EP079 - Modcloth CEO, Matt Kaness
EP079 - Modcloth CEO, Matt Kaness
Matt Kaness is the CEO of Modcloth a digitally native vertically integrated apparel brand, that was recently acquired by Walmart. Our conversation covers Matt's background, the Modcloth business, their brick and mortar FitShop concept, the future of commerce, and the Walmart acquisition.
Don't forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.
Episode 79 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded live from Shoptalk in Las Vegas on Tuesday March 21st.
http://jasonandscot.com
Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at SapientRazorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:02 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here are Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. This episode is being recorded live from the Shoptalk Trade Show in Las Vegas on Tuesday, March 21st. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg. And as usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Thanks, Jason. How are those throat lozenges working for you?
0:44 Uh, as our listeners can probably tell, not ideal. Cool. I'm gonna have to carry, carry the load yet again on the podcast today . Yes, I know I'm gonna get a lot of negative feedback- … that we're letting Scott talk too much again. And I just wanna apologize in advance to all the listeners. Cool. Well, today we're really excited to have a long-term, long-time friend of Jason and I, and of the show here, uh, on today. It's Matt Kness. He is the CEO of ModCloth. Welcome, Matt. Thanks, guys. Good to see you. Cool. Well, it's been a big news week for you guys, and we had had this, uh, scheduled before the big news, so, uh, appreciate you, uh, showing up now that you're the belle of the ball, uh, as it were. Um, so last week you guys were announced that you were acquired by Jet, uh, slash Walmart. So tell us… First of all, congrats.
1:25 Thank you. Awesome. And, uh, tell us, tell us how that feels. Tell us, uh, so it was just Friday it was announced, so it's been, like, four days. Are you, do you feel like you're in this kinda whirlwind? Are you, you through the, the eye of the hurricane a bit at this point? No, I, I think we're, uh, we're still kinda progressing through but, um, yeah, just to, to affirm what you said, we announced the deal on Friday. Mm-hmm. Um, really exciting to join the, the Jet team, Marc Lore, and, uh, the folks that, uh, he's assembled since he joined Walmart. Um, the team at ModCloth is really excited about having the opportunity to continue forward as, as what we've been working on for the last two years since I joined, and to now have a partner behind us who not only wants us to accelerate, but also help them in what they're doing online.
2:12 And so, uh, it's a new day. It's, it's a new world order, and, and we're game for the, for what comes b- uh, in the next days and weeks and months. Awesome. We, we definitely wanna dig into that to the extent you can talk about it, but before we do, let's, um, let's share some of your background. So it's always interesting to hear how people got into the fun world of e-commerce. Um, I always learn something when we have a guest on the show. When I was looking at your LinkedIn, I realized you had a mechanical engineering degree. I didn't know that about you. So that's, uh, your fellow engineering, um, nerd/geek as we like to say, so that, that's interesting. So- I always preferred geek to nerd. Okay. Good. All right. We'll, we'll call you a geek. Geek is not a pejorative. I just wanna be clear on that. Yeah. Okay. Uh, so, so, so tell us about that progression and how you got into, into retail.
2:56 Yeah, it, uh, it's really, it's been a, a meandering, you know, of sorts. I, I probably would say my career strategy has been to not have one, and to, um, I like to, I like to, to say everybody has an inner compass that has… And as an engineer who loved physics, uh, there's a, a force around your compass that as you amplify the force, you're attracted to the right situations and people, and you're repelled from the wrong ones. It's a living force between all beings. Yeah. It infuses us. It's between us. And, and, um- It's between you and that rock you know, I studied engineering and loved it, you know, loved the scientific method and loved to learn how the world worked, and realized I'd be a terrible professional engineer after a couple summers, uh, interning.
3:42 Thanks for not making me drive over your bridge. Yeah, I'm sensing some failed projects in there somewhere. Um, you know, and so I, uh, but I, I loved invention and innovation and, uh, pr- pursued a path in patent law coming out of undergrad- Hmm … that, um, working at the patent office, there was something romantic about being a patent examiner and, you know, tooling away, you know, reading inventions and learning- So you really worked for the USPTO? Worked for USPTO for five years. A la Einstein. Exactly. Yeah. That's, that was the, the geek romanticism that- Mm-hmm … you know, I, um, thought would be, uh, fun. And as much as I loved working with inventors and R&D shops of big corps, I realized that, uh, I would not be happy with myself if I had to be a patent attorney.
4:28 Um, you meet a lot of patent attorneys that do really well for themselves and hate their job. Hmm. And, uh, it's an incredibly important profession, and one that I just realized wasn't my passion, so I took a right turn to business school. Had an incredible, uh, time, experience at Darden, University of Virginia. Uh, from there I went to work for a startup out of Richmond, Virginia that was rolling up and acquiring industrial manufacturing companies. So I, I caught the, the entrepreneurial bug there. Uh, very general management focused, but realized after a couple years of selling clutch brakes and ball bearings that that wasn't- you know, what kinda, you know, got me up out of bed in the morning. So was fortunate to find work as a, um, product development operations consultant, uh, that led to a couple year project at Burton Snowboards, and that was kinda, "Okay, I found my lane."
5:18 And so from Burton Snowboards, working in merchandising and category management and product development and sourcing, um, I was fortunate to g- get introduced to, uh, Dick Kane, the founder of Urban. Mm-hmm. And that was '06-ish. Started for, uh, Urban in early '07. And one of my first projects was, you know, helping the company build out and grow the, the direct-to-consumer businesses. And, you know, that's eight years later I had the opportunity to join ModCloth as CEO, and now here I am on the other side of the deal announce. So there it is. Cool. And, uh, just for listeners, Urban is Urban Outfitters.
6:01 Um, and '06, it was pretty young, I think. So 100 stores, 50 stores, and you saw… You were there for, like, a really big arc of growth, I, if I recall the story. The, the… Yeah, the company went public, I believe, in, uh, early '90s, founded in 19- early '70s. Okay. Uh, but when I joined in '06, the company was about a billion in revenue combined across Urban Anthropology Free People. And in the, you know, seven, eight years I was there, the company grew from a, a billion in sales approximately to over three. Mm. And with the recession in between. That's almost three X. Um… Some quick math.
6:41 Yes. Let me pull out my calculator. I agree. Uh, yeah, so it was, it was incredible. It was an incredible time- Yeah … to be there. And you were chief strategy officer. What, what, um… That's kind of one of those broad terms. It can be, it can include, like, corporate development, like M&A. It can include digital. It can include, uh, you know, uh, experimentation and those kinds of things. What, what, what was in your purview while you were there? Yeah, it was, um- I, I, um, when I joined, I, I had two projects. Uh, it was help the company with a concept-to-market supply chain initiative, which was, uh, akin to work that I had done for Burton. Mm-hmm. And, uh, help, uh, Mr. Hayne with launching a fourth concept that was in his mind and yet to be birthed, uh, that turned into Terrain.
7:28 Mm. And so, um, the, the role was very operational. Um, and it literally wasn't until I was in the company a few weeks that I got a business card, you know, called, you know, head of strategic planning or something like that, and I was like- "I don't remember talking about a title-" "… on the way in." I thought, like, that was what was cool about, you know, joining the company was that nobody, you know, there wasn't a conversation about here's what your title is. It was just like, "Here's the work." Mm-hmm. And, um, I think they, I think they had somebody in that role who had left, and they had an open req, and it was just easier to put my name in the blank. Yeah. Um, and so, uh, but you know, the, the, the role was to primarily, um, you know, help, uh, the founder CEO, um, you know, build out the bigger vision, uh, and the strategy.
8:15 And then, you know, Glenn Senk became CEO after I joined, and he was in that role for five years, and I, uh, supported him as well, um, which is probably, you know, much more operational and tactical. Yeah. So I ha- I had this really great role where I had a foot in the operations and I had a foot in, you know, more the kinda the development, you know, side of what was coming next. Yeah. So- It, it was, it was unique. So supply chain in this context is, uh, store-based operations, I imagine. So getting things as quickly as possible from the manufacturers to your fulfillment centers out to the stores. Is that, is that kinda like what the supply chain stuff you were- Yeah. Uh, concept to floor, concept to market- Yeah … you know, meaning, you know, when is, um, when, when do you have the reads in the business from an, uh, an attribution perspective to predict where the demand is going?
9:03 And then how quickly can you, um, how can you develop a supply chain that's responsive so that you can quickly get in and out of the right inventory positions to, to capture that demand? Got it. Is that kind of a, a fast fashion thing? Is that kind of, uh, in that vein, or you guys are just like, because the store footprint had grown three X, you had to kinda like get some, get some more efficiency on the back end? Well, Ur- Urban's, Urban's u- unique from a m- uh, a merchant perspective in that it's still, um, very much lifestyle driven, and it's, uh, takes the best of internal design and the best of market and national brands and assorts to a, a customer segment versus Certain retailers that are all brands, you know, and it's very much kind of category driven, and then other specialty retailers have gone completely vertical and it's, it's all in-house design.
9:52 Yeah. So, you know, Urban and Anthropologie specifically are still, you know, kind of true merchant, you know, lifestyle businesses. Mm-hmm. And so with that comes a lot of the complexity in your supply chain, but it's also opportunity- Mm-hmm … if you're able to take advantage of the vast amount of resources and partners that, that you can tap into to, to respond to what the customer's telling you. So, uh, very cool. I, I do wanna, uh, kind of zoom in to ModCloth a little bit. And first of all, in the unlikely event that any of our listeners aren't familiar with ModCloth, um, how, how do you describe ModCloth? ModCloth is a, a women's, uh, fashion retailer.
10:36 We primarily serve, uh, women in their early 20s to mid-30s. The aesthetic's very feminine. Um, the concept, uh, derives from the founder, Susan Kougar's love of vintage back when she was in college, which is, uh, when and where she founded the company, uh, 15 years ago. Um, so there's always a, a hint or a nod to, to retro or, or, um, uh, past trends, uh, in our assortment, but it's very much grounded in today's trends, so it's the silhouettes, the, the fabrications are, are contemporary. Um, so that, that's from, uh, an aesthetic perspective and from a customer perspective. But what's really strong about ModCloth that differentiates it from other fashion brands and retailers is, um, the, the concept of community and participation.
11:24 And, and one of the things that Susan, when she launched the business, set out to do was, was to democratize fashion. And, you know, that's a little bit buzzy, um, but the way that she thought about it was to allow the customer to participate. Participate in the buying process, participate in the merchandising process, participate in the selling process. And so, um, the company was a pioneer in social commerce during the, they call it the Web 2.0 phase, you know, from, you know, mid-aughts to, you know, couple years ago. Mm-hmm. And, uh, really built out this amazing customer experience online through their app, uh, as well as web properties where the customer gets to, um, vote on, uh, items to be purchased.
12:09 They give, uh, their feedback, share their measurements, uh, w- in their reviews, and then we take that content and integrate it into the commerce site so that it becomes both a discovery platform for new customers, uh, as well as a personalization engine that allows us to take data from the community and help women, through our app primarily, enter their measurements and then get recommendations, uh, in our app for the highest-rated items in our assortment by women in the community who have a similar body shape and size. So it's really been pioneering this notion of, uh, social commerce or community participation, you know, for, for a fashion retailer.
12:54 Uh, since I joined a couple years ago, uh, we've been trying to… and, and have been, um, building out the opportunity as a brand, uh, more so than as a platform, and have Really rearchitected the entire assortment to be, um, more shoppable, to have more diversity in the offer, to be more lifestyle-oriented in thinking about the end use and the, the customer's moods with respect to, you know, giving her a lot more choice. Uh, we've also, um, taken our assortment from what was primarily third-party labels to now what is a majority of exclusive, um, product, you know, which im- I strongly believe is, you know, table stakes in, you know, in this w- Web 3.0 world that we're in.
13:41 Mm-hmm. And we've also tested and developed an offline store concept that we were, uh, able to get out of the barn and launch, launch in November that, uh, we call the Fit Shop, which allows for customers to come in and try on our apparel in a full size range. So everything in the shop is available from extra extra small to 4X, which I believe is the, the, the only fashion women's specialty retail Omnichannel customer experience in the country that provides a full size range. Mm-hmm. And it, it also plays to the culture of our brand, you know, being the most inclusive, um, fashion brand in America. And so that ability to be able to serve our entire community and allow women, sisters, girlfriends, coworkers, uh, mother-daughter, to shop the same assortment and have the same experience at the same time and not feel othered by saying, "Here, here's the plus section," or, you know, we wanna be really narrow in who we represent, you know, in our, um, in our marketing, uh, is something that we are really proud of and believe in as a brand.
14:45 And that, and that's probably the best description of what ModCloth is, i- is, is that, that broader purpose. Nice. There's a ton of meaty stuff there that we wanna maybe dive into a little bit. Um, but before I do, you came in, this was your first gig as a CEO, and you joined a company that had a pretty active founder. Um, how, how have you found that? Is that, um, is that a challenge to sort of be the outsider in a organic culture? Or do you feel like you've embraced the culture or changed the culture? Or how does, what… how does that work? Uh, y- so it's great… Uh, it's been a great experience. Uh, I tell my team that the, uh, the obstacle is the path.
15:26 And so- Mm-hmm … um, whether you call it challenge or, uh, or something else, um, it de- definitely is part of the process of coming in and replacing a co-founder, a CEO, but still working with them as board members and, and, uh, owners in the business. Uh, uh, I've been really fortunate in my career, um, out of complete happenstance, so nothing that, you know, I set out to do or that, um, I plotted. I, um, fell into the work at Burton Snowboards and had the opportunity to work for, uh, Jake and Donna, um, the founders there. And also, Laurent Pontdévin, who's the CEO at lululemon, was the president of Burton when I was there at the time.
16:09 Hmm. And so to work with founders and exceptional operators… And then I go to Urban, you know, and you have Dick and Meg Hayne, and you have Glenn Senk, you know, being CEO for a, a period of time that I was there. Again, working with, you know, founders and exceptional operators. And so for me, um, you know, I, I really, um, embrace the vision of the founders and what, what Susan set out to do when she said that, you know, she created the business that, and the brand that didn't exist in the world. And so, you know, I took it on as my, my own purpose with, you know- Having a 12-year-old daughter, you know, who is growing up in this world of, you know, false advertising, you know, around what is true standards of beauty.
16:56 You know, it, it means a lot to me. And so that was the lens I took the opportunity to, to kind of partner with Susan, but at the same time knowing that I was being hired for a job that had to get done. And so Susan and I have had an incredible partnership, um, through the journey and, um, you know, and I'd say of, of all the experience that I've had in the last two years, that's probably been the most gratifying is, is really, uh, having developed a strong partnership with her. Yeah. Uh, and if I can ask a, a semi-personal question. You're, you're part of a pretty big peer group with a lot of us that, you know, we're all around sort of in the emergence of digital retail, and I think if you talk to most of us, you know, there's this strong aspiration that like, man, the next step in my career progression is that sort of CEO role.
17:41 And, and, uh, you're, you're certainly one of the, the first folks from that cohort to step into that CEO role. And I'm just curious, like, I have a theory that it's a bigger, uh, change than maybe some people realize, and I'm… You know, I mean, have you found it as rewarding as you hoped? Like, have you been surprised by some of the, uh, you know, sort of isolation of being the, the final decision-maker instead of part of the, the team? It, it was the best of times, it was the worst of times. Yeah. Um, it, it's, it's a very, it's a, it's a very different responsibility. Um, and it's one that I've, uh, grown into the last two years.
18:22 You know, you make mistakes, you know, everywhere you go. I, again, tell my team it's not about perfection, it's about excellence, you know? And so, and you can't, you can't become excellent at something without- Taking a big swing and, and thinking big and, and failing along the way. And so, um, you know, I've learned, um, a ton f- in this experience as a first-time CEO, but I also feel like, um, I was meant to do this. Like, naturally, the pleasure I get out of leading exceptional people about being a brand steward and, and keeping-- kinda carrying the torch for Susan, um, has been unbelievably gratifying, and I love it. And I, um, excited to keep doing it for ModCloth.
19:03 Um, you know, having, again, back to my, you know, my gratuitous path to now be part of Mark Lore's team, another exceptional founder and operator, and I'm joining ranks with him. You know, I can… As I get to know him and his team, I'm gonna take inspiration from that and, and bring it to the work at ModCloth. But, um, y- it's a lonely gig. You know, you, you, you bring-- You, you take a lot on, and there's things that you can't share with your board or investors because, you know, they're, they're hiring you to carry that burden. There's things that you can't share with your team because you don't wanna distract them. There's things that you don't wanna share with your spouse 'cause you don't, you know, you don't wanna burden her with, you know, some of the, the challenges. And, um, you know, the way that I've taken this on is, you know, the success is the team's success and any failure is mine.
19:49 And so when you have that level of accountability, um, you know, there's a personal sacrifice, you know, that you have to be willing to take. So I, I would, um, I'd recommend it for anybody who, you know, what I just said sounds exciting and, and, uh, and they aspire to have that level of accountability. But there's, there's nothing that I've done before the last two years that fully prepares you for this, and it's, it's, uh, um… But it's been something that, uh, has been unbelievably gratifying. I always thought when you were a CEO, you didn't have a boss, but then you, you get a board, and you're like, "Wow, I have, like, six, six bosses." And, you know, they tend to be like, you know, you got a founder on there, you got a VC, you got this, that, and the other.
20:30 It's like, you know, it's, uh, it's more complicated than having a boss in, in a, in many ways. It is. And, you know, and, uh, and especially when you're stepping into a, a brand that's been developing for thirteen years and a business that, you know, took on funding as early as '08, um, you know, that, uh, there's a… Y- you know, you work for the sh- for the, the shareholders and the stakeholders, you know. And, um, you know, having, having alignment and a vision that everybody is, um, supporting and, um, and working the same direction is super important, you know. And I've been really fortunate that, you know, the folks around the table here are world-class and, um, and it's been a great experience getting to know them and, and having them, um, and stepping into a business that they had already, you know, supported and been bought into, and so it's been, uh, it's been nice to be part of the last couple years of that journey for everybody involved in ModCloth.
21:21 And now we got to an, a successful exit on Friday, which is great. Mm-hmm. And, you know, now we carry forward into the, the new world order. Yeah. And, uh, it's interesting because I feel like ModCloth has been sort of on the crest of a lot of these changes that have really disrupted the traditional apparel industry. Like I, you know, I certainly… Like you described, you've become a brand essentially, and have unique products. I have to imagine that that was one of the appealing things to Walmart, and maybe that made you a little different than some of their other acquisitions, is you, you have these unique products that you can't get anywhere else. Um, but I wanted to explore the community aspect and the, um, the sort of democratization a little bit.
22:02 'Cause we, like historically, and I, you know, I would imagine to a certain extent Urban Outfitters falls into this, this category, like we sort of had this notion of the merchant kings, and these, these, you know, great merchants had this u- this innate ability to pick the winning and losing products, um, that they would offer to the market. Um, and you know, certainly I would describe Walmart traditionally as a merchant-led, uh, organization. The y- you have a strong founder with a aesthetic POV, but then you, you really let the customers dictate the, the product line. And I think we're seeing that, that model win across all of apparel, and instead of the merchant kings, it's the influencers on YouTube, or in, in your case, your, your active community base.
22:49 And that, you know, I, I think that's something that large established companies like Walmart are going to have to be good at, and I would suspect that acquiring a company that already has that DNA is, is one of the elements of their strategy to get good at it. Is that… Do you… Have they talked to you about, uh, sort of not becoming Walmart, but helping Walmart become a little closer to ModCloth? They've been extremely clear that they are looking for teams and leaders who have a vision, ha- have a culture, have a market opportunity that they can help accelerate, and then over time we'll figure out, you know, kinda explicitly where things start to overlap or integrate. Um, you know, I can't, I can't speak for, uh, for the folks on the Walmart side as to what was the exact thing that they, you know, uh, this appealed to them about, but they're, they're clearly focused on talent and capabilities, um, and brand.
23:43 Yeah. And you know, I think the, um… But to, to your question about the, the merchant prince model You know, I, the way I view the world, and this, this is an ongoing, you know, kinda y- we're constantly being informed about what's happening. But, uh, I really believe… I mean, uh, retail's always been an execution business, you know, and, and that goes back to people. It goes back to leadership and, and teams and, and culture. And I really believe that in this day and age, the team, the, the companies that are competing, y- you are a software company or you are a brand. And if you are trying to do both It's gonna be really hard.
24:28 U-under one, un- under one team and, and, you know, leadership and brand umbrella. Um, and if you're, if you're not doing either well or you're not sure which one you are, you're gonna have a really hard time. Mm. And, you know, Facebook, Google, Amazon, Stitch Fix, they all view themselves as software companies. You know? They, they have brands- Sure … right? And they s- and some of them sell products, but they, like, their internal DNA, you know, is, you know, we are- Mm we're software companies. The same way that a brand creatively that has proprietary product, that is exclusive, that is scarce, that has a, a brand promise that they constantly, you know, are providing the experience and service around that promise, you know, it's the s- it's the same exact process internally, whether it's an artist or an engineer, you know, getting to, to some kinda output.
25:20 Mm. And so I think, you know, in this day and age, there, there isn't one person, you know, like, i- in the agile process, right? Like, there isn't, there isn't a person who is saying like, you know, "S- so it shall be done." It, it's, it's iterative. You're constantly using customer feedback. And, and Instagram has ruined the whole notion of, of a, of merchant curation because she's, at least in our category, 'cause she, 'cause Instagram has trained her eye based on who she chooses to follow, um, celebrities, influencers, her friends, whoever, as to what she, you know, uh, desires or wants to emulate or is interested in, and then it just becomes a matter of search.
26:08 Yeah. Right? And so I do think that that, that model is antiquated. Um, uh, maybe in other categories it, it, it still works and will forever, but at least within the women's fashion category, you know, I think it's, uh… I don't, I don't know that it fits going forward. One of, one of the fun things for me, um, the cognitive psychologists have this, this term they call the IKEA effect, and it essentially means, like, when the customer builds the table themselves, they love the table more than if they bought the table prefabricated. And you have this community that gets to influence the product, and I, I, I would theorize that as a result, that community has greater affinity for the brand and you, you, you have this great loyalty because they feel like they own the brand.
26:49 Um, and I'm, I'm curious, are there any, like, sort of standout customer stories that you think of as Well, we, we say all the time, I say all the time, we, we don't… This isn't our brand. This is the community's brand, and we're stewards of it. And, um, and, and that's the way that Susan created the, the, the concept, was it w- it was, it wasn't about a cult personality. You know, it was about a movement. And so, you know, that's how we talk about it internally. Um, when I first joined ModCloth, uh, my third day on the job, I was, uh, at breakfast with my head buyer in LA, and after, you know, some conversation, I was like, "Oh my God, you've never met the customer." I'm like… Uh, which makes sense because it was a, a, an e-tailer of third-party labels- Yeah … but online only.
27:30 I mean, no like… Not, not good or bad, just an observation. Sure. And I said to her, "Hey, let's have a pop-up in our lobby in LA, just so that we, like, the, like, the, the buying and the design and the sourcing teams can, can meet the customer and get feedback on product." And, um, and so we did it, and, uh, that April, a couple months after I started, and we had 5,000 women show up, or, uh, uh, respond to, um, uh, an email to the house file. We didn't advertise it at all. It was meant to be like, you know, maybe- … 50 people show up, 100. We had thousands of women show up over three days 'cause they love the brand so much, and they wanted to not only touch product for the first time, but they wanted to interact with the team. And this one woman, probably size 8 or 10, so like below the national average Um, our head of tech design was taking her measurements and she apologized about her, her, her size.
28:21 And Christine said, you know, "Don't apologize. You know, you're exactly who you should be, and it's our job to make you feel beautiful." And the woman started crying. Mm. Hmm. And she said she'd never felt welcomed by a fashion brand. She never felt like she could be included. And after three days of, like, working 14 hours, 10:00 PM that Saturday night, we closed the doors, and 30 of us had a, a party to celebrate, and I asked Christine to share that story, and we were all tears, you know, including myself. I mean, I, I cry at, you know, long distance telephone commercials. So I'm a total sap. But like, a- a- but and that was the moment for me that was like, "Okay, like, we need to create more moments like this in the world, and we can do that offline."
29:09 And so then, you know, we set out over the next year and a half to come up with a model that I also felt was fundable. Mm-hmm. You know? And so we came up with this notion of FitShop. I had a vision for, you know, not just what I thought the experience should be and visually how it should look, but also how we could capture data in the store and build the bridge back to online, and w- and we've delivered it. And so, you know, for me, that kind of like level of participation and starting with the community in mind, um, you know, is, is h- and, and with a purpose, you know, is I think, you know, then it becomes easy as to like what sh- you should execute because it's like, is this pushing our purpose forward or not?
29:49 Yeah. Um, and so for us it's always about community feedback and starting with the customer. So, so tactically, how does that work? Do you guys kind of- Uh, your designers, uh, come up with like this list of the next like spring of next year or whatever. They put it on the site and people thumbs up, thumbs down or… So, so walk us through the, the tactics of how that community thing works. Well, so we're similar to Urban fr- from a merchandising perspective. You know, where we're trying to take the best of our in-house design and the best of the market. Mm-hmm. And so we have, you know, like, like any fashion brand, you know, um, 11, 12 months out, you know, we're doing a hindsight on the previous season, we're starting concept and trend, and that's what the, the design team uses for their inspiration to come up with their seasonal concepts.
30:33 Um, from that, we build a bigger story from an assortment perspective to talk about what's important seasonally, you know, within, you know, those weeks and months that we wanna be able to, to build businesses in, and we'll go out into the market through our exclusive supply chain and build product towards that narrative. And then we use all of our, our attributing. So we have over 100 attributes per SKU that we assign that then allows us to mine the data and look for correlations between what attributes are trending and not, that we use a, a short, um, chase calendar, you know, with the market to, to, to get into new deliveries or get back in on replenishment for items that we can see are trending seasonally.
31:17 And so it's, it's, it's complicated, and you need not just exceptional Team members internally, but you need great vendor partners- Mm-hmm … you know, that have the, the capacity to, to work short and long lead, and have the capacity to source onshore and offshore. Um, but it's, it's through that lens of building an assortment for the customer through the best of in-house and external. But we have this really amazing culture where it was a tech startup. So I walked into a situation where you had people who were, you know, hungry for data, you know, that were digitally native with respect to communication and, you know, like how quickly we make decisions. And so, you know, the- we don't have these like giant process meetings.
31:57 It's all single piece flow. There's my, my engineering operations hat. You know, so it plays to more of a fast fashion calendar where we're launching dozens of new items every day- Yeah … within this broader strategy of what the assortment needs to be. Um, and, and but we're using data constantly to inform, um, not just the decisions, but also, um, the results. Cool. So the, the community is providing like the data that kinda like is the big input in this. Instead of you guys guessing, you get it right from the consumer. So from a design perspective, we're constantly using reviews, um, as customer feedback on, you know, quality, fit, um, value. And then, um, we're using the, this, the, the attributes around selling, um, within the assortment, as well as, uh, what we're seeing in consumer behavior with respect to like what they search for on the site, and where traffic's coming in from, and things we're seeing from our, our, you know, lookalike, one-for-one, you know, um, uh, digital efforts with c- with certain partners like Facebook- Mm-hmm that, um, then informs, um, what the, the quantity of the buys per attribute need to be on the go forward.
33:05 Interesting. Do you have a big data science team that kinda like fuels this? Uh, not yet. We have a… I mean, the company has been unbelievably scrappy i- in- Yeah … the two years that I've been in the business. 'Cause it starts to sound like one of these applications. And, and we had guest on, uh, earlier that kinda said, "Here at Shop Talk there's all this buzz about AI and machine learning, and it's all just like a fad." And they're just like… But this feels like one of those areas where, you know, right now you've got human learning, so there's probably humans looking at these trends. It does seem like an element where machine learning would ki- be kind of interesting, where you've, you've, you know, you could start to learn from what people like and don't like and, and- We, we have, we have data architects, we have data warehouse engineers, we have, uh, data scientists- Mm-hmm … you know, um, that we use. So I mean, we're, we're building it out.
33:47 It's just, um, it's early days. It takes time and, um, and this, uh, uh… So it's, it's the, you know, the art versus the science. But I agree, I think, um, this is an area where machine learning can not just help you from a, a supply chain perspective to take, to make you more responsive and take time out of your, um, your supply chain, but also from a personalization perspective. Yeah. You know who has a lot of data scientists is, uh, Walmart. Yeah, Jet does too. Yeah. Jet has… Is pretty, uh, early on that stuff. I heard Walmart was doing big data before big data was cool Um, I wanna, uh, jump into the Fit Shop a little bit. You opened the first store in Austin Yeah.
34:30 So November, uh, we launched. It was, um, incredible experience. The, the reaction from the market and the community was, uh, was more than we had hoped for. Uh, the, uh, the most important thing for me is as I go back to that story about the, the, the woman in the, the popup we had in LA, is that, uh, in two years time, we were able to take a, what was predominantly more than 90% third party product- Mm-hmm and build out a proprietary assortment, um, under our own label, um, as well as other labels that now we have over half of our apparel assortment available in a full size range. And we build out a supply chain behind it that we're able to order multi-channel so that we have samples that go into the fit shop that we can merchandise just like any other specialty store, but we have extra, extra small to four X in the back so that every customer who comes in, no matter who you are, can try it on based on style, not on size.
35:29 And, and we figured out a model that's inventory light. It's not an expensive build-out. Our, our brand and our assortment is so colorful and has such personality, we don't need to, you know, we don't need to pay for the, the personality on the build-out. Um, we're able to do it in a, in a model that, um, actually gives us leverage in our unified inventory, you know, in our direct to consumer fulfillment center. Mm-hmm. And, uh, gives us, uh, what we think is probably the most powerful acquisition channel from a media mix perspective for this brand. Uh, and which we saw through the popups in this first store is your brand awareness driving organic and direct traffic spikes in the local DMA.
36:13 Roughly half of the in-store orders have been new to file. And so we're really viewing this as, you know, not just how a traditional specialty retailer would view creating an experience in an environment and a service level around a, an exclusive assortment that caters to your entire audience, but this is part of our, our media efforts. And, you know, we're, we're pretty sizable re-relatively online only, or until recently online only digital business that now has this wide open opportunity to, to build out this offline channel in a way that actually will… is designed to accelerate the online business and to accelerate the, the repeat multi-channel business, you know, through the app and personalization based on data that we can collect in that, in that store experience that you can't necessarily give online today.
37:11 You know, maybe in the future through VR or otherwise, you know, it'll be s- you know, um, different. But sitting here today, we're pretty excited about it. How, how big is the store? Like- Uh- … 5,000 square feet? We're thinking prototypes more like 2,000. We have an opportunity here, um, with the first one to take a little bit bigger space. It's just under 4,000 square feet. Mm-hmm. Um, but, um, we don't need that much space because the samples, you know, give us the opportunity to have, you know, um, very limited inventory. So we're able to get more styles in per square foot than a typical retailer that, uh, is allocating inventory to the store. And it, it's like a Bonobos Guide Shop model, right? Like, you're not fulfilling product from the store.
37:52 You're- You can't, you can't buy and walk out. You're shopping in the store and then fulfilling from the online. So we're, we're still… W- w- I consider it a concept store. Yeah. We're still kind of tweaking the model. Um, it's a hybrid of their model, which we call fit and ship- Yeah … with a traditional brick-and-mortar retailer, which we call cash and carry. The apparel and the shoes where fit matters and where it's SKU intensive to handle a, a broad audience is w- is our in-store assortment that's fit and ship. It's the, the other categories, um, accessories, eyewear, um- Uh, handbags that is not SKU intensive, and it's kind of really easy kind of pick-up business that almost becomes a memento for new customers who come in and, you know, they're not sure they have the time to, to have a full session, but they're there and they wanna buy something.
38:47 So we're still kind of playing around with what's the right mix of fit and ship versus cash and carry, but the primary model is fit and ship. Very cool. And are there any other elements of the store that would be different than a sort of traditional, uh, apparel retail? Are you doing anything else to kind of bridge the online and store experience? So we encourage appointments, so it's meant to be an assisted selling, high-touch, um, experience. Uh, but we, we handle walk-ups just the same. So, um, unlike, you know, kind of the self-service model where you f- you know, you find your size and you try it on, and then you, you look for somebody to help check out, um, uh, we're able to put associates in the store who are trained and waiting to give, um… spend an hour or two with you to try on 20 different items.
39:34 And, and what we've seen is that conversion is 80, 90% on appointments, you know, compared to traditional brick-and-mortar, that's 20 to 25%. Um, and the AOV is, um, 50%, uh, or more higher than what we see in an online transaction for our assortment. The other nice thing is that because of the samples as opposed to having inventory, we have no clearance area. There's no sale section, and the team doesn't have to spend a lot of time on the back of house receiving and, and, uh, markdown ticketing and all that. And so those things are different and are, you know, more efficient as far as, you know, use of payroll.
40:15 I feel like our friends at TJ Maxx and at Gilt Groupe hate that model. I think it's interesting. So there's, there's all these, um, digitally native vertical brands. Do you guys think of yourself in that, that… So Andy Dunn at, at Bonobos kind of coined that. We use it on the show a lot- Yeah … 'cause Jason has a man crush on Andy, but that's, that's maybe a topic for another time. Shout out Andy. Uh, do you guys kind of… So do you kind of think of yourself in that bucket, uh, you know? Uh, yeah. And, and, and, uh- Yeah … I've had it… the, the pleasure of getting to know Andy a little bit. Mm-hmm. And, uh, really impressive guy. It's incredible what he's created, and, uh, I love how vocal he is about, uh, kind of sharing his, his experience and journey- Mm-hmm uh, in the world.
40:57 Um, he… I, I think when he coined that phrase in that Medium post, uh, he called us out as being, uh, not an apple or an orange, but a banana. I don't remember that. And I texted him and I was just like, "Really, banana?" I'm like, "You couldn't have thought of a better fruit?" You know? Like maybe something more exotic. Um… I feel like you're more of a papaya. There you go. I was gonna go mango. Um, but, uh, and, and may- you know, and may- maybe he's, you know, thinking of, um, us, you know, historically, but, but yeah, we're, we're, we're digitally native for sure. You know, we're a vertical brand for, you know, the m-majority of, um, our apparel sales.
41:39 And so… And that's how we're- we view ourselves internally, so yes. Yeah. I think it's interesting you guys are all kind of navigating to this guide shop kind of model, fit shop, whatever you wanna call it. Um, and we had a guest on the show who has kind of, you know, taken that model further and calls it concessioning, which is like in China, all retail has gone to this concession model where you go into a department store and the brand actually owns like a… It's a lot of little brand stores kind of a thing. And I kinda like see those worlds colliding, like, you know, you know, number one, it'd be interesting for all you guys to get together and, like, go rent 10,000 square feet, and then you'd have like the Bonobos side, the ModCloth side, the, you know, I don't know, maybe one of the shaving guys. There, there's, there's so many kind of cool options there.
42:20 Um, but then, you know, another idea is like, you know, could there ever be a ModCloth shop inside of a Walmart? I don't know if there's the right demographic or not, but, you know, that would be interesting. In- instead of going out and building out this footprint, you've got, what is it, 4,000 Walmarts at your disposal now. Yeah. I, I, I'm a, I'm a big believer in, in the opport- the opportunity for omni-channel from a, from a business perspective. I'm a big believer in the offline experience adding a dimension to the brand that you just can't fully capture purely online. Yeah. Um, you know, I think the… there's plenty of real estate brokers and developers and landlords who are, you know… who have incentive to make sure that we don't do what you suggested.
43:02 Yeah. And that, and that we, you know, they carve up the pie for each of us. But, um- There's some malls that may be a o- more open mind- There you go. Yeah … to these kinds of things now. But, um, but yeah, I think, you know, it, it, it all comes back to, you know, who's your customer, who's your audience, and who you're trying to serve. And, um, it- when I was at Urban, Free People was, uh, early in that trend that you're talking about, and was brilliant in how they partner with certain department stores in creating hard shops that felt like a little Free People boutique- Yeah … even though you were within, you know, somebody else's, uh, larger footprint. So I, I absolutely think that that's, that's a viable model. It's… It really just comes down to how do you connect, you know, your exclusive product with, you know, your target audience.
43:47 And, you know, in this day and age, whether you're… you got a, a shop on Etsy, or you're part of, um, a marketplace like Spring, or, you know, you're partnering with, you know, an offline distributor to get your product in front of, you know, customers internationally- Um, you have to be completely open to, you know, how you think about distribution. Cool. So, so, uh, I know from our talks, uh, after board meetings and stuff that you, you think a lot about the future, and you've, you've, you've had kind of a front row seat over the last 10 years, both at Urban and ModCloth with, with watching the trends. Project those forward a little bit. Where do you think things go? And, and you've been here at the show too, so anything you wanna tie in that you've heard at the show.
44:30 W- you know, what are… what's it look like in three to five years? What's, what are some of your pontifications on the future of, of brands and e-commerce and retail? I think there's gonna be a, a lot less supply in the market. Um, you know, I think the, the reckoning that you're seeing happening with bankruptcies is just beginning. Um, and I think that the, the, the whole idea, specifically in apparel, of an apparel store, um, is gonna go away. And, uh, I think that the, the incumbent brands that are being snatched up, uh, are the future. You know, it takes, it takes generations to build brands. Mm-hmm. You know? And it's really hard and expensive and sometimes impossible to reposition brands.
45:12 And, uh, especially in, in the fashion space, but also just generally consumer. And, um, and the, the businesses that have grown up in the last… brands that have grown up in the last 10, 15 years have a, a really distinct advantage. If for no other reason that the, the, the talent that they can attract- Mm-hmm … you know, is, is of this, this generation and, and they can, they can execute quicker. Uh- What, what's the root cause? Is it because we're over-stored? Is it because the consumer's changing- I think there's a, a giant commod- … rapidly? I think what the internet does is it commoditizes everything. It, it, it disaggregates every value chain from a consumer retail perspective.
45:54 Yeah. And it, it… and Amazon's genius at, at pulling those levers in trying to convince consumers that, that convenience, price, a- and access, you know, are more valuable is the only, is, is the, the reason for loyalty, um, than anything else. And so, um, in a lot of ways it feels like, you know, we're moving backwards to, you know, the generations of old where, you know, brands were small and scarce and, um, you know, and, and software is becoming the new infrastructure. And Google and Facebook and Amazon are going to be, you know, the layer through which all commerce goes, and you're gonna… and that's, that's your new landlord.
46:42 Mm-hmm. Right? You're gonna pay a percentage to, to your landlord in interacting with the customer. And, um, so it's just, you know, the, it's, uh, it's a virtua- virtual- mall real estate, um, layer that, that you're, you're paying the new landlord to. And so, um, I just… It doesn't-- The economics aren't there, the margins aren't there. If your products and category is getting commoditized, then you have two landlords to pay. Yeah. I think I know the answer to this based on what you just said, but just, uh… So, uh, we didn't ask the Amazon question, so I'll throw that in here since you kinda opened the door. The-- You guys never really sold through Amazon and- No and we get a lot of brands on the show and, and, you know, some of them tend to have this kind of, uh, you know, "No, they're the, you know, we… They will commoditize us, we don't wanna do it."
47:28 And other, others kinda say, "Well, they have 300 million active buyers and Prime users and all that kind of stuff, we kinda have to be there." Um, what, what's your theology on that? No theology. I'm a pragmatist. What's your, what's your pragmatic view of that? Um, you know, we, uh… I'm pretty sure that, um, ModCloth won't be selling on Amazon after Friday. Yeah. Yeah. I… Yeah, that's, uh, that ship's sailed now. But, um, you know, we just-- The, the two years I was at ModCloth, we just didn't get to it. Yeah. You know, we, we had conversation with them. I see the, the trade-offs, the benefits. Um, you know, in the one hand, you have folks saying, you know, "They're gonna bid up your terms. It become m- more expensive. You can't compete with the service that they're gonna offer your own customers, and they're gonna take your customers over time."
48:12 Um, and then on the other hand, you know, there's folks that are like, "Wow, that's a lot of volume, and we can get in front of a lot of people." Mm-hmm. "And, you know, the-- there's enough margin there for everybody to go around." Um, I, I've, I've always, you know, viewed Amazon as, um, as the alpha. You know, as the, um… You know, if you, if you… Be prepared if you dance with, you know, with Amazon, that the second that it wants to pull back, it will. And, um, you know, but I think cer- certain brands… I mean, look at what, what, uh, the footwear companies do. Mm-hmm. Right? They got plenty of, of, um, power in the value chain.
48:55 They got extremely smart segmentation in how they think about their, their, um, product lines through distribution. And so I think for certain businesses it makes complete sense, and they have the ability to, to share the, the proceeds. And I think for smaller guys, you have to be really careful. Yeah. Cool. Uh, one off-the-wall question. So, uh, Urban acquired a pizza company, and- They did? I was sitting next to you one time, and, uh, I forget where we were, but, like, someone was, like, totally pooping on that whole concept, and you were like f- you know, you were very angry and, and very positive about the whole pizza thing. Um- I don't get angry. You weren't angry. You were just like, you didn't agree with that person's opinion.
49:36 That, yeah, yeah. You were a zealous defender- Yes … of the pizza experience. Yeah. I, I, I think it's interesting. I think, you know, the, again, this kind of concession model where you have to bring entertainment into the stores and make it more experiential, it, it's probably the future of a lot of retail. Um, what, what was the thinking behind that, that pizza… I, I think that was under… while you were there. Yeah, I, I mean, I, I obviously, whether it's that deal or the, the ModCloth deal that just went hap- went down, I can't speak to anything, you know, specific, but here- Yeah, just- But in, but just in general, I can- Big picture stuff I, I go back to, you know, Urban is a collection of lifestyle brands, and they are pioneers in creating an experience with their customer in mind, and what does their target demographic of 18 to 28-year-olds, women and, and men who, you know, are interested in, in fashion and pop culture and music do?
50:36 They get together and eat. Yeah. Right? And so, um, I think it was genius to partner with somebody that was local in Philadelphia, you know, that there was the ability to work together on what that strategy should be. Mm-hmm. I think it was smart to, um, to get into a, um, a franchise in, in the pizza concept that was early in its gestation, so there was time to kinda mutually craft something that was beneficial to both the, the restaurant operator as well as the Urban. Um, and, you know, and then they gotta see. They gotta execute something that, that works, you know? And that's, that's always the unknown is will it work?
51:17 But I give them a lot of credit for having a, a vision and executing a strategy and, and working on it the same way that Anthropology is, is trying to reinvent the whole department store experience, and they're building out, you know, up to 40,000 square foot Anthropologies. Um, and going multi-department, but instead of it being, you know, um, high-low, it's very much for their target affluent, you know, customer who's into their aesthetic. Mm-hmm. And again, like, time will tell whether it works or not. Mm-hmm. But I just, I'm impressed by people who have a vision, who have the conviction to execute a strategy and wanna just work on it. I, I just really like the fact that it seems like they're not using conversion as the only success criteria, that they have to sell a, a garment every time you walk in there, that one of the intents of those experiences is that it's a brand impression, and if I'm not… I think, uh, Anthropology's even opening a hotel.
52:11 Um, I, I, I hadn't heard that. I mean, I know that that was talked about different times over the years. West Elm just did. Yep, yep. Um, and their, um, their president is an Urban alum. Yeah. So, you know, the apple doesn't fall far from the tree. But, um, the, uh… But yeah, I mean, it's the… I think that, that is the point about, I was trying to make about you're a brand or you're a software company, and you have to take both to the extremes. Mm-hmm, yeah. And, and, and I think in lifestyle and in fashion, you can, you can do a per- uh, my engineering hat again, you can do a Pareto analysis on how, how many big brands, you know, over time have remained relevant and cool- Mm-hmm … you know, to their target consumers, you know?
52:52 And so there's a lot of space in the market for a lot of different brands, and they can get to half a billion in revenue, a billion, maybe two, you know, and then you kind of tap out. Yeah. And so, but you have to, you know, be willing to, to focus and maximize on a, a particular opportunity for that brand. I mean, Burton Snowboards, I mean, the, the… They pioneered Learn to Ride as a kids… You know, basically a free instruction for kids because they wanted kids to have access to that sport as opposed to just learning how to ski. And then they, they hosted the US Open before X Games, before Winter Olympics was a, before it got cut over, to give the, the best athletes in the world of snowboarding a forum to get together and celebrate the sport.
53:37 Mm-hmm. And, and their, their whole mantra is progress over process, and it's just about repping the sport, you know? And so everybody who's involved in that business knows that it's about, you know, it's about that. And now you look back and it's like, oh my gosh, you go anywhere in the world and, you know, Big B is there, you know, not only teaching kids how to ride, but also, you know, you got everybody who wants to be, you know, the flying tomato and holding the board up when they get off for the, the, the selfie moment. Um, and so, but it's a commitment to the lifestyle and the brand purpose, and investing in that over time, you know, that allows you to create that result. A- and, and you have to have, you have to have somebody who's convicted and willing to, you know, to take that risk, and, and that always impresses me.
54:24 Uh, uh, me as well. And you know, Matt, it has happened again. Uh, we have blown through our allotted time. So I totally wanna thank you for your time, and it's always great to catch up. Thanks for joining us, Matt, and congrats again on the acquisition. We look forward to seeing where you guys take things next. Thanks, guys. Great to see you. I appreciate it. Yep. Until next time, happy commerce-ing. You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes or visit www.jasonandscot.com.
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed