EP075 - Tumi & DealNews live from ShopTalk
EP075 - Tumi & DealNews live from ShopTalk
Charlie Cole (@CharlieCole) is Global Chief Ecommerce Officer at Tumi, and Dan de Grandpre (@dan_degrandpre) is CEO of Dealnews. We caught up with both of them at a networking event hosted by Scot Silverman at ShopTalk.
Don't forget to like our facebook page, and if you enjoyed this episode please write us a review on itunes.
Episode 75 of the Jason & Scot show was recorded live from Shoptalk in Las Vegas on Monday March 20th.
Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at SapientRazorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:02 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here are Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. This episode is being recorded live from Shoptalk in Las Vegas on Monday, March 20th. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, and as usual, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Jason, and hey, Jason and Scott Show listeners.
0:44 Jason, we have another first here on the Jason and Scot Show podcast. We are recording live from the semi-annual Scott Silverman and Alan Dick E-commerce Influencer party. Um, so we're, just to set the scene, we're in the big beautiful Aria. We're in the, a penthouse, a multi-level penthouse apartment. We have a beautiful view of the Las Vegas Strip. And we went amongst the guests and found two of the most inebriated folks we could to, uh- to be on the podcast. Uh, so first let's, uh, excited to introduce Charlie Cole. He is the Global Chief E-commerce Officer of Tumi. Hi, Scott. Hi, Jason Hey, thanks for being on the show. We really appreciate it. Um, we like to just randomly grab people that have no prep, so this is gonna be good.
1:26 That's what I'm good at. Yes. Let's do it. Yeah. Uh, and then we also have Dan DeGrandpre. Did I say that right? Close enough. All right. And he is the CEO of DealNews. Glad to be here, guys. Awesome. Have either of you ever listened to one of our podcasts? I have. I have as well. Whoa, and you still agreed to be on? Yeah. Wow, that's, uh- Absolutely that's also another first. That's exciting. Yeah, so, um, so Charlie, let's start with you. So you're, uh, obviously in- involved with the e-commerce operations of Tumi. Um, the one question we ask everyone is w- tell us a little bit about your role. So, uh, what's that involve and what does it not involve? So, uh, my role's changed a little bit over the last four months because of Tumi's acquisition by Samsonite.
2:07 Uh, so Samsonite Corp., I think most people think of Samsonite as a brand. It's actually really more like a holding company. They own brands like Samsonite, American Tourister, Hartmann, Speck, uh, High Sierra, and now Tumi. Mm-hmm. Um, and so with that change in role, uh, I now have direct P&L ownership from a digital perspective on any pure play channel, and so that includes Tumi.com as well as Amazon.com. What it does not include is Nordstrom.com. That is still managed by the, the, the manager of the, uh, major account from a brick-and-mortar perspective- Yeah … 'cause it drastically outweighs that of the pure play dot com perspective. Mm-hmm. And then Sam- For now. For now. Yeah, for now. Mm-hmm. And then on the Samsonite side, I'm kind of, I, I, I refer to myself- as sort of a global kinda consultant as understanding where should we centralize, where should we not centralize things on a global basis across the brand portfolio.
2:54 Mm-hmm. Uh, and candidly, still trying to figure out what that really means because it's a relatively new development, but hopefully that sums it up. Cool. Has that, um… So tell us more about the acquisition. That, I'm kinda new to that. Is that, uh, uh… So it seems like you've expanded your sphere of influence, which is awesome. Um, is there kind of a… I realize it's like a holding company for brands, but is there kind of a horizontal thing where, uh, you don't have multiple e-commerce groups, multiple site technologies, multiple buying groups or, you know, all those kinds of things? Uh- Sales teams … it, it's, it's about as, uh- About as multiple as it can get in the sense that Samsonite's organization was entirely decentralized by region. So you had an e-commerce team in China, Korea, Japan, Singapore, Malaysia, uh, Canada, US, Europe, uh, you know, N- Nigeria.
3:41 And so, you know, that allows a lot of autonomy, and it allows a lot of the ability to move quickly. But it also meant that when I initially met with the board, they had 38 different ESP contracts. Hmm. Right? Wow. And so, you know, you kind of have to take the bad with the good in your structure, and I think if anyone's been in business long enough, we know that no structure's perfect. And so I guess my role is kind of understanding where their structure is limiting digital expansion in general, and at the same time trying to align on digital best practices in a way that we can scale on a not only multi-country, but multi-brand level. Because a portfolio offers a lot of complexity, but overal- uh, it offers a lot of opportunity as well.
4:23 Yeah, and are you finding that, uh You're having to manage all those conflicts now as you're, you're selling product direct and you're supporting the channel, and as you get more serious about your own direct efforts, and obviously the fact that they hired you, um, sort of indicated a renewed effort in direct-to-consumer. Is that a concern for the wholesale partners? Are they pleased to see you guys getting more digital chops? How does that- Yeah, I mean, it's, i- i- it's an interesting dichotomy, right? Because, um, uh, I feel like we can be a much better partner to our wholesale partners because of having some semblance of, of expertise at, at, at the top, right? B- and I know we were, we were chatting before about this, like one of our major partners across the portfolio is eBags in the United States.
5:06 You know, they frankly get it. They're digital pure play people. They are happy to share data with you, and if you sh- if they share data with you, you increase your co-op dollars with them, right? And you have the same sort of, uh, kind of reciprocity that you would see in traditional digital marketing, and you can span that across co-op. Now, when you try to do that with a Bloomingdale's or a Saks, it's a very different conversation, right? Because they are not a pure play digital. They weren't born and raised in that organization. And so they think of co-op where you, you really just kind of throw money into the chasm, and that's kind of where it is, right? And you get a page and a catalog or you get a whatever it may be. And so, um, I hope that most of the time we're adding value to all the partners, but I think at the same time, uh, I think all of us as digital guys still sort of feel like the Martians at times, e- especially when you're working with pure play brick-and-mortars that kind of started doing digital in the last five to 10 years.
5:56 Mm-hmm. Yep. And I'm imagining you also have a pretty broad range in terms of your partners of their digital maturity. Like, you have some really- Yeah … digitally mature retailers that you're selling through, and you have some people that are, like, pretty early in their digital evolution. Yeah, and there, and there's a really interesting dynamic that's happening in all of the, let's just call them omnichannel retailers, even though saying omnichannel, I think at this point, is sort of about as cliche as it gets. They all have verticalized across the cost segment, so they all have an off-price channel. Nordstrom has Nordstrom Rack. Saks has Saks OFF 5TH. Um, you know, Macy's is sort of kind of, it's still a little bit homogenous, but they're a little bit more down market as far as an AOV is concerned in the first place. And so what you realize is, a, a lot of those organizations are still siloed from a P&L perspective.
6:41 So if I grow the Saks business by $10 million, then we should be really happy, but if we do that by pay, taking $2 million away from Gilt and putting $12 million in the top end retail, not everyone's happy. A- and your buyer in the Gilt group is, is not really excited about that. And so, um, you would hope that structure wouldn't get in the way of progress, but that's just kind of the way it is. Sure. Cool. Dan, let's pull you into the conversation. So you're CEO of DealNews. Tell us… So pretend, uh, we don't know, uh, what DealNews is. How do you explain it at a, let's, let's say a cocktail party? Um, what- Sure. Well- … does it feel like? Hypothetically. Hypothetically. Hypothetically. Yeah. So let's- … let's say that you had, uh, uh, Samsonite luggage- Uh-huh … and, uh, you had an offer that you were running on it, and you wanted to connect more buyers to your offer.
7:26 That's what we do. Uh, we, we, uh, we have a, a series of products, websites, email, apps that, uh, reach about 10, 15 million people depending on, on the time of year, uh, that all we do is connect people with things that you already have an offer on. So, uh, we just do that in a way that's, uh, hand curated so our conversion rates are better than anybody's. Okay. So there's, um, in the world of retail some people call them, like, super affiliate sites, and you've got, uh, you guys. Let's see. You've got, um, FatWallet, Slick Deals- Yeah … RetailMeNot. There's a lot of these kinds of things. Help us, kind of help, help us kinda get a feeling for the space- Sure … where you guys fit in. Well, FatWallet's more cash back, uh, uh, loyalty based program like Ebates- Ebates, yep … is, is the owner.
8:07 Uh, RetailMeNot's, uh, bread and butter is coupon SEO. That's, you find them when you- Google for, uh, vendor name coupon. Got it. And that's not our business. Uh, we're- we're- we're more like Slick- Slick, uh, Deals is a user-generated content site. Uh, that is, uh, how they, uh, define themselves. We're an editorial curated site. Got it. And so the purpose to the user is very similar. The difference for us is the value we can deliver to the retailer is, um, is find the product offers that they're interested in and connect people. When it's user-generated content, you're entirely dependent on what the users are posting, which is great, and it's- it's not necessarily always what you as a retailer want. Got it. So just kind of to restate that, so Slick Deals is more like Reddit where it's kinda like users submit things, and it's thumbs up, thumbs down kinda thing.
8:52 Yeah. Um, RetailMeNot is more coupon-based, and then you guys kind of go out and curate. Tell us, tell us about the curation model. Do you have, like, this massive team, and there's electronics person and a housewares person and a this kind of- Yeah, it's a lot like that how does, how does that work? We have, uh, our staff is over 100, uh, people. We had 105 at the end of 2016, and, uh, we actually start in Dublin. We have an office in Dublin. Wow. And we start curating there so that there are i- interesting new deals in our products, uh, by the time the East Coast is waking up. Even though- Hmm … we are global, all of our audience is US-based for all intents and purposes. Mm-hmm. And so they, uh, use our software. We have a lot of data about what, uh, our customers are buying, our users are buying, and they have expertise. And one of the things that a- always struck me as- as most amazing about our process is, uh, our curators are trained by us using our software and our techniques, and we're able to take people from Ireland who don't know what a Target is and actually get them to be very efficient where they can identify… We have a metric called, uh, prediction where we predict, uh, the response, uh, the conversion rate that's gonna happen for, uh, one of the deals we list.
9:55 And we, uh, we have a game that goes on with our staff where they try to be best at that. Hmm. And the best performer of 2016 was an Irishman. Yeah. And that, uh, who had basically three years ago never heard of- never heard of, uh, almost all the brands that, uh, almost all the retailer brands that we all know. Yeah. The, um… So are you able to close the loop, and can you go back to a- a retailer or brand and say, "Hey, we see that there's, we think there's this opportunity for a deal that looks like this"? Can… 'Cause the curation… So there's a couple ways to curate. You can, like, take the universe of deals out there- Yeah but then you could also be more proactive and seems like- The best partners … because you're not user-generated- Yeah … you, you know, and these people get to be experts at these things. You could probably tailor the deals better by recommending them, and then they kinda become more exclusive to you, right?
10:40 Because- That's right … why not, quote-unquote, exclusive, but, uh, they're, you know, unique to you in that you've kinda worked with the retailer or brand to create them. Think that's when we get to the next level with the retailer. We typically start with the feed that they're giving to something like ChannelAdvisor. And so we can take that product feed and work with it to identify, uh, what offers that we need to connect people with, and over time, we're able to say, "We really are finding these types of offers are performing best and can recommend that you find more of those kind of, uh, offers for our audience." Yeah. One of the biggest controversies in this space was, I think it was Tony Hsieh, and I can't remember what year it was. This was, like, going on probably eight years ago, and he got on stage and he said, "All these coupon sites are garbage, and it's not incremental. Um, they're just stealing your own… You're paying them for your own customers.
11:24 Uh, we're gonna stop doing it." And they were like these… They kinda came out- Yeah … there's a Harry and David thing that happened around then, too. Do you- Yeah. Yeah … uh, so there's like these two retailers came out very against these kind of like, quote-unquote, super affiliates. Um, what's your reaction to that and, and how, how do you- I think our biggest marketing problem when we're talking to potential retailers, uh, clients, is to distinguish ourselves from that- Mm that we are not, uh, somebody who generates sales for you that you already had, and we just steal your margin because we do discovery. So we are much more like, uh, search. We don't have the volume that search has, uh, but we have, uh, it, uh, we're, because of our curation techniques and, and the years of software behind it, we're able to really do a very good job at that that's gonna perform much more like search and sales that you otherwise wouldn't have got.
12:09 One of the things that, uh, really trouble us is last click attribution, where people will come to our site, uh, will find something they wouldn't have found otherwise, send them to the retailer, and then there's a coupon code search at the end, and, uh, we don't get the credit- Mm … uh, for that. And that's… It's a, it's a frustration. I actually have talked to a lot of people in our industry about it. I know, Charlie, it's something that you've talked about. It's, it's very frustrating from our perspective that, uh, those, those, um, sales are being credited, frankly, to the wrong source. Yeah. Well, luckily only about 97% of retailers are using last click attribution. So we've only got 97 point… percent more to go. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. It's just baffling to me. I, uh, you know, I, I've waltzed in and out of kind of a, let's just call it corporate role to entrepreneurial role, and, and one of the things I was most excited about when I came back to a corporate role is all the technologies you can't afford when you're an entrepreneur.
12:59 Yeah. And one of the things I was most excited to look at was attribution, and candidly, it hadn't evolved, right? Yeah. In, in, like, five to seven years it, it was still the same two to three players offering the same things. And I, I've seen some cool stuff this week at ShopTalk, actually, that maybe gives me a, a semblance of hope. Um, but to your point, I, I don't think your 97 is that far off. It's still far away. Yeah. I, I don't blame it on tools anymore, though. Like, I, I actually think there's pretty darn good attribution models built into a lot of the tool… Like, Google Analytics certainly- Yeah, the, the- … has perfectly serviceable- the modal comparison tool is perfectly fine. Yeah … um, they're just- For the most part not used, right? Like, they're, you know, it's, it's cultural at this point. It's more people than it is tools. Well, and it's, it's the easy- uh, like the biggest epidemic in, i- in corporate America in general is self-preservation, right?
13:46 And, and the best way you can justify your own existence is an ROI that everybody can understand. Yeah. Right? And, and, and so when, when Dan's saying that to me, like, why try to overcomplicate something even though candidly it probably should be complicated just a little bit- Mm-hmm … beyond last click. But yeah, it drives me nuts. The, I guess the irony is that last click model is disproportionately under-representing your value to the sale. It's also way, uh, misrepresenting that digital leader's value to his organization. Absolutely. Um, because that lack of multi-touch attribution is also under, uh, referencing digital's value to those in-store purchases. Yeah. I had that conversation with, uh, uh, I can't remember the gentleman's name, a director of search marketing at Macy's, at Catalyst a couple weeks ago in Nashville.
14:32 And I asked- I hear that's a great event. Uh, it's, you know- … it's the people behind it who are really amazing. It's the sex reference. Yeah. Yeah. The, the newer people that are behind it. Yeah. So, uh, he's, he, uh, uh, owned up to the fact that basically they don't have a solution. They, they, they tried solutions. Nothing works for them. And, uh, and since he's search, he, he really gets bothered by this because- Carthen … he knows. Yeah. It was Carthen. Yeah. Yeah. Right. I don't wanna put words in his mouth, but I, I, I think that he would be one of the first people to say, "It sucks to be the guy owning search and you're not getting credit for the sales you generate." Well, and- Yeah … and not to beat the thing to death, but ultimately it limits your growth, right? Mm-hmm. I- if you cannot justify top-of-funnel traffic, you will not grow.
15:14 Mm. Right? A- a- and I mean, best case, well, put another way, you're 100% reliant on your brand to grow. Yeah. Right? You're not actually generating new interest because people need to hear about you through word of mouth or something, but you can't justify, for example, unbranded search, display marketing, uh, non-promotional affiliates. Like, uh, you, you cannot justify it because, you know, if you have an ROI of .7 to one in unbranded search, frankly if someone said that to me, I'd be like, "That's pretty damn good. Like, that's not bad. And as a mono brand, like, I could live with that." Mm-hmm. But the reason I think that is 'cause I know it backs into a four to one, five to one, six to one view-through or first click, right? It, it, it, it- but you will not grow and you will not generate incremental eyeballs.
15:55 You know, what you see people do is they, um, they get really optimized on this last click stuff, and then their volume goes way down, but their return on ad spend goes way up. Yeah. And then, but then, like, they miss their revenue target They justify their existence then. It wasn't me. I was the market. I was- There's this cycle, so then they do that, and they're like, "Whoa, we need to do more top of funnel," and then there's, like, this kind of- Yeah … you know, oscillating that kind of happens. But- There's a, uh, there's a new tri- uh, chasing last click is, that's a multi-billion dollar business, and the new trick doing, uh, for that right now is loyalty, where- uh, you're seeing coupon sites in- introduce loyalty programs so they can absolutely close the loop on last click. And if they're building the engineering and the logistics to be able to do, um, cash back programs to close the last click when they're already doing coupon SEO, I think that says something for you the retailer to figure out.
16:38 Like, is this really where you should be putting- Right … your money if, if the, if the system is being gamed that way? Yeah. We, we're actually producing a e-commerce movie, and I feel like you've just given us the title. Chasing the Last Click. Chasing the Last Click. Chasing the Last Click. Yeah. Yeah. It's like Kevin Smith's bastard child- Yeah of Chasing Amy. Yeah. Yeah, I like that. Cool. Let- let's take it up kind of 30,000 feet. You guys are here at Shop Talk. Is this your… Were you guys here last year? Is this your- My second Shop Talk. Second. It's my first actually. Your first? Okay. What, um, what are some of the themes that you've picked up at the show, just, just broadly? Um, fear. Mm-hmm. There's a lot of fear of Amazon. There's a lot of fear of the lack of- Jason and I make a living off fear of Amazon. I know. Yes. So it's, it's good. Fear of Amazon is, is, it's- Phew.
17:19 It's alive and well. I mean, there's, there is a lot of, of, uh, way to make money from that, but it doesn't change the fact that I don't think anybody knows what to do about it. Uh- I have to tell, I have to tell my favorite story, uh, of the, of the shop talk experience so far. I was walking the Expo Hall and this guy came up to me and he said, "Hey, um, I'd like to invite you to this thing," and he hands me a flyer, and it was, um, brand protection by Amazon. Really? And, and I looked at the guy and I was like, "That's the biggest oxymoron I've seen this show." Which, like… And he was from Amazon. They were putting on a clinic about their new tools around brand protection. Yeah. So that actually happened to me on the Expo Hall today. Yeah, the registry. Yeah. The brand registry Yeah, I didn't, I didn't go. That's actually really- … really good targeting on that guy's part.
17:59 Yeah. I'm sort of impressed. Well, I mean- Yeah … th- you realize that you can't walk through the Expo Hall with your, your thing on- Yeah … your lanyard- Yeah. Yeah … because you just, you, you know, they, they pick you off. As celebrities we have this thing. Yeah, clearly. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, uh- Everyone wants to be on the podcast. But I mean, I think for, for me the, for me the, the… I actually shot a vendor over to my head of marketing today and said, "The theme du jour is AI." Yes. And, and my- Jason's running a panel on that … my, my favorite is every single AI, uh, technology, and I just used air quotes on the radio 'cause I'm an idiot, uh, is basically Sortona's offering from six years ago. Mm-hmm. And she's like, "No, no, no, like we'll personalize the experience on the website, and, you know, we'll change your grid sort order, and we'll optimize your site search."
18:42 I'm like, "I was hoping for so much more from, you know, what artificial intelligence could and should, would, and would be." Um, but man- We, we wanted flying cars and we got another flavor of recommendations. Right. Yeah. But I mean, but that is… There are, I mean, there are so many, and it's like, um, it's kinda like how the first group of venture capital backed brands came out, and they all had like a cheeky name, which was like an English first name with like a ubiquitous last name. That's kinda the same naming complex here, is like you see ones like, uh, Albert, Alfred, you know, like Justin. Like, that's like kind of the AI shtick. Mm. So, um, that's been very prevalent at this show. You're right. That's really been everywhere, and just all… It's kind of the same, isn't it?
19:23 And they're all the same. It's all the same. Right? You're, you're, you're hoping and- Like, all your hopes are based on their algorithm being better than the algorithm next to them. Yeah. I think the difference is whether or not their booth has hamburgers at lunchtime. Or milk cookies. One of them had milk cookies. Yeah. Milk cookies. Yeah. That's a pretty good way to go. To get Jason, you have to have an espresso bar. He'll, he'll be in there 24/7. They have espresso by their booth. Yeah. Everywhere. Are, are you guys familiar with the Gartner hype cycle model? No? No. No, I'm not. So, uh, it's actually this pretty good construct that Gartner has come up with, and they basically have s- uh, have sort of defined the path that all new technologies tend to follow, right? And there's this kinda early adopter phase, and you start climbing up the mountain, and you're at the peak of the hype cycle.
20:06 Um, but at the peak of the hype cycle, there's still no revenue. Yeah. Um, and so then you drop down into what they literally have called the trough of despair, where, like, there's this realization that this huge value that everyone thought they were gonna get from something isn't there. Um, and eventually technologies climb out of the trough of despair into this, like, mature phase where they're actually adding value and having high ROI. It's like the slope of enlightenment. Yeah. Exactly. Uh- To use really colorful language. And, and it implies also that, uh, you eventually jump the shark, and you're on the other side of the curve, right? Yeah. And, and are we there? Are you saying that we're there, Jason? No. So I- I think we're at the peak … my, my premise is that AI is exactly at that peak, and it, it's actually a double whammy. We're at that peak, so we're gonna have to live through that, that despair of unfulfilled promises before we get to the- And, and that's where VR is … the, the slope of enlightenment.
20:53 VR's in the trough of despair- Exactly. Yeah. Yeah … right? Like, uh, maybe it gets out of it or maybe not. Absolutely. Uh, and then the other problem at the moment is the word is so depreciated. Like, you know, IBM has decided to attach Watson to every single product they make. Um, and you know, AI to some people is recommendations. It's, it's computer vision to other people. It's bots and speech to other people. Oh, yeah. Uh-huh. Machine learning. Yeah. All, all are, you know, interesting. And I, I happen to be a believer. I think in the long run, those technologies are gonna have a pronounced effect on our, on our business, but we're a ways away. Um- You mean, you mean this podcast? Uh, well, well- Machine learning will take over the podcast? It, it… That's like in the next- Maybe it could do audio engineering … in the next year.
21:36 Little does Scott know, it, it already is doing engineering. Um- But, but it, it… Like, to me, I, I completely agree with you. There are certain tasks we do on a day-to-day basis as at least e-commerce professionals that there is no reason we are better at it than a machine, right? And I, and I believe this is also true about autonomous driving, right? Yeah. Like, there is absolutely no reason a human with emotions and drinking problems should be better at driving than a machine. Yeah. Right? So- Would, would you count global chief e-commerce officer in that bucket? Uh, no. Okay. Somebody's gotta put the, like, keep, k- I'm a marionette runner at ultimately in my life. Okay. And hopefully those marionettes are ro- robots. But, um- Just m- just people that report to you. They're not you. But I mean, my point is, is that, like, like, um, I think- Certain things are gonna always have to have a brand filter, right?
22:19 And that's why people are gonna matter within brands. But once you put that brand filter on top of something, is there any reason that a machine can't manipulate Google search algorithm better than a person? Yeah. I would argue no, right? Now, is it there now? No. And frankly, you really don't see that pitch here, right? It's not really where folks are going. It's really more the optimization of grids. Now, i- is an optimization of grids completely autonomous? I'd also argue no, 'cause you actu- Like, the brand filter might have to align it up with the store window or certain, like, regional focuses or whatever. Um, but I, I do believe that it can work. I just feel like the offer right now is so ubiquitous, right? And no one is differentiating.
23:00 Their big pitch is, "No, no, it's cool. It's AI And that's the pitch Which, but frankly, to a lot of practitioners, they have a board of director that sent a email that says, "What's our AI strategy?" Oh, yeah. Yeah, right. So they have to go adopt one of those platforms out there so they have an AI- Well, the CMO of Alibaba went out and said that every company will have an A- chief AI officer in the next five years. Mm-hmm. Like, that's helpful. Yeah. Yeah. It's, at Razorfish we already have four, so that's- Sorry Sammy and friends. Uh- S- so here's a good example. I was talking to a, a brand today, and they were really frustrated with Amazon 'cause Amazon's replacing, um, buyers with effectively machine learning. Mm-hmm. We had Melissa Burdick on the show, and there's a name for it.
23:42 I forget what it is. It's kinda like, you know, um, data-driven buying. So the algorithm, you know, a buyer gets you started, and then the algorithm just kinda kicks in- Yeah … and it says, "We need to order this many more Tumi suitcases." We have it now, yeah. And there's no one you can talk to because, like, the machine is like, "No, it needs to be 12 of these and 18 of those." And, um, so that could almost be, like, where this goes awry in that, you know, to your point, kinda takes that human element out of it. Um- Well, and, and, and like the a- like, so it's a great example of if promotional cadence changes- Mm-hmm … they can't, I mean, a machine can't predict that. Yeah. Right? And so do you buy into it? Are you overstocked? Do you have a sale event that you didn't anticipate? I mean, there is always going to have to be a human component of it.
24:22 And, 'cause we're a part of the program that you just alluded to, Scott. I mean, it, it's- Mm … and it's bitten us because all a sudden we look up and it's April, and we said, "Well, we're overstocked in blank." Like, in blank, like every single retailer on earth. Yeah. And now we have to tell Amazon, "Hey, buy more into this event," and there's no inventory left- Yeah because the algorithm's been kind of doing its thing and, and, and we miss a huge opportunity. So, um, it's not perfect. We, we've ad- we've advocated on the show, um, we're seeing this, a lot of our customers at ChannelAdvisor are doing this hybrid model. And by running third party, it gives them their, you know, the ability to control their destiny a little bit. And Melissa was talking about there's kinda, like, I call it this ninja level where you can actually have your third party and your first party overlap. Mm. So Amazon takes X SKUs, you actually sell those SKUs yourself, so when the machine goes out of stock, you at least have some available there.
25:08 Yeah. Um, it kinda opens the door. Uh, tell us about, you know, Amazon's strategy and how you guys think about it. Um, we use that vernacular of 1P for first party, 3P for Marketplace, in case listeners weren't aware. Yeah, so we, um, I've had to completely reevaluate my thinking on Amazon in the last three months. A- and the reason being for Tumi, i- if you type in any, let's just call it unbranded search term- Tumi doesn't show up. Yep. Luggage, hard side luggage, backpack, purse, you know, business bag, portfolio case, you never see Tumi show up. So- On Amazon? On Amazon. Yeah. On Amazon. And i- put another way, the only way you find the Tumi brand on Amazon is if you type in a Peruvian word that you otherwise would never know unless you were fa- familiar with the brand.
25:53 Mm-hmm. So it's the definition of margin arbitrage, right? You're basically on there to protect yourself because, you know, the 40% of all s- product searches begin on Amazon, and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, right? But I… Like, investing in the platform was very hard for me to justify because I was getting more… I was getting no tertiary benefits whatsoever. Now, same exercise. Type in luggage, backpacks. Samsonite, American Tourister, High Sierra show up all over the place, right? So as a brand portfolio I, I now have to think about the business entirely different, right? Because to me, I, I'm more than happy to just sort of play hardball and be like the only benefit that I'm getting is, well, my motivation has to be one of two things.
26:33 Try to basically pay Amazon in the form of margin arbitrage for the pleasure of being able to advertise on AMS, right? So I can show up for luggage, show up in backpacks, show up in all that sort of stuff. Or play hardball and make the experience of typing in Tumi on Amazon so bad that the consumer goes type in Tumi, well, that didn't work. Go to Google, type in Tumi, and then we make our full margins. Mm-hmm. I can't do that anymore. Yeah. Right? So as a portfolio, um, they are a huge SEO benefit to the Samsonites and American Touristers of the world. So our portfolio strategy is hopefully such where we can work with Amazon to… I mean, the only one, the only thing that makes me just batty is lost buy box, right?
27:14 Every time we lose our buy box and we now are now arbitraging our margin arbitrage- … and, and I just, I just can't do it, you know? Yeah. And, and that's the thing that we keep on working with them on. And, you know, I try to be cautiously optimistic, but, um, uh, there hasn't been a lot of effort on the other side. And, and I, and I don't feel uncomfortable saying that out loud on a podcast. I, I just think that for a brand above, um, commodity- Mm-hmm … they eventually are gonna hopefully have to play nice. Yeah. I hope. Yeah. And just to kinda orient it, you guys… So let me see if I can get this right. So Tumi is kind of like, um, not a luxury brand, but it's kind of a higher end brand. You could make an argument we're the most premium brand on Amazon. Okay. It doesn't really discount much.
27:54 No. I- I've always seen when any retail i- site runs luggage deals, it always excludes Tumi. Mm-hmm. Um, so you, you guys are kind of… That's, that's kind of the top tier. Um, and then Samsonite's kind of in the middle, and Tourister's kind of the more discount- Yeah, totally fair kind of brand. Yeah. Um, yeah, so, so it must be hard with a portfolio 'cause it does require different strategies and, and- Yeah. 'Cause you, 'cause you hope, you hope to generate inspiration via Amazon. Yeah. Like, that, that makes them as a partner really exciting to Tumi. Mm-hmm. Right? Because, you know, I, I m- I mean, you have to always be pragmatic about it, right? Like, what percentage of the American population is gonna buy a $700 suitcase? 5, 10, 15? Yeah. W- we, we alluded to… Well, we didn't allude, but we talked about last click attribution before.
28:38 If I can get any sort of view-through branding efficacy from Amazon for Tumi, even if they end up buying an American Tourister, but now the name's in their head and they're that much more inclined to buy it five years down the r- that makes them really valuable. Yeah. But the, the, the fact of the matter is, is that I'm not getting any of that right now from a Tumi perspective, but I get a ton of it for AT and Samsonite. Got it. Um, so I, I just hope that w- we can be better partners on both sides. But it just, you know, uh, there's a reason why I made the oxymoron point. Mm-hmm. It just, it hasn't been a two-way street. Yeah. Do you… So Amazon's very transactional. Do you think there's a day when it's more inspirational, and you can kind of put those products in front of people? Or do you think Amazon will always be a transactional kind of system?
29:19 Well, I think right now, and this is not an insult because Walmart was and is one of the largest companies in the world- Amazon is acting like Walmart, which is they're gonna compete at commodities, they're gonna go to mass, and that's where the majority of their revenue is. Yeah. Right? But if they want to attract the… attract and keeps the Cole Haans. Um, Birkenstock had a very famous breakup with them last year. Mm-hmm. Um, keep the Tumi's of the world, then they're gonna have to act like more than, than Walmart did, right? And, and maybe they don't. Maybe they don't care. Yeah. Right? Maybe the, you know, call it contemporary plus price point becomes irrelevant to their business strategy. Um, but i- right now they're just hoping that their mass nature of traffic is gonna make up for their lack of brand appreciation.
30:05 Yeah. And I'm not sure that's sustainable. Hmm. Dan, you mentioned earlier that you can kind of smell the fear of Amazon in the room at Shoptalk. Mm-hmm. What, what do you recommend to brands and retailers that, that have the fear? Stay away from Amazon. Uh, uh, th- 'cause ultimately you're, you're selling your soul. And why would you do that? They have 300 million active buyers. So I'm a Tumi customer- Once you get a really good price for your soul. Once you get a really good- and there's a coupon. Um, so I'm a- … I'm a, I'm a Tumi customer. I, I have a Tumi, uh, uh, laptop bag. I have a Tumi, uh, uh, overnight. Uh, and I have a Tumi s- uh, suit, uh, uh, g- garment bag, excuse me. Mm-hmm. So I, I am definitely in Charlie's wheelhouse. And the reason that I would start at Amazon is because I start everything at Amazon.
30:47 And it's not that I want to buy from Amazon there. I don't know what else to do, especially if I'm not really familiar enough with the Tumi brand to know that they have this, they have the Nordstrom Fifth that I can go to that's not super far from where I live. They have, uh, they, they have the relationships at Saks and Macy's, so forth. But it's just so easy. And so when you do the thing that Charlie was talking about and you make it less easy- Mm-hmm … for, for the user, are you really losing that sale? Well, it depends on how attached I am to the Tumi brand. I'm pretty attached to the Tumi brand. I have five pieces of luggage that are Tumi, so I'm clearly attached to that brand. I'm gonna go find it outside of there, and you have to just have a brand that's strong enough to do that. If you don't have a brand that's strong enough to do that, then you have American Tourister, and you can only sell that on Amazon, Walmart, et cetera.
31:28 But if you have a Tumi and you go on Amazon, then you can expect that you're gonna have an American Tourister in five years. It, it puts the pressure on the brand to differentiate itself as something other than price. Yeah. I mean, it's just that simple. And, and, um- You know, w- uh, Scott, you said the strategy very simply: Tumi at the top, Samsonite in the middle, American Tourister at the bottom. Mm-hmm. Um, how does American Tourister compete with Amazon? Like, that's a tough question. Yeah. Right? Yeah. But what the real ch- question is is how does Samsonite continue to differentiate itself from the noise of that bottom p- bottom price point? Mm-hmm. Right? And if we fall into the, the cycle of just discount, discount, discount… Which is, let's not mince any words, it's how you win on Amazon, right? Yeah. You have a low price point, you show up higher in the grids.
32:08 The race to the bottom. Yep. And it's, it is that, right? Yeah. So Samsonite has what? 90, 100 years of heritage? Mm-hmm. They can't fall victim to that, and so they can't let a distribution channel dictate their brand. A- and that's what I think a lot of brands are doing. Yeah. Well, it's kind of in… You know, I don't know if this drove their acquisition of Tumi, but it's, it, it would be… You know, at least it's not just American Tourister. Uh, you know, at least they have, like, this family of brands- Yeah … and they can try different strategies, 'cause no one knows the right answer to some degree, um, you know. Yeah, and we- I bet Samsonite sells tons it on Amazon … yeah, we don't play in one segment. You can make an argument that there is an ultra-lux segment, which is the Gucci or Maz, Louis Vuitton. Mm-hmm, yeah. But the point of view is could you really talk out of- That, that's where Jason and I shop, just saying Yeah, I, I understand.
32:51 I, I could tell by the- … I could tell by the outfits. Um, but the, the- … the, the, the Louis Vuitton man or woman, I don't think you could talk him or her into Tumi. Yeah. Right? And that's why could you upsell American Tourister to Samsonite? Could you upsell Samsonite to Tumi? Probably. Yeah. If you have brand idif- differentiation. Yeah. The Louis Vuitton customer, they still need bags for their nanny. Yeah. Right, right. And so I mean, yeah. I mean, we, we just hope we get as much market share as we can. For sure. People buy their nanny bags? Yeah. Are y- are you a horrible person? I, I guess so. Yeah. Um, it is interesting though because I do feel in a bunch of categories, there are these sort of heritage brands that are value-oriented, and it, it is an awkward place because j- it's, it's- The Calvin Klein T-shirt.
