EP046 - NRFs Matt Shay, CEO & Shop.org 2016 Day Recap
EP046 - Shop.org 2016 Day Recap w/ Matt Shay
EP046: Shop.org 2016 Day Recap w/ Matt Shay
Recap of the day 1 keynotes:
- Dr. Michio Kaku - Renowned physicist and futurist w/ Marc Maron.
- Mike Amend - EVP Omni-channel at JC Penny.
- Reshma Saujani - Founder of Girls Who Code.
Interview with Matt Shay, President and CEO of the National Retail Federation.
Don't forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.
Episode 46 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded on Wednesday, September 28th, 2016.
Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:02 Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here are Jason and Scot Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg. This episode is being recorded live from the NRF Shop.org Digital Summit on Tuesday, September 27th, 2016. As usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo.
0:42 Hey, everyone, thanks for joining us. This is the third of our live podcast here from the NRF Clubhouse live at the Digital Summit, and it's our last one for today, but don't be sad. In a short time, at 3:30, Jason and I are gonna do a breakout session on level two in rooms C1 and C2. It's debate season. Uh, hopefully everyone saw the debate last night, and Jason and I are gonna be live debating some of the most controversial topics in e-commerce. Since we're here at the Shop.org Summit, we have virtually unlimited access to some of the big names in the industry, and today we're joined by one of the biggest, Matt Shay, who is CEO of NRF Hi, guys. Thanks for the invitation. We're excited to have you here.
1:23 Sure. I know you're, you're kind of the, I call it the Mayor McCheese of this event. Uh, and, uh, I know you're super busy trying to meet everyone- Mayor McCheese or, or Mayor of the Munchkins? Mayor McCheese. I'll go with McCheese. Yes. Yeah. And, uh, you know, so it's, uh, we really appreciate you taking time out of your busy schedule, uh, to, to be on the podcast. Well, thank you. It's f- it's fun to be here. Yeah, yeah. No, we have s- a huge national, uh, international audience, and I thought we'd start with, uh, you know, what is NRF? And, and love to learn a little bit about your career, of how did you end up at NRF? And just give us a little, little riff on, on the background of yourself and, and then also what is the NRF, uh, and, and what role does it serve? So, uh, the NRF is the, the National Retail Federation.
2:04 And, uh, so we are the, uh, trade association for the retail industry, uh, in the United States primarily, but also around the world. We've got members from, uh, 100, more than 100 countries. Uh, we've got 25,000 member companies. Those are both traditional bricks-and-mortar retailers, digital retailers. And, uh, as you two know and talk about often, uh, on this podcast, um, you know, those worlds are increasingly converging. A- and we also have, uh, solution providers and strategic partners, uh, who provide services to help, uh, face those opportunities ahead. So, uh, we have been around for more than 100 years, and, um, we are headquartered in Washington, DC, with primarily, uh, advocacy mission, government relations, lobbying, promoting the industry.
2:46 And obviously, as you are seeing here, uh, at the show this week and at our other events, with, uh, an enormous, um, mission of connecting our, uh, friends and our partners, uh, with one another and, um, delivering education and, uh, thought leadership and research, uh, to help drive the industry forward and, and make everyone more successful. Cool. And how did you become involved with NRF? So I was, uh, very fortunate to, to, uh, uh, join NRF about six years ago. Uh, I'd been leading another trade association in Washington, DC called the International Franchise Association, and, uh, had been there for many years, um, uh, four or five as the CEO. And so primarily the, the career was in, uh, Washington, DC representing sort of consumer-facing industries, uh, on policy issues and, uh, and also thought leadership and, uh, and, and events, uh, and conferences and trade shows like this one.
3:39 So there's a very… a, a lot of similarity both in the, uh, the structure of the business and the composition of the membership. Lots of diversity in the membership. You can imagine what our membership looks like if we go from, you know, the legacy, uh, bricks and mortar all the way to the digital. So there's a lot of variability on the, uh, vertical side, and then horizontally from the very largest, you know, from a Walmart down to the very smallest, uh, startup digital company. So we are a, uh, a very heavily matrixed organization and lots of people in lots of boxes across, uh, department stores, discount stores, luxury stores, uh, grocery stores, chain restaurants- Uh, specialty retailers, uh, you know, home goods, uh, you sort of name it, all the way, uh, throughout the entire ecosystem Yeah, and then, um, so, so for folks that don't know is what is a trade association?
4:28 Is it a, um, is it a non-profit or is it more… Uh, we just had, uh, Brad from REI on talking about co-ops, so we're, we're learning today all about different business models out there. So give us the basics of what is a trade association. Yeah, no, that's, that's, uh, an excellent, uh, excellent question, Scott. So, um, so a trade association is basically a community, um, of either corporations or individuals. And, and in our case, technically speaking, um, the, the, the companies are the members. And so a company joins, um, the association, uh, shop.org, uh, or, or NRF. And, uh, the company joins the organization, uh, in order to associate with other companies, uh, that are in similar businesses, and to learn from one another, and to, uh, uh, gain the, uh, gain the benefits of being in a like-minded community where you can network with each other and share thoughts and ideas.
5:21 Uh, and also participate in an organization that, uh, hopefully helps to promote the industry, uh, of which you are a part, and help tell the story of that industry. And so, uh, in our case, we talk, uh, a lot about the, uh, the issues in Washington, um, that legislators and regulators are considering. Whether it's, um, uh, you know, whether they're labor issues or tax issues or privacy or payments, uh, a- a- a- any of those things, um, that, that affect lots of people in the industry. And then, uh, the other benefit, I think in addition to that, of course, is the opportunity to build relationships with your, with your peers and with your colleagues. Uh, and get the thought leadership that exists, uh, really only, and I think especially uniquely at events like this when we bring people together.
6:08 There's a certain, uh, you know, one or two dimensionality to, uh, to doing things anywhere other than in a, an event like this one. And, and when people are together, there's an energy level, uh, that, that exists. And, and there's also the, um, you know, sort of the unexpected, you lean to the person on your left or right at a, at a meeting, and you introduce yourself, and within a couple of years, who knows, you might be, uh, you might be really close, uh- You may be podcasting partners in life. You know? It could, it could be that. Who knows. Yeah, yeah. Any one of those things. So, so my first exposure to NRF was at a, a summit, uh, like this. Uh, Jason met his wife at a summit. I don't know if you, you really realize you bring people together. Um, but, uh, then I got invited to go to the big show, and I was kinda like… So this show blew my mind the first time I came to it, and then I went to the big show, uh, which you guys typically have in January.
6:56 Um, tell us a little bit about the big show for anyone that hasn't come to that. So- The, the, the scale. So there's like 5,000-ish people at this digital summit, and then the big show. Yeah, the big show is, um, more like 35,000. Yeah. Uh, it's in New York. It's in January. Uh, it is a much older, uh, event Uh, been around for more than 100 years in some form or fashion. Uh, obviously evolved tremendously over those years. Uh, a-and, uh, that has evolved into a, uh, I, I think substantially a technology show, um, heavy on, uh, the kinds of, uh, solutions that CIOs, um, are l- are looking for inside companies.
7:40 That was sort of the trajectory. But it's really now become, uh, an event at which almost regardless of where you are in the, in the, uh, retail operational, you know, table of organization, there's an event for you at that. It's just gotten so big- Yeah … that, uh, it's really sort of the can't, can't miss, uh, once a year event that attracts, um, executives from across the United States and also from around the world. So we have a substantial number of international delegates that attend, uh, each and every year. So that one is, uh, is the older show. It's, it's much more of a legacy show. Um, it's evolved to the point that I, I think, you know, one of the descriptions I heard a CEO of a, of a major retailer describe having been to both of these events over the years, he described it as the big show is the kind of place where you can identify solutions that could be deployed in your business tomorrow and, uh, and solve problems you're facing today.
8:35 And, and the digital summit, uh, where we're seeing what's happening here this week, that these are the kinds of things that, uh, certainly some of it you could deploy today to, to solve, uh, problems we're gonna face tomorrow. Um, but there's also a, a greater exposure to the things that may be happening, uh, over one or three or five years, uh, th-than, than the, uh, than you see at the big show. I think they exist in-- both exist in both places, but that's sort of the… The dis-this is a little more cutting edge even than that. And, uh, even more innovation here, I think, than, than you see there in some ways. Um, if that's a Yeah. And then, um- I think that's pretty accurate. Yeah. One, one last thing on that. The, it's been interesting going… My first trip to the big show was probably five years ago, and it was very heavy kind of store influence, so it was like point of sale systems, and self-checkouts.
9:23 And then it's been really interesting over that five-year arc to see the worlds collide, where now you have Demandware there, and Magento, and, and then even, even the, the big providers like Oracle, IBM, Microsoft, they've really tied in the web and, and how you bring that into the store. So it- it's been pretty interesting to kind of see that progression and see things collide that way. Yeah. And I, and I think that, uh, that's very reflective of what's happening in the consumer economy, what retailers face every single day. And so the s- the show, uh, has evolved that way to reflect the way that, uh, the people wanna shop. And, and so cons- you know, consumers are driving the business changes that, and the investments that retailers need to make in order to, to connect and engage with them the right, the right ways, and, uh, deliver things to them at the time and place of their choosing.
10:08 Uh, so you sort of see the, uh, you know, the old one about, uh, Wayne Gretzky's, the great one, uh, quote about you don't skate where the puck is, you skate where the puck's going to be. And I think what w- what we see where the puck is going to be is that, uh, digital players, uh, are gonna look in some ways more like the legacy bricks-and-mortar retailers, and the legacy bricks-and-mortar retailers, uh, are clearly gonna look much more like, uh, the digital e-commerce players because they just have to, uh, evolve that way. And I, I think that's, uh, in many ways, uh, reflected at what we see both at the content, uh, the conversations at both shows and also of course, uh, on the, uh, expo floor and looking around at the, uh, exhibitors here this week. Yeah. We actually had some dinosaurs.
10:49 I don't know, I couldn't tell if they were wrestling or having a fashion show, but that was kind of a interesting thing there. Yeah. Uh, I think it- it's, it's interesting to follow the evolution of the two shows. I know Scott's been to many more shop.orgs than I have been to, uh, but I think this is… Uh, I've been to the big show now for like 19 years, and it's, the anthropology of that show is really interesting. Like, the, the thing that's most important or new for retailers has, has evolved a lot over that time. And, you know, at, at any given time when EDI was becoming a big deal, that was all you heard about on the big show floor. Or then when retailers moved from sort of digital cash registers to POS, like, you know, the show was dominated by the POS vendors or the traffic vendors.
11:31 And to your point, now you walk around that show and a, a big portion of the vendors of that show are the, you know, the, a similar set of digital vendors that you, that you've always been used to seeing at this show. And so that really tells me that we're officially seeing the sort of convergence of those, those two disciplines. Yeah, I think that's, that's, that's very much what we see. And I, you know, there's, uh, uh, there's just the, the pace of change and, uh, you know, this is almost cliché-ish because it gets talked about all the time, but, but the pace of change, uh, a- and I think as, as got discussed, uh, in one of the, uh, opening sessions this morning, we had sort of a futurist and a physicist, um, talking about, you know, the future of the world.
12:15 And, and, uh, in some ways it almost appears as if there's, uh, too much information, I mean, almost overwhelmed by the, by the, uh, potential solutions that exist out there. And so figuring out how to navigate your way through all those solutions and deploy your, your capital investments and your people the right way and, and, and your, um, uh, your different strategies. I think that's one of the things that you have the opportunity to, to improve dramatically when you attend a- a- and you build those relationships with your peers and colleagues, is you sort of have a way of sifting through all of that and, and you can kind of sort the data, so to speak, and understand as you walk around a show floor as big as this one, okay, you know, where do I go to find the solution I need for my business?
12:56 Uh, you, you know, you almost need someone to give you some guidance about, you know, where do I begin? And then when I begin there, okay, I know I need this, but there are maybe 50 companies or 100 that could provide the solution. Well, how do I even sort those? And, uh, and I think that's, you know, a big benefit of being here, is having the chance to, you know, sort of work through that process. You know, we talk about social proof, it's kind of like peer proof where you can- Yes … you know, you can go and talk to the other CIO or head of digital and kind of say, "Hey, I'm thinking about these six things. What are you thinking about?" Yeah. Y- it's interesting to see those conversations happen organically at the show. Yeah. Yeah. There's that, that, that natural benchmarking or peer review that goes on that you're sort of constantly trying to recalibrate and, like, what's the new equilibrium on, uh, you know, what's, what's the current thinking on a particular solution or line of solutions?
13:43 And then from there, you know, who are the best providers? Uh, speaking of that, we're now sort of one day into this show. Is- are any sort of trends or, you know, common topics starting to emerge in your mind from this year's show? Yeah, you know, um, it, it's been, uh, such a great first day, uh, first half of the day as we get into the afternoon here. And, uh, and I've had the, the chance to make the briefest of, uh, walks onto the show floor, uh, because of the general sessions going on and, and, you know, we do a lot of, uh, on the content side, on the programming side, a lot of, um, customized and, and personalized programs even more than, than maybe we have done in the past.
14:23 So we've got a, a CMO, chief marketing officer council going, meeting going on right now. We had a, uh, a women's lunch, uh, earlier. We've got student programs going on highlighting, uh, students that are looking for careers in, um, in, in retail that have disci- you know, experience in IT and, and engineering, um, a- and mathematics. Uh, so I, I haven't had as much time to walk through the show floor as, as I would like yet and see some of the solutions. But I think the topics, um, among the topics that we've heard people discussing are things that, um, you know, in some ways, uh, you know, the out there topics, things people used to think were even, um, more dramatic, you know, science fiction kinds of solutions like, like drones, like virtual reality and augmented reality.
15:11 Did, did Scott pay you to give that answer? Uh, he, he, he didn't, but- It's on my badge … I'm, I'm, I'm glad to hear- My badge says, "Ask me about drones." I'm sorry. I, I'm glad… I, I, I didn't see the badge. But, uh, I'm, I'm glad that we're on the same, uh, flight plan or wavelength, uh, on that issue. So I mean, some really interesting solutions and enhancements to, uh, to businesses that, you know, a couple of years ago people would've said, "Oh, that's, you know, way far off in the future." And, and I think that's the interesting thing about this show is you're always having those conversations about not the thing that's right in front of your nose, but the thing that you don't know is gonna be right in front of your nose, uh, sooner than you think it will. Yeah, one, one thing I notice, uh, when I come to the show floor, I always kind of look at those big anchor tenants kind of thing.
15:54 Um, Demandware's always had an interesting kind of innovative booth with, one year they had Godiva chocolates. They always highlight a customer. Um, like Cole Haan, they've always done some cool stuff there. And there's no Demandware booth here this year, and, uh, I was kind of, like, taken aback, and then I remembered, aha, yes, they've been acquired by Salesforce. Uh, and it turns out that today is the day they changed all their corporate branding to be the new Salesforce. And I have to look over at it. What is it, the, uh- E-commerce cloud … e-commerce cloud. Sales cloud, yeah. Commerce cloud, not e-commerce cloud. So, so that's kind of an interesting new kind of thing. Yeah. Um, so that, that's, uh… A- and it's very thematic that some of these really big companies are really starting to wake up to the opportunity in, in digital retail. Um, NetSuite has been ac- you know, has a pending acquisition with Oracle.
16:35 Um, am I missing anything on that big front? I think those are the big ones. I think, yeah, for this year, those are the big ones, but that's really sort of, you know, uh, following a trend of the last several years with, like- E- eBay and PayPal have separate booths, so that's interesting. Yep. Yep, and, uh, uh, Braintree in, in the- Yeah … that PayPal ecosystem. Uh, certainly Hybris getting acquired by SAP- Yep a year ago. And so it ju- uh, the vendors at this show are getting bigger and bigger as the, the sort of, you know, things that were niche to just this industry are becoming very mainstream, and so we're seeing a lot of acquisitions and mergers. Yeah, and cer- you know, Salesforce is a CRM system, um, and you see that kind of colliding with this.
17:17 So understanding that customer from all angles is, is kind of becoming important. Uh, Jason, you, you keynoted, or you, you emceed some of the keynotes. Yeah. Uh, I was not able to because I was here sweating it out in the booth while you were having fun doing that. Um- Thanks for doing that, Scott. Yeah, give us- By the way, the… You cleaned up the booth really nicely. Thanks, thanks. All I saw was a tweet about killer ray- laser beams of doom. So, so give us kind of a, a synopsis of what happened at the keynotes. Yeah. Uh, so, uh, Matt, Matt sort of alluded to one of… The first keynote of the day, uh, which is, uh, Dr., uh- Michio Kaku, who, uh, is literally one of the, the co-founders of string theory. So, you know, I, I feel like that's an ongoing joke for me is, like, understanding thring- string theory.
18:00 And so it was a, a, a fulfillment of a dream to meet a guy that actually does understand it. That'd be a little scary. I'd have, like, one sentence, and I'd be way in over my head on that conversation. Yeah, I didn't even try. Yeah. Um, and, uh, uh, so in addition to being a preeminent physicist- Yeah … he's written a lot about, uh, predicting the future. And 20 years ago, he wrote this book about, um, how he saw the future evolving, and it's a lot of stuff that now feels very familiar to us. Uh, you know, he really anticipated the, the diminishing cost of technology and how that would make things ubiquitous. Mm-hmm. Um, and then there are a few predictions in his, his book that haven't come true yet, and one of them specific to commerce is that, man, all of the information we are gonna need to shop are gonna show up as augmented reality on our contact lenses.
18:47 Um, and so, you know, he, he sort of described this much more elegant version of Google Glass and that, that, uh, digital would really reduce a lot of the friction in shopping, and we'd get much richer, more personalized information to help us make purchase decisions. Um, you know, for a, a, a physicist, like, he, he really did a pretty good job of highlighting a lot of the, the trends that you and I talk about i, i- in the evolution of retail. Um, and so but to keep him sort of grounded, he was interviewed by Marc Maron, um, who's a, a, a great comedian and a very prolific, uh, podcaster himself. So, so Marc was sort of the skeptic and was, was holding, uh, uh, Dr., uh, um, uh, Kaku's, um- feet to the fire a little bit, which was kind of fun.
19:36 Um, so one of the things that, that he talked about was that, hey, uh, we need to solve the security problem. That like as, as now we're all relying on digital, and we just can't have these vulnerabilities that we have. So he's like, "The- there- there's going to be a new internet, um, and it'll be pre- predominantly based on optical communication, lasers communicating with each others. And one of the advantages of that is, uh, that when any third party taps into the communication stream, it changes the polarity of the laser, so you can actually, um, have a much more secure communication system where you know when, when someone's, uh, interrupting the communication." And, uh, Mark chimed in, "And then can the laser kill them?"
20:18 Ah, good. Uh-huh. So that, that became- It all makes sense. Yeah, that was a long explanation for a short joke. But a very, but a very good explanation for pretty complex subject matter. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then how does string theory tie into that? Yeah. A- a- and, and fairly entertaining. I thought delivered in a, in an, in an entertaining way. I, you know, I- I- I… Scott, since you had to be here on, you know, KP duty, um- … as they say, uh, or, or b- you know, BP duty, um, you know, I think that the int- o- o- one of the things that I took away from the session was sort of the, the, the theme of, uh, Dr. Kikue's entire, um, you know, hypothesis about the future was that, um- That the change that we will experience will eliminate friction, uh, in our life o-of-of all sorts.
21:05 So whether it is, uh, you know, the, uh, the speed at which commerce takes place, or whether it's the ease with which we, um, you know, complete our daily tasks, uh, whether they are the mundane or the complex, that, uh, that the future that will be touched by, um, all of these technologies we're talking about, whether drones or vir-virtual or, or digital or augmented reality, uh, a-a-and, and laser beams and the parallel, uh, internet that's gonna be more secure, um, that, that all of it is intended to, um, reduce friction, uh, in, in those transactions and interactions, uh, a-and create greater levels of security to the point that I think… You know, one of the analogies he used was, uh, you know, once upon a time, a hundred years ago, um, we th- we thought… or a hundred and twenty-five years ago, we, we, we were more, um, we, we were more aware of, um, electricity, for example.
22:05 And, and so you… I mean, you actually… It was something you had to think about as opposed to today, something you… that in many parts of the world, we're, we're fortunate to be in, in, in a part of the world in which we have this luxury, and not all parts of the world do, that we can sort of take, you know, uninterrupted, reliable, uh, electric power, uh, for granted. Now, this is a commercial for the Edison Electric Institute and, uh, and all their members and power-generating companies. But I, I guess what he was trying to suggest was that at some point in the future, the internet, for example, and computers, for example, will be things that we don't have to think about. They'll just, they'll just be there. They'll be so, uh, ingrained in the infrastructure of our lives that it'll just be a given, uh, in, in many ways, as electricity has become, uh, certainly in, uh, in the developed world.
22:52 Is he a singularity guy? Like, does he believe we'll, we'll upload our brains someday like, um, Kurzweil or, or… I didn't really get into that. So we didn't cover that. I actually listened to a couple of other podcasts from him. Um, and he, he, I think, doesn't believe that. Yeah, I think he believes that there's, um, some level of variability in the chemistry of our brain, um, that you literally, you know, you can't replicate us with artificial intelligence, for example. Um, but, but, uh, a couple other things from his, his keynote that really caught my attention. You know, he talked about the fact that we're all evolved from hunters, and so that we, we really are hardwired to want these physical trophies of our hunts.
23:32 And so he, he used that as sort of a metaphor to say there's always gonna be a, a physical component to shopping- Mm-hmm um, which, you know, I think resonated with a lot of the, uh, the, the retail members here, here at the session. Um, and then a real practical metaphor, uh, that, that he had, he talked about, um, taking advantage of these future trends is a lot like surfing. Um, you have to anticipate where the wave is gonna evolve, but you can't catch the wave if you're either too late or too early. Mm-hmm. Um, so the real art form is both knowing where there are gonna be good waves, but also getting the timing right. And so I, I think frankly, he, he was advising that, you know, sometimes it's better to be a fast follower than try to be that first surfer to catch that wave and end up getting wiped out by being, being too early.
24:19 Yeah. He, he did. And, and I was… You know, there's all the, the debate in, uh, marketing and the literature about You know, first mover advantage and, you know, he, he was not a proponent necessarily of first muver, first mover advantage in the traditional sense. He sounded much more like the guy that said, "Let a few guys go before you and, and fail spectacularly so that you can sort of surf in, so to speak, behind them, uh, or be in that, that, uh, that tail that gets created." Cool. So then after that, uh, there was the JCPenney keynote. Um, what were some of the highlights on that one? Yeah, so that was Mike Almond. Um, and so he's, uh, been at JCPenney about a year. He's the, uh, EVP of Omnichannel for JCPenney.
25:00 Um, uh, like a lot of the luminaries we talk about on, uh, this show, he, he, uh, has a distinguished career in our, in our industry. He, he came to JCPenney from, from, uh, Home Depot, and prior to Home Depot, he ran digital for Dell. Uh-huh. Um, so he was talking a lot about, uh, the reinvention of JCPenney, a 100-year-old retailer, um, and how they, they really plan to leverage omnichannel as a competitive advantage, um, in that they're really expanding their assortment and changing their value proposition for, for the core JCPenney customer. So that was things like, uh, expanding and rolling out the appliance category and things like that. Um, we had a good conversation about, uh, how JCPenney can acquire enough talent to achieve all its goals.
25:47 Um, and I found that interesting, and that dovetailed very well to our third keynoter, um, who was the founder of Girls Who Code. Mm-hmm. Um, and, and, uh, she's, uh, to me, a very inspirational woman that, that, uh, has really made it her life's mission to address this huge gender gap we have in the technology industry. Yeah. Um, and so they have a lot of innovative programs to expose, uh, young girls to technology and get them excited about exploring careers in technology. And that, that whole talent thing really feels like one of the trends at this show, um, that as we have all this digital growth, uh, we need a lot of new people to come to the space, and we frankly need smarter people that are, that are more well-grounded in these new, new trends that seem a little foreign to the, the three of us at this table.
26:35 And, uh, um, you know, I think people are spending a lot of brain cycles about that, and, uh, that- Uh, one of the great examples is, of course, uh, NRF and shop.org have our own scholarship program, the Ray Greenlee Scholarship. So maybe the, the, uh, one of my favorite parts of the day is that we bring all the finalists out for the Ray Greenlee Scholarship and award those scholarships. Yeah, that was, that was very exciting. Um, and Jason, that's an excellent example, and that's one of the things that y- you know, the whole emphasis on, um, on talent and on the next generation and on giving back. Uh, I mean, all of those things are reflected in, uh, certainly, uh, with, with the example of Girls Who Code and with the, uh, the scholarship that, that we, uh, confer and the other scholarships we do and, you know, the enormous investment we've made through our foundation, uh, generally, but through, through Shop and, uh, and through the NRF.
27:32 I mean, it's, it's sort of part of the, the culture of the organization. And, um, so today we were able to, to recognize one of those students with a twenty-five thousand dollar scholarship and the four runners up, uh, five thousand dollar scholarships. Uh, these were twenty-five enormously, uh, qualified, uh, competent, uh, scary smart young people, very poised and very articulate. And, uh, w- you know, people that have backgrounds and, and interests in, uh, sort of more the, the hard sciences and, I mean, in the sense of mathematics and s- science and technology and engineering. Uh, a- and, uh, and those are all young folks that, that will be, if they're not already, um, you know, engaged in retail careers.
28:12 And, and we're happy to have the, the chance to support them, and that, that's a, an exciting, uh, and I think a really very, very worthwhile, meritorious, um, element of, of, you know, what we're able to do here through the scholarship activities and really through the generosity of, uh, uh, of the members of shop.org, uh, over the years to create that scholarship and their foresight, uh, in thinking about how we s- prepare for the next generation. Yeah, there's, um, when you l- kind of open up the Wall Street Journal, there's always these articles about the millennials, and they don't eat cereal 'cause it's too hard to put together and, you know, all these kinds of things. And then you come and you meet some of these young people, and you're blown away. You know, you meet these 18, 19, 20-year-olds and they've… They're so passionate about what they're doing and articulate and, you know, they're, they, they ask amazing questions about data science and, and those kinds of things.
29:00 It makes you feel a lot better about the future than you do after you read the Wall Street Journal. So, so I, I always take those things with a little bit with a grain of salt. So I, I think we're in good hands with, with millennials and Gen Z. Um, and it's great to see NRF really kind of finding the cream of the crop and, and supporting them and bringing them into retail. Yeah. You think, you know, that one of the w- a- a- among all the labor statistics that get talked about, one that maybe doesn't get enough emphasis is the statistic that, uh, at the moment in this country, we've got the highest number of, uh, jobs unfilled because of skills mismatches in the, in the history of, uh, recording that data. So 5.7 or 5.8 million unfilled jobs because the right skills don't exist and, you know, certainly that, that's reflective of, you know, a number of policy issues.
29:45 Uh, you know, o- o- one of which is probably immigration policy and, and, you know, we don't have that mix right, and we need to fix it. But a huge component of that is that, you know, our educational system, our training system, we're not providing the right skills and, uh, and workforce experiences, uh, for these young people. And so we're, you know, we're behind the curve there. And we'll, we'll s- we'll catch up. We will. The market will demand it, and, uh, and employers and, and individual job seekers will drive it. So those lines will intersect at some point. But at the moment, there's an enormous gap that is, uh, unfilled, and I think that's an opportunity for, uh, for us to do the part that we can do. Obviously, we can't fill that entire gap on our own, but, uh, but there's certainly a need, and, uh, we should continue to play a big role there.
30:31 So, so, uh, we've talked about kind of the current situation. Let's take it a little bit to the future. Um, you guys tend to put out some really good holiday forecasts, and you typically do kind of a, an overall retail and then a digital one. I think it's too early for those. Those haven't been published. But do you have any kind of vibes on how the holiday's gonna shape up this year? So the, so the, uh, NRF, uh, uh, holiday forecast, uh, will be released in, uh, in early October. So c- about two more weeks we'll do it. Um, and- Here's an exclusive sneak peek. Yeah. So, so I think an exclusive sneak peek is, uh, that we see consumers, uh, in a very strong position, uh, relative to where they've been y- you know, since the outcome of the recession in 2009.
31:17 So, um, you know, wages are increasing. We've seen some data out of census, uh, just in the last two weeks that, uh, uh, household incomes are up, and, uh, and biggest levels, uh, since 2009, since before the recession. So we know that, uh, consumers are, uh, in relative terms much more healthy than they were. Um, we know the, you know, the wealth effect and, and home prices and the stock market. Uh, that doesn't affect every consumer in the marketplace, but they're all indicators. Uh, you know, gas prices are still low by historic standards. Um, savings rates are high. Uh, people are starting to take on more debt. Um, you know, I think the, the, the question is, um- How will consumers spend as we go into this holiday season?
32:02 Uh, I think, I think they're in a good place. And, uh, so I think, you know, all the fundamentals, the elements are all there for this to be, uh, a very positive holiday season. Yeah. In the, in the last two holidays, a lot of those things have been lined up, but the, the consumer's kinda chosen to do other things. If I listen to kinda, uh, the CEOs of some of the public companies, there's, there's this weird thing where people are s- you know, they're spending their money on, uh… They're saving more, or they're spending their money on experiences and services versus retail goods. Um, or, uh, you know, another big winner seems to be the kind of, you know, the, the iPhones and the Samsung devices and, and that kinda thing. Um, you think that's playing out, or it's kinda hard, hard to tell if, if that's gonna still be a, a bit of a headwind into this holiday?
32:47 I think we, we, uh, th- those are all, um, you know, Scott, those are really valid, uh, assessments of where we've been. So we've seen, uh, if you just look at how much money gets spent on technology and technology plans today, um, out of a, out of an individual's, uh, monthly budget or annual budget compared to 10 years ago, obviously that, that money came from somewhere. Yeah. Uh, and so there's a little bit of trading around. Uh, healthcare costs have, have gone up, and, and that's been, uh, much in the news as we make the transition to, to new forms of healthcare, and, uh, people are still sorting out, you know, h- how those costs, uh, shake out. And then we've seen people putting, uh, money into automobiles and into their homes, um, and, uh, and then into discretionary experience, hospitality, lodging, dining, all the, the categories you identified.
33:38 Uh, I think the, the unique thing about the holiday season is that, um, it is, uh, much more of a, of an emotional sort of, uh, an experience. And so in that regard, you know, there are opportunities I think for retailers to, um, you know, to, to, to give consumers that opportunity to share an experience. And to the extent that you create, uh, a holiday shopping, um, you know, experience that makes someone feel good about, uh, what they're doing, uh, I think that's, that's gonna be the key. You know, we have the sort of to a certain extent, the distraction of the presidential, uh, election that's created a lot- Is that going on right now? That'll be done by November 8th.
34:19 That's right. So we'll at least- It'll, it'll be over … we'll at least know. Yeah, we'll have it behind us. That's right. I'm kinda burned out on it myself. Yeah. Yep. Yep. Uh, you know, uh, speaking of presidential elections, I know one of the, the, the value adds, uh, that, that National Retail Federation provides is the governmental advocacy. Um, and there, there's always a big slate of, of things that we're working on. Are there any particular advocacy issues that are sort of the, you know, top of mind right now that are, you know, either coming up for votes or are particularly hot, uh, uh, in Washington? So I, I, you know, I, I think first of all we wanna keep the government open. And, uh, so we'll, we'll start with, we'll start with the basic, you know, uh, fulfilling the basic duties of let's keep the government open, uh, and, uh, and running.
35:03 And- Is there a budget kinda thing? Isn't it, isn't- Yeah, yeah … like early December or something? By the, by w- by the end of this week, we, we need to do something- Oh, really? So it's that imminent. I didn't realize that … which, which will, which will, I think, I think will get done. It's, it's, it's, uh, it's not in anyone's interest of either party to, uh, y- you know, have something, uh, you know, distracting happen, uh, just, just two months before the election. So that, that wouldn't serve anyone's purposes. At this particular point in time, you know, I think both political parties would recognize that would be a losing proposition for both of them, because they both have candidates running for election at the top of the ticket and all the way throughout the ticket. So I think that, uh, you know, Congress doesn't do anything until absolutely the last minute anyway, so I think we'll, you know, something will get done.
35:45 Um, you know, I think as, as we look ahead to the next year, there are some things that, that we feel, uh, strongly, uh, should be addressed. And, and it is, uh, a bit, uh, disconcerting that to the extent those things are being discussed now, there's not a lot of enthusiasm, uh, for them. You know, a trade deal, uh, is the obvious example. I mean, I think that, you know, it's certainly understandable why, uh, the sound bite against trade, uh, can sometimes be very powerful. And coming from y- you know, the Midwest, uh, originally growing up there and spending, you know, almost 30 years in Ohio before I moved away, I know that, that, that, that my old home state, uh, has been affected dramatically.
36:28 I mean, it's sort of ground zero in many ways for some of the negative effects of, uh, of what's happened, uh, to certain businesses, you know, when globalization and, and technology forces, uh, you know, alter the, the w- the historic way of doing business. Uh, and so, you know, there are no doubt, uh, very legitimate concerns about, you know, how we make sure that going forward people get the training and the skills and the education they need to make that transition. Um, uh, the reality is we can't, uh, pine away for the good old days. The good old days won't come back. Uh, and so we can't go backwards. We've gotta go forwards, and we have to recognize that if you, if you look across the breadth of the economy, the benefits of trade, while they're more widely diffused across the economy, uh, are apparent in everything we do.
37:18 Uh, for every individual in the United States, the l- life is better today than it was 25 or 50 years ago in many, many ways. Uh, and that ranges from consumer to, to healthcare to, uh, transportation, logistics, supply. I mean, across the board, and much of that is due to trade. So, uh, you know, seeing, you know, the, the, the National Party candidates, uh, speak negatively about trade, uh, when both of them have, uh, been for it in the past, uh, you know, w- w- w- you know, I think ultimately trade is something we have to do because if we don't, we'll be left behind. Uh, tax reform is the other big obvious example of something that needs to get done. Uh, the president, uh, has said, uh, repeatedly, and members of leadership in, in both, both parties in the Congress have said everyone recognizes the need for, um, tax reform.
38:08 Uh, we- You mean specifically sales tax, or you're including income tax in that as well? Well, I think, you know, corporate tax, uh, depending on who you talk to, the personal income tax, because while we've got, you know, one million C corps, we've got 30-plus million, um, you know, businesses filing as individuals, and so you sort of can't do one without the other because you, you know, the, you, you give corporations a tax rate of 25%, and you have individuals who compete in many ways with some of those, uh, organizations that are incorporated differently are still gonna pay 40 or 45%. So the, you know, there's a deal in there somewhere. I think that's, that's the, that's the stumbling block, uh, obviously in a big way is, uh, you know, how do you address the, the challenges of, of the existing sorts of, uh, expenditure, tax expenditures and credits that exist, and how do you get the rate to a, a level that is competitive around the world?
38:57 And at 35% corporate rate, we're, we're clearly not competitive with countries that are 10 or 15%, uh, we're the highest in the world. Uh, there's a reason that companies, uh, are doing these tax inversion deals Uh, it's not because they, uh, I think, wanna move jobs out of this country. It's because they're trying to be, be competitive. They wanna remain relevant, uh, in a global marketplace. And, you know, the marketplace has become globalized, but our tax system has not. And so the market is more competitive, and our tax system is not competitive. And, you know, you've got a complete, um, mismatch there. So I think, you know, those are two issues that we talk about a lot. And, uh, and then there are others that are unique to, to retail, um, you know, whether they rate to-- relate to privacy or they relate to payments.
39:45 Um, uh, so there are many other issues that, uh, we wanna address. And then, of course, there's a whole range of, uh, of labor issues, uh, because the retail industry has historically been so labor-intensive and for the foreseeable future will continue to be. Uh, and so to the extent that the cost of labor increases Cost of labor increases, uh, a- and that drives up expenses for everyone. So I think those, th- those are all categories of things we need to get on about, um, in the next… And then immigration, I mentioned earlier, but that's another one where, you know, we, we can't close our borders to the world for either, um, goods or services or the individuals that provide them. And why we, uh, the, we all know the refrain about why we bring the, the best and brightest young people from around the world to this country, educate them, and then send them away.
40:33 Uh, you know, th- this country was built on, uh, a robust immigration, uh, policy and an immigrant population that grew this country for generations and made it what it is today. I would venture to say that the three of us and most of the people listening to this podcast, uh, are, uh, descendants of immigrants to this country, uh, themselves. And, uh, so we all should recognize that, you know, our diversity is, uh, just as it is in shop.org and NRF. You know, diversity is one of our key strengths and differentiators, and to the extent that we let go of that, I think we let go of our future as well as our past. Cool. That, that's, uh, that's good. And that's just a sampling. I know there's a lot of other stuff you guys are working on. If people are interested in, in, uh, learning more about NRF, they can go to nrf.org.
41:17 Um, and we want to lose our- .com … . Oh, sorry, .com, nrf.com. Uh, and while we lose our… use our last kind of four minutes to think, so that was kind of a, you know, holiday and then a year out. What do you think is gonna be the big trends in three to five years? We, we talked about drones a little bit. Ch- you know, death lasers, I, I'm not sure if, if… That may be like 10 years out, so that may be- Yeah … a little too far out. But, but what are some of the things that, that you track and think retailers should be thinking about? Well, I, I think that, um, that consumers will, uh, will continue to be agnostic as to the, the channel, uh, through which they engage with, with, uh, retail businesses. And as a result, um, the convergence in retail that's taking place today, that, that, uh, dipping of the toe in the water of some legacy, uh, e-commerce businesses getting into the bricks-and-mortar business and the, uh, the existing bricks-and-mortar retailers starting to sort of edit their portfolio of retail and, and engage in even more, uh, of the best practices from digital online.
42:16 I think that'll be accelerated, uh, to the point that, you know, I don't think we'll ever see a point where, where, you know, th- those two worlds come together and it's completely identical, and you won't be able to distinguish who used to be legacy e-commerce, uh, pure e-tailer, and who used to be legacy bricks and mortar. But I think that the, the consumer is going to insist that the future experience that, that they want, uh, l- makes the world look, uh, relatively indistinguishable. And so you're gonna see, uh, the water's edge begin to disappear, uh, e- e- even more dramatically than it has today. And, and I think that's, that's reflected, you know, where we started at the top of the show, what the exhibits look like, what the content looks like at this program and others, just the way that's changed.
43:00 And we know how quickly consumers are moving. Uh, I mean, consumers are gonna drive this change. And so the companies that are able to, uh, respond and adapt or, or better yet anticipate, uh, to use, uh, Jason's, you know, observation about getting on the wave at the right time, those, those businesses will flourish. And the ones that don't r- really won't be around anymore. I mean, I think the time for, uh, half measures is gonna come and go, and some of those businesses will just, will just cease to exist, uh, because they won't be able to keep pace with where consumers are headed. Yeah. Very cool, Matt. Well, it's happened again. Uh, we have used all our allotted time, and it has flown by. We really appreciate you taking time out from the show to spend a few minutes with us and educate our users or listeners about uh, the National Retail Federation.
43:47 Um, and, uh, as a reminder, we're, you still have a breakout session at 3:30 today in level two, room C1. So we hope to see everyone there. Matt, are you coming to our session? I, I, I will be there. I'm gonna walk there with you now. All right. Okay. So thanks, thanks for having me. It's been great to be part of the show. Yeah, we really appreciate it. And we're done with our live podcasting for today, but we'll be back up tomorrow at 9:00 AM with Rob Schmaltz from Talbots, and then Facebook at 9:45. Thanks again, Matt. We really appreciate it. Thank you. You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes or visit www.jasonandscot.com.
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed