EP008 - Predictions for 2016
Episode 8 covers Jason & Scot's predictions for 2016, as well as Scots recent visit to the Amazon store, and Jason't visit to the CES show.
EP008 - Chat Commerce, Gen Z, New Retail, and Walmart Payments.
Scots top 5 predictions for 2016:
- 2016 will be the year of Chat Commerce
- Amazon will make some big moves in logistics
- Jet will prove the naysayers wrong, and get acquired
- Google will make a bold move this year in e-commerce that surprises everyone
- Alibaba’s attempts to bring Singles day to the US will fail
Jason top 5 predictions for 2016:
- CPG’s and grocery will make major moves into DTC e-commerce
- Re-Orgs. Retailers will get rid of stand alone e-commerce departments and integrate e-commerce into core business functions; brands will do the opposite and establish new e-commerce departments.
- Mobile gap will narrow to be at lest half of desktop conversion and some retailers will see 50% of their e-commerce revenue come from mobile devices
- A major retailer will get sold in distress (Macy’s/Sears/9 West/J Crew/Bon Ton/Neiman Marcus)
- 2016 will be the year of the cloud for E-Com platforms, Cloud products like Shopify and Big Commerce will continue to grow and even get more enterprise clients. Niche solutions like Cloud Craze (running on force.com) will get traction, and SAP, IBM, and Oracle will work hard to solidify their e-commerce cloud offerings.
Things that (sadly) aren't likely to happen in 2016:
- Buy buttons from social networks won't catch on. Social commerce will continue to struggle.
- E-Commerce sites won't get much better at personalization (and most suck now).
- We won't see many great examples of truely integrating content and commerce
- Omni-Channel retailers won't close the gap with Amazon
- No single new Payment technology will gain major traction.
Scot got to visit the Amazon store, and check out how Amazon's merchandising translates to brick and mortar.
Jason is at CES. There are many more products supporting interoperability this year, such as Ford integrating with Amazon Echo, Toyota supporting IFTTT, Roku and Apple set-top boxes offering universal search integrating multiple content sources.
/ / http://retailgeek.com/podcast
/ / Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:00 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here is Jason and Scot Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show. This is episode number eight, being recorded on January 6th, 2016. Our first show of 2016. I'm your host, Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, and as always, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Happy New Year, Scott.
0:41 Happy New Year to you, Jason. Hope you had a great one. You went, uh, you had a trip to California, and I think you're out in Vegas at CES now, right? I am indeed. Um, me and 170,000 of my fellow geeks all, uh, trying to get cellphone service. And fighting for Uber/taxis. Exactly. The first year of Uber here in Las Vegas. That's one of the big new product launches apparently at CES. Has it helped with the taxi line problem at CES? Uh, minorly. It's super helpful for, uh, getting rides from places other than at the convention center. There's so much conven- congestion getting in and out of the convention center that I'm not sure Uber helps particularly much, and they're, they are sort of a red-headed stepchild here.
1:24 They're, they've g- been given designated loading zones, which aren't the most convenient locations in most cases Kind of out by the dumpsters kind of behind the convention center? In many cases, and at, in many of the hotels, exactly. There's, like, a, a new designated, like, ride share area that Lyft and, and Uber can share. Interesting. Um, you were in Seattle over the holiday, were you not? I was, yeah. We had a good trip. It was kind of more of a fun thing versus work, but I did stop into the Amazon bookstore, so that was cool to finally see that after all the hype. Gotcha. And did it live up to that? I thought it was pretty good. It, you know, it had, uh… It's interesting to see kind of omni-channel done the Amazon way. It, it, the store pulls in a lot of the concepts of the website.
2:07 So, you know, here's some books in a category that got over four stars. Here's, um, you know, books that are the most, most rising in our ranks, and that kind of thing. So it's, it's pretty clever. And they, I know you love digital signage, and they actually did have a couple of interesting examples of digital signage. I'll, um, I'll send them to you and you can put them up on the Tidbits post. Oh, good. I would love to see them. Tell me what's, uh, so exciting about CES. Have you, uh, had any hoverboard incidents or anything? I have not. I actually have not seen a huge amount of hoverboards yet, which in some ways is a, a surprise. They've actually banned all attendees from using hoverboards, uh, number one, so they're, you know, there certainly are no- nobody going around the aisles on them.
2:50 And, uh, CES is really spread out, uh, across Las Vegas, so the, the halls that I have spent the most, uh, time in today were not the places you would most expect to see hoverboards. So I've seen a few, and even a couple new iterations of Segways. Next week I'll have had a chance to see all the halls and can maybe give a more complete recap of CES. But one thing that was really encouraging that I noticed in the first day is a lot more of the interesting products this year are sort of open and enable interoperability with other products than I've ever seen at CES before. Normally, when something new gets introduced by a major manufacturer at CES, it's, it's a feature that's only supported by that manufacturer.
3:32 So, you know, when a automo- when a car company wants to show you that they can open your garage door and park the car Like the car manufacturer makes their own garage door opener, and it's the only one that the feature's compatible with. Or maybe they partner with a single manufacturer of garage door openers and, and, uh, you, you know, it, it only works with that one product. Um, but, but this year at CES, a bunch of the connected car platforms were all leveraging, uh, the Amazon Echo product, and so you could fully control your car from your living room by talking to Echo. A bunch of them supported if this, then that. So you could, you know, develop your own applications. And it, it just seemed like many more of the consumer electronics manufacturers have embraced open APIs and services for their products than I've ever seen before, which I think is really encouraging for end users.
4:23 Cool. So kind of a interoperability kind of a focus versus closed wall kind of systems? Exactly. So in a way, it's a lot about making the features that had been previously introduced better and more useful than it is about, like, creating ne- new products this year. Yeah. How about any- anything on the e-commerce front, or have you been doing mostly the automotive hall? Uh, so I've been mostly in the central hall, which is like the TVs and AV equipment, and the, the north hall, which is the automotive hall. Um, Amazon does have a, a small booth, the, um, AV hall that is really focused on, on, uh, signing up, uh, B2B customers. And there is a, an e-commerce hall this year, and I haven't had a chance to get to it yet.
5:05 So we'll maybe talk about that a little bit more next year. But I know Alibaba has a significant presence there, and the folks that are making the most buzz at the show in the e-commerce space is the Masterpay platform from MasterCard. And I heard that they have a really interesting booth in the south hall. So I'm, I'm looking forward to seeing that. But I can tell you in Samsung's booth, they're, they're showing, uh, one of the, the, the products from this, uh, MasterPass initiative. Uh, they have a smart refrigerator that's pre-integrated with MasterCard payment information and integrated with FreshDirect and MyWebGrocer. So you can now… You know, for several years they've been showing these smart refrigerators that can theoretically order products, but this is the first year that they were, like, really plumbed into real services, so you could actually click a carton of eggs on the front door of the thing, and it took the money out of your credit card and sent the order to FreshDirect if you happen to live in New York.
6:01 Wow. Only $5,000. Yeah. That's pretty cool. So hopefully no bugs in there so you don't end up with like eight gallons of milk or anything crazy like that. But that, that's cool to have all these things connected and working well together. Exactly, yeah. I mean, it's a, it's an encouraging sign. I, I'm not sure that the use case of, uh, ordering groceries while standing in front of my refrigerator is necessarily the- the one that gets me most excited. But like, it, it's a common cliched use case here at CES, and so it's, it's, it's always interesting to see it get a little more real and practical. Yeah. Cool. B- I'm bummed I couldn't be out there this year. Um, I'm a huge electric car nerd, as you know, and it was interesting to watch the live stream of the Faraday big reveal.
6:42 Did you, uh, go to the Faraday Futures event where they… It's a new electric car company. Did, did you make it to that? I did not make it to the press release, uh, where they did the unveil, but I did make it to their booth and got to check out the, the new concept car, which was very cool. Yeah. It's kinda like electric Batmobile kind of thing. Exactly. A all-white, uh, electric Batmobile, so very, uh, swoopy and elegant. And we, we were joking a little bit though, you know, for most of the car manufacturers, the, the cockpits or dashboards have gotten super digital, and they all have these, you know, huge 18 to 40-inch, inch screens in them, and they're, You know, Corn- uh, Corning has a concept car that, that has a all-glass cockpit with no, uh, you know, tactile controls.
7:27 And then this, this Faraday d- uh, concept car, which is a beautiful car, the only digital thing in the dash is sort of a clip in the middle of the steering wheel to attach your iPhone to the steering wheel. And, uh, we were, we were joking a little bit that like an electric car with 1,000 horsepower and Facebook on the steering wheel, what could go wrong? Yeah, tiny little screen too. How about, a lot of the other recaps I've read about CES talk about drones and, uh, AR/VR being kind of the highlights, and the Oculus Rift went on pre-order today, so if you, uh, you ordered your Rift? I confess I've been pretty swamped. Uh, I fully intended to, and maybe will after we record the podcast, but I haven't gotten to it yet.
8:08 What about yourself? I, uh, was very patient, and at 11:00 my time, which was 8:00 AM your time, I waited for 30 minutes for a page to load, and it finally did, and I got an order in there. So I don't, I don't think I'm first in line, but I'm definitely, you know, in the first 30 minutes, whatever that means. Nice. They don't have a booth at this show, but they're, you know, obviously have the most mind share and buzz in the show. So, you know, that's a nice, nice position to be in. Yeah. Yeah, you get all the benefit, none of the cost. Gotta love that. Uh, so Scott, since this is a new year, I was, uh, gonna propose that we start a new tradition. Sure. What do you have in mind? So I'm thinking that we should each make some e-commerce predictions for the coming year so that in the unlikely event that we're still, uh, around in a year, um, we can, uh, revisit them and see how we did.
8:54 Unlikely? Come on, we made it past, what, what did you say? Seven episode. Yeah, so we're… That sounds good. I love predictions, so why don't you kick it off? Number one, I think that, uh, 2016 is gonna be a big year in e-commerce for the consumer packaged good companies and the grocery stores. So those are two categories that historically have not had much traction, and frankly, haven't had much effort put into them. And, uh, I think this is the year that we're gonna see folks like Kroger get really serious about e-commerce, and we're gonna see an awful lot of the CPG companies get really serious about their direct-to-consumer efforts, and primarily through e-commerce.
9:35 I agree with the trend. Um, one question is, so if I'm a CPG company, you know, like I'll pick on… Most of them tend to have kind of what are not traditional e-commerce sweet spot products. They're usually lower ASP and kinda heavy, right? So a can of Pringles or, um, toilet paper or, you know, what are, whatever, uh, condiments or something like that. How, how do you think they solve that problem? Is it kinda in partnership with the grocery stores, or do you think that they do an Amazon Pantry kinda thing? Or what… How do you, how do you think they get over that hurdle? Yeah, I think it, a, a blend of all the above. Like, when you look at the portfolios of most of these companies, most of them have some products that are much more suitable for direct-to-consumer e-commerce than others.
10:16 Um, and so obviously I think they'll, they'll start with those products, like either the products that are, have recurring use cases and, you know, uh, have subscriptions or that are high value for their weight. You can certainly imagine that diapers is a, a strong category for e-commerce, whereas gum is probably a tougher sell. But I do think there are gonna be some clever partnerships and use cases that we'll see the CPGs try to figure out how to create impulse purchases and move some of those, the lower price point p- products like gum and snacks as well. So- Cool … we shall see. Or you can laugh at me in a year. Yeah, we'll find out To go along with that, my number two trend is that the majority of businesses are gonna reorganize how they run their e-commerce businesses in 2016.
11:06 And I think there are gonna be two shifts in opposite directions. So I think for most of the retailers that we're familiar with that are already significantly, uh, invested in e-commerce, I think we're gonna see a lot of them start to, uh, shut down their dedicated e-commerce teams and absorb those e-commerce responsibilities back into the main organization. And so instead of having separate digital merchants from the, the retail merchants, I think we're gonna see the, the digital merchandising responsibility move into the retail merchandising area. And instead of having separate marketing functions, you know, marketing for that e-commerce site moves under the CMO, technology moves under the CIO, and all, all of those sorts of things.
11:50 So I think we're gonna see e-commerce become a core part of the main retail business owner's responsibilities for the established e-commerce companies. And at the same time, for a lot of these new companies that are just gonna kick off e-commerce, like the CPG guys that we talked about, uh, in my last prediction, I think we're gonna see them create their first e-commerce function. So we're gonna start to see a lot more VPs of e-commerce in the CPGs and grocery stores and, and things like that. Good. And that's, uh, so it's kind of interesting. They're kind of a wave behind each other, I guess. And the-- who-- what do you usually see when, when the e-commerce kind of separate silo gets dissolved at a retailer? Does it kinda take over or is it kind of a little bit of a shuffling of the deck, a little bit of retail, traditional brick and mortar, a little bit of online?
12:37 Or how, how does that usually fall out? Yeah. So at the moment it's, it's gone both ways, right? Like, part of this is a little bit of a internal power struggle that when e-commerce wasn't a very significant part of a retailer's business, the CMO didn't particularly care about it, right? So he's perfectly fine abdicating responsibility for that tiny piece of the budget. But now that- Driving traffic to that website has become one of the core marketing tools. The CMO wants to own that, right? Like, that's a- Mm-hmm … a key part of the media budget. That's a key part of brand building. And so they, they wanna bring that back in. So where the CMO is digitally savvy or has a lot of digital competency on their team, we're seeing, uh, that those legacy guys have, are very successful at, at inheriting that, that responsibility.
13:25 But in many cases where that was sort of a, a longtime legacy employee that wasn't very digitally savvy, which might have been one of the reasons he let that, he or she let that responsibility go in the first place, where th- those guys aren't very successful, uh, when they get that responsibility back. And so in many cases, some of those digital leaders that came into the organization when they first set up e-commerce are, you know, getting promoted into those, those C-suite positions. And I, you know, I think last year we saw a couple of, uh, digital leaders, you know, become the, uh, even the CEOs of some major retailers. And I think that's a trend that we'll continue to see as well. Cool. What's next? So my big one that I'm hoping maybe you'll disagree with a little bit is I think that we're gonna see the mobile gap that we both talked about close significantly th- this year.
14:13 So at the beginning of last year, you were about four times more likely to buy something if you visited an e-commerce site from a desktop browser than a mobile browser. Um, and by the end of this year, you're about three times more likely to buy on a desktop than a mobile. And I think next year that that average across all segments is gonna be more like two to one. And so we're gonna see, in general, conversion improve on mobile much faster, um, than it does on desktop. And I think by the end of next year, we're gonna see some major retailers that are actually doing more than 50% of their revenue from mobile, mobile browsers I think I agree with the end point, but I disagree with how we get there.
14:53 I, I think we get there… I just don't see the conversion rates really improving that much. And so I think we get there by the, the-- just the denominator gets so big that, you know, i-if the traffic gets kinda over 70 or 80%, the conversion rate doesn't have to move much. You'll just kinda get there. So we'll kinda have to, uh, agree to disagree on, on how we get there, but I agree that, that we will probably get there. Do you think we get there as an industry or just kind of saying select retailers? By the end of 2016, I don't think the industry average is 50% of revenue from mobile. I think it'll be 50% of mobile for, for retailers that have favorable demographics, right? Like, so, you know, retailers that are catering to slightly more frequent shoppers where, where mobile comes into play more or younger, more digitally native shoppers.
15:38 You know, I think they'll, they'll do better than, you know, some other, other types of retail. So I don't, I don't think we'll get 50% overall, but, you know, everyone will move closer to that. And, you know, frankly, this might be wishful thinking on my part, but I'm hoping part of the reason is because we'll get a lot more serious and a lot better about creating mobile shopping experiences. And that's also part of the reason I think the mobile gap closes. And there, there's a lot of interesting technology out there that the engineers have brought to the party to make mobile experiences better. There are things like mobile accelerated pages, which is this standard that a bunch of, uh, firms inc-including Google and Facebook and Twitter collaborated on to make mobile experiences much faster, to share tags for analytics amongst all the analytics platforms, and to do all these things to guarantee much higher performance on mobile sites.
16:30 But that really requires the retailer to build A mobile site as opposed to building a responsive site that kinda reformats itself to fit into a mobile screen. And so, you know, I think the retailers that have the best mobile conversion rates are gonna be the ones that, that adopt a lot of those technologies and move behi- beyond just simple responsive design as their, their one-size-fits-all solution. Is there an example you can point us to that you've seen that's kind of a retailer on the cutting edge of this trend? Uh, well, at the moment, and I mean, it's not really a fair example, but there, you know, there are a few retailers that have really focused on, uh, building a, an audience on their mobile app, right? And then, you know, I think of even a marketplace like Wish, and, you know, obviously the, those, those retailers have been much more successful on mobile.
17:16 But I, I don't have a great example of retailers that have built really sophisticated mobile websites yet. But I feel like all the requirements, the prerequisites are there to enable retailers to do that, and I think there's a bigger, big enough economic incentive now that it's on the roadmap of a lot of big retailers. Cool. My fourth prediction is kind of a sad one. As we've talked about on several other shows, I am very optimistic about the future of brick-and-mortar retail. But that being said, you know, I do think we're gonna see a lot of retailers, um, sort of reshuffle their portfolio and close underperforming stores, and I think that's a, a normal, healthy thing. But I do think next year we're gonna see at least one very well-known, venerable retail brand either completely, uh, go away or get sold in some, some sort of fire sale as, as they, uh, continue to have economic hardships.
18:07 And, you know, certainly at this point, you know, Macy's and Sears would both be potential candidates for that, for example. D- there's a lot of kinda negativity around JCPenney, but they don't… They, they seem to have come out of that. Are, are they-- I don't track them that closely. Are they on the, the list there of concern, or you think they're probably not in that bucket? I think they are. I don't think they're the most in distress at the moment. I mean, I think they, they stemmed some of their, their most significant challenges, and so they're on a, a slight uptick at the moment, and that gives them a little more runway. And, you know, frankly, there's even other retailers, like we talk about Best Buy a lot as a, a nice turnaround story and how they've really stemmed the tide, and the management team there has done a good job of, uh, navigating a, a challenging category.
18:53 In a, in the short run, I think it's a great story, but in the long run, that's a really challenging category to survive as a brick-and-mortar big box. And, uh, you know, I think a bunch of those retail concepts are gonna have to dramatically evolve, and I, you know, I think they have maybe more than 12 months of, of runway to do that. But, you know, some of these guys, I think the runway's starting to get pretty short. And so I do think we'll lose at least one storied brand next year. Wow. Yeah, I saw today Macy's was out with a release. I, I saw a highlight on CNBC that they're, they're closing a bunch of stores and, and, you know, kind of having to cut staff, so. Yeah, I think they had a really tough holiday, and, you know, that, that sucks. Um, I have to say, like, they're responding to it quickly, right?
19:36 And so maybe that, you know, that does save them, that they take the, you know, the difficult economic decisions early. But you can imagine there's a bunch of retailers in that similar category, and if some of them are a little slower to, to take some of the austerity measures necessary, you know, it's possible that they suffer before Macy's does. Yeah. Yeah, I agree. And, and the, uh, the press release that I saw also said they're gonna take a lot of the savings and put it into omni-channel and e-commerce. So, um, there is kind of… It's more of a shifting of dollars is kinda how it was read when I actually kinda saw the company's press release, which was interesting. Yeah. And that's a tough one 'cause that's a tactic that it's sort of a, a two-headed tactic, right? Like, a really smart, savvy retailer that understands the future would certainly adopt that tactic and say, "Hey, we're gonna, you know, start over-investing in, in e-commerce versus our brick-and-mortar."
20:25 But that's also the exact same tactic that, you know, any distressed broke retailer would say as they have to start giving up leases. Yeah. Yeah. I agree. To get a little more optimistic with my fifth and final prediction, I do think that 2016 is gonna be the year of the cloud for the e-commerce platforms. So there, there are a bunch of e-commerce platforms that are natively on the cloud, and I think this is gonna be a great year for them. I think BigCommerce and Shopify. I think, uh, you know, there's some interesting more niche-y platforms like CloudCrazy that's built on top of the salesforce.com Force platform. Um, and I think this is gonna be a great year for all of them, and I think it's gonna be the year that the, the really big enterprise on-prem platforms like SAP Hybris and Oracle, ATG, and, uh, IBM WebSphere, I think this is gonna be the year that they're gonna have to figure out how to make a great cloud offering.
21:20 Um, or if they, if they're not able to do that, I think they're really gonna lose ground to their competitors. Hmm. Do you think they'll kind of just do a… It'll be just more of a buying option where they just host it and it's not really a multi-tenant per se, or you think it's a total re-architecture kinda thing? All of them require some meaningful re-architecture to really have, uh, uh, re- most of the benefits of having a cloud infrastructure. For the big enterprise guys, it may or may not be multi-tenant. In fact, it probably won't be. But, you know, a lot of the elements of those, those SaaS offerings, like the b- the ability to quickly onboard a new site. And, you know, uh, many of these big e-commerce operators are opening operations for the first time in a bunch of new countries.
22:03 And so, you know, you, you need to be able to sort of copy and paste those instances and launch new sites in new regions really easily. And at the moment, most of these on-prem things are, you know, major new infrastructure projects to, to even, you know, get a development environment up and running for a new, new region of the world. Yeah, I agree that there's definitely a challenge there for these guys. It's… I'm not sure, unless they've been kind of quietly working at it for three or four years, it's gonna be hard to see if they do it this year. So I think, I think timing may eat you on that prediction. We'll, we'll kind of have to wait And see how it comes out in December. Yeah. Uh, totally po- possible that I have some wishful thinking. Um, but what do you think's gonna happen this year, Scott? Well, Jason, thanks for asking.
22:44 So my five predictions, my number one, and we've talked about it a little bit on the podcast, is, uh, chat commerce. So I think this is gonna be a year where kinda come holiday of '16, we spend a lot of time, uh, and are surprised by how much commerce is either influenced or happens on, on chat commerce. Um, couple kind of news items that relate to this. There was a TechCrunch had an interesting scoop, and I've kinda heard inklings of this from some retailers that have said things like, you know, "Should we be developing a bot for Facebook Messenger?" And, um, so now it's leaked that, uh, there is an SDK out there. It's super secret, but a lot of retailers are, are in the loop on this thing evidently.
23:24 And what this SDK does, it's an API that allows you to create bots that tie into Facebook Messenger. And, um, what's interesting is there's a whole-- allegedly, there's a whole set of these trans-- you know, these SDK elements that, that have transaction capability. So you can, you know, if you're having a customer service chat with someone or whatever the chat is, you can inject a product, and it can be purchased right within there. So, so I think, you know, Facebook Messenger is probably the one to, to watch closely. Um, related to that, we'll, we'll probably get an inkling, um, their big developer conference, as you know, but for our listeners, is called F8, and a lot of Facebookers call it Fate. Uh, and that's gonna be April 12th and 13th, um, out in the Bay Area.
24:06 So if, if there is gonna be a really big push, that's when we'll kinda learn about it. So that, that's a prediction we'll be able to kinda keep an eye on this spring. Um, another thing that was kind of interesting is, you know, every year Mark Zuckerberg has kinda his resolution. Last year, I think it was a new book every month or something, kind of a book club. This year, he basically said, "I'm gonna build an AI butler," which I thought was kind of a, you know, when you're a multi-billionaire, you have really interesting New Year's resolutions, and I just thought that was kind of, kind of interesting that it'd be-- sure would be nice to kinda have that resolution. No, I think it's totally cool. I, I had a deja vu moment. I don't know if you remember, but like Bill Gates actually had a similar aspiration when he was building this custom home that he wrote about, and it ended up, you know, the technology was just too rough back then to make it very elegant.
24:52 So in a, uh, I have much more confidence that, that, uh, all the tools are in place for, for Mark to do a very cool one this year. Yeah. I remember reading that book, and it never said the word internet. They were like trying to… I forget the word he used, um, but it was a very weird book because it kinda like was hinting at the internet, but he like purposely wouldn't use the word internet. It was very strange. Exactly. And, you know, the book was unfortunately, I think, entitled The Road Ahead, so it turns out the internet was in the road ahead. Yeah. What do you think about chat commerce? Do you think it's gonna be, um, a flop in '16, or you think it'll kinda hit? No, I, I totally agree. I think the most challenging part is going to be the actual transactions, and so, you know, I, I, I'm not sure across the board we'll ha- we'll see like huge revenue in terms of people actually conducting transactions through, through chat commerce, although I- I'm confident in some, some segments it will be really popular.
25:45 But I think in terms of chat commerce as a pre-sales tool and as a customer support tool, I think it's gonna get a lot of traction this year. And in fact, uh, if you're an entrepreneur looking for a new business, I think a bunch of retailers are not ready for it, um, and aren't gonna be in a position to build their own chat bots and services. And so I, I suspect there's gonna be a, a nice marketplace for some, some vendors to come in and offer those services to retailers that aren't prepared to build them themselves. Yeah. Yeah, totally agree. Um, my second prediction, and I always have to have an Amazon one, so here it goes. Um, and we talked about this a little bit on the podcast. A lot more has happened since we did-- we kind of took a week off in there, and there was a lot, um, that came out during that week.
26:30 Um, so this is-- You know, I think Amazon's gonna make some pretty big moves into logistics. I think, um, I think eventually they'll, they'll head-on compete with FedEx and UPS, meaning they'll help either individuals or retailers ship packages. I, I think in '16 we'll see them kind of selectively prune, um, some deliver-- some of their own deliveries, kind of their first and, you know, kind of their, their, their deliveries, uh, to consumers of products, either first party or third party through FBA. Uh, I don't think in '16 they'll get to the point where they offer kind of the whole open network kind of a thing. Um, some of the news items there, um, and I don't know if you saw some of this on vacation, but there was a big Wall Street Journal piece about the relationship between UPS and Amazon kind of falling apart.
27:12 Um, and I've talked to a couple logistics folks I know, and, and it's kind of interesting. It's all, it's all scuttle, but, but, you know, one of the things that, that I've heard is because Amazon has these sortation centers, they went to UPS and said, "Hey, you know," and you're aware of zone pricing where you have kind of zone one, two, and three. I think Amazon kind of said, "Hey, everything should be one zone because we're getting the product so close, and you, you shouldn't have to move it to your hub because we-- we're pre-sorting it for you. So therefore, we want a special price rate that's kind of like zone one pricing everywhere." Um, and then evidently UPS kind of said, you know, "No way," and then, uh, that has kind of caused Amazon to pull the trigger on getting a lot more serious about this stuff.
27:52 So, so that-that's one kind of angle. Um, you and I have talked about, you know, is there enough capacity out there? And, and if you're at Amazon, you're probably kind of doing some calculations. And if they-- Let's assume they had a great fourth quarter, um, you know, there's probably a point in time, maybe it's twenty twenty, maybe it's twenty nineteen, I, I don't know. Um, but you know, the-- A lot of logistics people talk about this. There's a point in time because of just the, the current capacity, FedEx and UPS are adding capacity at a rate that is slower than e-commerce, and Amazon's growing two times e-commerce, so therefore they're growing orders of magnitude faster than the UPS and FedEx capabilities. Um, you know, what happens there? I, um… A lot of people have suggested to me Amazon should just buy the USPS.
28:34 I don't think that happens. I think that's kind of crazy talk. But, um, so I think that's gonna be really interesting to watch this year, uh, and would love to hear your thoughts on it. Yeah, I, I absolutely think, I mean, both as a competitive advantage initially, and to your point, just to solve the capacity problem, I, I think we're gonna see Amazon use their software and data analysis to take a lot of the low-hanging fruit logistics away from the third parties and bring that in-house and, and take more of that margin for themselves, if nothing else. I do think one limiting factor, I, I think we're gonna see Amazon invest a lot in, like, their domestic logistics and moving packages around in the US to either, to your point, you know, make it more efficient to just give to the other carriers to deliver the last mile or to deliver it, you know, all the way themselves.
29:24 But a big chunk of, of, uh, UPS's business is international freight, and, you know, it, it has occurred to me that that's gonna be a tougher nut for Amazon to crack. And, you know, as, as we've talked about, Amazon likes to build these infrastructures and then sell them to third parties, and I think there are lots of retailers that would be happy to pay a cheaper delivery fee to Amazon to have them move the boxes around in the US. I think there are a lot less retailers that wanna partner with Amazon on international freight when you suddenly have to disclose, uh, all the sourcing and pricing information that you do for customs to Amazon in order to, to facilitate them moving your, your packages internationally.
30:04 So I think domestic logistics is gonna be a big, big move for Amazon, but I, I, I wonder if it ever gets to, to be a worldwide thing. Yeah. Yeah, I agree. We'll, we'll kind of have to wait and see on the cross-border piece. That, that's kind of… And, and I don't think that's the majority of Amazon's, you know, business. I, I, I think it's probably 10%-ish or something. It's probably immaterial. Um, my third prediction is around Jet, and, uh, there's increasingly large number of naysayers around Jet I've found here recently. And I don't, I don't know if it's because of some of the, you know, the Wall Street Journal stuff about them having a hard time raising money or something. Um, but I think that, you know, there's, there's some kind of naysayers out there, and I, I think they're gonna be wrong.
30:46 I think Jet's gonna do really well. I think they've got a model that does work. It does have positive gross margins and all these kinds of things. Um, and I, uh, I'll kind of put it out there, this is maybe a little controversial, but I think that they do well enough that they get acquired next year. I think there's enough, uh, companies that wanna catch up on e-commerce and/or have, uh, you know, a counter to what Amazon's doing that we see Jet get acquired next year. So that, that's kind of my perhaps boldest prediction. Yeah, I absolutely think that's a b- a bold one. I'm, I'm gonna disagree with you on that one. I'm a fan of Jet, and I, I certainly want to see them succeed, but I think if they get acquired next year, it's gonna be for a bad reason.
31:26 It's gonna be because it-- they're in distress, and it's the only way to continue operations. And I, I don't think they're in trouble because of fundraising or anything. In, in fact, I think there's so many people that wanna see a foil to Amazon that it's artificially easy for them to raise money, and they've, they've raised a ton of it. Like I, I think in the long run, um, my fear with Jet is simply that their value pr- proposition is a tough one to sell to consumers, that if you're willing to deal with more complexity and complication and, you know, frankly like delays and more variance in the delivery of product, then we'll help you save money. And I, I think consumers are cost-conscious, but I think they're, they're also fundamentally take the path of least resistance.
32:11 And I think Jet is-- model is potentially is putting too much of the burden on the consumer, and I think that, that makes their value proposition a little nebulous. Hmm. Okay. We'll see. We'll see. The-- my fourth prediction is, and I, I can go fast through these last two. So, um, uh, I think Google this year is gonna make a pretty bold move. I think, I think that they're gonna look back at holiday '15 and have a bit of a bloody nose from Amazon, and at some point they're gonna say, you know, and maybe it's part of this alphabet rearrangement that they, they have the flexibility now to do more. But I just feel like, um, they're gonna do something big in e-commerce this year. Um, and they-- I think it'll be surprising, and it'll be a pretty bold move, and I, I think they kind of have to.
32:55 I think they're at this point where, um, you know, Amazon's pulling away and, and taking a lot of share of product search from them, that they're, they're gonna almost be, uh, on the existential kind of crisis mode here this year. So we'll, we'll have to see how that plays out for Google. Interesting. Yeah, I certainly think they have to do something. E-commerce is a huge part of their revenue. The majority of those ads are for folks that are selling goods online. Um, and so I think it's, it's very dangerous for them to continue to let, uh, Amazon in particular get, get all the traction in that space. So I, I do think they need to do something to shake it up. What, what's your definition of bold? Like I, you know, I, I think they're gonna offer buy buttons, and I think they'll have some, some limited success with that, but that doesn't feel bold to me.
33:40 Are you… I mean, are you talking about like literally creating an e-commerce offering or a platform or, or a service that helps, you know, Walmart and Target be more competitive with Amazon? Is it something like that? I don't know what it is. It's just kind of a feeling. I think it could be, um, it could be something like that. Uh, I think it's probably more of a big acquisition. So maybe they buy PayPal, or maybe they, maybe they're the guys that buy Jet. Um, maybe they in some way, um, you know, they're just kind of an enemy of my enemy is my friend thing, so maybe there's a partnership there that surprises us. Like maybe they work with Alibaba or something. I, you know, we'll have to kind of wait and see. Yeah. Uh, I'd, I'd love to see them buy ShopRunner and turn it into a real viable FBA alternative.
34:22 Yeah. Yeah, that, that could be another one. For the record, if that comes true, I'm only giving you half credit on that prediction since you didn't really get very specific. Okay. We'll see. It has to be bold. That's the, that's the thing. I don't know if ShopRunner's bold enough. Fair enough. We have to be shocked. And then my last prediction is, uh, as you know, Alibaba has been really pushing Singles Day and, um, at this year or in '15 they, they said, "Next year we're gonna make this a big US kind of an event." Um, and I just don't think it's gonna stick. I, I just think that we have our holiday calendar here in the US. We're pretty stuck to it. I think retailers may kind of give it a bit of a, you know, you know, softball kind of an attempt, just kind of put something up and see how it goes.
35:03 Um, and then certainly US retailers want to take, you know, advantage of Chinese consumers, and there'll be some of that. But I just don't see US retailers and US consumers really kind of getting into the whole Singles Day thing. Uh, I think you are probably right there. I think if they, they find a way to make it relevant in the US, it'll be something other than, uh, getting, uh, US consumers to buy a bunch of goods on Singles Day from, from, uh, for delivery in the US. Yep. And I know we're running right up against time, but, um, how about any ideas you have of where, where are some things you wanna see this year that probably won't happen? Um, so kinda anti-predictions. Yeah.
35:43 Uh, it's funny 'cause when, you know, you're thinking about what, what you think are the predictions, the, the first thing that come to mind are all these things you want it to be true, um, but that probably aren't, right? So I, I was desperate to say, "Hey, this is gonna be the year of personalization, and we'll finally see retailers leverage all that information we're sharing, uh, with them about ourselves to make the experiences better." Um, and, you know, while I'd love that to be true, I, I don't think we're gonna see huge, huge progress on personalization this year. Uh, we, we talk a awful lot with retailers about, uh, the integration of comme- commerce and content and how to, you know, better blend those two kinds of experiences. At the moment, you go to a lot of sites, and there's kind of a choose your adventure. You click the read tab, and you, you get a bunch of great content, or you click the shop tab, and you get, you get commerce experiences, but the two are, are very segregated.
36:31 Um, and I'd, I'd love to say this is the year we see some great examples of, of integrating those two experiences, but I'm not, I'm not optimistic that that will be true. I'd love to say this is the year s- uh, a bunch of the, the traditional retailers figure out how to fight back against Amazon and kinda close the growth gap between, uh, their, their digital operations and Amazon, but I, I strongly suspect Amazon's gonna widen the gap largely around a lot of the logistics investments that you've already talked about. Obviously, there's a ton of buzz around payments, and I think we're gonna see a lot of new payment platforms launch next year, but I don't think next year is the year that any of them win or get, you know, significant traction. And, uh, you know, this quarter we had a lot of talk about buy buttons and, you know, sort of social commerce, and I, I, I don't think we're gonna see any of those become, you know, really big wins or mainstream this year.
37:19 Hmm. How about, um, on payments, do you think Apple, Apple Pay, um, jumps to websites? And, uh, you know, I've always kinda wondered why Apple doesn't have effectively a marketplace, so kind of a, a collection of, of e-commerce-type products that are available through Apple Pay. You, you don't think any of that gets traction in '16? I don't. I mean, they have to get there eventually for it to be a successful payment platform, and, and you have to have a solution for the, for e-commerce on the web, not just on apps. But I, I think Apple's, uh, certainly more than a year away from being able to do that based on, on their security models right now. And obviously they do a lot of stuff in, uh, in stealth, and so it's possible they've been working on this a lot longer than I suspect.
38:02 But I, uh, not very optimistic that 2016 is gonna be a huge progress year for Apple Pay. If anything, it's gonna be the year that Apple Pay sees a bunch of competitors with similar strengths and weaknesses to theirs and, you know, some that will address their weaknesses. Um, so I think it's gonna be a crowded, confusing space, and I think that confusion is gonna hurt adoption for any of them. Cool. Well, I think that's a good set of predictions. We'll, um, we'll immortalize these and, and keep track of them as we go. Uh, I think we're up against time, so should we call it a show? I think that's a great idea, Scott. Um, next week we'll, uh, hopefully be able to share a more detailed recap about CES, and that'll also sort of be our pre-NRF, uh, show.
38:43 Sounds good, and thanks everyone for joining us today. We'll talk to you next week You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes and please leave a review
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed