EP007 - Holiday sales and shipping woes, how big Amazon really is
Episode 7 covers an update on brick and mortar holiday sales. The top 5 online shopping days. Shipping woes for UPS, Fedex, and Jet. Is e-commerce at a tipping point in-terms of overtaking brick and mortar sales? And a discussion about how large Amazon really is.
oin your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:00 Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here is Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. This is episode seven, being recorded on December 21st, 2015. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, and as always, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Happy Star Wars Week, Scott. Thanks, Jason. Welcome back to the US. It feels good to be on the same day.
0:40 That was kind of just very strange to me. It was time travel-ish. It was a little disorienting. I am, uh, very happy to be home. You know, I didn't tell you in advance, but this is a special episode. I've seen a bunch of statistics that most podcasts fail before episode seven, so we've actually passed an inflection point this week. Boom. We proved all the haters wrong. We lasted to episode seven, so take that all you haters that probably don't listen to the podcast. Exactly. And speaking of episode seven, uh, have you seen Star Wars yet? I have. I saw it twice. I chose the IMAX 3D format. I, I know you haven't seen it, so I don't wanna do any spoilers. I, uh, I really enjoyed it.
1:22 I think that JJ did an excellent job. So what was neat is seeing it twice, I picked up 5 or 10 things that second time, and I think I could go a third time and pick up 5 or 10 more things. So it's, it's quite dense, so go when you have a fresh mind, have a little caffeine beforehand, and, and enjoy. Very cool. And, uh, looking at the box office stats, you were not alone in your enjoyment of the Star Wars movie. Yeah, it was kind of interesting. I got to, uh, got to the line at 8:00 AM and thought I would be the first person there, and there was five people before me, and they were all podcasters oddly enough. So it was like the whole podcast crew. Now, did you bring episodes four, five, and six to watch in line when you got there at 8:00 AM? I didn't, but they, um, they did, and they had all kinds- … of, uh, we have, we had a lot of surreal Star Wars debates, as you can imagine.
2:06 I, I can indeed. In speaking of real-life Star Wars, when we first started this podcast, Jeff Bezos launched a rocket and landed it back on the pad, and I, I understand today that SpaceX did a, a similar, although potentially way more impressive fe- Yeah. They, um, sent a two-stage rocket that carried … I think they had supplies for the space station, and they landed the first stage back on land. Uh, and so that was pretty exciting because it's the first orbital, uh, rocket to actually take off and land. Yeah, which is very cool. And so the big distinction there is much higher. It got to like a practical altitude where it could do real commercial work like launch satellites and payloads and stuff.
2:48 Yeah. The Jeff Bezos company, which is called Blue Orbital, they did not go as high Got you. They, they kind of just flirted with the atmosphere and came right back down. Whereas this kind of circled the Earth a couple times, delivered a little payload out to the space station, and just came on, right on back down. And I, I feel like now that Elon Musk has guest starred on, uh, The Big Bang Theory, he's got, he's got several things to lord over Jeff Bezos. Yeah. And he's been in Iron Man. I haven't seen Jeff in that, so that's, that's another one. There you go. There, there, there's actually a, a good holiday reading thing for our folks if anyone is an Elon Musk fan, as I am. Uh, there's a biography out about him that is actually pretty good. It covers a lot more of the SpaceX stuff than I knew. Uh, and then some of the dirty secrets of X.com and, uh, some of his earlier companies.
3:33 And, um, pretty interesting. Um, I liked, uh, I like to do audiobooks. I have about a 30-minute commute so I can kind of chew through an audiobook in a week or two. So I did it on that format. But I'm sure the, the printed or ebook page is just as good. But, uh, you would never listen to an audiobook until you were caught up on the Jason and Scot podcast, I assume. Yeah. Usually I just listen to our podcasts until, uh, you know, three or four times and then I listen to an audiobook. Smart. So some really good news this week. Several weeks ago when we were doing the holiday edition of the show, we talked about a lot of those real-time forecasts, and we were seeing a lot of early data that e-commerce was up. And we were seeing, you know, the common narrative being that retail was down, uh, brick-and-mortar retail rather.
4:15 And at the time I think you and I both mentioned that take that with a grain of salt, that the methodologies that folks are using for that real-time data Is, uh, somewhat dubious. And, uh, sure enough, now we're starting to get some of the more credible data streams coming in. Um, and MasterCard just released their data for November, and they obviously see all the transactions that happen on the, the MasterCard-branded credit cards. And they showed the Cyber 5 up, and the whole month of Dec- November up by 4.6%. And then perhaps even more credible and helpful, the Department of Commerce released their November data. And if you take automobiles, gas, food, and building materials out of the retail number, uh, retail was up 6% in November, which is the biggest rise we've seen in like four or five months.
5:05 So some strong evidence that brick and mortar is actually doing, uh, reasonably well this holiday season, and obviously growing much slower than e-commerce, but, but it appears that the entire economy is doing, doing well in terms of, uh, holiday purchases. Hmm. News of retail's demise is greatly exaggerated. Good, uh, to hear for most of my clients, for sure. But speaking of the e-commerce growth, uh, do you have an update for us? Yeah. Yeah, we have some, uh, same store sales coming out tomorrow that I can't spoil. But what I can tell you is, uh, we always-- one of the things we look at is not only the year-over-year growth rates, which are always fascinating, but what were the top days of the year. So, um, I'm gonna do it David Letterman style.
5:48 I have the top five. Uh, the fifth biggest day was December 15, uh, which is the Tuesday after Green Monday. So that's kind of interesting. It's kind of a later day than, than we always have. December 1st was the fourth day, which is the Tuesday after Cyber Monday. So kind of interesting to see the Tuesdays perking up here this year. Uh, the number three day was December 14, which is called Green Monday, um, that was evidently coined by eBay The number two day was November 27th, which is also known as Black Friday. And then, drum roll, the number one day for 2015 was November 30th, which was Cyber Monday. Ah. So certainly not a surprise, those top three.
6:31 I'm curious, did you see those Tuesdays perform that well last year? Or have you looked at multiple years? 'Cause we don't hear as much talk about the Tuesday spikes. I did go back and look at the Comscore data and, uh, and our data, and it was very unusual this year to see those Tuesdays. I, I look forward to seeing if Comscore saw the same thing, but their data won't come out for, for a long time, so we'll have to, we'll have to kinda sit on pins and needles until that comes out to see if it was, it was something about our customer base or what was going on there. Gotcha. Well, now that we've passed seven episodes, we'll almost certainly be around when that data does come out, so we'll, we'll be able to close the loop on that. Absolutely. I also noticed there are a bunch more articles starting to hit talking about shipping struggles on e-commerce, and I know we, we talked earlier about some of the potential struggles that UPS was facing.
7:18 I've now started to see some articles that, that track the percentage of on-time shipments, and they're, they're showing from a few different sources UPS dropping from their usual 97% down to, like, a 91 or 92% of all shipments on time. And I know they've now passed this threshold where they're, they're actually promising slightly slower delivery times, so that catches some people off guard. You know, overall it, it seems like we're seeing exactly what we discussed could be a challenge that, gosh, U- UPS added 6% capacity this year. From multiple sources, we're seeing e-commerce grow at, like, 16%. And for most retailers, UPS is the preferred and, and dominant, uh, shipping source that, that's used.
8:03 So it feels like they're seeing the most pain from this e-commerce growth. At the same time, I saw an article from FedEx saying that, "Hey, we're having a great quarter, and our profits are actually up 4% because, uh, we're, we're doing more e-commerce orders than we anticipated." And, you know, they generally deliver a lot less e-commerce packages than UPS does. Part of that's 'cause their network is much more optimized for business deliveries, and UPS does a little better at home deliveries. But in that FedEx article, what I found interesting is Fred Smith was talking a lot about winners and losers in e-commerce amongst FedEx customers, and what he was describing was that FedEx made all their customers forecast their demand for shipping, and that some retailers did a really good job of forecasting their demand, and they anticipated this growth and were able to use FedEx to help meet it.
8:53 But other retailers did not forecast the growth very well, and FedEx actually turned down their packages, uh, because they simply didn't have the, the capacity. And so they-- You know, he was talking about there was a clear distinction between retailers that were doing well at their forecasts and retailers that were not doing well. And, you know, frankly, when I read that, my mind went instantly to some of the stories we talked about earlier, like Target or Finish Line, that were literally having to throttle customers coming to the website because they didn't have enough servers to support all the, the demand. And if, if you're not forecasting the demand for the servers, you're almost certainly not forecasting demand for, for the shippers. Um, and so I, I have a feeling, uh, that some of the same retailers that were throttling a little bit, we're also gonna see not have as good, uh, access to the shippers based on those bad forecasts.
9:42 It's kinda tough to say to your customers, "Hey, we're glad you're doing so well, but we really can't, uh, take your packages. Sorry. Glad you're beating your forecast, but, you know, do better at forecasting." Exactly. Sometimes you just can't. You know, you get, you know, you, you have a runaway product, or you get some kind of a promotion that kinda goes, uh, rogue on you, and you… It's very hard to predict these things. Absolutely. Although, this should be the time of year when those spikes are more predictable than a particular promotion, for example, that way outperforms expectations. Yeah. I've actually seen some cool plugins even, uh, some, some, uh, statisticians have built plugins for Google Analytics that can actually look at your historical data and help you do more database forecasting, which is kinda cool.
10:24 But I did also see some shipping news from Jet. Did you see that? I did. So Jet has kind of a system-wide message up. Uh, and they've had it up for a while now, I think three days, maybe four, um, where they've just been, you know, pretty clear saying that there's a high probability your deliver- delivery will not be there by Christmas. And there's kinda two takes to that story. So they've, they've gotten a little bit of a black eye in the press. People are kinda saying, you know, the headlines are, "Jet can't guarantee Christmas delivery." That was from the USA Today. And then, uh, Recode had, "Jet misses last-minute Christmas sales and shows the downside of its model," uh, essentially saying that because it's a marketplace and not a retailer, um, like Amazon, that it can't guarantee delivery.
11:04 Um, Jet kinda-- when you peel the onion on those articles, Jet's whole argument was, uh, "You know what? We're having such a great December that we decided to be really, um, you know, a bit obsessive about customer service and, and underpromise and overdeliver, uh, and make sure that people knew that there was some risk they wouldn't get their packages." So it's kinda tricky to, you know- To understand what the right path there is. I, I do think it's better to be very upfront and not risk upsetting your customers, especially when you're, you're young and whatnot. Um, but you know, you definitely turn away business when you do that, so it's definitely a long-term kind of mindset. Uh, you're damned if you do, damned if you don't sort of thing. And I, I think it's also true as a marketplace, they just have a little less control over their whole supply chain and how fast vendors will ship and, um, and obviously they try to optimize those shipments through, through a, a wider variety of, of delivery tools than some other retailers do.
11:57 So- Yeah … in some ways there's just more risk built into their supply chain than, than some other retailers. Yeah, one of the articles said they were working on some things to, to try to add a little bit more capability there. And so we, we've seen that, uh, in a couple marketplaces. So the way Alibaba works is they actually, uh, have a network of 3PLs that they recommend, so it's kinda like a networked FBA kind of a model. Um, so they have a little bit more integration with fulfillment systems that are there. Uh, so it's kinda like a tier one, tier two kind of a thing. Uh, and then, uh, Amazon's actually doing this with something called Merchant Fulfilled Prime Eligible, where for certain retailers that have a deeper integration, uh, they can sign up for the Prime promise and their products will show up Prime eligible.
12:39 So there, there are some technological things that Jet can do that, uh, you know, just because they're a marketplace, don't count them out of being able to solve some of that. Um, just that, that a lot of marketplaces like eBay has never really kinda gotten their head around it. An- another interesting aspect in the Recode article, they essentially said, "Hey, we're gonna do around 45 million in GMV in December, um, and we have two million actives." So that was kind of a interesting new data point that, that I hadn't seen them talk about before. Uh, if you do the math on that, that puts them at kind of a, you know, call it a $600 million-ish kind of run rate, which is, which is pretty impressive. So, so nice kinda start for Jet, and I… They're really only four or five months old now, so um, you know, well on their way to being a, a pretty big player.
13:21 Uh, another marketplace that's growing really rapidly is called Wish, and the last data I saw on them, I think they were at 500 million run rate, but that's probably three or four months old, and it wasn't a holiday kind of in there. So, you know- Jet coming out of the gates very strong. And I actually respect that they're, they're taking a long-term view here and turning away customers if they can't make them happy. Yeah, absolutely. And I, I would certainly imagine that, that Jet's advertising budget is considerably larger than Wish's. Yeah. Yes. I don't know, though, if you've ever, uh, uh, if you've ever seen those suggested apps. Wish is always in mine. I don't know. Maybe I'm just, uh, targeted or something. If you were gonna target people for a marketplace app, I feel like you would be one of the people I would target.
14:02 Yeah, maybe that's what's going on. Match my audience. You know, an article that, that caught my attention, and I, I feel like it might becoming a- an annual tradition. CNBC ran an article quoting Jeff Jordan, who's one of the, the founders of Andreessen Horowitz, a, a famous VC. And he, he was talking about this year being the e-commerce tipping point. And he's telling this story about how he and Marc Andreessen are sitting in a, a retail board meeting, and the, the retailer is, you know, expressing their, their regret that they had tied up all their inventory in all these stores, and now couldn't get it to all the customers that wanted it. And that gosh, they wish they just held all this inventory in a fulfillment center that they could l- deliver via e-commerce.
14:45 And in Jeff's mind, that that was a clear proof point that, uh, Marc's earlier prediction that retail is eventually gonna die, and all of this shopping is gonna go e-commerce is, is, uh, here this year. Yeah. The, um… I think it was about 18 months ago. They had a post in, um… My favorite part of that post is they had the adoption rate by category. Um, and I do have a Wall Street, uh, report that kind of updated that. I, I forget where they get the data. I think it's a combination of the Department of Commerce and the Forrester stuff. So, you know, some, some categories are way ahead, and others are, are still very laggy, so it's kind of interesting to watch that. The other one is, you know, how do we, how do we rate versus other countries is always pretty interesting. And like you said in, you know, I think in the US, depending on which one you look at, we're either at 12% or 8%, depending on certain things that are in or out.
15:32 Uh, but then you have companies like, countries like Korea, where they're up in the high teens or even into the 20s. So I think I agree with them that we, we still have a lot of room to run. I, I do think that there's a lot of blocking and tackling that has to happen to get there. Uh, for example, shipping. You know, if, if this were kind of like drinking a, uh, you know, a ginormous thing through a tiny straw here. We've, we've gotta get that part of the capacity to expand i- if we're gonna, you know, make sales in the US online as big as they are in China, for example. A- absolutely. And, and, you know, forget as big as China. If you're, if you're actually gonna get to a tipping point where you're at, like, 50% e-commerce, we're generously at 10% right now, so we're, we're talking about, you know, the UPSes and FedExes of the world having five times as many trucks as they have now.
16:20 And certainly that, that could happen, but it doesn't feel like next year is the year that that's gonna happen. Yeah, I saw you got in a little bit of a, a tweet, uh, battle with, uh, JJ. How did that go for you? Probably went better for him. I think he, he has a few more followers than me. That's actually not true. He's like, "Listen here, retail geek." Exactly. More of my followers were my… are my family members than him, I think, is the main, the main distinction. But, uh, no, I mean, I think he's well-intentioned, and he did, you know, cite that US Department of Commerce data, and it, you know, it sh- obviously there are a bunch of categories that are growing real fast, and there's one category that's well over, you know, 20%, approaching 40%, but it, it's digital goods, so they don't have the shipping constraint, and that, you know, to me makes, makes perfect sense.
17:06 You don't have to touch them, try them, sit on them, feel them. The Department of Commerce data isn't super current, so it takes a long time for it to come out. A lot of the other data sources, like Forrester and Comscore, have kinda declared apparel the number one or number two category, and some of those guys put that now at, like, 26% in the US. So, you know, I think that's, that's a leading category, and the fact that, that, you know, one out of every four dollars spent on apparel in the US is spent online is pretty darn impressive to me. I just don't think that it's a foregone conclusion that we're, we're just one or a couple years away from 25% becoming 50%, and I certainly don't think it's true for all categories.
17:50 Yeah. And this is a good segue because as an industry, we're really starting to butt up against this whole shipping capacity thing, right? Um, and one, one thing I've been following very closely is Amazon and what they're doing, and this all started with the shipping debacle of two thousand and thirteen, where there was, I think it was-- was it three million or four million packages that, that UPS couldn't deliver? Since then, Amazon's been kind of meticulously building out their, their infrastructure, not, not within fulfillment centers, but, but kind of further down the chain of the last mile. Uh, the first thing they did is they built fifteen sortation centers. I, I believe by our math, they're up to about twenty-two sortation centers. Uh, and then now we're starting to hear a lot of interesting reports about them having, uh, tractor-trailers that are, are going between fulfillment centers, kind of, uh, that B2B part of what happens there, kind of the load balancing between fulfillment centers.
