Welcome to The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News!
Jan. 24, 2017

EP066 - Scott Silverman Interview

EP066 - Scott Silverman Interview
EP066 - Scott Silverman Interview
The Jason & Scot Show - E-Commerce And Retail News
EP066 - Scott Silverman Interview

EP066 - Scott Silverman Interview

EP066 - Scott Silverman

Scott Silverman is a principal at Scott Silverman Associates and Scott is also co-founder of the Global Ecommerce Leaders Forum. On top of that, he also advises several startups in the e-commerce arena. Scott is one of the inventors of the term CyberMonday. Scott is also a former Executive Director and board member of shop.org.

Don't forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.

Episode 66 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded on Monday January 16th, 2017.

http://jasonandscot.com

Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.

0:02 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here are Jason and Scot Hey, welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. This episode is being recorded live from the NRF Big Show. We wanna thank the folks at NRF for hosting us. As usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Jason, and welcome Jason and Scott Show listeners. We have a really exciting guest on the show, the one, the only, Scott Silverman.

0:47 Scott has a storied career, that means he's been at this for a very long time, uh, in e-commerce over the last 15-plus years. He's currently a principal at Scott Silverman Associates, and he's also the co-founder of the Global Ecommerce Leaders Forum. On top of that, he also advises several startups in the e-commerce arena. He's had long stints at shop.org. He co-created Cyber Monday. Uh, and he's a Steelers fan, we're just learning here this morning. Welcome to the show, Scott. Thank you. I'm glad to be here. I, uh, one of the most exciting things about being on this show is I've been… I have this opportunity to say hi to one of your listeners, longtime listeners, Jeff Bezos. So I wanna say hi, Jeff. Hope you're enjoying this podcast.

1:28 Thanks. Yeah, he'll, uh, he's usually one of the first people to download, so you'll, you'll definitely get that message soon. And you guys need to talk really fast, 'cause I listen in one-and-a-half speed. So it's really weird to hear you guys talking so slowly. That's crazy, 'cause we do talk so fast that I actually have to slow the recording down to 75%, so we're balancing it out. There we go. Cool. Before we jump into it, let's set the stage here. We are in a, what could be best described as a podcast fishbowl in the middle of an innovation lab. Uh, within my eyesight I've got a robot arm, a, some kind of a robot that wanders around, uh, shelves. What's that one called, Jason? Uh, that's Trax. Trax. T-R-A-X. And, uh, it's pretty exciting. It's, uh, I think it really fits in with the vibe of our show.

2:09 We're right here in the middle of a curated, uh, innovation experience that NRF put together in the clubhouse. So, uh, I think it's really cool, and we're excited to be here. And what could be more innovative than the Jason and Scot Show podcast? I know. Look, um, and then, uh, let's back up a little bit. Last night, uh, you know, very excited for you and proud. You won a big award, and you were at a gala event. I did, yeah. Tell us about that. Well, I, I tend to do a gala about once a week. I know you're modest, so let's, let's hear the real story. Yeah. Uh, well, the NRF actually does this very cool thing every year. Um, they recognize 25, uh, influential people that have had a, a hopefully favorable effect on retail, and so they divide it into these categories: the power brokers, the givers, the innovators.

2:52 Uh, and I was very honored to be, uh, one of the influencers that was recognized on the NRF The List. I heard there's a backstory. They had, uh, one of the folks dropped out, uh, and you were next on the list, so that was, uh, that was good that you- I, I think that's true. And he, I think he's gonna be a guest, uh, later today. So, uh, make sure you tune in for that podcast. Just kidding. But- And I was super proud of you, 'cause all the show, you know, they were putting up those pictures, and it was very red carpet-y, and everyone was black tie. Boom, there was Jason not wearing a tie. So it was total maverick-y, so I was, I was very impressed by that. I thought that was gonna slide under the radar screen until To- uh, till, till Scott used his big, uh, social media presence to out me. Um, but it was, it was, like, me and the CEO of Nike were the two guys without ties.

3:34 I just wanna find out what your wife's gonna say, 'cause my wife always… Like, if I can, if my wife doesn't find out, I'm good. Or maybe your mom. Your mom listens to the podcast, so you could be, yeah. So my wife wouldn't- This could be very dangerous … have found out had you not just outed me. Cool. So you're on a roll this year, 'cause you won the predictions as I was listening earlier this week. Uh, like, and I, I, to take nothing away, I'm very proud of the NRF, uh, recognition. I'm, I'm very grateful and, uh, probably undeserving. But I'm, I'm m- even more proud to have narrowly edged out Scot Wingo, um, in the voting. Although I have, a number of listener comments have disputed our scoring, so. Oh, really? Hmm. I haven't, I haven't seen those. Uh, okay, cool. Scott, we're excited to have you on here.

4:14 Let's, let's start by just going a little background for the folks that don't know you. How did you get into e-commerce or even retail? And let's go back to college. What'd you study, and how did you get to where you are today? Uh, so, uh, I am a Pittsburgher. That's hence the being a Steelers fan. Uh, I grew up there and went to University of Pittsburgh. Uh, had a degree in political science, which as, like as we hear from many of your guests, lots of zigging and zagging into this industry. Um, I had this theory of just study what you find interesting and passionate about, and then figure out what you wanna do. Um, it-- I figured out that I wanted to be in PR, so I, uh, moved to Washington, DC.

4:55 I actually had an internship in the White House, um, under the George Bush the First. Mm-hmm. Uh, and then moved into a couple trade associations in the telecommunications industry, worked for some PR firms, um, including one called FleishmanHillard on, uh… And most interestingly there, it was on the AOL account. These are the early days of them sending out CDs and, uh, from there I Saw an ad in, you may recall, the Industry Standard, the old magazine of the internet, for NRF having a director of internet retailing. And I thought that sounded really cool, so I applied.

5:35 This was in 1999. Uh, I- You, you probably knew about the NRF 'cause they're pretty big in Washington, right? Yeah, pretty big in r- It's, it's kind of in lobbying and PR circles they're pretty well-known. I think everyone else in the internet was making so much money, they didn't have any interest in the job, so they took me. And it was the beginning of my career in e-commerce and retail. I haven't looked back. And I love the industry, I love the people in the industry, and I'm still having a great time. Feel very fortunate to be in this part of the economy. Cool. Well, we won't spend a lot of time on kinda that, that, that segment there in the early days of e-commerce. But before we go there, let's kinda talk about what do you do today. Like, so, um, you know, you've, you know everyone in e-commerce and everything, and, and, uh, you're leveraging that some cool ways.

6:17 Tell us, tell us about what Scott Silverman Associates is up to. So broadly I describe myself as a digital retail connector. And, um, what that means is that I put together different gatherings of e-commerce leaders. I have a few different businesses that are tied into that. Uh, I started and run two conferences, um, with two different sets of partners. One is focused on cross border and international e-commerce called the Global Ecommerce Leaders Forum, and we do that two times a year. I do that with, uh, my partners are Jim Okamura and Ken Allen. Uh, the next one is February 9th here in New York.

6:57 Okay. Uh-huh. Uh, and then we do one in LA in the fall. And then I have- These are more boutiquey, right? So 500 to 1,000 kind of people? L- Little bit smaller than that. Okay. More like 300, 350. Okay, good. It's been growing. But it's a, it's an exciting part of the industry. Uh, very complicated. I mean, it, m- my reason for going into that particular topic is it's one where if you go to a lot of conferences, you'll see one or two sessions, high level, um, help you make the decision of, should I go into international? Should I sell in China, Mexico, wherever? But when you start getting into the details of how do I localize payments, um, do I tr- do translations in this country or not, um- Who's gonna sit on WeChat 24/7 and answer questions about my products?

7:42 Right. Exactly. So- Stuff like that, that really matters … uh, so I like finding these, uh, topics that I think are underrepresented in the, you know, broader, uh, industry in terms of conferences. And the other one that I'm doing is called Grow Commerce. That's at the end of July in New York. I'll be, uh, going into the third year of that, and that's focused on e-commerce customer acquisition and growth. So both conferences I'm, uh, excited to be a part of, and they're a lot of fun to, uh, find speakers and, uh, and to produce those. And as your kind of role as Pollinator in the e-commerce world, you do… I, I've, I know some folks you've helped kind of place in other places, and you have, you typically have a really good idea of, like, who's hiring what kind of role, and you, you've kind of facilitated some of that in the past as well.

8:25 Yep. I've dabbled a little bit in recruiting, and I, you know, anyone that wants to reach out to me that's either looking for a new role or trying to fill someone, I just try to be helpful. I, I don't do it professionally. Uh, I mean, I dabbled in that a little bit but stopped doing that because I got busy in all the other things that I'm doing. But I kinda have an open door as if anyone wants help, just let me know and I'm, I'm happy to make some introductions. Nice. That's a total first world problem. Um, so we alluded to at the beginning of the show the origins of shop.org, and I, I know you were there. So maybe you could tell our listeners a little bit more about how shop.org came to be and what the i- initial sort of objective was.

9:06 Yeah, the… It's fun to tell the story because I think a lot of people don't, uh, realize what happened in the early days. So shop.org started in 1996 as an independent organization. They were being run by an association management company. They had a vibrant organization, conferences, board of directors, and so on. Um, over time, they decided that they wanted to get associated with a larger trade association, and they actually put out an RFP to be acquired. And I, at the time, was, uh, had started at NRF in 1999. I, I mentioned earlier this position of director of internet retailing.

9:46 Um, and I created the poorly named, um, Internet Retailing Advisory Council, or IRAC, uh- which I, uh, still get, um, people giving me a hard time about that to this day. It's better than ISIS. Like, I always feel bad for that, uh, that payment company that was ISIS before ISIS- Yeah … and had to rename themselves. That's a good comeback. I, I will keep that in mind. Yeah. So, uh, I had created this community of internet retailing executives from the NRF membership, and we had our very first meeting, I think it was in like May of 1999. Uh, one of your past guests, David Belotky, at the… when he was still at Goldman Sachs, was our guest speaker. He came in and presented his point of view from Goldman Sachs on, uh, on internet and, and the impact it's gonna have on retail.

10:31 Um, and then I, I was actually listening to his podcast, and it sounds like he was pretty far along in starting Uncommon Goods even when he was there. I had no idea at the time. So this community started building, and eventually, uh, NRF, uh, uh, applied or, you know, participated in the RFP. The shop.org board at the time agreed to be acquired by NRF. And so everything that I had been doing under IRAC got combined with what shop.org was doing. We called it the new shop.org within NRF, NRF's digital division. And then I, um, within a little bit of time, began running that organization.

11:14 Um, it was a- So that was 2001, 2002? Uh, this was in like January of 2001. Yeah. Um, you know, greatly timed with the dot-com collapse. Yeah. So, um, within about three months, we lost, I think, half of our members. and had a pretty pets.com tough time. And the other thing, uh, that's interesting, uh, one of the challenges that we had to overcome was the very first annual summit for shop.org was scheduled for September 11th, 2001. So that one obviously never happened. Uh, the first one happened in 2012. But between what happened with the economy from 9/11 and the dot-com collapse, uh, we were just crawling and scratching to rebuild the organization.

11:59 You didn't really have the omni-channel guys bought in either, right? So it was really the pure plays at that point mostly. There was a couple omni-channel guys dabbling, but it was really mostly the pure plays, right? They were-- The, the, the omni-channel folks like telling the story of how they were, uh, uh, in an office in the basement, uh, with, you know, very, very few resources. Nobody believed in the internet at the time. Um, that's one of the things that really drew me to the industry is this, uh, uh, underdog, um, kinda mentality within e-commerce. And especially around the omni-channel folks, that they were always the true believers that this was gonna be a huge business opportunity, but they were constantly fighting for resources and to get respect within the industry.

12:43 So it's great to see, like at a show like NRF, where digital is such a prominent topic now. I mean, it took a long time, but I really, uh, uh, just kind of believed in that, and that, that really was fuel for me to be around those underdogs. Like that, that's a, a great theme is that these things that seem so obvious in hindsight and are so easy to look back and go, "Oh, well of course that's how it was gonna evolve," are anything but obvious when you're, you're living through them. Um, and another one of those things I sort of associate with you is today we all take for granted that, you know, the day after Thanksgiving would be this, this huge shopping day.

13:25 And, you know, I think Cyber Monday is a super recognized, uh, term and event in popular culture. Uh, but that wasn't true back then, was it? No. So o- one of the things we had been doing for a while was research on the industry. And we would do some consumer research, and we would survey the members. And we began seeing this trend of a big surge in shopping the Monday after Thanksgiving. Uh, at the time, I was working closely with Ellen Davis, who was running PR for NRF. She was such an amazing partner, uh, for shop.org. She's, uh, continued with NRF and is doing some amazing things with their foundation and, and then some other areas.

14:07 But, um, we always had this really strong PR machine, thanks to Ellen, and we never imagined that Cyber Monday was going to be as big as it was. So we issued a press release about a week before, uh, the Monday after Thanksgiving, and I think it was 2005. The Wall Street Journal picked it up, and from there it snowballed. And the next thing you knew, um, I'm watching The Daily Show and they're doing a bit on Cyber Monday. Uh, and it was on every late night TV show. And of course, at the time, retailers had no idea it was coming, so they never, they couldn't prepare, uh, do anything like that. And the other thing that happened was I did have the foresight to, uh, to register cybermonday.com.

14:55 And, um, the The outcome of cybermonday.com, I think is the thing that I'm most proud of, of my time at shop.org, and we can go into that in a little bit. I can talk more… I mean, Cyber Monday overall was, it was always fun. Um, again, getting to this underdog, uh, kind of mentality. I was constantly fighting, you know, whether it was with Business Week, Comscore. I think, uh, Amazon's head of PR that, you know, in the early days was resisting this, and nobody wanted to believe it. They, everybody wanted to make their own mark by kinda taking Cyber Monday down a notch. And now, of course, it's continues to be the biggest shopping day. It maybe it won't be, maybe that'll, um, go away, um, I don't know, next year, but, you know, over the next three or four years.

15:40 But it was a lot of fun. I, I mean, I, I enjoyed the fight with that. When you, when you guys put out that first press release, what, were you reacting to data you saw where you could s- you were hearing from your members that that Monday was big, and you just decided let's name that? Or did you decide- That's- … let's name something and hope it's big? Which, which kinda- No, that was exactly it was it the chicken or egg? We, we th- there was, there wa- th it was already happening, and at the time there were a few factors. One was that, uh, people would go into their office because at the, you know, then, back then in 2005, uh, wi- Wi-Fi wasn't, or high-speed internet wasn't as prevalent in people's homes. So it was, you had better Wi-Fi or, uh, connectivity in your office, so a lot of people would wanna go into their office and shop.

16:25 The other thing, and this, uh, you know, uh, uh, applies still today, is it's nice to shop in your office when you don't have, you know, loved ones around you looking over your shoulder and when you're trying to surprise them with a gift And bosses love it. Yes. Well, but that- … that's just one of several days, like with March Madness, that you just, you know- Yeah … have to write off productivity. Yeah. Um, it's for a good cause, Scott. Uh, absolutely. The, uh, I'm curious, was the name, like, did you put a lot of thought into that? And was there debate and brainstorming, or was it sort of one of those things that just came up and you didn't think about it that much, and now it's- We tossed around some different names, like Blue Monday, I think, for the, uh, hyperlink color. Kmart guys would've loved that.

17:05 Yeah. Uh, it was, I think, Green Monday. Uh, a- and we came up with Cyber Monday. Information Superhighway Monday? Just checking. I, I think it was probably- That's what that theory's called, right? Bill Gates proposal. Yeah. It was probably the weirdest name bec- uh, it was kind of an outdated name, but I think it ended up sticking. It, it, it, it's … I think because it was a little odd, it had some staying power, and w- I don't know. You know, it is, it, it, it, it turned into this big thing, and I, I don't know exactly why, but I'm happy it did. Nice. Uh, and, uh, you know, there's … It's … Not all the listeners know, but, uh, we al- always have a second guest booked on this show for the second hour, and just unfortunately, so far, we've always ran out of time, so Jeff Bezos has never made it on our show.

17:48 Um, but, uh, if I'm recalling correctly, he was a early speaker at shop.org. He was. Uh, this was in… I was looking it up before I, um, came on. I think it was 2006. Uh, at the time, uh, our ch- the chairman of shop.org was Elaine Rubin, uh, who probably a lot of your listeners know her. Um, she had been chairman of, uh, shop.org for a number of years. Shout out to Elaine. Woo-hoo. She- Way to get her on the show … yes, and, uh, one of her, you know, one of the roles that she had in the industry was running enterprise sales for Amazon. This is when they were actively trying to convince retailers to use Amazon's technology to power their e-commerce sites like they were doing with Barnes & Noble and Target and all the other companies that end up suing Amazon, uh, you know, later down the road.

18:43 And because he had a sales pitch, he was willing to come to shop.org and talk to us. I honestly can't remember. I think it was a sales pitch, but I don't remember him making any kind of bold predictions or doing anything. But it was just cool to have him there. Cool. Um, so you hinted that there was another outcome of, of Sh- uh, Cyber Monday. Tell us a little bit about that. Yeah. So we, a- as I'm, as I mentioned, I registered cybermonday.com, and we didn't know what we were gonna do with it. Uh, I had a very unfortunate thing happen. One of my coworkers, Ray Greenley, who was the VP of Membership and Research, passed away from lung cancer in 2005, I believe it was, in the fall.

19:27 And we attempted to raise money to create a scholarship fund in his name, and went through the traditional methods of going to members and other people and asking them to make donations, and we collected some money. And, you know, I was very grateful for the people that donated that. But then we had this idea of maybe cybermonday.com will get a lot of traffic, and what if we create a website where all of this traffic can go, and we can make some money from it? So we partnered with a company, uh, it's now called Cartera Commerce. Uh, they built the website. It's bas- basically an affiliate site, so all of the members were putting their deals on cybermonday.com.

20:11 We were getting a lot of press continuously from the effort that we had already, and sometimes they were direct mentions of cybermonday.com. And I think in the first year, our cut of the affiliate commissions was something like $350,000. And I remember being in a Shop.org board meeting proposing this and getting, like, a, some, you know, grumpy responses like, "Oh, back of the envelope, this is never gonna work." But we decided to do it anyway, and I think they've raised over $3 million for the Ray Greenley Scholarship Fund. So it's, uh, awesome to have it in Ray's name. Uh, I think hi- it makes his family really proud.

20:52 I think it's a great thing for Shop.org to have such a strong, uh, organization that is donating money to students that are pursuing careers in e-commerce. And it's makes me so proud when I, uh, am at the Shop.org annual summit, or I guess it's NRF's Digital Show, uh, is what it's called now, and they always have the finalists for the Ray Greenley Scholarship. And now they're giving, I think, uh, maybe one or two people a year are getting, um, upwards of $25,000 in tuition assistance. So that makes me so proud, and, uh, I'm, I'm really excited about that. Yeah. It's, uh, I don't know about Jason, but I've spoken to some of those kids before and, and, uh, they're really amazing.

21:34 It's always, you know, everyone gives these millennials this bad rap that they're slackers and live in their parents' basement and stuff, and you meet some of these kids that are getting these scholarships, and man, they are go-getters, and they're all just kinda like, you know, they LinkedIn you five seconds after you meet them, and they're trying to meet this person and that person. They're just really a impressive set of new folks coming into the industry. I think, here's an idea for Shop.org, is- It's been a number of years since we've had these, uh, students. There-- Many of them are in the workplace now. We-- There should be a whole panel discussion at one of the events where you have former scholarship winners Talking about what they're doing in the industry. So I think, I think there's, there's even more that could be done with that. That's a, that's a terrific idea. I, I've been lucky enough to be a judge the last few years.

22:17 Um, and the, you know, all the kids put together these elaborate, um, submission packets. And often there's a, uh, part of the exercise is to do a mock proposal for a retailer. Uh, and I'll frequently see proposals that I could easily take to th- that retailer and that would be well received. I mean, it's amazing. Have you ever done that before? Just put Jason on there, scratch out. No. Yeah. Not as far- Sarah, put Jason … as anyone knows. Here, Walmart, here's my proposal. Exactly. I think they would know because it would be much more creative than my proposals usually are. It would, I'd kind of out me. Like, wow, Jason's stepping up his game. Exactly. I, I, I got influencer, not innovator, Scott. Okay. All right. Sorry. Yeah. Yeah.

22:57 So tell us some more stories from that k- the kinda golden ages of SHOP.org. What are some things that, that stick in your mind? I mean, I, I just remember overcoming some of the challenges. So, um, you know, i- in addition to the period after 9/11 and the dot com explosion, then we had a period where, uh, there was the Great Recession. I, it was like 2008, 2009. And, um, y- I'm just so proud of the, the team at SHOP.org and NRF, um, and the brand that the organization became. Because it, it, there was such a legal, a loyal following to SHOP.org, and it finally paid off.

23:37 So when we saw in 2000-whatever, the recession was at its worst, and every conference was down on attendance except SHOP.org, which was up. And I think that was a testament to the, um, the leadership, uh, within the board of directors, the loyalty, the way that they support the organization. So that, that was, um, you know, some- something that I'll, I'll never forget. One of the things I think that's also unique is the Digital Summit travels around. You know, most shows go and they'll just like anchor somewhere. So like internet retailer's been at Chicago since I think day one. Um, you know, Shoptalk's anchored around Las Vegas. But one of the things that's interesting, Digital Summit kinda travels around. What, what was the original… Do you remember the, were you involved in the thinking around that?

24:20 Was that a conscious decision, or it was just like- So it- … "Oh, my God, we need to plan next year's show. Where are we gonna be?" S- s- selecting cities for conferences is, uh, it, it is always challenging because there are a ton of opinions. It's really hard to… Like, I, there's very little data that you can look at that's gonna predict whether the, that particular city's gonna be really good or not, and there's always an argument for having it in the same city year after year. We had been in Las Vegas for a number of years and of course people get tired of Las Vegas. Some people hate Las Vegas. And so we started looking at some different areas, and w- beginning with where there were concentration of retailers or- You know, certain criteria you have to have, an airport that's easy to fly into.

25:05 And I think the first time after Vegas was we were in Dallas. And another Steelers shout-out, uh, and a shout-out to my friend Tom Giacalone from Vera Bradley. He brought a Terrible Towel with me. We had our big evening event in, I, I guess it's now called AT&T Stadium. Mm-hmm. Uh, so I got to wave my Terrible Towel in the middle of the field in the, among Dallas. They really should have never let, let me do that. But, um, thanks to Tom Giacom- Giacamoli, I was able to do that. Yeah, I remember that. That was, like, the one of the best corporate events I've ever been to. Everyone, you know, we could kick field goals, the cheerleaders. It was, like, really cool. Attempted to kick field goals. Yeah. I, I don't, I didn't get any through. Yeah, that was definitely my favorite corporate event, 'cause I met my wife at that event.

25:46 That's- Ah … that's where, where we first met. Uh, and I did kick a field goal and had a groin pull for about six months after that, I think. Was it good? Uh, the field goal? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah, not the groin pull. Yeah. No. The groin pull sucked. The field goal, uh- The time he met his wife, he was laying on the ground. Yeah. "Oh, I'm dying." We, uh- "Can I help you, sir?" We- Yeah. Well, in, in fairness, I, I played a lot of soccer, uh, going in, so it wasn't, it wasn't shocking. And thankfully, uh, we have a saying, "There's no pictures in the scorecard." It wasn't, it wasn't pretty, uh, but it went through the uprights. Um, and I, I do recall, uh, the Steeler fans defiling the star. Um, but I… Almost more funny, there were a bunch of Redskin fans, and it, to me, it's just funny that there are Redskin fans.

26:27 Right. Um, but they smuggled jerseys in, and I remember a bunch of them putting on their jersey and surrounding the star and taking a, a, a picture while they were mocking, uh, you know, probably an inappropriate act on the star. And I, like, if I were Dallas, I would, I would, uh, never let, let fan, uh, opposing fans on my field ever again. Well, Jerry Jones makes money from it, so that's, he's probably willing to overlook that. Exactly. Yeah. Cool. So, um, so you've, you've had this long, storied career, and you're still very involved in the industry, and you're, you're, you're, you know, you spend a lot of time thinking about cross-border trade and stuff like that. What are some of the trends, and you're an avid Jason and Scot listener, uh, so what are some of the trends that you think are, are most interesting that are top of mind with retailers?

27:13 Let's just, like, keep it the timeframe right now that's just current. Like, what are… What's top priorities in 2017 for a lot of the retailers you talk to? Yeah, so one of the other things that I do that I should mention for context of providing a couple, uh, ideas on that is I have a business where I get hired by e-commerce software companies, and I h- host dinners with, say, 15 or so people. I do about four of these, uh, a year in all the major US cities. So I'm hearing… I'm in these conversations constantly with retailers. So, um, there are a few topics that are very popular. I mean, Amazon, uh, is the number one topic that gets people both excited and agitated.

27:56 Um, the, the how do you compete with them? Where do you compete with them? Uh, that, y- you know, I, I think everybody has a little bit of a different take on that. I think everybody, uh, is looking at things like customer experience, uh, or the idea of let's go where Amazon is not and, uh, take an approach like that. But yeah, that, that's a, a topic that, uh, never gets old. Uh, people are always eager to talk about that. What's the Scott Silverman advice? So if a, let's say, a multi-brand retailer like a Macy's, but not specifically, comes to you and says, "Scott, what should we do about Amazon?" What's your… What's, what's your sage advice? I mean, it, it's stuff that you guys have talked about.

28:37 Um, you're not gonna compete with them on convenience and price. I think the private… If you're a retailer selling third-party products, then find a way to get private label products in there, uh, or be a brand. Uh, and I think that's one of the best ways that you're gonna not have to feel the effects of Amazon as much as a traditional retailer that's selling products. And I, I think, uh, the other part would be, uh, service and leverage your expertise. So if you have a, uh, if you're a store-based retailer, you have an army of associates, and put them to work for you, uh, in some way to deliver that expertise that, um, that Amazon isn't able to do because they wanna automate everything.

29:23 Got it. Cool. What else? Uh, omni-channel. So, uh, I think that continues to be a topic. It was interesting Um, listening to your predictions show, and I think, Jason, you were mentioning attribution, um, being an iss- being a t- uh, like, one of your predictions that they're gonna figure out attribution. And it's, uh, one of the very first things I did, even bef- w- at, at NRF even before the ShopDotOrg acquisition is we did the very first research that demonstrated the impact that online was having on offline when we actually took, uh, hired a survey company to be, to go in front of stores as people walked out and ask them, "Did you look at this product online before you made your purchase?"

30:10 And we had the first set of data to estab- like, establish what everybody knew already. But that was 1999, and this is 2017, and you're finally predicting that they're gonna figure out attribution. And I'm nervous about the prediction. I, I mean, it, it's just I think everybody knows that it's happening. Um, nobody has a, the, the, the, the final number on, like, how much, where do I think about my investments in this area to make it, to, to, to kinda follow along with the, what the actual consumer behavior is. So that one, it just doesn't get old. And, uh, it, it's an, always an interesting topic.

30:50 The … My other thought on omnichannel is I'm a big fan of the basics. The things that I see moving the needle the most are things like inventory, visibility, uh, when you … ways to optimize ship from store by, you know, tools that may help you, um, lower safety thresholds, expose more inventory, things that are, um, helping with returns, preventing returns. I see those have the big, the, the, the biggest immediate impact, um, on, on this topic of omnichannel. And, and om- omnichannel's a funny thing. I mean, I, I think at the core of it, it's really about inventory visibility. I mean, uh, if you were to take everything away, there's all these multi-touch point, you know, experiences.

31:35 But I think, you know, if, if you can't figure out the inventory part of it, you're really not doing omnichannel. Yeah, no, I, I totally agree. And it's, it, it's funny, I, we were talking with some analysts about that this week. Um, when omnichannel first be- started becoming a buzzword, like all, all of these thought leaders like quickly put together these checklists. Like what are the omnichannel experiences? And there were, there were all these scorecards like which retailer checked the most boxes? And it was like buy online, pick up in store, buy online, ship to store, all, all these different experiences. And they'd, you know, they'd come out and it would be like Sears and Best Buy are the omnichannel leaders and, you know, so and so is a, a laggard or whatever.

32:17 Um, and the reality is like those scorecards always focus exclusively on the customer experience and never those fundamental things like just simply unlocking inventory and making it available everywhere. So often, you know, re- retailers got sort of credit in the press for doing superficial omnichannel rather than like really making the organizational changes necessary to embrace it. So omnichannel is a good jump-off point. We, we talk a lot about Mallageddon, you know, which is this … And, and here we are in January at NRF, and there's been probably more store closures announced than, uh … And I think The Limited just closed s- you know, a couple hundred stores. Um, what do you think about that, having kinda watched this?

32:59 Does it feel like it's accelerating and we're kind of, we're gonna see this mass exodus of, of traditional retail? And, um, you know, we … One, one thing that causes is malls. You know, if you ha- you're a mall and you have a couple of these anchor tenants that are in trouble, then that whole mall … You know, I've seen reports that up to 20, 30% of some malls are, are at risk. Uh, what's your view from kinda the front lines on that? I … Well, maybe we can cut this out. I, I, I don't have much of a point of view on the malls. So, um- Yeah. But you live in New Jersey. You're like- I live in- … in the home of malls Well, I live in New Jersey- You got Garden State … and, uh, when I go to Short Hills Mall, I mean, it's one of the It's an A mall. It's probably one of the, like, probably the most lucrative malls in the country. It's amazing. Yeah. Um, but I avoid going there 'cause I don't wanna deal with the parking.

33:40 Yeah. Um, and it's, it's every luxury brand. So I'm, I'm, I d- I'm not in the habit of spending $400 for a T-shirt, so- Um, I mean, maybe I'll go in there and get a cup of coffee at Starbucks, but- Yeah generally, I'm, I'm trying to buy everything online, but … I imagine, uh, in the early days of digital commerce, uh, there were, there was a lot of conversation around like, "Oh, is this putting retail out of business?" It was sort of a either/or sort of, uh, thing. And obviously we're, it seems like we're still having those kind of conversations together. Um, in your mind back then, was, was digital commerce something that was gonna replace retail or something that was gonna augment it?

34:21 And I'd be curious if your, uh, perspective has changed over the last 15 years. Uh, I … My perspective really hasn't changed. I think it's always been about augmenting it. Uh, I think the digital You know, I was always a, a believer that it was gonna grow and have a huge impact on the store experience, every part of, of retail. I think the argument that, that was incorrect was the either/or. Like, it's either gonna be the pure plays are gonna take over the world, or the store-based retailers are gonna win. You know, it was a fight of that. And I think where we're seeing things play out is the, uh, the omnichannel retailers are continuing to up their game, invest more in digital.

35:09 And I mean, how many, you know, millennials are thinking about pure play versus omnichannel? They're just thinking about, "What is a good experience? Who has the product that I want the most? Where do I go and get it? What's the easiest way to get it?" So- I, I, I think that's always been, like, product and, uh, the passion around product is the one thing about retail that's never changed, and it's always there. Well, I totally appreciate that, 'cause I'm always the, it's, it's both, and, and, uh, Scott is, of course, like, uh, "Digital's gonna crush retail." And I was sort of worried two Scotts against one Jason that I might be outnumbered, but I'm, I'm glad to see you're on the, on the winning team. Well, it's… I think it's interesting to see how- A lot of the early e-commerce companies or the, the e-commerce startups, they, they all seem to grow really quickly at first.

36:02 They get to, say, 100 million in revenue, and then they have a really hard time getting past that and scaling. So you see, uh, like, Nasty Gal file- filing for bankruptcy and other companies, uh, in the same vein having that challenge. And I-- You know, you look at these omni-channel retailers, many of them are north of a billion in revenue, and there's a huge gap between these startups and there. And when you hear all of the hype about the startups that are gonna be taking over, I mean, aside from Amazon, maybe Wayfair, and a few others, um, they haven't been taking over. And I, you know, I, I think, yes, they're all struggling, and you talked about many of them being at death's door, but they have scale.

36:48 And that says-- that's, that's huge that they have accomplished that, and it's something that many of these other startup retailers haven't quite been able to get to that point. And will they ever? And then the question is, are we in a new era where, you know, there are not billion-dollar, you know, retailers being born every day? Is it a whole sea of small niche retailers? There's a, uh, a VC, uh, Lawrence Lanahan, he used to be at FirstMark, and now he has a new company called Resonance where he's incubating these small apparel companies, and he wrote a blog post that I think was really interesting, this was three or four years ago, saying the days of the billion-dollar brand are over.

37:32 And you look at a company like Lululemon kind of being the last big brand to come out of there. And from there, you have all of these niche brands. So you look at, like, a company like Lululemon, and now there's four or five companies that are making products in their particular category, but that's all-- th- like, in a particular narrow area, and that's all they're making. But you can only grow so big that way. But I, I, I think it's interesting to think about, is that the shape of things to come or, you know, or will we not have these behemoths besides Amazon or not? So super fragmented little mini brands instead- Right … of, like, the big giants.

38:13 Interesting. Let's, um, so it's the ten-year anniversary of the iPhone. Happy, happy ten-year birthday, iPhone. Um, so let's see. You were probably still at shop.org when it came out, uh, so '07, yes. Um, ha- you know, we're clearly in this kind of point where mobile is, is, you know, everyone agrees it's material for, you know, for almost all retailers, it's over half the traffic. Some are approaching half the transactions. Did that happen faster than you thought it would or slower? 'Cause I remember flip phones, people were like, "Oh my God, we're gonna buy stuff this way." And you had to go, you know, you had to hit, to type in something, you had to hit, if you wanna hit C, you had to do, like, the one key three times and then wait, and Well, I mean, I don't think I'm different than anyone else.

38:53 I mean, it happened faster than everybody imagined, and, uh, that's probably the second most popular topic that comes up at the dinners that I do, is the angst around mobile. And I, I don't envy any retailer, um, for, for what they have to deal with with mobile. The investment that they have to make in yet another customer experience with being blind to, uh, the, uh, uh, the particular impact of it. How much of the mobile experience is driving a transaction or not? And there's still so little data, uh, available to the retailers, yet they're forced to make these investments in the mobile experiences.

39:38 And then even within the mobile experience, are you optimizing for a transaction? Are you optimizing for, uh, like augmenting the store experience or some other use case within mobile? And when it's the small little device, I mean, how many, like optim- like optimized use cases can you have on that particular device or app? It's, I, again, I, like I said, I don't envy the retailers for what they have to do there. So I'm, I'm happy to sit on the sidelines and, uh, and listen and hear what they're doing with that. Yeah. Um, and that, that one is funny 'cause it, it keeps evolving, right? Like the, you, uh, retailers will sort of catch up to so- you know, some sort of perceived benchmark, and then the, the industry keeps moving the finish line on that one.

40:27 And it's, uh … Scott and I have spent hours on this show talking about the, the mobile gap and the challenge in conversion on mobile devices versus, uh, tablets and desktops. But one that's coming up more for me, which is interesting, is this whole, uh, digital is a much more closed loop for refinement. So we build a website, we test something. Uh, if it works, we deploy it. If it doesn't work, we iterate it really fast, and we have, to your point, great analytics. Um, and so we've really improved these digital experiences quickly. It's much harder to improve a store experience. Um, and so now we've taught customers that there are these super important things when you're shopping, like ratings and reviews.

41:11 Nobody has ratings and reviews in the store. And so this new version of mobile I'm talking a lot with retailers about is, uh, gosh, how do we create a digital experience in the store? And of course, stores are all over-stored, so they're closing stores. They don't have big CapEx budgets, so we're not putting a lot of screens and technology in the store. And what that leaves is, man, we gotta get the customer using that mobile device in the store for a very different experience than they would use it for at home, which, which, you know, I think is interesting. Yeah, I have a fun story. I was at Target yesterday, and I had to change lines 'cause the lady in front of me was trying to Cartwheel her stuff. And, you know, you go in these Targets, and they push Cartwheel, and there's no connectivity. And the Wi-Fi was, you know, she couldn't figure that out, and it was just like a total train wreck.

41:54 So some of these things sound really good until you're in practice, and the lady's taking 30 minutes to connect her Cartwheel. I, I, I think that, A, what part of that story was fun? I mean, the, the biggest, uh, uh, uh, you know, one of the biggest things I think that doesn't get invested enough when it comes to mobile or omnichannel is people. And because it's the store associates that you are, that retailers are depending on to execute the, all of their strategies. So you, you could invest, you know, millions and millions of dollars in an app or something that's engaging people in the store. Maybe it's showing them reviews. But if the, the people working in the stores are not embracing it in, in a material way, then these things are all gonna fall flat That's actually, uh, uh, one of the big themes that, uh, I've seen at this show this year.

42:44 Uh, the first day was totally dedicated to that employee training and the value of that. And I know, uh, like Kip, uh, Kindle, the, uh, current, current chair of the NRF board was talking about how they've done these, these analytics, and the average retailer invests eight hours of training in an associate, and his company invests 240 hours. Um- It's Container Store is his company. Oh, gosh, sorry. Um, and, uh, Walmart, uh, Greg Foran, the president of Walmart US was here, and he, you know, they famously- Right … jacked up their, their, um, hourly wage for associates. But they also made a major new investment in training, and he was sharing that they had a total measurable improvement in all the store KPIs, their, their fast, easy, friendly KPIs after they, they improved that, that associate training.

43:32 So what you should, uh, add, re-edit your predictions and someone should add that. Like, 'cause I think that's gonna be really shaping the industry is, like that's where maybe a lot of the investment that's gonna pay off the most in omni-channel is investments in salary and training for the store associates to bring these omni-channel plans to life in a way that they haven't been able to. Can't re-edit the, uh, annual forecast. Yeah, no editing on that one. Okay. It's set in stone. I gotta keep an eye on Jason on that. Yeah. And the, of course, tens of thousands of listeners have already heard it and weighed in, so it'd be hard to change at this point. Yes. Yeah. So that's a good thing. So you've been here at NRF for a bit. Tell us, so it sounds like the associate training and that kind of stuff's important, what else are you seeing here at the show?

44:16 Uh, I, you know, it, it's a, it's a weird thing, i- to be at the show this year because we're, there's so much disruption happening in the industry. Um, we're seeing, uh, it, th- you know, this, this dichotomy of, uh, retailers that are, you know, shutting down or going bankrupt, and then you have the optimism of digital, and it's all kind of in the same place. And when you see the cross-section of that or the intersection of that is in things like these ideas to spend more on training or change management or, you know, your team overall. So I, I think that's a really interesting trend.

44:58 I mean, there's also … I mean, there's a lot of shiny objects, um, especially in this innovation lab, um, that we're in. Uh, so it's gonna be interesting to see. And I see the retailers engaged in w- whether it's AI or chatbots or things. So they, um, are interested in investing in these. How those are gonna pay off in the near term, I, I'm not sure. But, um, I, I think it's, uh, a, an interesting thing to watch that play out. Cool. Cool, that's a good jumping-off point. So we've been talking about kinda current trends. Let's, let's kinda fast-forward and whatever timeframe you're comfortable with, three, five, 10, 50 years into the future, what, what are some of Scott Silverman's predictions for, for what retail will look like and, um, you know, how fast things are gonna change?

45:42 You, you've seen- Well- … 20 years of change, so. Uh, I, I … One area that I, I've been predicting for a while, and I, I don't know if this … Maybe this isn't allowed because I predicted it, and it's beginning to come true, is that when the, the leadership within retail is transforming to people that started in the digital, uh, part of the business. And we're seeing those folks, not just in a CMO role, but moving into a CEO role, uh, like Art Peck over at Gap, or in some private equity companies like, um, Sam Taylor, who's at Oriental Trading, had a whole, um, kind of history in, um, digital. So I think we're gonna continue to see more and more of that.

46:23 Uh, you know, the, the brand selling direct, um, I, I feel like I'm just, uh, kind of, uh, uh, li- you know, maybe I've been listening to your show too much. But I- … I do, I do think that's a continued trend, is the, the brand selling direct continuing to invest because they're, the, they're, the, they're less vulnerable to Amazon than the retailer that's selling third-party products and competing on price with, with Amazon. Yeah. And you're an advisor to a vendor, um, used to be called Chat Idea. I always forget their new name. Um, that's interesting. When I saw it, that was, that was like one of the first companies I saw very early in that brands going direct Yeah, they're, what they're doing is pretty interesting, which is kind of taking the brand selling direct and incorporating that into the retail experience.

47:09 So the idea would be that if you're on the Best Buy website and you're looking at a Samsung phone, you could have a direct chat with a Samsung rep. Yeah. And everybody wins in that situation because, you know, manufacturers, you know, always believe that nobody can merchandise or talk about their products as well as they can. So now they have this direct line to the customer, but, um, rather than through their own direct channel, they're using it through one of the retail partners, so. Yeah. It helps them build that muscle tissue so that when people do come to samsung.com, they, you know, they're not like, "Oh my God, what do you do about a chat coming in here?" And I, I know, you know, one of the brands' hugest concerns in this whole digital disruption is they're getting even further disintermediated from their customer.

47:54 And so that, that's an opportunity for them to have that direct relationship. I'm not sure everyone wins, though, because when that happens for Samsung, Sony does not win. Right. That's, that's true. Sony could win if they, they participated, too. So yeah. Yeah. Going, uh, back to your earlier point, another great example of the digital guy getting elevated to that, that, uh, C-suite, uh, former shop.org member, uh, board member Jason Laroche is now president of Under Armour, which I think is very cool. Yeah, yeah. Right. So yeah, I, I think we're gonna see more and more of that. Hopefully those guys will all be really successful and set the precedent. Yeah. Yeah. They're always welcome to come back to the podcast. Yeah. Well, listen, Scott, it has happened again.

48:35 We have flown through our allotted time. Uh, but super grateful for you taking time out from the show to speak with us and the listeners here at the NRF Big Show. Well, I, I thank you very much for having me on. I love your podcast. You guys are doing an amazing job. I think it should be incorporated into college curriculums. There's so much that could be done with this. So, uh, congrats. Thanks. Thanks for listening. And maybe, uh, are you gonna… If you listen to this one, are you gonna listen at 1X or you still do 1.5? Uh, maybe both. And then I, I- … I'm gonna make my family listen to it at 50%, so it- … it'll take, like, two hours for them. Nice. I'll, I'll make a special edit for you and make your voice way louder than ours for your family.

49:18 Excellent. Thank you. Yeah. So listen, until the next show, which will be very soon, happy commerce-ing, everyone. Thanks, Scott, and thanks to NRF for hosting us. You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us in iTunes or visit www.jasonandscot.com.