EP250- Holiday 2020 Recap
EP250- Holiday 2020 Recap
This week we recap the commerce results for Holiday 2020 (including the data sources you can use to get a read for yourself), give an update on #shipageddon, and cover some industry news.
| 2019 | 2020 | YoY %Ch | |
| Stores | $864.69 | $822.79 | -4.8% |
| Online | $140.28 | $190.47 | 35.8% |
| Total | $1004.97 | $1013.26 | 0.8% |
Nov-Dec Sales estimates from e-marketer $B
- November Retail Sales Aren’t As Ominous As You Think Jason's article in Forbes, recaping the results we've seen through November.
- Consumer Trends 2021 report - Dan Frommer's recap of 2020 consumer trends (highly recommended).
- MasterCard Spending Pulse
Shipageddon Recap:
Episode 250 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded live on Thursday, January 7th, 2021.
Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, Chief Commerce Strategy Officer at Publicis, and Scot Wingo, CEO of GetSpiffy and Co-Founder of ChannelAdvisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:02 Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, Chief Commerce Strategy Officer at Publicis, and Scott Wingo, CEO of GetSpiffy and co-founder of ChannelAdvisor. Here are Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. This is episode 250, yes, being recorded on Thursday, January 7th, 2020. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, and as usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Jason, and welcome back Jason and Scot Show listeners.
0:44 Happy New Year, Jason. It's a new year, and you actually said the wrong year in the intro. So we need to, uh, we need to jolt your brain, bring it back, back into 2021 here. Get you out of the, the time traveling hot tub. Yes, absolutely. I do feel like there should be a grace period, but, uh, thanks for, like, not saying anything during the eight rehearsals and then pointing it out on the live show. The grace period ended on the 7th at about, uh, 9:00 PM. Sorry, you just missed it. Darn it. Just my luck. Well, that one day when you make a mistake, I'm gonna point it out too. It's, uh, it's been, been, uh, a long time already, so we'll see. Uh, the 250 episodes, we do about 50 a year, so that feels like we've been at this about five years if I'm doing my math right there.
1:32 Yeah. Uh, most people get sick of me way before now, so you, you, uh, definitely are getting some kind of, um, perseverance trophy. Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. I think, uh- Have I outlasted your wife at this point? We're pretty close if I recall, which- Uh, she has more years. You might have more concentrated time because of my usual travel schedule, but, like, let me just say she's gotten, uh, more of a dose of me than anyone should ever want, uh, in the COVID year. Yeah. If you can survive COVID, then you can survive anything. Exactly. The… Also, you get to update your slide and say, "If you enjoy this talk, there's 250 hours of me out on the internet." I know, I know.
2:12 Don't, don't give away my cool lines from my live presentations. Sorry. It always gets a chuckle. Everyone's like, "Uh…" Did you have a good holiday? I did. Uh, like many people, um, kind of atypical. We didn't do our usual holiday routine. We, we mostly hung out at the house, but I got to spend a lot of time with my wife and Steven. And, uh, uh, maybe in some, like, COVID-induced, um, craziness, I did try to take on a couple of new hobbies, so we'll… And I'm sure they're not gonna stick, so we'll see how that goes. But it was kind of fun to try to learn some new things.
2:53 Cool. And I saw you updated your profile picture everywhere. That got a lot of, uh, a lot of chatter out on the interwebs, so that was good. You, you're actually smiling in your new profile picture. I did. That's exciting. I did. Uh, I like to take, uh, listeners' feedback. Um, I'm just a little slow. So I took a picture, like, a year and a half ago, and I must have been having a bad day, because I was not smiling. And, uh, perhaps the most consistent feedback I get, uh, is that, uh, "Hey, Jason, that picture doesn't reflect your personality. You should get a picture where you seem more happy." And so a mere 18 months later, I, I got around, uh, retaking the picture. The good news is you haven't changed your Zoom avatar, so I'm sitting here looking at good old 2020 scally Jason.
3:37 Oh, gotcha. Yeah. Uh, which is the one I've known for five years, so that's good. Well, as you know, we've had a little hiatus from the show, so I haven't, uh, had to fire up my personal version of Zoom in a while. So, um, so thank you for pointing that out. I will update it. I, uh, shortly before the show, I got a new avatar from Shoptalk. The one of the caricature kind of thing? Yeah, yeah. So, you know, I've been a f- I, I have actually spoke at every Shoptalk Grocery Talk event, and so Shoptalk started in 2015, and they, they did an avatar, a caricature for me back then. And, um, the, uh, as a cost-cutting measure, they kept inviting me back and reusing the same caricature. So this year, it's been six years, they did a new caricature.
4:18 So, uh, you can go on Twitter and you can look at the, the six year… I haven't aged a bit. My skin, my complexion is exactly the same in my, my cartoon caricatures. Nice. Very cool. Did you get any fun, uh, gadgets to report on for, for the listeners? A few things. Um, so I, uh, the thing that I'm having the most fun with is super lame and geeky, and I think you also are gonna say you got an upgrade in this genre, but as, as you and the listeners will already know, I have a way overkill video conferencing setup here. Um- Yes … so I, you know, I do spend all day in front of the camera for work. Uh, but, and it, it's helpful to have a nice setup, but I, uh… at some point long ago, I way surpassed the, the, um, effort, uh, versus return, um, ratio as I kept adding more toys to the setup.
5:11 So the toy I added over holiday, um, I'm really digging. I got, like, a pretty commercial teleprompter to put in front of my camera. So I used to be, you know, have a laptop right below the camera lens, and so you're c- you know, you should be looking at the camera lens, and you could see your, your PowerPoint presentation or the people you're interacting with right below the lens. But I, I noticed in a bunch of webcasts that it looks like I'm always looking down and not making eye contact, uh, despite my best efforts. So now my, I have a mirror of my laptop screen that's literally right in front of the camera lens, so I'm star- while I'm, like, looking at you or reading my slides, I'm, I'm staring right at the lens, and that's, it's worked out really cool.
5:58 So it's transparent so you're looking through the camera and the camera can't see it? Yeah, and that, that's basically what they do, like, at every, like, news station in the country is there's, like, a, a glass that's reflective but allows, uh, but is clear from the back, um, that's at a 45-degree angle, um, that's in front of the lens, and then you put a monitor below that glass that's reflecting up. Got it. So it look- Very cool. Yeah, so it looks very similar to a newscast, and I, in fact, I've done a couple television segments this, this holiday season, and, uh, uh, both of the producers, like, laughed at me when they saw my setup. They're like, "Yeah, that's a little, uh, further than most people take it."
6:43 Uh, so I, so that has been a fun toy. And then I did buy, it's totally cool. I will never, like, get full use from it. Uh, I am non-musical, never took a music lesson, don't know how to play any instrument. Um, but I saw, uh, I, I totally fell for some Facebook ad and bought this thing called a LUMI, which is a, a small piano keyboard, uh, with, uh, LED keys that light up. Mm-hmm. And so you, you, uh, it interfaces with, like, an iPad, and there, it teaches you how to play the piano, and it, like, highlights the keys as you play them. So, so think of it as kind of like Guitar Hero for a piano.
7:24 Very cool. So, so I've taken a bunch of, uh, online piano lessons over the last two weeks, and, uh, it's been fun. It's totally cool. I have no talent, and I'm sure I'll give it up in the, in the next few months, uh, as work gets busy again. But- Is that L-O-O-M-I or L-U-M-I? It's L-U-M-I. LUMI. Ah, okay. Cool. Awesome. So some good new stuff there. Yeah, what about yourself? You, I feel like you both had a, a much more exciting holiday, and I'm sure you got some better toys. Uh, I don't know. The, I did, uh, squeak a trip in there, so that was fun. We went to a beachy destination, so that was good. Um, got a little… We're here in the very cold North Carolina, so we're, it got down to 40, so we had to escape that to warm weather, which was good.
8:10 Uh- Yeah. Are your neighbors annoyed that you're tan now? They are. Yeah. We are, we are pretty tan. Um, and then on the gadget side, I am, I'm, like, eight steps below you. I finally got a, uh, kind of a more modern, uh, DLSR without a mirror that I can do better streaming with. So, uh, I've been having fun trying to get the firmware updated on that. That's been an adventure. Uh, and then I got a lot of Mandalorian stuff, including a Baby Yoda who wants to say something. Baby, that's the most boring one. Oh, that's him using the Force. Can you feel it? I do. I do. Although, I think that's him saying, "My name is Grogu."
8:51 My name is Grogu. Uh, so that was good. Uh, yeah, so it was, it was great. And then, um, my son got a PS5, and I got an Xbox X, so we're, we're caught up on the consoles, which is good. I always like to keep those current and- Yeah … so that's been a lot of fun. Any initial… Like, I feel like the, the normal narrative is that people are liking the PS5 better. Is that your impression as well or? That is. Yeah, they, they did a really good job on that with the industrial design and the online components and all that jazz. So that is actually getting more play than the Xbox right now. Um, and then there was a… As a software guy, it was really fascinating to watch this Cyberpunk debacle.
9:35 Have you tracked this? You probably did. Yeah, a little bit. Yeah. So they, they released this game. There was all this hype, and then it was so buggy that Sony actually, um, if anyone bought it through the online portal or through the Sony channel, if you will, um, they refunded everybody. Um, you know, even kind of, uh, unbeknownst to the game developer, and that caused a whole rift between them and the game developers working hard to fix the bugs. So it's a, it's a classic, uh, you know, example of, uh, it's better… Sometimes we fall into this go fast and break stuff mindset, but this was one of those times when that did not work. Yeah, they broke a little too much stuff. Yeah, they broke stuff, and it just broke.
10:17 Yeah. Customers were not happy. Uh, disproving the adage that there's no bad press. But there are some fun YouTube videos if listeners wanna learn about this. Just Google Cyberpunk bugs and, you know, you'll be driving your little car around, and you'll end up inside of a building, and all, all kinds of- … all kinds of, uh, very strange glitches in the code there. I like it. Very cool. Well, it's January, and you know what that means. It is event time. Um, and you are, uh, you always speak at a lot of these January events. Uh, walk us through what you have coming up. Yeah. Uh, so ordinarily, January is the most miserable time of year for me because shortly after New Year's, I'm jumping on a plane, flying to Las Vegas, uh, to hang out with 300,000 of my closest friends at CES.
11:04 Um, and then usually I catch the flu at CES, which has a whole different connotation this year. Um, and then have, while sick, have to fly straight from New- from Las Vegas to New York for NRF, which, um, I do look forward to NRF. It's fun to see, uh, lots of my, my friends and peers in the industry, but it's a long two weeks. Uh, so this year, both shows are, of course, virtual. So virtual CES, I'm really curious how that's gonna work. Like, to me, a big draw at CES is randomly discovering stuff that you had no idea existed on the trade show floor. Um, and I, I have no i- I- I'm cynical that they'll be able to recreate that digitally.
11:49 But on the flip side, the keynotes are so popular, and it's so congested that I rarely get to see them. Um, and this year I'll, I'll, I'll, of course, get to watch any of them that I want. Um, so that CES, that starts, uh, next week. And then, uh, NRF is doing a two-part show this year. They're doing a virtual show in January, so that'll, uh, be stretched over, like, a week and a half. Um, uh, week after next is when it starts, and then they, they do hope to do a, uh, chapter two, uh, in-person show in, uh, sometime in the back half of the year. So, um, I will be, uh, presenting a little content at NRF and, and, uh, um, trying to take as much advantage of, of that as I can.
12:34 But full disclosure, the best thing about NRF for me is, uh, getting to see all, all of these, you know, friends that we don't get to see in person all that often. And often you come, so we get to, uh, hang out together for a little while. And so it, it's gonna be, uh, a little sad for me, uh, to not, not have that experience. Yeah, I'm gonna miss standing outside the Javits Center in freezing, pelting rain and sleet trying to get a cab when none's available and r- rolling a suitcase through all that misery. Yeah, yeah. I don't know that we have time on this show, but sometime we'll have to, like, I, I do think COVID, uh, is probably an accelerant of, um, sort of a lot of these events, uh, permanently changing.
13:20 So it, it's interesting to think about some of the ways that, that, that, that this will affect, permanently affect the, the events industry. The other thing I've never gotten about NRF, uh, and I do love it because you and I get to go see all our, our buddies, um, it's over the weekend, and, like, some of the best content's on, like, Saturday and Sunday, and it's just like, come on, guys. Yeah. It's, like, the only show I know that does that, but they're kinda like, "We're retail. We're gonna have a weekend meeting." And it's just like nah. Yeah, I think in their def- I agree. Um, and in their defense, uh, I, I'm not sure if this is the right decision or not, but what, what you have to remember is that's a 100-year-old show, um, which is remarkable if you think about it.
14:02 Um, and so the, they are still following the basic ca- like, it's in the exact same location, the same time of year, and the same days, uh, for almost that entire 100-year presence. Like, occasionally there's some, like, a ho- like, a holiday will fall in the middle of that and they'll have to change the schedule, but, like, there's, um, there's some nod to history with those days. And s- and, like, in fairness to them, uh, people complain about it, but everyone goes and partakes, and that show has grown every year, so it's hard to, it's hard to convince them that those days aren't working. I think they all, uh, take the opposite side of that argument, as you and I often do, and I think they would show that retail is flexible and able to change with the times by getting rid of the weekend hours.
14:46 Yeah. Well, I think they're hoping to show that this year by going virtual. Yeah, COVID, uh, COVID gave them no choice. Yeah. And then, of course, the event that I feel like everyone is more looking forward to than either of those events, as good as they are, in January, is the annual Jason and Scot Predictions podcast. Yeah, usually we, we try to wrap it up. Uh, we do a recap and predictions in one show. It always is an hour and a half, uh, which is a little long. So this time we're gonna split it up. We're gonna cover a bit of a recap and some news here today, and kinda put a bow on 2020. Uh, and then next week we'll put our big predictions show out. Exactly.
15:27 So that, good cliffhanger, Scott, I like it. Bum, bum, bum, bum. And this is a great time to remind folks that we love five-star ratings. So if you would go to your favorite podcla- cast listener and leave us some ratings, that would be great. Uh, so Jason, let's kick off the recap of the year with our favorite topic, Shipageddon. Uh, what ha- what, what's your conclusion for how that went? Uh, I saw Amazon s- put some stuff out there. What did we learn from them? Yeah. Um, well Amazon didn't like, you know, obviously the retailers are hesitant to talk about, uh, what went wrong with their shipping. Um, so I haven't seen any sort of Shipageddon specific numbers from Amazon.
16:09 Amazon did issue a press release, uh, you know, bragging about a lot of their accomplishments and kind of the, the top line. They, uh, they didn't disclose any overall GMV sales, but what they did say is that third parties, um, sold $4.8 billion on, uh, Black Friday and Cyber Monday. So 3P sales on those two days were $4.8 billion, um, which is up 60% from the, the previous year. Um, so I can remember when it was a big deal for, you know, to have a billion dollar day. Um, and, and, uh, you know, now they're, they're talking about both of those days being just the 3P sales being over 2 billion, which is impressive.
16:53 Um, and I, you know, we've talked about this before, but I feel like Amazon is really focusing on bragging about the 3P and how they're helping small businesses, uh, because I think that's a, a good narrative for them, um, you know, vis-a-vis some of the antitrust climate that's out there. The, um, it is, you know, I, I wish there was more public data out there. Uh, anecdotally, it feels like what happened is, uh, FedEx and UPS, by being really stringent on what they took, they were able to get most of their deliveries done. You know, so there are some, some cases where they missed some things, but, uh, you know, what, what I think that happened is because shippers couldn't get as much through those two channels, they really flooded USPS.
17:43 So, um, you know, there's no, unfortunately no… The USPS doesn't kinda generate a report that says, "Hey, look how many packages we missed." But, um, since you and I were really well-known for Shipageddon, we got a lot of reports that there were some things that got there really late. I know individually we had some stuff ordered in early December that didn't show up until literally just, you know, like January 4th kinda timeframe. Um, I had done a, a, a calculation that it would be somewhere between eight to 12 million packages would be my guess that, that ended up late there. Um, the folks at ShipBob Um, you know, we had them on and they talked about their, their tracker. Uh, so if you go look at that, uh, they still have it up, you can see that the, the days to ship got up as high as kind of mid six to seven, so six and a half days.
18:31 Um, and then that's-- I think that's actually short because when you look at the time, it was taking, um, you know, days to just get the tracking numbers entered in the system on the front end of, of the whole process, and even a lot of times, you know, on the back end as well. So we would, we'd have a package delivered, and then three days later I would get a notification from the USPS that it had been delivered. So, so it seems like their infrastructure, their, not only their, their hardware infrastructure with trucks and whatnot was maxed out, but, but off- you know, definitely the, the software side as well. So, um, you know, uh, that was interesting, and then that tees us up for re-Returnageddon, which I guess we'll talk about on the next show possibly, if that's one of our predictions.
19:15 Maybe it is, maybe it isn't. Um, anything else you saw on Shipageddon? Yeah, no. I, uh, again, I think it's mostly anecdotal data. I don't think there's a perfect roll-up to say, like, Shipageddon was, was m- you know, more acute than expected or as acute as expected. Uh, in general, I would say, uh, that f- while things slowed down and got gummed up a little bit, they mostly held up. Like, that I, you know, I don't think, um, FedEx or UPS, like, really got horribly behind and they weren't able to work through those, those spikes. Uh, part of the reason for that, uh, I'm gonna explain in our next segment, so I'll, I'll put a pin in that.
19:55 Um, but the, the s- the lack of scanning data, all the carriers got a little behind in scanning and, and USPS got way behind, and of course, a lot of USPS pac- products are not trackable anyway. So, um, that actually r- uh, dramatically exacerbates the slow delivery from USPS. So if, if you think about it, if you're an e-commerce business and you ship something to a customer, um, and it doesn't arrive when that customer expects it, and they go online to track it and the tracking says it's lost or it hasn't shipped or it's, you know, in transit someplace far away, um, that customer generally expects you to reship a new version of the package.
20:38 And so in, in, uh, the, the fact that you, that the shippers couldn't clearly articulate where all these packages were in the network caused a lot more make-goods, and just the customer calling into customer service is super expensive. So all this extra "Where's my package?" calls and all the extra customer accommodations that had to happen because of The slow delivery and the source scanning caused a real problem. And then if you were in a category like perishables, where you're shipping cookies or something like that, um, it was a mess. And so I, I do think it's, it's very clear that there were a bunch of holiday packages that were shipped via US Post Office that did not arrive in time for Christmas. Um, as a pure anecdote, uh, the, that LUMI piano I mentioned, I ordered well in advance of Christmas.
21:27 They promised it for Christmas. Um, and they, they sent a communication saying, "Hey, we've shipped them all. Uh, we have no idea where they are. We can't track them. Our, our carrier isn't telling us where any of them are. It, it now appears some of them aren't gonna arrive before Christmas, so, uh, hopefully yours arrives in time for Christmas. If it doesn't arrive in time for Christmas, here's the, the bonus that we're gonna give you." Right? Like, and they, they just had to send that to everyone because they, they couldn't tell who was getting it on time and who wasn't. Yeah. Yeah, and it's super frustrating if something's late and it's just kinda like the, you know, it- the, the shipper has not uploaded the information.
22:07 You're just like, "What? You have it." You know, your, your go-to as a consumer is, "You told me this thing shipped, but I'm going to the tracking and it's not looking like anything's happening." Exactly. It's, uh, it's not fun. Well, cool. So we, you have been updating clients on, um, kind of the year-end summary. Walk us through some of the highlights. Yeah. Uh, well, I'm gonna, uh, not spend a lot of time, but I'm gonna, uh, a brief, uh, foundational, um, element is when you're in this business and you're talking about holiday, like, what are the sources that you can use to track, uh, how the holiday's performing?
22:48 Um, and so I just wanted to highlight that there's, there's no perfect answer. Like, we, we don't have clean reporting that, you know, on a day-by-day basis tells us in real time, uh, what's going on out there. So we have to piece together a bunch of imperfect data sources. So, um, the way to th- think about this is, um, to me, there's, there's kind of like, uh, four or five big categories of information. Um, there are companies that try to tell us in near real time what's happening with e-commerce, right? So they, they … Nobody has kind of real-time data on the brick-and-mortar stores, but, um, there are a lot of tools that e-commerce sites use that see a big chunk of the traffic, uh, through those e-commerce sites, and many of those tool vendors are set up to, to, um, kind of give summaries of sales in real time.
23:36 So, uh, the ones we talk about on this show most often are, uh, salesforce.com, formerly Demandware, um, you know, do a lot of real-time reporting. We had them on the show during holiday talking about how things were going. Um, Adobe is one of the best sources out there. A lot of people use Adobe for their, their analytics for e-commerce sites, and they report a lot of their data. Um, and then there are other tools out there, like Bloomreach, um, and, and others that also try to report real-time data. So one, one input we have in the holiday are these real-time data from these digital providers. Um, then there are folks that, uh, have big panels of users and, and measure how consumers behave on the web.
24:18 Um, so these aren't tools that are on the e-commerce site. These are tools that are in the consumer's browser. Um, and so these are tools like Similarweb and Comscore, and generally, you pay for them, and they, they provide you some really useful data about traffic to specific sites. So, um, so I look closely at those. They, they tend to only report, uh, one month in arrears, so, you know, it's usually not till the first week in December that I can see November's web traffic and, you know, uh, and, uh, so on. Um, so those are really useful to tell us how many actual visitors, uh, went to Walmart versus Amazon, for example. Um, then there are folks that- Don't know what you bought or where you bought, uh, what you bought exactly, but know how much you spent and where you spent it, right?
25:06 And these are people that have access to credit card data. So there's a bunch of third parties that have access to credit card data, and again, they tend to be time-delayed. So there's companies like, uh, Factus out there. Um, my company, uh, Publicis, own a company called Epsilon. Epsilon sees three point five trillion dollars of consumer spending every year, so about half of all consumer spending. But we, uh, we don't really get that data until thirty days after the fact. Um, one of the credit card companies, Mastercard, publish their data much more promptly. Um, and so Mastercard has a reporting product they call SpendingPulse, uh, which is a super useful recap of, uh, spending both in stores and online that can come out maybe a week after the fact instead of a month after the fact.
25:54 Uh, folks like eMarketer that we have on the show regularly publish, like, estimates, uh, of what they're seeing, um, largely by synthesizing these other sources. Um, and then there are a bunch of tools that specialize in measuring how many people walk into brick-and-mortar stores. So the stores have meters on the front of the stores that measure the traffic, and some of those meter companies are allowed to anonymize the data and summarize it. So that's companies like Sensormatic and ShopperTrak. Um, and then there are other folks, like cellphone companies or, uh, CDN networks like Akamai or, or these companies that use GPS software in your phone, like Placer AI, and they all put out these real-time estimates of how many people visited the stores.
26:36 So that's the pool of data sources we have. And so when you say, "How did holiday go this year?" I, I try to roll up those data sources. So the, the first thing to say is like what, what happened on the, on the Turkey Five week? Um, so that, uh, Thanksgiving, Cyber, uh, Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Thursday, Friday, Monday. Um, so I go to the Adobe, Salesforce, Bloomreach data, um, and you'll see that they don't all agree. So on, uh, Thanksgiving, those companies reported that e-commerce sales were up between twenty and twenty-eight percent. Uh, so we were predicting that the whole holiday period would be up like thirty-three, thirty-five percent.
27:20 So twenty to twenty-eight percent is… it's healthy growth, but it's below expectation on, on actual Thanksgiving. Um, Friday was even lower. Those guys said the range was twenty-one to twenty-six percent. So again, healthy growth, not as much growth as last year and not as much growth as expected. Um, and, you know, given that because of COVID, growth is just Up dramatically everywhere, uh, this felt a little disappointing. And then Cyber Monday, um, was even more disappointing. The range was 10 to 24%. So, um, so these are all imperfect sources, so we don't know exactly. But basically, it feels like Thursday and Friday were up 25%, and Monday was up 20%.
28:07 Um, and so the, the big three days that we would normally expect to be the biggest e-commerce days were big days, and they actually set records for the most e-commerce, but they weren't as spike on top of spike as, um, we sort of expected or feared going into the holiday. And I, I honestly think that this was really good news for Shipageddon. I think if, if these three days had been like acutely up, that would've been the big pig going through the… or the b- uh, going through the snake and really gumming up sales, and it would've taken a long time for, for the carriers to catch up. But because those days were a little more moderate, um, the, the, uh, shippers were able to, to catch up and keep up a little better.
28:54 Um, so do, do those three days mean that that holiday was, was below expectations? Um, and the short answer there is no. A lot of the data that looks at the whole month of November or November and December or even October through December, um, show that we probably came in at the 33% e-commerce growth that we were expecting or better. Um, and the data definitely shows that, uh, purchasing did start earlier. So there was a lot of talk about would Prime Day in October and the sales in October, would they be able to pull sales into October? And the, uh, the preponderance of the data is that e-commerce was way up for the holiday period, and that the holiday period started early.
29:40 So what happened a little bit is instead of all the sales happening on the big three days, it got spread out towards all the days of the season. The… Are you tracking me so far, Scott? Yeah. Yeah, and one thing I would add is, and you may be going there, the, the shape of the holiday. So if we kinda kick off at Thanksgiving, you know, you would normally have this kind of, uh, you know, V shape. So, so you have the spike at the beginning, then you have this kinda lull around the 12th to 15th of December, and then you have, like, what I call the procast- procrastinator pop. This year, um, it was like a s- down sloping line, so we didn't have that, that kind of shape to the V in the e-commerce side of things.
30:23 Um, and I think that was … I think you and I played a role in that 'cause we educated people on Shipageddon. Uh, we saved Christmas, Jason. Yeah. Congratulations. Congratulations to you. So we, uh, I think, uh, hopefully we, you know, in all seriousness, hopefully we did help out by alerting people to shop earlier, um, because it w- you know, I think we, we ended up… I lost count. I think we ended up with, like, 30 or 40 publications really, and, and these are pretty material ones, like Today, Today Show and stuff, that picked up Shipageddon. So hopefully it did play a role in not causing that, that back-end surge to really muck, muck up things. Yeah. Yeah. I, I, uh, have no idea, but I'm, I, uh, would like to pretend that it, it, it contributed at least in some small way Um, I think it's unanimous amongst us, uh, the two of us here Yeah.
31:13 Two out of two podcasters agree Yeah Uh, so, uh, just as a sanity check on that, on that, uh, Cyber 5 data, uh, I looked at Occamize web traffic data for that same period, and they basically said that traffic was up about 27, 28% on those days. So that, that passes the smell test to me. Traffic was up in the, you know, just north of 25%, and sales were, were similarly up. Um, I pulled the SimilarWeb data for November, uh, which sadly I'll have December's data tomorrow. So for the next show, I could tell, I can tell you November and December. But for, uh, November, the whole month of November, web traffic to the top 20 e-commerce sites was up 38%.
32:01 So that gives you an idea of how all of November was up versus just the spiky days. Like the spiky days were up 25%, but the whole month of November was up almost 40%. Um, and if you're, uh, interested, like for the whole year, SimilarWeb would say web traffic was up 25% this year over last year. So C- that's the COVID effect. Um, and then November had this other nice, nice spike up to 38%. Um, to me, it's One of the cool things about SimilarWeb is I can see the traffic for each individual retailer. So I pulled the top 20, um, and the, the biggest traffic sites on the web are, uh, for e-commerce are Amazon and eBay.
32:45 Um, and they are basically up at the industry average. So they grew like 25%. Um, the big winners is that next tranche of retailers. So the, by far the biggest traffic winner of the season is Etsy. They were up 100% this year over last year. Um, Walmart was up 75%, and Walmart's traffic is now almost identical to eBay's. So, so they're similar size. They grew a lot faster. Target, Costco, Sam's, uh, and Bed Bath & Beyond were the other kind of 75% or better growers. So, so what really kind of happened is the biggest e-commerce sites got their kind of traditional share of growth, but then, you know, uh, as, as they, you know, uh, ran into capacity issues and things, people turned to this next tier of retailer, and they, they grew the fastest in this thing is those, those omni-channel retailers.
33:37 So to me, that, that was super interesting. Um, so, so far we've all been talking about digital, what, what sales were like and what websites were like. The other half of this question is- The other half of this equation rather is what happened in stores, um, and that wasn't very pretty, right? So, um, the … I mentioned that there are these, uh, t-tracking services. Um, Sensormatic said that traffic was down near 100% on Thursday. That makes total sense 'cause a lot of stores that traditionally were open on Thursday, uh, were closed for Thanksgiving this year, so, uh, that's not a shock. Um, but then Black Friday, which ordinarily would be the highest traffic day of, uh, the year, um, was down over 50% for most retailers and, and down even worse for department stores, down even worse for malls.
34:28 Um, and looking at a bunch of the different traffic sources, that, that was pretty consistent is that, that traffic is way down in brick-and-mortar stores at the same time we're seeing traffic being way up in, uh, online. Um, so when you look at the guys that track credit card data, that, that's kind of where they come out. I mentioned Factus. Factus said November, uh, brick-and-mortar sales were down 4% and online sales for all of November through their data set was up 78%, which feels a little skewed high, but that kinda gives you an idea of the order of magnitude. And then to me, what ended up being the best data source this year is that MasterCard SmartPulse.
35:11 Um, so they said in, from November through December 24th, the brick-and-mortar sales were up 2.4% and online sales were up 47%. Um, so that feels like a, a, a pretty good middle ground on all the data sets that I looked at. Um, the … If you break that down into categories, uh, you know, there are categories that were clear losers this year. So apparel was down 20%, department stores were down 10%. Luxury, um, which includes a lot of jewelry, was down 21%. So those were the categories that got most hurt, and then the categories that did really well, uh, furniture, furnishings were up 16%.
35:53 Uh, do it, DIY, so the, the Home Depots and Lowe's of the world were up 14%, and grocery, as I've talked about a lot on this show, was up about 7%. So, um, that is kind of how all of these, uh, preview data sources play out. And then of course, um, the, the data sort, we- source we talk about a lot on this show is the US Department of Commerce, and, uh, they do not publish December data until, uh, January 15th. So, um, oh, I think, uh, that's a week from tomorrow, next Friday. Uh, I'll download the, the December data, and I will, you know, start, start putting some of that data out on, uh, on my social media platforms, and then I'm sure we'll do a podcast about it shortly, shortly thereafter.
36:42 Yeah, and I'll be watching, um, for when Amazon, uh, announces Q4. So if the MasterCard data's right and Amazon grew that fast, that could be pretty surprising, I think, to, to everybody. So that's gonna be interesting to see if they benefited from it and, you know, where Etsy ends up and Shopify. So we'll be reporting on all that, uh, as it comes out. Yeah. And I will just … One other side note I failed to mention, um, is that, uh, when the, the November data came out from the US Department of Commerce, I did write an article about that in Forbes. Um, and it, it actually has some kinda cool visualizations that we put together that kinda show how fast cate- which categories are growing very fast versus last year and which categories are suffering.
37:27 Um, and we also included in that article kind of, um, all the public retailers and what they reported as their e-commerce growth. So I'll, I'll put a link in the show notes to the Forbes article if you wanna check that out. Yeah. Did I see you tweet over the holiday that you wrote some code to, uh, pull this data into a new cloud, a JSON cloud? Yeah, so that, that was the other hobby I foolishly undertook, uh, during the, the, um, the holiday, uh, s- period when I had some downtime, is, um, the, the US Department of Commerce, like, publish all this data on a website. There's kind of a cool interactive tool you can use, or you can download Excel tables.
38:08 But you, um… All the interactive tools just let you take one slice at a time, and, and a lot of the slices I'm interested in caused me to have to download, like, eight or nine different slices and kind of put them together in Excel. Um, I work with a bunch of fancy data scientists, so over time, they help kind of, um, automate the Excel process for me. But, uh, I, I, I really was getting tired of doing all that. I wanted to get a faster analysis, so I kinda took it upon myself to say, "Hey, how can I pull the commerce data from a API, and how can I automate all these different, um, looks that I wanted to do?" Uh, and so I actually, uh… The first thing I needed was a development environment, so I actually, uh, had never kinda gone hands-on on, uh, uh, AWS and EC2 instances.
38:58 So I learned how to spin up a bunch of different kinds of EC2 instances, started playing with code, and what I landed on was, uh, um, a Python script, and it turns out that you can run Python pretty easily natively on my Mac. So I didn't need to use those EC2 instances. Wrote a Python script that gr- grabs all the data, and I throw it into Tableau, and then I kinda taught myself how to build some, what to me are cool dashboards in Tableau. So I'm super excited for next Friday because if, uh, if nothing's broken, I'll, I'll get a fresh feed of this data the second it publishes to the website, and it will automatically flow through all my, my visualizations.
39:40 So that, uh, was my giant, uh, coding time sink, uh, for this thing. And then I'll throw one other thing. After I did all this, I discovered another cool AWS amenity called Lambda, which lets me actually run my Python script without a server instance, so it's kind of a serverless way to run Python. Um, and so that, I now have a Lambda service set up to actually go grab that data and throw it into my Tableau. Cool. Soon you'll have this running on your watch. You can, uh, press a button on your watch and tell us how the, uh, how the, the Department of Commerce data's looking. Exactly. My dashboards are already kind of chunky. I do not wanna make a watch version.
40:22 Okay. That'll be your 2022- Yeah … plan. Yeah. So if any, if there's any Tableau or, uh, data science geeks on the, on the show that wanna sync up, uh, at some point I do plan to sorta open source all this, so if anyone else wants to, uh, take advantage of my misspent holiday, um, you're, you're welcome to any of these tools. Very cool. Uh, anything else on the recap? Uh, I think that is it for, for holiday at the moment. Again, um, uh, you know, I think given the pandemic circumstances, it's remarkable. I think retail is gonna be up. Uh, brick and mortar will be, you know, softer than usual, but it, that was more than made up for by, by e-commerce.
41:06 So, you know, from a, a, a… Remains to be seen what profitability will look like, but from a revenue standpoint, I, I think it's gonna be a, a, a strong Q4, and I, I pity all the, the retailers that are gonna have to comp against it next year. Yeah. Yeah, it's gonna be a fascinating year from, from that perspective. Let's jump into some news. It wouldn't be the Jason and Scott Show without some Kaiser News. Your margin is their opportunity Yeah, so in true fashion, we, we in the Shippageddon part of the show, we did talk a little bit about some of the news, uh, out of Amazon, but there's been a lot more.
41:55 Um, one of the ones I saw that I wanted to get your hot take on, um, I think it was two or three years ago, Amazon partnered with, let's see, Berkshire Hathaway, and was it JPMorgan? Um, and they were gonna do this kind of trifecta go solve healthcare, uh, thing, and it was called Haven. And I noticed, uh, as a CNBC junkie, uh, the big news, um, I think it was last week, was that they have unwound that effort. Um, and then you've been talking about how Walmart has kinda got its eyes on this, this same kinda area. What's your take on that? Yeah, it's super interesting. So you're right. Like, uh, Haven was a big deal. You figure, like, Jeff Bezos, Jamie Dimon, Warren, uh, uh, Buffett are finally gonna solve healthcare for all of us.
42:40 I was thrilled. Um, and yeah, this, this week or, or end of last week, it, it dissolved, which was kind of surprising. Um, but, uh, looking under the covers, I, I have a hypothesis for what's going on. So, uh, healthcare is a super important category that I think Amazon and Walmart care a lot about. They're both investing billions of dollars in it. Um, you'll remember a couple months ago, Amazon launched a, a significantly enhanced pharmacy offering called Amazon Pharmacy. And, um, if you kind of follow all the coverage of the, the leaders at Amazon and Amazon, Amazon Pharmacy, one of the interesting side stories was that there was a lot of internal conflict at Amazon between in-house healthcare efforts and Haven.
43:30 Um, and what it's sounding like is that there was a lot of competition, that a lot of the management team at Amazon felt like they were in the best position to come up with unique new products and that Amazon, you know, uh, embracing the day zero or day one method mentality kind of w- was capable of moving very fast and being very innovative and that maybe this, this doctor-led joint venture with, with, uh, JPMorgan and, uh, Berkshire Hathaway wasn't capable of moving as quickly or being as innovative. And so I actually got the strong sense that there were a lot of people at Amazon that wanted to do healthcare internally and did not like the partnership.
44:12 Um, and so I think pharmacy is one of the efforts from these internal efforts. Uh, and it sounds like they may have won the day because, uh, my understanding is Amazon pulled out of Haven, and that kind of caused it, it to dissolve. So, so my expectation is we're, uh, still gonna see some big investments and some innovative, uh, solutions from Amazon in healthcare in the, in, uh, in 2021. Uh, and, uh, you know, we also have seen a lot of really interesting things from Amazon. I do think this is gonna be one of the big clashes of the titans this year, and hopefully we all benefit because, you know, the whole country could use better healthcare, so. Yeah. Did you see any other interesting Amazon news?
44:53 Yeah, a few things. Um, so one that kind of, uh, is super interesting and tickled my fancy, my funny bone a little bit, uh, this year, um, so Ad Age, like, do these studies on who the biggest advertisers in the world are. Um, and, uh, this year Amazon surpassed Procter & Gamble to become the world's largest advertiser. So, so Amazon will spend $11 billion, um, on, uh, advertisements, getting people to come visit the Amazon site and properties. And, uh, uh, a very large chunk of that is Google. I, I've been led to believe that Amazon's the largest advertiser on Google, and, um, that's, that's interesting, and it's kind of funny to me because of course there's been a lot of news lately about Amazon being an advertising network and competing with Google, and it, it almost f- like, when you look at it through this lens, it almost feels a little bit like, like, um, audience arbitrage that, like, uh, Amazon bought $11 million of eyeballs from Google and sold them for $14 billion Wow.
46:01 The, uh, there was a lot of noise about Shopify, um, and Amazon working on a, a kind of a, a inside effort to, to counteract their thing. In fact, someone said, you know, Bezos is highly engaged in digging into that. Did, did you read that, and what'd you make of it? I did. I actually… I was curious what your, your take on that was. So the… I think the key article was, um, you know, that, that Bezos had kinda moved out of day-to-day, uh, uh, operational management of Amazon. Um, and that, you know, he was spending a lot of his cycles on initiatives outside of Amazon, obviously, uh, um, Blue Origin and, and some of those other things.
46:43 And that the, the pandemic and, you know, some of the unique challenges sucked, uh, Bezos back into a very hands-on role. And, uh, these articles that were talking about Bezos coming back all talked about one of the initiatives that he took a hands-on effort in was Amazon's response to Shopify. Um, and, uh, so I'm really curious to see how that manifests. Uh, Scott will know, and some of our listeners will know, Amazon has been in the Shopify business before. So Amazon used to have a product called, uh, and now I'm gonna confuse the name in my head. Uh- Amazon WebStore. Amazon WebStore. It was confusing- Thank you … because everyone, everyone called it AWS. Yeah.
47:23 Exactly. Um, and so that, that… at the time, like, the, the big, like, SaaS web platform might've been, for small businesses, might've been Google Shops or Yahoo Shops. Um, and so this was kind of Amazon's, you know, better version of Yahoo's product. Um, Yahoo, of course, is not in that business anymore, and neither is Amazon. Um, they, they shut that down a number of years ago. Um, and so since then, you know, Shopify has emerged and has been wildly successful as a SaaS e-commerce platform for small businesses. Um, and it sounds like Amazon doesn't like that, and so it sounds like they're, they're figuring out what their competitor's gonna be. And, uh, you know, it, it'll be really interesting if it's a revised version of those Amazon WebStores or something completely different.
48:11 I was, I was curious if you had any take on that. Yeah, it's tricky because… Yeah, maybe we'll talk about this. Let's save it for the predictions show. All right, fair enough. Um, but that's gonna be a fun one to watch. We'll, we'll pile on the teases, yeah. Yeah. I'll tell you what my favorite bit of news was since our last show. Um, Amazon came out with a product that totally surprised me. Um, they came out with a made-to-order T-shirt product. And, uh, the, the reason this is interesting to me is a common question I get asked is, like, "Hey, Jason, how do you compete with Amazon," right? And I used to have all these stock smart aleck answers.
48:52 Like, for a long time it was, like, you know, sell something that has a bunch of complicated attributes like, you know, car parts that you have to figure out how it fits in the engine. And, and as Scott will know, Amazon solved for that and is a huge player in car parts, right? And they have a fitment database and they do all that. Uh, and so then I used to tell people, "Oh, sell live plants." Like, Amazon doesn't know how to ship live plants. Um, so as all the listeners that got their Christmas tree from Amazon this year will know, Amazon now sells a fair amount of live plants. My wife buys live fish from Amazon. Um, so they've kinda figured out the plants and animals thing. And so, you know, my last smart aleck answer was always, like, sell custom, you know, made-to-order products, right?
49:38 Like, the Amazon fulfillment centers are all, you know, predicated on, on warehousing a bunch of something and shipping it fast to a customer. You know, they, they don't wanna make stuff on demand for customers. And so lo and behold , Amazon's like, "Yeah, we're gonna make custom T-shirts. We're gonna sell them for $25, and we're gonna ship it to you five days after you order it," which, um, the normal lead time in made-to-order apparel, you know, is, is usually measured in months. Um, so you think about, like, uh, Indochino that was on the, the, our, our show a, a number of years ago. Like, they've, they've done a lot in made-to-order suits. But, you know, it's, it's like a six to eight week… Um, made to order is getting increasingly popular, but it's still, like, his- you know, is kind of a sleepy industry that, like, made customers accept, like- uh, a lot of friction.
50:31 Like, you both would have to go to a tailor or go to a showroom and get measured, um, and then you'd have to go home and wait, you know, uh, weeks or months to get your, your stuff. So this felt like a disruptive offer to me from Amazon. Like, A, it was interesting that they're bypassing all their fulfillment centers and, and tackling custom-made products, and they're saying, "Hey, you know what? We're gonna use artificial intelligence and computer vision in the Amazon mobile app to measure you so you don't need to go to a showroom. We're just gonna use your webcam, y- the camera built in your phone to measure you, and then we're gonna make and fulfill the product in five days." And so, you know, whether, whether we all need custom T-shirts or not is an open question, but from a, from a, a intellectual exercise standpoint, this is a really interesting new space, and Am- and my initial reaction to Amazon's offer was, like, if they're able to deliver on that, that's, that's really strong.
51:28 And so, um, I, uh, took it upon myself to try it. Um- And so I ordered, uh, uh, I used the camera, the, uh, measured myself, and ordered a T-shirt a couple days after they launched the service. So I ordered… My order went in on December 16th. Um, they did promise five-day turnaround, and they were not able to do it. Like, obviously this happened over Christmas. Um, so my T-shirt arrived on, uh, December 29th, which is 13 days. Um, so if someone would've promised 13-day delivery for made-to-order apparel, I would've thought that was super impressive. I'll be honest, it felt a little disappointing because they set this expectation for five days.
52:12 Um, but I will say anecdotally, other people talking about this on social media, there definitely were people that got their, their first orders faster than I did. Um, and I'm willing to cut them a little slack that this was, you know, right over the, the, the Christmas spike. Um, so I'll, I'll be interested to do another order, um, you know, when things slow down a little bit and see if, if they're able to hit that five days. Uh, but you know, Cliff, you know, I know all the listeners are on the edge of their seat, I thought it was an awesome T-shirt. Uh, it's 25 bucks. Um, it was, I- you know, to my f- my sensibility, it was a very high quality fabric.
52:52 They have two options. They have a, a lightweight, uh, fabric that's like a blend of, um, uh, modal and cotton, and then they have a hun- a medium weight shirt that's 100% cotton. So I did the medium weight. Um, it fit me really well. Uh, it was a really easy process to use the, the, um, camera in my phone. Um, you know, a lot of people on social media were joking, like great, the, you know, the one piece of information Amazon didn't have about me, um, you know, my exact body size now I'm giving to Amazon and yeah, there, you know, there is a, uh, an interesting privacy story and data collection story here. But, uh, uh, as a consumer, uh, it's the best $25 T-shirt I've ever owned.
53:38 I probably have some more expensive T-shirts that, like, I like a little better, but, uh, um, it's darn impressive and, you know, it's not hard to imagine a future when you'd wanna get all your clothes custom made if you could do it that easily and that accurately. So I, I think that's a, this is a potential really interesting, um, offer and it, it is an interesting space. I've been watching the space. Uh, a- another company that had a exciting innovation at the same time is MTailor, and MTailor's been in this business of using your phone to measure yourself for a while. And the same time Amazon rolled out their service, MTailor upgraded their service to let you measure yourself using the LIDAR in the latest and greatest iPhones that you and I have.
54:21 So I was also eager to see if The, the LIDAR app on the MTailor could measure better than the camera app on Amazon. Um, so I did also order some custom clothes from MTailor. Um, the app came out a couple of days later, so I ordered, uh, uh, some clothes from them on the 20th, and it arrived just a couple of days ago, January 5th. So that was 16 days. Um, and it also fit pretty well. It's interesting. Um, I definitely don't feel like it was a better fit than Amazon that used, you know, the camera instead, uh, versus the LIDAR. Um, the… I will say the fits are slightly different, but my suspicion is that's just the design of the garments.
55:05 That, like, the Amazon shirt is designed to be a little bit of a slim fit and the, the MTailor is a little baggy. Um, but yeah, it's, it's interesting. I, I definitely think made to order could be the future of apparel. Um, and it could definitely be a disruptor if, if people are able to cost-effectively deliver better-fitting apparel, um, you know, that's as fast and friction-free as, as, uh, you know, we used to get off the rack. Yeah. And then, um, so are these T-shirts meant to be like undershirts, or y- do you typically get something printed on them, or how does that work? Yeah, uh, so, uh, these, uh, the, this first offering from Amazon is just T-shirts, and they're plain T-shirts.
55:46 They, they have two weights, and I, I suspect that the, the lighter weight is primarily intended to be used as an undershirt, and the, the heavier weight could be an undershirt, or it could just be a, a casual T-shirt. Um, I guess you could take it somewhere and have it silkscreened, but they're not selling any, any sort of graphics. Uh, they are selling it in a bunch of colors. Got it. Uh, awesome. And then, um, the LIDAR on the iPhone is on the back of the phone, so are you having to kinda like mount it on a tripod and stand in front of it while someone lines it up? Or like, how, how did you pull that off? That's a great- 'Cause you can't really do a selfie, right? That's a great question.
56:26 Uh, so side note, you're mostly right. Uh, iPhones actually had kind of a version of LIDAR on the front of the phone for longer. The face scanner actually is a, a, a time-of-flight sensor. It's not technically LIDAR. Um, but it doesn't go far enough to be useful for measuring your body, so you're right, the, the only, like, sensor on the iPhone is on the back. And so that makes it, uh, very difficult to use yourself, and so Amazon calls it a two-person process. And so they basically, um, you, you're… M- in my case, my wife held the phone and followed their instructions, and it played instructions for me over the speaker. So it's like, uh, you know, "Stand this way.
57:08 Rotate." Right? And I, I couldn't see the screen because my wife was holding the phone, so it required two people. Um, sorry, that's the M Taylor experience with the LIDAR. Uh, the Amazon is completely self-service. So Amazon has you rest the phone on the ground, um, with the, uh… And it's using the, the selfie camera, the front-facing camera. Um, and so you can see yourself on the screen. Um, and it, it, you know, was, I would say, easier. You could do it alone. Um, you know, you need to be wearing tight-fitting clothes or not wearing a lot of clothes when you do these things, so you could imagine- Ooh yeah, wanting, um, some privacy.
57:51 And then, you know- … you have to decide if you wanna, you can, you have to decide if you wanna trust these guys. But they all claim, like obviously they're sending a half-naked- So not only does Jeff have your picture he has- Yeah. Well, it's only fair- … you. … because we have his naked picture, so it's only fair that, that he should have ours. Um, they all claim as part of their privacy thing that they don't retain those images, that they just retain the measurements. But obviously, you know- Mm … every, uh, customers, uh, are gonna make their own determination about how much they trust all these vendors. But I, I do think that is one of the impediments here. Yeah, that's crazy. Oh, uh, sidebar. It is a very sad day for Jeff.
58:31 He is no longer the richest man in the world. I know, but I feel like you're a fanboy of two billionaires, and so it's like, I feel like one of your, one of your idols got replaced with another, if I'm not mistaken. It is, yeah. If I had to go, if I had to take one of my favorite billionaires to a deserted island, though, it'd probably be Elon, so I'm excited for him. He-- I do, I suspect he would just be more interesting. Yeah. Yeah, Jeff is, comes across as kind of a little grumpy lately. Uh, yeah, you talk about first world problems. Uh Any other Amazon news before we head to some other news? Uh, I- the two other small, uh, well, I g- a small one and a medium one.
59:15 Uh, the small one that I just, I just think is super awesome, uh, kind of statement for the pandemic. Uh, a- as you know, Amazon has an air force, uh, as part of their fulfillment network. Um, they lease all the planes, and so, uh, a big piece of news last week is Amazon bought their first 11 planes. Um, so obviously, uh, you know, they're, they're continuing to rapidly grow their own fulfillment capability and making a major investment. Um, and they bought eight of those planes from Delta Airlines. So in my mind, that's just the perfect kind of wrap-up of the pandemic right there, is that, like, airlines don't need their planes anymore 'cause no one's flying.
59:56 So Delta is selling all its planes to Amazon that needs all the delivery capacity they can get their hands on. Yeah, and we're converting malls into fulfillment centers, so there's, like, this huge shift of, of things, um, happening in, in all these industries. Exactly. Maybe we'll revisit that one on the, on the prediction show, but I'm, I'm, like, super not, uh, I, I, I'm cynical that we're gonna see a lot of malls turn into fulfillment centers, or at least, yeah. So we'll talk about that later. Um, but certainly it gets talked about a lot. And then the last piece of Amazon news we've talked about on the show before, but Amazon has a new grocery store format that's not Whole Foods. So it's called Amazon Fresh. They opened a couple in LA, uh, during the pandemic, so annoyingly, I had to read about them, but I couldn't go visit them.
1:00:41 Um, and, uh, apparently, uh, you know, we, as we know, Jeff's a frequent listener of the show, so he, he was kind enough to order them to, to open a Amazon Fresh store in Chicago. So I took my family as a holiday treat to drive, like, an hour into the suburbs of, uh, Chicago in Naperville and, uh, go visiting the Amazon Fresh grocery store. And you'll, you'll be happy to know, Scott, that the Amazon Fresh store is now my son's favorite grocery store. Oh, good. Did you, uh, did you put him in the little cart, and does it, like, ring him up? It's like you just bought a son. I did. I did. And thank- You bought a child. Yeah, thankfully they, they, uh, they, uh, he was not in their database, so I wasn't charged, charged for him.
1:01:26 Um, like, obviously I was going to observe the store. Um, and you know, my wife and five-year-old came with me. And, uh, um, to, to sort of make things even with Ste- uh, easy with Steven, we did let him, like, pick some treats, and he, like, brilliantly gamed me and my wife to double the amount of treats he was supposed to get. Um, so it's his favorite store because he came home with a bunch of, uh, junk food from Amazon. Um- Very cool … but from my perspective, uh, it's, it's pretty interesting. The… We've talked about the main features of the store before. Um, it, it does not have Just Walk Out technology, which the Amazon Go stores have, where the kinda cameras watch you- You and know what you put in the cart and just charge you when you leave.
1:02:10 Um, it has a smart shopping cart called the Dash Cart. So we, we did get a Dash Cart, and the Dash Cart works way better than I expected it to. So it has a screen in it, and it has a bunch of cameras, and, you know, reading about it, I thought, like, "Oh, you, you have to find the barcode on everything you buy and kinda rotate the barcode, um, to be lined up with the camera and, you know, scan it like you would if you were scanning something on your phone or on that self-service checkout, you know, thing at the grocery store." Um, and I have to say, the, the Dash Cart has cameras pointed in every direction, and it just automatically recognized all the products when they got even close to the cart.
1:02:54 So it was really good, um, at recognizing all the things that were in the cart, and so that part was impressive. Um, there's Alexas on the aisles that, uh, can be used for way finding. I thought that would be a silly gimmick, but it actually works shockingly well. Like, you, you know, you just go like, uh, you know, "A- Alexa, what aisle is the milk on?" And it, it gives you… Like, it totally understood that and gave you directions, like, much easier than, you know, finding someone in a typical grocery store to help you find the peanut butter or whatever. Um, so that was interesting. Uh, you know, it has my favorite feature. As you know, Scott, they have digital fact tags with ratings and reviews for every product in the store.
1:03:35 Um, so to me that really… Uh, ratings and reviews are super impactful in s- in terms of sales, and that really elevates how important they are when you're now using them for physical shopping. Um, so it had all the things that I had read about. The Dash Cart worked better than I thought. Uh, the Dash Cart still is a stupid gimmick even though it works really well, and I say that because they're afraid you're gonna steal the Dash Cart if they let you take it out of the store. So it kinda defeats the whole purpose. Uh, you, you go shopping in the Dash Cart, which by the way is too small and can only fit two shopping bags, um, and then when you get to the front of the store, someone takes the Dash Cart away from you, and you have to carry your groceries out into the parking lot or transfer them to a not-smart cart to push them out to the parking lot.
1:04:23 So that seemed like a, a really dumb, high, high-friction thing. Um, and at the moment, they, they have people auditing every Smart Cart. So you actually… Like, a person has to check to make sure that you, you properly got everything scanned in the cart, and I got to watch her interface. It's pretty spooky. Um, she can see the photo that the Dash Cart took of every product you put in there, and so she can… She does a quick check to make sure it kinda matches up. So, um, still seems like early days, a little gimmicky on the Smart Cart. Um, but the biggest surprise of all for me, which I save for the end of this recap, uh, is I will bet you anything that in the near future this Amazon Fresh store is a Just Walk Out store, which surprised the heck out of me.
1:05:14 And the reason I say that is because I counted 600 cameras in the ceiling of this store. Like, they- So they're, they're probably running it in the background, and they'll, they'll- Yeah, I think they're collecting data and- That's good because they can check it against the cart. That's exactly right. Uh, so I think- Yeah ordinarily, uh, there are always errors in self-checkout, right? But what most retailers have decided is, um, being 100% accurate is not cost-effective. So instead of like, you know, all these self-checkouts used to have scales, and they would, like, throw an error if you scanned something that didn't weigh what they expected. And over time, retailers all turned off the scales because they were spending more money, like, resetting those things than they were for the, you know, the shrinkage when someone bought the wrong product.
1:05:59 Um, so it, at first I was like, "Why would Amaz- Why is Amazon spending all this money and adding all this friction to make sure that the cart's 100% accurate?" Like, it already should be pretty accurate, and I think you just stated the reason. Because they want a source of truth for exactly what's in that cart so they can match that up with what they thought was in the cart from the, the overhead cameras and, and optimize that. So I, I definitely think, uh, like, th- there are way too many cameras, and they're configured exactly like a Go store. Um, and there's 100% coverage on the whole store. Uh, they either did all that to have hyper-accurate measurements on how people shop, and so maybe it's just a data collection thing.
1:06:41 But I, I think they're, they're getting ready to roll out Just Walk Out for a, a grocery shop-sized store. Yeah, when you do these machine learning algorithms too, so what, what they're probably doing is recording from the ceiling, and then they have the cart as the source of truth. Then they can go run, you know, 8,000 simulations of the ceiling data, and, and it will learn… The machine learning algorithm will use the cart data as the, the, the thing to learn against. And yeah, so that, that's, uh, that's why they need that, that one piece of data. And they don't need it for very long either. They could, you know, they'll have some target of, you know, 99.8% accuracy or whatever it is. And so you could see them, you know, after maybe 1,000 carts, they have enough data that they could then take the cart part out and then trust the, the JWAT at a bigger scale.
1:07:28 Yeah. No, and I think that's… Again, uh, nobody has said that about the LA store, so I, I'm curious if either no one noticed it or if that's a new thing that they just built into the Chicago store. But, uh, um, uh, it was pretty interesting. Having gone on one of these visits, I'd bet they, they didn't climb up into the shelves and pull off the digital fact tag wires and figure out where they went and all the, all the things that Retail Gate does. Uh, yeah, the, uh, they almost certainly have, have video of me tear- taking apart their fact tags and everything else. It's so funny 'cause not that long ago, I remember, like, you… It was really risky to just take pictures in a store.
1:08:10 Like, it was illegal to take pictures in a store. Um, and I have gotten caught and kicked out of stores for my entire career for taking pictures. And you think about it now, like, how, how ridiculous that is. Yeah. There's 600 cameras in the ceiling. Yeah. Uh, cool. Well, uh, coming out of Amazon news, um, one of my weird hobbies, uh, is not keyboarding, but, uh, I love to watch, uh, read S1s and follow the roadshows for folks that have. So two roadshows are live. Um, a lot of people aren't aware that when you go public, when you start your roadshow, which is usually closed outside of COVID, I imagine this is all being done by Zoom, but you actually put it up on this public website called Retail Roadshow.
1:08:55 And right now there's two that I think listeners would find interesting. There's Poshmark and Petco. So those are really good, uh, to watch and I strongly recommend them. Um, so they'll only be up there typically for 7 to 10 days, so this one, if you are interested, uh, strongly recommend checking that out. Um, as an entrepreneur, I love watching these because they're kind of the ultimate pitches, if you will, of, you know, these are companies that are, are obviously pretty large. They're either hundreds of millions if not billions of dollars in size, and I always learn something about how they pitch their company, how they talk about it, how they frame things. So I like it from an entrepreneurial perspective, but then I always learn something about cohorts or a new category or, um, you know, how they talk about subscriptions.
1:09:44 There, there's always a ton to learn from these, so I strongly recommend that for listeners. And then you sent me a really cool deck. Um, tell me about this, um, consumer trends deck that you've discovered. Yeah. Uh, so there's a journalist out there that, uh, uh, has been writing about commerce and that I followed for a while, Dan Frommer. Um, and, uh, uh, he has started his own newsletter. So there's a, a free v- version of this newsletter and a paid version of this newsletter. As you know, these kind of, you know, paid newsletters are, are super popular right now and is kind of one of the ways that good content creators are monetizing their content. Um, but Dan put together a 2021 consumer trends deck, um, and that's freely available on the website, so we'll put a link in the show notes.
1:10:36 Um, this is a PDF or 102, uh, slide, um, Google Slides deck, uh, and it's just an awesome recap of all the interesting consumer and retail trends that we've, uh, seen and been talking about all through this, this pandemic-altered year of 2020. Um, so as, as you know, Scott, like, uh, a, a giant, uh, uh, super dense deck that we always looked forward to every year is Mary Meeker's kind of state of the internet, um, deck. And as I think you and I were talking about offline, um, I used to really look forward to that deck every year and it had a bunch of useful insights in it In recent years, I've found it to be a little derivative and not as exciting or useful for me.
1:11:25 Um, but flipping through Dan's deck kind of rekindled that excitement that I used to get from the Mary Meeker deck. So this is, uh, uh, for anyone that enjoys this show, I'm pretty confident you're gonna find the deck super interesting. So I'd encourage everyone to, to check it out. Uh, and if you're interested, subscribe to Dan's newsletter 'cause he did a great job. Cool. Throwing over Meeker for Frommer. Yeah. Controversial. Exactly. We'll see how that goes for you. Yeah, yeah. I think, I think Meeker is still slightly more successful than Dan so far. She's a VC now, so maybe- VC … uh, maybe she'll add some more content and liven it up, shake it up. Especially once she hears that, um, you've switched to Frommer. I think that's gonna be a shot across the bow for her.
1:12:07 Ex- exactly. Uh, well, Scott, uh, it has happened again. You know, we took a couple weeks off, and we got out of practice, so, uh, sure enough, we blew through our allotted time. Um, as always, if listeners enjoyed this show, we sure would appreciate that five-star review. Uh, but, uh, I hope all the listeners had a wonderful holiday break, and thanks for listening. And we're, uh… Please tune in next week to check out the, the forecast show to see how much better Scott did than me, um, and to hear some interesting predictions for this year. Yeah. And, uh, 250 episodes. We really appreciate everyone's support. We wouldn't be doing this if we didn't have really engaged listeners.
1:12:50 We love, uh, all the feedback we get from you guys and really appreciate it and looking forward to another great year of commerce-ing. And until next time, happy commerce-ing. You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes or visit www.jasonandscot.com.
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed