EP335 - Kevin Ertell The Strategy Trap
EP335 - Kevin Ertell The Strategy Trap In this electrifying episode of the Jason & Scot Show, recorded on Friday, October 10th, 2025, hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg and Scot\t Wingo welcome a very special guest and longtime friend, Kevin...
EP335 - Kevin Ertell The Strategy Trap
In this electrifying episode of the Jason & Scot Show, recorded on Friday, October 10th, 2025, hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg and Scot\t Wingo welcome a very special guest and longtime friend, Kevin Ertell. With over 30 years of combined history, the duo dives into Kevin's impressive career trajectory, his extensive experiences in retail and strategy execution, and the valuable insights behind his newly released book, "The Strategy Trap: Why Companies Fail at Execution and How to Get It Right."
Kevin's impressive background spans from starting at Tower Records to holding senior positions at iconic companies like Borders, Nike, and Sur La Table. He discusses his evolution in the retail space, the intricacies of establishing the first TowerRecords.com site, and his current role advising various businesses, including helping the Minnesota Timberwolves with their ticketing operations. As he unveils his book, listeners learn about the core theme: effective execution is the linchpin of successful strategy.
Kevin breaks down the key concepts of his book, structured around the "six C's" that are critical for avoiding common pitfalls in strategic execution—co-creation, clarity, capacity, communication, coordination, and coaching. He emphasizes the importance of bringing teams together in the co-creation phase to ensure buy-in and alignment on the strategy, a central pillar in fostering commitment across the organization. The conversation touches on the significance of clarity in communication and the necessity of creating a space for people to provide feedback and understand their roles.
Throughout the episode, Scot and Jason explore Kevin's practical strategies and actionable advice for leaders looking to strengthen their execution capabilities. Kevin offers insights on leveraging constraints creatively, encouraging listeners to view limitations as opportunities for innovation, much like how companies like Costco manage to maintain low prices while driving efficiency.
As the discussion unfolds, the trio delves into the nuanced nature of workplace culture, highlighting the benefits of psychological safety, the impact of social incentives, and the importance of regular communication channels to keep everyone aligned within the execution framework.
Moreover, they touch on fascinating concepts such as pre-mortems, a proactive method of anticipating potential failures before launching a project, differentiating it from the traditional post-mortem analysis. This mindset shift encourages teams to address concerns upfront, minimizing the likelihood of catastrophic missteps in execution.
As the episode wraps up, Kevin shares his hopes for the book's impact, inviting listeners to access "The Strategy Trap" at their local bookstores or online. He emphasizes the vital interplay between strategy and execution, urging leaders to recognize that a well-crafted strategy is only as strong as its execution plan.
Join us for this enlightening discussion filled with practical lessons, captivating anecdotes, and a wealth of insights from an industry veteran. Tune in, and let’s embrace better execution practices for a thriving business landscape!
Episode 335 of the Jason & Scot Show was recorded on Friday, October 10th, 2025
Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, Chief Commerce Strategy Officer at Publicis, and Scot Wingo, CEO of ReFiBuy and Co-Founder of ChannelAdvisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:23 Welcome to the Jason and Scott Show. This episode is being recorded on Friday, October 10th, 2025. I'm your host, Jason Retail Geek Goldberg. And as usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scott Wingo. Hey, Jason, and welcome back, Jason and Scott Show listeners. Well, Jason and listeners, we have a real treat for you on today's episode. Jason and I have both known Kevin Ertel for about 15 years each. So that's about 30 years by my calculations, Jason. Yeah, it probably fell longer to Kevin. It did. It probably felt like 60. We get a 2x multiple. The two of us together are a lot to handle.
1:03 And we'll get into his amazing career. But what's really exciting is he has a book dropping, and we were able to get him, due to that 60-year relationship, on the show to tell our listeners about it. The book is called The Strategy Trap, Why Companies Fail at Execution and How to Get It Right. Kevin, welcome to the show. Thanks, guys. Great to be here. It's been a bit since I was last on and I'm excited to be here. Yeah, yeah. We had the interns looked and they couldn't find it. It's been that long ago. Yeah. It predates recorded history. Yeah. It was chiseled on a tablet somewhere. We'll have to dig it up, literally. Yeah. So as you alluded to, Kevin, this is not your first time on the show.
1:46 If memory serves, the first time you were on this show, you were with Sir LaTabla at the time. Is that correct? Yeah, that's right. It was, yeah, back in 2015, I guess. But yeah, a few things have happened since then. Yeah. And weirdly, our careers like overlap and coincide for many years before that, which maybe we'll explore another time. But as we always like to do on the show, kind of remind the listeners what your e-commerce journey was prior to writing the book. Yeah, I mean, I spent most of my career in retail. I started, you know, on the very ground floor as a clerk at Tower Records.
2:26 And I really had all my formative years there. I spent 20 years at Tower Records, started as a clerk and left as a senior vice president and led the team that built the first TowerRecords.com, you know, when it was mostly people on dial-up modems coming in. And I remember, you know, kind of obsessing about the image sizes that, you know, would download quickly. And fun fact, Tower Records was, of course, like an icon, a public pop culture icon, but it was run by one guy that owned 100% of the company and it was wildly successful. And he, inside baseball fact, he did not like ties.
3:06 No, he did not. And so if you were so silly as to show up in his office wearing a tie, he would cut it off and pin it to his wall. And I know this because one of my ties is on his wall. Oh, I don't think you ever told me that. You got your tie cut off. Yeah, and I was totally punked. My co-workers who sent me like a lamb to slaughter at this meeting, like, I guarantee you were completely aware of what was going to happen and like, led me to believe that I should wear a tie to meet the billionaire owner of Tower Records. Hey, you know, I mean, a lot of people consider that a badge of honor to be in that case of ties. So congratulations to you on that for sure. I'm certain it was not the nicest time. So I distracted you, but of course, beloved, beloved music store featured prominently in a lot of America's greatest movies.
3:58 Yeah. And I mean, just it was the greatest company to work for. I absolutely loved my time there. But, you know, as you said, it came to an end. So then I went to Borders, you know, which was still doing really well at the time. And I first went there to lead the building of the loyalty program, Borders Rewards, and then also led Borders.com. Did that for a while, left there and moved on to the vendor side for a little bit as the VP of retail for 4C Results, a company that measured customer satisfaction. And so I worked with more than 100 retailers and helped them understand customer satisfaction and how to respond to what they learned about what their customer experience was and how to make it better.
4:41 From there, I went to Online Shoes as a CMO, got me to Seattle and moved on to Sur La Taub from there when we talked. And at Sur La Taub, I ran digital, but also marketing and technology for a while. And then I moved to Nike and I spent seven years at Nike, three different jobs there. Initially as sort of the GM of the digital business for the running category globally. Then I led global online or global digital operations. And then the last job I had there was leading global retail operations. So stores, a little bit of a full circle all the way back to that. And Kevin, for all of our young listeners that only wear contemporary shoes, remind us what Nike does.
5:22 Yeah, right. You know, a few shoes, a little apparel, sweatpants, that sort of thing. That's a great idea. Yeah. You've heard of it? I have. You could probably have a mild success in that industry. Yeah. Seems like it did pretty well. They've done well for themselves. As long as you don't hire any eBay people to run it. Oops. This is where I'm going to go no comment. Fair. Pleats the fifth pretty early. This may be a record. Yep. Okay. I have to get this. Yeah. I'm going to have to on that one. And then after I left there, I started Mystere Advisory, a consultancy where I focus on three things, helping people with strategic execution, which we'll talk more about.
6:07 I do executive coaching and also do some advisory work with a variety of different companies, software companies. And all that's led me actually to what I'm doing right now also is working with the Minnesota Timberwolves and leading the ticketing business there. Oh, neat. I didn't know that. That's new information. Breaking news for. Me and all of this is a side hustle for your main gig which is a musician is that correct. That is correct yes all supporting that yeah still playing music all the time and working on getting a new band together here in cleveland and of course you guys i think have been there we play that gig every year in new york right after right as part of nrf and we'll be doing that again this year at the cutting room in new york looking forward to that that.
6:51 Is the The best event at NRF when I can stay up late enough for it. Yep. Drink your coffee. Have an extra one. That is a safe bet. And I believe you've even passed the music bug on to the next generation. Oh, it might. Yeah. Not so much in my house. They listen. They don't play. Awesome. So we want to jump into the book, but before we get too deep, just please tell me it's not a deep dive case study in all of my failures. Absolutely not. In fact, you do appear in the book as a kind of a hero, really.
7:33 Yes. So, it's a fiction book. Awesome. It's entertaining reading. I was certainly entertained. So, before we jump into the content of the book, like, Like, you know, Scott, Scott kind of alluded to it in the intro. What, what inspired you to write a book? Is it the money? Yeah, right. I had thought about it for a long time. And, you know, I've been writing blogs for a while and sort of got a few people had said I should write a book. And I finally just decided, you know, to take that seriously. And then I really had to think about what was a topic I wanted to write about.
8:14 And something that I'm really passionate about is the fact that, you know, most strategies fail. And there's a lot of data about that. And the number one reason they fail is poor execution. So I really wanted to focus on that. And, you know, I mean, there's a million books about strategy and how to write a strategy, but there's not that many about execution, funny enough. And most of the ones that are out there are written by consultants and academics. And so I wanted to write this really from an operator's perspective and really somebody who's sort of been there and has the scars from it. But I also didn't want to just make it, you know, my perspective. So I interviewed more than 60 operators, people who had been there and done that across a ton of different industries. I actually started in retail, but as I started to ask people who they knew who were successful executors, it just sort of passed me on.
9:07 And before you knew it, I was talking to people in just about every industry you could imagine, you know, in content, media, tech, healthcare. I talked to a guy who does like public utilities in Australia, you know, so really kind of covered the gamut. And what I found in doing that is it just was a lot of commonality in the things that work. So that's what got me really inspired to kind of make this a book to put it out there. Cool. One of the things I like about it is how you structured it. So you've got kind of two chunks, you know, phases, phase one, setting the stage and phase two, showtime. And then you go through basically, you have six C's and each one is basically a C word and how you and then a trap that kind of goes along with it.
9:54 So for example, I'll just pick one. Part two, clarity, escaping the complexity trap. Part five, coordination, closing the silo trap. And the reason I like this is this, it's kind of book, some books you read once you're like, okay, I had some good takeaways. And then others, like one of my favorites is this Ben Horowitz book called Good to Great. And it's, it's kind of similar where it's like a collection of case studies so you can read them linearly. But then you're always like, what was that case study? Oh yeah, it was in that book. And then you can jump right to it. Cause I, cause I feel like people could read this and then be, they, a lot of times you don't know you're in the trap or it's coming. So, so I think they'll, they'll get into the trap and they'll be like, I think I'm in one of those things Kevin was talking about.
10:36 And they'll look it up and be like, oh crap, I'm in the ivory tower trap. And then, then you give them, you can like help them get out. So I think that'll be handy when, when people actually get their hands on this. Was that intentional? You try to make it a reference and a read? Yeah, totally. I mean, I very much wanted it to be practical. So I wanted to make sure that there were lots of how-tos in there and lots of things that you could take away and go execute right away, you know, kind of make it happen. So very much wanted to make it easy to reference, different sections that you could go to quickly. At the end of every one of those parts, there is a checklist that you can use to kind of go through and kind of see how you're doing and rate yourself.
11:18 So yeah, I wanted to make it super usable. Yeah, I can even see, I've been in companies where we do little book clubs, and this would be kind of a good one for an executive team or even a team to kind of have as they felt like they weren't being as effective on the execution as they wanted to be. You should do the reading club follow-up. That way you can sell another book. Yeah, I love it. Let's do that. The workbook. so you kind of stated this but just so listeners can tie it together i'll ask the question what is the strategy trap. Yeah i mean the strategy trap is when leaders get kind of obsessed with the idea and even the presentation the idea maybe the slide deck but they don't spend nearly enough time focus on creating the conditions for the people on the team to actually bring that strategy to reality.
12:12 And that is the fundamental problem that sort of leads to all the other traps. How do, so I've always had this trouble, this challenge. So I'll, I'll talk to them blue in the face about our vision and I'll even tie it into, you know, the plan and everything. And then we'll do these employee surveys and now everyone's always like this division isn't clear. I'm like every quarter I go through this, like, why is this not landing? What am I doing wrong, Kevin? Which trap am I in? Well, I mean, you know, this, the vision is only part of what you need to execute. So that in the end it's you know this you want me to go through the six c's would it help to kind of give the big picture yeah yeah.
12:55 Let's let's hit the c's. You know you talked about the two phases setting the stage and then and then uh show time but in setting the stage the sick the first three c's are co-creation clarity and capacity and those three are super super critical Co-creation is all about, you know, bringing the team at multiple levels within multiple functions in to help develop and create the strategy. And what you get out of that when you do it that way is, you know, alignment and buy-in. You get people really kind of owning it a little bit. You get validation to make sure that this plan that you're putting together is going to be workable. And then you get commitment.
13:36 And so partly people are sort of fully understanding the strategy then and then really buying into it and really saying, I'm ready to go. Clarity is about simplicity and it's about meaning. So it's about helping people understand it, but really understand and connect their personal meaning to it, which really helps retention right on it. And then capacity is super critical you can't just drop any new strategy on top of people's existing work and just expect it to get absorbed within and and so that becomes a real problem if you don't do that so taking the time to create space for it really really matters those are all setting the stage that gets you set to kind of move into showtime and actually start to go on this thing and so the three c's there are communication coordination and coaching, communication you know is an is a non-stop thing so to your comment a little bit.
14:29 I actually heard this. I was at a Nike conference a few years ago, and Kara Lawson, who's the head coach of the Duke women's basketball team and a former WNBA player, she talked about her concept she tells her players of early, loud, and continuous. And she's talking to them about that in the context of basketball you know hey like you got to tell people if a pick is coming get there early the arena is really loud so you've got to be loud and you got to continually talk about it because they didn't hear it the first time, and i think that applies to when you're communicating a strategy to get in there early talk about it even before that vision or the idea was was fully formed you know so people can understand the why, but then be loud, talk about it in every forum, in every way, and in every different method you can think of.
15:19 And then continuous matters because you can't stop. There's like this thing called the Ebbinghaus forgetting curve that says people forget 90% of what they heard within 30 days if it's not reinforced all the time. So you kind of have to do that. Coordination then is about having checkpoints and just ways along the path to make sure that you're sort of organized and implementing this thing and people understand the why and what their component of it is at any given moment and how it fits in the big picture. And then the last but not least is coaching, which is a component of leadership, but not all of leadership. It's a specific one about creating culture and how do you do motivation and incentivizing people to do the work.
16:01 But all of that reinforces the vision that you're talking about at the beginning. So I find having that structure across all those six C's helps people understand the vision better, helps them understand their role in executing in that vision and reminds them and motivates them along the way. Yeah, I think I'm already stuck in the first one. So you can't just tell people what to do and they just do it like the whole. Yeah, not so much. I was going to say, like, I didn't want to pick on Scott's incredibly successful managerial style. But when he did that survey and they said the vision isn't clear, what they actually meant is they didn't get a chance to co-create that vision. And so they weren't committed to it.
16:42 It is entirely possible. Exactly. Had you read Kevin's book, we could only imagine how successful you could have been. I know. Maybe this time. We'll see. Yeah. Let's start over. I think you just did start over, didn't you, Scott? Yep. Yeah. I will actually, well, we already have a vision, so I've already skipped. Yeah. And he's not letting any of his coworkers share in the co-creation. They're just desperately trying to hang on to the Scott rocket ship. I will as long as they come up with the same thing I did yeah yeah co-creation, is that how it works Kevin yep. That's exactly how it. Works okay, let's pick on Jason now I feel I feel attacked yeah.
17:28 Yeah you guys are practitioners I just talk about this stuff I very explicitly. You just drop all you do is spit strategy and disappear must be nice. At my office I'm known as the pelican because I My main role is to fly over, drop something down, and then fly off. Nice. Okay. It's better being known as a pigeon, I suppose. Yeah. You can see why no one's reading my book. Pretty short. Yeah. Which one of these... A lot of times you kind of think about writing a book and you frame it up and then you write it and you're like really good. Which one was kind of like your favorite? If you had to pick a favorite, what was your favorite part?
18:12 Wow. Favorite C. I guess it probably is co-creation because I do think that's foundational, you know? Yeah. And I think that without it, it's really difficult to get to the other ones. And also, when you co-create in a good structured way, it really sets the foundation and superpowers all the other Cs. So I suppose co-creation, that's a good one. It's a fun one. But I love all my babies. So is this a, are we having a facilitated conversation? Are we, you're like, you delegate to the team, come back to me with what you think. And then you basically veto it. Like how, what is the, uh, I know that's not the right structure. What is the right structure?
18:55 Yeah, I think it's iterations and it's, it's working with people. It's, it's having, you know, you might start with a small group of people, although I really like to have that small group of people be representative of different teams and even different levels to some degree, because you're getting a more well-rounded initial kind of take at your strategy when you do that. And you also start to build, you know, advocates and even find some detractors to bring into that. But there is multiple phases that you want to start with that group and then start to share it out and get more feedback and more ideas. There's one person I interviewed in the book, Amber Taylor. I used to work with at Nike. She has this great concept I love called a proposal to hate.
19:38 And so, she would take, you know, kind of the initial idea and she would take it out to people and say, this is a proposal to hate. I want you to tell me what's wrong with it. You know, she would give them permission to do that. And I think that's super valuable. You know, Jason, you and I talked when I interviewed you for this book about the six thinking hats. Yeah. That's the black hat. Yeah. I mean, that's one of the hats, the black hat, right? But the six... I am a huge fan of six thinking hats, too. Edward de Bono. Edward de Bono. Yep. That's the guy. And you've had experience with it, as have I. And what's great about that method is that you sort of...
20:19 You can take some of these ideas, you know, the core of a strategy, the vision maybe, and you start to get a group of people together, but you structure their thinking. You know, you have a metaphorical hat or maybe you get real hats and you put, you know, have everybody in the group don a hat, you know, the one Jason just references the black hat. And if you say everybody's got a black hat on now, when you're wearing that hat, you only talk about negative things, only talk about the problems of this idea. So it's not just people randomly throwing in ideas. It's they're all focused on that. Or you have the white hat, which is like, what are the facts we know about this? We're only talking about facts, no opinions.
21:00 And there's a couple other different hats that you put on in this context, but the idea is that you're getting everybody to be thinking about this idea, whatever strategy you have with the same perspective at the same time. Jason, you could probably talk about it. Yeah, I think you nailed it. I mean, traditionally when you have an unstructured conversation with a group of people and you say, hey, I want to talk about what success could look like in my new company, while you're talking about that success, one of the people who's not bought in is just thinking about all the ways that this idea is going to, or is likely to fail because there's not a structure, right?
21:41 But so when you, you ask everyone to put on the black hat and then everyone gets to, gets permission to be super negative without being a jerk because it's, it's the literal assignment. And then when you take off that black hat and said, now I want to talk about like what success looks like. Well, they just took the black hat off. And so you've kind of taken that ability for them to be sort of sabotaging the brainstorm about success or, you know, about expansions or about different things. So I really like that. I'm a fan of cognitive psychology and like I love that you pick co-creation. Because kind of going with retail metaphors, there's a super fun cognitive bias that literally got named after a retailer. It's called the Ikea effect.
22:29 And essentially the principle is, if I take two identical tables and one of them I build for you and just hand to you, and the other is a kit of parts and you have to struggle and build the table yourself, guess which table you like more and value more? The table you helped co-create, even though, So even if at the end they're identical tables, the table with your blood, sweat and tears in it, you, you have more love for, right? And so, you know, in that same way, like having, having these, these strategies or having these ideas and, and, you know, empowering people to feel like they, they were following the key instructions to get to that idea makes them more committed to it.
23:16 Right. And then there's kind of a related cognitive bias called the endowment effect, which is whether you built it or not, if I get you to think you built it, you'll value it more. If you imagine owning something, if you imagine that you're an owner of this company or this idea, then you will value it much more than if you don't. Right. And so in retail, what we're often trying to do is get customers to look at that product and imagine that they already own it. Yep. Yeah. And that, and they, they will value it much higher in that scenario. So yeah, it's super important. Scott, are you taking notes?
23:57 I am. I'm still writing down the hats. So I'm, I'm kind of way behind you guys. Yeah. One other thing about that. Now in Scott's version, all six colored hats are going to say refi, bye. One of them might be a South Carolina hat. Ooh, good. Yeah. Yeah. What on the hats, one other point about that, that I always think is interesting too, because you called out the one, the person who's negative and you gave them permission to be negative and that gets you really good value. What I have found interesting when I've implemented that too is that you also have people who are super optimistic and they can never see anything wrong with it. So when you get them to put a black hat on, it forces them to see things differently.
24:40 And then the same is true when you give the yellow hat, the optimism hat to the person who's always negative. It starts to expand their minds and their way of thinking about it so not only are you getting better insight into your strategy and your ideas but you're also really sort of changing the thinking of the team as you're going about that which is which has been pretty valuable too yeah. The okay let's is that a good time to wrap up co-creation or anything. Sure we should learn about. That okay Yeah. Cool. Jason, over to you. Yeah. So, Kevin, you kind of make this, I want to say, relatively easy to understand because it still is...
25:22 It's a dense book. There's a lot of interesting thoughts in it, but you give this kind of framework which helps, at least in my mind, it helps kind of distill it down. But I'm kind of curious, how do you see the book being used in places that traditionally are launching traditional strategy and getting those bad results? Can I iterate here? Can Scott just learn that he's making a mistake about not co-creating his strategy and that will move him one step closer to success? Or does he sort of need to embrace all six C's in order to be successful?
26:05 I think definitely people can jump into any of these C's and use those directly. You know, clarity is a good example, you know, and Scott, if you said people were maybe not understanding or not remembering, I think then some of the techniques in clarity might be a good place to just jump directly into and talk through some of the things that we have in there. You know, in the showtime section of thing around communication, coordination, there's a lot of techniques in there that you could take from something that's existing and just refine your capabilities and build on it and take some ideas definitely you know i think you don't have to read the book from start to finish and exactly the way it is you could jump into the areas that you felt maybe you had the most opportunity to prove in for sure although i'd love you to read it from start to finish you.
26:55 You you talked to was it 60 we you talked to 60-ish folks, what were some of the most, and you can't say Jason, what were some of the most. Uh, I think it was a safe bet he wasn't going to anyway. What were some of the most intelligent, no, uh, what were some of the, you know, sometimes you go into those things and you're like, okay, I kind of know this person's story. And then you hear a real, you know, zinger comes out of left field. What did you have? Tell us an experience, something like that, that, that really kind of came at you from the side. Yeah, let's see. That's a good question. You know, one person I talked to was Joe Megabo, who's, you know, now the CEO of CPAP.
27:38 He's been kind of in a variety of sleep-related companies lately. But he actually told me a pretty good story about analytics and I didn't actually realize that he started his career in analytics. And he talked about the framework he used to take on analytics projects. But I really liked kind of his approach to how he thought about that. It was very structured, which was good. But he really kind of got into some of those concepts I talked about, about, you know, you could do analytics about a million things, but how do you sort of sort through and say, what do we really need to focus on? What is actionable that we could be doing, not just interesting? And, you know, how does it fit within the capacity that we have.
28:18 So, I thought his approaches on some of that stuff were not where I was expecting he would go that were really valuable. Where did that land into the book? That is in the capacity parts, I believe. Okay, cool. Shout out to Joe, who is another legend in the industry. I know he's done a bunch of sweet gigs lately, but I think of him as an apparel guy, right? Wasn't? Yeah, he was at American Eagle. American Eagle. Yeah. But he was like Expedia before that. So he's kind of jumped around different industries as well. Very cool. what so there's not a lot of pictures in the book kevin i if i have a criticism, yeah there there could be more images but there are some interesting visuals there's some interesting charts and one that i'm remembering is it the derrick sievers chart derrick sievers yeah sievers oh gosh see i should have listened to the audiobook it.
29:15 Hasn't been created yet but. Yeah and i assume you're you're gonna narrate it yourself when it is yeah. I think so yeah. Yeah i I insist on it. Okay. Well, then it's decided. Nice. Tell us about that. Yeah. I mean, Derek's an interesting guy. I've known him for a long time, but he has been like an entrepreneur and an investor. He's a TED Talk speaker. So, he gets a lot of people coming to him with their ideas and they want to, you know, kind of work with him to create an idea. And he has a story he talked about where this guy kind of came to him and was like, I got a billion dollar idea. And Derek's like, okay, great. What is it? And the guy's like, online dating with music.
30:00 And Derek was like cool what else and the guy was like that's it you know you're the tech genius that's the idea let's just go and we'll split a 50 50 kind of it so Derek kind of was he took out his notepad and he kind of wrote this chart out and he had on one column the idea quality and he wrote kind of you know weak so so good brilliant and then he wrote another column called execution quality. And he wrote like, you know, weak, so, so good and brilliant. And he kind of drew out a score for each of those with the idea. It was kind of, you know, weak ideas are worth one, so, so five, brilliant 20. But the dollars he put on the column next to the execution quality, where he wrote those one to 10 million.
30:47 And he basically said to the guy, look, you know, if you want to make a business, you got to multiply these two. Ideas are just the multiplier. and they're worth nothing without the execution. The guy kind of walked away a little defeated, but that was kind of the idea that he showed that the idea doesn't have nearly the value as the execution does. The combination is where you get there, but a brilliant idea doesn't take you very far. You have to have a real plan to execute it, not just let's do online dating with music and you go just do your thing. Yeah, that's amazing. I feel like that's a weekly conversation I have with my in-laws when they come to me with their billion-dollar shark tank idea.
31:31 And I'm like, yeah, yeah. The idea is the least difficult part. Yeah. I mean, you can have a middling idea and great execution. You're going to be way better off than a great idea that doesn't go anywhere. Yeah. And let me give you an example of the online dating. So, you can laugh at me for this, but as many people know, I started my digital career at a super successful company called Blockbuster Entertainment. Yeah. And I got a real opportunity to work for an amazing entrepreneur named Wayne Heisinger who built a billion-dollar business three separate times in three totally distinct industries. And amongst the cool things about Wayne, he used to keep score by how many millionaires he made.
32:17 And so we sold, I know it's a big joke, everyone likes to make fun of Blockbuster, but we sold Blockbuster for $8 billion and moved on like years before Netflix was ever invented. So we sell Blockbuster to Viacom, I moved from Florida back to the West Coast, and Wayne is like, hey, all this .com stuff is going on in the Bay Area right now, find some deals and we'll make some investments. And I'm like, oh my God, I just got my Wayne Heisinger golden ticket, right? Like, like I thought like this, I thought like this was the greatest moment in my life. And so you moved to the Bay Area and I'm, I'm looking for a deal to bring to Wayne, right?
32:58 And Wayne's a guy that like saw the market for garbage trucks and bought and built waste management, right? He saw video stores and built Blockbuster, you know, used cars and built AutoNation later. So I get there, I'm looking at all these companies and I find the first company that I want to take to Wayne. And it's this company called Electronic Classifieds. And their, like, in hindsight, totally correct idea was, hey, digital and the internet are going to totally disrupt this hugely lucrative business that newspapers have called classified ads. And our proof of concept is we're launching an online business for the most popular category in classified ads, which is dating.
33:42 And so this proof of concept is called Match.com. Oh. And so I, like, side note, signed up for Match.com and my free lifetime username, I've been married for over 10 years, But my free lifetime username on Match.com is Jason at Match.com, to put it in perspective. But I took Match.com to Wayne, and he's like, don't see it. And, you know, Wayne is no longer with us, I'm sorry to say. But let the record show that, like, their market cap has greatly dipped and is currently $8 billion. Wow. Yeah so it turns out like the idea is interesting but it it all comes down to that execution and how many companies like had that idea and you know, who it ultimately took our friends at Tinder to make it work.
34:37 Yep. There you go. Yep. Execution's everything. Yeah. So no one thought this strategy book was going to help you find a spouse, but now you know. Yeah. Well, you never know where these conversations are going to turn. Another, another story I liked was Linda Carlisle. Maybe share kind of the story there. Yeah. Well, Linda is a communication specialist. And we talked a lot about communication and how to, you know, best communicate strategy to be executable. And she basically talked a lot about the idea that you would start with a big bang, like a lot of companies do and, you know, have a, you know, town hall or what have you.
35:25 But then you have to really start to break down your communication and make it much more meaningful to people at every level they're at, you know, and empathy needs to be a big part of that. You got to understand where people are. When a new strategy is coming and is going to change things on them. Actually, in a side note from Linda, but a former colleague I had at Nike, Amina Warner, one time during change told me, you know, change is the death of the old. And I thought that was such a profound statement to think about when you're going to put change and communicate it, is that actually what they call the change curve actually follows pretty much the exact same path as the grief cycle.
36:08 And Linda kind of got on that idea too, that you've got to be empathetic for people. You've got to understand that they're going to go through these different, you know, emotional stages as they're encountering new change and build a plan to recognize that. But then have plans that you can pass along to different leaders and have them be able to do the communication as well at a more individual level or a smaller team level to make sure that that vision or that big picture strategy is broken down and meaningful to people at each team level within a company. So people are locking in on it in a way that makes sense to them in language that they understand.
36:53 That seems like totally sound advice. One of the questions I wanted to ask you was from the execution section, Kevin, and you introduced this concept of pre-mortems. And I have to be honest, like when I first started reading it, I was concerned because I actually, there's a super common thing that happens in my world where at the end of a project, you do a post-mortem. And I hate that idea. Right. Cause I mean, I mean, amongst other things, like the, the metaphor is just that like, whatever you do did died and now you're, you're evaluating why you accidentally killed the patient. Yes. And so, you know, and usually like sometimes those projects are successful and have good outcomes and other times they're not successful, but you have good learnings.
37:38 Like, like hopefully in most cases you didn't kill anyone. Um, so, so I'm kind of, I think language matters. I don't love the word postmortem. And so then I'm reading pre-mortem and I'm like, I'm not sure I'm going to like this, but you actually won me over. So maybe you could explain the concept. Yeah. So pre-mortem, I mean, you talked about what a postmortem is, but the idea of a pre-mortem is to say, look, before we launch this thing, let's imagine the future and let's imagine that it went horribly wrong. Why did it go horribly wrong? And I think the value of doing it that way versus contingency planning is that it sort of forces the mindset to go, oh my God, everything went wrong.
38:24 And now we're going to do the same type of analysis we would have done if everything went really wrong and be able to identify, you know, a number of different problems before they happen. And when I've done, I've done these things lots over the years and they always produce things that you hadn't thought of. And then that allows you to start to, to kind of work through the plan and make sure that you're not missing anything. So it's just the mindset really that, that helps you get there, but super valuable. Just did one of these a couple of weeks ago, actually. And it, you know, stuff that came out of it was, was surprised a few people to be honest, because people just weren't thinking of things. So super valuable. Yeah. And, you know, again, like part of my objection to postmortem is kind of you're like objectively evaluating your finished project in a negative light.
39:13 But like here, you're kind of proactively thinking about what could go wrong. So I'm like the negative is kind of more in the context of the black hat thinking we were talking about earlier. But I also it kind of reminded me of another business tactic that's near and dear to all of our hearts. It's like, you know, Amazon's methodology, right? Where, you know, when they're selling in a major idea, of course, they famously want to write the one page press release. That's the, the sort of sick premortem success story, if you will. And so I kind of took your thing as saying like, Hey, an even deeper dive is, yeah, let's, let's envision what that success is going to look like.
39:55 And let's make sure we understand that. But let's also like, you know, think about like, if we don't, if we don't achieve that success, what are the likely reasons that we didn't? Because if we can identify those upfront, we can remediate for them. Yes. Yep. That's exactly it. And, and I, I think that Amazon press release thing is also a great thing. I don't have that in the book when we should have, cause I really like it. And it helps with you with clarity and communication too, if you're sort of imagining how you would tell the outside world about your strategy. Yeah. Uh, that whole begin with the end in mind, I think is the, the thing I really like it. And I'll be honest, I've taken a lot of Amazon business approaches and use them in workshops with other clients because, you know, clients are always super interested in Amazon methodologies and there's a bunch of novelties, but I would actually say like a bunch of them don't work.
40:46 Like when you just, you know, do it in a one hour exercise, right? Like, and so you take people they're not used to quietly reading six page narratives and you make them read a six page narrative and it's, it's painful to watch. Uh, and so, so like, you know, unless the whole culture is all in on something like that, it's really hard to make it work. But I do think that that, that notion of the begin with the end in mind, both the positive and negative end, like is super easy thing. You add that to any organization and you see they adopt it and they want to keep doing it because they like the the benefits come pretty easy and are pretty apparent yep.
41:27 Love that yep and it definitely is a great mindset shift. Cool what one of the topics you raise is how to leverage constraints and as a startup guy this is the trick is we're always trying to unlike you guys that work at nike and publicist these eight trillion dollar companies we've got like a couple million bucks and then we we hit the wall so we've got to be That is the ultimate constraint. And we know the end of the life is out there. Don't you just keep going back to your investors and asking for more candy? Yeah, that works until it doesn't. And then, yeah, they want to see, this is where execution matters. They actually want to see results and stuff. It's kind of a bummer.
42:08 And yeah, so talk a little bit about that in the context of the book. Yeah, I mean, I love constraints because I think constraints really force great thinking and they force great creativity and they actually create freedom, I think, ironically. Because once you know that you have limits, you can then maximize everywhere else, you know. So deadline is a great constraint. Budget is a great constraint. You know, in the book, I tell kind of a famous story about the Costco $1.50 hot dog and soda, you know, which the guy, Jim Senegal, the kind of founder of Costco, said that that price would never change. Someone asked him what it would mean.
42:54 He actually used some more colorful language than that. Yeah, I think he said, if someone asked what would it mean if that changed, he said, I'm, So, but what did that do? It caused Costco to find all sorts of creative ways elsewhere to make up the difference or find ways to, you know, they initially outsourced a lot of the food, they ended up creating it on their own, but they, you know, they just did a number of things that they wouldn't have done otherwise without those constraints to make them more effective. So I think that kind of thing is really valuable Rick Rubin talks and he's got a book on creativity where he talks a lot about constraints and how it drives creative thinking when you tell people you know they have a limit to how much time they have on something or they can only use so many instruments on an album what have you but all of those start to force different kinds of thinking that ultimately leads to, more efficiencies or better creativity better more interesting results so I'm a big fan of them how do you like to use them scott.
43:55 I don't i just like to live live in them i don't. Really like. Manufactured they kind of are manufactured for me already so how do you use it like have you used it in the corporate context like how do you constrain nike or. Well i mean it doesn't have to be a nike. Case study but like one of these bigger companies i i can't i've never really worked for a big company so i have a hard time imagining how you do you just like say this is the deadline kind of thing like there's a time constraint. Yeah deadline is a good one but a budget is too. Just because a company is big and they have tons of money doesn't mean you should spend it all or you should let things be open-ended because when you do that, you lose focus. So, you know, you still can put a budget limit on something, absolutely, to kind of force thinking and force people to be creative.
44:41 I think being intentional about constraints, And like deadlines, like budgets, you know, try to think of something else. But anything like that helps galvanize thinking, I think. I see a lot of resource constraints. Like people will say like, hey, you greenlining this project, but you can only use this amount of people. Or you have to find a way to do it without disrupting this piece of our supply chain. And sometimes those are, I'll call them environmentally imposed constraints. Like the constraint is coming up because we literally can't afford to disrupt that supply chain, right? But other times they are somewhat like, arbitrary sounds too negative, but like they're constraints that are introduced for the purposes of constraining the project, not because the resources aren't available.
45:33 Right. But those can be freeing if you think about it, you know, because once you know you have a limit that you can't change, then you stop worrying about trying to change the limit and you start worrying about how can you be successful within that. And that's where you get the value, I think. Yeah. No, I totally buy that. And it's rare in the real world that you ever get the opportunity to do something that's literally unconstrained. So, building muscles around working within those constraints seems pretty valuable. Yeah, for sure. Yeah, it's a great point. It's rare to be completely unconstrained and probably dangerous.
46:15 Let the record show it only took me 48 minutes to make a great point. The the we talked about like a lot of the the stuff in the execution section in my mind the the next big section was kind of the the culture and communications um pillar if you will and to me this feels like the area like a lot of the other things that cause strategies to fail are, like not shocking like I mean they come up quite commonly but like it feels like the ones that are most underestimated to me and misunderstood are the culture and communication ones.
47:00 Yep. Yeah, and culture, you know, how you set up the team to be successful, there's a couple things in there that are so important, you know, giving people psychological safety so that they can speak freely and tell you when things are going off the rails is super important. Incentives are super important. You know, when we talk about incentives a lot of the time, most companies, it's about financial incentives, you know, it's about bonuses and those kind of things. The reality is there's a lot of research that a lot of financial incentives don't actually change behavior over a long time. But there are other kind of incentives that are more cultural that do. Social incentives, you know, is one that I like to talk about, which is, you know, rewarding people, calling them out, making them feel good, making them feel prideful in front of their peers or peers calling each other out and celebrating each other.
47:53 Those are social incentives that do drive behavior. And they're much more day to day. they get people, you know, kind of excited, the dopamine hits that they need. And then another one I think is a huge deal is convenience incentives. You know, we humans will go to the most convenient thing all the time. So how do you make things easy for people? You know, somewhat as part of culture, maybe part of some other processes you might put in, they'll gravitate to those things. They'll gravitate to the things that are more easy to do. So those are all things that can really drive behavior and galvanize team and focus that maybe aren't always the things that we're super intentional about.
48:34 Yeah. And it's funny, again, like as I was reading that section, you know, I'm picturing all these retail moments and there's, you know, a almost universal thing that happens every morning in every big box retailer that has ever existed. Like there are these like morning team meetings. And whenever I bring new, new associates to, to their first retail account, and we go to a Best Buy morning meeting or a Walmart morning meeting. Everybody is shocked and uncomfortable because if you haven't experienced it, it feels a lot like the, the pep talk right before high school football game. And there's, there's like a lot of cheering and there's a lot of like peer pressure and there's a lot of like acknowledgements and affirmations.
49:20 Like there are all these things that like, it would be easy to look at them cynically and say like, this is all sort of corny and, and forced behavior. But the reality is like what I've learned through a pretty long career, like the, that, that those meetings like set the tone. They, uh, they, they create a culture in which all of the members of that culture want that team to succeed. Right. And they, they're creating the, the circumstances for all those folks to work super hard for the next 12 hours for not a lot of pay and, you know, do their best to serve customers and make that, that retail environment successful.
50:01 And it's, it's literally like the, the beating heart of most retail in America are these kind of like non-financial cultural motivators that, that, you know, kick off our, our retail day every day. Yeah. And I mean, I mean, I love going to those sessions, you know, I did Nike one of the last row with stores. I go around and do those all the time and they're super fun and they super motivating. You know, those aren't things maybe that you end up doing in a corporate environment, But there are opportunities within corporate environment to get similar on that and I think, Those regular team meetings are a great opportunity to use, for example, celebrations to reinforce the strategy, too.
50:44 You know, so there you're kind of calling out when things went really well. You're getting peers to cheer each other on. But, you know, every time you have a celebration, you put it in context of the strategy. This was awesome. We did this because it moved us forward in the strategy. It's an opportunity to reinforce it all the time while getting people pumped up about it. Yeah. And I will agree with you that it's way less common at corporate headquarters than it is in the field. But I will tell you, if you work at Walmart for any period of time, you're going to stand in a room and do the Walmart cheer. And everyone's going to like, you know, emphatically clap and do the swiggly.
51:24 And it's like, it's pretty funny. like it it it and it you know first people feel uncomfortable right but like pretty soon that becomes kind of part of like it it becomes uncomfortable not to get into the spirit of it. Well i mean i love that and that seems like walmart's doing okay. Yeah yeah this is what i really wish we had. A video podcast. Yeah hey i will we'll do a video podcast i will happily We've got some Walmart guests coming up, so I'll happily do the Walmart. Oh, you guys can squiggle together. There's a Sam's version of the cheer. Too. Do you also have a spark? What is it called? A spark?
52:05 The spark is the Walmart logo, but yeah, that doesn't work into the cheer. Oh, okay. I'm curious about the squiggle for sure. Well, and the super inside baseball thing is, of course, Walmart was originally spelled with a hyphen, and the squiggly is the hyphen. So so it's after the l um but like in a subsequent rebranding the the corporate name is no longer hyphenated so but you still squiggle yeah but so you still do the squiggle in the cheer and then in the sam's club version you do the apostrophe which is also a funny physical gesture. This is good. Yeah i think you're gonna have to demonstrate this for us at some point.
52:47 Yeah, that's darn it. That's going to be on the extended version of the podcast. You have to be a paid member in order to download the paid subscription just went through the roof. The extended version of the Jason and Scott show. People are paying for the squiggle and the apostrophe. Yeah. But, you know, obviously, we could take 30 hours to talk about the book, but we are coming up on time. And I do want to make sure we land the plane, like somewhat in the spirit that you land the book. You wrap things up by kind of talking about the future strategy. I don't want to spoil the book, but how can we talk about this, Kevin?
53:30 Well i think the key to me is that strategy should be part of execution you know i mean, it shouldn't be sequential you shouldn't have a strategy and then figure out how you're going to go execute it the first step of execution should be actually writing the strategy and then as you're doing as we talked about co-creation and building that strategy that's actually how you're starting setting the stages of how you're going to execute it. Um, and you're making sure that you have an executable strategy. That's key to everything. I think that's, that's the mindset and that's the process and structure that is critical, I think, to make it happen.
54:13 Cool. Let's wrap it up there. Kevin, if folks want the book, where can they go? The book will be available at bookstores near you. It'll be available pretty widely, obviously, on Amazon and all those, but it will be out there everywhere. So I hope you'll pick up a copy. I'd love to hear your thoughts if you do. And happy executing. Oh, nice. I see what you did there. Yeah. Yeah. Very good. Are you going to do like signings? Scott has embraced it too. I feel like I'm contagious. Yeah, yeah. What did you do the other day, Scott? Was it happy regenticking? Agentic converging. Yeah, agentic converging. Yes. Yes, amazing. I feel like I one-upped you.
54:54 Well, as you have done for our entire history. Yeah. I'm okay with it. Kevin, I don't want to derail us at the very last minute, but like, have you talked to the publisher about implementing instant checkout on ChatGPT? Oh, wow. Yeah, I have not, but maybe we'll do that in the bonus material. Got you. If they need any help, I know a guy. Yeah. I don't know, for sure. Yeah. And on that cliffhanger, I encourage all the listeners to go ask a question about the book to Chad Chibiti and then ask if you can buy the book directly there. There you go. And if you can, you should buy it. And if not, maybe you should, you know. Go the old way?
55:35 Yeah. Yeah. Go get one of the dead trees. um but as always kevin it's great to reconnect you know i've learned a lot from you over the years and i i'm i'm very appreciative that you're you're sharing some of that knowledge with the rest of listeners on the podcast and the the millions of people that will undoubtedly buy and and read the book as well so congratulations yeah. Thank you i hope that's true but thank you guys always a pleasure to talk to you guys and i learned tons from you as well yeah. Congratulations Thanks for joining us. And until next time, happy commercing.
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed