EP014 - Walmart E-Com, NYC Retail, Amazon Apparel
EP014 - Walmart E-Com, NYC Retail, Amazon Apparel
EP0014 - Walmart E-Com, NYC Retail, Amazon Apparel, and Amazon Flex
Walmart Earnings
Nordstorm Earnings - Rack cannibalizing Mainline stores?
New Neiman Marcus Long Island Flagship
New Barney's NYC Flagship
SnapChat Commerce
Shopify Chat Commerce - Shopify Shopkey
Amazon Apparel / Amazon Diapers - Mama Bear
Amazon Flex - An uber killer?
Microsoft Hololens Ted Demo
Metavision.com Ted Demo
http://retailgeek.com/podcast / / Join your hosts Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg, SVP Commerce & Content at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, Founder and Executive Chairman of Channel Advisor as they discuss the latest news and trends in the world of e-commerce and digital shopper marketing.
0:00 Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show, your source for the latest news and trends in the e-commerce industry. Featuring host Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, SVP of Commerce at Razorfish, and Scot Wingo, founder and executive chairman of ChannelAdvisor. Here is Jason and Scot Welcome to the Jason and Scot Show. This is episode 14, being recorded on Friday, February 19th, 2016. I'm your host, Jason "Retail Geek" Goldberg, and as always, I'm here with your co-host, Scot Wingo. Hey, Jason. How are you? Happy Friday. Uh, happy Friday or, uh, guten tag. Yeah, you were in Germany this week, right?
0:41 I was. I just got back a few hours ago from the Hybris Partner Summit, or I should say the SAP Hybris Partner Summit in Munich. You feel good to kind of finally take the lederhosen off and relax? Why… Who says I've taken the lederhosen off? Okay, good. You're, you're wearing it for the show. Man, I've totally ruined the rest of the show with that mental image for our audience. Yes, as if there were positive mental images before that. Do you get, uh, your fill of, of pretzels and, and beer? I did. I feel like that's a, a, an SAP thing all over the world is they like to serve Bavarian food To remind you of where they're from. And so when you're in Bavaria, the, it's, it's pretty abundant.
1:23 Ah, good. Well, while you were out enjoying the… Was it snowy there? I imagine it was pretty cold if it- It was not. It was, um, warmer than Chicago. It was- Ah … probably like 30s or 40s Fahrenheit. Well, while you were enjoying trotting around in your lederhosen, we had a lot in the world of e-commerce that we should talk about. Exactly. The first thing that you probably missed, I, I don't know if you were able to check out, uh, some of the news, but, uh, Walmart announced their earnings. And this is after they'd kind of lowered their forecast going into earnings with a bit of a pre-announcement when they did their same store sales. Um, and I think the, the surprising thing with this one was that they lowered their outlook even further.
2:03 So when they last lowered it, which I think was in January, like that first week of January, they said, "Hey, um, you know, we're gonna lower our outlook, and we'll be kind of… We were expecting 6% growth, and now we're looking at 3%." Then in this lowering of their outlook, they kind of said, "We were wrong. We're essentially gonna be flat." Uh, and then that counts the store closures and some currency headwinds that they're having. So, so all in, they're saying they'll be flat. Um, now, uh, stores is, is a big part of that, and I think, you know, it's up .6% or something is what they're predicting when you take out the currency and the store closures, and those two things are enough to kind of annihilate that .6%.
2:45 Um, the bright spot in the earnings was the e-commerce growth, which, um, they kind of… It was a little confusing 'cause I saw two numbers. I saw an 8% number and a 12% number. And, and you and I went in, and because of our, uh, our staff on the research side, the research staff was able to determine for us what's going on there. And the 8% number, uh, which is their e-commerce growth, is GMV, and the 12% is actually their sales from e-commerce. Mm. So they're, they're starting to have, uh, almost like a marketplace, and, and, and Walmart does have a marketplace, uh, where they're talking about GMV and then the revenue from e-commerce. So, so, um, you know, let, let's stick with the 8% number 'cause that's probably… I, I always think GMV is kind of where the actual economic impact is.
3:27 So while that's good compared to stores that are gonna be flat, it feels like a win. I think what's a little worrisome about it is it's quite a deceleration. So, um, you had found a chart that shows, uh, on Fortune them going from kind of a 30% growth rate in e-commerce down to 8%. Last quarter, the third quarter of two- 2015, e-commerce grew 10%. Uh, so definitely even e-commerce is slowing down. So, um, some, some, some good news-ish, but a little concerning that Walmart still needs to do more in e-commerce. What, what did-- Did you get a chance to see that, and what'd you think? Yeah. So I, I didn't get to, to listen to the earnings call, but I did read the transcript. And I mean, I think you pretty well covered it.
4:07 Like, the stores, you know, when you net everything out, stores were basically flat. Like, uh, they were marginally up, which gave them a story they liked 'cause they, the stores have been up every quarter for, like, seven consecutive quarters. So they, they made it up again, but it was up by 0.6%. And traffic was nominally up in the stores, which, you know, at least traffic isn't down, which is a trend we're seeing in a bunch of other retailers. So those, those were kinda not terrific news. And then on the e-commerce growth, they just-- they have this-- they've consistently been decelerating. And so, you know, what's scary is that, you know, m-man, in 2013, they started making these big investments in e-commerce, and they, they really hadn't meaningfully invested, and they were way behind Amazon, and their, their sales were anemic.
4:56 So you could have really fast growth, frankly, pretty easily. So they were, you know, posting these 30, 27% growths every quarter. And now, you know, fast-forward a couple years, they've been investing billions of dollars a year into the e-commerce business, and they're not sustaining those kind of growth rates. Like, all that easy growth is behind them. It's shrinking down to 8%. And now, you know, they're barely growing-- Depending on how you count, they're barely growing faster than e-commerce overall. They're certainly losing ground to Amazon, which if you consider the size of the e-commerce business at Amazon and Walmart, it should be much easier for Walmart to grow than it should be for Amazon to grow.
5:36 So, so that is super alarming that they've made all these investments, um, and it feels like, like, you know, things are just, uh, slowing down to a, to an equilibrium for them on e-commerce. Yeah, and to put that, uh, 8% in perspective for folks, we, we generally talk about, I like the comscore growth number of about 15%, so it's about half that rate. Amazon's fourth quarter was, uh, all in, was about 26% constant currency. If you take books out, then it was 30, 31%, which is the EGM. But then if you look at the third-party marketplace, the marketplace grew at about 40%. So, so Amazon i- is just gobbling up share.
6:17 What, what do you think Walmart should do? Uh, you know, so, so let's kind of, you know, pretend you're the CEO of Walmart. You get a bit of a sideways kind of a, a move in your career. Uh, you're CEO of Walmart. Uh, what do you do? How do you- … how do you stop this? Well, Neil Ashe and Fernando, I'm glad you asked. Um uh, no, I mean, so they do have some smart guys running the ship, and to be honest, they, they sort of tipped their hand what they thought they would do, and it seems like a reasonable approach. Um, before I jump into it, I did wanna sort of mention one thing that, that listeners should bear in mind about Walmart is their e-commerce business is pretty international at this point.
6:57 So North America is for sure their largest market, but they are getting meaningful revenue from China and from Brazil and I, I think probably the UK as well. So, so some of these numbers we're, we're slightly comparing apples to oranges with North American growth versus, versus international growth. And I think Walmart mentioned that, that they were particularly taking it in the shorts on e-commerce in some of those international markets, for whatever that's worth. But I think the story is still-- the trend is still the same in North America for sure. And so one of the things that they talked about is a real focus on increasing the assortment, uh, particularly in the grocery category.
7:39 And that's an interesting play to me for Walmart for a couple of reasons. Uh, number one, unlike a lot of the other, uh, general goods merchandising categories where they're competing head-to-head with Amazon and there's all this established consumer behaviors, you know, people are already buying from Amazon, grocery e-commerce is really pretty nascent. And none of the big grocery retailers, you know, they, they've all been basically digital laggards. I think Kroger j- which is the largest grocery chain in the US, Kroger just launched buy online pick up in store this quarter, and it's been phenomenally successful, which shows you there's a lot of latent demand for, for digital shopping experiences in grocery.
8:22 And so while I know Amazon has a play there as well, Walmart's a very big brick-and-mortar grocery store. They actually sell more groceries than Kroger does, and, and it feels like that's a little bit more of a white space and a chance where they could compete maybe on a little bit more of a level playing field than, than in, uh, you know, apparel or other categories where they're h- you know, having to try to catch up against a, a market-leading competitor that's running super fast. So I do think for a variety of reasons that grocery might be a smart play. And, and if I take a step back from that and even generalize it a little bit, it just-- it doesn't feel like it's realistic for Amazon right now to focus on-- or I'm sorry, for Walmart to focus on capturing dramatically net new market share through e-commerce.
9:11 Like they're, they're by far the largest retailer in the world. What, what their focus really needs to be on is capturing wallet share of their existing customers and making sure that when those brick-and-mortar shoppers transition to digital behaviors, that they have a good option to do it in the Walmart ecosystem and not leave that ecosystem to go to Amazon and places like that. And so, so in general, I thi- I think It's too ambitious to say, "Oh my gosh, Walmart should be going head-to-head with Amazon." What they really need to do is protect the $300 billion in revenue they're getting from the brick-and-mortar stores by, you know, offering things that ap- uh, appeal to their specific demographic.
9:52 Um, and you know, I think they're trying a lot of those things. The, you know, buy online, pay in cash for the unbanked customers, the savings catcher. You know, I think if they, if they do a good job of extending into grocery, like those are all good defensive tactics to sort of shore up their, their existing customers. Yeah. Isn't-- So I'll, I'll play devil's advocate. Um, I get where you're going with grocery, but isn't that like insanely hard? So y- when they say that, do you th- do you think they're gonna do like Amazon Fresh and have trucks delivering these things or, or, or is it just gonna be more like in-store pickup of grocery? What, what do you think the vision for grocery online at, at Walmart is? Yeah.
10:32 So I think there's a three-tier play. There's a ton of people shopping in the store that want more product information and want pre-shopping. They wanna know that you have the steak that they want in stock before they go to the store, uh, for the barbecue you're planning or, you know. So frankly, just having better-- having a better digital shelf for your brick-and-mortar customers would be- Mm … um, an improved customer experience would p- which would potentially win them visits for, uh, at Walmart against Kroger and Safeway and the traditional physical, um, grocery retailers they're competing against. So to me, that's tier one. That's, that's the low-- the super low-hanging fruit. Then you get into the, the buy online, pickup in-store experiences and leveraging that footprint of all those stores they have and that, that, you know, feels like kinda walk in the crawl, walk, run.
11:21 And then, you know, delivering the groceries to home is, is really the run play. And, you know, given the economics of that right now, that's really not a perfect match with Walmart's demographic. So I don't think protecting their existing customer, uh, that a home delivery service for grocery is necessarily like the most important play for Walmart. Like that, that makes more sense for Amazon that has a more affluent customer base. Not saying Walmart shouldn't tackle it at some point, 'cause frankly, there, there's nothing easy left for Walmart to do here, right? Like they, they are a huge retailer. They're enjoying tons of revenue. They make $5 billion a quarter, you know, which certainly Amazon, by the way, does not do.
12:01 What-- You know, there, there are no easy plays for Walmart here to keep growing. Like they're, they're going to have to tackle something that's very hard and be successful at it. And I think what, what scares investors is They're, they're tackling a really hard thing that Amazon has already tackled, and they're, they're throwing a bunch of money into it, and they're not seeing phenomenal results. And so, you know, I, I think they need to pivot to, to something where there is a little more white space. Okay. Fair enough. Any other interesting, uh, retail news that you saw this week? Another earnings, uh, call was, uh, Nordstrom. And, you know, they're in a category where everyone is reporting some disappointing results. And I don't… You know, Nordstrom's w- was very disappointing.
12:43 I think they, they took it in the shorts pretty hard on their stock after their, their earnings call. Um, but what was interesting to me was this juxtaposition of the mainline stores and the rack stores. So, uh, you know, there were a couple storylines there. This quarter There were more Nordstrom rack stores than there were Nordstrom mainline stores. So the rack kind of passed Nordstrom in terms of store count. Um, and in terms of growth, same-store sales in the mainline Nordstrom stores were down three point two percent, and growth was up six point nine percent in the rack. And the reason that is really interesting is because Nordstrom, for a long time, has been saying that the rack stores are additive and do not cannibalize their mainline stores, and the shoppers are different.
13:33 And, you know, when, when analysts in the market talk about the-- these discount retail models cannibalizing mainline sales, Nordstrom was the biggest example of, of someone proving that that's not the case. And frankly, they were opening rack stores a few blocks from mainline stores in, in, you know, the exact same zip codes. And, uh, you know, this quarter, the results don't appear to support, uh, Nordstrom's premise that, that there is not cannibalization. Maybe, maybe in a good economy, there's not cannibalization, but as things get, get, uh, squeezed, um, it appears like there are the, uh, mainline customers that are willing to shift down to, to those Nordstrom rack stores.
14:17 And so that, you know, had a, a really derogatory effect on Nordstrom's margin. And then, you know, on the e-commerce side of the fence, in a way, it's a similar story to Walmart, that they, they got very serious about e-commerce a few years ago. They've made these major investments. They announced like a five billion dollar e-commerce CapEx program over four years. They've spent over half that CapEx already. Um, and on the one hand, they've had huge success. They've grown from like, uh, e-commerce being four percent of their sales to this quarter, e-commerce was twenty percent of their sales. So very meaningful. I think that makes them the second-best, um, department store in terms of e-commerce sales behind, uh, Neiman Marcus, which is at like twenty-seven percent.
15:04 But, uh, as we've talked about a few times on this show, margins in e-commerce are, are tough. And it, it c-- it-- You know, sometimes they're much-- it's much more difficult to maintain margins in e-commerce, particularly in apparel, where you have very high returns and you have to offer free shipping and free returns. So, you know, now that, that e-commerce is a huge piece of their mix, they're, they're finding that e-commerce is straining their, their profitability as well. And so that was one of the factors for them, them missing their profit target so significantly. I always thought it was kind of interesting. I, I don't know if people really have their heads around this, that, uh, and, and this is probably true for Saks and a lot of the other luxury brands is there's this perception of luxury and, you know, this very high-end kind of experience.
15:52 But then where a lot of their growth is, is from their outlets. So they almost like create this luxury kind of thing brand to then have an outlet where they sell stuff to mere mortals. So it, it's pretty interesting to see that play out in the numbers like you described. Yeah, absolutely. And, you know, the age-old question is, uh, h- how long can you offer those, those sort of, uh, discounts and still maintain the equity in the mainline brand? Like, do you eventually erode it, right? And, you know, frankly, people talk a lot about Coach as, as the example of a, of an aspirational brand that, you know, got super aggressive at outlet stores and super aggressive at price points. And, you know, the, the sort of, you know, joke was, you know, that y- your cleaning lady now comes to the house with a Coach bag, and suddenly it's not aspirational anymore, and a lot of the goodwill in the brand goes away.
16:41 And so, you know, we're in a, a market right now where Nordstrom, Saks, Macy's are all rushing to this pr- you know, seemingly more profitable discount m- uh, model. But, you know, there are… The cautionary tale here is, are they doing long-term damage to their brands by focusing so much on that discount shopper? Mm-hmm. Yeah. How about, I saw Neiman Marcus is opening a big new flagship. Have you, uh, had a ch- chance to shoot over there? No, I have not yet. I am planning a New York trip because there's, there's frankly a bunch of new retail that's opened in the last month in the New York area. So the Neiman Marcus flagship is, is sort of in, uh, Long Island, so a short jaunt from, from Manhattan.
17:23 I think I mentioned earlier that Neiman Marcus was an early investor in e-commerce, and they're actually at, like, twenty-seven percent of all their, their sales are from e-commerce, which is pretty impressive. Mm. Part of the, the thing you have to remember here is for some of these luxury brands, um, their, their stores are only in aspirational places that lots of the US population can't get to. And so those stores help them build this brand. But then, you know, many more customers are able to visit the, the e-commerce site than are able to physically visit the stores. I, I know at Saks, you know, it's, it's a, it's a huge number. It's like ten times as many people visit the e-commerce site every year as visit all the stores combined.
18:05 And so that's part of the reason that these guys have, uh, e-commerce as such a big piece of their mix. But so if you're opening a store and you have a big chunk of your customers that are used to interacting with you digitally, you know, it, it raises the bar on the, the expectations for the digital experience inside of the store. And so, again, I haven't been to the new store yet. I know that they're deploying those, uh, MimoMe mirrors, which is one of the smart mirror companies out there. Mm-hmm. You tend to see two kinds of smart mirrors. There are mirrors that go in the dressing rooms, and tho- those for, for reasons that might be obvious, tend to not have cameras on them, but they have, like, a user interface, so you can see what other colors something's in and ask a salesperson to bring you another size or things like that.
18:52 But then you have these- Mirrors that are outside of the dressing room whose main feature is that they have a camera in them. And so then you can try on apparel, uh, take a photo of you in that dress, send that to your friends to get some social proof or, um, or get some validation. You can see what it looks like from behind, which is hard to do, um, without the, the video capabilities of the mirror. And you can see what, like, other colors of that outfit would look like without having to try it on. And so these Memo mirrors are that, are that later kinda virtual try-on that lets you socially share your, your products and stuff. And so that sounds like it's a big part of the new store. And then, uh, Neiman Marcus has one of my favorite clienteling apps.
19:36 So they give all the salespeople iPhones. They, they have all the- their, their best shoppers' purchase history in there. But what I really like is they have really good integration with their customer… their store affinity program, which is called the, the In Circle program, and there's a bunch of tiers of this In Circle program. If you're in one of the top tiers of the In Circle program and you walk in the store, they have geo-fenced you, and the store manager gets pinged that a, a, a, a known high-value customer just walked in the store. So not only do they, they have a bunch of information about what you've browsed online and what your past purchases have been online and in the store, but they actually, you know, give the sales associates a heads-up, uh, to help identify those highest value customers and give them a really, uh, special, uh, personalized experience.
20:26 Cool. Does it actually work? Does the manager kind of come running over and say, "Hello, Jason, welcome to our store"? So here's the one challenge. The top tier of the Neiman Marcus Affinity Program requires $50,000 a year in spend, and so I haven't actually hit it yet. Oh, okay. Keep trying. I've, uh, much to my wife's chagrin, I've fallen far short every year. So I haven't personally experienced that, but I, I have been told that there, that there are, you know, frequent customers that, like, really appreciate the sort of bespoke level of service and that you just… you feel more special because you are, you are known and, uh, treated differently, you know, in exchange for your, for your frequent patronage.
21:09 Cool. So that seems like a cool one. Uh, I know Barneys also opened a new flagship store, and this one in lower Manhattan. And this is a fun story. Barneys' original store was on the same block. So their original store was on 7th Avenue between 16th and 17th, and this new store is not the exact same location, but it's on the same block. And once again, like the big story of this flagship, it's not a, a huge square foot store. It's not as big as their 5th Avenue store, but it's a much more digital store. And so they've outfitted the whole store with beacons so they can geo-locate you. They've added clienteling, which, uh, is new for Barneys.
21:49 So this'll be their first experience giving all those sales associates iPads and, and having them have a, a better view of their customers' preferences. And they're also doing same-day delivery out of that store. So they're exposing that store's inventory online, and shoppers can place purchases and have them delivered to their homes in Manhattan. Cool. So when are… Are you going there soon so you can bring us a report? Uh, I absolutely will. I, I do not have a date booked yet, but there's also, you know, there's some cool, uh, Etsy pop-ups. There's a new T-Mobile flagship store in Times Square. So there, there definitely is enough good stuff going on in Manhattan to, uh, justify a retail trip. So hopefully sometime in the next four or five weeks I will do it, and, you know, podcast listeners will be the first to know.
22:34 Who ended up taking the Toys "R" Us space? Has, have they announced anything? No, I don't believe that that's been rented yet. Ah, okay. Wow. It's this, uh, interesting quagmire, right? Like, the… It's the world's most expensive retail real estate. And so when a retailer can't afford it anymore and it goes empty, there are not a line of people waiting to spend that money to move in there. And so sometimes in order to maintain those high prices, those landlords have to sit on those lots for longer than you would like. Maybe Amazon will put a bookstore there. That would be awesome. So I'm a little confused on Barneys. So they, they had a store. Did-- Was there a period of time when that store closed, and then they reopened? Yeah. They moved the store from- Okay … this kind of like downtown location.
23:17 Ob-obviously, like all the, the fashion and buzz industry moved, uh, to, you know, Midtown and, and particularly to Fifth Avenue. And so like during this kind of, uh, evolution in New York, Barneys closed that, that, uh, lower Manhattan store and opened, uh, an iconic Fifth Avenue store. And so now they're, they're returning to, to lower Manhattan, which has suddenly become trendy and hip. And in fact, this store is actually only a few blocks from the, uh, my Razorfish office in New York. Ah. So you're right in the… Of course, you're right in the heart of the trendiest- I mean, that's sort of what defines trendy is, and hip, is where-wherever they would have me sit. Yeah. Well, one story I saw that, uh, was more pure digital that was really interesting is, uh… And I'll preface this to let listeners know I'm not a huge Snapchat user, but my teenage daughter is.
24:06 She spends probably, uh, an ungodly amount of time on Snapchat every day, so she's, she's a big user of that platform. Um, and part of what she has started to really like… So the first thing she really likes about Snapchat that's new are these lenses. So the companies… They started out where Snapchat would give you these lenses, and the way it works is, let's say you, Jason, are taking one of your many selfies of the day. You can actually kind of enhance your selfies. So you could be… You could give yourself popping eyes or, uh, my favorite one is where you could be vomiting a rainbow. That's, uh, that's always fun. Uh, and that's called lenses, and they started out giving you some lenses, and then they had sponsorships for lenses. So companies would sponsor these things, and you could have, you know, like your eyeballs could be Starbucks logos or something like that, just as an example.
24:52 Um, then they have another area where, uh, in addition to just chatting with each other, you can discover new things. So, um, one of them, for example, was, uh, they… Victoria's Secret does a lot of this cool discover stuff that, that, uh, folks love, where you can kind of see some content that they've published out there. Uh, it was leaked. One of their board members was at the Recode conference and said that, um… And her name's Joanna Coles, and she works, uh, in some capacity with like one of the publishing companies, and they have a channel on the Discover channel, uh, within Snapchat. And they're saying… And I think it's called Suite. They're saying that it's gonna have some e-commerce coming soon. So think of it almost like a curated, kind of a product-oriented video with some content where you can buy right in Snapchat.
25:37 So that's, that's pretty interesting. You and I have talked about, um, chat commerce for a long time. I've been a long believer that Snapchat would go this way. Facebook, I think, is a little bit ahead. We're watching very closely for April when they have their F8 conference. I think we're gonna have a lot of Facebook Messenger announcements around e-commerce. So it's interesting to start to hear Snapchat kind of buzz and grumble a little bit about this and, and we'll have to kind of see what that looks like. Yeah, no, I mean, I think it makes perfect sense that they, uh, are and should offer a shopping experience. They, they have a really appealing, highly engaged Demographic. What's gonna be interesting, I haven't actually seen… The Discover piece of that, that app has grown a lot, and there's a ton more content on there than there was even just a year ago.
26:24 Yeah. But I haven't actually seen engagement stats to know, you know, how, how much that Discovery content is really getting consumed. And so, you know, I think the age-old question is gonna come up, you know, are folks that are primarily using, um, Snapchat as their utility for communication with their social circle, do they want a commerce experience through that same app? Like, you know, and again, some parts of the world, that seems like a real common behavior, and so far in the US, nobody's hit a home run with it yet. But it certainly makes sense that Snapchat should throw their hat in the ring and see how that works. And, and for the listeners, I would just let them know that, uh, you know, Scott can blame his daughter all he wants, but I send Scott Snapchat messages at midnight, and he responds instantly.
27:10 Just saying. Oh, you totally outed me on Snapchat. I did. Uh, one thing, and I don't think this worked particularly well, but you know, they did… You mentioned the lenses. They had a, a kind of interesting promotion where they gamified the lenses, where you could on- you could only acquire certain lenses by visiting those particular brick-and-mortar stores. So they did, like, a Lily Pulitzer promotion where you had to go to a, a store, and once you did, you were allowed to download the Lindsey Pulitzer, uh, lens, and then you, you know, you could use that treatment, and in their case, it's, you know, that cool resort pastels kind of thing. Um, you could apply that treatment to any of your photos that you published on Snapchat. So it actually created an extra reason to go visit a brick-and-mortar store, which I thought was pretty clever.
27:54 Yeah, that is pretty neat. Did you do it? Uh, I fully confess, I have the Lily Pulitzer, uh, lens in my Snapchat, and I'll, I'll be happy to send you some, some, uh, Pulitzerized, uh, uh, photos in the near future. We should start a Jason and Scot Discover for all five of our millennial listeners. Yeah. There's a ton of female-oriented shopping services on the net, and most of them will report that they have, like, .06% male audience, and it's usually a safe bet that I'm in that .06%. Good. I think I'm one of the first users of, uh, Little Black Bag, for example. Speaking of the kind of intersection of commerce and chat, uh, I saw a, a clever new offering from Shopify this week, the, the Shopkey keyboard.
28:43 Did you, uh, see, uh, that? I did not. I saw their earnings. Uh, I did not see this new gadget. Ah. Yeah, so you know, Shopify obviously a big SaaS platform for, uh, predominantly smaller e-commerce operators doing a lot of interesting things. But so this, this feature, this Shopkey thing is they have created their own keyboard that you can install in the iOS- uh, operating system for your iPhone. And custom keyboards is kind of a clever way for people to be able to put their own apps in, in the iPhone, and the Shopify keyboard downloads your whole Shopify product catalog. And so what it lets you do is imagine you're a customer service rep that works for a Shopify retailer, and you're talking with a customer and providing customer service.
29:31 You can switch to this keyboard, see all the products you have for sale, touch those products, and it adds them to the chat that you're in so that the person on the other end of the chat can then click on those products and purchase them. So it's a clever way to enable a customer service agent to provide shoppable links to products and just make it a little bit easier to provide chat commerce and, and, uh, commerce via, via any of the chat services through the iPhone. So I'm not sure it'll have huge adoption. It seems like it's definitely targeted at small businesses, both 'cause that's the majority of Shop- Shopify's membership, but also I think only a small business would be using an iPhone to provide customer service.
30:13 But nevertheless, uh, it definitely shows that there's interest in this category of chat commerce. Sounds kinda like a stretched use case where you kinda have to be doing, you know, a small business doing support on an iPhone. Al- although I do know they, um, their point of sale system that's on an iPad is relatively popular for people that wanna have kind of a lightweight omni-channel kind of a thing. So maybe that would be a good, a good place to utilize it. Yeah, absolutely. And again, they're a one-stop shop for a bunch of small businesses that, you know, you, you host your, your e-commerce site on them, you use them for your point of sale. If you go out and do events, y- you know, they g- uh, the point of sale's mobile, so you can sell stuff off of your, your iPad when you, you, uh, you know, travel to events in your industry.
30:57 Uh, and it's a, it's a… You know, the platform's gaining a lot of momentum 'cause it's very fast, it's very low risk. You know, I'll confess that I have a lot of enterprise clients that are on e-commerce platforms that cost millions of dollars, and they'll come to me with a special project and say, "Hey, I wanna launch this special thing that's, that's needs to go live in six weeks." And, you know, I've now done half a dozen Shopify sites for big enterprise clients because it's just so fast and, and low risk and, you know, gives you, you know, frankly, a great feature set and value for the buck. Mm-hmm. Cool. Well, it wouldn't be a show without talking about Amazon. There was quite a bit of Amazon news while you were out of town. Yeah, catch me up. Well, the first one was, um, and I'm sure y- um, you're familiar with this, but just for all our listeners, Amazon has had kind of a long history of private label.
31:45 Um, they started first with something called Pinzon, which I think was bedding. Uh, and then they have Strathwood and a couple other things. They even had a coffee brand that were private labels. Um, and then when the, the most popular private labels were introduced, probably about four years ago, maybe five, and that's Amazon Basics, where they essentially found… The urban legend I've heard is they got tired of, uh, always recommending to people a $15 HDMI cable to go with their $900, um, TV. And the cost of these cables is literally, like, 50 cents, so huge margin for whoever's selling it. So I think Amazon looked at that and realized they could do a $7 HDMI cable and still make plenty of margin.
32:25 So, um, so that's probably the biggest, just to guess, brand that Amazon has out there is the Amazon Basics, which is largely technology cables. Um- So, uh, a couple new things this week around private label. First of all, um, they had tried diapers, and, and this is a bit of a reaction to Jessica Alba's company called Honest, which we mentioned, I think, last week is, is looking at filing for an IPO, which is pretty exciting for them. But they have a line of diapers that are very popular. It's their number one seller. Um, so Amazon, uh, about a year ago tried to replicate that with something called Elements, and it did not go well. So, um, so they… There was an article out this week that they're running some tests with consumers, and I think it was via email kind of surveying folks, trying to find a new brand for a new kind of relaunch of diapers.
33:14 So I'm calling it Amazon Diapers 2.0. Um, and in there they talked about a new brand called Mama Bear. So, so kind of outside of the Amazon basics and then this other kind of Elements piece that was kind of trying to be like Honest, it s- looks like this new diaper, uh, brand may be Mama Bear. Um, so I know you have a relatively, uh, young diaper wearer in your house, so that could be exciting for, for the Goldberg family. Yes, he will be forced to be a guinea pig whether he wants to or not. He's already a guinea pig for the, the Amazon Elements baby wipes, which are a, a direct competitor with the Honest product. How are they doing? Uh, I think they're doing pretty well. I'll be hon- I don't think they're… You know, the Amazon position is that they're revolutionary better than anything else on the market, and that, that, you know, in my limited expertise around baby wipes, they don't seem to be particularly different than the, the Pampers baby wipes we were using before.
34:08 It's hard to, hard to be innovative with a two-dimensional product. I… Yeah, one would think. But I will tell you that, uh, I use that product as an example a lot for a great product detail page in the Amazon ecosystem. You wanna see a great example of using all the, what Amazon calls the A+ features, they've done a really good job of building their own product detail pages for Amazon Elements. And so, you know, uh, we use those a lot as a best-in-class example. Yeah, that's a source of frustration for third-party sellers because only first party, um, get access to the A+ pages. So as a third party, you don't have the ability to do all that cool stuff, unfortunately. Yep. Uh, but, and even some first parties claim that those Amazon pages do stuff that, that's not even available on A+ pages.
34:53 I don't… Have you, have you seen that? Uh, it's for sure true, and there are different features that are available in different categories. Um, so it, it, it's super obvious when you look at Amazon products like the Kindle that they, they absolutely have added incremental features, and there, there's lots of examples of features that are available on product detail pages for brands in some categories that are not available in others. Yep. So that was the first, was diapers, and the second was fashion. Amazon's been pretty serious about apparel for a while. Uh, and by that, though, they've meant just kind of working with designers, having apparel on the site, and, and working with other brands. Uh, but now there's news out that it looks like they're hiring a Marks & Spencer exec that is gonna get them very serious about private label apparel.
35:38 Did you see that? I did. Uh, that, you know, before we talk about the, the, their own private apparel, uh, I would just point out they've been really successful at going from apparel being an insignificant part of the mix on Amazon to them being, I think, like, the second or third largest apparel retailer in the US, and they're forecast that they'll be the largest apparel retailer in the US by the end of this year So they've been making a big investment in selling apparel overall, so it makes perfect sense that now that they built up the audience and that people, uh, trust them, that they would try to improve their margins by, by making their own apparel and selling it to consumers.
36:19 Yeah. So do you think they'll, um, think they'll get pretty serious about this? Are you envisioning a whole line of things, or do you think it'll be just, like, a pair of khakis and some basics kind of thing? Or what, what do you think-- where do you think they'll go with this? Yeah. So, so competing in fast fashion is a whole different ballgame than competing in staples. Mm-hmm. Um, the… I, I'm not sure they have tipped their hand. They, they've talked a lot about, like, "Because we now are a big apparel retailer, like, we see the data, and we see the gaps in the offering." And, um, the… You know, they're basically implying that "We, we think there's a market for particular types of apparel that isn't well-served by the national, uh, labels, and so, you know, we-we're, we're gonna have an opportunity to leverage all this great customer insight to, to make products for an untapped market."
37:07 It's very difficult to stay on trend and, uh, both either identify a trend or create a trend, make enough products, market that product before the, the product sells out or be-before that trend expires, right? And this is what the, the Zaras of the world and the H&Ms of the world are, are super good at, and it's also frankly why they really struggle at e-commerce because, you know, they tends to be short life cycles and short lots. And then you look at the, you know, the, the traditional staple apparel retailers, the Gaps, the J.Crews, the Uniqilos, their product lines change a lot less frequently. And so intuitively you would think that that is where Amazon is likely to start.
37:52 It's, it's hard to imagine Amazon being a true tastemaker and, and competing well in fast fashion but, you know, they've, they've tackled a bunch of tough categories before that we all bet against them and made them successful, so I'm, I'm not prepared to completely write them off. Yeah. I think staples kind of lines up with that Amazon Basics approach where if they could take a couple, you know, khakis and, you know, a pair of jeans and something like that, and not c- you know, have something that's similar quality to what's available but half off, it, it could be kind of disruptive. So that's my guess too, that that's where they'll start. Um, the other thing I think people don't have a full grasp of is if you look at the scale of Amazon and the amount of data they have, I, I think it gives them a bit of an interesting unfair advantage on some of this stuff, and, and they're a very data-driven company.
38:40 So I imagine, you know, they sit there and they, they can count the number of, uh, I'll just make this up, you know, the number of khakis or… They, they can look at the data and see where there's an opportunity, and they can also start-- They can see- demand supply imbalances. I've often felt that's kind of what they did with the HDMI cables, where we, we had a lot of third-party sellers there just, you know, struggling to keep up with the demand for HDMI cables even. And I think they can look at that and say, "Hey, this, this is an area where we, we need to help the market because there's just not enough supply, so we can, we can provide that." So it- it's very interesting that they have this-- they have so much transactional data that they can call on when it comes to this private label stuff, and they can, you know, they can probably be pretty scientific about guessing how much it will sell, how to price it, uh, and all that because they see such a large spectrum of the data.
39:29 Yep, particularly, uh, size I think is gonna be an interesting one. You know, a lot of the traditional apparel brands have kinda used intuition and been a little snobbish around size, right? Like, they're less… I mean, the Abercrombies or the Lululemons, you know, sort of famously weren't very interested in appealing i- in, in offering products in all the sizes their customers wanted them in. And Amazon sees all those searches, right? And when they say, "Hey, we see a gap," you know, part, part of my suspicion is that, you know, part of that gap is that there's items that people wanna buy in sizes that, you know, have constrained inventories that, that they're looking to, to capitalize on. Yeah, absolutely. Uh, two other Amazon things that I'm not sure you saw.
40:12 Uh, you were in Europe, so maybe you saw this one. Um, they've had Amazon lockers, and those are very popular. It's largely in the UK. They've got some in the US. Um, they did announce, uh, that they are going to be pretty, um, uh, heavily investing in expanding the locker program to the rest of Europe, to kind of continental Europe. So, so that'll be interesting. Um, it is interesting 'cause they've been using kinda some third-party lockers that are out there. Uh, so in Germany, I think they use, uh, it's either Deutsche Post or something like that, or, or DHLs. Um, so, so in a way that's gonna be kind of a competing locker system. So, so whatever reason it-- maybe the economics didn't work out there, or there weren't enough of them, or they're just kinda going at their own, they're, uh, you know, they're gonna be investing pretty heavily in lockers throughout the rest of Europe.
40:55 Um, and then the one that really caught my attention that was under the radar with the rest of the press, and this whole program is very under the radar, and I, I think we owe it to our listeners to kind of bring it to the forefront. Um, I've been following this Amazon Flex program very closely, and the way it works is essentially it's a clone of Uber, uh, but for packages. So Uber has a program called Uber Rush, and it's, it's, it's very close to Uber Rush. So the way Flex works is it was born in Seattle for, um, when they do Prime Now, which is their same-day kind of one-hour, two-hour delivery. And the way it works is very Uber-esque. So there's a driver app, and there's these drivers out there, and they get a notification from Amazon that says, "Hey, we have, um, some parcels for delivery to this zip code.
41:37 Um, there's five parcels, and we're willing to pay anyone, uh, $10 to deliver this just to make it up." So you-- They send a message out there, and you raise your hand as a driver and say, "I'll take that delivery." So then, um, there's a consumer-facing app where you can see, uh, where the driver is in their delivery to you and all that good stuff. Just, just very Uber-esque in that regards. And then there's a third app, which is the Amazon coordination kinda backend to this. So, so then Amazon expanded it as they've expanded the Prime Now program, which is one of the fastest expansions I've ever seen. Uh, there are well over 20 markets now, including ours here in Raleigh-Durham, which is always kind of a, uh… we're always the last to get things, so it's interesting they're here. And all the drivers I've seen so far have been Flex, uh, oriented drivers.
42:21 Um- There's an article out today that they are now starting to use Flex for primary Amazon deliveries. So that means the things that you could order through your normal Prime, not Prime Now, so two-day delivery, um, they're starting to test in certain regions, uh, using the Flex network for that. And what I, what I think is interesting in this, kind of having watched the Amazon playbook, uh, and, and 'cause just, you know, when you start to see stats like today something like 25 to 30%, depending on whose number of households have Prime, um, something like 80% of college deliveries are, are, um, you know, Amazon boxes. Uh, what, what's interesting to me is if I think about this, I think this could be a Trojan horse way of competing with Uber.
43:06 So, so s- bear with me for a second. Let me kind of explain how this could work. So you're Amazon, you experiment with this Flex. You get s- it's, it works. The economics work out because of the package density that you're providing. So if you can have someone deliver for $10 and five packages, that's $2 a package which is, which is pretty good compared to like a UPS or FedEx at anywhere from $4 to $8 let's say. Um, so first of all, the economics are good for you and your delivery business. But then what starts to happen is if you have enough of these Flex drivers out there, why couldn't you then have an app that kind of says, you know, Amazon, um, People Mover, you know, just to kind of create a random name, where you then start to say, "Hey, if we have enough drivers delivering packages, when they're not busy maybe they could deliver people."
43:47 So maybe they move people around. And you don't have to have the margins of an Uber. You could, you could almost, you know, pass 100% of that onto the drivers and subsidize your package delivery with people delivery. So it's almost kind of the opposite way that Uber has gone about it. I think if I was at Uber I'd be very worried about this because there's certain benefits to delivering packages over people. What do you think? Am I, am I crazy or, uh, am I onto something? Well, so, A, none of this disproves that you're crazy, so I'm gonna go with yes, you are crazy. But I, I still think you might be onto something. I mean, it, you know, certainly it's much There, there's much less complexity to delivering packages than the people, right? Like, you don't have to worry about the safety of the passengers as much.
44:30 Uh, packages are, are perfectly happy to share the trunk with a bunch of their friends, whereas passengers don't tend to like that as much. You know where they're going beforehand, so, you know. And, and that to me is the big thing, and that's, to me, a big distinction even between Amazon Flex and Uber, uh, delivery, right, is that the Am- Amazon is deciding if and when to use this service. So they have a bunch of packages that need to get a place, and then they decide what the most v- uh, uh, cost-effective mechanism is to get them there. The Uber delivery model is exactly the opposite, right? Like, you're … The customer chooses that as the delivery system, and then that product gets delivered by Uber.
45:11 And to me, that's a huge miss because what that means is that package is going in that car alone. Mm-hmm. Um, and that's, that's super inefficient. And, you know, so in the short term, it seems like Amazon has a very practical model for, again, taking costs out of the delivery, uh, system, which is gonna be critical to their continued growth and profitability. And if you look at this in the real long term, uh, I'm gonna confess, I, I'm a avid watcher of Shark Tank, and, uh, Chris Sacca, who's one of the original investors in Uber, is, is a guest on the show this season. And I'm constantly yelling at the screen because at every deal he mentions how, uh, he only invests for the real long term, and that's why he was one of the earliest investors in Uber, for example.
45:56 And I keep thinking, Uber's potentially a great investment, and they … You know, I use them all the time. Uh, I'm a big fan of the service. But it seems to me that that's very obviously a service with a finite life, that, you know, 15 years from now when all the cars are driving themselves, we're not gonna be using Uber to book those driverless cars. Like, you know, U- Uber's value in that supply chain kind of goes away. And so to me, they seem like they solved a, a, a tertiary problem right now, and, and congrats, and hope- hopefully they can make a bunch of money on it in the, in the next few years. But it's, it's not a long-term solution, and the, the Amazon model potentially scales much better and, and, you know, solves a much more fundamental problem.
46:39 Yeah, so we'll, we'll keep an eye on this for listeners and keep you appraised of if we see more of this. But I do think everyone should kind of check this out. It's Amazon Flex, and that's their drivers delivering packages program. Um, we're, we're short on time. Just a couple other things I wanted to throw out there. It wouldn't be a Jason and Scott show without some AR/VR. So, um, as we sit and wait for our Oculus riffs to, to be delivered at some point this spring, uh, there was a couple news items here just to hit on quickly. Um, there's, uh, the TED, uh, Show is going on, I think it's in Canada or something, this, this week, uh, and this weekend. And today, uh, all the news was out that, you know, AR/VR stole the show So one of the things I saw, um, some screenshots of, the videos won't be out for a couple weeks, was Microsoft was there giving kind of another HoloLens demo, and every demo they give is a little bit better In this one, they did a couple things.
47:30 They did a Mars teleportation, so the person wearing the HoloLens, they took actual scans that the Mars rover had done and, and essentially teleported that person to Mars right on stage. Um, and then they did, um, kind of a shared experience kind of a thing, so then they could almost, like, put a third… a second person in that same situation, but they were in another location somewhere else far away. So they could kind of see the other person. So the person in Canada, and let's say the other one was in, I guess, Redmond, uh, they could kind of be part of that s- experience. So it's kind of like Skype for 3D, if you can kind of get your head around that. So that, that blew people's mind when they did that. Um, everyone thought the Mars thing was cool, and then it, like, just blew everyone's mind when the, the second person was doing a shared experience.
48:13 So, you know, you and I could go to a basketball game in New York. You could be in Chicago, I could be in Raleigh, and we could be virtually sitting next to each other. It could be kind of a crazy s- That's the kind of stuff that's gonna happen with this technology. I'm picturing you and I having some epic, uh, matches of virtual Minecraft. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. Or, um, you know, uh, ch- doing our lederhosen dances and stuff that we do. Uh, the other one I saw that was interesting was, uh, a company called Meta. Everyone calls it Meta, but you, you know, to learn more about it, you have to go to metavision.com. They have a pair of AR glasses, and a lot of their use cases seem to be more business-y. So they, they have kind of conference calls where… You know, imagine you're doing a conference call, and you can see, you know, uh, good 3D representations of people kind of hovering in space in front of you, kind of like Skype for a conference call in 3D.
49:01 Um, so those are two interesting things, and the last one that was interesting was, we mentioned it on the show, um, there's this Xbox, uh, demonstration which is called The Mall on Xbox One, and it's by this cool digital agency in the UK called Von Bismarck. Uh, I had a call with them a week ago, and it reminded me to go check that out. Uh, it is on the Xbox One kind of App Store. So I downloaded it, and, um, it was a really good experience. It's really cool. You can, you can use the Kinect and everything to try on clothes, and, uh, it's pretty neat. You can shop using your hands and flip through all the things you would expect in kind of a, a interactive mall like that. Uh, the thing that was surprising to me, though, when I went to buy something, it didn't just kind of use my Xbox points.
49:43 It started to use this thing, and it was like a QR tag, but it was called a Pow!a or Pow!a tag. Um, and what was interesting about that is I saw an article that they're one of these unicorns, but, uh, like a couple of the other corn- unicorns that have hit on some hard times, like the Zenefits, uh, you know, what, what's happening is this company seems to be, um, going into administration. So it's one of these that had a couple million dollars of revenue, but hundreds of millions of dollars of losses. So, um, I don't know much about that. It's payments, and I, I thought I would ask you about that, and had you heard anything about it in, in any other AR/VR news that you saw? Yeah, so I, I have not seen any other AR/VR news this week other than, uh, I think the, the deals are now out for the The, um, Oculus Rift compatible PC, so you can start shopping for your PC to make your Oculus Rift work now.
50:32 Uh, Powertag has been out there for a couple years. They're, um, a little bit of a, a Swiss Army knife of products. So they have, um, a audio, um, watermarking technology. So, uh, a few folks have used them on television ads. So that, you know, uh, somewhat similar to Shazam, and I, I would say Shazam is a much more popular version of this. You, you can put some, some, uh, audio signature in your soundtrack, and then that can cause an app to know that a particular commercial is playing. And so they, they've, uh, they've sold that technology to a couple advertisers. They do have this very old first-generation mobile wallet, which is what you're seeing in the Xbox Mall demo.
51:14 And, you know, frankly, probably not competitive with, with more recent, uh, mobile wallets, and not, not likely to survive. And then they also bought a mobile p- point of sale company. And so they, they do have a, a bunch of users out there that have this, that are running a mobile POS, uh, that's powered by Powertag. And so I, I think the, the thought was they bought these three different businesses, and they could kind of link them all together and be, you know, enable end-to-end payments, uh, through, through advertisements, through shopping, you know, on devices, on mobile phones, et cetera. And I, uh… Does not seem like they've, they've captured great traction. I have a couple clients that have, have used them in various promotions, and it's, it's all just too proprietary.
51:58 So, like, in order to use any of those things, you have to have the, the, the appropriate app installed on your phone. Whereas- Yeah … you know, a QR code is kind of generic, and there's 10 readers that can read it. The, you know, Shazam is installed on millions of phones. The Powertag experiences really only work when, when you successfully get someone to install your, your Powertag-enabled app. And so to me, that, that's a limiting factor for those guys. But it sounds like, like they, they, uh, may be hitting some economic hard times in any case. Yeah. Yeah, so we'll, we'll, uh, keep everyone posted on how that goes, too. Yeah. So, uh, we should probably wrap up for tonight. But, uh, uh, as soon as I get unpacked, I'm gonna repack, 'cause I'm headed off to eTail West next week.
52:39 So hopefully we'll, we'll get a chance to talk about, uh, some of the stuff from that show in next week's edition. Cool. And where are they having that this year? Yeah, well, you know, I'm obviously going for the content, so the venue doesn't really matter to me. But, uh, I did notice that it's in Palm Springs, which is much warmer than it is here in Chicago. Ah, so you get a little winter vacation and enjoy some sunshine. Exactly. It's probably, uh, you know, a contributing factor to many attendees of eTail West is the, the nice weather this time of the year in Palm Springs. That's pretty smart of them. Well, thanks for listening, everyone, and you have a safe trip, Jason. Thank you much, Scott. Talk to you next week. You've been listening to the Jason and Scot Show. For all the latest news and trends on e-commerce and shopper marketing, subscribe to us on iTunes, and please leave a review
Overcast
PocketCasts
Amazon Music
Audible
Youtube Music
RSS Feed