EP072 - RetailDIVE Editor Jason Ankeny
EP072 - RetailDIVE Editor Jason Ankeny
Jason Ankeny is the Editor at RetailDIVE. RetailDIVE is a daily e-newsletter focused on the retail industry, offering industry news and original analysis, and is one of Jason & Scots favorite industry news sources. Jason is on Twitter as @jankenydive and can be reached via e-mail at jankeny@industrydive.com. Jason sat down for an interview live from the NRF Big Show, and we covered a wide range of topics.
Don't forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.
Episode 72 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded on Monday January 16th, 2017.
Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:02 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here are Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. This episode is being recorded live from the NRF Big Show in New York. We wanna thank the folks at NRF for hosting us. And as usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Jason, and welcome Jason and Scott Show listeners. I am surrounded by Jasons yet again.
0:43 We're excited to have the editor of Retail Dive, one of my favorite regular retail reads, Jason Ankeny. Welcome, Jason. Hey, thanks, fellas. Happy to be here. Cool. So we love to start on the show just kinda going through, uh, a little bit of your background. How, how'd you get involved in this fun, uh, business of retail/e-commerce? And, um, and then we'll dive into what you do at Retail Dive. Sure. Uh, I joined Retail Dive about 11 months ago. Been a business reporter for quite a while. Uh, I was the senior writer at Entrepreneur Magazine until, uh, I guess February of last year. And, uh, so I wrote about a lot of verticals there, including retail, um, which is really sort of my first exposure as a journalist to the subject.
1:25 And, uh, before that, I, I, I wrote about mobile for a long time. And, uh, before that, I was a music and film critic. And then before that, I was just a drifter. Okay. Yeah. Isn't music and film critic synonymous with drifter? Uh, absolutely. In, in terms of, of, of tax bracket, yes. Yes. Very cool. So tell, um, so I'm very familiar with the, the newsletter, so tell folks a little bit about Retail Dive. Sure. Uh, Retail Dive is a daily e-newsletter. Uh, we have an, an app. It was actually sort of conceived more for a, a, a mobile, mobile readership. And to that point, the initial focus was on very much quick hit reading.
2:07 Uh, you know, get to the news, break it down as simply and efficiently as possible, and then sort of delve into the, the, the, the, the larger impact and repercussions of the news. As time's gone on and, and as the newsletter's evolved, we've really emphasized the insight more and more and more. So while you can still get your quick news on the most important industry subjects and, and headlines and, and, and trends, if you want to delve deeper, we are offering a, an increasing amount of, of depth and, and insight. And, uh, you know, thanks to, uh, uh, fellas like yourselves who are w- uh, willing to get on the phone with us and lend some insight and perspective on, on the way you see things unfolding. Yeah. You know, Jason and I will talk to pretty much to, uh, anyone who'll listen as, as evidenced by this podcast.
2:51 Well, and, and obviously- Yeah you know, you guys are, uh, you, you'll have anyone on the podcast. Yeah, clearly. Yeah. I, I- So how, how- Oh, wait. Did you think we were recording this? Well, I, I, I'm assuming, but I, you know, I'm not a tech guru. I have no idea if this is real equipment. How big, um, you know, to the extent you can tell us, how big is the audience for- Sure. Um, we, our, our subscribers ship's a little over 75,000 now. Um, it's grown quite a bit. Uh, I don't have a lot of numbers at my disposal. I don't really look at the numbers personally. I feel like I can get bogged down in that stuff and, you know, look at maybe points of emphasis that, that- we shouldn't necessarily follow.
3:33 You know, I, in order to, to really stay true to the mandate of just covering the news that's most important, I, I just try to focus on the quality and- I don't think you would do well at BuzzFeed. I'm gonna, just gonna put that out there. I would, I would be the worst BuzzFeed ever. Or Buzz- Buzz- BuzzFeed employee. Um, yeah, listicle's not really a favorite- It's not your thing … format of mine. Um, nostalgia doesn't really interest me that much. Yeah. So, um, yeah, I would, I would, I would be fired at where, if I were at BuzzFeed. I saw on LinkedIn you talk about, uh, Industry Dive, so I imagine that, you know, I've only seen the little slice of Retail Dive, but are there sister publications that, that- Yeah, absolutely. Um- So Industry Dive as a company is devoted to newsletters, tar- B2B newsletters targeting verticals.
4:17 Um, everything from utility and healthcare to, to things that are directly related to retail. Uh, there's a, a supply chain publication. There is also a, uh, a food dive publication that within the last week or so launched a, uh, a new pub called, uh, uh, Food Dive Grocery, which is also daily. So the, the- Mm … there's obvious overlap in, in both of those pubs in what we do, especially with things like Amazon Go, for example. The, the, the, the Venn diagram overlap between those pubs is, is increasingly obvious in a way that if ha- had Grocery launched a year ago, I don't think we would be nearly as c- as, as collaborative with them- Mm as, as we are here in, in early 2017.
4:59 Does that just mean you get to do a lot of content reuse? Uh, that is part of it, yes. There, you know, there, there's definitely content development collaboration, but with the end result or the end game of reuse. So, yes. Absolutely. Nice. That doesn't make you a bad person. Oh, well, thank you. Well, there's a lot of things that make me a bad person. Yeah, I didn't say you weren't. And I don't think that's one of them. I didn't… Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Glad we clarified that one. Oh, yeah. Well, thank you. Cool. My mother will be thrilled. And, uh, we were talking before this show, you're based out of Chicago. I am. Yeah. But you and Jason have never met. No, this is the first time. The two Jason Chicagos have never met. Wow. It's a small world. I think we're the only two. Yeah. Uh, qui- possibly. Possibly not. Uh, but I'm happy to say that you spell your name correctly.
5:40 Oh, yeah. Or you spell my name correctly, I should say. Yeah. Not that, that superfluous Y. That Y. Yeah. There you go. Yeah. That's, that's, that's so pretentious. Mama's ass. Yeah. I hate superfluous Ts too. It's so, it's so arrogant. Yeah. So- That's right. Yeah … yeah, yeah. So rude. Uh, anyway, so, uh, one of the things I enjoy about your newsletter is it kind of, it takes a stand and, and, um, has an editorial voice where a lot of these things just kind of aggregate news, and then you kinda have to formulate your own opinion, whi- which is fine. But I really like, and I think you guys call them, you know, our take, uh, on these things. How big of a… It feels like you have a pretty big editorial staff. How, how big is that? Uh, we have a surprisingly small editorial staff given the amount of, of work that we publish. So in addition to me, uh, we have Corinne Ruff, who's our associate editor.
6:24 And in terms of editorial, we're the, the, the, the two f- full-time staffers. Uh, we have a great and growing stable of freelancers. Um, Daphne Holland, who contributes the majority of our daily content. Dan O'Shea, who writes briefs for us as well. And then we have a couple other freelancers. W- were we recording that? Yes. So, so, so when you guys do these kind of, you know, your takes, um, you know, I- again, I really like that you're not like, you know, "Here's the pros." You, you tend to take a position. Sure. Um, do you guy- and I know you're not big on metrics, but any, do you get kind of pushback from folks? So, you know, that's one of the downsides of taking a position is, like, how dare you take this position from… You know, for example, there was recently, uh, Macy's closing, so you guys have said, you know, "This is not good.
7:13 This is the beginning of the end." And then you cite some other folks that say they really think that, you know, maybe this is just the start of many more store closures. Um, yeah, so, so, so those are, those are pretty big stands to be taking out there, and I'm just kind of curious, does, does that have a bit of a, a backlash to it a- at all? Or how, how does that work? We, we don't get a lot of backlash. It's, it's surprising. I think we go out of our way to, to support the arguments. You know, we're not in the business of hot takes at all. We try to be really objective and balanced and measured, and, and, you know, none of us are rooting for or against any of the companies that, that we write about. And, but again, it, it's, we, we spend a lot of time talking to experts in the industry, analysts, executives, so on and so forth.
8:00 And so we don't arrive at conclusions or at opinions lightly. We, we, we, we back them up and, and, you know, I think, I think we've been proven correct much more often than not in, in, in, in assessing where we think a story's gonna, gonna end up. Yeah. Uh, another reason I love to read you guys is you cover Amazon a lot. Um, what are your, you know, as we look kind of back last year and anything this year, what, what are your thoughts on Amazon? I think like a lot of people, I'm still trying to figure out exactly where all the pieces of the puzzle fit and, and how all the moving parts correspond. But, um, to me, Amazon Go is probably the biggest story that, that we've written about in the last year or so.
8:47 Um, I think it's just an absolute game changer. And, and I, uh, I don't know that … I have a 92-year-old grandmother, and I don't know that she actually knows what I do for a living. Mm-hmm. But Amazon Go is the only thing that she ever heard about retail-related on the news that she called me to ask what I could tell her about it. So I think if, if, if, if that basic premise can, can speak to someone outside of, of, of the normal demographics that, that we talk to and, and, you know, that really impacts the, the consumer in that way and, and piques their imagination, I think it speaks volumes about the, the potential impact it's going to have. Obviously, there's so much that we don't know about it at this point, but what we do know seems absolutely revolutionary to me.
9:34 And, and it does seem to fit within the larger footprint of what they're doing. But, you know, I, I don't know about you. I mean, we, we report on, on things then … And I don't always understand exactly where they are going to fit in the larger Amazon mosaic. Yeah. When there's a, a report that they made by American Apparel, that kind of makes sense, but then I don't really know where it fits into the larger end game for them as well. So I mean, Amazon is endlessly fascinating to me because it's just like a, it's a, you know, it, it's, it's like a movie where you, you know there's a twist ending coming, and you're constantly trying to process what you think that's going to be. And then that twist ending arrives, and it's not at all what you forecasted it, it to be.
10:18 Yeah. I feel that way about Echo. You would have never guessed after the Fire Phone failure that they would suddenly, their next gadget would be a huge hit. Like, that's- Exactly … that's the kind of twist you get on Amazon that makes- Right them very fascinating to follow. Well, and then I just look at how quickly things snowball with Amazon, that, that the Echo and, and Alexa were sort of interesting things. And then they kind of started to gain a little momentum in, in maybe the third quarter. And then with the, the advent of the developer program and then all the announcements at CES, it just seems like now Alexa is the engine driving so much of, of where they're going in the future. And- Again, I mean, it, it almost came out of nowhere in, in hindsight- Mm-hmm … to, to be one of the things that we're reporting on most regularly as it relates to, to the Amazon ecosystem.
11:07 One of the interesting things to me now is they're in so many lines of business, that when they try something new or have some no- new innovation, it's no longer even obvious which line of business it's intended to serve. Mm-hmm. So, like, I, you know, I think there was some news recently about, uh, them applying for some wireless tests, right? And there were a bunch of people speculating, like, "Oh, that's, that's drone communication." And, you know, Scott, you know, who foolishly predicted that Amazon was gonna launch a new phone this year, was, you know- We'll see thinking, uh, yeah, uh, thinking that that could be part of a phone test, right? And it, it, it's, it's true. Many of these things could now… Like, does Amazon wanna buy American Apparel because they need the real estate to open showrooms for Echoes?
11:53 Or because they think that that's a valuable apparel brand that they can grow and- Absolutely. Yeah. Well, I mean, that, I guess that raises the question, is there, is there any Amazon rumor that you would automatically discount at this point? I, I feel like anything within the, the, the realms of, of reality and reason, you would have to think, "Hmm, okay. Maybe." Something like Jeff Bezos buying a newspaper or something. That would be crazy. Well, exact- or, or, or building a rocket ship to space. Yeah. But God forbid he would do something bananas like that. Um, yeah, I, I don't know. I mean, it, it, it, it, it's obviously it's really tough to write about that in a… You know, 'cause we're not a, a, a rumor blog.
12:40 We're… and, and we're not a, a, a gossip column. So it's really hard to, to ferret out exactly where all these things are going and, and to what extent they're even pushing deliberate misinformation into the media. That's, that's my, one of my many paranoid conspiracies, that they're deliberately releasing stuff just to further cloud whatever the, the ultimate objectives really are. Yeah, if I, if I kinda… So I've been following them for 20 years, and I play back everything. I can't, I can't really think of anything that they've kind of announced that didn't actually come out. I mean, you know, the drone, a lot of people I talked to think it was a PR stunt, but then when I talk to Amazon people, they're like, "Yeah, we're on version nine, and we really think this is the future." And- Really? … you know, they're- Yeah … they're investing in it.
13:21 If that was a PR stunt, they're… But props, 'cause they're all in on that PR stunt. They're, yeah, they're two years into this thing still, you know? So it's kind of like, all right. You know, maybe it… You know, I don't, you know… I can't think of a single thing that didn't actually come out to some degree. Okay. Now, certainly, like, there's been all these rumors of acquisitions that don't happen. Like, I don't really think they were involved in American. That doesn't make any sense to me. But I don't think they floated it. I think, you know, some other random person did. I'm just incredibly mistrustful. That, that's good. You're a journalist. You should be. Any other Amazon thoughts? What, do, do you have a dialogue with readers? Do you get, like, a lot of inbound questions about Amazon, and that's kinda, like, why you guys are covering it more? Or is it just because, you know- Well- … as an editor, you, you're kind of predicting that there's more intellectual curiosity around it?
14:05 Well, we absolutely… When, when we, when we publish Amazon stories, they always do really well for us. But, but again, it's really… We write about them because they're setting the pace. Mm-hmm. We would… We'll write about anybody that is- Mm … setting the pace and, and, and redefining the rules of, of the business, and it just happens to be them more often than not. And, and it seems like they're creating an inc- increasing distance between them and everyone else. You know, I mean, I feel like just even being here at NRF, Amazon is the elephant in the room that isn't actually in the room. They're every- they're on everyone's minds. Every decision, every service, every project seems to be in some way a, a, a response to something that Amazon is doing or something that Amazon is about to do.
14:53 And, and I feel, you know, certainly we've seen that before with Amazon and, and with… Or with A- with Apple and with other companies in segments at particular points in time. But, um, it's… Their, their, their influence just seems inescapable right now. And, and, you know, we… One of the nice things about, about our newsletter is that we have a number of stories every day, so we can write about Amazon without excluding other companies and other trends. Mm. And, and, and so, you know, it's always a balance that we're… We, we don't want to be an Amazon newsletter, certainly. Yeah. And, and, um, but they're, they're inescapable. For, for, for everyone who- whose, whose livelihood is based in retail, Amazon is inescapable, whether it's the press or, or anyone else in attendance here.
15:38 Yeah. You, you've seen these arcs over your career where, you know, IBM was kinda like, you know, no one got fired for doing IBM. Then Microsoft came along, and they couldn't fail. And now, you know, it seems like Amazon, and we've got Google kind of in there and Facebook. Do, do you think someone kinda knocks Amazon down a peg, or do, do you have any thoughts on what that would look like? Or is it more like Walmart finally wakes up and says, "No more. We're gonna really go at these guys"? Or is it, like, two dudes at Stanford right now that, you know, will come up with the idea that, that, that shoots them past Amazon? At this point, it seems like only Amazon could trip up Amazon. I, I don't know that this industry moves quickly enough. It's not- Okay. Yeah, unlike something like social media where, you know, you mentioned Facebook where you could go from Friendster to Myspace to, to, to Facebook in less than a decade, each usurping the one that, that was king of the hill before it.
16:32 I d- I just don't know how you would build out anything re- remotely comparable to what Amazon has built and with all the tentacles at this point and compete directly with them. I think what, some of what Walmart's doing is really interesting, but I, I certainly question their ability to bring in millennials and, and if they go all in on that, h- to what extent does that alienate their core audience? Now, Amazon just isn't faced with those sorts of questions, I don't think. And, and, you know, obviously, and, and, and the investors don't question what they're doing. Doesn't seem like there's any kind of internal decision about the direction that they're following.
17:12 I mean, those are, those are historically the things that, that bring companies down. And, and until, you know, certainly the fulfillment costs and everything that we saw in Q, Q3, those are, they're sor- are certainly problematic. But I mean, uh, unless I'm completely blind to, to some threat on the horizon, I, I just don't see what it is in, in, in, in the short term at all. Okay. Interesting. Uh, I do wanna go back just a sec. Like, so the format of the newsletter, you have all those daily pieces, and then you have the features. Mm-hmm. Uh, and I'm, I'm a big fan of the features. Thank you. Uh, I'm curious what the editorial cycle is for the features. Like, how much time do you invest in a piece?
17:54 Well, it depends. Yeah. We certainly, we try to get things up as quickly as possible. Um, and, and that's where our writers are really great. They're, they're flexible, and they want to, they wanna cover stories. And, and they want to be, if not necessarily the first to publish, to be in the, in the sandbox as quickly as possible. So we're, we always have any number of features in the hopper, and some are very news-driven or res- If, uh, um, a, a recent example, The Limited goes bankrupt. Obviously, the writing was on the wall there. We had a feature in the works. We accelerated the process to get it up within a matter of days of, of, of them officially closing all the stores.
18:37 Other, other times, you catch lightning in a bottle. You're, you're working on something, and then there's a major news event and that makes the, makes that feature incredibly relevant and timely when you weren't necessarily thinking that it might be. And then, of course, we have evergreen features as well, and w- we have to. There, there's, with publishing five days a week, there's no way that we could have timely feature… Well, they're, they're all timely, but hyper timely, let's say. Mm-hmm. Um, so- I'm working on features, Corinne's working on features, and, and the, the contributors are usually working on multiple features at any given point in time. And, and as you pointed out earlier, with, with, uh, with the Industry Dive model, we have complimentary newsletters that, you know, we can, we can joke about reusing content, and, and I think it is kind of funny.
19:27 I've, I've been doing this long enough that that still is, is a, a, is an odd thing to me to do. But at the same time, if, if, if, if Food Dive Grocery has a really compelling piece on Amazon Go, it'd be ridiculous for, for us. And because we… Especially with that being a new pub, they, they don't have all the subscribers that we do, but our subscribers should see that, and they might overlook it. Um, so, so yeah, there's a- there- we do a crazy ass amount of content, but there's a lot of planning that goes into that and, and a little bit of luck. And again, just most importantly, really, really hardworking people that, that like what they do, or at least they tell me that they, they like what, what they do- … while, while they're scrambling to find other employment.
20:08 No, they do like what they do, just not doing it with you. Well, that's usually, that's usually how all those things work out professionally and personally for me, so. So a, a follow-up question. So how many other skeleton features do you have right now on bankrupt retailers that haven't gone bankrupt yet? Uh- And which ones are they, obviously? Yeah, it's, it's, it's sort of like the old, uh, uh, obituaries in, in newspapers. You know, you, you know that, uh- You have the retail obit template ready? Exactly. Everyone knows Betty Die- Betty White is going to die eventually. No one wants to admit it yet, but everyone has that obituary written. So yeah, so we have, we have comprehensive obituaries for, for all of the, uh, all the retailers and actually some readers and, and, uh, fans of the, of the publication as well.
20:58 Uh, so we, I have to fact check a few things with both of you guys after we record this, by the way. Okay. Totally unrelated to the- … to the obits. Fair enough. Uh, and then, uh, another topic, uh, you may, uh… Your name, Retail Dive. Mm-hmm. Uh, was there any strategic like… So to some people, retail is our whole industry, online, offline. Some people talk about retail though as designating, uh, brick and mortar, for example, versus online. And so, uh, w- in our industry, when we talk about, like, our vertical practices, there's always this controversy, retail versus commerce versus- Like, did you, like, intentionally pick retail with any specific meaning or?
21:46 Well, I did not pick it. Uh, the, the Newsletter was launched four years ago. Gotcha. So many, many years before I came along. So I- Did they, they didn't leave you any notes? No. All right. Uh, I, I, I was not- You ever thought about changing the name? Uh, no, I never have. I mean, it seems like the, uh, uh, you know, I think that to, to, you know, to some of the points you were making, I think it's the best catch-all. Um, I think anything else would start to skew the perception of, of what we write about. I mean, we want to write about retail in all of its forms, digital, online. Um, and, and, you know, not even just merchants themselves, but their, their, their partners and, and technology firms and everything.
22:29 So I, I think, I think Retail is, Retail Dive is probably the most appropriate name under the circumstances. Um, certainly if you guys have better suggestions, I would, I would love to hear them. But, but it's not something I've thought about. I've actually put retail right in my name, so I'm totally- Well, that's true … on, on the line, yeah. Uh, was, was that a legal name change or? Uh, it was not. My, my mother was very encouraging, uh, for me to change my name- but she was, you know, she may have had some different motivations. Oh, I'm, I'm sure. Yeah. I, I can understand. Yeah. Uh, so outside of Amazon, are, do you feel like there are other big recurring themes that you- Feel like, uh, you cover a lot in the- Oh, yeah, absolutely.
23:14 Well, omnichannel is a big one, of course, and, and mobile both in, in the context of omnichannel and, and outside of, of that. Um, bankruptcies, of course. And we're, we're not a financial publication, but we-- but obviously we, we cover those, those stories very extensively. Um, you know, I'm, I'm really interested in this, this sort of the rebirth of, of brick-and-mortar that we're starting to see with, with a lot of the… Well, maybe not a lot, but a number of the, uh, the, the, the pure-play e-com companies starting to move back into the space and, and recognizing the value that, that, that has and, and, you know, and so what that entails. And I, and I think it's gonna be really interesting to see what a digital native version of a retail store is like.
24:01 We know that obviously a non-native version retailer executive, what their version of, of digital is, doesn't always work, but I think the, the, the, the opposite transition is going to be a lot more seamless and a, and a lot more innovative. Um, and, and, you know, I guess also kind of related to that, just the, the, the transformation of malls is, is a, is a big subject. Um, not only just the, the types of stores that are moving in, but the types of non-stores that are moving in, and mixed-use properties and things of that nature. Um, you know, we, we write about legislative issues that impact the, the industry, um, employment issues, on-call scheduling, things of that nature.
24:45 Um, we're-- we can't be comprehensive, of course, but we, we definitely strive to be. And, you know, every day it's, it's-- As, as we figure out what we're going to publish the next day, there's a, there's just a running document of potential stories, and they're, they're moving up and down. It's like horses in a race or something. You know, something might be out front, and then in the eleventh hour, two or three more important stories present themselves, and then that thing that seemed really important earlier in the day gets moved down in, in the, in the rundown. So, and, and that's what's kind of, you know, really fun about this, is that we're, we're not beholden to anything beyond covering retail.
25:28 I mean, that's all we do in, in a way. And obviously that's-- it's a massive, sprawling thing to tackle. But- Whatever, whatever trends present themselves, we will cover, and, uh, and hopefully, you know, get a pretty solid balance of, of, of, of things that different people are going to want to read. Yeah. One, one of the topics you guys cover that I call it Mallageddon is- Yes. you know, there's, um… And I think I first saw it in you guys. There, there was an interesting Wall Street report- Oh … where they kind of did this analysis of here's the malls that have, you know, a couple of these anchor tenants that are struggling, and then this is what it looks like. And it was a pretty big number, if I recall.
26:08 What, what do you think, uh, you know, tell us your kind of thought about this, this whole mall thing that's going on? I think, so I'm not a millennial obviously, but, but I think it's really interesting that people are starting to rethink what malls can mean for millennials and, and developing these mixed use properties that are, may include retail, but also hospitality and entertainment, even healthcare, and even multi-unit dwellings. And I think malls as we've known them are, are certainly on the way out if they're not already there. But I think that, you know, one of the things that I think is really interesting was the, the Aeropostale deal and with, with, with, with Simon and, and, and I forget the other mall operator in the mix there, but this recognition that Obviously they need stores like Aeropostale to survive to, to, to bring people in.
27:04 But I think what's more interesting, and, and we'll have to see how it plays out, is what, what can a store like an Aeropostale do if it's owned by the mall operator and has access to all the analytics information, all the big data about the, the different consumers that are coming into the malls? And, you know, I feel like that's a template, that deal's a template for a lot of things, not only just how to bring a retailer out of bankruptcy if, if the, there's still the perception that there's value in the brand, but more importantly, how malls and the, and the businesses within them can work in a more collaborative way and, and, and play to one another's strengths, share information, share data.
27:45 Um, I, you know, I don't know if there are any other examples like that. I certainly haven't come across any, but I feel like it, it's indicative of where things could and, more importantly, should be going. And I also think bringing in things like rock climbing walls and, and, and, and, and things of that nature are really, really interesting as well. You know, let's, let's just abandon the idea that these are retail centers and make them into something more like a Mall of America, I guess, where it's this combination s- retail environment, theme park, massive food court, and- Movie theater and entertainment … God knows what else. Yeah. So, you know, I don't think I think malls as we know them are dead, but I don't think malls are dead.
28:27 And I, I actually think that that's going to be one of the most interesting trends to, to watch over the next several years. I'll, uh, I'll give you half credit for that answer, 'cause I, I s- totally agree about the mixed use. Um, Mall of America has another attribute which I think is going away in malls- Mm-hmm which is these, um, remote locations with a huge moat of parking around them that are k- like, completely, um, segregated from the community. So I think, like, when we look at all those A malls and those, like, 150… There's 150 malls in the US that are growing faster than e-commerce. Mm-hmm. And in those malls, like, they tend to have all that m- mixed use, uh, stuff that you're describing, and they tend to be more, uh, integrated in the community lifestyle, things that are you know, feel like more part of your life as opposed to a destination that you had to go out of your way to get to.
29:23 So, so what do you anticipate with, with those malls that are struggling? Do you see them… How do you see them riding the ship? Oh, I, I think the regional malls, I, I think the encl- to your point, like, the enclosed, um, catalogs of stores are likely going away. Um, there's some new research that, uh, like Generation Z might be more mall friendly- Mm-hmm … um, than, than Millennials. I'm not sure how credible that research is at this point, so I, uh, I'll, I'll see it when it actually happens as opposed to the surveys. But the, but I, I think there's, there's a bottom 20% of malls that, that served a purpose, and that purpose is going away, and I think there's a top 20% of malls that are a no-brainer, you know, huge money maker, and then there's that, that chunky middle.
30:10 Right. And, you know, there's gonna be winners and losers in there. Absolutely. Cool. How about, um, let's bring it down to the show here. Have you had a chance to walk the floor, and anything interesting you've seen? Yeah, I've, uh, I've spent a lot of time on the floor scrambling from one briefing to the next. Um- There's, there's, there's not a… I haven't isol- isolated one really dominant trend. But, um, and one of the things that, that I've heard several people talk about, and it actually started on the, on the, uh, yesterday morning at the opening here with the, with the launch of Rise Up, which is the, uh, NRF Foundation program to educate and, and credential, uh, uh, store associates. And the, the associates seem to be a really interesting part of a lot of dialogue here, which is not something I anticipated at all.
30:57 And, and I think it's, you know, it's, you, you, you come into a show like this thinking people are going to be talking about tech innovations and, and, and, and new strategies, and so on and so forth, and not something that's been a, a fundamental element of retail all along. But it does seem like there's a… People are starting to come back to understanding the role that associates play in stores. And, and, but then conversely, uh, there's a, a, a report that Cisco's putting out, and it, it, it looks… Th- they, they sat down with 200 different retailers and talked about their digital transformation. And the amount that they are spending on the customer experience still dramatically dwarfs the amount of money that they are spending on store associates, even though according to their data, that the, the return on investment in, in, in associates far outstrips the investment and in, in, in, in the customer experience.
31:52 And more importantly, I think it's really strange that they are dividing those two, that, that the perception is that those are two separate things. I feel like they're, they're two halves of, of a much larger whole. I don't know how you- It seems like store associates is part of the customer experience. Exactly. That's usually the front, that's the tip of the spear. Ex- exactly. Yeah. I, I, I feel like every customer experience I've ever had, positive or negative, if it's memorable to me, it's because an associate played a, a very prominent role in that. So I, I, I think it's, it's… While, while I applaud the efforts to educate And, and create better associates. I feel like there's still a lot of work to be done simply in better synthesizing them into the overall vision of, of what the stores are going to be.
32:39 So but, but it does… It- regardless, it does seem like there is increasing awareness again that, that humans still matter in this equation. And, uh, uh, and again, I think that goes back with the, with the, the sort of brick-and-mortar renaissance that we were talking about a few moments ago. Cool. Um, you know, again, Amazon. Everyb- everyone seems to be talking about it, either directly or indirectly. I don't know that that's a theme or trend. I don't know about you guys. I w- I thought there'd be more about AI and about machine learning, and, and, and I don't, I don't know what led me to believe that. And, and I don't want to suggest that my experience here is representative of what everybody's talking about, but are, are people talking about AI in, in your conversations?
33:23 There's a lot of little robots, but I- There, there are a lot of robots. Yeah . Yeah, so it, it, it, it's tricky because AI is both like a, uh, an interesting specific thing, and it's sort of a buzzword catchphrase that everyone redefines for their own purposes. Um, and so I, I'm seeing less people at this show than, for example, CES, uh, use AI as a buzzword, right? Mm-hmm. You go to C- CES, and the new iteration of every product is new because it has AI of some kind, right? And y- what does that mean, right? Oh, it means it acts like a human or it has some cognitive computing behind it or, or whatever the case is.
34:04 Uh, here I see less of that as a buzzword, which is interesting and surprising. Like I, I, uh, I mean, this industry is not immune to buzzwords. Um, so you know, you, you certainly could expect to, to see it on the floor. But there are certain AI use cases that are pretty prevalent on the floor. So, um, computer vision, for example. Uh, I've seen a lot more applications of computer vision on the floor this year than I've ever seen before for like sending robots around the store to take pictures and figure out your inventory and measure planogram compliance and things like that. A- all the people counters are using computer vision now.
34:46 Google's demonstrating like sentiment analysis in their computer vision models. So we see that one a lot. A lot… All the analytics companies of course are now calling their analytics, um, machine learning. And then, you know, one of the biggest booths on the show is IBM, and I think they just have a blanket policy that all IBM products are now called Watson. Um, and so that, you know Makes, makes things a little confusing. So I think, I think you, if you scratch beneath the surface, like there is a fair amount of stuff that I would put in the AI category here. Um, but I would totally agree with you. For whatever reason, I haven't seen like AI hype for AI hype here as much as other, other industries at the moment.
35:32 Mm-hmm. Cool. Any other NRF things you've seen? Well, I did spend time with one of the robots, uh, the, the SoftBank Pepper robot. Oh, yeah. That was a very, very interesting experience 'cause it… And, and I actually wrote a feature about it that we'll be publishing probably in the next few days. Um, it's a, it's an- It's an oddly emotional experience when b-b- the, the, the… It was very noisy. They're, they're, they're sort of tucked back in a corner, and it's very noisy back there. And so the, the robot was struggling to hear me as it's asking these questions about what kind of shoes I want. And then he just ultimately gave up, and his shoulders just fell.
36:16 It was like a, like a child that was trying to explain something to you and, and you're just too dumb to get what this kid is telling you. And he just finally just, you know, just looks at you like you're never gonna get it. And, and I had no idea that a robo- a robot could convey emotion in that way. I, I was actually… It was, it was… That's really what the piece is about is, is just my own reaction to it and, and, and that, you know, it's something that I didn't… Well, certainly robotics in, in, in fulfillment and shipping and picking, I can, I… You know, that's pretty easy to understand. I didn't really understand, though, the value of robots in, in a customer environment.
37:00 And I'm not sure I still do, but, uh, it definitely made me much more of a believer than I was. And I think that, you know, maybe it's just a novelty. Maybe if I have four or five of those experiences, then I'll just shrug it off. But it, as something that I experienced for the first time here, it was definitely unexpectedly compelling. So that's something I'll probably be tracking a little more closely as, uh, than, than I was before I got here to New York. Yeah. Yeah, the, uh… I saw an IBM demo where they used those little half-size robots. What are… Do you know what those are called? Uh- I do, but it's not- Yeah … on the tip of my tongue. And, uh, the guy was talking on stage, and the robot was, like, going through some… And it was, like, freaking everyone out because you're just like, you know, you could hardly listen to the guy 'cause you're, like, watching the robot kind of, like… And it was, like, you know, changing its weight on its hip and- Mm-hmm … it had been programmed with these human body motions, and it was very distracting.
37:48 Yeah. Even though my brain was saying it's just, you know, been programmed to do that, so you're kind of, like, keeping an eye on it just in case that little guy jumped off of there and ran at you with a knife or something. Exactly. As happens in every science fiction film- Yeah … ever made. You know it's one step away. Yes. Uh, at CES, the… You know, we've, we've all seen the vacuum robots, but they're no- they now have the lawnmower robots. Mm. And I'm pretty sure those, the next, uh, round of horror movies are all gonna prominently feature, uh, vac- uh, lawnmower robots. But what's more horrific: a lawnmower robot that attacks you or just mowing a lawn in the middle of the summer? Uh, fair enough. I'm willing to take the risk. Yeah. A, a fine point you make. Uh, yeah, the humanoid robots is interesting.
38:31 Um, and it, it always… It just reminds me about, like, how hardwired we are, right? Like, that we're like- Absolutely … uh, those emotions get triggered, like- Even in the not very humanis- human realistic images. And so there were a bunch of products at, at CES again that were, like, designed to be cute, and they were … And it, it works. Like, just the sad, droopy eyes- Yeah … uh, like, gets you to bond with that, that product more, which is evil ingenious. Yeah, no. It, uh … Yeah, the, the, the eyes is, is what it's all about. I, you know, it … I have a dog, but I would imagine if I were to walk through a, a, uh, you know, an animal rescue, I would have 30 dogs. Yes. Because they would all look at me with those same big eyes that the robot did.
39:14 And yeah, uh, apparently I'm a incredibly soft touch when it comes to this stuff. It's good to know. Uh, the, the maybe near term version of the robots that, uh, in customer service that, that at least I, I believe is we're likely to see a lot more of this year is the chatbots for customer service. Mm-hmm. Um, and, you know, I, you, you, you can … I maybe expected to see a little bit more of that on the floor than I have, but certainly at, at like shop.org later in the year we'll see a ton of vendors showing new, new platforms for, for providing customer service via the text bots, which again, is a flavor of AI. Absolutely. Well, and that's something that we've been writing about, um, fairly consistently.
39:55 You know, it does seem, it, it does seem like there's more hype than substance around chatbots still at this point, but the, but it is progressing a little bit. Um, all the conversational commerce, chat commerce, whatever you wanna call it, that's, that's another thing that, that we've been following pretty closely. And, and I, and I do look at it as, as, as a form of AI simply in that, you know, I, I feel like, you know, as, as a, as a culture right now we're so laser focused on, on jobs and, you know, here, here comes this, this AI technology with the potential to not only transform retail, but any, any industry with a customer service component. And I, and I, I'm surprised that that isn't more of a, of a topic in the mainstream conversation in the, in, in, in, in, in the mainstream media.
40:44 Um, obviously it has, but I think, you know, Amazon Go was really the sort of the start of what do all these new innovations in retail mean for associates, for, for jobs as we move forward? Yeah, these things sound great as a frictionless experience for a consumer where you don't have to make chitchat with the person that's ringing up your groceries or whatever. But the, you know, I think the, the larger cost of that is, is currently lost on, on a lot of folks, and I think chatbots are part of that. And, and all the ma- and anything machine learning orientated, it's only going to eliminate jobs, which again, does seem to be at cross purposes with this, this move back slightly to, to brick and mortar.
41:25 And I don't know. I mean, I, I think this is a, a … There's an in … This is an industry with, with- An untold number of cool and compelling things, but I don't know that any of them really complement one another at the end of the day. Mm-hmm. So much of this seems to be working at cross purposes, and, and, uh, it's really tough to say how it's gonna shake out and what's gonna win and what's gonna lose here, but… The, the spin that I'm not sure I buy- Mm-hmm … but I, I appreciate the spin nonetheless, is like, "Hey, if we don't have to waste a bunch of money and time on associates being tied to the cash register and doing those perfunctory tasks, they can be more customer-centric and being, uh, assisting the customer more with the, the purchase decision making."
42:08 And so, like, the theory would be, "Oh my gosh, we need to invest more in associates and educate them more and hire more, 'cause that's one of the differentiating features we can have versus a, a giant pure play e-commerce site from, from Seattle," uh, on the one hand, and then on the other hand, like, we'll shift that labor from, you know, guys that used to have to work in the back and guys that used to have to work at the cash register. Uh, but I'm with you. The, the industry that puts on this show, NRF, like, that, you know, their talking point for the last several years has been, "We're super important because we're the number one jobs provider, um, in the economy." And, uh, you know, so, you know, this year the shift is like, "And that's a super valuable resource that we need to invest in and cultivate," and then, you know, two of the biggest news stories going, Amazon Go is gonna eliminate 6 million cashiers, and the autonomous v- all the autonomous vehicles at CES are gonna eliminate 10 million truck drivers, right?
43:06 Exactly. It doesn't add up at all. No. Amazon's gonna hire 100,000 people this year, so boom, we're okay. Yep. And I, I heard that Alibaba's gonna hire, like, a million. A million. Oh, yeah. Oh. Well- Yep … you know, I'm sure that's entirely authentic, just like everything on the Alibaba platform. I'm sensing a, a- … a, a smidgen of cynicalism, cynicism. Yeah, that… Yeah, no, that, that, that, all the, all the Jack Ma comments just seem inc- just puffery. I don't know. I, uh, there's, there's absolutely no way that, that anything like that will happen, and it's probably best that we don't steer down a, a, a more political road in this conversation, but yeah, uh, I don't believe that for, for a second.
43:53 Interesting. The, uh, so skirting that political line just a little bit more, like if you guys- Oh, God. Here's where I really get in trouble. No, no, no, no, no, no. But, like, uh, have you guys done … I haven't seen anything yet, any pieces on, like, how the new administration could affect retail. Uh, we, we have published those. Uh, Corinne has written a couple pieces on, uh, one, uh, uh, several weeks before the election, and then one that we published the morning after the election, if memory serves. And, uh, yeah, I mean, that's absolutely something that we will be tracking. And, uh, you know, again, I, I, I think we will, we will strive to always be I mean, we're, we're a news organization.
44:36 We're, we are going to be objective about it, and, but it's, it's absolutely imperative. And even with, with, you know, with Matthew, Matthew Shay coming out this morning and, and, and basically applauding the, the election of Trump because of the job creation promises and, and, you know, mentioning that… And, and I'm paraphrasing now, but this is the, the first retailer in the White House. It's a, a haberdasher from Kansas named Harry Truman. You know, I mean, we we, uh, it, it, it will be a, a, a big a- a- as big a part of our coverage as it needs to be. Um, you know, I think certainly probably more in the, in the early going, within the first 100 days, you know, as things start to In as much as this administration may ever be predictable, I, I think w- the, the, the, we'll focus more when, when the policies really start to evolve and, and, and the, the, the paths become clear.
45:34 But, um, I, I have to imagine that for the duration of the four years, that will be a topic that we cover, especially with the company itself being in DC. Yeah. Uh, so changing topics entirely, uh, one that Scott and I have been talking about a lot lately is grocery. Um, the… My, my premise is that, that grocery is a lot, uh, more digitally immature than some of these other categories, and that that's the big new battleground that we're gonna see this year, and that w- you know, uh, I don't think we'll ever see a, a true Amazon, Walmart head-to-head in sort of general merchandise, 'cause frankly I feel like that battle's already played out- Mm-hmm and, and, uh, won by Amazon.
46:20 But, but I think it's gonna be interesting to see these, you know, two of the most valuable companies in the world, uh, both fighting for a, a, a category that nobody's won yet. And then you've got, uh, I'll call them the dark horse, but you've got another huge company in Kroger that, like, you know, uh, isn't an incumbent, that in theory should have some important, uh, business to protect there. Absolutely. Well, and we published a feature a few weeks back that, that Daphne wrote, and she got some really great research talking about how really Walmart should not be fearful o- of Amazon or any other US retailer. It should… It's, uh, Lidl and Aldi that because they've, they've w- created so much havoc in Europe and, and, and really kicked Walmart's ass at grocery in, in, in, in, in, in, on the, on the European continent and, and in the UK.
47:14 They pose an enormous threat here. And, um- You know, that, that's definitely something that we're going to continue following as well. And, and, and, you know, to, to me, those brands are, are, as a consumer at least, they're, they're virtually unknown. I, I, I've, I'd never shopped in a, in an Aldi store in the US and, and obviously, uh, you know, there are no Lidl stores here, but, um, it does seem like they are very effective at capturing a similar customer base overseas and doing, doing what Walmart does, but doing it much better. Um, obviously this is a dramatically different market, and they are, they're virtual non-entities here by and large, but so was w- was Amazon 20 years ago.
48:01 And- We have one in North Carolina, oddly enough. I don't know why we, we have an Aldi. But, um, it's wildly popular. It's kind of like Trader Joe's, everything's their own brand. Okay. Um, and, uh, it's super busy, so it seems to be doing really well. Well, and, and I'm sure I will forget or, or get some of the details from that story wrong, but if I'm remembering correctly, the, it was two brothers that founded the companies and, and I think the company that… Uh, th- and then those brothers had a falling out. But then the, the, the company that owns Aldi also owns Trader Joe's in the US. Oh, okay. I didn't know that. So, so this- This is all Jason's area. He's the grocery guy. Is that, uh, is, is- Yeah … did I, did I get that right? Yeah, it's, it's basically the Nike Puma of grocery.
48:41 Okay. Uh, they're like two brothers with- Pu- Puma Adidas I'm sorry. Oh my gosh, yeah. Good. Thanks for the catching me there, Scott. The Puma Adidas of grocery. Uh, and Aldi, I think, under their own brand, does have, uh, is starting to have a footprint here, and they're, what, where they're being wildly successful is price competitiveness. Um- Exactly … and so if, uh, and that's super impressive, 'cause, you know, say what you want about Walmart, like they're an awesome operator, and they're, and they're terrific at taking costs out of the system. And then, you know, here are these guys who have come over from Europe, and you start to hear Walmart using words like instead of lowest price, we want to be a low price provider.
49:21 And that's like a nod to the fact that like, you know, they've sort of, kind of hit rock bottom in terms of taking costs out of, out of these systems. Absolutely. Now it's- I wish I had the feature at my disposal right now, 'cause it w- it's, it's really good. I would rec- I'd recommend anyone who's made it this far into the podcast to, to, to look up that feature on our website, 'cause I think there's a lot of really compelling information and insight in there. Uh, and we'll, uh, I'll find a link to it, and I'll put it in the show notes. Well, thank you. I appreciate that. I'd be happy to. Uh, for folks, in the unlikely event that anyone on our podcast isn't already getting the newsletter, it's retaildive.com, and- Correct … sign up at the top or bottom, I think, if memory serves.
50:05 Yes. And you guys have a good retail, I mean, uh, Twitter handle too. Yeah. That's just Retail Dive. Yeah. And, uh, and I'm on Twitter also, although I never tweet, so I don't know if there's any value in, in giving out my handle. But Corinne is a fairly active tweeter, so I'd recommend that you, uh, I think hers is @corinnesusan. Yep. Cool. I'll make sure that's in the show notes as well. And don't follow me. I'm a terrible follow. All right. We won't follow you. Thank you. Like eating on the way out of the building? You're probably an egg. You're an egg. Uh, I am an egg. Yeah. Yeah. It's, it's- Scott and I have a no egg policy. Yeah, I'm sorry. I'm just not a social media guy. When you told me you looked at my LinkedIn profile earlier, you could see it. Basically, it's a- Yeah, it was- It's a wasteland of non-information.
50:46 It was, yeah. You have no digital footprint? I, I, I'm trying to erase it, get off the grid as much as possible. Which doesn't help when you have a byline that gets published virtually every day in a newsletter. Yeah, good luck with that. I'm, I'm, I'm really not doing myself any favors in, in, in evaporating. Fair enough. Uh, and Jason, it'll shock no one that we've once again, uh, blown through our allotted time. So, uh, super appreciate you finishing your day here at the show with us. Well, thank you, guys. It was an absolute pleasure to be here. Yeah. Thanks, and thanks NRF for hosting us. Yep, and till next time, happy commerce-ing. You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes or visit www.jasonandscot.com.
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed