we even touch it and aggregated at a very high level, so we can talk about these macro trends. But yes, that's where the data comes from, Adobe Analytics. Perfect. And then, um, uh, and that was… You already answered my follow-up question.

5:38 W- uh, in the core data set, you have not integrated any of the new data that you might have access to from Magento, and if I have it right, you're also at this point not really using data from the rest of the Adobe Marketing cloud. Mm. Well, I wouldn't necessarily say that. Oh, okay. So we do, uh, we do a lot of… So we have integrated a lot of the Magento data. Um, it allowed us to look at things like shipping and returns th- that, uh, were new, were new sort of angles for us, and it certainly gives us this amazing view into that tail set, uh, as well as some of the bigger players in terms of e-commerce. Uh, but we also, uh, you know, use the Marketo data, formerly Marketo data, to look at some of our marketing channel information.

6:20 Uh, AdCloud, which used to be TubeMogul, uh, which I worked for, um, we used them for some advertising data around Thanksgiving. So we, we bring in all the pieces- Oh, cool … um, but, you know, not all of it necessarily goes to that top line number as you, as you say. Sure. And then, um, i- you kind of alluded to this, but you're not just trying to report on trends from Adobe customers. You're, you're using some, uh, advanced math, and, uh, uh, you do… Adobe customers represent a big chunk of the market, but then you in- interpolate, uh, what the total market is based on, on the, the subset that you see. Do I have that correct? You do. I could spend a whole other podcast on how we do that. Yeah. But it's- Let's not do that … let's not do that. But let, let's just call it cool math.

7:01 Yes. It's cool math. We do cool math. Yeah. And then the other thing that comes up a lot, and I think you guys are, um, really good in this as well, like very often we talk last year versus this year, and when a lot of vendors report their data- The customers they have this year are different than the customers they have last year. So when they're, when they're talking year over year growth and things like that, it's usually not perfect apples to apples. Um, but because you're, you're, um, trying to normalize the data for the whole market before you do it, when, when you say there is a 20% growth this year versus last year, um, that, that's a pretty accurate number. All right. Dwight? Yeah, I think my answer to that is yep. You said that really well.

7:42 Um, but that's- Perfect. You can use that in your highlights. Now we've, we've reciprocated. Awesome Cool. So, uh, now that Jason's extracted his pound of flesh- … let's, uh, let's jump in at a high level. How, how would you view holiday 2019 shaping up? I, uh, I think it's been quite strong. It has been strong all through today. In fact, uh, if you'll let me, I'll, I'll give you, uh, data as of this morning. So yesterday's numbers through the 3rd of December, we saw $84.7 billion in online retail sales, and that's up 14.8% on, uh, last year for the same period. So that's a little faster than our aggregate prediction, but the way that the model is trending that out puts us, uh, on target to be about 14.1%, roughly on our, uh, predicted path for, for the season.

8:36 So, and then 14.1%, I mean, some listeners and people who visited our website will see that last year was particularly strong. That was a 16% growth year. But if you look back a few years, you know, s- 2016, 2017, this is sort of on par with those growth rates, but on a much larger base now as we head into, you know, almost $150 billion in sales. So it's, it's pretty huge. Um, the, the other tidbit of information I can give, uh, listeners about yesterday, uh, Giving Tuesday, is that it was a $3.3 billion day, which is amazing. We're starting to count $3 billion days the way that, uh, when I started in this gig, we, we counted $1 billion days.

9:17 So they're coming fast and furious. Now, that's only up about 11% on last year, so, uh, it, it, it leaves us open to the question of, you know, are consumers… Have consumers, you know, taken all these early deals, uh, and, uh, won't be spending later, or are they, uh, just taking a break on Tuesday and, and ready to get back at it today? Yeah. Let, let's, um… So it sounds like we're growing kind of 14% year over year. Um, if you, if you kind of look at the shape of the holiday so far, I know you can't predict, or, well, you- Mm-hmm … you don't know when it's gonna happen, uh, here towards the end. It- it's kind of gotten this, what I would call a U-shape, where it's being more front-end loaded than back-end loaded. So the front end is people that, that have their act together and, and jump on the deals.

10:00 Uh, and then the back end is like Jason and I, where we're like, "Holy cow, uh, holiday is here. We should do some shopping on the 23rd." Um, Yeah. Yeah. The, uh, it… Does that, does that kind of what you've seen, and is it getting more pronounced? Can you tell, you've seen the front part of the curve. Um- Yeah … I saw some data that said, like, Veterans Day was unusually large, and, and, like- Mm-hmm … early November days were larger. Are you guys seeing that? Uh, absolutely. So, uh, we saw… I was just pulling some of these numbers for this conversation. You know, if you look from the begin, what we call the beginning of the season, so the 1st of November, roughly, right, to, um, to that Wednesday, we, that whole, to the Wednesday before Thanksgiving, that whole period grew at about 15%. So that's, and that was about a point and a quarter faster than we would have predicted.

10:44 So in aggregate, we saw a big, uh, li- we saw a lift above what we would have expected in that early season. And that seems to be attributable to a bunch of, uh, earlier deals. We had something similar happening last year, but it's even stronger now, where discounts came earlier in electronics and computers and televisions. Uh, we also saw that, you know, last year, Thanksgiving itself was a breakout day, where you had this spike, and suddenly Thanksgiving was growing faster than any other day. That spike seems to have moved back now to Wednesday, where the Wednesday before Thanksgiving was growing at about 22%. And I think, again, that's attributable to, uh, a lot of deals moving forward, uh, in time.

11:25 So, and to your point, that really changes the shape of the season. You know, we used to basically tell a story of like, "Look, everything is sort of lifting around that Cyber 5 set of days. The Cyber 5 set of days is getting a disproportionate share." Um, that's still true, but we're seeing sort of a, a shift back to earlier sales, uh, this year. And that might be, have to do with the calendar, but I think it is actually a broader trend of, of thinking about these, uh, pre-holiday sales and pre-holiday promotions as being things that happened earlier, both for retailers and consumers Yeah, it's interesting to me. It's like, um, it feels like in the beginning of the season, you know, there's, there's a lot of retailers under stress and have to have a good holiday, and there's this kind of winner-take-all men- mentality.

12:14 And so we both see more aggressive promotions and discounting at the beginning of the season, and I f- I feel like we also see more digital marketing, like more investment in ads and things like that, uh, that really goose the front half of that U. Um, and then I have a hypothesis. We'll see if it plays out. But, uh, you know, of course Amazon has gone to faster and faster shipping, right? And so this, you know, this'll be- Mm-hmm … the first big holiday with, with sort of standard one-day delivery. Um, and in various forms, Walmart, Target, and to some extent even Best Buy have all been forced to sort of match that fast shipping. So, you know, not that long ago we would've had this, this very gentle ramp down of sales as we'd hit shipping cutoffs and people would stop buying goods, and then they'd just be doing BOPUS or gift cards or things like that because they'd run out of time to get the gifts before the end of- Mm-hmm … uh, be, you know, in time for holiday.

13:10 But now everyone can be a procrastinator like Scott and I because so many of the vendors will ship so fast. So it feels like, like all of those things conspire together to make the very beginning and the very end these, these, uh, anomalous spikes or that U shape. I think that's, that's gonna be absolutely true, and this, this year in particular with this shift to more buy online pickup in store, um, or click and collect behavior and to these accelerated shippings, uh, it's gonna, it's gonna make people think they can wait longer in a season where they can't really wait longer. To your point, you know, it's, it's three weeks away before even those things are gonna be, uh, almost too close to Christmas to shop for, to, to, to purchase with.

13:50 And so, you know, I think, uh, we'll see that ramp up at the end as people start to panic a little bit. Uh, and that's also why, by the way, you see, uh, jewelry discounts be really strong on, like the 20th. Everybody who's panicked and realized they haven't gotten anything starts, uh, starts looking for something nice and blingy to, to give as a gift Interesting. I was always assuming that people just misbehaved right before the holidays and therefore- You, you may have a better hypothesis than I do on that one. I- Yeah. I have no- I would strongly- … personal experience or data to support that. Just to be clear, honey, if you're listening. Um, the, uh, uh, I do wanna jump in, uh, to the Cyber 5, uh, though. Um, so we just got through those.

14:31 Uh, can you kind of give us a recap for, for specifically how, how Thursday through Monday played out? Sure. So, uh, overall it's about $28 billion of online purchases, uh, over that same timeframe, and that's 10, almost $11 billion of purchases through smartphones. So e- overall it was quite strong, almost 18%, if you look at those five days over last year, five days. Uh, with peaks even on Black Friday and Cyber Monday, which always kind of blows my mind because I get the question every year, "Are these days too big, uh, to really grow, outgrow the rest of the season?" And I keep thinking, well, maybe next year they will be, and it's not, not the case.

15:14 People not, not only are moving more online, but they're really focusing a lot of those purchases in increasing amounts, uh, on those big days. Uh, so you know, Cyber Monday, for instance, this year was $9.4 billion. So we're almost gonna guarantee that we're gonna see a $10 billion day, uh, barring anything serious happening, next year on Cyber Monday, which is, uh, incredible. And over a third of that, those purchases are really coming on phones. Uh, so you're seeing people not only window shop, but actually make purchases on those big days, uh, on their phones especially. Uh, not so much Cyber Monday when people go sit in front of their computers at work, but you know, people under the table at, on Thanksgiving, uh, people on Black Friday will pretend to ha- hang out with their family, but, but buying one or two things anyway.

16:02 Uh, that's really been a mobile story. And then the other story of the, of the weekend, which, uh, I always… You know, you were talking about how buy online, pick up in store, um, is a, you know, is a, is a, is a capability that might drive people to wait a little longer for their purchases. But nonetheless, we saw a big bump in BOPUS activity even on that, that major weekend, uh, with about 40% more, uh, purchases than we had, than we saw last year over the same time frame. So out- outstripping overall growth and really, um, pushing BOPUS share up. Interesting. And so, and if I think of it from a historical perspective, you know, 10 years ago, uh, fewer people had r- reliable internet, and so, like, you know, Cyber Monday… Or we'll call it 20 years ago.

16:50 Mm-hmm. Cyber Monday became a big thing. Like, we'd all, uh, enjoy Thanksgiving. We'd go to work on Monday, steal our boss's internet, and go shopping. Right. Um, and so th- th- that was, like, the one-day spike, and then as, as, uh, you know, we all became, uh, ubiquitously online, uh, the traditional big shopping day, Black Friday, also became a big online day. And in fact, I feel like there often are these forecasts that, that Friday is eventually gonna surpass Monday online, which, uh, seems like hasn't happened yet, right? Do I- But yeah, but- … have that right? It hasn't, hasn't gotten there yet. Yep. Uh- And then… Oh, go ahead. Oh, no, finish your thought I was gonna say, and then increasingly those other days in the weekend have grown to be extraordinarily meaningful.

17:35 So like, you know, frankly, 10 years ago we'd talk a lot about Cyber Monday. I actually don't care as much specifically about the results on Cyber Monday because it, it feels like the, the aggregate results of the Cyber five is much more, um, uh, important and indicative of how holiday is going than any one day in the, in, in that block nowadays. Is that a- I- … a good way to look at it or am I being shortsighted? No, I would agree with that. And I think what, what's always fascinating to me, and is, uh, you know, topic of a longer conversation, is that to your point, there's no need necessarily now for Cyber Monday. Everybody's not only got good internet access at home, they've got good internet, internet access in their hand.

18:15 Uh, but we have become so habituated to that day being a major sales day an- both on the consumer and the retailer side, that it continues to grow. Uh, and the psychology of this often drives, um, a lot of the behavior even beyond the pricing or the deals or anything that our model might pick up. Uh, so to your point, you know, I, I think if you just looked at the data you might think, "Hey, look, this is all gonna smooth out a little bit." But people continue to, to think about those days as the big days to go shopping, uh, online and offline. Interesting. So you're saying people might be willing to go shopping even when it's slightly irrational. Interesting. No. Thank God for that. It's a new, fine thing I, I came up with. Yeah, yeah.

18:55 Yeah. Um, and along those lines it feels like folks have been trying to, um, kind of make hay in some of those other days. Like for a while now that, that, uh, Saturday has been Small Business Saturday. Mm-hmm. Um, and I think there's a couple people trying to grab Sunday now too, right? 'Cause I'm trying to- Yeah … uh- Super Sunday has a, a bunch of different cuts at it. Exactly. And, and th- and they are big days now. We're talking about, um, you know, they're, they're three and a half, almost $4 billion each, and it's, it's massive. Any other day of the year and, uh, we would be having a conversation about a particular $3 billion day, but they just come fast and furious, uh, between November and Christmas Do you, do you have a, at the end of the season, um, everyone has a different word.

19:46 There used to be like a free shipping day, and then I think it's called Green Day or something. But do you guys- Mm. What is, what is last year, like was there a bump, and is it, how does that compare to like Cyber Monday? So we s- we would see, uh, ramps toward the end of last year, and I don't have the, the last little couple days, um, uh, to hand, but they were more… They're closer to sort of Super Saturday and, uh, uh, or even smaller than that in the sort of $2 billion range. Um, as you head in there, they're not… They, they weren't as big a ramp last year, but to our earlier point, I'm really curious to see if we don't see a big bump, uh, come to the 20th or 19th. Yeah. It… This has just kind of came to me, so it's, if you don't have an answer, I understand.

20:28 Sure. So, so last year we grew 16%, this year we're growing 14. W- where do you think that 2% delta is coming from? Is it just kind of across the board, or is it a certain category underperforming? Do you have any, any thoughts on that? Uh, I have some thoughts, and I think it'll be a really interesting conversation to have in a few weeks. Uh, but the, the, um, the… So couple things. First of all, you know, the, the model's telling us 14-ish. Um, my gut says there might be more upside risk there than downside. So be- some of that gap might close. Um, what seems to be the case so far in the data is that there was an, a proportionally even bigger push into the early season, um, because of, uh, um, as people moved into Thanksgiving and, and on, on, um, on that Wednesday, some of those deals moved forward.

21:21 But honestly, if you're just, if you're just looking at the math, which is, uh, what we particularly are good at, the, just pushing the season shorter between Thanksgiving and Christmas is about a billion dollars, which is, uh, you know, 50 basis, 50 of those basis points, uh, or more, sorry, on its own. So between a little bit of margin of error and then some of those basis points and, uh, and, uh, a- and not the shock of all these earlier deals that got everybody accelerated, I think between those three things you kind of get to, uh, the delta. Okay. So the jury's still out, kind of depends on how the models perform and, and how people react to those missing days. Yeah, exactly. Uh, if we get a big surge and everybody sort of just comes off of, uh, of, off of S- Cyber Monday and thinks, "Gosh, I gotta sprint toward, uh, toward, toward wherever the last shipping day is," then, you know, it'll be very different than everybody feeling like, "Gosh, I, I blew my budget, uh, on all those early deals."

22:16 Yeah. Cool. Uh, it wouldn't be a Jason and Scott show if we didn't talk a little bit about Amazon. Um, and I, I understand if you can't talk specifically about any one retailer or, or whatnot. Um, but any insights into how Amazon's holiday is going? They, they put out their annual release that said something like vague like, "We sold hundreds of millions of dollars," and, you know, "Third parties did great." So, so it always befuddles Wall Street when they, they kind of put out these puzzle boxes for them to figure, figure out. Yeah, you get JJ Abrams doing their press releases. No, I, uh, yeah, as, as you said, uh, you know, it wouldn't be your podcast if you didn't ask about Amazon. It wouldn't be a Adobe Response if I didn't say we don't talk about particular retailers. But what I can say, uh, is we do track the, the biggest and the smallest against each other, really looking at, um, especially as you see two big trends, right?

23:05 Big… A lot of discussion about big, big, uh, retailers pushing, uh, click and collect, pushing one-day shipping, having great deals, uh, and a lot of democratization of, uh, e-commerce as, you know, a lot of platforms, you know, we have a platform as well as others that makes that much easier for people to, to bring businesses to the market. So those two, two forces are going on. Um, in the, on the average, uh, you, you see big companies outperforming smaller ones, uh, in terms of growth. So if you compare November, an average day in November to an average day in October, for the big companies, they're up about… And these are sort of billion-dollar plus companies, they're up about 87%, uh, in sales, whereas the smaller companies in the 50 million and, and lower range, so these are the small ones, are up only about 43%.

23:51 And some of that is, that's coming from at least, from the data at least, it's coming from two things. One is, uh, the larger companies are, are much better at, uh, mobile conversion, so they're 80% better at taking a customer and bringing them to purchase on a phone than, than the smaller companies, and consequently they get about 10% more of their share of their revenue, uh, from those phones. And the way that I s- I read the data is that if you're a consumer and you are going to a big retailer, that big retailer has a number of advantages, including a wide set of products, a wide set of promotions, r- generally really good AI at connecting you with those promotions, and a really slick speedy checkout process that they've, they've worked on really hard.

24:35 And for the smaller companies, they obviously don't have as quite as wide a selection. Some of them haven't, um, figured out how to, how to turn customers, uh, into buyers a- as swiftly. Uh, the, but the last thing I would say, and this is I think the most im- important part about this, is I am talking about the averages. So, you know, in the, in the smaller companies there's a lot of entry, a lot of people trying things out, um, and a lot of exit. And, uh, there are within that average a huge number of small companies who are just blowing the doors off. It's just that on average, uh, they're not doing as well as the, as the very big ones Sure, that makes sense. Uh, um, you, you talked a little bit about omni-channel. I wanted to d- jump into that for just a second.

25:15 Th- that seems like an area where, um, in particular, a lot of the big companies have made major visible investments in their infrastructure. Mm-hmm. Um, so of course, you know, Target bought Shipt, and then now that's heavily integrated, and they have, um, rich, like, same-day delivery and curbside pickup options available a- across all their mobile platforms. Uh, Walmart, you know, has, has done a bunch for general merchandise omni-channel, but even more for grocery, um, and curbside pickup and, and all of, of those things. Even, um, uh, the, uh, Amazon, you know, although much more, uh, footprint are starting to get a little better at omni-channel with their, with their small footprint of retail stores.

25:59 Um, is any indication if that's paying off? Like, are you guys able to, to see an omni-channel transaction versus a pure digital transaction? And is there any… Like, is the rate of growth of those omni-channel transactions faster than overall? Oh, yeah. So we're, we're seeing, you know, as we said, we're, we're roughly in the 14 to 16% range, uh, in growth for the overall marketplace. But for buy online, pickup in store, for BOPIS, I love that word, um, it's up at, like, 40% for the season. So it's way outstripping, uh, overall sales. And what's also really interesting is we see that… And this has a little bit to do with large versus small, but we see that, um, companies that offer, uh, BOPIS, uh, are 20% better at converting than companies that don't offer BOPIS.

26:47 So people are coming there, uh, specifically for that capability, uh, or at least finding that capability incredibly valuable to them. And my, my thought on this is, you know, look, we've got a phone in our hand that has moved the display window experience into your hand. It's moved the checkout experience into your hand. And, you know, everybody just wants to move that fulfillment, that, that one thing in between, the fulfillment experience, uh, closer and closer. And, you know, one-day shipping is great, but, uh, sometimes it's just easier if you drive down in about 10 minutes and go pick up the thing you, you just saw and knew you wanted Oh, and plus these guys are, um, you know… What we see in the survey data too is that this is good for the brick-and-mortar stores.

27:32 That not only are they, you know, as you guys know, that not only are they making… people making purchases online and sitting in the car and getting that, that pickup, they're also going to the store and buying another thing because they thought of it on the drive, and that, that makes a big difference to, for, uh, for the brick-and-mortar stores as well. Very cool. Uh, um, you- you've hit on this a little bit, but let's talk about mobile. So, um, do you guys… When I talk about mobile, I, I tend to take tablet out and, and it seems like you do too. Mm-hmm. You seem to be- Yeah … explicitly calling out smartphone. Um, so, so you mentioned, I think, I can't remember, was it Black Friday? You said it was a third of the sales came from mobile. Um- Yeah … talk us through any other kind of insights on, on the mobile side. Sure.

28:12 Uh, so to your point, we try, we've tried in pr- prior years to be really disciplined about mobile versus smartphone. We've been a little lax this year because tablets are, are decreasing share. So, uh, smartphone really has started across that, that one-third, uh, threshold on major days in terms of dollars spent. It was always, or has been for the past couple of years, the majority of visits were coming from phones, so people were doing… initiating their shopping. We had this challenge in, in prior years, and still to some degree do now, that they weren't closing the deal, uh, from that mobile visit, either not at all or going to the desktop to purchase. That gap continues to close. In fact, on Christmas, uh, of this year, we expect to have the first day in the US where m- the majority of online purchases actually come through a phone, as people aren't going to their computers.

29:01 When their families are around, they're actually using their phones to make that, that purchase. Mm. Okay. And the, the, the things that are driving this, at least in the data that we see, are, uh, two really interesting and related points. One is that time per visit is going down rapidly. So consumers are coming, they're not messing around. Um, they're ex- looking for and expecting, uh, the product that they, uh, that they came for, at least a product to buy. And some of that is gonna be, uh, in part because, you know, connection speeds have gotten faster, screens have gotten bigger, processes are faster. But also retailers have gotten much better at streamlining that process on the mobile phone. And consequently, the amount of money that people are spending per minute or per second on a mobile phone, it continues to skyrocket month after month, year after year, as people just get faster at making those purchases, especially with a lot of the new checkout options that make, make it easier than, you know, say, trying to type in the numbers on your credit card.

30:02 That's, uh, fascinating. The, um, that would be cool if, uh, Christmas did end up being the first, like, majority mobile day. Um, I was also curious, you mentioned something earlier, um, that it sounds like that, I call it a mobile gap when traffic's high but conversion's lower, and it sounds like that mobile gap is getting lower for big companies, and you cited a couple reasons why that might be. Um, in general, do you feel like that mo- like, is that mobile gap, um, getting narrower across the board, or is it only for large companies that they're, they're being successful closing that gap? Well, I think large companies, a- again, it has to do with sort of the, the broad, um, uh, a r- you know, array of, there's a much broader array of outcomes in smaller companies than in larger ones, so it's harder to paint them with the, with the same brush.

30:51 The large companies obviously have focused on this, figured it out. They can track per second, per user, per region, per item, um, how much time consumers are willing to tolerate, and they can shave those things down, uh, if nothing else, w- by just bringing more machines online. Can- uh, smaller businesses don't always have that, um, uh, ability, but the, the platforms, um, one of which Adobe has, but the, you know, the, the other platforms for e-commerce, um, are making that whole process, uh, from visit to fulfillment and even in the marketing channel, uh, much, much more, uh, streamlined, especially for small businesses who, um, really think about that for a little bit and focus on, on what their consumer's, uh, experience needs to be Got it.

31:35 Um, so I wanna t- uh, transition, uh, briefly to profitability. So last year- Mm … I feel like the narrative would've been, uh, you know, a big growth year, a jump from the, the previous year, but a lot of people felt like it was, uh, that was partly attributed to heavier than usual promotions, which meant it actually ended up being, you know, not a phenomenal profitability year. Um- Mm-hmm … and so this year we're seeing the rate of growth slow a little bit from last year. Is there any reason to believe that people are being more conservative on promotions, or, or do you have any insights about how we're gonna come out from a, a promotions and profitability perspective?

32:17 So, you know, I'll be honest. Uh, we're, you know, we're really good about figuring out the revenue. We're really good about figuring out prices. We, we are generally missing that third piece of costs, uh, that allows you to talk about profitability. But I, I'll tell you what. I was, I was thinking about this, um, this morning and last night, and, uh, looking at bunch, looking at it from a bunch of different angles in our data and, and frankly, the, the short answer is the results are mixed. So we did… You know, if you asked me this a, a week or so ago, uh, or even two, I would've said, "Look, the discounts seem to be moving forward, especially in electronics." Um, and so, you know, maybe the, you know, maybe the, the, the profit margins are, are slimming. But then we started to look at toys, and toys bottomed out quickly.

32:58 Um, uh, you know, maybe it… Once the Toys "R" Us process was, was through, um, the toy discounts didn't go as deep this year as they did last year, and we're seeing some… We saw, for instance, when we looked at appliances, appliances discounts were a little bit later than last year. So exactly how the, the profit margins are gonna go, hard to say, but the, um, uh, you know, and the revenue looks reasonably strong. So, uh, you know, I, I think the jury is, uh, a bit out on, on where profitability's gonna land. But I don't, for consumers, see a year where we, like, have massively deeper discounts, uh, than the last year. We just have them earlier and on particular products Got it.

33:38 That, uh, that makes sense, and I, I, I agree. It's, it's really hard to get a, a clear picture until well after the fact on the promotions because there's, like, there's promotions and pricing effects and all these other things. But one thing that seems like it might be coming into play a little bit more in profitability this year is profitability, like, there's a couple levers. One is that pricing and promotion. Another is the cost of acquisition. Um- Mm-hmm … and I, I do feel like folks, uh, there's a lot of folks that use the Adobe Marketing Cloud, um, for, for their cost of acquisition. Like, are you guys seeing any trends around higher advertising rates or spend rates than previous years, or is that not something you guys are looking at yet? So we, we don't, we haven't looked at overall, uh, investment in advertising.

34:22 That can be a fairly complicated thing to, to gra- to look into. But we have looked at performance and individual, um, you know, ad level pricing. And what's interesting is we definitely see, if you're, if you're advertising, um, especially in video but also in display or search, you're gonna see costs go up, um, a bit as everybody sort of pours online and, uh, wants to, wants to acquire customers. In the, in the video realm, that's about 23% higher CPMs. But when we look at performance metrics, those go up by an even greater amount. So, uh, you know, a- again, in video that, so where, where price is up 23%, performance in terms of, uh, viewable completions of, of videos are going up 30%.

35:03 Or we see, for instance, you know, email efficacy goes up, uh, quite a bit over that, that same timeframe. So, you know, we certainly haven't reached a point of, uh, diminishing returns, uh, uh, in those areas yet where prices start to outstrip performance growth, and I think there's a lot of opportunity for customer acquisition there. Uh, and, and, uh, advertisers and marketers have figured that out and are, are pouring the money in now when it's, uh, when it's most productive. That, that makes sense, and that's gonna be a great place to leave it because we have, uh, slightly exceeded our allotted time for this show. Um, but as always, if, uh, we didn't get to something that folks wanna talk about, you're welcome to hit us up on Twitter, um, or leave us a question on our Facebook page.

35:47 Uh, as always, if you enjoyed this show, we'd really appreciate it if you, um, jump onto, uh, iTunes and give us that five-star review. Um, we're also nominated for this, uh, uh, vendor of the year award in our category, so I'll put a link in the show notes. If you could take a couple minutes and vote for us, we'd really appreciate that. But, uh, Taylor, really appreciate you being on the show and, and, uh, sharing the data. I know it's a busy week for you. Thank you guys so much. Really appreciate the opportunity. Thanks, Taylor. Until next time, happy commerce-ing. You've been listening to The Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes or visit www.jasonandscot.com.