EP047 - Shop.org 2016 Day 2 Recap
EP047 - Shop.org 2016 Day 2 Recap
Recap of the day 2 keynote: Jacques Panis - President of Shinola. Trends from the trade show floor.
Don't forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.
Episode 47 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded on Wednesday, September 28th, 2016.
Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:02 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here are Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg. This episode is being recorded live from the NRF Shop.org Digital Summit on Wednesday, September 29th, 2016. As usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Well, Jason, it's a little bit bittersweet on this podcast.
0:44 We've been, uh, doing a bit of a marathon session. I think this is probably our eighth or ninth, I've kind of lost track, podcast here from the show floor, and it's our last one. So the bitter, sorry it's at an end, but the sweet is always good to go back home after you've been on the road. So, uh, it's been, been a lot of fun. Appreciate, uh, you being the audio engineer and hauling all this stuff all around creation to, to set us up It, it's been fun to get to spend some quality time in person, Scott. Yeah, we never, never see each other. We, we're usually doing this remote. Um, so for this last podcast, we're gonna keep it pretty short, and what we're gonna do is we- we've been here three, three-plus days now just absorbing and talking to literally hundreds o- of retailers. Uh, Jason's been on the keynote stage, kinda doing that whole thing.
1:27 Uh, so we really wanna kinda just wrap the digital summit and talk about what we've been hearing, what retailers are talking about, kinda what's the buzz, and, uh, what, what we've been hearing out there. Um, so first I wanna start, uh, you, you hosted a keynote with Shinola today, uh, the watch manufacturer. Uh, I wasn't able to, to make it to that, so I wanna hear how that went and kinda what some of the takeaways from that one were. Yeah. Uh, so there was a keynote this morning with the president of Shinola. Uh, and for those that aren't familiar, Shinola is a brand that's really focused on sort of celebrating Detroit. Um, so the- they have a mission to create jobs in the US, um, and they're, they're really, like, leveraging Detroit as the sort of anchor of, of their brand.
2:14 And so they actually have a few different kinds of products. They, they sell Shinola watches, which are Swiss movements that are assembled in Detroit. So they, they brought over a Swiss watchmaker and trained several hundred employees in, uh, assembling these watches, uh, that they, they sell successfully throughout the US but, but assembled in Detroit. They have these, uh, v- uh, cool vintage bicycles that, that are assembled in Detroit. They sell a lot of leather goods, which the original heritage of the brand was, uh, leather polish, so- Okay … so that, that sorta makes sense. And they are a perfect example of what we've talked about several times on this show, uh, digitally native, vertically integrated brands.
2:56 So they, they make their own products. They have about 20 retail stores that they sell direct. Of course, their, their largest distribution channel is selling direct online. Um, and I, I, I guess the one debatable point is they're a very analog brand, and so it's… Like, the digital native part y- may be in some dispute. Um, but they actually have a very solid digital block and tackling, and it sounds like they're getting ready to, to launch some, some newer digital stuff. Cool. Did they, uh, the, my favorite topic of Amazon come up at all? Do they, do they sell on Amazon or, or- They did- … or wholesale or? Uh, so they, they don't sell on- You didn't ask my favorite question? Uh, well, so I, I was thinking it.
3:37 Uh- Okay … they for sure do not sell on Amazon. They don't sell through any third-party, uh, channels. The- Thing that was interesting, uh, for them is they, they, knowing that it was a digital audience, they sort of shared some of their, their tactics and learnings, uh, from building their own audience on digital. And so one of the, the, the tests that they showed is they were really curious about the value of buying their exact match brand terms on Google. Mm-hmm. Um, so he, uh… So they, they literally, you know, did a test that a number of retailers have tried. I think eBay has famously tried at one point where they- So this is the brand term Sh- Shinola Shinola. Exactly.
4:17 Yeah. I imagine. Yeah. So they, they, uh, were making a meaningful investment in it. They turned it off, um, and they, they showed their Google Analytics. Um, and you, you can actually see that, like, when, uh, paid search on that term, like, dropped to zero, or- organic search, uh, exactly rose to the previous level. And so their strong conclusion from that test was, uh, we, at least in our particular case, we don't need to be investing in those exact match brand terms. So they, to this day, don't, don't buy those terms, and they've reinvested those dollars in, in other, uh, product-based terms. Interesting. Wow. Yeah.
4:57 Uh, so a little bad news for Google there. Yeah. I may have mentioned that it was probably a good time to short the Google stock, and he pointed out that, uh, magically, uh, Google finds some other way to get the money. Yeah, yeah. They- they just kind of allocate the budget to long tail terms, I imagine, or something like that. Exactly. Yeah. So, so that was, uh, interesting. The… They're doing some interesting things. They're opening a hotel. Hmm. Okay. So just kind of leveraging the Shinola brand, um, and, you know, try- Their big, big fundamental challenge that he didn't really have an answer to is the stores are very experiential. You walk in, and there's a, a specific leather smell to the stores, and they have, uh, a gourmet coffee bars in all the stores. So they serve coffee, and, and, you know, they really trigger all of your senses in this, like, brand immersion experience, and how do you recreate that online?
5:46 Like, you know, candidly, you know, just between us and our 60,000 listeners, I would say, like, they, they don't, right? Yeah. Like, it feels like a very traditional catalog site. Until we have Smell-O-Vision or some kind of smell-emitting device on our laptops or, or phones. We, we did discuss a potential scratch-and-sniff screen could be the, the partial solution. Okay. Cool. Wow, good. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So, uh, so after that, what else, uh, have you heard that's interesting here at the show? Yep. Well, so I didn't get to attend it, but one of the other keynotes was from Google, and they made an interesting announcement about the, the next iteration of one of their, their, uh- sort of innovation projects, which they call, uh, Project Tango. Yeah, and that's, uh, we love to talk about augmented reality and virtual reality here on the show, and that's a, that's an AR kind of a solution through a phone.
6:34 Um, um, tell us a little bit more about that. Yeah, so it's actually even blending a couple of things. It, it definitely has a strong AR component. It also has some geolocation components. So the, the original, uh, iteration of Project Tango actually piloted in some Walgreens stores, and it, it involved devices that Walgreens put on shopping carts. And they essentially, uh, geolocated the shopping cart, so they knew exactly what aisle the shopping cart was on, and then the, the shop- the device had a camera and a video screen with augmented reality. So y- so you got a view of the aisle you were on, on your shopping cart that was then augmented with, with additional product information and offers.
7:16 Okay. Um, so that was… It went live I, I think like maybe 18 months ago, two years ago, and it may not still be live. And so at this show, they announced that they, uh, a new iteration of Project Tango that ran on a consumer's phone as opposed to a dedicated device in the store. Um, and it has some cool new features, um, for visualization of like custom kitchens and cabinetry and furniture in rooms. Uh, the novel new feature is it uses a, a thr- uh, 3D modeling from the phone to measure the room and give you a very accurate representation of your room and, and if a, a sofa you're considering buying would actually fit in that room.
8:00 Okay. Um, so I've seen some demos before. It's very cool. You could definitely see the value add to the consumer. The wrinkle at the moment is most of our phones don't have the ability to accurately measure distances. And, and we think we talked a little bit about this on our, our iPhone 7 episode. Um, so one, the one phone that does have the stereoscopic camera right now is a Lenovo phone. And so at the moment, this Project Tango pilot is limited to folks carrying that, that specific Lenovo phone. Wow. Which is a pretty narrow market. Yeah, yeah. Um, but it is cool to start to see bigger companies kinda do these things where we've seen some of these startups and, and kind of vendory kinda things now to see Google kind of looking at the intersection of AR, VR, and, and retail is, is pretty exciting.
8:44 Uh, another area that I know you get excited about is personalization. Um, there seems to be, uh, a lot of vendors here that are, are kinda focused on that. Um, uh, we're, we're just to kinda paint a picture for you guys listening, we're, we're in smack in the middle of the exhibit floor here. Uh, and we can see two vendors that focus on, uh, apparel fitting, so we, we should probably talk about that. Uh, but then there's a whole startup area, uh, uh, what's the name of that? It's called… I can't see it. Uh, but there's, like, more of a retail… A launchpad. Yeah, it's called Launchpad. Uh, and I walked through there, and half the vendors were personalization, and the other half were AI, uh, or artificial intelligence. Um, what do you think about those kind of technologies and where they are right now?
9:25 Yeah, it's, it's an interesting time in that space. So there have been some pretty well-known personalization vendors in our space for a long time, and I, I would've said, like, their, their products are pretty mature, right? And they, they tend to be around, like, primarily product recommendations, right? Yeah. So, so, you know, hey, we'll fill in these product tiles on your category pages and product detail pages, um, with using some artificial intelligence to, to recommend products that your customers are likely to buy. Um, there, uh, are a lot of tools that, that sort of started life as AB testing tools and have evolved to become sort of personalization engines. So, you know, uh, letting you know your audience a little better, maybe bringing in some third-party data from Blue Kai or others to, like, know the demographics of your visitor and then personalize the, the site based on those, those demographics.
10:16 And a lot of those vendors have been in this space for 10 years, and they're on their, you know, fifth or sixth iteration of products. And so what's been interesting this year at the show is there are dozens of new vendors, um- Coming into that space. And they all have, you know, some unique value proposition, but they're all pretty narrow solutions. Like, this vendor has a really novel approach for customizing emails on open. Um, you know, so that's, that's a big deal. Like, you know, you don't necessarily wanna customize the email based on when you send it, because a user might take several days to open it, and- Yeah … the, the, the best personalization trigger might, might have changed in those several days. Yeah, open, you know if they're on a phone versus a desktop, where you know a lot more about them at open.
10:59 Exactly. Um, and there are a bunch of vendors that have specific personalization for category pages or banner ads or attributes on a product detail page. And you look at a bunch of those and you think, you know, these seem like good mousetraps. These are thing… You know, best practices that a retailer might wanna follow. But the, the caveat is, do you really wanna build your overall user experience by Frankensteining together 16 of these different point solutions? And so you have your, your e-commerce engine personalizing some of the experience, and your CMS i- uh, personalizing some of the experience, and your ESP personalizing others. You're, you're creating all these little silos of personalization and the underlying data, um, and it, it becomes very unruly and, and, uh, sort of unmanageable.
11:49 Mm-hmm. And so I feel like that's, that's gonna be a challenge for some of these vendors to, to overcome that, that hurdle. Yeah. And, um, on, uh, we, we heard this when you were talking to some other folks. You're more of a proponent of, um, uh, and I don't want to put words in your mouth, but give, give people a set of APIs, kind of a cloud-based service framework for personalization, and then let them kind of bake it in. Let the retailer kind of pull that down and bake it in across kind of more of a horizontal approach versus kind of a, a vertical solution approach. Yeah. If, if you were doing no personalization, the, um, but you had a really big email list and you were, you were doing a lot of email, um, there, there probably was a high ROI for, like, investing in a point solution to make your, your email more personalized.
12:35 Yep. And if you had no product recommendations, there's probably an ROI around, uh, implementing some, some solid product recommendation feature. But, like, there's diminishing returns for, um, buying a specific tool to change each of these touch points. So once you have those real basics in place, I, I really think it makes more sense to solve personalization as a system- Yeah … um, as opposed to a bunch of- When you, when you go with the multiple tool solution, they're not gonna learn from each other, right? So- It, it- … the email- If they are, it's ver- it's gonna be very hard to plumb them all together. Yeah, yeah. The, the email personalization's not gonna learn from the product recommendation and, and et cetera, I'd assume. Yeah. Cool. And then what do you think about, um, you know, so last year at the show, big data and kind of how do you consume big data was really big.
13:20 Um, the problem with just kind of the phrase big data is it's just like a, it's a, it's like electricity. It's, it's not a solution, it's just a thing, right? Um, so now it seems like a lot of the, the buzz is around these AI companies where they're taking machine learning. Uh, I think that's more of what they're doing. I'm not sure if I would call it AI. Uh, they're taking some of the machine learning things that have come out there and, and applying it to some of these similar kind of personalization problems and whatnot. Um, is that something retailers should be thinking about, or is that kind of science fiction-y at this point? No, no, no, I definitely think it's interesting. I, uh, it is, uh, right on the verge of being one of these shiny objects. Like, there's certainly… I, I would argue the majority of retailers that have deployed a customer-facing cognitive computing solution today are largely doing it for the, the PR value.
14:05 Um, and you know, that- that's not a bad strategy. And, and North Face famously has a, a Watson experience. Yeah. And oh, by the way, IBM put the, the CEO of, of North Face, like, in a national television campaign, which certainly, certainly benefited North Face. Um, but I'm not, uh, sure that those product recommendations are dramatically better than the, the product discovery tools that North Face had before Watson. Um, but when you look at the demos, um, of what's becoming possible, and when you really feed richer data sets to these engines, um, I, I am definitely convinced that they add real value and have the ability to, to reduce friction in the shopping experience.
14:51 Yeah, and I get the application of machine learning to things like driverless cars and, um, you know, uh, healthcare issues, diagnosing a healthcare problem. What, what's a use case in retail where you think machine learning can, can move the needle? Yep. So, a, a couple. Uh, inventory planning, um, is, is a really interesting one, is- Taking data from sales in store and sales from online browsing behavior, um, to make smarter decisions about what styles and sizes should be carried in what depths in each of your retail stores. Yeah. Um, so th- those decisions today are largely made by humans that, that follow some, some guidelines that have been ha- handed down from generation to generation, and there's often some urban legend that data was behind the original methodologies.
15:44 But probably wasn't. Um- Yeah … and there, those are, that's an area where it's really expensive to make mistakes. Um, and so if the computers can help, uh, a retailer decide what depth of what products to carry in each store, that makes a lot of sense. One, one that was particularly interesting to me is, uh, a lot of retailers because of, uh, loss prevention or traffic monitoring now have a lot of video and still photography image, uh, is, of all their stores. So say you're a retailer that has 1,000 stores, and say you're, you have a video camera facing the front door of the store that you use as a people counter. One of the interesting things you can now do with that is say, "Hey, what style of apparel do shoppers that walk into my store favor?"
16:31 Hm. Like, what, how are they dressed when they come into the store? What colors do they favor? What, what sizes are they? Um, there's, there's potentially some, some cool versus creepy issues with some of that, but there's a, a super rich data set- Yeah … uh, to help those apparel retailers, uh, realize what, what styles and sizes they should be selling. Interesting. I hadn't even thought about that. Cool. And then, uh, I know you have to shoot to a meeting, so we'll kinda wrap this up with the last topic. The, uh, we spend a lot of time on the podcast kinda thinking three to five years out about the future of commerce. There's a lot more vendors here, uh, that are doing AR/VR things. I haven't seen any drone vendors. I've been looking for them. I don't think they're, they're, uh, that we've gotten to the point where those folks are exhibiting yet.
17:13 Um, well let's talk about this fashion stuff, the, you know, what do you think about these systems that- that kinda, you know, help with the- the problem of, you know, everyone has a different body type and size, and apparel, and how is it gonna fit me, and that kind of thing? Yeah. I, I think there's a lot of interesting stuff going on, and I think they're solving a, a high-value problem. Um, so, you know, returns in e-commerce- e-commerce is, is hard to be profitable in general, and we've talked about that. The op- you know, the economics are challenging, and returns can really be the, the difference between being profitable and unprofitable. And in the online apparel space, returns have been particularly high. Um, and it's, it's sort of a twofold problem.
17:55 People buy stuff that legitimately doesn't work for them, and they, they have to return it. But also, in the early days of online apparel, we taught customers that the way to shop for apparel online, since you, you can't go to a fitting room ahead of time, is, "Oh, don't worry, just buy it in multiple sizes and send back what you don't need." Um, and you know, the Zappos's of the world were like, "That- that's the only way to instill confidence in users to buy shoes online." Mm-hmm. So now, good job, we've educated customers that that's what you do. And, uh- I imagine returns have gone up. Yeah. And so selling shoes and selling apparel, the return rate is much higher than consumer electronics, for example.
18:37 Mm-hmm. Um, it, it literally can be 20% or 30% for some retailers, which is hugely expensive. Yeah. Um, so now we're all shifting to say, how do we help the consumer get the right product the first time, right? And part of that answer is machine learning. If you're a regular Zappos sh- customer, and you always are buying the 10 and a half and the 11 shoes, and you're always returning the 10 and a half- We can now message you on that product detail page. Like based on your previous history, this shoe is gonna fit you better than that shoe. Right. Um, and so we're, we're starting to see some retailers in- including Zappos, who leverage that tactic. But the, the challenge is, of course, for apparel and shoes, fitment is very inconsistent.
19:21 So just because you are a 10 and a half in the Adidas Stan Smiths doesn't mean that you're gonna like the 10 and a half in the Nike. And so, uh, a couple of companies have addressed this problem by saying, "Hey, let's use data to answer that question. What if we go into our warehouse and we 3D scan all of the shoes?" And so now we know what the volume is of that Nike versus that Adidas shoe. We know how high the arch is, and if you tell us that that Adidas 10 and a half is the most comfortable shoe you own, the best-fitting shoe, I can tell you what the analogous size is in the Nike shoe, um, based on real data. And so in… This isn't a hypothetical example.
20:03 There was a company out there called ShoeFitr, and spelled cleverly F-I-T-R. Um, and that's exactly what they did. And I think Zappos was an early partner, and they got access to the whole Zappos inventory, so they were able to scan a ton of shoes. Um, and they were a great solution until they were bought by a company you may have heard of called Amazon. Ah, yeah. So they're now… That solution is no longer available to most of the market. Yeah. And so you, you could imagine that, that there are, are shoe retailers that would like a solution like that. Um, and then we're, we're sitting across from a booth called True Fit, which solves very similar problem predominantly for jeans. And I think they would say they focus on all apparel, but I think the category they started in that they're best known for is women's jeans.
20:49 So if you know the 7 For All Mankind, uh, uh, a particular cut in that jean is most flattering on you, they'll tell you what the, what the equivalent Calvin Klein jean would be. Now, do they scan your body or they're just using kind of the, the product data, not the, the personal body data? So True, so True Fit in particular uses the, the database of SKUs to tell you- Okay … other, other makes of apparel that are likely to fit similar to apparel that you've already tried. Yeah. Uh, but you, you've touched on the other half of this fitment problem which is coming, which is, hey, is there a way to scan me, um, and know what's gonna fit, right? Yeah. So, so some of the older technologies that are out there, uh, there, there are some interesting companies that, like, are installing booths in malls, and they actually use the same back scatter technology that they use at airports, uh, for security.
21:40 Oh, really? And so it turns out that, um, you know, those things go right through your skin, and so they can see the guns under your clothes and all those sorts of things. Uh, if you use those devices with less power, the, the rays go through clothes but bounce off of skin. Mm-hmm. So that lets you go stand in a booth in a mall, and they can measure your a- hyper accurately measure your body dimensions right through your clothes. And so, so I always thought this was a pretty clever model. I think we probably creeped out half the audience, though. I'm not sure. Yeah. You know? I see people get really agitated when they go through that TSA thing. I can't imagine that they would volunteer for this, so I don't know. So, so that is, like- That's gonna be one of the challenges … one, one of the challenges. So, A, this is not a cheap piece of hardware.
22:21 Yeah. So you, so, like, you can't put it in every store. So their premise was, hey, we put one in a mall. A subset of customers will be willing to stand in this thing, get measured, and the value prop is I will then print you out a list of the best fitting apparel that's available in the mall that you're standing in. Mm-hmm. And they were essentially a, an affiliate, so they, they provided this service for free and carried the cost of the hardware, and then they hoped to make enough money on, on those referral fees by sending people into The Gap to buy particular- Jeans. So, uh, for customers that really, they used it and got like great fitting clothes, that seemed like a good model, and then of course the smart digital component is now that they know your size, they upload that to their website, and now you, after you get home from that mall, you can go shopping online, and they'll point you at a bunch of apparel that, that fits you perfectly.
23:10 Got it. Um, so that limited appeal because, A, it's awkward to get fitted in public, even wearing your clothes. You feel like sort of a hamster in the, the tube, and to your point, the, the backscatter machine is scary. So the next iteration of that is, well, can't we just use the super computer in our pocket to take our measurements, right? Yeah. And so there are a bunch of made to order companies that now, like, you know, do novel things with like, "Hey, put your phone against a wall, stand eight feet away and we'll take pictures of you, and we'll, uh, with some reference object, and then we'll, we'll ascertain your size based on these pictures and make you a bespoke suit." Um, and the very best versions of this u- use the stereoscopic cameras to measure you very accurately.
23:55 So Intel in particular has a 3D camera that they build into all the Intel branded laptops. Mm. And so Zappos and some others are using that technology to let you scan yourself in the privacy of your own home standing in front of your, your, uh, laptop. And then in their use case, you can actually upload that data to Zappos. Zappos will give, will make a 3D avatar of you, and not only will they recommend the size that fits you best, they'll show you wearing that clothes as that, that garment would actually fit you. Wow, cool. Yeah. And then you can imagine in ARVR that, that, that would be a great part of that experience to make it seem more real versus like 2D avatars- Abs- kind of splayed all together … yeah, and o- once you get just a little bit more horsepower, like once you've done that once, now you go to the store and you pull out your phone and just, you know, as you, you wave your phone at any of the apparel, it recognizes that apparel, it applies it to your avatar, and using augmented reality, you're seeing yourself as the mannequin for every, every garment in that store.
24:58 Cool. Any other future stuff that, uh, you saw here at the show that you wanna share? Um, so in the future stuff, obviously a lot of folks are talking about chat commerce. We've talked a lot about that. Um, the, uh, I, I, I he- I hesitate to even call this future, but the other dialogue that, that seems like more folks are having this year is about, like, truly addressing some of the, the attribution problems. And we, we've been talking about these for a long time, but this feels like a year when, when retailers are actually starting to invest some dollars in trying to solve attribution. Yeah. I feel like the attribution problems, we talked about this with Milton, um, uh, if that one hasn't been published when you listen to this, it's coming soon.
25:41 Uh, and, you know, in the… When I first started in e-commerce, attribution was all kind of last click versus this, you know, that kinda thing. Um, and now it's multi-device, and then it's, like, online and offline. So, so if anything, it's become an eight-headed beast versus kind of a one-headed beast. Yeah. It's at least a three-headed beast, right? Yeah. Like, y- y- you've got the online versus offline. You have multi-touch. You saw an ad on Facebook, and then you bought something off a Google PLA. Yep. Um, how do you, you give credit to both of those, those ad units? And then the multi-device. You browse for something on a phone, and you bought it on your laptop, and so. Yeah. So when Razorfish clients come to you to solve that, the attribution problem, how do you, how do you guys solve this?
26:22 Yep. Um, so, uh, two phases to that. The data phase. Okay. Like, how do, how do you collect the data? And we, we are big advocates of aggregating all your data and creating what we call a universal ID, and a bunch of ways to get there. That could be a digital fingerprint. That could be, uh, a repository of cookies on these different devices. But using whatever attributes you have about, um, your, your shoppers and their behaviors aggregated in a, in a data warehouse. We actually have a- A framework for that that we call Cosmos, but like, you know, it's basically a methodology- Yeah uh, for aggregating all that data, number one. And then the second thing is, once you have all that data and you can see multiple touchpoints from multiple devices, how much cre- like, what's the right model for deciding how much credit to give to each device, right?
27:14 Yeah. And so, you know, the, the default model we've all used is last click. The last touch gets 100%. Yeah. Um, there are lots of alternative models. Linear, they a, a, every touch gets equal credit, or time decay, the, the last click is most valuable or least valuable. Um, and, and positional, certain points in the shopping decision are different. So it turns out that the best way to do it is to apply your data against all of those models, and have those models compete with each other to see one f- which one fits accurately your profitability the best. And so you can actually use machine learning to have these different attribution models compete against each other to create a bespoke model that fits your particular business and user base the best.
28:00 Cool. Interesting, so then that model would spit out, you know, here's how to do it, and then you'd use that going forward. Yeah. And so it's, it's really interesting that, like it's, it's, it requires the eggheads that are much better at math than I am. But the, the deal breaker that makes it not work right now is it, it doesn't matter how accurate the model is. The, it… Most retailers that have one of these systems in place, it got bought, bought by one department, and it's believed in by a small set of stakeholders, right? So then you, you walk into the big marketing meeting, and you tell the CFO, "We wanna dramatically change how we're investing in our marketing based on this attribution model," and the, the CFO didn't sit in on any of the, the, the sales meetings or the test meetings for that attribution model, so they're not buying it, right?
28:47 Right. So it, it, as with all of these things, it comes down to organizational change management. Um, if, if the whole management team agrees on a, on a multi-touch attribution model, behavior will change. But, but y- it can't just be championed by a single stakeholder within an organization. Cool. Got it. Well, I know you have to shoot to a meeting, so… Yeah. Uh, really appreciate the listeners sticking with us through, through these updates. It's been great live casting from the show. Really enjoyed meeting some of the listeners. And so until next time, we'll wish you a happy podcasting. Yeah. Thanks to all our listeners for, uh, joining us here online and offline. And really wanna thank all the guests that we had here while we were at summit.
29:27 We were able to get a lot of, uh, a lot of great material on tape, and we will be putting it out there as soon as possible. And you know we don't really use tape, right, Scott? I know. I like to say it. It's like a radio thing. Cool. You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes or visit www.jasonandscot.com.
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed