EP342 - The End of the Attention Economy, and What Retail Does Next with Mitch Joel
Recorded live from NRF Nexus in Colorado Springs, Jason and Scot sit down with keynote speaker Mitch Joel. His core thesis is that the attention economy is over and we're entering the intimacy economy, where the winning brands make every customer feel like the experience was built just for them. From there the conversation covers why digital commerce broke serendipity and discovery, how curation becomes a competitive edge once AI can scale it, whether agentic shopping is actually what shoppers want, and how AI is being deployed at companies (often pointed at internal productivity instead of the customer). It closes on trust, and the uncomfortable cases where AI improves the experience but only if you don't disclose it.
Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, Chief Commerce Strategy Officer at Publicis, and Scot Wingo, CEO of ReFiBuy.AI and Co-Founder of ChannelAdvisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:00 My big idea is that the attention economy is over. I really think that we are in this idea of the intimacy economy. My idea of the intimacy economy is that we have been living in a shift that hasn't just been a mass of digital, it's actually been very, very little specific things that have made people feel like this is being made uniquely for me. And that the delta today for retailers or brands is, wait a second, if it scales the way it does, how can I create an environment where the end user, in this case it would be customers, 'cause it's retailers, feel like everything they're touching with our brand feels like it's just for them?
0:42 Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, Chief Commerce Strategy Officer of Publicis, and Scot Wingo, Co-founder and CEO of ReBuyBuy. Here are Jason and Scot. Welcome to The Jason and Scot Show. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg. And as usual, I'm here with my co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Jason, and welcome back Jason and Scot Show listeners. What's not usual is we are live, live, live from NRF Nexus in beautiful Colorado Springs. Jason, you enjoying the altitude?
1:23 I'm totally enjoying the altitude. I'm particularly enjoying getting to hang out with you, 'cause it's been too long. Yeah, yeah. Did you climb to the top of, uh, Mount Cherokee there? I opted out of all strenuous activities. Yes, yes. As befits my physical capability. Yeah, our badges have this thing about what every retailer's favorite thing is, and the number one was alcohol, and it's good to see you partaking. A close second was caffeine, and I feel like th- those perfectly overlap my- Yeah … my interest. I, I think we're gonna start a new direct to consumer espresso martini business. Yeah, and to Jason's left we have a coffee and a, a thermos of vodka. A beverage that we cannot confirm or deny has- Or … has spirits.
2:03 So this is, uh, this is gonna be fun. We, uh, we were able to snag the keynote speaker. When I say we, you. So excited to welcome Mitch Joel to the show. Hey, guys. Welcome. I'm, uh… I, I thought I was lightheaded 'cause of how good-looking you are, and then I realized, oh, it's 'cause I'm in Colorado. You're in altitude. It's the altitude. Stay hydrated. Yeah. So you're not, you're not good looking. Two things can be true at the same time, Mitch. No, that's fair. I have to grapple with both of those, I guess, yeah. Yeah, this was the big reveal. We just went video two or three episodes ago- Right … and people realized we're not Brad Pitt and, and, uh- That I, I think there's huge disappointment. Yeah. There's a huge business in AI filters for Gen Xers is what I'm thinking, especially when it comes to video. Yeah. I have a face for audio podcasts. Yes. That's clear. Absolutely.
2:44 Yeah. Next, next, next company. Snap or… Yeah. Yeah. So this is a little bit of a fanboy moment for me. Oh, come on. It… No, it really is because- At least for me, 'cause I'm a fan of- Well, uh, it goes without saying that yeah, it's mutual. True. But not really. Scott and I started this podcast almost exactly 11 years ago. And I, like, wasn't a super popular space back then. I had done a little research and, and I liked the average mortality of a podcast was, like, six episodes. Yeah. So my whole goal was, let's see if we can last- Two months, yeah s- s- seven episodes. Exactly. And now, you know, I went to bed one night, I woke up, it's been 11 years. And now I always, when I introduce the show to someone, I say, like, "We were podcasting way before it was cool."
3:30 But in the back of my head when I say that, I'm like, "Mitch had a way more popular podcast for 10 years before we ever laid down a show." So your both early entry into this space and your y- awesome consistency in maintaining that quality over more than 20 years now- Yeah … I, I think is a underappreciated accomplishment. Yeah. I hope your family's proud of you. I, and I don't think anyone is. I- It's been, it, yeah, it's been 20 years. 52 episodes a year, no repeats, no seasons. And I, I'm one who stands on stage and projects to retailers and others that I think consistency is something we sorely lack.
4:13 But not just consistency in, like, doing it often. I don't know if you guys had this experience. When I was younger, I loved physical magazines. I, I would say I still do, but I'm a big fan of Press Reader, where I can see the physical magazine on my iPad. I like that better. But I was… This was before the internet. I would devour magazines, like, over and over, to the point where I would go to the store and I could feel when there was a new issue. Mm-hmm. Much like you guys would remember, like, must-see TV, Thursdays 8:00 PM. And I think that humans have, like, really lost, in the current world, the understanding of how important not just consistency, but regularly at the same time, even if you don't communicate it to the world.
4:54 And so my whole thing was like, I'll publish every Sunday morning and never tell anybody when I do that. And over the years you'll see people say like, "Hey, is everything okay? 'Cause it's like 11:00 and like my podcasting host glitched," or something like that. So, so it's been a long time, but I will, as, as another side to that story, when I started in, in the marketing kind of media world, there was three other podcasts and it was really like this holy trinity of marketing communication with Joe Jaffe, Michelle Holtz was doing it, and there was Inside PR out of Canna, uh, Terry Fallis, who's now a very well-known author with, with, uh, David Jones, and I thought I was late to the party. That's it. So just like you say that- Yeah … I always think about people. And I remember going to like a podcamp and thinking to myself like, "Wow, I'm really late to this party.
5:36 Can't believe it." 20 years later, it's, it seems like it's just becoming a real business. Uh, so. Yeah. Yeah, it's the old after 20 years, you're an overnight success. Overnight success. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. That, that is awesome. And you, you started to allude to it, we always like to start our shows with guests by kinda getting a little bit of background about our, our guests. And so you've done, the, as if the podcast wouldn't be enough- … you've done quite a bit including some significant work in, in my space of pompous marketing agencies. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So I, I started very young publishing music magazines. Internet just came on. Really proud that in like '91, '92, we had a cover of the magazine that was the net, and the big tech breakthrough at the time was hyperlinks.
6:20 Mm. The fact that you didn't have to type in the huge URL, you could actually click a link and go to the page. So I was in and interested in it really early. I got really captivated by technology, media, marketing, advertising, even content. So I did that for a bit. I, I worked where I live in Montreal for a local community paper that was also very early days of the internet. Through that connection, I started working at mama.com, which was one of the first search engines on the internet prior to Google existing. Yeah. Yeah. So it was a meta search engine, but- Yeah … you know, I was on those early calls with Sergey and Larry and I, I, we, we had developed things like pay per click before it even became what it is today. dotcom boom bust echo wound up found- finding myself in a mobile content company, which seems logical these days, but this was mobile before there were smartphones, before there was even a web browser, before there was interconnectivity between carriers for text messaging.
7:10 Like, if you were on Verizon, you couldn't text somebody on T-Mobile like that early. So you know you had your audience for a while. It was really like it was on the deck. You'd go to, like, content, and it was like there, and these people were licensing stuff. It was a very interesting thing. And then I started a digital agency in 2000 with three business partners that we scaled and then inevitably sold about 13 years ago to WPP. Uh, that agency was called Twist Image, became Mirum. Uh, when I left, earnout and all that, we had about 3,000 employees in 30 countries. It was d- it was doing really, really well, and I just took my assets out of there. I took m- literally, the podcast, the blog at the time, my writing, my speaking, my books. And since then I have Launched a startup.
7:53 I've done a lot of advisory work, a lot of consulting, a lot of speaking still, and I still do the podcast and writing. Well, thank goodness. And I, I should mention for many of our listeners, the magazines you reference, that's like a, a Substack on papyrus. Right. Ex- yeah, yeah. I mean, the models were awesome, right? Yeah. A free magazine, 40,000 circulation, ad supported, and you'd hear 40,000 and you'd think like it's just nothing in the digital age. But, like, at the time it was like- That's a huge- Yeah … yeah, yeah. Big circulation. Yeah, it's hilarious. You have started a new venture called Thinkers One, and I, I, I want you to explain it, but I, I feel like my quick takeaway is how can you get shorter gigs and do less work? No, yeah, kind of, yeah. I mean, the, the, the way that I could get myself sued would be to say they're customized TED Talks, right?
8:38 It's, it's, it's an a b- a way for a company to buy essentially 15 minute executive- No one from the TED people- Right … watch the show, you're safe … they're too sophisticated for us. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. It's a, it's just a way for companies to really connect with a thought leader in 15-minute experiences, so live or recorded, and they're really like executive summaries, and it's just a great way… Like, when I do an event like this, a lot of times they'll come over and say, "Ah, how do I bring this back to my business?" And that's just a, an easy way to do it. If you're doing a smaller event, an offsite, just even a general, a marketing meeting, a team meeting, it's a great way to add really good insight. People don't want… I, I don't think people want long courses and studying and added stuff. We had all these intranets, and I don't think anybody accessed any of these courses. But if you could bring that into a 15, you know, in an hour meeting and have 15 minutes, it would be somebody interesting and different.
9:23 So we're doing that, and I'm about to launch NextEra Institute, which is my, my bigger project, which I hope will be my life's work, which is really, you know, the ability for organizations to connect with all of the stuff I do, which I'm gonna bring under the NextEra Institute and just create a whole bunch of new products and different ideas that I'm really excited about. Now, with Thinkers One, is it like a marketplace, kind of like a Cameo where you- Yeah, exactly. Yeah … have people say- So you guys should be on it, absolutely. Yeah. I mean, the only part that's not like a Cameo marketplace is we highly curate it. As you guys see here with your tools and toys, if the person doesn't have the ability to be really cogent on video and really good and really natural ability to just shoot it, edit it, send it, it becomes a bit laborious and not worth it.
10:06 The idea is that it's really kind of cheap and cheerful. So that's, that, there's a bit of curation. I wanna make sure the people are good on videos. You guys know somebody can be great on a podcast, terrible on stage, great on stage, terrible on video. These are all very unique communication skills that are not intuitive for everybody. Tell more about the, the new one, The Life's Work. Yeah, so, you know, NextEra Institute, it was really a … You know, c- candidly, it was … I was in a place where I thought, "I'm, I'm kind of tired self-promoting, I think." And I didn't have to do that in the agency. When I left, I kind of realized I gotta build the brand. So one is I wanted to build something. If I'm gonna build a brand, I wanted to have equity. And the way to have equity is obviously build it around the company, not an individual. I've seen just a lot of stuff in the conversations of what's been happening from all of the transformations we've gone through, and I feel like there's a, a greater theme around speed that I'm trying to kill.
10:57 I think speed has always been a part of the conversation. There's not … I do not believe there's a moat in speed. And my theory, which I'll be presenting tomorrow, too, is that direction and momentum is much greater than speed. But in order to find the direction and how to find those moments to build momentum are the tricky part. And so what I'm hoping to do with this institute is facilitate different types of products. Some of them will be content, some of them will be more physical, where leaders can speak more candidly, and we can work together to find those directions and opportunities to build momentum. So that's what I'm gonna I'm really excited to get to that. So we're recording this before the keynote, so give us a couple more teases. I, I think the stuff you guys would like, candidly, is I feel- Scott's breaking into a rash because we haven't talked about AI yet.
11:43 Oh, we'll get there. We'll get there. So my big idea is that the attention economy is over. I'll leave it there. I, I really think that we are in this idea of the intimacy economy. Now, I didn't create this idea. I stole it from Yuval Noah Harari with full accreditation. But Yuval Noah Harari was stating it in relation, Scott, are you ready? In AI. His idea was that we are creating a technology that can feign intimacy, that can make and look itself feel like us, and that when we do this, we don't understand the ramifications, that it will probably lead to some type of problem with democracy, socialization, humanity, et cetera.
12:26 Big ideas. And I heard him say this, I was actually physically in the audience, and I thought, "I've been tracking a whole bunch of little things in the marketing, retail, media space that line up exactly under this idea in a different way." My idea of the intimacy economy is that we have been living in a shift that hasn't just been a mass of digital, it's actually been very, very little specific things that have made people feel like this is being made uniquely for me. And that the delta today for retailers or brands would be their ability to not be paralyzed by, "If I don't use this, we're doomed. If I do use this AI, my cognition's gonna slowly go away and they won't need me.
13:10 And the worst part of me doing all of this is that my kids have no future on top of it." Like, I think it's the worst marketing story of technology ever- Yeah d- developed or like, I can't even believe that's the story they're selling people. Yeah, yeah. Like, it's mind… Like, I'm like, do they need a C- a CMO? 'Cause they, they should just call me up. I can help them fix that. Yeah. But, but, but what they should be thinking about as a net end, especially the people in the room tomorrow, is wait a second, if it scales the way it does- How can I create an environment where the end user, in this case it'll be customers 'cause it's retailers, feel like everything they're touching with our brand feels like it's just for them? So I, I'll give you like a really quick example of this.
13:52 I do like TikTok. The FYP, the For You page, is amazingly fascinating. Like Scott, if you and I had the exact same interests, uh, weird comic books, bass playing magazines, like I like weird jazz, whatever it might be, we could follow the exact same topics and have completely different FYP pages. Yeah. So when we talk about like what is it that's making it work, I think even in relation to like Reels and other, and Shorts and other things, is that it's very quick to understand not my social graph but my interest graph in a very unique and personal way, to the point where it is almost like that, that old joke where it's like, "If I ever get hit by a car, make sure you delete my playlist," right? 'Cause like you, you don't want to be embarrassed for all the guilty pleasures you have.
14:32 Right. So that would be like one great example of TikTok being at scale only because of how intimate it feels to each person. Another quick little example is you guys use prompts, whether it's Claude or ChatGPT or whatever you use. Why does it do dot dot dot? Do you ever think about … like the reason it does that, I think that's an actual interaction design choice to make it feel like it's writing it just for you, that when you see it come out, like text, right, it doesn't just clump it, it writes it out. Why? Because it feels like it's just for you. And I think there's all of these things, and I got plenty of others, that really demonstrate that we are in this intimacy economy.
15:16 The bigger challenge with that is is we as marketers, as retailers, as businesspeople, are still operating in the attention economy. Yeah. And we're selling it, and I don't think we're there anymore. And the reason I say that is because just look at advertising. Like look at all the AI tools we've had in two and a half years we'll call it. When was ChatGPT? Two and a half years, right? Yeah. Go ask anybody. Go ask anybody in the audience tomorrow. I'm gonna try to ask them if I remember. Tell me where in all of Let's use Meta as an example. Not picking on them, but just use Meta as an example, where they're seeing a better experience 'cause of AI deployment. Are they paying less for ads? Do they understand their customers better? Are they getting better creative out it? Like what are they getting? The vast majority of them will tell you the opposite.
15:58 They're reaching less people. It's costing them more. They're, they can't even see where it is, and yet we are in a world where, what is it? 25, 30 data centers the size of Manhattan is what Meta is building. So two and a half years, what's been depl- I'm not being critical, I'm just saying like in that world, what does it look like? And so again, like I think there's a lot of stories in this that we're not necessarily seeing, and that's why I believe that's why we're out of the attention economy. I think YouTube being the number one media company in the world is another signal because that's not about mass. It's not about them getting licenses to live sports. They don't have the next Squid Game, right? What do they have? They have a bunch of people like us Who are passionate, who are talking to a really interesting audience and communing with them.
16:43 I can't see a signal, and I've been doing this a long time like you guys, that, that pushes me in a world where attention is the game. It's intimacy. So the takeaway for a retailer is they, they need a basically a for you page. So I, I go to retailer.com- Yeah, yeah, yeah … and I've got this hyper-personalized experience? What's crazy interesting is that you see a lot of beautiful signals out of retail. Yeah. I mean, you're seeing beautiful signals out of them. I know… You know, I was looking at who's here, and, and there was one of the, the senior people from Fanatics. I just look what Fanatics did. They were selling highly commoditized sports T-shirts. They got licenses. They built that out. Then they bought Topps. It was a multi-billion dollar acquisition. People thought nothing. They revitalized an entire world of collectibles.
17:26 Those little square cards that are cardboard that was literally they call it junk wax, because there was so much of it- Mm … has become highly priced to the point where, I don't know if you saw recently at the Javits, they had their fa- Fanatics event. They brought in the, the athletes, the p- I mean, they've built an entirely powerful world around it, and I think there are lessons in that that are, are massive to other brands and other retailers. I could countless examples of this, but if you look at it and you splice it down, it speaks to both the intimacy of it and their ability to make… You know, why does it work? It's that connection. We just came from the opening keynote. The Denver Broncos CTO, CMO, what, what were they talking about?
18:06 Community, connection. And I know it was happening. When, when the audience going, "Yeah, we're not a sports team." Right? "When we win something, millions of people won't march a parade in our streets." Although Macy's does get a parade. Yeah, exactly. But Macy's, Macy's has sponsor, I believe is the word. Yeah, yeah. Fair. But in that, like, there's a lot of interesting lessons I think retailers can take in terms of, like, what are the little things we could do to make people feel supremely connected? I mean, I wonder if retailers had great Wi-Fi just alone if that wouldn't be, you know, an amazing experience for people. That wouldn't have, like, six clicks to get onto it. Yeah, yeah, and that… By the way, can we talk about that? How, when was Amazon launched? You guys would know that better than me.
18:47 '94. What's changed? Consider all the tech, all the amazing things we've done visually, even filters. Like, it's amazing that, like, you know, I think about my, my good friend Brett Hurt, Bizarre Voice. Yeah. The customer reviews was a huge thing for that industry. I would've thought video. I actually think the thing that, that will work if they get on board, 'cause again, this goes back to Fanatics and others, back to fans, is like, like a whatnot model. I think I, I'm s- I'm shocked that retailers haven't played more in the whatnot model. Like that ability, like we have a store, how much foot traffic do you get? Like, get your people doing this live and selling and sharing knowledge and, and building brands. Like, what an amazing thing to do.
19:27 Been in the marketplace world before. I was in magenta commerce, and many retailers, they want a marketplace, and then you add it. Uh, like Best Buy kind of famously, they added a marketplace. Right. And the CEO was like, "Why is there an HDMI cable on there that's cheaper than ours? That's bad for us." And it's like, well, that's what the internet is. And then they like shut it down 'cause they were like really worried. So they, they have that merchant prince control problem. Right. And I think- I- … having a bunch of randos selling stuff under your brand would, would freak them out Same. I, I'd add to that, that I think marketplace is the complete homogenization of a brand. One of my kids came to me, they wanted an iPad and, you know, we know thir- was it 30%, the prices went up 'cause of memory.
20:09 Yeah. It was kinda heartbreaking for the poor kid. Like sending him- Right … goes from like 400 to 800 bucks. Like, "Sorry, kid. Welcome to economics," and boom. Good lesson. Yeah, but but in that, you know, oh, I found on, on Best Buy or this, you know, 400… And I'm looking, like it's a third par- You could buy that iPad, that person is selling it in probably 60 different places. Mm-hmm. I feel like marketplace would be an amazing business if they added in the little thing I do over at Thinkers51, which is a touch of curation. Yeah. So I don't under- So to me, the experience is, is, is quite the opposite, and I would tell you that even as a customer, I feel it a little bit in Amazon too. It's like there's so much from so many brands. Yeah. Especially ones you don't know, and I know you guys have talked about that ad nauseam.
20:53 So I, I'm, I'm curious to see if the marketplace at scale still evolves or if you start seeing curation. I think Costco does curation on the marketplace, if they even do that. They do for sure do curation. They- Yeah … they have a shockingly small assortment. It's like 5,000 SKUs. O- online. Yeah. But to put that in perspective, Walmart's 40 million SKUs. Right. Amazon's a billion SKUs. Costco sells 6,000 SKUs online, 4,000 in the store. So- Yeah, 'cause I, I'm, I'm advising a company now that has a couple products moving onto Costco, and th- I was looking at that thinking, "Oh, it's inter- There's a curation there." Yeah. My only thought was maybe it's not a marketplace, 'cause- Yeah, I don't, I don't see that there's, there's a new marketplace. Yeah, it's a… I think they're just curating who they bring on.
21:34 But they're, they're… What I'm saying is they will bring on things that you can't get in a store to make it a more expansive selection, so you… But it's not a marketplace, right? Yeah. Kind of bridging those last two topics, I, I do think it's interesting, first of all, on the, on the personalization point, I, I tend to agree with you. And I, I tell… I sometimes like put on my professor hat and I become a retail historian. That's what we're here for. Yeah. My favorite retail experience is this 400-year-old retailer that's still doing business in London on Bond Street called The Lock Hat Company. Right. Second-longest continuously running retailer in the world. Free before it. Has he told this story 6,000 times on this show?
22:14 This sounds new to me. Yeah. Okay. Oh, okay, good. I don't think Scott's- Finally. ' Cause by the way- He's- … I repeat stories on my show to new guests all the time. I, you're- So it's- Yeah … I love this guy. You've been stuck on this ice vendor for like, since agenda conversation. Yeah, yeah. This is, yeah. This is good. The ice, the ice evolution is a good one too. But- … The Lock Hat Company, this amazing hat company. They make hat for all r- the royals in, in London. They're based in London. You know what their, their core customer experience used to be in the 1600s? You would walk by the front of the store and you would yell, "Hat," through the doorway, and then you would go home. And someone in that store would hear you, recognize your voice. They would go to a paper journal that they had, and they had literally invented this device, this head sizing device that took 26 measurements of all their customers' heads, and they would look up the journal of what hat that customer bought and how they liked it bent and exactly what size it was, and they would make this perfectly bespoke hat, and then they would get on their horse and deliver it to your house.
23:18 Wow. And it was like- The Embassy. We're back to it. Yeah. It's all those people. Are they still doing that? Kind of. Kind of. ' Cause it's the horse one I'm curious about. Yeah. Weirdly enough. Well, some of those roads in London- … like, you would rather be on a horse than a car- Sure. Yeah, yeah … these days, 'cause they were not originally designed- Yeah with, with horseless carriages in mind. But what, what happened, right, so when they started doing that, the entire population of London was, like, 400,000 people, one of the big cities in the world. Right. Right. And then very shortly, it exploded to, like, 160,000 peop- or, or, or 1.6 million people and then 10 million people, and you couldn't deliver that kind of curated bespoke experience at the scale, right?
24:00 Right. And so we all moved into the, these like one-to-many marketing and, you know, the newspaper and the radio and TV and all of these broadcasting things. And the thing that has me excited about AI is if it's used properly, it has the potential to return to that lock hat company experience- This is… And that's intimacy at the scale. Yes. Exactly. This is it. And so, so- The marketplace model has totally won in retail. It's not curated because traditionally curation has always required humans. It's always required Mickey Drexler saying, "These jeans are stylish, these jeans aren't." And so no one could figure out how to scale that to the billion items on Amazon, but the robots can.
24:47 Okay, so, so you think curation is gonna become this interesting AI- middle I think it's part of agent of commerce. Yeah. The… With 11 years of the podcast, I've never gotten a prediction correct, so I hesitate to- Yeah … to say, say I predict it's gonna happen. You're, you're at 40%. Okay. All right. Well, thank, thanks for that. So you're close to a coin flip. I'm almost as accurate as a VC. Yes. What is the difference in that to it knows my purchase history? Like I come onto Amazon and it, it… Is it similar to that or different to that? It's like the TikTok algorithm. It- Okay … it knows what you looked at. So it's gonna be able to give me adjunct things, not- Yeah. And it's tricky because there's lots of cool things that we have in the world now that we didn't used to have. And per your point, Amazon knows your whole purchase history and all these things.
25:30 I would actually argue that per your point, that the experience hasn't changed that much since 19- since 1994. We're awful at using all that capability. That like we haven't delivered on the promise of all of that. Like with the- retail has no way- We never have. No. Uh, I, I have a beloved relationship with a brand, United Airlines. Flown 2 million miles on them. I carry their credit card. I, like they know everything about- They meet him at the gate and give him high fives- Right and a massage. Yeah. Yeah. They, they know everything about me Every single flight I sit on every single week, the screen pops up in front of me and goes, "Welcome, Jason Goldberg. Would you like to sign up for our credit card?" Yes.
26:10 The credit card I used to pay for the flight, right? Tell me, tell me how in 2026 the bank that you bank at is sending you emails asking if you need a checking account. Yeah. Doesn't know your gender, not that that's a big deal, but it, it might be. Yeah, yeah. And so I just argued that, like, even though the technical capability is there for a lot of super rich experiences, w- it's still the first inning of this whole dig- commerce is 6,000 years old. Yeah. Like, we've had digital commerce since 1994. So, like, it's still the first inning, and we still all, for the most part, suck at it. So here's where I'm going, and I'm presenting this tomorrow, so it's fine. It's great. We started off, uh, on the, on the marketing side as like a one-to-many. Yeah.
26:50 Okay? And then we talked about many-to-many, so social, and then we talked about, like, maybe we can get to one-to-one. I don't think that ever happens. I think we're kind of in there. And then in the retail we were talking about omni-channel was like the other way in which you're gonna … You know, e- every slide we saw was, was, uh, the customer at the middle and all this stuff around it. My argument with this intimacy economy as the baseline is that we're moving to what I call one-to-X. One is the retailer, the brand. X is the unlimited amount of, of customers you have. So I actually, like, inverted it, made the brand first, and I'm in that world where I'm like, this is how not only it should feel, because I think it should've felt that in one-to-one.
27:33 We just didn't g- we couldn't get there. We just talked about three examples. Yeah. There'll be probably 20,000 more. Uh, but now it's like there's no excuse. The, the problem I think is that they're deploying it completely wrong. They're, like, trying to do this weird productivity, efficiency internal thing, and I'm like, "Why?" Wouldn't the first thing you should do is do something on the customer experience? That'd be the easiest thing 'cause it won't hurt people, right? Because the deployment problem of AI right now, beyond the fact that it's being board pushed and there's b- just money thrown at it because it has to fit in the craziness of the economy, is that the end person, which is the employee, whether they're VP level or down to some type of administrative job, they're not being told the full story.
28:18 They're being told the first part of the story. It's like, "Here are the tools and do stuff." Maybe it's better than that. Maybe they're getting some training. Like I, everyone's got different variables. We, you know, we heard Jill talk about the fact that, you know, everyone now is still kind of unsure. I get all that. But the second part of that is really the part that no one's being told, which is if we're right about AI- And it's automating all this stuff that we used to actually hire you to do. Here's where you add value as a person. We are not working on that. I don't know what… Do you know one company that's deployed AI in that framework of, "Here it is. Use it. Do all this stuff. Great. And also this is why you're- you bring value to us"?
29:01 Nobody is saying that. So that, that creates a vacuum, and we know what happens with vacuums. It gets filled. And of course, what it's gonna be filled with is a high level of anxiety because we're going back to the marketing pitch of it, which is, "If you don't use it, you'll be fired. If you do use it, you might be automated out of work." And the general sentiment out there is your kids are screwed, right? So I, I find it really amazing that, you know, we're probably gonna have great conversations here over two and a half days, and I promise you, you won't have a conversation like this. No one's gonna ask about that question, and no one is doing that inversion of one-to-one. It's always like brand to this. Well, what if the brand is singular, and now you are doing it to an X, which is the unlimited amount of … I think that that paradigm is, is massively huge.
29:44 And by the way, I think it would cost less than what they're spending on marketing today. Yeah. Which they do. Where I can think of an example, and it's not in retail though, is software developers get are, you know … And maybe it's 'cause they're so mature on AI now. Yeah, it is. Where if y- if you are a developer and you're really good at AI, and you're producing 10 times more, you will get more compensation. So, and there's … So it's not replacing them. It's- Right. And also- It's, it's like a bionic type of thing, you know? They of themselves have removed their skill. They're vibe coding it on their phone. Yeah. They're not in the Matrix- Well, the skill- … with six screens- Yeah … you know, like with jolt. Like they're n- Yeah. No, I got you, but I'm saying that they've … they, they are pushing it to be to the point where they can disrupt themselves so they can just do this stuff.
30:31 Yeah. Yeah. But that has not been the sale to anyone else. Yeah, agreed. It's unbelievable. Yeah. Agreed. Right? Like, like think about writing. I mean, I'm sure you guys use it for content generation. Like my whole thing with using it for content generation is I've just bifurcated it. I'm like, there's blue collar and white collar writing now. Blue collar work writing, give me the keywords for this. Give me 15 great titles for this. Turn this into a completely different way to say this so that I don't get dinged by SEO 'cause I need to write this twice, but if it's repetitive, I'm gonna get D… Like, or I could give you countless blue collar. But the white collar, like what's the idea? I wanna put those words in. But writing hasn't bifurcated, so this is the panic, is you have copywriters who are going, "Okay, the average piece of copy is average."
31:18 Claude, ChatGPT, it can do better than average right now. Mm. Right? This isn't … Like I get when writers are holding their words precious, and all true. But the stuff that we do day to day, like come on. Like first that corporate kind of like soulless content. But if we move that into where is it? That's blue collar content. We gotta do the brochure, we gotta this. It can have life and, and, and, and … But it's not that type of this work- Yeah … where it's gotta be the speech, it's gotta be the article, it's gotta be that. So if you can do that, and then have time to do this, imagine the beautiful content that will come out. But it's not the story we're selling anybody in marketing or advertising or in any of our agencies. The copywriters who work in that organization that you work for right now are panicking.
32:03 Yeah. Because no one has given them that part, and that's part … That is the same thing. Here are the tools And now we're gonna show you where your real value lies. Now you're gonna … And the coders figured it out. Yeah. They're doing incred- I mean, you go to the Valley and you see these people, they are literally vibe coding on their phone by voice. The vast majority of them are like, "If you're not using WhisperFlow, like just talking to your computer, you're missing the whole point." Prompt, that was the thing today. Prompting is dead. You should just be talking to your computer. Yeah. Some of these people are talking to their computer for 10 minutes before the prompt goes. Yeah, and they have a pedal, and they've got the whole speaker- Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I've seen that. So, I mean, where are we in this world? Like, that's the thing. And again, that goes back to the intimacy economy, right?
32:43 'Cause, uh, I mean, the, there, there is a secondary part to this which is when somebody figures … I think Jack Dorsey just announced this new thing where he's doing like a Slack- Buzz but for collaborative- You know. But the collaboration is- Yeah, yeah, for bots and for people … for, for agents and people. Yeah. I think there's something here where it's like why haven't we, and I guess 'cause the technology's too nascent, it is the most uncollaborative technology I've ever seen in my life. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, what are we supposed to do if we wanna work together? Am I supposed to sit next to you with the iPad and we both take turns? Like, so someone has to crack that too, where it's like how do we actually do projects and have multiple … And that when your pr- like, if your prompt sucks and his is great, like we have something. 'Cause otherwise you're gonna screw up his work.
33:26 Like, you can't even jump in on his project. Yeah. Yeah. So that's the other part of it, too, where I think it's so, so for coders, makes sense. Most of them work in solitary. They're given a chunk, something to solve, and off they go. It's the collaborative part, whew. So complex Yeah, we just started using… So Claude has a new feature where you can tag it in on Slack. Right. And it's really cool because you can… So I'm in, like, the sales channel, and I was showing the salespeople how I would build a one-pager, and then they can… And I'm iterating, right? Right. And they can, like, see the whole process. They can see the final result. Can they jump in on the process? And then it's… Yeah. Yeah, they build- And then they'll jump in and say- Do things screw up? Sometimes, yeah, which is actually part of the learning process. Okay. And I'll say, "Well, you, you, you didn't-" Like, you made it worse.
34:07 They, they notoriously… You l- you learn after you prompt enough the wordier you are, the better- Right … which is kind of like the opposite world where we've been- So it's good to hear. I didn't know. Yeah. Like, it's still a human. So we're just- but we're super early in this. Yeah, I mean, this is the thing, too. It's like, oh, you learned something new. It's like, when did they add that? This week? Like, okay. Like, I feel like we're still in that cycle where it's like, oh, if you're not… If you don't give everybody access to ChatGPT, you're crazy. Next week, it was like, "Oh, ChatGPT is dead. It's Claude." Now like, "Oh, no, no, no. Codex is great. You gotta go buy it." I'm like, what company… Like, I get you can do this as an individual coder and you're making YouTube videos. You're brilliant. But what company could move like that? I'm sure the harnesses, which is what they call Codex and- Yeah … Claude Code and Cowork, I think they'll have a team. Yeah. They'll have a multiplayer. I see. It's c- it's… I'm sure they're using it internally. I'd be curious to see, like, how do you do that when you're interacting, especially in core.
34:51 It'd be interesting to see how they're… how they collaboratively work, like- The, the agent adds a lot of value 'cause it can tell you- Yeah … like, it did a thing where I was talking about a customer, and it's like, "Well, Adam has a call with them tomorrow," and I never even, like- So good thought of it. And I was like, "Oh." And it… But it's, like, the agent informing me of- Yeah … a piece of information I didn't have- Yeah … without Adam being… You know, I didn't have to go look at his calendar. S- so every week, I do a thing on, on my… Like, I don't call it a blog anymore on my, my platform, Thinking with Mitch Joel, and it's called Six Links that Make You Think. That's also been going 16 years. I haven't stopped every Saturday. Two of my buddies, Alistair Croll, Hugh McGuire. Alistair is one of the guys behi- behind StartupFest and FWD50, and he built… He's a real intelligent coding human being.
35:32 He built an entire world for bots for events like this, and he ran it at StartupFest. So essentially, you'd go in and let your agent go. These agents were, like, pitching each other. They came up with talk ideas. Yeah. They were networking. They were DM'ing people, and at the end, you get, like, what did your agent experience at this conference, all the notes from every session. You can't attend every session. There's concurrence. There's this. So a- that world's interesting to me, but I'd love to know from you guys, are you, are you really sold on this agentic shopping thing? Like, do you think that that's- Depends on the definition, so we should start there. Ooh. Yes. ' Cause this, I'm really c- 'cause this is, like, my whole, like, a sh- like, I, I don't buy a lot of stuff, but I love to shop.
36:13 Yeah. Like, I love to ma- mall rat, and I love to just look at stores. I just don't really wanna buy a lot of stuff, and I, I see in myself that there's certain things I'm okay running on a subscription service, but there's other things, like, I just kinda just do wanna pick it up or wander around. And I find that in the retail world, there's so much push towards this idea of, like- I don't know, I think people love hanging out and shopping and doing stuff Some people for some missions. Right. Like, I think it's mission-based. And so that, that ends up being the, the secret sauce, right? Is for … In different moments, we all want different things. I, I spent a lot of time in my past at Best Buy, and I was part of this really interesting customer centricity experiment where, like, we invented these personas, and then we literally built physical stores for each persona that Where we tried to make everything exactly how Barry would want it or how Joe would want it, right?
37:07 And a, a huge debate in each of these stores, is this a self-service store or is it a sales-assisted store? Right. Yeah, yeah. Does Barry enjoy the treasure hunt and he wants to figure it out for himself, or does he wanna go to the smartest, best salesperson that he's ever met that can help him answer that question, right? And the, the unfortunate fallacy of our problem, project was that there was a binary answer to that. Yeah. And the, and the answer is he wants all of those things, or she, often in the same visit, by the way. Right. And serendipity. Like, this is the other thing too, where it's like when we saw the web develop at, at first, like the original Yahoo page that you could customize, that was amazing.
37:47 I like sports. I went to sports. I have music. I like music. And then you realize like, oh, like, 'cause, 'cause I'm on the other side too, I'm a publisher and I'm an editor and I'm thinking about … You lose all serendipity And, and there's something magical, I think, about I'm going into Best Buy 'cause I want the DJI Osmo 3, and then, oh, there's this remarkable tab, or there's, like, these mics, or there's this, this cool, like, stand for my phone that'll clip to my MagSafe. And, and I, again, we, we, we look at things through such weird blinders. Yeah. It's, it's amazing to me. And- That's why agentic shopping to me feels, like, really- Yeah … strange. And I love this stuff, and I'm like, I don't- So- So I think your definition is agents… You tell an agent to go buy something for you, and that, that's how a lot of people define- Totally.
38:30 But yeah. Yeah. I, I think it actually… And, and to your point on curation, if you start to use… Go to, go to Amazon and then start at Rufus, now called Alexa, For Shopping, which we could talk about. Yeah. Yeah. Not, not a huge fan of the rebranding. Just be known as Rufus. Yeah. Yeah. You will find it to be… It will start to f- You'll start to feel that in the discovery process, it adds a lot of value. Um, so some of it is kinda like that give me the technical spec when I want it and then help me, like, just explore. I think it's gonna be so hard. I mean, like, I go, I go to Amazon every day 'cause I love my Kindle. Yeah. And Kindle Deals, greatest thing ever. And they have Today Only. Yeah. So you have awesome books a $1.99. I'll tell you what makes it magical.
39:10 It's the fact that it's not grabbing what I actually bought and feeding me all that. Yep, yep. I'm like, oh, like, you know, you wake up one day, you hear something. Oh, maybe I should check out Brandon Sanderson in sci-fi. Like, I've never… And I just kinda see all this stuff, and I, I just think there's this weird serendipity in human experience that we think that if we just refine everyone's usage exactly right, and I'm like, ah. I, I'm, like, really curious to see how that plays out in retail. Yeah. Really curious. Yeah. All these techs, they do have the potential to be either, right? So I would argue per, per your point- A lot of the digital commerce technology to date has ruined serendipitous discovery.
39:51 Yeah. We have a great joke in our industry, e-commerce saw buying but broke shopping. Exactly. Right? 100%. And so yeah, when you go to Target, you walk by all the other brands, and you discover stuff you never knew you wanted. But when you type something into a search engine, you laser beam right to what you're buying, and you, you bypass all that other stuff. And by the way, we pulled a hey squirrel moment where, like, we just kinda jumped, but my question on when Amazon was created w- was moving towards this thought of I can't believe, like, we're sitting here, and the overall, like, user online shopping experience online hasn't changed. It blows my mind. Like again, going back to Whatnot, I feel like that's a little bit different. But I, I'm still amazed it's, like, image, title, description.
40:32 Like, I know there's a habituation that we have as humans. I get it, but I'm just shocked in the world of digital con and how we moved from, like, reading to videos to images that… And as they try to integrate, it just doesn't seem to- Yeah. There's been 1,000 try-on tools that just- Yeah … don't ever seem to get traction. They were doing those. Like, I remember we had, like, My Virtual Model was the big one out of where I, I… That was when I was at Mao. That was, like, 20, uh, 20 years ago. It was, like, almost 30 years ago. Yeah. It's crazy. Let's do one more quick topic. Yeah. One thing, you, you've written a lot about trust. Talk a little bit about, little bit about we're, you know, we're doing all this more automated stuff, and yet trust is… What's, what's it gonna do to trust? What's your prediction on that? Yeah. Well, first, when you say trust, I was thinking about, I can't remember.
41:13 Hernan Cortes wrote a nonfiction book called Trust. It is not even related to this, but if you haven't read it, fantastic book. Just it has nothing to actually do with the word trust, but brilliant writing. Uh, I think it won a Pulitzer. Trust is an interesting thing. I don't know how you guys feel. I'm always in these conferences where the person from Edelman is doing the trust barometer. And there's something about it that I, I love them, love the company, love the idea, but I'm always like, "Why are we surprised?" Like, why are we surprised that trust keeps falling and falling if we look at just how our governments act, our social structures, our confidence, the noise, the echo chambers, the… So I actually think, going back to this idea of the intimacy economy, that this is where we can, I'll say, rebuild trust.
42:03 And if you look at some of the politicians who've won recently, whether you like their political views or not, a lot of it is driven on these very, like small type of ecosystems. So I look at it less as trust, and my, my thing, I have an acronym called PACE. The C in PACE is for commune. It's not community, it's not get together, it's not hang. It's, it's what happens when we do these things. To me, retailers, people who spend more time focusing on how they can commune with one another or facilitate that are gonna be the ones that win. I spent a lot of time in the early 2000s talking about community, and every branch built community, and I realized really quickly, like, call it 2004, it wasn't working, and I was unfortunately calling my peers out.
42:51 It's like, "You have to build community." I was like, "I don't think a lot of customers wanna be part of a bank community or, like, a veterinarian community." Like, I, I just don't think that that's the case. I do think that if you're a vet, if you're a vet, you have a great opportunity to help your patients and customers commune. These are great places where you can get, like, really, you know, special organic food for your pet. This is where, you know, if you got a new pet, this is where you can go and it's a safe dog run. And I believe that things like that spark a massive connection to it. There's, um, a screenshot I'll show tomorrow of… I mean, it just looks like the most beautiful co-working space, and it's a bank in Poland.
43:31 And what they realized was, like, they have a space like this, and there are, like, fake plastic trees, those airport ropes, and people stand… Broken pens. Nothing looks good. It's all dusty. The pamphlets on a coffee table that's, what is that? And they were like, "What should we be doing?" Well, what if we actually gave space to our customers to, to work, to have a nice coffee, maybe have a conversation, maybe have a book reading. Like, again, they're not building community, they're creating moments to commune. And I'm gonna guess that if you're walking down a street and thinking about your bank, and you realize you could get some co-working space there for free if you have a checking account or whatever, grab a coffee, you're probably more inclined, like, in a simplistic way- So I don't look at trust as like the, "Do we trust?"
44:14 Like, I think it's like table stakes. The product's gotta be good, it's gotta be delivered fast, it's gotta be priced well, it's got to have great follow-up, great service, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. I think it's really gonna come from how brands facilitate those things. By the way, we see this at scale in things like drops. Right. It's like, what happens when 300 people line up for a store? I'm not talking about Swatch and, and AP. That was not a good example. It was a bit chaotic for that. But, but even that, do you not think people were talking in those lines about watches and what they like, and what do you like, and what … You know, you, you, we used to go to concerts- Yeah and not be on our phones, and this is the reason we have the pouches now at Jack White shows.
44:55 But what happened at those concerts is you actually communed, not only with the music and the experience, but you communed with people. You met people Retail was that. And I think, by the way, a lot of people our age or similar age, we are very nostalgic for that. Like, if I could … If we could go back in time to, to when you were 14, and we could go back to those stores you used to hit on Saturday. Yeah. Now, as a 50-plus-year-old person, would you love … I would l- I, I can't think of something else I would rather do. Because one is I would take more advantage of it. I'd have better conversations with the clerks instead of being maybe intimidated or unsure, like, they're gonna think I'm shoplifting or something. But we met- I actually was shoplifting- You were raised- So that's, yeah … that, that was you.
45:36 Yeah. Yeah. He was testing the security. Yeah, prevention. Yeah. I was just walked out- I believe it was- … way before Amazon. Yeah, yeah. And now he's giving the keynote at NRF on prevention. Yeah. Yeah, it's great. Yeah. So those things to me are, like, the, the real power of, of You know, it's, it's beyond trust to me. It's this amazing connection you feel to it. And there's so many brands that do this. So Hot Wheels is such a great example of that. I mean, it's … You, people don't think about that brand. It's, like, my favorite case study. If I have time, I'll do it tomorrow. I probably won't. Think of it as, like, a dollar product, but it's not. Like, look at the product SKU. Look at the treasure hunts. Look at their in-person events that they do with Walmart. Look at their Red Line business. Look at what they're doing even … By the way, they're successful with NFTs. Mm. Totally successful with NFTs.
46:17 And all they're really doing is giving people who love cars an opportunity to commune. It's unbelievable. So I, I think that that to me is the win here. No, I think that, that is a great point. I, like, we do talk a lot with trust about clients, and I, I'm kind of with you. I have a … It's a double-edged sword. I actually think it's super important, and when we look at what experiences win versus lose, like, the intangible difference is- It just feels like a table stake is trustworthy, yeah Like, again, like, does what it says, priced well- Yeah … get great service. I trust you- Yeah … 'cause, like, it worked. But I, I think it's impossible to measure, and I think Edelman's survey of 40,000 people, do you trust this or do … Like, trust is a subconscious thing.
46:58 Like, you can't- How do you define trust, sir? Yeah. Yeah. How do you feel about surveys, James? Yeah, I'm not a big fan of, of stated preferences. I like to, I like to enjoy- Tried to close this out, and now- Yeah … here we go. Yeah. Now we're gonna jump into the whole thing. No, but, uh … And so I, I do think the jury's out on all of this tech, and I, I … You've written about this. It has the potential to be more trustworthy, and it has the potential to erode trust, right? And I think in the wild right now, there's lots of examples of both. Hopefully, the trustworthy examples will win out, and natural selection will kick in. We got a cup, but I'll give you a great one. Can I give you a great one? Yeah. Have … Did you hear about … God, was it in Canada? They were, they used AI voice to change … Did you hear about this?
47:44 To change the dialect of the, of the person providing the service to sound more American or Canadian. So they're based in India or wherever. So they go from sounding jerky to sounding friendly? From s- sounding like they have an accent to sounding like that. You know, what were they seeing? They were actually seeing it move the needle in terms of a positive reaction. But then when people found out, they got really dour on it. Yeah. So this is that thing about trust too. It's like sometimes the metrics will tell you something versus like now the big thing in the world was, uh, multicast fiction audiobooks, you saw this, are scoring better than AI created than human voice. And it's … My whole world's gone crazy over this. And it's like, well, if you told them that it's an AI voice, they would have a completely different reaction.
48:29 So now … And, and, and what's the trust? Dan, I read from you that they're preferring the AI narrator- Yeah. Yes, yes, yes, yes … to the, a real narrator for audiobooks, right? That's the point. Yeah. And but if you tell them it's AI, they'll, "I don't want." Yeah. "No, it's bad." It's, it's a game changer. Yeah. So then by not telling them, they like it more, but y- you lost your trust. Yeah. Yeah. You lied. To build trust, you have to lie. So it's exactly what you're saying, yeah. Yeah. It, it's a tricky conundrum. And that's a perfect place to leave it because once again, we've used up our allotted time. Mitch, we usually wrap up by asking where to find guests on the, on the interweb. But you're all over the interwebs. Um- Thinking with Mitch Joel is the best right now. Yeah. And so we'll, we'll put links to everything, but we'll put that at the top. And thank you so much for taking time out to- I, I'm humbled to be with you guys. It's a … It is a mutual admiration society.
49:10 Great to be here. Yes. Yeah. Thanks, Mitch. You've been listening to The Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us in iTunes or visit jasonandscot.com.
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed