Welcome to The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News!
Oct. 10, 2016

EP049 - HBC, Milton Pappas, SVP Digital Marketing

EP049 - HBC, Milton Pappas, SVP Digital Marketing
EP049 - HBC, Milton Pappas, SVP Digital Marketing
The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News
EP049 - HBC, Milton Pappas, SVP Digital Marketing

EP049 - Guest Milton Pappas, SVP Digital Marketing at HBC Digital Digital

Milton Pappas, SVP Digital Marketing at HBC Digital. The Hudson Bay Company (HBC), founded in 1670, is the oldest continuously operating business in North America. Today their brands include Saks Fifth Ave, Hudson's Bay, Lord & Taylor, Galeria Kaufhof, Gilt Group, and others. We spoke with Milton from the trade show floor at the Shop.org digital summit 2016.

Don't forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.

Episode 49 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded on Tuesday September 27, 2016.

http://jasonandscot.com

Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.

0:02 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here are Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg. This episode is being recorded live from the NRF shop.org Digital Summit on Tuesday, September 27th, 2016. As usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Jason.

0:42 This is the second of our live podcast recorded at the NRF Digital Summit. For our live audience, at 2:00 today, we're gonna be doing a roundup of news, and we have a special surprise guest, hopefully, knock on wood. And at 3:30, Jason and I are doing a breakout session up on level two in room C1 and C2. Because we're here at the summit, we have access to what I would call e-commerce luminaries, and today we are joined by Milton Pappas. Milton has had a storied career in retail and e-commerce, and was most recently, uh, uh, just mo- most recently, I think, days, uh, has announced that he is the SVP of digital at HBC Digital. And he was previously SVP and the chief digital officer at New York & Company. Before that, he did stints at Nine West, TRU, and… or Toys R Us, I should say.

1:26 Uh, I always call them TRU, and Redcats. Uh, Milton also serves on the shop.org board, which is where Jason and I met him. Uh, well, I've known you since the Toys R Us days. Right. But we, we spent a lot of, uh, fun time with you there. Welcome to the show, Milton. How are you doing? Uh, thank you guys. Great to be here. Doing great. Uh, it's really a great show. Uh, lots of really great discussions today, so, um, getting a lot out of it. Cool. And so you've enjoyed the summit so far? Enjoyed the summit. Um, participated on a panel, uh, discussing attribution. Uh, there was a lot of really great discussion on that. And, um, also attended some of the keynotes, so really great content this year. Cool. So, so you've had a, you know, quite a interesting career.

2:07 Uh, you've sold toys and apparel and a little bit of everything. Um, give us a little bit of history of how you got into the industry and, um, you know, any- anything you wanna hit along… I did the super highlights there, but anything along that arc. Would love to hear more about, about how you, uh, got into this and, and your career path. Sure. So a long time ago, I actually started out in IT, um, and moved over to, uh, a marketing role. Um, uh, kinda grew up initially in marketing in the publishing industry, in direct marketing. I worked for a publisher, Reader's Digest, for a number of years. Um, moved into the catalog industry, and that's where I had my opportunity to run marketing and e-commerce.

2:47 Um, and uh, it was really a great opportunity to take all the disciplines, everything I learned in the direct response industry, and say, "Wow, you know, this is pretty cool. You can actually do this from a digital perspective." So what we were doing in direct mail and, uh, a lot of those principles I found worked, uh, great from an email perspective and online. So spent some time in the catalog industry, then moved over to Toys R Us, um, to run ToysRUs and BabiesRus.com. Um, so I… It was… C- Came out of, uh, apparel into the toy business. Uh, and from there, Nine West, so back into the fashion, uh, industry. And then most recently a New York company, um, as a chief digital officer.

3:28 So my role there was, uh, a little bit broader, where I ran e-commerce, digital, and, uh, we're also launching a lot of cool drive-to-store initiatives with digital. Uh, so that was very exciting. And, uh, as you pointed out, most recently I'm now at HBC Digital. This is day seven for me, so. Okay. Uh, and I know HBC stands for Hudson Bay Corporation- Yes … or Company. Um, uh, what are the different brands within Hudson Bay? So- So this'll be your seven-day quiz. That's right, so- Uh, make sure I get this right. So Saks, Saks OFF 5TH, uh, Lord & Taylor, um, and also Hudson Bay, um, up in Canada. That's, uh, the oldest, uh, retailer in North America. Um, and then we also, um, have a, um, uh, a German retailer that we most recently w- uh, was purchased.

4:12 So it's a fairly large organization, um, doing a lot of cool stuff from a digital and retail standpoint. Cool. And, and when you were at Toys R Us, uh, if memory serves me right, you were… They had, uh, outsourced their, their whole e-commerce to eBay Enterprise, or, or previously known as GSI. Um, were you there during that part of that whole tenure? That, that, that trans… Well, they were at Amazon, and then they kinda famously left Amazon to go to GSI. Um, were you… Did that predate you, or were you there during that transition? That predated me. I, I believe that transition happened around 2006-ish, so uh, I, I joined the company in 2011. Um, so they were al- already working with, um, on, at the time, the GSI platform, eBay Enterprise.

4:57 Um, so it was, uh… I was there for about almost two years. Got it. About a year and a half. Got it You know, there was a keynote this morning from JCPenney, and, uh, during the keynote, Mike Amend asked the question, "Raise your hand if you're with a retailer that's more than 100 years old." And you actually could have raised your hand three and a half times. I did raise my hand. I raised both hands, actually. So you've been at HBC a week. Uh, have you figured out how to do expense reports and where the bathroom is? Um, I know where the bathroom is. I have not done an expense report yet, so this is actually quite timely. Hopefully I'll know… I'll learn how to do that by the end of the week. Um- You might wanna let me buy you dinner tonight, just to be safe.

5:37 Oh, that's great. Yeah. And being on the podcast, we'll expense you $2,000. So if you can run that through. This, uh, this, this setup doesn't come free. Great. Thank you. And, and by the way, I, I missed a brand. Uh, we also own Gilt. That was a recent acquisition. Oh, yeah. So… Very cool. You mentioned some of the interesting drive-by, uh, traffic generation stuff that you had been working on at New York & Company just before you came here. Could you, uh, elaborate on that a little bit? Sure. So we were doing a lot of testing with affiliates, uh, Ebates, RetailMeNot, um, mobile drive-to-store campaigns where we were actually testing store-only coupons that were, um, only available, uh, through their mobile app. Uh, we, we had some, uh, great results.

6:20 Um, and actually it was, uh, something that we had struggled with in terms of our digital marketing efforts, just e- emails, sending an email out every morning. We knew intuitively that it was also driving store sales, but it's o- often difficult to measure. Uh, so we were, uh, really on a quest to try to figure out how much, uh, was our digital spend doing in the way of driving, uh, store sales and visits. Interesting. Did, uh, any, was that a, um… Did you learn anything inter- any interesting insights you can share? So for sure, uh, digital is driving store activity. Um- Oh, good. Phew. It's good to know. Um, a- and I think it varies by industry in terms of the level of research that's done.

7:03 For example, um, mobile, as I like to call, is the omni-channel enabler. Um, you are, if you're like me, you're constantly on your mobile phone. Um, you're, you're, uh, doing your research before you go into store. Uh, and in some industries it's as high as they're saying 70% of all store purchases are actually researched, uh, through mobile and online. Uh, so it was, uh, very exciting for us to test, uh, various digital initiatives through email and through affiliates, where we specifically were trying to drive an action of, "Okay, let's see if you can get into the store and make a purchase." Cool. It wouldn't be the Jason and Scot Show if I didn't ask you this one theology question that comes up a lot.

7:45 Uh, also known as the, the Amazon question. Um, so Amazon, uh, your last couple stops have been in the fashion industry. There's a lot of new reports that show Amazon has a voracious appetite. They're kinda kicked off when they acquired Zappos. Uh, depending on what you read, they're either the number one… I think they're number one online in fashion, and number two i- all in. Uh, number one seems to be Walmart. I, I guess that's all sweatshirts and sweatpants and things like that. Socks, lots of socks. Um, how do you, how do you think about Amazon? Some people kinda take a hard, very binary approach that, you know, friend or foe. Um, some people are kind of in the gray area. What, what's your philosophy around Amazon? So I, I think it depends on the industry you're in, um, and whether you manufacture your own product or not.

8:29 So, um, it- when I worked at Redkat's, which is a plus size, uh, men's and women's apparel retailer, we actually launched on Amazon, uh, with multiple brands. Um, and I believe at this point they're still selling on Amazon and it's a, um, a source of, of revenue for them. Um, but they, uh, similar to New York & Company, uh, were manufacturing, we were manufacturing our own product. So we were not a reseller of someone else's product. Uh, we were, um, so we were the only place you could get it. We didn't have any, a store presence. Uh, we, we mailed catalogs, lots of catalogs. Uh, they drove, um, a ton of e-commerce business for us, the, the print media.

9:11 Um, so we launched on Amazon and, uh, I believe at this point they're still s- selling on Amazon. Um, when I moved over to Nine West, it was a slightly different relationship with Amazon, where we were selling wholesale. So Nine West is a very large wholesale fashion, uh, fashion brand. And, um- They were actually, Amazon was actually buying directly from, uh, Nine West. So that was a different model Kind of the wholesale or what I would call the first party or 1P model. Exactly. Yep. So during my time at Redcats, it was a third party model. Nine West was, uh, um, they were buying direct. Um, and then in the last earnings call at New York & Company, our CEO announced that we were launching on Amazon, and I believe that's happening this month.

9:57 Um, so there, again, similar model where we were manufacturing our own product. Um, we felt that it was going to, uh, allow us to access an audience that frankly was not coming into our stores, uh, or websites. Yeah. And so you think they'll do… Some, some customers we're seeing now, especially these folks that manufacture product, they do a bit of a hybrid model. So they'll go to Amazon and they'll say, "Here's our thousands SKUs," or 50,000 or whatever it is. Amazon will take wholesales, maybe 10% of that, and then they'll put the other 90% of their catalog on 3P. I kind of call that the hybrid model. Do you think they're doing that, or are they switching all to 3P? It's all 3P at this point- Okay … because we didn't have a wholesale model. Um, but, but for sure, if you're selling, if you're in the retail world nowadays, you're looking at alternative models.

10:43 Um, and I believe the numerous retailers are actually looking at going into the first party model, setting whole- selling wholesale. Uh, but day one, it's strictly 3P. Okay. Interesting. The, an interesting conflict we see a lot, there are a number of retailers that are really focused on private label specifically to have products that aren't available at Amazon, right? So we, you know, again, going back to Mike Almond from JCPenney again this morning, they're targeting trying to get 65, 70% of their merchandise to be private label so that it is exclusively available from them. Then on the flip side, uh, we're seeing more and more manufacturers that do have exclusive products, Lands' End, um, uh, The Gap has mentioned it, and, and certainly you guys, uh, that are trying to reach that Amazon audience and, and are willing to put your products on there.

11:35 Like, do you, like was, was that a, a difficult decision to make? Well, for sure there are numerous retailers that have kind of mixed feelings on whether I sell or not on Amazon, right? So, um, or- organizationally, we felt that it was the right thing for us because of the fact that, um… And I've, as you know, I've, I've sold now on Amazon in a couple different worlds, or three different worlds it will be, and the majority of the time my experience is you're accessing new customers that are new to your brand. So we felt that strategically it was going to allow us to sort of fish in a different place now where, you know, we can actually, uh, get access to customers that were not shopping with our brand today.

12:19 Right. How about, um… So that, that, you know, so you're kind of what I would call marketplace-friendly, which, uh, coming from ChannelAdvisor, always good to hear. The… How about, um, eBay and Jet and Walmart? You, you know, what are your thinkings? Should people think about selling there? Um, there's, there's some, some brands… And I'll say this so you don't have to. Some brands have a little stigma there where some people kind of say, uh, you know, I've pitched so many companies on selling on eBay, and the number-one thing I get back is it's a flea market. Um, they don't wanna have their brand associated with it. Walmart has kind of obviously a discount kind of a brand association. Jet seems to be cleaner because it's kind of a new brand and doesn't have any of that kind of history. Um, so any, any… With that background, any, any thoughts on, you know, if people are seeing success on Amazon, should they try some of these other marketplaces?

13:02 For sure. Um, once you, once you start that model, and if you're integrated with, like, a ChannelAdvisor as, as we were, um, you basically have created that pipeline that you can Point to a different marketplace, if you will. So when I was at Toys "R" Us, we sold on eBay- Mm-hmm … eBay Marketplace. Uh, we were, I believe, the largest… one of the largest suppliers of toys. Um, and then at Nine West, I actually launched a Nine West store on eBay. Um, so it was, uh… So, and there is, again, we were selling first party to Amazon, so they were buying from us wholesale, and we were selling, uh, third party on eBay. As you know, they don't, they don't participate in the f- first party, uh, wholesale standpoint. So, um, and this was the time when eBay was really trying to push in the whole fashion world, um, and they were inviting designers, et cetera.

13:48 So we felt it was a good place for us to, to sell product. Uh, clearly i- it's, uh, it feels like a different consumer that's actually shopping on Amazon versus eBay. Uh, we were able to participate in the eBay, um, the Deals of the Day that they run. Those were very successful for us. Um, so it became a, a good liquidation channel for us. Great. Yeah. What's nice about it is you can, you can have liquidation on your site, but it's cannibalistic. When you liquidate on eBay, it's not cannibalistic to your site, and you're acquiring kind of a new customer that you can then try to bring over towards your, your website. So it's kind of a, um, you know, a, a double win versus a one loss kind of a thing is kinda how I look at it. Yes. And again, we found we had a very large percentage, I would say over 80%, of the customers that were shopping through eBay were actually new and had not previously purchased from us in the past.

14:37 So, so that was exciting. Just jolted one question I've always wanted to ask. The, uh, Toys "R" Us does… I think I looked this up. They do, like, 80% of their business in, in holiday or something, some, you know, extreme amount kind of a thing. November and December- Yeah … very intense period. Yeah, yeah. And at Channel Advisor we're at something like, you know, 30 to 40%, and I've always… That's always stressful when you have, you know, the whole back end, the year or so back end. What was it like? Was, was it like a visceral kind of a, you know, stress kind of, you know, eating your knuckles un- until you saw the numbers come in? So interesting. I, I, I started at Toys "R" Us, uh, November 2011, and I actually started on Cyber Monday. Ah, wow. So, um, when they hired me, uh, they felt strongly that, uh, in order for me to really understand the toy business and the culture of the company, um, even though obviously day one Cyber Monday I wouldn't be able to- Contribute.

15:29 Um, it was really more to kind of s- be there as an observer, and to just see that intensity of the toy industry over that, let's call it six to eight-week period, is just 'cause y- you're doing 50% of your business. Um, so that was really, uh, it was very intense, high volume. Um, and also the fact that you are an iconic retailer like Toys "R" Us, where, uh, regardless of where you're making your store purchase, you are going to do your research on toysrus.com first, right? So, uh, we had a, a ton of traffic, um, around Black Friday, Cyber Monday. Um, and, uh, it w- it was, it was a great experience. Um, it w- again, it was very intense.

16:10 Uh, a lot of volume over eight weeks. And then the cool thing is, um, which it was also a big focus, is, you know, we're doing good things for kids. I mean, you're, at the end of the day, you're selling toys, so that's a lot of fun, and you're, you're making a lot of kids happy, so from a retail and an online standpoint. But if I don't get my Tickle Me Elmo, I think that's 2011 timeframe, then I'm gonna lose my mind, so, so- That's right … there's, there's a, there's an edge to that that's kind of a little tricky to make sure you nail. Well, there was definitely a commitment organizationally that we were gonna get those orders there by, by Christmas. I mean, it was very much a, a major focus to get those orders out the door. Yeah. Did that, uh… Do you think you built some extra holiday readiness muscles from that experience that you're gonna be able to apply in your new role?

16:54 No question about it. Um, I've found that since my time at Toys, um, I approach Black Friday, Cyber Monday, uh, in a much… I have a much different perspective, and, uh, it really gets you ready, um, to, uh… Y- you really think about it completely different, and you're, you're much more focused when you get into the holiday period Uh, changing topics to omni-channel a little bit. Uh, I, I sort of think about each of your roles having a, a, a different complement of omni-channel experiences and philosophies. N- I don't know if in a week you've, you've had a chance to even get up to speed on, uh, HBC's omni-channel. Um, but how did you guys think about that back at, at Toys?

17:36 So, um, I would… So Toys was my first real experience in the omni-channel world. Um, so when I joined the organization, we were doing in-store pickup, ship from store. Uh, we were, had the ability for the store associates to actually place an online order in the store. Uh, during my tenure there, we launched ship to store. Um, so that was very handy for the, the big, bulky items like the gym sets, um, and then on a Babies R Us standpoint, the cribs, et cetera. So, um, that is really, um… That opened my eyes to the power of omni-channel when I saw that a large percentage of our orders, um, um, not quite, I, I believe Mike quoted it was about 50% or so that were picked up in a store for JCPenney.

18:22 We were not that high at the time. Um, it, it varied obviously during the time of year. Uh, so for example, um, you always have your shipping cut-off in e-commerce, right? It could be like the 21st of the month or whatever. December, you're saying, um, you know, this is the last day, uh, to order before get in time for holiday. O- otherwize after that you're gonna have to get into expedited shipping. But when you're doing in-store pickup, you can literally promote down to December 24th and say, "You can get it today and come to one of our stores." Um, so that's where I really, I realized that it's a significant advantage to actually have a brick and mortar presence, um, when you have a, a sizable e-commerce business.

19:02 And, and now if you see, look, look how many pure players are actually opening up stores, right? So Amazon, uh, I, I read recently that they're gonna have something like 100 stores that they're looking to open or some big number like that, right? That's certainly one of the rumors. Yes. Yeah. Some of those are pop-ups, to be fair. I don't know how many- Sure … will be like full on stores. Right. But, but nevertheless, I mean, in, in New York City we have the War- a Warby Parker store, right, in the Meatpacking District. Uh, Rent the Runway, uh, has a store. So, so there's, uh, Bonobos. Uh, there's for sure, uh, they're realizing, uh, the advantage when you're a pure player, uh, to actually have a brick and mortar presence because at the end of the day, you still have well over 80% of retail transactions that still happen in a store, right?

19:44 I know, uh, y- your CEO at Toys "R" Us at the time was a very impassioned advocate for the value of, uh, stores, and I, I think I remember him doing a keynote here where he, um, sort of strongly made the case for the fact that the stores can be a competitive advantage. And he's your boss again now, isn't he? So, yeah, Jerry Storch. So Jerry is the, uh, chairman of HBC, um, and I actually, uh, report to a gentleman by the name of Dion Rooney, who's the head of HBC Digital. Um, yes, so, so Jerry Storch, uh, he spoke at, um, shop.org a couple years ago. Uh, he's very passionate about the omni-channel experience. Cool. And I know you're only seven days in, but, um, you, you know, uh, a topic we love to talk about is mobile.

20:29 Uh, most retailers we talk to, about half their traffic or more is kind of now coming from mobile. I put tablet in with smartphone. Google doesn't, so, you know, put it wherever you want. Um, what are some of the things you've learned about mobile over the years? And, and, um, you know, what… If you have any vision for where you wanna, where you think mobile, how retailers should deal with mobile, would love to hear it. So I, I think … So first of all, the, the question that always comes up about mobile is, what are we gonna do to boost that conversion up, right? So at the end of the day, when you look at your conversion on desktop and tablet, probably pretty similar. Uh, tablet's usually, at least in my experience, a little bit lower. Um, so for example, if I just use some numbers.

21:10 So if your conversion on desktop is, let's call it 4%, tablet you're probably, like, three-ish. Um, and then on mobile phone, you're somewhere between one and two, okay? That's typically how it will index. And many retailers are trying to drive up that conversion on mobile. It's never going to be where desktop is because at the end of the day, the mobile device is not only an ordering device, but it's a browsing device. So as we talked, uh, as we mentioned initially, you're doing a lot of browsing, you're doing research in stores, you're bringing up customer reviews. So you are driving a lot of browsing traffic that's typically not going to convert. Uh, and then you have the other sort of multi-device attribution, uh, in the world of I do my research on mobile, and then I actually finish my transaction on desktop, and vice versa.

22:01 Uh, so I would say you have to think about mobile a little bit differently. It's not just a mini website in a small screen. You have to really think about, um, how am I developing a, a customer experience that is for someone that is, quote-unquote, "mobile," um, and, and how do I also use it to connect to my store, uh, from an in-store experience as well? Yeah, have you, like in any of the roles, have you done anything around specifically mobile in store and providing a unique mobile experience in the store that's differentiated from the at home? So, so when I was at New York & Company, we had a mobile app that, um… So we had a, a store card, a New York Company rewards card. And, uh, w- New York Company has a mobile app, and the, uh, rewards card is actually integrated in the app.

22:46 So we were, um, basically the customer could come to the store with a mobile app and actually bring up an image of their card, of their store card, and we could scan it at the POS. Um, so we were, uh, using, uh, loyalty, our store card, uh, where we had a, a, a decent percentage of our store and online transactions as, as the hook for our mobile app. Uh, so we were really looking to drive that usage in store. Did you get to the point where sales associates could have a retailing platform and then kind of say, "Oh, I know you, Mr. Customer. You love this kind of shoe brand," or, or anything like that or? No, not yet. That, that was not something we had been working on. Um, but of course, every single retailer has to look at that in terms of, um, 'cause the consumer's almost expecting it now.

23:33 Yeah You, you mentioned attribution earlier, and that's, uh, you know, one of the challenges with mobile. Um, have you seen any interesting, uh, sort of tools or tactics to do that multi-device attribution? So that, that's a really good question. Yesterday, one of the questions that came up is, who are the vendors that you're working with? What are you doing that's cool from a, from a s- a, a, a, uh, software or technology perspective, uh, fr- on, on attribution? I, I would say a couple of things. I, I think first, um, and I'm, I'm not sure that there's enough emphasis placed on it, but I think, I think there has to be a focus on getting as much of that data, uh, ensuring that everything is tagged appropriately, uh, making sure that, uh, the data kinda makes sense, uh, from an attribution standpoint, and then sort of taking that next step and trying to get it down to the customer level so that you can… Uh, that's very powerful to know that a customer recently browsed your website, um, they were on a mobile device.

24:41 Um, so I, I would say there's really kinda no clear answer, Jason, because I, I think everyone's still trying to figure it out. I think you have to kind of pick a lane and, and sort of learn as you go. It's an iterative process. Yep. Yeah, and attribution's interesting. So when I first got in e-commerce, it was all about marketing attribution, kinda last click, and, and, you know, how do you give some assist up-channel. And then, uh, omni-channel kind of became the hot thing, and then it became store to digital, and then kinda mobile kinda came into the conversation, and then that started device kind of, you know, attribution. So it, it's, if anything, it's kind of gotten logarithmically more complex, you know? So, so now you're kinda trying to attribute these things. Um, I always… And we have Facebook on the show tomorrow, and I think they're in a really interesting position there because, A, they have like 1.6 billion people that use their, their app.

25:28 Uh, and then they've done a really good job of kinda saying cookies and that kinda stuff aren't the future because they're, they're so device, um, agnostic or, yeah, device- Depend … dependent. Uh, and Facebook has kind of, you know, they, they, they can be the one company that seems to be able to kind of possibly solve that. Right. Um, but, you know, there's some limitations there as well. And I, I think there are, there's also a lot of retailers doing some cool things with first-party data in Facebook, um, in terms of being able to kinda open up, get the email addresses, and being able to do some targeting directly on Facebook. Kinda like the audience matching- Exactly … kind of technology. So- Yeah … so I think they're doing a lot of cool stuff there. Um, uh, I, I would say Facebook, obviously to your point, has such a wide net that they're in a unique position.

26:10 Um, and, uh, and they're doing some forward-thinking things. So for, so I think there's a lot more to come there. Yeah, there's, uh, you know, two platforms in North America that just have a ton of authenticated users, right? And that's Facebook and Google. And so it's not an uncommon strategy to do some targeted media with those two companies explicitly so that you can see the multi-attribution for that advertising audience. So, you know, that, that can act as sort of a surrogate and give you for a, a feel for what the, the multi-device attribution is for your entire customer base. Um, an interesting thing, uh, that Adobe's trying to do, and I, I don't think it's, it, uh, they've really hit critical mass yet, is actually set up a co-op of all the retailers that are using, in their case, Adobe Analytics.

26:59 So, uh, you know, their, their model is you opt in to this co-op, and you share anonymous authenticated, uh, data about your users, and they aggregate that with all the other retailers in the co-op. Um, and then when you have a, a known user, you can, you can go query that, that known user in the co-op and get all the other device IDs that that user owns. Hmm. So it's sort of a, a, a way to democratize that, that big competitive advantage that Google and, and Facebook have that they, they know so many of their users. And s- and sorry, so that's a really good point. It is about critical mass, right? So they have such a large audience, uh, between Google and Facebook.

27:39 And at, at, at the end of the day, it all starts there, uh, being able to get access to the audience because as a retailer, we're constantly looking for new customers and traffic, and that's what's driving our business. So to be able to tap into those audiences is, is really a huge advantage that they have. Cool. So you, you've had a, you know, a, a great career in e-commerce and have seen a lot of things happen over the last 10, 15 years. Um, let's look forward three to five years. What do you… what are some of the interesting trends that you think about? On the show, we've talked about chatbots, uh, augmented reality, virtual reality. Jason sent, sent a tweet out about laser beams. Uh, I'm not exactly sure what he's saying out there. Uh, I believe that's killer laser beams. Killer laser beams. I don't know how you feel about those.

28:21 It sounds a little violent for, for kind of, uh, being customer-friendly, but I, I don't know. Um, any- would love to hear, you know, kind of the things that, that, that you see on the frontier of e-commerce. So I, I think what's exciting from an e-commerce standpoint, I mean, obviously mobile, um, trying to figure out what, uh, the level of store activity that's being driven by digital. Um, so paid search, is it, is it just driving conversion and sales on my site, or is it actually, uh, driving a store visit? So there's a lot of cool stuff you can do with geotargeting, geofencing, et cetera. Uh, so I think that, um, many retailers are trying to figure that out. I also feel that the user-generated content is really, um, a, a great trend.

29:07 If you think about, you know, when we started, it was about content, commerce and community. And so the content and commerce obviously has been excelling and doing well, but community sort of lagged behind, right? And I think now community is finally starting to pick up. Um, so in, for example, uh, at Nine West, uh, and also at New York & Company, we were taking a lot of the social data, the user-generated content, and actually, um, posting it to our website. And we had a photo gallery, and we were, we gave customers the opportunity to upload, um, an image of herself in the new dress that she bought at our store. Uh, and we were, uh, we were just amazed how many customers are actually engaged in doing that, and, and we found it very powerful to post that content on the product page as an, like an alternate image, if you will, and it was driving a lot of sales for us from a conversion standpoint.

29:59 So, uh, so I'm very excited about all this user-generated content, uh, and, and this trend that's really picked up in the last couple of years. I mean, for sure, customer reviews have been around forever. Uh, I first launched customer reviews when I was at Red Cats in 2007. Uh, initially that was very controversial. Merchants didn't wanna… uh, they were, they were concerned about, "Okay, someone is going to actually see a review on a product that I created," and they were concerned, but, but all the… over 80% of the reviews were positive. Um, but now this trend of being able to, to take social content and, and being able to post it on your site, I think is very powerful.

30:41 Yeah, uh, and particularly you think about some product categories where they're a little more subjective, right? So, you know, apparel, like, just because I rate something, uh, highly, I, I have no style, um, that, that potentially shouldn't be a very influential review for you. Um- Right … and wh- uh, whereas that, that other form of social proof, that user-generated content, if a bunch of u- uh, very dapper-looking gentlemen are all uploading photos of themselves in that, that garment, that, that serves as a, a great alternative form of social proof. And, and you know, that's a really good point because if you look at what the, the growth categories in retail right now, men's fashion, men's apparel is really growing.

31:23 And, um, many, uh, a lot of folks in the industry attribute that to all the social content that's out there now. Um, because, you know, previously I could have my wife basically tell me what I should wear, but now I can go to Pinterest or Instagram and, and actually get ideas, to your point, of, uh, what other folks are wearing, so. And while I am not very stylish, let the record show that Milton and I are very similarly dressed at the moment. Yeah, yeah, I'm the underdressed one in the group there. That's a, a moral victory for me. Yeah. Good job. Just wear what Milton does. Exactly. That's your social proof. Yeah. I just got- Upload an image. Exactly. Post an image. Send me an image every day, and I'll… Yeah, yeah, exactly. I have a feeling that could cost me, uh, a lot of money.

32:05 Um, well, listen, Milton, uh, we totally appreciate you being here. But as per usual, we have, uh, flown through our allotted time. Uh, so we desper- definitely wanna thank you for taking time out from the busy show to share some of your thoughts with us. Um, up next at 2:00, we're gonna have a news recap and a special guest. And then, of course, at 3:30, Scott and I are going to take our show onto the big stage and host the Jason and Scot Show session, um, where we'll, we'll finally get to the bottom of b- of a bunch of the popular topics that Scott is wrong about and that I'm right about. Yeah. Yeah, the audience will get to chime in on that. Milton, we really appreciate it.

32:46 Best of luck with your, uh, you've had your first seven days. For the next h- hopefully years at your new gig, and, and we look forward to hearing, having you back on the show to, to hear more about HBC and, and what you're doing there. Thank you, guys. You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes or visit www.jasonandscot.com.