33:36 Yeah. Uh- Yeah. How does that survive in an Amazon world? Wrangler jeans. Yeah. All of those 100-year-plus, plus brands. There's some pretty clear set of tactics for those high-end products. There's a qu- pretty miserable but clear set of tactics for those pure price-based products. But, but how do you retain that heritage brand story, uh- I think you do it like Tumi's doing it. You have a few promotions a year- Yeah … and you don't, uh, find those products at Kohl's with a n- with a… There's no, um, Tumi red label at Kohl's. Yep. And by the way, there's a much easier answer to the, uh, how do you overcome fear of Amazon. It's move to China.
34:17 Well, then you have a new fear. Exactly. Yeah. Suddenly Amazon doesn't look so scary. Yeah, man. Did you see the Alibaba presentation today, where it's basically, um- 12 million packages … all your bases are b- Yeah … yeah, it's like- Yeah … everything is, is China. Welcome to the new world. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And by the way, only half our population is on the w- internet yet. Yeah. Well, you know, we're, we're in the hat, so. Exactly. Cool. So, um, so some of the brand conversations we have when I'm, when I talk to brands, and it's been this thing in the last 18 months. So some of the big topics are channel conflict, um, and this is kind of around the topic also, a lot of the brands are starting to say, "All right, my channels are shrinking. Amazon is the biggest and fastest-growing game in town. Um, I need to kinda have a direct strategy."
34:58 And I don't know where your brands kind of lie in that, that, so would love to talk about that. But then as they think about that, you know, how do they build more of a direct strategy, then what pops up is channel conflict. You know, most of, most of your sales are probably through a channel. You don't wanna disrupt that. Um, and then MAP pricing. What do you do about authorized resellers? That kinda ties into this pricing kinda discussion, because, you know, a lot of them… a lot of people come to me, and they're really frustrated with Amazon 'cause a third-party seller started lowering a price. Yep. Amazon followed with the 1P part, and they're kinda like, "How do I stop that?" So that, that's kind of a common theme. Um, would love to kinda talk about any of those topics, uh, near and dear to your heart. I mean, they're, they're all pretty near and dear.
35:38 First time you've heard of this? Yeah. I mean, well, so the, the Tumi Samsonite acquisition was sort of, um, this perfect MBA case study. And the reason I say that is Tumi was 70 to 80% direct, and Samsonite was 70 to 80% wholesale. Hmm. And Tumi was 70 to 80% US, and Samsonite was 70 to 80% international. Okay. Right? So all those topics of channel conflict, to Tumi, we always had leverage, right? We were always easy to say, like, "Well, I mean, we can walk away from this money because we're a direct retailer." Yep. Um, but then now getting into Samsonite, the pricing is such where it's remarkably diverse, right? Remarkably. And, and all those things you just mentioned of, uh, somebody taking a $99 bag and making it 97 and showing up in the buy box, it happens all the time.
36:24 Yep. I, I just don't see how it's sustainable. Yeah. Uh, I mean, I think MAP pricing has to be the only way, frankly, retailers and wholesalers coexist. Mm. Like, I, I, I just don't think any other way is sustainable. And there's another really interesting component that you sort of mentioned, but in a, in a more roundabout way. Well, but hey, we over-bought for Nordstrom, so we're just gonna ship it all to Nordstrom Rack, which is this ultimate kind of brand, more fluffy, not as quantifiable. I don't want Tumi bags in the Rack. I don't want Tumi bags on Gilt Groupe. But does that mean they overbuy on purpose so they don't care about full price sell-through? Hmm. A- and, and it just becomes really murky.
37:05 Yeah. Um, and, and I think the only way… I, I don't see how a brand beyond commodity, uh, doesn't have MAP pricing. And I think you also have to be very careful about how you manage off-price channels- Yeah … uh, regardless of what they are, because you used the phrase race to the bottom before. Mm-hmm. This is the ultimate race to the bottom, as has been proven by, frankly, all of their businesses. Yeah. We love MAP pricing, and the reason is, is because it creates demand for that brand later. But you're a deal site. I know. You're like, you're trying- It sounds counter- You're constantly trying to break- You're the antithesis of MAP pricing. Yeah. But what happens is, is that if you're… Exactly, in theory, right? But in fact, when there is… 'Cause there, there is a promotion at some point. And when a Tumi or a Coach or whatever goes on sale, uh, for that brief moment in time, demand spikes, and we're able to generate more volume because there's more interest.
37:46 So it actually works really well for us, too. Got it. I just, I, I really encourage every brand listening to this podcast- Get your pricing in order. Yeah. It drives me… It's, like, so obvious to me, and I don't know if I'm just crazy- Mm-hmm … but it's just so obvious to me. One thing I've seen the suitcase guys do, and I don't know which of your three brands kind of does this, but, um, you create unique SKUs per channel. Yeah. So, you know, you'll do a four-piece bundle. I think maybe it's Tourister that does this on Amazon, and then you can't really price compare that anywhere- Yeah … because there's, like, a five at Macy's and a, you know, individuals somewhere else kind of thing. Um, so the ultimate kind of people that do that are, like, Samsung with TVs. Yeah. You can never price compare their things 'cause, you know, the model numbers, there's a different SKU for Best Buy and, you know, everywhere else.
38:30 Mattresses. Mattresses- Mattresses … is the other one … done forever. Is, is that, is that part of the, the strategy or you're, you're probably, probably having to learn that 'cause Tumi probably had the ability to not have to do that. And the, the answer to your question is yes, though. Yeah. I mean, and I think the, the challenge is, um, y- y- y- we're all getting smarter. Mm-hmm. Right? Like, and so I think it's just a matter of actually offering a different product. And bundles are fine, right? I think bundles are a good way to do it. Um, but hopefully we continue to work towards a truly unique SKU as opposed to unique by way of model number- Yeah uh, which i- which I think is important to what he said. I actually think the unique by way of model number is going away. I hope so. I think that was a, a, a… I'm, I'm not gonna say a good tactic. That was a potentially effective tactic in the old world of obfuscation where the shopper only knew what the retailer told them.
39:15 Uh, but today in this world of perfect transparency, um, with all these deal aggregation sites and all these other, um, social user-generated content sites, you just can't get away with something like having an identical SKU with two model numbers and expect to trick consumers. Right. You, you take one millimeter off a trim, right? Like, I, I, I think you're right. Yeah. I think you're right ultimately. Yeah. How about, um, another one that comes up a lot with brands is private label, and Amazon's getting really aggressive at this. Um, you know, I've heard from some of the luggage folks they're getting increasingly concerned because there's… I don't know if they've come out with their own bag or not. They have. They've done some- Packing cubes … accessories. On suitcases, yeah. Packing cubes and… Yeah. Is, is that… Do you guys worry about that or you, you don't really worry about it 'cause every retailer you've been in already, I imagine, has some kind of private label thing?
40:01 It, it goes back to, to what Dan and I were saying before. Um, you have to have strength in brand. Yep. Right? And if you… A- they shouldn't worry, but the… as Jason said, like, the Calvin Klein T-shirt, you know, the, they should be scared. You know? Yeah. If you do not have a differentiation between your repu- reputation, design patents, quality, after-sale service- Price warranty, price- Yeah … y- you're in trouble. Yeah. A- and so I maybe from a point of naivete, doesn't bother me that much, doesn't scare me that much from a Tumi perspective, doesn't scare me that much from a Samsonite perspective, sort of scares me from an American Tourister perspective. Yeah. A- and I, and I think that's the way you have to think about it. That's what I say. Okay, cool.
40:42 In the, uh, so on the Tumi side, when you guys … You said you're 80% direct. Does that mean you had to build up all that retail kind of muscle tissue, like going and getting an email marketing system, and going and getting a big platform, and going and getting a, you know- A much bigger channel analytics and, uh, you know, all those kinds of things. Um, did you guys have to go build all that? Or, or- Yeah … tell us a little bit about that, that journey. Yeah, so I inherited, uh, uh, a Hybris platform and, uh, kind of a very V1.0 CRM, uh, traditional analytics instances. And, and sort of a lot of our expansion has been upgrading those systems. Um, you know, the … We, our CRM did not have predictive analytics capability.
41:25 It did not have a single view of the customer, including off- uh, sorry, offline as well as online. Uh, it didn't have customer service data flowing through to be a predictive analytic component. So we did a lot of work over the last year in kind of updating the website to be more personalized and actually have a CRM that had a single view of the customer, and those are hard conversations. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, because I, I sort of delineate the world into commodity technologies and differentiating technologies. And, and one of the things that I, I love, and I love in a very ironic and sarcastic way, is how much people fret about their e-commerce platform. Mm-hmm. And they're like, "Well, we selected Demandware, and they're best in class." I'm like, "Well, best in class, like, all your competitors use it."
42:06 Yeah. Like, is this really a differentiator? Like, w- like … And that's not a shot at Hybris or Demandware. They both do the job, right? But they're not strategic. Yeah. Like, they're not, because everybody uses them. And so how are you gonna truly differentiate your brand and, and think about it in a way that's creative? E- getting out of the groupthink in this industry is scary. Yeah. Uh, but I think it's something we've had to do over the last year. It goes to the customization stuff we were talking about earlier, machine learning. I mean, that's … Everybody's doing it, so there is no differentiation anymore when everyone's doing the same thing. So I'm, I'm gonna totally agree with you, uh, but I just wanna double-check your conclusion on that, right? Like, so I don't think any of those platforms are differentiating, and I don't think you win by picking the right one. You could certainly lose by having a bad implementation- Sure … with any of them.
42:51 Um, but, uh, I don't think that the conclusion is so you should build your own platform. No. Okay. No. Good Lord, no. Uh, but look- But we still see a lot of that. Well, I mean, I think you have to decide what your brand differentiation is. And if your brand differentiation is, "I'm gonna build a better e-com platform," God bless you. Yeah. Right? But you better invest in it. Yeah. Um, I would hope that Tumi's gonna invest more into continuing to build the greatest bags on the face of the earth, as opposed to becoming an e-commerce platform company. Yeah. Right? And content and personalization- Yeah … based on the unique context and data you have from your customers and- Exactly right … all those types of things. And, and to, and to us, like we, we have this remarkable treasure trove of data, which is … Honestly, like the data that I'm most interested in just from a consumer perspective a- as just sort of a Tumi fan, is the after sales data, the warranty and repair data.
43:40 Mm. Um, because the, the number one indicator of long-term lifetime value we see is people that have their bag break. Like how does that make any sense, right? It's because- Things happen, right? You own a bag for seven years, and you hear these stories of people that are wheeling their bag from an airport, a wheel pops off, and they end up going to a Tumi store, and we give them a loaner. Like, we have that customer for life. You do that? Yeah. I didn't know that. Yeah. We do that. Awesome. And so, like, that is where we have a competitive advantage that Amazon cannot do. Yeah. Yeah. Right? So we need to keep on doing stuff like that- Yeah … instead of trying to beat them at their own game. Yeah. It… Not to de- digress, but the… Is there a little bit of a donut in the Tumi warranty brand pro- Like, I, I feel like Tumi was born with this amazing warranty, and the brand, I think, changed hands a couple of times.
44:27 Yeah. And that warranty was sort of eroded, and now you're, you're, you're clearly, like, it's getting its back. Yeah. And, and we… I would say as a brand we over-corrected a little bit, to your point, as we went through… I don't know what the actual number is. It was before my time, but I think it was two different private equity transac- uh, transactions. We kind of slowly gotten back to realizing that it's what we have. Like, we have the best materials on Earth. Um, we have the best after-sale service on Earth. And the more we erode it, that differentiation and that brand differentiation goes away, right? So we, we're certainly, uh… I would like to think that we're the best in the industry still, but I think that's understated. Dan's gonna return now, what was it, three bags? I- Got any dings and duffs on there? I have- We give them loaners … little, little things that I can get loaners for.
45:08 Oh, a little squeaky wheel. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You just changed my life, man. I do what I can, Dan. All right. And it happened here on the Jason Experi- Yeah. Yeah, everyone listening, yeah, yeah. Call. Um, so Dan, you, you talk to, I would imagine, hundreds if not thousands of retailers and brands about pricing strategy and deals. What, what are some of the recommendations you make to folks? You, you, um… You know, we were surprised you talked about MAP pricing as a positive thing. Yeah, I think Charlie's right that, uh, f- well, it's not for every brand- Yeah … but it is for, uh, brands, uh, that, uh, that aspire to be something. Uh, you have to be able to differentiate yourself and, and not b- constantly be on sale It's 'cause otherwise you are racing to the bottom, like you said earlier. So th- one of the, one of the key things that, uh, that Charlie did say that I don't think you could say often enough, is to control your pricing.
45:52 Mm. So one of the… All, all the tricks you can use to, to game the system, like changing the SKUs so that the, the, that the buyer can't find a comparison, those have bad experiences to the buyer. The buyer was looking for a comparison. So I think you wanna keep in mind that as you do those kind of strategies, that these are your customers that you're, that you're, uh, can sometimes infuriating. And so, uh, you can go a little bit too far perhaps, and possibly, uh, make it so that the customer can't feel that they find the information, and don't feel they have the confidence to complete the purchase. Got it. That's, that's not necessarily pricing strategy, but that's part of your overall strategy to be able to not, uh, create, uh, competitive pricing. And, and I don't wanna s- overplay that, uh, but I, I, I know it's something that users will f- will find, and that you shouldn't overdo.
46:37 But, uh, one of the key things for, for what you're talking about is, uh, is when you're a Tumi kind of brand, you can definitely do this much more easily than you can with an American Tourister. I find something like Samsonite to be the really fascinating one, because there is so much diversity in that brand. Uh, I remember the Black Label. Mm-hmm. And so you had this product that was aspired to be Tumi-esque, and then you have the stuff where there's five bags from Samsonite for $99 at Costco, and you have all this dif- you know, variation- Mm in your brand. And so that's a really messing pricing, messy pricing strategy. And when you have that kind of noise, it affects the consumer choices as well. They don't know what they're getting at that point. Is Samsonite high-end or mid-range or low-end?
47:18 Uh, am I getting a good deal from eBags right now? Am I getting kind of the everyday deal? Yeah. You start to really have a lot of confusion for the user. So owning your price is, is what you have to do. A- and Scott, you, you referenced something a little bit earlier that I, I would say to all the, the brands listening, wholesalers are really clever, so it's not as simple as MAP pricing Every wholesaler will now do a spend $500, get a $50 gift card. Yeah. Right? And so that's just as bad. Yeah. You gotta be opted out of those. Um, eBags has a very famous, uh, loyalty program. What do you do about that, right? Mm-hmm. So just make sure you're thinking about it beyond just pricing because there's now crawlers everywhere that they can tell you if your price is not being matched, right?
48:00 Yeah. And they'll tell you, like, "Hey, these are the violators online." But those promos skirt that issue- Yeah … and it's much harder to track. Yeah, absolutely. Well, that keeps the crawlers in business. Yeah. Exactly right. Um, Dan, I'm curious, like, you guys have all this great insight as to which of those deals move the needle on actual- Yeah consumer behavior. Have you collaborated with any of the manufacturers when they're creating their deals? Like, are- We, we only really work with the retailers, but we work with retailer, uh, that, retailers that are brands. And what, uh, one of the things that we love to do with the retailers is we can, we can segment our audience so we can do a test promotion with you. So you could say, "Hey, I want to only try this promotion, and I wanna try it with something very specific and see how that's performing." And we can measure that, uh, ba- basically it'd be tested for you.
48:43 And so you can use information from our system in other promotions and other pricing promotions you use elsewhere. And it's fun for us because what we're able to do for the, that segment is have some exclusivity of the offer that we're in- introducing into that, uh, that user's day. Yeah. And ultimately, the whole point of what we do is helping that user just find something they wanna buy. The, the, the joy of getting something is, is our bread and butter and the thing we can't forget our- that we do. Mm-hmm. It's really important. Seems like a lot of retailers are so obsessed with getting, uh, people in stores. Do you guys see- get pitched those kinds of deals? And it's, like, really hard without a coupon code- Yeah … it's hard to kinda track the, the loop on the- Yeah. I would say that we are 95% purely, uh- Online online. Yeah. Uh, we, uh, the problem is tracking.
49:23 There's solutions that do tracking for when you wanna bring people into the store. But, um, uh, and I'm, I'm c- including that 95% order online for in-store pickup. Yeah. Uh, but for actual true, uh, in-store experiences, it's just not something that, that we can track very easily, and the providers, uh, don't do that good a job. There's… I think that's one of the things that something like RetailMeNot's app does well. Yeah. And there, there are solutions like that. It's just not a space that we're in. Yeah. That's, uh, you know, one topic we love to talk about is mobile, and that seemed to really catch a lot of the super affiliates by surprise- Mm-hmm like this kinda sea move to mobile. Um, I think RetailMeNot went through kind of a rough period. Maybe it was their own little trough of disillusionment. Uh, but they've kinda come back to the other side of that, and now they have, you know, a lot of users of their app.
50:06 How, how have you guys… how have you guys navigated through that, that change over to mobile by the consumer? So, so the, uh, the gold standard for us is, uh, is Amazon. Mm-hmm. And, uh, so when we look at Amazon, what we see is we see three to one desktop to mobile conversion. In other words, a mobile visit to Amazon's gonna earn about a third less as, um, a desktop visit. Mm-hmm. And that's not just us. That's kind of pretty much the standard. And so what we find is that, uh, no matter what we do on mobile, especially in the app, we're gonna see that from just about everybody. Uh, that's best case. Yeah. Uh, we actually ran this, this, uh, this interesting experiment, which I really didn't expect, uh, to, the result that happened. So we, um, we saw that some of our clients, we were seeing conversion rates where it was, um, a hundredth of desktop on mobile- Mm or five hundredth, uh, of desktop.
50:54 And we're like, "That's crazy. There must be a tracking problem." Mm-hmm. So we actually got clean phones, went to a Wi-Fi network that wasn't in our bui- building and, and placed orders, uh, from those clients to be sure that we, that they were, the tracking information was being passed along correctly. And in every case where we did that, we found that the information was being tracked. Uh, so what that means is that there's not a tracking problem when you're seeing really, really poor mobile conversion. It's probably a UX problem. Yeah. And that's something that as much as we wanna help the retailer, we can't fix for the retailer. Yeah. Absolutely. That's fascinating. We talk a lot about that mobile gap and, and across a wi- wide variety of retailers and industries, it's like one-third.
51:34 Yeah. But what's interesting is the sort of urban legend is always that Amazon is actually an outlier that's much better than that. Um, and it sounds like you're saying it. When you refer traffic to Amazon, you're seeing that same sort of mobile gap that everyone else- Yeah, yeah. And, uh, and we see some retailers beat it. Sure. Uh, but the vast majority are underperforming it. And, um, and the crazy part is some of them underperforming it, uh, at, at, at, you know, a tenth to a hundredth of what- Yeah of what that should be. That's, that's bizarre It just sh- it, it shouldn't be that hard Generally when I see something like 100, something is fundamentally broken. Exactly. Like it's actually like a- They're tracking you … checkout obstru- well- Or, or UX … like an obstruction in checkout that you, you can't buy anything When we, at, at Tumi we had a, when I joined Tumi, the mobile page load time on average was 11 seconds.
52:20 Yeah. Like s- Good luck. Yeah. Good luck. Yeah. I mean, like your conversion's not gonna be any good, right? Yeah. So there's, there's certain things that are just fundamentally broken. We certainly talk about that one a lot. Uh, speed is one of the, like only reliable correlations that we find that like literally every time you see, uh, page load times decrease, you see conversion increase. Yeah. Oh, we, we had a, uh, smart engineer who, uh, took it on himself to just experiment with it. And I believe he found that conversion rate increased by 20%, uh, per second that he knocked off. Yeah. We, that sounds about right for us. It's crazy, right? Cool. Very cool. Well, it has happened again. We have, uh, flown through our allotted time.
53:01 But, uh, greatly wanna, uh, thank you guys for taking the time out of the busy party to join us on the little podcast. That's why we went first. I mean, now we can just go get a drink I think. Absolutely. Yeah. Let's do that. Think so. We're gonna do another one after you've had a few more cocktails. That, that'll be, uh, the, the blue podcast. Yeah. Thanks Charlie and Dan. We really appreciate you being on the Jason and Scot Show. Thanks, guys. Thanks, guys. Until next time, happy commercing. You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us in iTunes or visit www.jasonandscot.com.
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed