Welcome to The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News!
May 30, 2016

EP029 - Ferrara Candy, Amanda Greenberg Sr. Director, eCommerce

EP029 - Ferrara Candy, Amanda Greenberg Sr. Director, eCommerce
EP029 - Ferrara Candy, Amanda Greenberg Sr. Director, eCommerce
The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News
EP029 - Ferrara Candy, Amanda Greenberg Sr. Director, eCommerce

EP029 - Interview with Amanda Greenberg of Ferrara Candy

We have a new facebook page!

amandaAmanda Greenberg, Sr. Director, eCommerce of Ferrara Candy Company and former head of E-Commerce at Kind.

Topics discussed included:

  • Brand Lifecycle
  • Channel conflict
  • Pricing strategy / Map pricing
  • Amazon
  • Digital Impulse Purchases
  • The future

Episode 29 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded on Thursday, May 26th, 2016.

http://retailgeek.com/podcast

Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.

0:00 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here is Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. This is episode 29, being recorded on Thursday, May 26th, 20- 2016. I'm your host, Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg. And as always, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Jason. How are things in Chicago? They are wonderful. We're right before Memorial Day weekend here.

0:40 Yeah, yeah. We're gonna go to the beach and get our, uh, first sunburn of the season. What are you guys up to? The weatherman tells me that we are not gonna get a sunburn. I have my mother visiting me to hang out with our nine-month-old son. Aw, that'll be fun. Yeah. Totally looking forward to it. Also known as free babysitting. Well, let- let's jump into it. As we mentioned earlier in the week, uh, we were at Shoptalk, and I gave a panel called Brands Taking Control. And really excited to have one of the panelists here with us tonight, Amanda Greenberg. She's perfect to help us understand this general topic of brands going direct, and, and how do these branded manufacturers think about e-commerce, because she's the senior director of e-commerce at Ferrara Candy, and before that, she ran e-commerce for KIND.

1:26 She also worked for Philips and, and Crozel, a home furnishing company in e-commerce. So she's essentially an e-commerce ninja that brands bring in to help figure out e-commerce, both the strategy and to go implement it. Wow, Scott. That's excellent. I think that's our first ninja on the show. Welcome, Amanda. Hi, guys. I'm, I'm, uh, kind of, uh, flattered to be called a ninja. Yeah, it's kinda like a Six Sigma thing. You're kind of a e-commerce ninja. You rappel in from the ceiling, stealth-like, and implement strategies before they realize what's going on. I love that. I love that reference. I actually, um, I'm Lean certified, so, um, Six Sigma and Lean are close to my heart, but, uh, e-commerce is closer. Cool. Coincidentally, Ferrara Candy is close to Scott and I's heart.

2:08 Yeah. I'll send you guys some samples after this. What's your favorite Ferrara Candy? Mine? Yeah. Um, I would say the Stonyfield organic, uh, fruit snacks are my favorite. Mm. I'm a Lemonhead fan. Love the Lemonheads, especially the big giant ones. How about you, Jason? So I personally have not met a Ferrara Can- uh, Candy that I don't like, uh, but I'd have to go with the classics, the Now and Laters. Oh, those are great. Yeah, I can remember as a teenager having those when I had braces, and they ripped literally all my braces out, so they were not popular with my orthodontist. They were financially very popular with your orthodontist. Yeah. Yeah, I guess.

2:49 He has the fancy tires on the Porsche thanks to those. Amanda, start off by giving us a little bit of your background, and how did you, how did you get into the wonderful world of, of doing this kind of thing for brands? Um, where'd you go to school? Uh, were you classically trained in being a ninja? That… You know, we'd love to hear a little bit of background before we jump into some of the, the, the big topics that brands are facing. So no, I wa- I wasn't a nat- a naturally changed, uh, trained ninja, um, but I've, I've loved e-commerce for a long time. So I went to George Washington University fully anticipating that I was going to go into politics. I actually interned for Senator Chris Dodd of Connecticut, he's a Democ- he was a Democrat out of, uh, the Senate, and, um, became slightly disillusioned with natur- uh, national politics and, uh, fell into business, and I applied, um, to JD/MBA programs, and my father, uh, graciously told me not to go to get my law degree, and I focused on business.

3:48 And what I really love about e-commerce is that it's an am- amalgamation of all parts of the business world, so marketing, strategy, sales, uh, supply chain. Just everything that you can think of in business, finance, is part of e-commerce, and the general management aspect of it is what I really love. So I've been involved in various parts of business for my career, but what I love the most has always been e-commerce. So you like that kinda where you're the Swiss Army knife versus the, you know, the surgical scalpel, where you have just very, you know, a very kind of specific thing that you do? Yeah. And, and the other thing that I love about e-commerce so much is that it's constantly evolving.

4:31 The way that Amazon operates today is not what it, the way it operated a year or two ago. Um, Jet.com barely existed a year ago, so it's a constantly changing environment, and that's so fascinating to me, and I love the fast pace of it. I would also venture to say if, uh, your experience is anything like mine, your politics background probably, uh, helps you quite a bit in some of the corporate cultures. Uh, you would be surprised. So in some ways it does, and in some ways it doesn't. I, I consider… I don't know whether this is appropriate to say on this podcast, but I consider myself a little like Joe Biden. I have a hard time keeping my mouth shut when I have an opinion. Those are exactly the guests we want on this show.

5:14 Yeah, it makes for good radio Any- anything else? So, um, you've been at several companies, um, through there. Any kind of commonalities or differences that are interesting? I, I think the biggest thing is if you can connect yourself to who the consumer is, even if you're not the traditional consumer of the product, you can get inside the head of that person and then figure out the best way to proceed. Um, uh, that's how I approach it. So I may not have been the consumer of Philips Avent products when I was at Philips because I'm not a mother. Um, I'm not traditionally a, a very big candy consumer, but I understand who the consumers are in both of those segments and, and to me, that's the important thing.

5:59 So it's a… it's the ability to connect the consumer to the product and really think about that strategically and get into their shoes, and in that way, I would equate it to very similar to politics. It's how do you connect what the p- what the consumer or the constituent wants with what you're trying to sell? Hmm. Never thought of that. That totally makes sense. One of the things that's interesting to me about your background is you've been in the home industry, you've been in the ele- consumer electronics industry, and what I'll broadly call the CPG to include food, um, industries. And, and what jumps to mind immediately to me about those three industries are that consumer electronics is… it was sort of a early adopter of e-commerce.

6:46 They're kind of a digitally mature market, and home is si- sort of in between, and a lot of the food and CPG companies are, are sort of new to e-commerce and, you know, are still kind of getting their, their digital legs under them. And so it seems like you've had experience acro- across a broad range of maturities of industries. Does… Is, is that how it felt to you? Yeah, I mean, I guess going back to what I, what I had said previously is, is if you can put your- yourself in the shoes of the consumer, I think you can connect yourself back to how do you sell the product. Um, when I was in home, it was 10 years ago and, or almost 10 years ago now, and, um, selling bedding online is very difficult.

7:30 So people want to touch and feel their bedding. They want to understand exactly what size it's going to be and how it's gonna fit on their bed, so it actually was a fairly uphill journey. And not to mention the fact that it was almost 10 years ago, so, um, people really didn't understand e-commerce in the way that they do today. Electronics, for sure, was a much more mature market, but then there the challenge, at least on, on the Philips Avent side, was, uh, mother/child care is an evergreen consumer, so you're constantly trying to get someone into your brand, and you have their audience for maybe two years before they exit out of that, uh, uh, that market. And then on the Philips Sonicare side, the other brand, big brand that I worked on- Uh, o-- there was about 30, 25 to 30% penetration.

8:19 So you had 65, 70% of the consumer base that was still using a manual toothbrush, and the, to get someone into an electric toothbrush category, it's a difference between spending f- three to $5 and spending 100 to $190 on a, on an electric toothbrush. So that was a big jump. So each of them had their own individual challenges, and food for sure, I agree with you, is, is still on the precipice. From an e-commerce standpoint at Kind, we were actually fairly mature. Uh, granola bars and, and, um, nutrition bars in general are very shippable. They're fairly lightweight. They're fairly compact. Um, so it was a, it's a much easier buying decision for the consumer, and it's a much easier sell for the, for the, um, retailer to ship.

9:08 On the confection side, it's… The, the big challenge that we're facing, that I'm facing is it's much more of an impulse purchase. And so the big challenge that ultimately I will have is how do we overcome that impulse? But those are, those are the kinds of challenges that make it fun. Awesome. Um, one, one kind of question kind of on that is when, when these brands bring you in, you're kind of… Seems like they're at different phases of their life cycle. And in the retail adoption of, of digital and e-commerce, we've seen it kind of go from, you know, kind of the, the early 2000s it was kind of like, well, it's kind of a, it was a hobby, right? So you, you had to do e-commerce because you weren't sure, so maybe you outsourced it.

9:49 And then in the mid-2000s everyone got more serious about it. Um, but it was kind of still this different part of the org. And then now in most retailers, it's become this omni-channel, totally integrated r- Jason and I have talked a lot on the show about the digital people are kind of taking over. So now you've got this chief digital officer taking over for the CMO kind of a thing, and, and the whole org is kind of becoming digital. H- how do you, how do you take that? Do you think that model happens in brands, and, and have you kind of seen that over your career? Or is it gonna be kind of a different thing? Do brands maybe not go that far? I think it really depends on the company and how seriously they take it. Uh, I think it's a very big mountain to, to climb, and there's a lot of very traditional people out there.

10:36 I'm very lucky that I work for an organization that while they have not been in e-commerce or digital for very long, they're taking it very seriously. Um, and Ferrara really wants to move quickly into the space, so they are putting the resources and the time and the energy behind it in a big way. I think, um, ultimately it depends on the organization and also where the trend takes it. I think that, um, the, the big challenge, and, and I'd love to get your guys' opinion on this, uh, because this is one of… From a, from an organizational standpoint, this is the big quandary that CPG people tend to have is does, does digital end up sinking into brand, or does brand end up sinking into digital?

11:23 Because, uh, digital is Pervasive in every part of marketing at this point, and e-commerce is pervasive in every part of sales, and yet it seems as though there are still specialists. So at what point does it get absorbed, and in which direction does it get absorbed? And I'd love to get your thoughts on that. Jason, you wanna take that one? Yeah. I think of these digital specialties that we have right now as very tertiary positions, right? And I'm, I'm saying this about my own career. We're in a transitional time where digital disr- is disrupting everyone, and there's lots of legacy employees that know their businesses really well, but, you know, maybe haven't had deep exposure to digital.

12:07 And so the, those companies need to augment their traditional skill sets with these new digital skill sets. So yeah, you hire some digitally savvy employees, or maybe you even appoint a chief digital officer to sort of, um, help, help, uh, shepherd digital into your organization. Or, you know, my favorite solution is to go hire some big, expensive digital consultants like me, um, to, to come in and help augment your skill set. But in the long run, I think that all of us are gonna have digital skills as a core part of our job. And to your point, like, digital just is gonna be a fundamental part of branding, and everyone that's good at branding will understand the digital components, and there won't be the need for this standalone specialty.

12:52 And so the, the joke I, I like to tell is back in the 1920s, when all the factories were transitioning from steam power to electricity, for the first time, they could plug the factory into the electricity to run their machinery, a lot of factories hired this chief electricity officer, and that was a super important job to help that factory transition from the in-house steam plant to the electricity on the grid. But you're very unlikely to find a chief electricity officer today because that's just a fun-fundamental part of everyone's skill set. Yeah, my, my take is wh-when I talk to brands, they have various reasons why they've prioritized digital, um, and I'd almost turn it back on you.

13:32 And, and when I've talked to brands, there's, there's a number of reasons. They tend to fall into two camps. One of them is they're very keenly kind of aware of their consumer, and they're, they're trying to realign with them, or, or they've lost a consumer, and as they research, they realize that consumer kind of went digital and they weren't there kind of a thing. Um, that, that's one kind of bucket of answers I generally get. The other one is usually, um, for more traditional companies like, like some of the, your last two that are CPG, uh, they see it happening. They, they've got this channel layer between them and the customer, and they either are worried about the channel, um, or n-not getting digital fast enough, and they feel like they have to compensate, or the channel is kind of pulling them and saying, "Hey, you guys need to, you know, do more and, and kind of support us more in this digital thing."

14:20 So, so I'm kind of curious what, what's going on to, to drive that at your organization. Yeah, I think the big thing at, at Ferrara has been we've had an opportunity to, um, get serious about e-commerce sales. Uh, there's really not anyone in the candy industry who has done it very well thus far. Um, and so we have a real opportunity to get ahead in a, in a bigger way. So, I- many people I'm sure have not heard of Ferrara, but we're actually the b- the third largest manufacturer of candy in the United States behind, uh, Hershey's and Mars. So, um, and in fact, we co-manufacture for a lot of, for both of them, and also for a lot of other candy manufacturers as well.

15:04 So, we're, we're producing a lot of candy out there, and we've moved into some of the better few space. But I think ultimately, um, with the vision of our EVP of sales, John Levin, and, uh, our CEO, um, Todd Sewack, they, they both felt like this was a place that we needed to be, um, to, uh, move forward and to be a leader in the market. Um, and as, as I've been meeting with e-commerce customers over the past month or so, we've- I've heard over and over again that they're so glad that we're taking this seriously because they've needed someone in this space. Hmm. Interesting. In- interesting. One of the questions I was curious about is, one of the things digital does for a lot of companies is, particularly manufacturers, is it's the first time that they feel like they have an avenue to sell direct to consumers.

15:56 And so, you know, you'll… A lot of people that were manufacturers that traditionally sold through retail, only through wholesalers, will launch it- their own direct-to-consumer e-commerce site. I don't think that's the case at Ferrara yet. Is it? Do I have that right? Like, you guys aren't selling direct online? That is correct. We don't have that. That is something that we've talked about. Uh, and it's an interesting proposition. So at Phillips, we had it. At KIND, we had it. Um, I've managed direct-to-consumer websites at, um… I did not manage Phillips. I managed Crow cells, and I also managed KIND. And, uh, it's an interesting business. It's a tough business because- In my opinion, it defies the shopping behavior of the average consumer.

16:38 So there really has to be a reason why the consumer is going to have that direct impact. It tends to be a very high cost per acquisition. Uh, it tends to, um, be difficult to gain real traction, particularly when you have high ACV or high distribution in stores or online for that matter on, on channels like Amazon or Walmart.com or any of the big, uh, e-commerce retailers. But there are reasons to do it. And so the reasons to do it, in my opinion, are for data, because there's very rich data that you can get through the direct-to-consumer link. To con- to work with your consumer and to have that direct link to them so that you can get their feedback is a big reason to have that, that direct, uh, link as well.

17:27 And then also breadth of assortment, um, and testing. So there are lots of reasons to have a direct-to-consumer website, and it is something that we've been discussing, but it's not something that we've activated yet. What-- You mentioned data. What's some of the data that would be kind of interesting to you as, as a brand? Is it conversion rate or top sellers? What, what is it that's, that you would find-- that you would immediately dig into when you started getting that data? I think one of the biggest things to me that's interesting is device usage and how they're shopping. Um, whether they're fluctuating between devices and how they're fluctuating b- between devices. Also, what pages they're looking at.

18:07 So some of the reason to have a direct to consumer website isn't necessarily for the purchase, but also finding out w- where they're finding information, um, and then how they're acting upon that information. Um, I also think the conversion rate is interesting, but a conversion rate on a branded website is always going to be lower than a retailer website. So I, I, I don't know that you're comparing apples to apples, but all of the information, which products are purchased at the highest rate. So if you see, um, a product that is purchased at a very high rate that has a very low distribution, either online or in retail brick and mortar, then perhaps that's something you can leverage with other retailers to gain distribution points.

18:51 Uh, all of those, all of those various things are interesting. Yep. And I, I would just pile on. Getting the opportunity to work with a lot of multi-branded retailers and with branded manufacturers, the retailers are not really good at sharing data with the, the manufacturers yet. So they tend to share some very limited sales data. In many cases, they only share that data if the brands pay. And to my knowledge, none of the big retailers share this really granular data that's super useful to the brands, like search behavior. So when people are finding your products, are they searching for the brand names of your products, and what's the conversion rate when they do that? Are they searching for a flavor profile?

19:32 Are people typing sour or tart, and is that taking them to your products, and is that having a better or worse conversion rate? Are they misspelling some of your brands? And, you know, all, all of those sorts of interesting behaviors that retailers get to observe and then change their experiences to accommodate. Retailers aren't really good yet at, at making that data available back to their brand partners to help the- their brand partners improve their content. Yeah. And I would add, I would add also onto that, um, is when you have a, a, a house of brands like, um, Ferrara, like Kimberly-Clark, like Unilever, any of these companies who, um, have a very… have a fairly large portfolio, but none of the brands ladder back to that master brand, uh, it, it is very helpful for discovery as well.

20:23 Uh, and I think that's an interesting piece of it too. Absolutely. One clear kind of channel conflict is, hey, you're the brand and you start selling direct. And you mentioned, you know, Phillips did that and, and, uh, Kind did that. And so you have these age-old arguments. Am I gonna irritate my wholesale channel, and am I gonna create this channel conflict, and is Walmart gonna buy less from me because I do that and punish me, and, and blah, blah, blah? But there's this- Other kind of channel conflict that I suspect might be closer to home at Ferrara, while you've chosen not to sell direct, have you chosen to sell to some new Online only retailers, i.e.

21:04 Amazon, for example, and did you have those same kind of… Were you around when they made that decision, and, and did y- they have those same kind of conversations, "Are Walmart and Target gonna be angry at us for selling through Amazon," for example, or Jet? It, it's an interesting question. I guess that remains to be seen. We are, are going to partner with, um, traditional… Actually, I shouldn't say traditional, but, uh, I, I kind of think of Amazon as a traditional e-commerce retailer at this point. Um, with, with some of the e-commerce retailers that are online only, uh, including both Amazon and Jet, and we're excited about those partnerships. We're also ex- equally excited about partnerships with walmart.com and target.com, and any of the other retailers that have an e-commerce presence.

21:50 So part of my job is to specifically work with the brick-and-click retailers. Uh, so you can think of Ahold with sh- uh, Stop & Shop and Peapod. Um, you can think about, uh, walmart.com or target.com. Kroger recently, um, within the past year or so, uh, acquired vitacost.com. It's another retailer that we'll probably work with. So we will be working with most of the e-commerce retailers out there, uh, and, and I'm excited about all of them. The fact is, is that the broader distribution we have, the better all retailers do. So, uh, ultimately, as I say to everyone in my organization who's concerned about e-commerce, I don't believe e-commerce is a price disruptor, which is usually the biggest risk within channel conflict.

22:40 I view it as a very large mirror, that if there's a pricing issue in the market, it will hold that mirror up to it, and it will shine a light on it, but it's not going to be the reason that there was a channel conflict. Very interesting, and it, it sounds like this is clearly the case at Ferrero, but, like, just, just to clarify for our listeners, it's funny. When you talk to a, someone in consumer electronics or apparel and you say, "I have a e-commerce role," you're almost certainly talking about someone whose main job is to sell direct to consumer via an e-commerce site. But when you talk to someone in food or CPG that's in the e-commerce role like you're in now, the, your primary job is really to make those products, that digital shelf at all your wholesale partners more successful, and for you to sell stuff more successfully through walmart.com and target.com and Peapod and Amazon.

23:33 Do I, do I have that right? Uh, I think it's both. So at kinda had both pieces. At Philips, I was… I had a number of different roles, but when I was in e-commerce for them, I was focusing on the marketing revolving around, uh, the e-commerce retailers. And at Crowell, it was both pieces as well. So- I think ultimately at Farrar it will be both pieces, um, both the direct to consumer and the wholesaler piece. Although as e-commerce is a new initiative starting a month ago, the focus right now is on e-commerce wholesale, and that includes both, uh, omni-channel, brick and click, and pure play.

24:14 Cool. You, you mentioned kind of this mirror and, and it holds it up. Um, kind of talking generally about brands, one of the, one of the things we find is, um, these brands will come and they'll say, "We wanna go direct to consumer, and we're gonna set up a website." And they do, and then they're always surprised when they don't sell a lot on their website because, uh, of this minimum advertised price kind of challenge the industry has. So, so they'll be out there and, and they want all their retailers to sell something at $199 or whatever it is, if it's electronics or something. Um, and then they, they adhere to that on their website, but then all their retailers are selling it for like $139. Um, just generally, and, and you don't, you know, I don't want any specifics about companies, but just kind of… I-I'm sure you get asked this a lot.

24:58 Uh, what's your philosophy on, on that, both, both on map pricing and, and is it effective? And then also just pricing in general a-as a brand when you have this kind of, um, you know, you're selling things direct maybe, um, and then you have this channel kinda out there selling it too. So pricing in general I think is very tough. There's lots of different pieces that go into it. Map pricing is effective if you are operating in an industry where that's typical. So when I was in the electronics space, it was very typical, and, uh, it was very effective. But it was only effective because we had teeth to our map policy. So if someone didn't abide by that policy We would either, there were three, it was a three strikes policy.

25:44 So first one was a warning. Second, we would stop shipping them for I think a month, and then the final one was we would stop shipping them permanently on that specific SKU. And because we had teeth to the policy, it did work. In the food space, it's not common to have MAP pricing. So y- it is common to have what they call an SRP or a suggested retail price, but no one necessarily abides by that, and they don't have channel strategy the way they do in durable, in the durable space where they have specific periods of time earmarked for promotions. So you end up having promotions at all different points in the year, which leads to price disruption in the market, especially when you layer e-commerce in.

26:28 Um, but ultimately, I think the reason people don't go to, to… The reason people don't go to branded websites to purchase, I believe, is because it defies consumer behavior. It's so easy to shop on Amazon or to shop on walmart.com or one of their apps or to shop on diapers.com or Quidsi, uh, or soap.com or target.com or any of these apps that we have on our, on our smartphone. That's an easy thing to do. To go onto someone's mobile website, there has to be a reason. And so whenever I go into a, a new position, my question is always why? Why do you wanna have this as, why do you wanna have a direct-to-consumer website?

27:13 Because if you can answer the question why, and your answer is, "I want the data," or, "I want the, the direct con- uh, the direct consumer impact, and I want that, that relationship experience. I want the loyalty, and I wanna be able to control that experience for the consumer," all of those things are really good. But then the subsequent question is: what is the con- what does the consumer get out of it? So one of my favorite examples is Kiehl's. Every time you order off of the Kiehl's website, which is a L'Oréal company, you get a free sample or I think multiple free samples of other products that you can try. So the consumer benefit is they get free samples. The benefit to L'Oréal or Kiehl's is that they get all of this data, and there's a reason.

27:56 Also, Kiehl's isn't the easiest brand to find in brick and mortar or even online for that matter. So that's a, a win-win for everyone The best branded website that I've seen is Nest. Um, I think they do a great job of, of explaining their product, which is a smart, uh, home product. But when you get into the food space, there's not that much to explain. And so, um, the idea of replicating a Nest for, uh, for our candy is just not even close to being achievable. Mm-hmm. How, how do you feel, um, I don't know if you had a chance to see him at ShopTalk, but one of these new brands, you know, there haven't been a ton of CPG brands born, um, you know, you're working for kind of one that's, that's been around for a very long time.

28:43 Uh, The Honest Company, I thought it was interesting at ShopTalk, you know, here you have this multi-brand kind of consumer CPG company k- kind of came out of nowhere. It's got a celebrity angle too, which I think a lot of people poo-poohed at first. Um, what do you think about their strategy of really, you know, they, they, they're very, very specific about how they price things and where they sell them and, and that kind of thing? I was… Uh, so the CEO's name is Brian Lee, correct? Yeah. Mm-hmm. I was very impressed by him. I actually did sit through, um, his talk, and I was really impressed by his singular focus on the consumer. One of the things that resonated the most to me, and I'd love to hear your thoughts on, both of your thoughts on this, was his idea that he was able to see the everyday man or the everyday woman for that matter, the everyday person, and that he was able to figure out what would resonate.

29:33 The other thing that really struck me, so having come from the mother childcare space with Philips Avent, the biggest challenge is it's constantly a new consumer. It's what we call an evergreen consumer. That consumer comes in, and they exit within X number of years because there's ages, age and stage to their baby and their, and their own development, um, as a pregnant lady and then subsequently with their kid. Um, and, and Jason, I think you have a young child as well, so, uh, the- I'm, I'm a big Avent customer right now, in fact. Are you? Okay. So the, the thing that shocked me was he sort of flipped that idea on its head because to me that's, that's a barrier. But the way he said it, it was an opportunity, and I, I was really, I was impressed by that.

30:18 He said, um, that, that the, the mother cons- the, the consumer who's a mother is willing to spend anything to make sure that both she and her child are taken care of. And I-- That fascinated me to, to flip that on its head. Very cool. The, um- So, so you, you've kind of mentioned it a couple times, the-- it wouldn't be a good Jason and Scot show without talking about Amazon. So when, when I've talked to a number of brands, the, the funny one, I was talking to someone in the UK, and he kind of in that classic dry UK humor said, "You know, Scott, I have a love-hate, hate, hate relationship with Amazon." And, um, digging in, you know, what, what brands love about Amazon is the distribution. You know, with over, you know, close to three hundred million consumers and, uh, you know, well over or, you know, around two hundred billion of GMV globally, what's not to love about a channel partner like that?

31:09 But what I found a lot of brands worry about is, uh, it, it's growing so fast and, uh, becoming, you know, a large part of their growth and their company, so that's a little scary. Uh, and then sometimes, you know, like anyone, Amazon can be tough to negotiate. They may not take all your selection. Um, a lot of these folks that are really obsessed with map pricing, it frustrates them because Amazon is very robotic in changing the pricing if they see it lower anywhere else on the internet. And a lot of brands spend a lot of time trying to figure out who, who started the cycle of lowering prices and the race to the bottom and all that. What, what's your advice? Um, you know, so let's say a, you know, a, a, a brand came to you and said, "Hey, Amanda, what-- how should we approach Amazon a-and deal with it?"

31:54 What kind of advice do you give to folks? So I have a love, love, love relationship with Amazon. Uh, and I, I enjoy working with them so much. Um, maybe I've just had extremely positive experiences in all of my times working with them. But I've had some great vendor managers. I've had some amazing DMMs and, and VPs as well, and I find them to be an extraordinarily collaborative partner. Um, I, I just-- I can't even say how many good things, uh, enough good things about working with them. But my advice to people is be really open-minded when working with them. Give them all of their ideas. Uh, I was joking… So I-- when we were at, um, Sweets and Snacks earlier this week, I, I saw an old coworker of mine from Kind, and he was joking with me that, uh, they recen- that his new company Um, had recently sampled in one of Amazon's sample boxes.

32:50 So they have this new sample box, which is really cool, where the consumer can buy it, I think, for ten or fifteen dollars, and there's, uh, includes all these samples. And if they buy anything in, in the box, they actually get a ten or fifty, whatever they're, whatever they're putting forward as the, as the investment, they're getting that in credit so that they can buy something from that box. And hopefully, the idea is, is that they'll get someone into a consumable category where they'll continue to consume that product. And that was the brain-- that was part of the brainstorm that we had done when I was at Kind. And it was one of the ideas that we had come up with. And, uh, my friend, uh, who, who works for, um, a, a beef jerky company had said, "I can't believe they took that idea, and, and we just participated it."

33:33 And that's the sort of thing that Amazon d- they-- it's not that they took it, it's that they recognized it was a great idea, and they implemented it. And so I, my advice would be anytime there's n- there's a great idea, they should go forward and, and ask Amazon to, A, partner with them on it and B, implement it. And Amazon is open to those sorts of ideas, which I think is so amazing from a partnership standpoint. I also think that, um, the biggest risk is when someone is from the brick-and-mortar world and they expect Amazon to act like they're from brick-and-mortar, they're going to be disappointed. They're going to find fault with Amazon.

34:15 When you take it from a fresh perspective where you say Amazon is innovative and spectacular at what they do, and they can't be compared to brick-and-mortar, there will be no disappointment. They'll be very straightforward about their business model. They don't price degrade. They price match. And every single time that I've looked at a price decrease that someone has said Amazon led, it wasn't Amazon, it was someone else. Um, so I, I love working with them. I think they're a great partner, and I think they have so much innovation. And, um, I, I truly believe that, uh, and, and I think this is unfortunate because two years ago, I made a different pr- projection, and I'll tell you what that was, but I truly believe Amazon is gonna get brick-and-click right before Walmart or Target does.

35:01 Um, and so two years ago, I said Walmart was gonna get it right first, but I don't think that's the case. I think Amazon's gonna get it right first. Hmm. Well, two, two quick things on this topic. Number one, uh, I learn something new about Amazon every day, and you have blown my mind with this sample boxing. I did not know about this. Jason, did you know about this? I, I have heard about the sample box, but Amanda's the first person I've talked to that has some first-hand experience with it, so I'm fascinated. Yeah, so if you go to amazon.com/sample-boxes, B-O-X-E-S, uh, it looks like they have four right now, and what they do is you buy these things, and you get a credit. So it s- seems like a no-brainer to me.

35:41 And right now they're doing a lot of beauty products it looks like. Um, so pretty interesting. I, I had never known of that, and I, I could see why a brand would love that. It's a, you know, a, a great way of kinda getting that sample in the hand of the consumer and, um, and I assume Amazon takes care of all the logistics and everything. Is that kinda how it works? Yeah, it is. So you provide them with the product and also the funding, as always, and, and they handle the, um, putting the box together and getting it sent out. And just to give my friend some credit, uh, hi- his name is Ben Guarnero, and he's with, um, Chef's Cut, uh, beef jerky. Neat. That's a great idea. Um, and then the other one is we're, we're seeing… Um, this is more in apparel, so you may not have encountered this.

36:25 Um, one of the things that frustrates apparel brands is Amazon doesn't take their whole selection. So, um, kinda the classic example is Under Armour. When, when they were first, um, on the scene, they were really well known for their dry fit shirt but not some of the other sports they wanted to get into. Um, so they, they opened up a third-party store, and they kinda did what I would call hybrid, meaning they were both kinda first party, traditional wholesale retail to Amazon, and they were also on the marketplace. Um, what do you think about that strategy? Does that make sense to you, or is it crazy or, or have you had any exposure to that? I don't have a lot of experience with third party. All of, uh, my experience with Amazon has been first party, and they've taken everything I've asked them to Yeah.

37:05 Okay, cool. One other Amazon question. A, you've provided somewhat of a fresh perspective, which is great, 'cause to be honest, we, we talk to a lot of folks that are more leery of the potential downsides of Amazon, so it's great to hear your perspective. Taking Amazon specifically aside, folks in your, in your industry have, uh, seems like they've always had concern about one retailer having too much leverage and power over the market in general. And so, you know, for the last decade or so, that's been Walmart, you know, that dictated a lot of pricing and literally changed people's products lines based on what they carry and what they wouldn't carry, and dictated their shopper marketing based on what programs they liked and didn't like.

37:47 And now it seems like Amazon getting half of all the growth in retail in the last quarter, that they're sort of taking on that role, at least for a lot of newer products. Do you have any concerns? It sounds like Amazon's been a great partner to you, but do you have any concerns about them having too much control of the market? And, you know, so are, are you … It, it, it sounded like you're also very actively exploring all of the, the Amazon alternatives in the food space, the Jets and the Peapods and the Holds and all that stuff. I think any time there's a, a big retailer out there who's, who understands the market better than others, and in addition to Walmart, I would add Costco to that, uh, a- and, and some, uh, Kroger from a grocery standpoint, Walgreens from a drug standpoint.

38:33 There are these dominant partners in each space who really understand retail and get it better than anyone else One of the initiatives that I led at Kind, uh, while I wa- after my first year there was to decrease dependence on Amazon. And, and what I would say about that is it's not about slowing down growth at Amazon, it's about accelerating growth with alternative platforms. And so ultimately, you don't wanna be tied into any specific retailer with 85% of, of the channel going through one player. But the reality is, is that often happens. So when you look at, let's take the club channel, for example, Costco, BJ's, Sam's, the majority of, of sales go through Costco because it just happens to be bigger.

39:21 And I would say it's the same thing in, in e-commerce. Amazon happens to be the biggest player, but there are other players in the space that have, that are ripe for innovation. And I think that's where brands can play a huge role in advancing those players so that y- you're not decreasing the amount of acceleration that Amazon has, but you're decreasing the dependence by growing others faster. That makes perfect sense. I wanted to take a ch- an opportunity to sort of transition us to the future and where we think all this is going, and, and I have a, a couple specific questions. You mentioned at the top of the show that a big part of your current product catalog is impulse purchase, and I think a lot of us are nervous/curious about what the digital version of impulse will look like.

40:11 Because I, I sort of look at the marketplace right now and I say, gosh, as more consumers transition from shopping at Kroger and Target to shopping on Fresh Direct or Peapod or Amazon Subscribe & Save, what, what happens a lot is you see a lot of list reordering, and they build a list and they reorder that list over and over again, so they, they don't get that opportunity to add those impulse items. They don't get the serendipitous discovery as they walk through the candy aisle to get to cash wrap. And then even in the stores, the interesting thing is you have a lot of products that are merchandised at the cash wrap, and traditionally in retail, those cash wraps have been the, the highest revenue per square foot part of the whole store.

40:54 But now you watch customers standing in line waiting to pay at the cash register, and they're all heads down on their mobile phone catching up on Facebook, and it, it seems less likely that they're even noticing the Red Hots. And so I wonder, do you have any thoughts about what the digital equivalent of impulse might be? Am I overreacting and, and impulse is gonna be just fine? Is, you know, is someone gonna invent some cool new version of impulse, maybe something like the sampling box we were talking about at Amazon? I'm, I'm hoping you're gonna invent something I would love to. I'm trying. I, I think there's, there's two things there. The first is, is that I, I do think in-store impulse is a lot easier. So one of the best retailers for impulse, and, and I'm assuming that neither one of you has shopped there except potentially with significant others, is Sephora, where you have to wind down, uh, as you go to the cash register, you have to wind down this little, uh, tunnel of products.

41:50 Uh, and, and each of them look so exciting as you're walking down this aisle. You end up buying, like, $80 more than you anticipated. By the way, it's adorable that you think the retail geek hasn't shopped in Sephora. Oh, okay, so you have. So you understand exactly what I'm saying. I have spent the night in Sephora. So you have an appreciation for it as much as I. Uh, we just need to get them to sell candy in that little, uh, maze. Yes. Yes. The … There are not a lot of man impulse items in Sephora, I will say. No, there are not. Um, so that's one thing. The, the second thing is I think … So one of the things that during this brainstorm that we had with Amazon and, uh, Kind about a year ago, um, was talking about impulse and how do we get consumers to activate.

42:33 And, and Pantry has a very interesting Uh, opportunity in that realm. So as you build your box and it tells you you're 75% full and you need to have 25% filled, and you don't know what else to put in, that's kind of the opportunity for the impulse purchase, where you can say, "This bag of Trolli gummies will fill 3% of your box," or, "This box of Wrap, uh, protein gummies, um, as a substitute for a protein bar will fill 14% of your box and get you almost to closure." I think that's where impulse comes into play, and I see that replicating itself out in the market in different ways.

43:15 But I, I wonder, um, I wonder how else that can be activated, and I'm ex- be- besides the marketing tactics of email and flash sales and all of those things that do drive impulse, I, I'm interested to see how that, how that works in the future. I think there's a lot of opportunity in that space. Yeah. I tend to agree. I think there's some interesting opportunities for impulse in the checkout flow and in the cart. And y- the challenge is, of course, when you talk to retailers about that, they're terrified to add any, any additional friction to that checkout flow 'cause they have a bunch of items in that cart already, and they wanna get conversion on those items. Often I'm talking to them about the analogies in their store, and I'm, "You don't seem very worried about adding friction to the checkout flow in the store when you add all those impulse items at the checkout, but you do online at the moment."

44:03 So we'll have to see how that all plays out. Yeah, agree. Changing topics, I'm curious if you have a position on what the world's gonna look like, who, who the survivors are gonna be in the next few years, right? Like, obviously we've been talking about a bunch of traditional retailers that, you know, I'll call multi-brand retailers, guys that buy products from a bunch of different brands and sell them all. And obviously Amazon is the biggest example of that on the web. There frankly aren't a lot of other examples that are surviving, right? And Jet is giving it a good college try right now, but there's a lot of people that feel like that's gonna be close to a winner-take-all model, and there might only be one of those. So then you look at the other online models, and the one that seems like it's the most healthy is the one Andy Dunn talked about at, at Shop Talk last week, what he calls those digitally native vertical brands, where they're both the product manufacturer and they primarily sell direct.

44:57 They might also sell through wholesale, but they're sort of- Younger brands that are natively digital know how to talk to the digital consumer, and they make their own stuff. His position would be, gosh, the traditional retailers that don't make their own stuff are gonna be toast when digital, uh, disruption is, is all said and done. I'm curious, do you have an opinion on how that's all gonna play out, or wh-who should we put our money on? I think they'll both succeed. I think that, um, Amazon will continue to succeed. I don't think they're going anywhere. But there are also some really interesting players out there. Um, in one of your last, uh, I don't remember exactly which episode it was, but one of your last pod-podcast, um, you guys were talking about how, uh, everyone's kind of rooting for Jet to succeed because it actually does a lot of good for the rest of the market, and I think that was a really interesting point that both of you made.

45:47 Um, I think there's some innovators out there like Boxed who, um, are, are attacking the space very differently from a business online club perspective and focusing on the larger pack sizes, a lot of small businesses. Um, I think they'll succeed or become ingrained like a Quidsi was with Amazon. But I also think that there are some brands like The Honest Company, who started out as that direct to consumer, um, vertical, and then e-ended up as, uh, Brian Lee stated, uh, expanding out to Target and to other retailers. Um, and I think that'll be interesting as well. So I think there's … The, the space is really open.

46:30 I think ultimately for me, it goes back to the question of what is the consumer get, gaining from the experience, and how are you going to, uh, communicate that experience to the consumer? Because when they're ingrained in a shopping behavior, for me, it's I, I, I will be totally transparent. I shop almost, at least non-grocery, I shop almost exclusitly, exclusively at Amazon. Um, and so why would I change that behavior I think that's the interesting question. And, and that's the question that someone has to answer is why would someone change their behavior? And if you can come up with a reasonable explanation, then you have a business model.

47:14 Yeah. Yeah. Well, really appreciate you doing this. And any last thoughts that you wanna leave the listeners? We don't wanna eat up too much of your time. I know that it, uh, it's been a long week and wanna make sure that you, y- you, uh, we, we are respectful of your time. Any last thoughts for our listeners? No. I love your guys' show. I've been, uh… Over the past few weeks, I've been listening to all of, all of the past podcasts. You guys have such a great show, so I'm, I'm totally honored to be on it today, and I hope that some of the thoughts that I had were, were nuggets that people will enjoy. I truly am passionate about the e-commerce space. I think there's so much to delve into, uh, a- and so much innovation and, and that's why I'm passionate about it, and I hope that, uh, that everyone can see not only my passion but both of your passion and become equally e- excited about what's going on here.

48:04 Awesome. We really appreciate you doing it, and I know I learned a ton, uh, from you both on the panel and on the show, and really appreciate it. And I'm gonna go order some, uh, sample boxes f- for my wife- … and be a hero this weekend, so, uh, really appreciate that. Perfect. Yeah. Amanda, I, I just wanna echo Scott's sentiments. Thanks very much for your time and the fresh perspective. Uh, it's greatly appreciated. And to all our loyal listeners out there, I would just remind you if you enjoyed the show to rate it on iTunes and like our Facebook page. If you have any comments, you can certainly leave them there and continue the dialogue. And with that, I'd love to wish everyone a happy e-commercing. Thanks everybody. Thank you.

48:45 You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes, and please leave a review