Welcome to The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News!
Oct. 7, 2016

EP048 - REI, Brad Brown, SVP Digital Retail

EP048 - REI, Brad Brown, SVP Digital Retail
EP048 - REI, Brad Brown, SVP Digital Retail
The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News
EP048 - REI, Brad Brown, SVP Digital Retail

EP048 - Guest Brad Brown, SVP Digital Retail at REI

Brad Brown is the SVP of Digital Retail at REI. We spoke with Brad from the trade show floor at the Shop.org digital summit 2016.

Don't forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.

Episode 48 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded on Tuesday September 27, 2016.

http://retailgeek.com/podcast Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.

0:02 Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here are Jason and Scot Hey, welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg. This episode is being recorded live from the NRF shop.org Digital Summit 2016. Today is Tuesday, September 27th, 2016. As usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo.

0:43 Hey, Jason. Thanks for joining us, everyone. This is the first of our live podcasts recorded at Summit. For the live audience, at … Our next guest will be Milton Pappas. Uh, he is the SVP of Digital at Hudson Bay. And then at 2:00, we're gonna be doing a show news roundup with a special surprise guest. As a reminder, at 3:30, Jason and I are doing a breakout session on level two, rooms C1 and C2. Because we're here at Summit, we have access to what I would call luminaries of the e-commerce and retail industry, and we're excited to join for our first live podcast Brad Brown, who is the SVP of Digital Retail at REI. REI has over 140 stores in 35 states. I'm a co-op member and love shopping there.

1:25 Uh, it's a unique retailer because they are a co-op. Welcome to the show, Brad. How are you doing? I'm doing great. Thanks, Scott. Uh, Jason, thanks for having me out here. Sure. Fun to be on the show floor. Yeah. We, um, we had a little audio issue, so we appreciate you, uh, you actually pitched in and helped, so it was, uh- It was actually fun to watch you guys working. Yeah. This, if this whole, uh, digital thing doesn't work out, we do need more support for audio engineering, so just wanna put that pitch in there. Great. Um, so, uh, we usually start the show, uh, for those of you that don't know you, love to know kind of, uh, kind of your, your arc of your career and, and how you ended up at REI and, and a little bit about what your span of influence is there.

2:05 Okay. Um, so the short story is, uh, started in, uh, you know, out of college in retail at a chain that is now part of Macy's. Um, started out in accounting, uh, moved into IT, changed jobs a few times, uh, ended up at, uh, Egghead Discount Software, uh, running their IT business. Was recruited away from that, uh, to join REI, um, as their vice president of IT. Took them through Y2K, uh, the launch… Uh, well, joined right after we had launched our, uh, digital presence on rei.com and moved over and started running our digital business in 2006.

2:47 Um, now that includes our core store, which everyone knows is rei.com. It includes a, uh, discount and closeout business that we call, we used to call The Outlet, we now call Garage. We did some rebranding of that and launched that in, uh, August. And then also our mobile, uh, app, shopping app. Cool, cool. Very cool. Um- I feel like you forgot the most important question. What's your REI member number? Uh, member number is 438855, so that's, like, a 1974 member number. Very impressive. It cert- certainly has me beat. Wow. Do you know your membership, uh- I don't. No? I don't have it memorized, so I'd just go- I can look it up, Scott … and give my phone number.

3:28 Yeah. I- I was gonna say, I, I have learned from previous experience not to exaggerate your member number with Brad, because he has access to the database. Okay. Yeah. I'll be careful with that. So, um, so you've been through, you've been at R- REI through the whole growth of e-commerce. Um, what was that like and, um, in the early days, were you kind of pounding the table saying, "We need to do stuff here," and then ultimately the company kind of bought in, or, or were they already kind of thinking about it and forward-thinking? Um, you know, Scott, honestly, it's a little mix of both. I mean, I was telling somebody last night at a party, the location of which I don't really clearly remember, but- Um, when we started rei.com, which was in '96, we had a very strong mail order business, so it was very easy for us to kind of plug an order into our mail order system.

4:16 So we always had… We were always integrated. We were always kind of omni-channel before that became a word. Um, and the business grew relatively quickly as people moved from mail order, um, l- literally mail order, to phones and then to, uh, digital orders. Uh, and then our business really kind of stalled out in about 2003 or 4. Kind of, we, we had a hard time climbing out of the internet implosion. Remember those days? Um, and then, um- When I took over in 2006, uh, we had not invested very much in the business at all. We were, you know, we had, as a company, had become reasonably happy with growing about twice the rate as our comp stores were growing.

5:05 Um, we didn't have things like product reviews, which were pretty much industry stan- you know, a base expectation of a website in 2006, and we had a really antiquated search. And I just, like you said, I started, um, I started going to battle, uh, for more investment. Um, sometimes that was in people, in skills. Um, and sometimes it was in technology, and usually it was in both, and we built that up over time. So coming from the IT side's interesting. A lot of the folks we have come from the marketing or the sales side. Do you think, uh, how did that help you kind of in your career, uh, on the e-commerce side? Um, I think, um, that, that's an interesting question.

5:47 I really haven't thought about it that much. I mean, I knew, uh, from my IT background the, like, the tools and the technologies that we had and we were putting to bear on the site, but I really didn't know much about the business of doing that well. Um, so there was a huge opportunity for me to learn that side and, I think, ask questions that perhaps I might not have if I came from the marketing side. So, um, I don't know if it helped me more than the team, but it, it, uh, I felt pretty good about the technology, so I didn't have to nose around in that. I didn't know much about how we went to, to market. Yeah. I find it helps me hold people accountable. So if the database engineer comes back and says, "It's gonna take nine months to do this thing," you're like, "What?" Yeah, the smell test.

6:28 Yeah. They call it the smell test. It ju- you know, it just didn't quite smell right. Yeah. And so, yeah, I didn't, I really didn't have that problem. Um, I didn't have the problem… I, I still remember implementing reviews. Um, you know, the team kept saying it was gonna take longer and longer, and so I, I had to dig into what kind of requirements they were trying to deliver, and I found these elaborate reporting systems so they could tell the merchants when we were getting a bad review, and everything else, and I just said, "Look, we're gonna offer empl- customer review capability before holiday, and none of this matters. None of this other stuff matters. We'll do it later." We never did it, because the reviews were more important. And guess what? The merchants were looking at the website to see what customers were saying about the products they bought.

7:11 Yeah. So it worked itself out. Great is often the enemy of good- Yes. -with regards to those features. Uh, so Brett, what, what is your whole scope today? Like, are, are you involved in, in marketing and traffic generation to the site? Are you involved in digital inside the stores? Um, so one of the things that's, um… I, I think, I think I can say is unique about REI is we are pretty disciplined about roles and responsibilities. So in your example, I, I look to our marketing department to drive traffic to the site. Um, I look to them, um, and it, it's, it's one of those things where it's very clear that I look to them for email traffic.

7:55 Natural search, you know, there's people in marketing that help us with it, and then I've got people on our team that work on optimizing natural search. Paid search is marcom spend, so I look to them for traffic on paid search. Um, affiliates business, I look to them. So just as I have merchants on our site that worry about merchandising the site, they don't buy the merchandise. Uh, a merchandising group does that. So we're, we're pretty good on, on kind of delineating responsibilities. Got it. So the traditional merchants are responsible for procurement and curation, and the digital merchants are sort of like digital visual merchants.

8:35 Yeah. Well said. Okay, cool. Uh, and one of the things that's always really interesting is REI has a very unique business model The co-op The co-op, yep. And so having worked for a few, uh, traditional for- for- for-profit companies and, and then being in a co-op for a long time, what… You know, how, how is that model working for you guys? What are some of the pros and cons from your perspective? Um, so, uh, first, a little clarification. We are a p- for-profit company. We are not in this for exercise. Um, but that said, um, the co-op model is a… We're, we're a private company. We're owned by members. Scott and Jason, you guys are both members, as am I.

9:17 Um, I think the biggest advantage we have from the co-op model is, um, we don't have, uh, the equity markets to please on a quarterly basis. So we can take a very long range approach. Um, we can do things in the short run that would be… That, that a lot of public companies wouldn't think about doing, like what we did last year around closing our doors for Black Friday, which is, I think, my fourth or fifth highest volume day in just, you know, kissing multiple million dollars of revenue away from my business, and certainly a lot more from our physical stores. Um, so we can think about the long term. We can think with the members' best interest involved, uh, both in how we deliver a customer experience, digitally or physically.

10:00 Um, the, uh, the drawback, um, is we have, uh, we're more constrained about access to capital, right? If we can't fund and build enough cash in our treasure chest, we have to go to a bank and ask for a loan, and that's a hell of a lot more expensive than floating stock. Um, I think the other drawback is, and, and some people see this as a pros and con… Uh, as a, as a, a pro. But, you know, in a public company, you have a board of directors, you have, uh, shareholders, and you have management that worry about the long-term viability of your company and your, uh, and, um, your success as a business.

10:44 We don't have the shareholders, so In some ways, that's very liberating. In some ways, that's an additional burden to really be a good shepherd and steward for the co-op, 'cause you don't have the public oversight that you might like. And, and the way it works is there's some kind of formula where you guys say a certain… You, you make a certain profit and then the rest is returned to members. Is that kind of my understanding? The- That's right … I know I get a check, and I always enjoy that. Yeah. So we, uh, the basic working model is, uh, we give back to members 10% of their online or their full-price purchases, and that's, at our business, uh, last year I think that totaled up to be about 140 million.

11:26 Mm. Which is another challenge, because most public companies would keep that and even be reluctant to do a cash dividend, where we do, you know, 10% of our, of their purchases. Significant portion of our profit is given back. Yeah. The good news is almost all of that comes back into the company. Yeah. And what, what's al- also interesting is you don't really have to have a loyalty program. Your business model is your loyalty program in, in a way. Yeah, very true. In fact, it's interesting because in the olden days, uh, that I'll define as, you know, early 2000, late nine- uh, the late 1900s, um, people, people understood membership as a benefit, not as a loyalty program.

12:09 But with the, you know, everybody's got a loyalty program. So I was actually talking to somebody yesterday, and they go, "Yeah, you got a great loyalty program." And I kind of went, "Well, it's not really a loyalty program. It's a dividend for your patronage 'cause you're a member." Um, but I've, I've, uh, got a lot of this gray hair, and a lot of the hair that's missing has been acquired by trying to explain that to people. So I just don't. And I said, "Yeah, it's pretty good." Is it fair to call it an affinity program? It does feel like more than just a vehicle for giving back the dividend, right? Like- Uh, you call it what you want. Like I say, I got a lot of gray hair and a lot less hair from trying to explain this. But yeah, I mean, it encourages… It, it, it's a very important part of our flywheel, right?

12:49 We give $140 million back to members. Almost all of that comes back into the co-op the following year in terms of a, of purchase. So. Yeah. I think of it as a business model where your customers are your shareholders, so you, you have one constituent versus two, and that, that's interesting 'cause then you, it, you know, whenever you have two of something, the chances of being misaligned are higher than when you have one of something. So, um- That's true … that's kinda how I think about at a macro level. Um, so you guys are based out of Seattle. The, uh, flagship store is amazing. Um, I love going to that and seeing what's new. Uh, last time I there, the rock wall was kind of the cool new thing. Yep. Is, is that still the, the big thing? What is that thing, like 50, 60 feet? Yeah, it's 55 feet- Yeah … I think.

13:30 Still gets a lot of, uh, a lot of use in the Seattle store. We've stopped putting, uh, climbing walls in new stores. Uh, little bit of square footage issue, a little bit of staffing issue, and with the insurance- Oh, yeah, insurance. Little insurance issue. Little, yeah, that's, little risk management issue. Yeah. Yeah. Uh, and you know, there's a lot of indoor climbing gyms now that have a lot more features and functions than, than we could ever do. So climbing's still important part of our business, but, but not that experience. Yeah, so as a a- uh, Seattle business, I have to ask the Amazon question. So, um, you know, we talk about Amazon a lot on the show. You and I have chatted about Amazon quite a bit. Um, would love to know kinda how you feel about it, and, um, you know, are they friend, foe, and, and what's it like having that 800-pound gorilla kinda in your backyard?

14:16 They, they don't have to give 10% back to the- No, they don't … the, the members. They don't, they don't give a fraction of any percent back to anything. Um, so that might tip your hat to how I think about them. I think they're absolutely a, a foe. I thought the conversations we had yesterday were, were interesting. And I think the, the, uh, the challenging thing for all retailers is Amazon's one of the most… has become, in consumers' eyes, one of the most beloved brands in the United States. And yet, I think everybody at this conference, if they're not scared to death about how they're gonna compete with Amazon, um, I'm kinda curious where they've been lately. Um, so we're… They're a, they're a big deal for us.

14:57 They're the number one, uh, website customers go when they leave REI, uh, and don't purchase. Um, they're selling a lot of products that we sell. Um, and, uh, I think they're very hard to compete with. You know, there's that saying, you know, "You gotta skate to where the puck's gonna be." I think with Amazon, you almost have to skate where they can't push the puck- Hmm … um, to be successful. Yeah. Find a corner of the rink. Yep. Um, so what do you, what do you guy… So, so, uh, would love to hear REI, but if you're not comfortable talking about that, strategically, how do you recommend people, uh, you know, skate… you know, put the puck to where Amazon's not? One, one thing Jason and I always talk about is private label products as a way to kinda, you know, you have your own brands.

15:41 Mm-hmm. Looking at my REI bag over there, I have an REI tent. Uh, I'm finding my purchases th- increasingly at REI are kinda more branded kind of things that you guys have. Mm-hmm. Um, that seems like an obvious one. What, what other things do you do there? Yeah, I… Private brands are very important to us for that reason. One, only place you can get it. Um, and two, you know, we try and deliver a little bit higher profit margin and value for the price. So that's a, that's a big and important part of our business that we'll continue to work on growing. I think, um, one of the few other ways to compete with Amazon is to truly differentiate your brand. Um, harder for us because we're a house of brands. So how do you differentiate a experience buying an Arc'teryx jacket on, on, uh, rei.com or in a store versus, uh, on Amazon?

16:30 And that, that's a, that's a challenge for all of us. But I think to, um… I think successful retailers in the future will truly have a, a, uh- A brand presence that is differentiated and is compelling enough that even when people may start their search on Amazon, as more and more people do, um, when they narrow that search, we believe strongly they're gonna, they're gonna bump into us at some point in their outdoor lives, and are gonna find out enough about us to be attracted to the things that we stand for as a brand, and will be willing to transact with us because of that differentiation.

17:12 Uh, it's a, it's a big part of our bet. Right. And, um, you guys seem to be one of the early companies that I noticed was doing kind of store-within-a-store with brands, uh, particularly North Face seem, you seem to have a really good kinda relationship with those guys, and I don't believe, uh, North Face is directly available on Amazon. Um, does that resonate with brands? Do you k- kinda tell them that story and say, "Hey, let's, you know, uh, Amazon's not here to build your brand. We are. Let's kinda work together." Have you guys, uh, tried that kind of approach with, with the brands? Yeah, it's actually-- It's a great question, pretty insightful on our business. We've spend quite a bit of time, our merchants, our head merchant. Um, you know, we see ourselves as a, um, outdoor specialty lifestyle retailer.

17:56 Mm-hmm. And, um, we… Part of that is specialty, and what makes things special are curated assortments from the six hundred and fifty thousand backpacks you can buy, um, on Amazon to the probably maybe two thousand on, on REI. So our merchants have-- They've curated that assortment to things that we think are appropriate for the activities that we support, and we work really hard with our vendors explaining our view on specialty. And frankly, our view on specialty does not include Amazon. I think it's, it's hard to, it's hard to be special in a sea of six hundred and fifty thousand backpacks. Um, it is easier to be specialty when you're a merchant, you know your market, you know your business, you know the products, and you can go in and pick those products that you think are unique and best suited to fit our customers' needs.

18:50 Um, we, we have those conversations with Amaz- with vendors who do business on Amazon frequently. Yeah. Yeah. Um, delicate, um, but, uh, we, we think it's important. Yeah, and th- this kind of starts to bleed over into one of Jason's favorite topics, which is omni-channel, but do you have any data on show rooming? So, you know, you have all these awesome displays of backpacks. I go in there, I try on four of them, and then I go to Amazon so I can save 5% kind of a thing. Do, do you guys… Are you able to track that at all or any indication kind of what-- That's always kind of the, the tough thing. Yeah. You spend all this time and money curating that in-store experience, and then people kind of pop out and kind of are drawn by that smaller discount somewhere else. Yeah. So, uh, couple of data points.

19:32 One, uh, start digital first, and we, we, we know that Amazon's the first place people go if they don't buy on rei.com. Um, it's not where they buy, uh, it's where they go, and then they usually go somewhere else to buy. So that's, uh- you know, kind of a little bit encouraging, a little bit depressing. Uh, in the stores, one of the things that we worried about, we put in, um, free Wi-Fi, uh, in the early 2000s, I think it… Well, probably 2006, 2007, I guess. And that was when the fear of showrooming was perhaps at its highest. Um, and we just felt it was the right thing to do for our customers. We knew that more and more customers were pulling out mobile phones, uh, even then.

20:16 Um, and our concern was exactly what you said, that they would, you know, scan the barcode, use one of umpteen million scanner price lookup things, buy it on Amazon while in the store. And interestingly enough, the number one place people go on our wireless, uh, networks in our stores is REI.com. Yeah. Uh, and Amazon often isn't in the top five, which is interesting. It's REI.com and then typically to a, a vendor site like The North Face, Arc'teryx, Solomon, something like that. So, uh, we know it's happening, uh, less than we admit. I, I like it 'cause like let's say I've narrowed it down to two tents or something, I like to be able to see the online reviews.

20:57 So that's kinda… I, I think it is good, great that you guys kind of… You could take the negative view, which is, "Oh my God, we're giving people a path to go price shop us," but I actually use it to pull down the content. Yeah. Um, so it's pretty, uh, it, it's a good feature. Yeah, I, I tend to not, uh, buy into the showrooming concern very much. I… In my mind, showrooming's been going on ever since the second retailer opened, right? And so, you know, folks already were going into your, your stores for the best experience, and then maybe they're going to Dick's or Sports Authority or, or wherever, uh, to price shop you. And that, that used to be really inconvenient, but, but we know lots of consumers do it. There's well-worn parking lots between Best Buy and Walmart where, where folks physically showroomed.

21:40 Um, obviously digital reduces some of that friction, but it also lets you know, um, that hey, you're within, you know, a, a small, uh, percentage of Amazon's price, and you can get the goods right now from the guy that just helped you make the selection. Sometimes it gives the customer permission to buy from you the fact that they, they could see Amazon's price. Well, I think you're right. I think the other thing, and I, I felt this in the early days of the showrooming conversation, was if, if you think about the investment that someone has when they've already driven to a store, parked, walked to the store, thinking about probably leaving the home, thinking about what they were gonna go to REI to buy, um, they're in the aisle.

22:22 They're, in your case, looking at the l- the last two things they've narrowed their choice down to- And I, I think the difference in price has got to be a significantly bigger hurdle than it is in our business today to say-- to have that consumer actually go, "Ah, you know what? I, I'm not gonna buy it today. I'll buy it, I'll buy it today, and I'll get it in three days, and then, then it'll be cool." Right? They, they've made such an investment. They're so into the buy at that point. Um, I think that's another thing that has knocked it way down. One other thing that I've always found to be unique about REI, and I, I suspect is a, a nice competitive differentiator, is even before the digital pre-shopping was really busy, you guys were producing a lot of your own content.

23:07 So you, you talked about, um, curating the assortment. Not only do you curate the assortment, th- but then you tend to publish these buying guides. And I have to imagine they're somewhat controversial with the, the vendors because you, you very bluntly say, "Hey, for this use case, we like this product over this product," or, "Here's, here's the attributes you should be thinking about when deciding to buy a tent." Um, and once digital took off, that was a really vali- I, I have to believe that must've been a really valuable, um, repository of content that, you know, still today, the, the big assortment retailers like Amazon don't have. They're not gonna help you pick a tent. Yeah, I mean, content's always been kind of an interesting… I, I, I don't really think of it that much as a, as a differentiator 'cause it's just something we've always done.

23:53 But even in the early days of REI.com, uh, you know, we didn't get a lot of content from vendors. They didn't… They had catalogs that were designed to appeal to a merchant to buy their product. And so from very early days, we created our own product information. You know, we had requirements of 160 words, and we needed these attributes 'cause we were starting to understand a little, little about search. And, um, it's something that, um, you know, the, the people that research those products are outdoors people. Um, and they, you know, we've got, I think, 13 or 14 people on that team right now, and that's what they do. They grab the f- product, they touch and feel it, they weigh it, they… I mean, it, it's important.

24:38 So it's a, it's a big deal for us. Well, for our, um, recorded audience, uh, there appears to be a dance-off between a T-Rex and a velociraptor if you're hearing screams and whoops. Um, it's not because, uh, Jason's in the booth, although we, we did have some fans stop by earlier. Uh, exactly. I was gonna mention that periodically Scott's getting up and dancing on the table, and that, that's tending to generate some whoops. It's a little distracting. Yeah. I think I can dance better than that velociraptor. He, uh, he had the little arm thing going. I got, I got more arm span than he does. Uh, I don't know if you realize this, but you're referencing a very popular recent Razorfish campaign for the, the lonely T-Rex. I did not know that. We'll, we'll, we'll cover that another day. Um, but, uh, Brett, uh, we did wanna talk a little bit about omni-channel.

25:20 A, a lot of retailers, one of the, the weapons they're using against Amazon is, uh, pickup in store, which I know you have a robust feature, but also ship to store, which I haven't heard as much from you. Like, how, how do you guys think about omni-channel and what's, what's in the, the funnel for you in terms of those kinds of features? Yeah. Um- I think, I feel pretty strongly that we've been a pretty good omni-channel retailer before there was omni-channel retailing. Um, you know, we did, uh, re-- uh, what we call retail store pickup, um, that was not having store people actually pick the product off the physical store's shelves, but actually send it on the next replenishment truck.

26:02 Wildly successful. We had, at the time, uh, this was before free shipping on REI.com, uh, I think we had about thirty-five percent of our business was getting picked up in the store. So we're, um, we're going to implement some software, um At the start of '17 that will allow us to actually do same-day, same-day picking, same-day pickup for, for, for items that are assorted in that store. Um, and I think, um, there, there's emerging conversations inside of REI now is should we incent customers to do that instead of having them ship to the, ship to their house, um, if, if the product's available?

26:46 Again, it is one of those situations where, uh, far and away the biggest assortment is on rei.com. Uh, there's a lot of stores that are a lot smaller than that flagship store you talked about that just don't have the assortment. Um, we're trying to figure out what that footprint is and, and how do we incent people to do that because it gets traffic in the stores, and that's a big deal. Do you guys do ship from store at all? Uh, we do ship from store. We started that, uh, early '15. Um, so, you know, as, uh, you know, especially at the end of season when you have inventory running down, you might not have any in the warehouse, and you still have a lot in the store.

27:27 We, we started shipping. Uh, my business went absolutely through the roof when we did that. Um, the other thing it did for us is it helped the merchants understand where they had product, where they shouldn't have product 'cause as we think about it, we really should never ship a full price product from a store. It should be in the warehouse 'cause we can pick and package, ship it, uh, less expensively and get it to the customer faster. So, um, it's challenged the merchants a lot to look at kind of their assumptions on what their distribution of digital and physical sales were and, um… But it's been a big lift to our business, and it's helped us, um, kind of improve our margins 'cause you take fewer markdowns if you can sell through that stuff a little bit better.

28:10 It's been, uh, really good for our business. Yeah. I've often wondered, the, the knock I always hear about ship from store is you have, you know, this expensive retail space. You've got people that are trained to be more retail friendly, and suddenly you're asking them to do pick, pack, ship kind of- Yeah … uh, how… Have you guys found that's a problem, or is your, your store associate able to kinda do both things? Um- Or is there a designated person that does that kind of thing? Yeah. We've assigned it. It's a role for the shipping and receiving team. Okay. Um, we've got a pretty automated process, so they get alerts back in their workstation. Um, they're… You know, we typically in every store have a shipping and receiving clerk working, you know, ten to twelve hours a day.

28:51 Uh, we have products coming in via UPS. We got our replenishment trucks. We got stuff shipping out now that we're doing, um, ship from store. Um, they stay pretty busy running around the stores picking orders, and- Yeah it's, it's been a good lift for them 'cause we kinda double count the sale. So when we started this, a lot of stores would come in on a, on a Monday morning after the shipping and receiving guy, and basically have their sales day already made, sitting in orders waiting to, to pick, pack, and ship. Nice. So they, uh, they tended to like that quite a bit. Any more omnichannel questions? No, I, I guess I, uh… You mentioned that you can usually ship faster and cheaper from the, the DC.

29:35 Like, the picking costs aside, some retailers are finding that, man, if I have that full price good in a store that's in the same market as the customer, that local ship- shipping can actually be cheaper and faster than shipping from the- Yeah, that- fulfillment center … that, you, you called me on a little data fact that I said, and then I said, "I should probably clarify that," so we're clarifying it. Now, yeah, in many cases, if you're, if you're within that first zone from a store, you're gonna get it the next day, and you'll get it for a couple of bucks cheaper than, um, coming from one of our three distribution centers. Got it. Caught me. Uh, switching- I forgive you. Yeah. Switching gears a little- Troy, Troy'll be happy. Switching gears a little bit, um, you know, we talk a lot about mobile. Most retailers we talk to have seen mobile as traffic on their website, uh, up over half.

30:20 Um, some retailers are split on should they focus on mobile web versus an app. Uh, would love to know kind of where are you guys in your mobile evolution, and, and what's your, your kind of, uh, philosophy around mobile? Um, so Scott, you pack like five questions into one question. You do it brilliantly. Um, let's tackle those little bit by bit. I heard mobile web, mobile app. Um, I think, uh, if you're not designing your website in a responsive way and running two code bases, you're, you've got… You're playing catch-up ball. We completely redesigned our website, launched it last fall, uh, a hundred percent responsive.

31:03 Um, so we, you know, at that time, we retired our code base that was running our m., our a.com. Um, and the other thing we did at the time… A- and when we did that redesign, we optimized it for mobile. By that I mean, you know, uh, as you moved to, uh, break points, you know, being able to tap your finger on a color was a lot more important to us than being able to click a mouse on that color. So we, we, we did a… I think the team did a really good job with the UI of that. We retired our, um, m. code base. The other thing we did is we started saying, "Okay, now how do we make our mobile app unique, and how do we deliver features and functions that are unique to mobile?"

31:46 And we're still just getting into that space, right? The mobile app, we know where you are, so let's take advantage of that. Um, let's take advantage of the fact that there's information about your payments and your other things on your phone that we can leverage. So, uh- Have you guys… And it's okay if you don't want to answer this. Have you guys crossed over that fifty percent mobile threshold that most other folks have kinda hit? Uh- Or is your customer base not as- No, we're… I think we're right around fifty percent. Okay. You know, it depends on traffic sources. You know, I, I think we're almost eighty percent of our emails are open on mobile now. Wow. Um, I think, uh- I think last fall, um, we had our first month where over 50% of our traffic was mobile, and that was, uh, December.

32:33 Um, and I, I, I, I don't have the data in front of me, but i- if we're not 50% now, I think the way we thought about the progression of mobile, this would bui- will be the first holiday season where over half of our traffic consistently comes from mobile devices. Got it. When, when you have a major, uh, go outside campaign, is that mostly mobile traffic in those days? Oh, yeah, it's huge. The whole, the whole Opt Outside thing was, that we did last year was, um… When we do it this year, it will be a much more, uh, mobile-first design. We kinda scrambled last year, and we were a little unsure if this was gonna blow back in our face or be an accelerator, and- Yeah. Let- -it turned out to be an accelerator … let's, uh, let's, let's tell the audience about that.

33:15 That's a good time to segue into this. So you… So, so for folks that don't know, last Black Friday, you guys decided to close your retail stores, um, and you called it Opt Out, um- Opt Outside … Opt Outside. And, uh, why'd you do that? Why would you do something crazy like that? Why would we do something crazy like that? Well, because we could. Um, yeah, the r- the real… I mean, this started out from, um, some meetings we were having in, you know, post-Christmas. Uh, and it's always been a struggle for us to stand out f- from the crowd in Christmas, I think, 'cause it, it's a struggle for every retailer, right? You get this Thanksgiving paper that's four inches thick, and it's, you know, how early can I get to the mall to, uh, to fight some people for a 65-inch TV?

34:00 Um, and one of our executives had the idea and kind of said in a joking way, "Why, why don't we just close? Why don't… Let's just… Let's not participate." And that, you know, we started riffing on that idea. Uh, we came up with this idea around Opt Outside. Um, we thought it was just perfectly aligned with our brand and our desire to get people outdoors, um, and, uh, decided to take a risk. And, you know, I was, uh, in the board meeting when we kinda floated the idea to our board, and it was, it was interesting, right? "You, you, you're gonna do what?" Uh, but when you break the numbers down on that one day of business and you take, take it down to gross margin and the fixed cost you already have, there wasn't… Uh, there's millions of dollars of exposure, but it just seemed like the right thing for us to do.

34:50 Um- We, we built a, a campaign that was, um, uh, ambitious but cautious, uh, at the same way because, you know, we didn't know if, right? You know, we're gonna open on Saturday, so like are you against retail or are you against the madness? And it was really against the madness and, you know, take your family, go outside, have fun, share it with us. Um, and, uh, we're gonna, we're gonna do it again this year in a much, much more significant way. Any social metrics from kinda like how many tweets did you see or any- anything like that that kinda- Uh … you can share? There are.

35:31 I don't have them in my head. Okay. It was, it was, it was way beyond our wildest imaginations. I mean, we had, um, we had national parks in 10 states, uh, open for free. We had state parks in five states, uh, open for free that day. We had a lot of companies in the outdoor business say, "You know what? We're gonna close our offices." Uh, not, not those, those that were retailers didn't close their stores. We're encouraging them to, um, get fully on the bus, um, this year and, and close. Um- We've got some, uh, some companies that are gonna join us in a pretty significant way this year.

36:12 And, um, you know, we're… W- we have this notion of starting a movement. Um, and w- we'll see, we'll see what happens this year. Awesome. So you're the digital guy. They close the stores for a day, and, uh, volume goes way up on the, on the digital platforms. Did you immediately come in and say, "This ought to be a weekly thing. We ought to…" Well, actually, what we did on the, on the website, uh, and the mobile site, is we put on a… We put up an interstitial page. Um, and we, we actually started doing this on Thursday, because we wanted people that were shopping with us on, on Thursday to know that we're not gonna be open on Friday, so we're actually… You know, don't expedite your order, 'cause there's not gonna be anybody here to, to do that for you.

36:55 Uh, and then on, uh, on Black Friday, we, we had a, we had a page up that said, "We're not here. You're happy to browse. You're happy to shop. Just know that no one's gonna work on your order, uh, until s-," I think it was Saturday at, at 8:00 AM. Um, we originally wanted to take the site down and just say, "We're closed." Um, but the whole effort around Black Friday at REI last year was, let's just keep it as simple as possible. And it turned out as we looked into shutting our site down, we had actually not engineered it to do that, um, intentionally. And I remember the conversation I had with the CEO, 'cause I said, "Jerry, you know, I know you want it to be easy.

37:38 It turns out it's easier to do this by accident. It's very hard to do on purpose." And so that's when we, we picked the interstitial page. Oh, the irony. Yeah. Kind of funny. Yeah. But, uh, it was, it was actually really… It was gonna be really, really hard for us to do, and then even harder to start back up, 'cause we had never done that either. Yeah. It's a little scary, like flipping the switch- Yeah … on the machines and hoping they all come back up. Yeah. It's like showing up at a trade show and expecting the audio to work. Yeah. Exactly. Uh, I wanted to change topics for a minute. Uh, one of the things that seems like a unique opportunity, uh, most retailers really struggle to get the majority of their customers to identify themselves, right?

38:19 Like, so the overwhelming majority of web traffic is anonymous. The user hasn't had a compelling reason to log in to the site. The overwhelming number of purchases in the store are completely anonymous. Um, and because of your membership model, and because, you know, everyone wants to earn their dividend, I'm assuming a much higher percentage of your traffic is known to you, and I'm just, A, wondering if that's true, and B, that would seem to really open the doors from, for some interesting personalization opportunities. Uh, another well-packed series of questions there. You guys are very crisp at this. Uh- E- personalization is one of those things, and you both know this very well, anybody that's listening to this probably has, uh, a range of opinion.

39:07 But it, it's been one of those things that this industry's really struggled to kinda figure out and how to make work well. And, and we are of the same, uh, ilk. Um, our-- We have a pretty good chunk of our traffic that's known to us, but not as much as we'd like to have. Um, certainly in the stores, we know those purchases, so if we can… You know, one of our challenges is how persistent is that cookie versus how frequently do people visit rei.com. And, um, we're trying to do things to make that cookie more persistent. We're trying to get- do things to get people back more frequently, so we can keep hitting them. Um, personalization, though, is still a challenge for us.

39:48 We've, we've experimented with things like, you know, if someone's coming to us, uh, from the desert Southwest in winter, let's not show them snowy slopes. Let's show them the desert and some arroyo cactus and a hiking trail. And it's interesting 'cause we do this, and a lot of people go, "We don't wanna see that. We can see that by looking out our window. We wanna-- We're thinking about a ski trip, and we wanna see…" You know, so you're kinda going, "Boy, how do you figure, how do you figure that out?" So, um, we're, we're doing more and more, um, but I would still say baby steps. We still haven't, um, really figured out a way to do that well. It's a challenge.

40:29 Brad, you've been in this industry for a long, long, long time. Um, what do you think is the future of e-commerce? You've seen things… You know, sometimes things happen faster than you think they do. Sometimes they take a while. We've been talking about mobile for 10 years, and then, you know, we're kind of there. Um, what do you… You know, I'd love to hear you pontificate on the future of e-commerce. What are, what are some things listeners should be thinking about as kinda the next waves? Uh, I think more and more, and more and more mobile, mobile, mobile, mobile. Um, I think, uh, you know, there's still, still, you know, websites are still gonna be important. I think, um, if we look at the consuming public, and we think about multicultural millennials, how they shop is gonna be the next thing, um, for retail.

41:20 Um, you know, inter- You mean like texting or chat bots or you buying the- Chat bots I think are a very interesting technology. Um, I think, uh, things like, you know, a lot in Asia, a lot of w- you know, commerce on WeChat, uh, in chat with, with retailers is gonna be interesting. Um, I, I think more and more will be done on mobile. You know, it was interesting to see there's some, some chat bot booths around the show. Uh, it was interesting talking to them and how they're approaching it. It's not something that we've started looking at, but I think, um, I think most of the future is gonna be around how are those multicultural millennials gonna be shopping. And they're like, like folks our age, um, to put us all in one big category, they all have… You know, I talked to one of the Ray Greenly scholarship finalists, and she likes shopping with her friends in a mall.

42:14 And I'm kinda going, "This is a endangered species." But, but that's what she likes doing. It's, it's almost therapeutic for her. So there's still gonna be those customers, and we can't lose track of them, but I think, uh, I think millennials are gonna shop in a much more social way. I think I can imagine, um, this individual in the future, you know, shopping and sharing pictures and getting feedback real time. Whether that's through, you know, Messenger or chat or Snapchat or, you know, whatever it is. Um, and having that be a digitally social experience I think is gonna be an interesting opportunity. Yeah, on the topic of millennials, uh, all the surveys you read, they always score, uh, sustainability very high in their purchasing decisions.

42:58 You guys have been kinda living that as a brand. Yeah. I, I don't know if it's, like, a purposeful statement. It just seems to be part of the brand. Um, has that helped you with the millennial audience, do you feel? And, and what is kind of the sustainability kind of philosophy of REI? Yeah. Um, sustainability philosophy first. We'll try and do things in the most sustainable way we can do them. Um, it's actually kind of part of what, how we go about any, any of the work we do. We, uh … Best example of this is we just opened our third distribution center in Goodyear, Arizona. Uh, we realized going in, or w- we realized in the process that if we could get a few, you know, not a few more, another kind of array or two of solar panels on the roof, we could be energy neutral.

43:44 Um, it would cost another quarter of a million dollars. We did that in a heartbeat. Uh, we're gonna be the first, uh, zero energy LEED platinum distribution center in the United States. We haven't got the certification yet, but we're shipping from that. We did a whole bunch of re-engineering of our air conditioning and our air circulation systems, and it's literally off It's, it's on the grid 'cause we sell power back a lot of the time. Um, so those are things that we just, they're part of our DNA. Wow, very cool. Well, Brad, it's happened again. Uh, we have used our allotted time. Um, but we're super grateful to you for taking the time out of the busy schedule, and sure appreciate your insights.

44:29 As a reminder to our live audience here, uh, next up we have Milton Pappas, um, who's with HBCE. And after that, uh, we're going to do a news recap of the day, including a special guest. Uh- Thanks, Brad. We really appreciate you having you, and enjoy the rest of your show. I will. Thanks so much. And, uh, know that I will continue to be an avid listener. Thanks. Thank you, guys. Thanks. We appreciate it. You've been listening to The Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes or visit www.jasonandscot.com.