18:44 Uh, and then this week there was a report out that they're in negotiations to lease, uh, over twenty jets to have kind of an air service between… It's not exactly clear what they're gonna do with these jets. You know, there's, um, some people are assuming it's just kind of for internal use. Uh, the, the thing that I've been thinking about, um, having watched Amazon for a while, is just to kind of rewind a little bit, they have a very interesting playbook, and the first couple pages of that playbook are pretty familiar. They test a lot of stuff, à la Google or Apple, and if it works, uh, that's great, they scale it up. If it doesn't work, they kill it. So, uh, the Fire Phone, I think we would all agree is kind of in that kind of killed it category. They had an auction thing they tried for a while that they killed. Um, but, but then what's unique about their playbook is after they've tried something, it's worked, and they've scaled it, then the thing they do that's kind of non-intuitive, especially for people in offline businesses, is then they open it up for anyone, and they share the cost.
19:39 And, uh, so, so y- the cloud computing is the most obvious example of that, where you have a company like Walmart, and they have this huge computing infrastructure, and, you know, they know when women are pregnant before they do kind of a thing, uh, because of their big data platform. But they view that as their core asset, and they don't let anyone look-- use it. Whereas Amazon said, "Wow, it sure is expensive to have all these computers sitting idle, you know, for every day except Cyber Monday. What if we kind of shared the cost of that with these other folks?" And thus, the cloud computing was born. They've, they've replicated that model with, you know, literally hundreds of different things that they've done. The other one that's obvious is fulfillment centers with FBA. So one of the things we've started thinking about, uh, about four years ago is, you know, once they have all this, this infrastructure, why can't they just get into the delivery business themselves?
20:27 Why can't I ship a package and, you know, Amazon's coming to my office every day anyway, why can't they pick up a bunch of packages and take them to California or something like that? Um, there's a famous Jeff Bezos quote where it says, "Your margin is my opportunity." And I kinda think they look at that and say, "You know, we've built 80% of what we need to be a FedEx or a UPS. L- let's, let's start selectively just chipping away at the other 20%. And the, the other thing I, I think that's interesting about this is, um, you know, Amazon knows exactly where the most profitable customers are 'cause they know how much they order from Amazon Um, where they all live, how much Amazon is paying to the UPSes and FedExes of the world.
21:07 So they can actually kind of come at this in a very kind of margin smart way and say, "We're gonna take the highest margin routes and start to trim those and clip them off of UPS and FedEx and put them onto our system," and then work their way down. And they could even stop. So they can say, "Hey, this big vast area of Wyoming, we will always use FedEx and UPS. We'll give them that unprofitable route, uh, and then we will keep all the big metros and these other cities that make sense for us." So, um, so we've been talking about this for a while. Um, and, uh, then now it's starting to gain. These last two reports, there's starting to be a lot more Wall Street analysts that are picking up on this, and then also, uh, press reports coming out. What, what do you think about it, Jason?
21:47 I think it makes perfect sense. I mean, as we've talked about, the ability to deliver products to consumers is a major growth constraint. And so it's totally smart for Amazon to be investing in growing that capacity themselves. And, uh, like many other products, I certainly think, uh, that there is an opportunity for them to turn that infrastructure into incremental profit by offering it to other people. But I tell you, what would be scaring the bejesus out of me if I'm UPS or FedEx or the US Post Office is that Amazon has a pretty proven track record of iterating and improving way faster than those other businesses.
22:28 And so, you know, them getting into the business, they're likely to be very competitive and, uh, be very disruptive. Yeah, the thing for listeners to think about is would you use… You know, let's say Amazon came to you and said, "Hey, Mr., uh, you know, IR20 retailer, um, we have a feeling that FedEx couldn't satisfy all of your needs. We can do it for you, you know, through Amazon Air, and, uh, we can do it for 20% less than FedEx, and we're not gonna have that silly holiday constraint," you know? So that, that starts to be a really interesting question for retailers. You know, maybe you wouldn't use them for cloud computing, and certainly you wouldn't use them to power your store, uh, and you probably won't use them for fulfillment, but would you use them-- or fulfillment centers, warehousing, but would you use them as a courier?
23:13 Yeah. And the more of those services that get bundled up, the harder it, it can become to say no, right? So Amazon, you know, productized their payment service, and so, you know, checkout by, uh, with Amazon, they pitched to all the retailers. And, you know, frankly, it didn't get a lot of traction, largely because big retailers don't wanna brand their site with Amazon logos. And then we've seen Amazon come back and say, "Well, what if we found some way to introduce Prime Eligible into the equation?" And now, you know, suddenly giving you access to all these highly profitable customers that Amazon has. And then they can come after that and say, "And we've got this great air cargo service that can solve a bunch of problems for you."
23:55 Uh, at some point you- It, it becomes hard to keep resting your laurels on the fact that they're a direct competitor, um, when they have the most competitive offering out there and you need it to serve your customers Yep. Um, so I, I'm very bullish on Amazon investing in, uh, fulfillment. I'll, I'll tell you the other common story you hear for solving the fulfillment problem that I'm way less bullish on is, "Oh, all these shipment problems are going away because we're all gonna, we're gonna be able to ship all these packages via Uber." Yeah, I'm not sure I believe in that. The, the economics doesn't really work because, you know, even a short Uber trip is kind of a good 10, $20, so the economics go the wrong way on that one, I think.
24:38 Um, however, you know, Amazon is playing around with a similar model with this Flex kind of concept. Uh, another, another solution I hear a lot of times is, um, you know, we're gonna ship from the store and, and, uh, you know, I'm not a huge believer in that. I'm curious, what do, what do you think about that? Well, so I like ship from store a lot. If you have goods in store, you should be shipping from store, right? Like, you need to unlock that inventory and make it available to more of your customers, and once those goods are already in the store, there's lots of efficiencies in delivering those to customers that are very close to you. Comma, the economics just can't be the case that it's more efficient to send tho- those goods from a manufacturer to a DC to a store, have someone unpack those goods in the back, put them on the shelf, and then pay someone else to pull those off the shelf and deliver them to a consumer.
25:27 So I, I don't think it's a highly efficient supply chain if you're only thinking about getting the products to the consumer at home. I do think there's a bunch of extra benefits to having those products on the shelf, like the fact that millions of people see them and then want them, and it's a powerful marketing tool, and once you've put them on the shelf, you should certainly also l- leverage that inventory by delivering from that shelf, is sort of my take. Yeah, if you can deliver a good customer experience. If, if you're getting a high failure rate of, of, you know… My, my story on that is I always get, like, this high failure rate. I'll try it, and then it says, "Sorry," you know, "we went to get the product, and it wasn't there." It must be in someone's cart, they always say.
26:07 I'm kinda like, "Wow, there's so many products in carts wandering through these stores. It's amazing." That, you know, brings up a- another news tidbit from this week. Uh, The Washington Post had an article talking about buy online, pickup in-store, or, uh, BOPIS, as we, we often say in the US. Um, and in this article, they're quoting a, a Kurt Salmon study that 60% of all buy online, pickup, in-store orders that were placed on Cyber Monday had some flaw in them. So customers didn't get the product they expected or had a, a delay or, you know, uh, some, some other mistake that literally 60% of the BOPIS orders were flawed.
26:48 And the, the article included a bunch of anecdotal stories about customers that were, you know, severely inconvenienced by a bad BOPIS experience and aren't likely to use it again. Wow. Does that ring true with you? Do you think 60% is the right number? I think it depends on how strict you're being in defining something wrong. Like, I, I don't think 60% of all BOPIS orders, at least for any of the customers that I've looked at, um don't get the goods to the consumer. Could there be a delay when the consumer gets there? Could there be a misunderstanding about where the consumer's supposed to go to pick up those products? Could, you know, lots of things that shouldn't happen and are bad customer experiences I do think happen with BOPUS.
27:28 And I do think there's a way too high of a real failure rate where literally the goods just aren't available and the customer, you know, wasted a trip going to the store. You know, I think that's a service that's kind of in the infancy. Retailers have figured out that it's really important for customers, that there's a bunch of value in offering it, but retailers really haven't invested and f- uh, solved all of the logistics challenges about doing it well and holding themselves to a very high standard. Yeah. I've, I've found if I can kinda mix two or three cutting edge things, then my failure rate goes up towards 100%. So if I, if I do, um, BOPUS with, like, PayPal, oh, that just destroys these things. They… You know, I get to the store and they're like, "You haven't paid."
28:10 I'm like, "Yes, I have." And they said, "How?" And I'm like, "PayPal." And they just look at me like I'm from another planet. Yeah. I think what you really wanna do with that order is mix in a return for part of the cost, too, and see how that goes. Whether you're a big fan of BOPUS or not, I do think the, the British have it right. Like, they call it click and collect, which just sounds much cooler than BOPUS. Yeah. And they have collection centers. Yep, absolutely. That does take me to the next topic that was somewhat interesting. You know, we, we talked about Amazon being really the only retailer that's making a major investment in their own fulfillment capacity. There have been a bunch of articles this week talking about how Amazon is really eating the overall marketplace, right? And so I think there was a Bloomberg article that you were quoted in, a- and then the title was Amazon's Eating E-Commerce.
28:56 Yeah. I mean, there's, uh, one analyst had, uh, I think he said that if you look at kind of the, that gains that are coming from the 15% growth of, of e-commerce, Amazon's getting a disproportionate share. And I think he had something like, was it 60% or 50%? Yeah. Yep, 60%. Yeah. Yeah, and if you do the math, it, it, it actually makes sense. Um, so yeah, I, I definitely think this is… It, it's just amazing that Amazon's at their scale and still growing, you know, all in. I- in our data, 20%, but when they report, it'll actually be higher because of the, the effect of the, uh, the EGM category, electronics and general merchandise. They're just really doing very, very well. It's gotta be particularly disheartening. There's a number of retailers looking up at Amazon that are making billion-dollar investments in their own e-commerce infrastructures.
29:44 And to be spending billions of dollars and still having Amazon extend the gap on you, you know, it has to be pretty terrifying. Yeah. You know, Walmart, uh, is building a lot of, uh, they're kind of number two out there in, uh, in e-commerce, and they're building all these fulfillment centers. But I think they get to six here when they're done with this last build-out. And, you know, Amazon has like 100 and, and 30 or 40, so it's tough Yeah, no, I, I get asked to comment on the, on the Walmart competition with Amazon a lot, and, you know, I, I tend to tell people I don't think Walmart is even looking to challenge Amazon for share at this point. Like, I think all of Walmart's investments, which are pretty prodigious, are really around protecting wallet share of the existing Walmart customer.
30:30 Um, and so I, you know, I don't even think their aspiration is to peel off Prime customers from, from Amazon at this point. I think they'd be happy to keep the loyal, uh, Walmart customers in the family and stop the defections. Yeah, you know, one thing that kind of is a little tricky with a lot of these articles is, um, and we spend a lot of time talking to the press and retailers about this, but it kind of takes a while for it to land, so introduce it to our listeners here. It, it's how big is Amazon? And, uh, you know, so Amazon's revenue is one number, but what's tricky about it is there's kind of two parts of Amazon packaged in that revenue number. There's the first party, which is where Amazon's the retailer, and then there's third party, where Amazon's the marketplace.
31:10 What causes a lot of the confusion is d- due to accounting rules, this thing called GAAP accounting that we all have to live by, um, when you're a retailer and you sell, let's, let's pick a $100 item Uh, you, when you're a retailer and you sell a hundred dollar item, the revenue's a hundred dollars, and then you have a normal reta-retail P&L. However, if you, Jason, sold that same hundred dollar item on Amazon as a third-party seller, Amazon's revenue is now, you know, essentially ten percent, which is their commission or their take rate, uh, minus payment. Usually they'll charge twelve percent, but two comes out as payment, so we'll just-- to keep the math easier, we'll call it ten percent. So for that exact same item, Amazon's revenue is now ten dollars. What that does is it has the, the unintended or maybe intended by Amazon, I, I'm kind of convinced Amazon likes it when this is kind of hidden, uh, that understates Amazon's scale.
31:58 So let me give you some numbers here. So this year, Wall Street kind of forecast that Amazon's global revenue will be, uh, a hundred and seven billion. So, you know, maybe they'll get a little higher than that if they have a great Q4, but, you know, call it a hundred to a hundred and ten billion, uh, which is pretty amazing, and they're growing twenty percent, right? So that, that's, that's huge. The US revenues within there, uh, are, are about sixty billion. But all that is first party. Now, Amazon really only gives you one metric, and what they say is forty-six percent of their units are from third party. But that's-- the, the keyword there is units. And what's tricky is the bulk of the media business, which is still a-a-about a third of Amazon's sales, is in one P.
32:39 And as you can guess, media has a low average order value, kind of sub ten dollars these days. You know, when's the last time you paid over ten dollars for an e-book or a DVD or anything like that? So, um, so what that does is it also has the unintended or intended consequence of making you think forty-six percent of the business is one P and-- or is, um, is three P. But it's actually quite higher because the average order value is, in three P, is higher because of the media imbalance. So we, we do this whole calculus at ChannelAdvisor where we, we literally back out all this. We, we have a pretty good idea about what these average order values are, and we can get to units, and we can get to the forty-six percent, and we can make it all work. Um, and the, the punchline is if you, if you do that, and we look at two thousand and fifteen, for example, the one P GMV will be ninety-three billion dollars.
33:26 So you take that 107 in revenue, you have about 14 billion, uh, some of that's AWS, but then the rest is third-party revenue, and then you have 93 billion is actually first party, uh, where revenue equals GMV. But then we have to multiply times 10 that essentially, uh, $13 billion that's out there. So now we get $130 billion for the third party GMV. So Amazon's total global GMV for this year will be 225 billion compared to 107 in revenue. Then if we look at the US, it's 135 billion. So the, the punchline is Amazon is effectively twice as big as people think it is because they're undercounting the third party GMV.
34:06 So, um, so, you know, if you're worried about it, uh, at the current scale of kind of thinking of it about, uh, you know, kind of 60 billion in the US, they're actually north of 135 billion in the US, which is, which is pretty impressive. And I think that's fair because when they sell a third party item, uh, Walmart loses out on, uh, the $100, the GMV, not the commission. So, so I, I think that's kind of a fair comparison, and you have to look at it way, that way because it is the transactional value. Certainly offline retail loses the transactional value. Yep. That… I mean, and that certainly captures the wallet share from the consumer. I'm always amazed by how few people seem to get that. So, like, you go to Internet Retailer and their, their IR500, and they, they have Amazon listed at $60 billion in revenue.
34:52 Like, there was a article on LinkedIn this week talking about how, how Amazon's forty percent of all e-commerce and is as big as the, its next twenty-one competitors, and it, it cited Amazon at sixty billion. And y- I'm reading those articles and I'm going, "Yeah, but, you know, Scott has taught me that Amazon's actually 135 billion," and frankly, that, that 3P revenue is, is probably more profitable business for Amazon than the 1P is in many cases. Yeah, I, I think it's been kind of the… Amazon has had two cash cows, and for a long time we didn't realize that AWS was a cash cow, and now they've had to split it out and, and that's been pretty amazing. Uh, and then the other one that if they ever split it out, I think, you know, people would be floored, is the 3P business.
35:33 I, I suspect it's extremely profitable for them. It's hard to lose money on 3P sales, where it's, you know, darn easy to have slow turns on 1P sales and lose money. Absolutely. One important correction I wanna make is that if I sell $100 in merchandise, I'm selling it on Tmall at a 4% take rate, not on Amazon at a 12% take rate. So I'm making a lot more on that $100 sale. Okay. And you'll figure out how to, how to promote it and ship it to China. Ab- absolutely. Well, I'm not … Not necessarily. People are shopping, uh, Tmall all over the world now. Yeah, yeah. You could be on AliExpress, for example. Exactly. Interesting topic for, uh, people to keep in mind that, that, you know, Amazon is really a juggernaut in the US, that they are eating a disproportionate percentage of the growth in e-commerce.
36:20 And, you know, a lot of the simple-minded articles we see really understate how, how dominant they're being. This is sort of a, a false, uh, comfort, but the … You know, the one thing you can point out is as big as Amazon seems and as big a percentage as they seem of, of US sales, Alibaba is actually even quite a bit larger. Um, so while Amazon might be, like, 40 or 60% of US e-commerce, someplace in there depending on how you count, Alibaba is, like, 80% of China's e-commerce, and it's 80% of a much bigger number now. Yeah, and they're bigger than Amazon, so there's always a bigger fish. And, you know, we've, we've gone through these cycles in the, the tech world where everyone thought Microsoft was invincible, and then Google kind of took the realm.
37:04 And then now you have Apple ascending, and, um, you've got … You know, Amazon is, is out there on e-commerce. But what are Apple and Google gonna do? Um, it's gonna be kinda interesting to watch this play out, which is a good tease for our next show, where we'll do some holiday predictions. But why don't you kinda tell folks what's gonna happen to get us there? Our next episode, uh, we will cover some, some of, uh, both Scott and my predictions for next year. Um, but I know, uh, Scott, uh, we both have vacations planned for next week, so, uh, you may have to wait two weeks for those predictions, and I think we'll skip next week's podcast, if that's okay. Yeah. Now that we've made it to episode seven, it's kinda smooth sailing. So we might as well just kinda take a, take a week off.
37:45 Exactly. Hopefully that will build up the anticipation that much more. If you haven't gotten a chance to listen to all seven episodes, this is your chance to catch up and be ready and fresh, uh, for episode eight. Yep. Well, everyone have a happy holiday and a happy New Year. Uh, happy holidays and merry Christmas. You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes and please leave a review.
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed