Welcome to The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News!
Feb. 3, 2017

EP067 - Recode's Jason Del Rey

EP067 - Recode's Jason Del Rey
EP067 - Recode's Jason Del Rey
The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News
EP067 - Recode's Jason Del Rey

EP067 - Recode's Jason Del Rey

Jason Del Rey is the Senior Editor covering Commerce and Payments at Recode. You can follow him on twitter at @DelRey. He hosts the #CodeCommerce series of events, the next one of which is in Las Vegas on March 20th. He's always looking for new scoops in the commerce industry at jason@recode.net. Jason sat down for a interview live from the NRF Big Show, and we covered a wide range of topics.

Don't forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.

Episode 67 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded on Monday January 16th, 2017.

http://jasonandscot.com

Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.

0:02 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here are Jason and Scot Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show. This episode is being recorded live from the NRF Big Show in New York City. We wanna thank the folks at NRF for hosting us this year. As usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Jason, and welcome, listeners. We have a really good treat for you today. This guy has more scoops on e-commerce than anyone else I read.

0:46 He follows e-commerce, Amazon, and payments for Recode, and you guys share a first name, so, uh, we'll have to see if you're related here in a minute. Um- It's the most powerful name in e-commerce, Scott. Goldberg. I will point out we've had two Scotts on the show, so we're just catching up on Jasons here. Oh. Um, let's welcome Jason Del Rey, senior editor of commerce at Recode, to the show. Thanks for having me, guys. So about four… I'm about four years into this beat, and, um, very happy to be here because I've learned a ton from both of you. So I know how to kiss butt, too- Yeah … as you can tell. Yeah. Gotta work the sources. Yes. That, that's an important skill, 'cause I'm actually auditioning for a new co-host. Uh, you know, w- uh- … Scott's probations period is about up, and we got some hard decisions to make, so.

1:27 I think Jason and Jason Show would be kind of weird. J squared? Yeah. Yeah, I don't know. I don't like it. Of course you don't like it. Cool. So you've been, uh, on the e-commerce beat for four years. Tell us a little bit about your background. Um, where'd you go to school? Did you go to school for journalism, or you just kinda stumbled into it? And what, uh, what kind of things did you cover before the wacky world of commerce? Sure. So, um, I've been in journalism pretty much since I graduated college, which was about 12 or 13 years ago. Um, and I went to school at Georgetown University, uh, with a very useful double major of English and Italian. Hmm. My accountant father was very, very proud of that decision. Um- … so about two years later, I went to journalism school, a one-year program, uh, in New York at Columbia.

2:12 And, um, have basically since I graduated from there, have been a business journalist. Um, Inc. Mag- I was at Inc. Magazine writing about all sorts of entrepreneurs and small businesses, Advertising Age, where I wrote about the digital media industry and the very fascinating advertising technology industry. And then, um, and actually was enjoying that quite fine, but had an opportunity to work with Kara Swisher and Peter Kafka at, what was then called, All Things Digital, now Recode, and, uh, there was an opening for a commerce reporter. And I thought covering Amazon, as it's turned out to be, would be very challenging, fascinating, um, experience.

2:53 So, uh, that's the quick and dirty. I did some sports reporting at some point in there prior to grad school. Um, so if you follow me on Twitter, um, you're a brave person, and you will get some sports mixed in there. But I- I was gonna say, on Twitter, you still are a sports reporter. I- Or at least commentator. I, I am. Yeah, it seems like Giants, and Knicks- Knicks … yeah … and- That's about r- … hockey. You follow hockey, too, right? Uh, dist- Little? … that's a distant fourth after basketball- Athletics … football, and, uh, and baseball. I am a New York Rangers fan. Um, but you will get commerce. You will get commerce too if you follow me. So, uh, Del Rey on Twitter. I'm already starting the plugging. We haven't even gotten started. Exactly.

3:33 And that's D-E-L-R-E-Y, not- R-E-Y. And not- Correct. R-A-Y. But if you're into cats, R-A-Y is also a good follow. Yes. Yes. We've already gone off the rails. Yeah. I like you guys. Cool. So you're here at NerdRF. You've had a, had a chance to look around here or, um, what are the kind of things… So when a reporter comes to a show like this, what are, what are you sniffing out? Um, I'm really, you know, one thing I'm looking, usually looking for is, like, what the, like, energy and vibe is, frankly. Like, this is, you know, probably one of the biggest, if not biggest, group of, um, retailers in one space in the world. And so, you know, sentiment is always something that I'm, I'm trying to get at.

4:16 Um, it's obviously not a science, but you can… You know, you spend enough time, you could tell. Um, I've only been here a few hours, so probably a bit early. Um, frankly, I'm always interested in whether people have their heads in the sand or are, like, talking openly about the huge challenges facing the sector. Doesn't mean they need to mention Amazon every other sentence, but, like, s- like, awareness is usually a good s- like, a starting point. Um, so that's something I'm looking for as well. And then of course, you know, we're a technology publication. And so if there are technologies that are really, you know, you know, going past pilots, um, with big organizations, that's something I'm, I'm trying to get at as well.

4:58 So, um, we'll see over the next 36 hours. Hopefully I'll, I'll get answers to a bunch of that. Cool. One, one thing you kinda wrote before you, you know, in the last week, I believe, was, uh… And I may get this wrong, but it was Macy's, you know, Amazon didn't kill Macy's, Macy's killed Macy's. I did. I did. Tell us, riff on that a little bit. You know, so, so one thing that's always weird about this show, it's kinda here early January, and that's when all these stores, it's kind of become an annual drumbeat in the last three years, they announce all their store closures. So you have like you know, January 10th, you know, "I'm closing 100 stores. Limited's out of business," you know, et cetera. And then here we are kind of in an industry gathering. Um, so, so would love to hear your thoughts on that whole Macy's piece. That, that was interesting. Sure. So I mean, funny thing is, um, I almost didn't write it because I thought a lot of what I was saying was obvious.

5:44 But I've also found in over a decade that, like, some of the most obvious findings can be the, the best received. And, um, I think I may have said this on Twitter. I got, I've gotten the most feedback on this piece, which was, which was, you know, based on four years of reporting knowledge but was really commentary. Um- Feedback being death threats, or? No. Uh, so I mean, maybe people are saving the hate mail and sending it- … via, you know, snail mail, and I haven't gotten it yet. But most of it has been right on, "I don't know why more people aren't saying this." I've gotten emails from, um, former CEOs of, uh, different parts of the Macy's organization, not, not the company on the whole. Um, current employees- Are you sure? ' Cause I think Terry Lundgren knows how to block his caller ID.

6:27 Um, you know, current employees just saying, "Listen, we've had, we've, you know, it's kind of simplistic stuff, but we've had merch- we've had merchandising problems, differentiation problems." Um- You know, we're an organization… This is coming from current employees. We're an organization that's a top-down organization, and, you know, we have a lot of great ideas at the lower levels in technology, and we're, we just feel like we're in a really tough spot. And so, um, I just think, you know, people have seen the e-commerce and Amazon wave coming for a long, long time, or should have. And, um, you know, I just, I think the word I may have used somewhere in it is, like, I, I've sensed compla- complacency.

7:09 And they're not alone, but they're a big brand that a lot of people love, and it would be really sad to see them, you know, go away. And I know that sounds crazy right now with hundreds of stores still, but, I mean, this stuff is, this stuff's, like, changing really rapidly right now. And so, um, I worry about the size of their stores. I worry about differentiation and merchandising, and, um, and we'll see. I, I think the American public should be rooting for retailers to figure a lot of this stuff out. Um, um, you know, we all like in the e-commerce industry to talk a bunch about, you know, you know, how innovative, you know, digital-first companies are. But I, I think economy-wise we, we, we need success from some of the traditional guys.

7:51 So hopefully they figure it out. Yeah, and it's not crazy to talk about. I mean, shortly before the three of us were born, Woolworths was the largest company in the United States. Right. And for most of our lifetime, Sears was the largest company in the US. And so, I mean, it, there's, there's a, a strong pattern there that, you know, it, it's, you're almost more bucking the trend if you survive a major disruption like digital and remain a big player. Totally. I mean, you could count on, I don't know, couple fingers of, like, of big traditional retailers that, um, that you could really make a strong, strong bet on right now as, you know, w- w- leading first in digital in the future.

8:33 Um, so… It's, it's funny though, I do struggle… I, I loved the article. I struggle with the whole topic of, uh, don't blame Amazon. Um, because I, it's, I certainly agree with that, right? Like, no retailer is going out of business because of something Amazon did. Um, but the flip side is we also talk on this show an awful lot, I think, we think a lot of retailers underestimate the effect that Amazon has, right? And, you know, last holiday season everyone's talking about the weather being the major disruption. It was too warm, not a… Yeah. Too warm here, not warm enough there. And miraculously, Amazon and some other retailers did really well des- despite the weather.

9:14 Right. And so in some ways, I think re- many retailers are still underestimating the threat. And I, I still go to retailers all the time, and they're talking about how to compete with two-day shipping. And I'm like, "Guys, 60% of Amazon is one-hour shipping." Right. Um, the- No, that's a fair, that, that, that's a fair flip side. And, and, you know- Yeah, of course, yeah, you, part, part of it, part of writing something that, um, you want attention for or you think is worthy of it is, you know, being bold in your stance. And I don't think anywhere I would say, you know, Amazon has not had an impact. But I think the w- I think, I think we're actually kind of coming to the same place, which is sometimes the lack of self-awareness that, um, some big company boards and C-level suites are showing in the space, um, is alarming.

10:05 Yeah. I think that, I think that's what I, I think that's what I'd say. Sometimes big companies have to walk right up to that existential cliff before they, they change. Um, some of them don't, you know. So like Microsoft's a good example, where they kind of walked right up to the cliff, and they seem to have come back a little bit. Yep. Uh, it's a little bit easier when you're a technology company 'cause you don't have stores and like all this, you know. Um- So it'll be interesting … and then the last thing I'll, I'll say on this point is, and I, I didn't really get at this in the piece, but you know, the c- the having to deal with the quarterly drumbeat of earnings as a public company, um, and having, you know, it's not talked about a lot, but having, you know- Obviously bonuses and the like tied to performance. I mean, it's, it's really… I, I'm not blaming the public markets necessarily, but most companies are not, uh, do not have the leash to operate on, you know, 5, 10-year horizons like Amazon has earned, I think now earned for itself.

10:55 And so I don't know how do you break out of that. I mean, you have to, y- resetting expectations to say, "You know, we're gonna start thinking two, three years out, and our numbers are gonna show that," you know, that's g- that's gonna be tough as a CEO. Yeah. That's actually … So that's the interesting thing is we're, we're seeing a bunch of retailers announce store closures. One of the disappointing things to me is, uh, when you're gonna reset expectations in the market, that's the perfect time to take all of your medicine, right? Right. And say, "Hey, we're gonna close these stores, and we're gonna make some strategic investments that aren't gonna have immediate payback, and here's gonna be the effect." And the markets are obviously gonna react to that, and that sucks. But the markets are gonna react just on the store closure.

11:36 So why wouldn't you… You have this opportunity to reset expectations. Like, it feels like you should go in with both feet, and I… It, it feels like I'm seeing a bunch of retailers coming in the market with the bad news on the store closures, but not using that opportunity to, to reset expectations around- To rip, to rip the Band-Aid off. Exactly. Yeah. I think to reset the expectations to the level you need. So they do, they… But it's usually 5 or 10% kind of thing. This is gonna be like, "We're not gonna make a profit for five years. We're gonna…" You know, I just don't think they can, you know… That's like a 180 degree kind of reset. Well, the note, the note I got from one, um, young Macy's employee in technology there was, um, you know, a lot of the project, you know, when new projects are being drummed up, um, you know, R- unless it ha- unless it's ROI positive from, you know, essentially day one, it's not happening.

12:28 And, and granted, like, start, Silicon Valley could learn a lot from… Is probably the other extreme there, but there's probably a middle ground where you need to be cooking up some new stuff that you're not gonna see, um, you're not gonna see in the real world making a difference for a while. And again, I n- You know, much easier, I'm not an operator, much easier said than done behind the mic. But, um, some of it seems obvious. Yeah. And that is a big trend that, uh, a lot of the CPGs, in particular like Warren Buffett's famous for this with Heinz and Kraft and the implementing this zero-based budgeting thing where you essentially have to demonstrate an immediate ROI to make any investment. And you think about- How far away that is from competing with Amazon, which in my mind all CPGs are at this point- Yep um, is crazy.

13:15 That's actually, um… CPG's another category that I haven't, um, I, I've done some reporting on, but I'm r- super interested in because I think, um, the sort of turf wars and internal battles going on right now about how to address and, uh, go to market in digital, you know, a lot, w- well, r- I like to say right now I hear, you know, e-commerce strategies from a lot of CPG companies are Amazon strategies, and that's really scary. And so, um, I think play- seeing, you know, CPG companies try to go direct to consumer, um, over the next few years, you know, battling with different sales channels, and Amazon is gonna be, is gonna be one of the great stories of business. Yeah, so, so we've kind of nibbled around Amazon.

13:56 Let's jump into it. Um, so you- you've had four years kind of watched the arc, and you've, you know, some of your stuff you've written about how dominant they are. Uh, just at a high level, do you think anyone's gonna contest Amazon's dominance, or is it kind of game over? Should we, you know? I sure hope so, because, you know, they've yet to become a boring story, but, you know, dominance eventually gets boring, I think. Mm-hmm. And so it could be- AKA the Patriots. Um, they're, they're- they're just terrible for a bunch of reasons, but I'll, I'll move on from that. Uh, as a New York guy, I'm just a little bit biased. That was my clickbait right there. Yes. So, um- Just trolling you. I mean, you know, look, I'd love to see, you know, the Wal- people have talked about the Walmart-Jet deal, you know, ad nauseam.

14:41 But, um, and, uh… and I came down on a couple of different sides of it. But I, I love to see at least some aggressiveness with, uh, you know, from a company that has the size to do some damage pricing-wise. Mm-hmm. Um, so I sure hope the next few years are interesting from that perspective. Walmart, um, and Amazon, um, I'm skeptical, very, very skeptical ag- and have grown increasingly skeptical over the years that, um, you know, big guys outside of maybe Walmart could, could do some damage. And then, um, and then sort of the, you know, what happens to retail and e-commerce at large 10 years from now if Amazon continues on the path it's on.

15:22 It, you know, may be great for a consumer, maybe not long term. So, um, that's a long answer. But I'm, I'm hopeful that, that we'll have some good narratives out of Walmart versus Amazon over the next couple of years. So you think it's likely to be kind of one of the incumbent retailers that, that challenges, not some startup, you know, two guys at Stanford right now, they're gonna come up with a better mousetrap? I mean, look at the, you look at the history of Silicon Valley into trying to get into e-commerce and retail over the last, let's say, let's call it five, 10 years. Um, there's not much success there to point to, frankly. I mean, maybe getting to 60 to 80 million of revenue, but that's, you know, that's a sneeze for Amazon or a Walmart. And so, um, it's been interesting to watch, you know, some of these, uh, companies come out.

16:07 You know, Jet came out of Hoboken, New Jersey. Um, y- people would just call it New York, that's fine, but it's- Uh-huh New Jersey. Um, couple of big deals out of LA. Um- Zappos was Nevada. Zappos was Nevada. Las Vegas. Um, and so, uh, you know, you have, you have some startups in Seattle, and you do have, you do have some in San Francisco. But, um- I, you know, I think startups are trying to… Startups in the space that are coming out are trying to avoid Amazon at all costs, right? Like, there's room for innovation for sure, whether in your own consumer products, trying to build your own brand, and then selling wholesale. Um, but going straight at Amazon, maybe Wish is the closest thing, and that's sort of like a really long, long tail part of Amazon that they're going at.

16:55 Um, so short answer, I think it's, I think it'll be one of the big guys, if anyone. Yeah. So on, um, you've had a couple interesting scoops on Amazon lately, uh, around their private label stuff. Um, I know you were one of the first to talk about the athleisure that they're starting up- Yeah … which is kind of like, you know, the, the Lululemon cut st- type stuff. Uh, and I think you were early in on the men's clothing and some of that things. What, you know, why, why is that interesting to you, that, that Amazon basics private label angle? I mean, for one reason, anything that Jeff Bezos is personally taking, paying attention to and spending some time on is interesting to me. And, um, you know, he had a quote in a profile I think last year where they asked him what he was spending time on, and one of the things he mentioned was private label clothing.

17:39 Um- I, uh, I ran into him very briefly backstage at one of our events, and, uh, it was clear he's spending a lot of time thinking about it. Um, you know, I haven't reported this yet, but I'm pretty sure I know who, which supplier they're working with, and he's, he's spending personal time meeting with the chairman of that company. Um, so I mean, at very s- Like, I like, you know, if the man in charge is paying attention, I am. I also think, you talk about retailers underestimating. You know, when I talk about to private, to CPG guys and retailers about private label at Amazon, first response you get is every… You know, "This is the oldest, this is the oldest model on the books," you know?

18:20 W- "So yes, we're paying attention," but it's really an afterthought. And then I just think the disruption with what, with the data they have, um, whether they'll use it, y- you know, in a great way or not, we'll see. But data they have, they know which price points, where there are ho- holes. Mm-hmm. I just think, um, I think we're gonna see a lot of attempts at this from not just Amazon. Um, but, uh, I, I, I just think it's a huge market, and so I'm gonna try to pay attention. Cool. What do you think about… So there's some of this, uh, kind of edge innovation stuff they're doing that, that a lot of people are freaking out about. Uh, the latest one was the giant blimps that deploy bloon- drones from the stratosphere kind of thing.

19:01 Um, and then more real is the stores. What do you think about kind of Amazon going with the physical stores? Um, I've been… You know, even though I've done a bunch of reporting about it, I've, I've actually been surprised that they, they already have as many bookstores, um, lined up publicly as they do. I think there are, last I looked, there are, have a, they've announced at least eight. Mm-hmm. Um, and sort of- So let's see. There's, um, there was Seattle, San Diego, Chicago? And there's- Announced, but not open. Okay, and then- New York … I think there was- Portland's open … Portland. I believe. Portland's open. Portland. Um, New Jersey. And are they all the same format- Block from here … of that Seattle store? So they're kind of that, that same format? Yeah, I believe so. I- San Diego's very similar to Seattle.

19:41 I haven't been to Portland yet. Okay. And then, uh, there'll be one 10 minutes from my house in New Jersey at Garden State Plaza Mall. Um- Jeff told me that was for your benefit. Thank you. Appreciate that. But one near Delray. Yes. I, uh, feel bad for those poor staff- Yep … because they're gonna see a lot of me. I told them I don't think Delray's a reader. Yeah. I'm just a speaker. Um, so that's interesting. I think, you know, I've been led to believe by some people who know the company well that, um, we may be surprised and see the go, the go model, which is the grab and go and not stop and check out, um, ac- Just walk out technology just walk out tech- yes. I did- JWT.

20:22 Yes. JWAT, right? Is that- #JWAT … is that what you guys are calling it? Yeah, yeah. Okay. Um, that we may, we may actually see that expand quicker. Um, again, I'm, I'm still reporting, uh, all of this out. Um, and the interesting thing there, right, is, you know, as you both know and probably have, uh, talked about on this show, s- similar ideas have been out there including some, was it IBM commercials from- Yeah, yeah, yeah, from the '90s um, and I think there's been some cost impediments around, uh, was it RFID or some other tagging. And so, um- You know, to have this idea that's sort of been, I guess, laying dormant for a decade, um, you know, and then Amazon come out and do it, um, whether it works or not, it just sends a signal that, um, they're gonna, they're gonna really jump on stuff that they think will, will move the needle eventually or, or at least try.

21:17 Yep. Um, the problem there, of course, for other people is Amazon's been working on this for four years, right? How many, how many current competitors can do that? Yeah. So- And, um, this machine learning stuff, we've tried to articulate this on the show. It's kind of a weird comp sizing. It, it creates these insurmountable leads, right? So if you've trained your technology on eight million demo SKUs, and then now you have it in 10 physical stores, that just creates that much more of a, a competitive moat that, that other people can't jump through. So there's this benefit of the machine learning that, you know, you get these insurmountable leads, which, which is pretty interesting. Yeah. Um- And I think Amazon seems to have really got some religion around that. Yeah. I'm, uh, I'm hopeful. I'm going up to Seattle next month and hopeful that, uh, it'll be open to the public, uh, by that time, or at least to a reporter named Jason Del Rey by that time.

22:04 Sure. Someone from Amazon will just walk you right in. Yeah. They love to show me around, anything I wanna see. We, we've had a couple guys in the store, and the, the intrigu- interesting report I've got is that it's probably not quite as far along as the video perceived. And, like, the most common thing that I've heard is it's much smaller than perceived, that it's, like, potentially a couple gondolas of food in it. It's not a 7-Eleven size. Well, what is it, 18, 1,800 square feet, right? It is, but that includes the kitchen. Prep area. Yeah. And so they're saying that, like, the merchandising area is pretty small and constrained, and it, it definitely- Feels it … feels like a proof of concept. The other funny thing I've heard is that the lighting is extraordinarily bright, like presumably for the cameras.

22:50 And so, you know, we've talked to some people that felt like they got a good dose of vitamin D just shopping the, the store. I'm gonna, I'm gonna have to, uh, l- look really good that day to make sure- Exactly. Wear your shades. Yes. Yes. Wear my shades. That's good. A, uh, an o- I haven't had a chance to talk about this on the podcast yet, but there's a French retailer called, uh, Monoprix. And have you seen… I'm sure I'm mispronouncing that by the way. Monoprix? Uh- Monoprix. Sounds better. Yeah. They uh- They did a super snarky parody video of Amazon Go. I have not seen it- Yeah … which means I'm a very bad at my job. I will find a link and, uh, put it in the show notes. But essentially, uh, so they've had this, this feature for about 10 years where you load up your cart, and instead of, uh, getting everything scanned and paying out, you just give your cart to an attendant.

23:43 Um, they ring up… You leave the store, they ring up your stuff and deliver- Yeah … bag and deliver your groceries to home. And so they, they did a sentence for sentence recreation of the Amazon video, except that they're saying like, "For 15 years we've been doing it," and sort of snarkily making fun of, of Amazon- Yeah and, uh, for their video. And then I did- Is this a small… Are they, are they a small company or no? Uh, well, so I think they're a, they're a national chain in France, so obviously- Oh … like not a huge- Yeah … geography, so you know, not a huge number of stores, but definitely a well-known credible retailer. And I do think their experience is interesting and their point taken. Um, let me just say, if you go read the Yelp reviews for any of their, their stores, you will find people complaining about standing in line.

24:30 So it's, it's hardly- Hm … the case that they, they eliminated the, the line. But it was a, a funny video. Anyone who can have some fun with Amazon is probably a friend of mine. Yeah. And the French can do snarky it turns out. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Okay. I'm, I'm looking forward to that one. It's not really just walk out technology though. It's like, just leave your stuff and we'll bring it to you in a couple of hours. Exactly. That's a little, little different. Yeah. Fair enough. Yeah. But, uh, uh, also in fairness, like I, I feel like a number of us all through high school were shopping with the just walk out technology. I was a good boy. Cool. How about, um, I, I don't think I've seen you write much about, uh, Echo and Alexa. What do you think about that? Is that like someone else's beat, or, or have you actually covered that? Wow. You just lit me up right here for not doing my job.

25:12 Um, I… No, I'm gonna be covering… So the areas I'm most interested at Amazon right now are, um, uh, anything having to do with private label, yep, CPG in general, and then Alexa. And, um, you're gonna see a lot more from me around Amazon and Alexa. I, I mean, anecdotally at home, it's amazing to see, a little scary, but amazing to see my three-and-a-half-year-old, like, scream at this thing, probably, like, a little too forcefully, but- … um, to play Justin Bieber. Um, but he… Like, it's just the- they've nailed, like, making it intuitive. It's just, it doesn't always work.

25:52 It actually works a lot less than, um, you'd probably expect for all the great reviews it gets, but it's early days. Um, so I think it's super intuitive. Scary for me personally. Um, I'll be in my bedroom, and we have just an Echo down on the first floor, and, uh, I'll, like, start to ask Alexa the weather. The, the weather. Um- Yeah, you just, you get used to that presence and you just, like, start talking, thinking it can hear you. And so, and so listen, I think, I think- It's gonna be more scary when the one downstairs orders you one for your bedroom based on, on that behavior. Yeah, so I think… So, so I'm gonna be paying, I'm gonna be paying a ton of attention. I think, um, I think there has been a ton of reporting about, like, w- what developers are saying with actually ease or not ease of, um, working with the platform, so I'll be honing in on that.

26:43 Um- How about one of my predictions was that we're gonna see another shot at a phone from Amazon kind of anchored around Alexa. Um, and since we did that show, I've had several kind of folks that are close to Amazon say there's definitely something going on there, so I thought that was interesting. Yeah, I think- So I'll give you… There's a tip, a live tip, a hot lead. I think they've, uh … For thousands of people in addition to me, yes. Yeah. Um- Is that not how you like to get tips? You know, I, I have a lot of ways where, uh, thousands of people won't hear the tip at the same time, so probably- … maybe number 12 on my list, um, future reference. So that doesn't, that doesn't surprise me. I think, um, I think it was clear if you saw some of Jeff's, Bezos' public comments in interviews since then, that, um- That the idea is not dead for sure.

27:33 I think, you know, something they talk about, a lot of companies do, but they do too, is we're, we're only gonna do something if we feel like… We're only gonna come into an existing market if we feel like we could really do something that people can, like, look and right away know the difference. Um, I think they thought they had that with, um- 3D? with 3D, and um, and didn't. So, um, not surprising. I think they've had people working on ideas probably all along. Um, I don't have anything to reveal right now, but you seem to, you seem to have good sources. Well, I switched, uh… I personally switched from my Samsung to the Pixel. I just got a Pixel and just kinda tried it out, and then I just really fell in love with it, having it with me. And it's really nice having it in the car.

28:14 You probably don't commute much 'cause you live in New York, but- Yeah … you know, when you're in the commu- car, you got a 30-minute commute, it's really handy just to say, "I better not… I don't know. Okay. Okay, Google," you know, "Play this song," versus, you know, like tapping around and, and trying to find it on your phone or something is more dangerous, so. Yeah, I think- So I just seem to benefit from the Google one, and it's not as good as Alexa, so it just, like, seems like a no-brainer to me. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, the, the other interesting thing would be if they decide that they wanna go the AWS way or, like, like they're doing in-house already, which is- Just embed it in every phone, yeah just em- embedding it, which you could see potentially longterm having a, a bigger impact on their business. Um, so I'll add that to my list, Scott.

28:54 Yeah. That, that is w- I think one of the reasons it's super interesting from a commerce beat is, uh, we, we just pushed a show this morning on CES, but we declared, uh, Alexa the winner of CES, 'cause it was literally embedded in 700 products at the show. And so one of the implications- Yeah, if you're running a marketing department and you don't have Alexa in your product, like, you are fired right now. Yeah. Um, and you think about that, like, so that's a hu- that's just another huge platform that Amazon owns that puts the rest of retail at a disadvantage. If all the refrigerator manufacturers are embedding Alexa in their refrigerators, and Alexa can only do grocery replenishment from Amazon, um, you, you got aced out of a significant market.

29:44 'Cause, uh, you know, uh, grocery is, like, 30% of all consumer spending. Non-perishables are, like, 50% of that. That's a big chunk of retail. It is. I will… I have to say at the same time, like, some of the use cases right now are just, like- I was gonna curse, but this is a family-friendly show. Ridicul- I'll just say ridiculous. Like, absolutely ridiculous. You don't need Alexa in your trash can to open your trash can for you? Um, that's actually, that would be top of my list. Simple human showed that, yeah. Yes, yes. Um, so you know, it's always fun with new technologies to see, like, the mar- the marketing gimmicks come out. Um, and so, but, but that's a fair point. But you raise another point, which is just the growing, the growing power of the company. And, um, something, uh, I'll be obviously following closely is over the next few years, whether it's four years during Donald Trump's, um, first or last, um, uh, reign in office, uh, will, will we see- I'm trying to remember, has anyone at Recode ha- weighed in on Donald Trump?

30:42 I don't remember. You know, we do have a pretty vocal founder named Kara Swisher, who has opinions she's not fear, uh, afraid to share, so give her a lot of credit for that. But I was, the point I was just gonna get to is do- does Amazon ever run up against antitrust issues? And, um, and, uh, I don't think right now you could say the answer is definitely no. So, um- I think it's entirely possible that you could be boning up on your antitrust law as part of the commerce beat in the next four years … I will, I will wish I paid more attention to the environment around me when I went to college in DC probably. So I'll, um, I'll have to do a crash course Cool. So, um, so it's a little bit of a segue into, you know, so there's oth- other tech companies that you guys follow at, at Recode.

31:27 So you've got Facebook, Google, Microsoft, et cetera. Um, why do you think they're not more aggressively going after e-commerce? Are, are they just ceding this to Amazon? Or, or do you, do you get a vibe that they're working behind the scenes to try to slow them down? The, the stat I always look at is that, you know, product searches starting at Amazon's gotta be hurting Google. Yeah. Now, they can make it up because there's non-product searches like, you know, uh, insurance, and financial services, and pharma, and all these things. So, so I think that's insulated Google a bit because they've got a diverse portfolio. But at some point, that's like a really big chunk of Google that Amazon's sucking away, and there has to be response. Yeah. I mean, I, I, I completely agree, and I was, I was, you know, for a while covering some of their efforts pretty aggressively.

32:08 Um, but they've just, they've just been bad, like just bad efforts. I mean, so, you know, you have sh- Shopping Express, um, uh, which maybe one-- maybe you guys know better than I do right now where that, where that stands today, how many markets they're in. They, they said they're gonna expand to more markets, but it was kind of, you know, didn't meet with this huge fanfare and, and it's, uh, you know, I think they're just using a cur… It's not like a seamless customer experience like you get with Prime now. Um- Right … you know, so, you know, things are always in stock. And so you, when you go through Google Express, you'll see like Costco, and they're like, "Wow, that's great." But then there's like eight SKUs, and you're like, "All right. Yeah, I get bottled water, but where's my favorite, you know, peanuts that I want?" You know? Yeah. So it's just so limited, and it's kind of, it, it's kinda sounds good at the top, but then it's like just much more of a facade at the end.

32:53 They've-- I mean, they've struggled in commerce for a long time, and what, what scares me for them is from people I talk to, um, like it's not top of mind for Sundar, the CEO. And, um- Like how much can you get done if it's not, uh, you know- Yeah … a top initiative? Um, an- another bad sign w- for Google Shopping Express was when, uh, basically the executive who incubated it inside of Google left for Uber. Yeah. Like, not a good sign. Mm. Not a good sign. So I have the same question to you two. Um, I've tried to, you know, get analysts to help me do the math on the actual impact on their business, y- losing all the search that, uh, Amazon has had.

33:35 I've, I've probably pinged both of you about any smart takes. You, you may have actually given me one and, but I decided it wasn't smart. He's looking at Scott, not Jason, just for the record. I am looking at Scott. Um- I've always heard that product searches at Google are 40%. Um, and then I've tried to go resource that, and all I can find is me saying it, so um- That's double confirmation. Yeah, yeah. Mm. So, so I don't have some journalistic clean way, but, you know, it just logically makes sense. Um, and I was there at GoTo.com in the very early days, and product searches were even, like, 80 or 90% back then. So it just makes logical sense that, that there's, you know… It, it is the largest vertical out there, so 40% seems right. Something I haven't, something I haven't reported on yet, but I'm sure you guys have talked about is, you know, Amazon once again testing, uh, PLAs on, on- Yeah, they've lit those back up recently.

34:25 Mm-hmm … on Google. Um, I'm not quite sure what to make of that yet. Uh, I don't know if you have any hot takes, Scott or Jason. So the reason they didn't do it at first is they didn't want Google to have their product catalog. So they kind of said, "All right, we have all the selection. Why would we share that with Google and make PLAs better?" Um, so if you believe that, then why would they turn it back on? I think maybe they're at the point where they probably did some tests, and they're like, "Yeah, it's a pretty good way to acquire some customers." The other thing that's happened is Google has made it so much of the page, um, that, you know, the… I, I would imagine both the SEO and the paid part of Amazon has gone down because they've just, they've amped up PLAs so much. Um- Talking about antitrust. Yeah.

35:05 Uh, well, uh, yep. Uh, and then I won't, uh, that's a third rail for me, so I'll stay away from that. Uh, the, uh, so then in, on mobile it gets even worse. Like, when you start doing mobile searches, all you see is PLA. You have to scroll, you have to scroll, like, three times. So it could be an, uh, you know, it could be a position that says, "Hey, it's kinda game over. Now we can… Now who cares if we put our catalog out there?" And also, that catalog argument isn't very valid 'cause you can control it, right? You can kinda say, "I wanna just fill a couple of holes," or "Here's, here's some limited selection," or, or where the Venn diagram overlaps what's out there already, let's be competitive. So I just think that there's something that's happened to change that idea at Amazon- Mm-hmm … that, that, you know, the, it's probably just an efficacy thing of the advertising dollars. Uh, so one quick clarification.

35:46 Uh, sporadically but somewhat consistently, if that's not an oxymoron, uh, uh, Amazon has always had PLAs for Amazon-branded products. So they- Right. Yeah, Kindle, right? Yeah. So they've continued to run the Kindle and the Echo and- And the subsidiaries. So Zappos- Yeah … and some of the other shop, uh, some of those things … and all the, the formerly Quidsi brands. Yeah. Exactly. So what we've seen recently is them start to turn on PLAs for first-party product that isn't made by Amazon. Um- Yeah, I saw some… I don't know. I did some random kitchenware search. Um, I forget if it was a Crock, I think maybe even a Crockpot, and there was an Amazon ad for- Yep … some other brand. Yep. And I, I, to Scott's point, like, those are, that is the most effective product in the Google portfolio for, for product certainly, so that, that's interesting.

36:29 A lot of other retailers are getting more and more momentum, uh, running co-op PLAs. So getting the manufacturer to fund- Hmm … PLAs- Hmm … that are then placed by the retailer, um, which, uh, the retailer ends up with, uh, like, much higher quality scores for their PLAs, so they get placed better because you can actually click on the retailer's PLA and buy it. Yeah. So what I, what I haven't validated yet is are the, are the new PLAs we're seeing funded ones? Like did, did Samsung or, or walkthrough say pay, uh- This is a very big- … Amazon marketing … growth area of Amazon is. In Vendor Central, they have all this money now you can spend, and they, there's an AMA and an AMR that you can spend in there, and that, that could be part of it.

37:13 There may be some co-op dollars that, that tipped it over. Yep. That's good. Good insight. That's another good story idea for Jason Del Rey. Yeah. Thank you. Yep, this will be out in, uh, 12 hours- We're, we're here for you … so the t- clock is ticking. Um- He's used to shorter deadlines than that. Cool. So, so let's, uh, so we've talked about kind of current trends. Let, let's extend it out a little bit, kind of three, five, 10 years, whatever you're comfortable with. W- where do you think this goes? Like, where, where are some interesting, you know- I think voi- I mean, I, it's very popular to talk about this now, but I think for good reason, like voi- just voice as, um, an in- like the next interface, I think, um, for computing. Uh, I think, I think that's huge.

37:53 I, I do question how Amazon, um, how shopping happens via voice that is not, you know, reordering. You know, one thing we've seen from Amazon, which hasn't gotten a lot of press, and I probably should do a better job on it, is the idea of Amazon basically choosing an Amazon's Choice product. So if you're gonna order, say, you know, um- Alexa, order me some deodorant, men's deodorant. Um, that was a really bad choice- Yeah … but we'll go with it. Um, that Amazon… I don't know if they have it for this category, but a lot of categories Amazon will select, you know, a Prime-eligible deodorant. And, um, so I think that, it's just a way for me to say there need to be a lot of solutions to, to, um, trying to browse via voice.

38:42 Like, I, I- Yeah … I have more questions than answers right now. Some of the skills, it's conversation, like the pizza ones. Um, and it actually… If… The first time you do it, it's a little weird, but then you get kind of used to it, 'cause you're just so used to, you know, speaking out these things. So it'll be interesting to- What, what would be an example? So, you know, "Alexa, I want to order a Domino's pizza." "What size?" "Large." "Um, would you want any toppings?" "Yeah, I'll take pepperoni." "Do you want that on the whole pizza or a half?" "Whole pizza." "Is that it?" "Yes." Boom. You know, so, so it's a weird… It, it's kind of- It's like a decision tree … the first time you do it, it feels a little weird, but then, like, you start to go through it pretty quick. Or you can even… Now, then the other thing is once you go through it the first time, then you'll say, "Alexa, order me a Domino's pizza. I'll take a large with pepperonis on the whole thing."

39:23 And then it'll say, "That… Is that your…" So it's really interesting. It, like, trains you to… And you can start making these larger utterances in the first sentence, and it'll actually get it. You know, I think, I think we've been trained because the voice stuff's so bad with, like, some of the other solutions that you try to, like, you know, you're over-announcing like, "Alexa," you know, "order a pi-" And now you don't have to. You can have more of these conversations. And as it gets closer to 100%, you can either have the conversation or a, a much larger initial kind of sentence that, that does it. Hmm. How many of these pizza orders have you done, Scott? Well, I spend a lot of time doing research on this, uh, for the Jason's gotcha. Uh, I notice you're not using the flowers for your wife example as much as the pizza example. Well, that one's a little tricky because, you know, you don't… My wife's generally around me when I'm talking to Alexa- so it's kind of hard to have a stealth conversation with Alexa.

40:09 There could be a Cyber Monday flow- uh, Cyber Valentine's Day pre-flower ordering day. Uh, nice. That, uh, that, that cycle that you mentioned about the, the network training us to speak, uh, has played out before in commerce. So in the early days of internet search, people typed complete sentences into AltaVista and then later Google. And, like, we probably remember a time when we could successfully search on Google but our parents couldn't because they didn't know the syntax. Now we've all learned this, like, keyword syntax for Google. And ironically, now that we're shifting to voice- People, people, uh, tend to speak in complete sentences to voice, and so it actually changes the, the keywords and the SEO, um, because you, you give Cortana complete sentences.

40:57 Right. Yeah, that's another thing, you know, the exciting thing for me from a story perspective is it's obviously a platform that, you know, there's plenty of stuff we, we can't even imagine right now and sort of new gatekeepers popping up. So Amazon is, like, the gatekeeper of the voice web. Like- Pretty, pretty scary for… Should be pretty scary for almost everyone that's not Amazon. Yeah. Yeah. Um, I haven't seen… You know, I'd be-- I'd love to read a great story maybe you guys have on, on, um, where Apple, like, went wrong with Siri or, um, it just seems like- It's obvious now, but they could have been there years and years ago with, uh, s- something along these lines, and maybe… And n- I never count Apple out, so- Yeah … maybe they, maybe they still m- will make a huge push in the home.

41:48 Um- The common consensus with Apple is they're, they're such a hardware company that they under-index on the software side, and that, that tends to be where they fall down on these things. That's why are… the Google Apps are so much better on the, the iPhone. Like, I don't use any of the native Apple apps- Right … if I can avoid them. It's kind of… But if it… Yeah, I, I, I totally agree. Like, software and services. But i- if, if you're a company whose, like, whole being is around, you know, "We need to own end to end," you can't be average on one of those ends, right? Yeah, yeah. Or sub-average. Yeah, yeah. So there's, there's some, uh, the- That's my lesson for today … Reid Dilling Fireball. That's good. He's an ex-Apple guy. And then, uh, there's one called St- Stritchery, which is like… That one's good. Yeah, I'm trying to- And they do some really long pieces- Ben Thompson … on that stuff.

42:30 Yeah. Yeah. So Ben writes a lot about this, like, battle of these two business models, right? Like, the network effect- Mm-hmm … which is, like, making your system open- Android … so lots of people use it. And, uh, and the lock-in effect, like, you know, making people use your products and only use your products. And like, you know, his, his premise would be, like, you know, Apple is one with the lock-in effect, and so that's their DNA. And, uh, you know, Amazon and others have won with the network effect. Right. And that, you know, the lock-in effect is working against Apple in, in voice. Yeah, I'm very excited, actually. We're gonna have… Ben's gonna come do a media presentation at the Re- Code Media conference in February, uh, out in, uh, south of LA.

43:12 So, I'm excited to see him firsthand. He has a lot of, obviously, a lot of fans in technology world, rightfully so. It was- Yeah, let's promote that a little bit. So you do these little sideshows called Code Commerce. Um- Correct … you've done them at Shoptalk. I've been to a couple. Um- Yeah … tell us a little bit about how did that come to be and, uh, sounds like there's another one coming up in February. Yeah. Um- Different thing, but yeah. Yeah. Oh, sorry. Yeah. Yeah. February's media… uh, one of our media events. Okay. But I'm, but I'm doing another one in March at Shoptalk. Okay. It's, um, Monday night at Shoptalk. It's a one-night event. So, um, for people who don't know Recode, and before that, All Things D, um, conferences have been in sort of the, uh, our DNA for a long time. And so, you know, if you ever saw a video of Steve Jobs and Bill Gates on stage together, that was, um, that was at one of our events.

43:57 Um, this past year, those, uh, D Conferences are now called Code Conferences. This year- You guys always have the most comfy looking chairs. They are. Like, when I watch the live stream- They're really great I'm like, "That looks like a comfy chair." It's the signature- Steelcase red chair, yeah. Yeah. And, um, so this past year at our big event, our main one, we had Jeff Bezos come, Elon Musk, and some, um, some other great speakers. And so the idea for me was- Can I sort of replicate this in my own way, but focused on strictly the commerce industry? So I've started with these small one-night events, um, where we do, you know, really no BS interviews, three or four of them, with CEOs and entrepreneurs.

44:38 We also stuff you with drinks and maybe some food. And, um, and the idea is really just, um, should be a little bit fun. Sh- you should definitely learn something. And we also love audience participation, so we're big … You know, every speaker has to be okay with, um, you know, anyone in the audience getting up and asking them a tough question. And so the, the goal would be, you know, later this year for me to do a standalone full-day event focused on future of e-commerce and, and retail and payments, uh, all in one. So- Cool. That'd be very cool. I, I have been to- Count us in … two of your three- … and, uh, the speakers and content and conversation was all awesome.

45:20 Uh, versus the original D or Code Conference, the big, the big knock is, like, yours tend to be at, like, uh, a conference room in a hotel in Las Vegas- … and Code is on the beach at Terra No. So I feel like our goal needs to be to get Code Commerce to the beach. Well, if you wanna pay 6,500 instead of $195, we could probably arrange something at… But, no. But yeah, w- we're- I drank at least $195 at both of the ones I went to. Yeah. So yeah, the last one we had, you know, Jack Dorsey talking about Square, and, uh, Kate Hudson and Adam Goldenberg from Fabletics, and also the CEO of Wish. Um, I, I'm not gonna try to re- pronounce his last name again.

46:01 I did it well that night. And, uh, the head of Apple Pay at Apple, Jennifer Bailey. So, um, we, we get some great people together, and, uh, we'll be back at Shop Talk. And for listeners, it, it is a invite-only event. You have to be approved to go. But if you mention that you're a Jason and Scott Show listener, you basically get in. And- It would actually hurt their chances … and send a tip. I, I haven't dec- I haven't decided about, about chances with you guys yet. We'll sort it still out. Yeah. The one I went to, the last Shop Talk, um, it was interesting. You spent a lot of time talking to the guy from Target, and then right after that, like, they all either, you know, summarily left. So I don't know. Is there, is there a curse around this? You do the Del Rey interview- It's like- … and you're doomed … it's, it's the Madden curse. Yeah. Um, s- so yeah, that was … Yeah, so Jason, uh, Goldberger, uh, over at Target.

46:45 Um, I think he's- No relation? No relation. Um, I think he, um, I think that's probably the only one- Okay. All right. So it's not officially a thing … out of the three events. So give me another year, and we'll see if we could ring that up, but hopefully not. What's going on at Target? Like, um, you know, is there … You know, you … They, for a while there, so if we look at kind of, what was it? '15, they really did well with their Cyber Monday promotion, and then things kinda hit a little bit of a, you know, went a little sideways. And it seemed like they had a bunch of changes at the top. Is, is that … Do you dig into that on a regular basis? From time to time, for sure. I mean, I'm excited today to, um, you know, listen in. I think the company's CIO, I believe, is, um, is gonna be on stage.

47:27 And so, um, I'm, I'm interested to hear from them. Um, very curious what the change is in digital for sure, and whether, um, you know, whether that means sort of taking a foot off of the gas in, in digital and, you know, reevaluating, um, how much priority to put on that. Um- I read a lot of negativity around their grocery efforts. It kind of, you know, the, the general trend pieces seem to say they're kind of like half, half in, half out on grocery. Half in and half out. Yeah. I find that with my experience. We'll go to there and we're like, "Oh, let's go see if they have graham crackers," and like, they don't have them. You get really frustrated, right? Yeah. These things you would think they would have, but they, they don't. I know personally, I mean, my, my wife would do, uh, and occasionally, um, if, if I'm around, we'll, we'll go and do, you know, some grocery shopping either at Target or, or Walmart.

48:16 And, um, she's now pretty much, you know, for the certain items, uh, all Wal- all Walmart. Obviously, Walmart's done a great, great job in grocery. They should use the concierge service where they kind of bring it out to the curb. Um, not that I know of. She's like the anti-Jason Del Rey, which means the anti-lazy person. Um, and, um, so we don't do … Only for testing do we do even grocery delivery at home. She enjoys strolling the three-year-old through all the long Walmart aisles. She wants her … And now a seven-month-old as well. Yeah. Oh. She wants the, uh … She likes picking out her own produce. Um- Yeah … I think, uh- There's something to be said about that … as do many consumers. Yeah. So, um- Forgot, forgot how we got to Wal… Oh, Target.

49:00 Yeah, I'm not sure. I'm, I'm, I'm a bit confused by the moves, frankly. And so, um, you know, I'll, I'll be, I'll be listening today intently, um, see what their executive has to say. I feel like in, uh, grocery, a lot of people describe them as being in this uncomfortable middle. Like, there, there are these really good price competitors that have emerged in grocery, like Aldi and Stop & Shop and these guys, that are lower prices than Walmart, right? Mm-hmm. And Target is definitely not there. And then you've got, like, the high-end premium assortment of, uh, Whole Foods, and that, that kind of puts Target a little bit in a no-man's land. And, you know, Brian Connolly would definitely say, like, "Look, the focus is on these, these five signature categories that we know are important to the Target guest."

49:45 And so, like, it remains to be seen whether, whether that can generate traffic or- Yeah, I mean, one test they were doing that I thought they were seeing great stuff from, um, I, I know they were happy with the In- Instacart test in a couple of small markets with, um, one-hour delivery, and felt like they were reaching people who were otherwise not coming to their store. Mm-hmm. Um, and they just… I, I, I don't have a magic answer, but they just did not expand that, and I, I, as far as I k- know, I think they're just in a couple test markets still. I think they turned off a bunch of the, like, both the curb tests, I think Jason mentioned they turned off at, uh, at your, uh, at the Code Conference, and then I- they turned off some of the Instacart markets.

50:26 Um- Yeah, the curbside test where you pick up, you know, curbside, um- I think there were over 100 locations, and then- Yeah, the, the challenging thing with food delivery is there's two ways to pay for it. A convenience fee for the consumer- Yep … which, you know, once those get up towards, like, north of $10, they, they vomit on that. Um- I think, I think, I think mass-wise- And then, and then the groceries itself … I think more than- Yeah … well, I think a lot of categories, you get up, you get to five, you know- Yeah … over five- Yeah … food, yeah. Fees are much more- So then, so then what they do is they, they put it into the product, and if you're Target, you know, suddenly you get a customer complaint, "I just paid $8 for this broccoli, and it was, you know, it was, it was $6," that, I think it creates this next, ne- you know, negative customer experience that, that a lot of people are unwinding these things 'cause of that.

51:07 Yeah, Instacart's actually a company I'm starting to dig in a lot more, um, f- try to figure out. You know, they have a big, ol' val- you know, valuation on paper of $2 billion. I think, I think that was really, you know, a high bar for… That's gonna be a high bar for them to clear, and I just, um, I just, uh, there are a lot of people continuing to wonder how viable the current model is. They're changing pay an awful lot with workers, and so, um, we'll see. Yeah. Uh, yeah, that's gonna be an interesting note, uh, one to watch play out. Uh, I, I would, I'm gonna take the short on Instacart for grocery 'cause, uh, just the economies don't work for perishable deliverables.

51:51 Mm-hmm. When someone has to be home for that delivery, the economies get, get really complicated. So I'm way more optimistic on pickup for grocery. Yep. Jason's long Snapchat and spectacles. Yeah. And Jason has never made a, a dollar on speculating, so- … um, take, take my advice with more than a grain of salt. I've not worn a spectacle or spectacles yet, but, um, but- They're perfect for a three and a seven-month-old, yeah. Yeah. Capture these little moments that are coming up. Any, any… Oh, yeah, I just try to not have anything valuable around my three-and-a-half-year-old- Yeah … because he's, he's a destructor. Nice. I, I have one of those as well. Um, well, listen, Jason, uh, it has happened again.

52:33 We have flown through our allotted time, but we're super grateful from you, uh, taking time off from your busy beat to, to talk to us, and we'll, uh, look forward to reading your stuff in the future. Yeah, thanks, Jason, and thanks, NRF, for hosting us. Thanks for having me. Jason@recode.net if you do have some good tips. Yeah, and, uh, to follow on, on Twitter, you're @delrey, D-E-L-R-E-Y. Thanks a lot, guys. Bye. Until next time, happy commercing. You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes or visit www.jasonandscot.com.